Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Tr. P. (C) No. 01/2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche vs. Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Tr.P. (C) No. 1 of 2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche,
Tibetan Monk,
Presently residing at the
Dharma Chakra Center, Rumtek,
East Sikkim.
…
PETITIOINER.
- versus 1.
Karmapa Charitable Trust,
a public religious and charitable
trust having its head office at
Dharma Chakra Center, Rumtek,
East Sikkim.
2.
Jigme Tenzin Gyaltsen,
Son of Late T.S. Gyaltsen,
Resident of Trateng Villa,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3.
Amrit Jyoti Kansakar,
Son of late Gyan Jyoti Kansakar,
Resident of Kwapulhu, Thahity,
Kathmandu, Nepal.
4.
The State of Sikkim
Through its Chief Secretary,
having its office at Manan Kendra,
Gangtok.
5.
The Secretary,
Ecclesiastical Affairs,
Government of Sikkim.
having its office at Manan Kendra,
Gangtok.
…
RESPONDENTS.
Tr. P. (C) No. 01/2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche vs. Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
Petition under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
--------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Yangchen D.
Gyatso and Ms. Tamanna Chettri, Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. K. K. Rai, Senior Advocate and Mr. B. Sharma,
Senior Advocate with Mr. S. K. Pandey and Mr. N. T.
Bhutia, Advocates for Respondents No. 1 to 3.
Mr. S. K. Chettri, Assistant Government Advocate for
Respondents No. 4 & 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
(20.05.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
1.
The instant Transfer Petition is filed under Section 24 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, by the third defendant therein, seeking
transfer of the Title Suit No.1 of 2017 (Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.), pending on the file of the District Judge,
Special Division-I, East Sikkim, Gangtok to any subordinate court of the
lowest grade, having pecuniary jurisdiction in the matter.
2.
The facts, in nutshell, relevant for adjudication of the
petition, are that the Respondents 1, 2 & 3 with one Kunzig Shamar
Rinpoche filed a Title Suit No. 8 of 2004 in the Court of the District Judge
(East & North) at Gangtok, seeking a decree for recovery/restoration/
return of the main key of the principal shrine hall of Dharma Chakra
Centre, Rumtek, East Sikkim, along with other incidental reliefs.
The
Tr. P. (C) No. 01/2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche vs. Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
valuation of the suit was determined at Rs.1,00,000.00 (Rupees One
lakh). Accordingly, the suit was filed in the Court of District Judge (East
& North) at Gangtok on the basis of valuation of the suit at the relevant
point of time.
3.
The first Respondent and one Kunzig Shamar Rinpoche
moved the Supreme Court of India in a transfer petition, being Transfer
Petition (Civil) No.191-194 of 2010, seeking transfer of the said Title Suit
No.8 of 2004 titled as Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
vs. State of
Sikkim & Ors., pending on the file of District Judge, Special Division-I,
East Sikkim, Gangtok and also other petitions to the court of any
competent jurisdiction preferably at Delhi. The Supreme Court by order
dated 07.11.2012 passed the following order:
“2.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties
and we find that one of the grounds taken in the
transfer petitions in support of the prayer for transfer is
that the petitioner No. 2 who is also one of the plaintiffs
in the aforesaid suit is unable to pursue the suit at
Gangtok in Sikkim as by an order passed by the District
Magistrate at Gangtok, he has been externed from the
State of Sikkim and is unable to enter into the State of
Sikkim to pursue his suit as one of the plaintiffs.
3.
Mr. Ganguli, learned senior counsel appearing
for respondent No. 3 vehemently submitted that
besides the petitioner No. 2, there are several other
plaintiffs in the suit and this is not a sufficient ground
for transfer of the suit.
4.
We are unable to accept the submission of Mr.
Ganguli. The fact remains that petitioner No. 2 is one of
the plaintiffs in the suit and has interest in the outcome
of the suit. Hence, in our considered opinion, the suit
should be transferred from the State of Sikkim to the
neighbouring State of West Bengal and in particular to
the Court having appropriate jurisdiction in the District
of Darjeeling.
The District Judge, Darjeeling shall
assign the Title Suit to an appropriate Judge competent
to decide the Title Suit.
5.
We make it clear that although there were
prayers in the transfer petitions for transferring other
proceedings, we are only transferring the aforesaid Title
Suit. The District Judge at Gangtok is directed to
transmit all the records pertaining to the aforesaid Title
Tr. P. (C) No. 01/2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche vs. Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
Suit to the District Judge, at Darjeeling, West Bengal,
within a month of receipt of this order.
6.
The Transfer Petitions stand partly allowed.”
The title suit was, accordingly, transferred to the Court of District Judge
at Darjeeling, West Bengal.
4.
In the meantime, the pecuniary jurisdiction of the court was
revised lastly by the Sikkim Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 2013, which
was notified on 22.10.2013. The pecuniary jurisdiction of a Civil Judge
(Senior Division) was increased to Rs.6,00,000.00 (Rupees Six lakhs)
and the jurisdiction of the Civil Judge (Junior Division) was increased to
Rs.5,00,000.00 (Rupees Five lakhs).
5.
The Petitioner herein/Defendant No.3, in the said title suit,
preferred a transfer petition being Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 501 of
2016 in the Supreme Court on 10.03.2016, seeking re-transfer of the
Title Suit No. 155 of 2012 (re-numbered after transfer) (Karmapa
Charitable Trust & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.), pending in the Court
of Civil Judge, Sr. Division at Silliguri, West Bengal back to the Court of
original Jurisdiction of the District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok. The
Supreme Court by order dated 19.09.2016, allowed the petition as
under:“For the reasons recorded hereinabove, we are of the
view, that the prayer made in the instant transfer
petition deserves to be granted. The same is
accordingly allowed. The records of Title Suit No.
155/2012 (re-numbered on transfer) be transferred
from the Court of the learned Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Silliguri, West Bengal to the original
jurisdictional Court, namely, the District Judge, East
Sikkim at Gangtok, within four weeks from today.
Parties shall appear before the learned District Judge,
East Sikkim at Gangtok on 24.10.2016.
Tr. P. (C) No. 01/2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche vs. Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
Since the matter has been pending for quite
some time, we hope and expect, the trial Court would
expedite the disposal of the same, as far as possible.
The instant transfer petition is allowed, in the
aforesaid terms. “
6.
The case file of the pending Title Suit pending in the Court of
Civil Judge, Sr. Division at Silliguri, West Bengal was re-transferred to
the Court of District Judge, and re-numbered as Title Suit No. 01 of
2016, which is sought to be transferred to any subordinate Court of the
lowest grade, having pecuniary jurisdiction and competent to try the
same, by this petition.
7.
Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior counsel appearing for the
Petitioner, would contend that the pecuniary jurisdiction of a Civil Judge
(Senior Division) has been enhanced from Rs.60,000/- to Rs.6,00,000/and that of a Civil Judge (Junior Division) from Rs.50,000/- to
Rs.5,00,000/- by operation of the Sikkim Civil Courts (Amendment) Act,
2013.
Thus, the Civil Judge (Junior Division) is the most competent
court having pecuniary jurisdiction to adjudicate the dispute in the
pending case. It is further submitted that at the time of the filing of the
title suit, the competent court, having pecuniary jurisdiction, was the
Court of the District Judge. On change of pecuniary jurisdiction of the
Courts, the suit deserves to be transferred to the subordinate court
having the relevant pecuniary jurisdiction. Referring to certain orders
rendered by the District Judge, whereby other Civil Suits pending in the
Court of the District Judge, pursuant to the decision of the High Court of
Sikkim, were transferred to the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Mr. Rai,
would contend that this Title Suit is also required to be transferred to the
Tr. P. (C) No. 01/2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche vs. Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
proper Court, i.e. subordinate Court, to enable the Petitioner herein to
avail further remedy of appellate jurisdiction of the District Court.
8.
In response, Mr. K. K. Rai, Senior Advocate appearing for the
Respondents 1, 2 and 3, would contend that the transfer of the pending
suit is not automatic unless there is a statutory prescription in the
amendment Act, itself. There is no such prescription in the Amendment
Act, 2013. Thus, the pending suit is triable by the same Court wherein
the disputes are pending consideration. It is further contended that the
amendment Act came into force w.e.f. 22.04.2013 much before filing of
the transfer petition, by the petitioner, in the Supreme Court, seeking
transfer from the Court of Civil Judge, Senior Division at Silliguri, West
Bengal to the original jurisdictional Court, namely the District Judge, East
Sikkim at Gangtok. The Supreme Court has considered all aspects of the
matter and transferred the case to the Court of the District Judge, East
Sikkim at Gangtok, thus seeking further transfer to subordinate Court is
tantamount to review of the Supreme Court’s order dated 19.09.2016.
In view of that, the transfer petition deserves to be dismissed.
9.
Heard learned senior counsel appearing for the parties,
perused pleadings and documents appended thereto.
10.
Indisputably, the Petitioner herein moved the Supreme Court
in transfer petition, being Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 501 of 2016,
seeking transfer of the pending title suit being Title Suit No. 155 of 2012
from the court of learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Silliguri, West
Bengal to the original jurisdictional Court namely the District Judge, East
Tr. P. (C) No. 01/2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche vs. Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
Sikkim, at Gangtok, as evident from the prayer made by the Petitioner in
the transfer petition (supra) filed on 10.03.2016.
The Petitioner was
aware of the amendment in the pecuniary jurisdiction of the court. The
pecuniary jurisdiction of the Civil Courts was enhanced by notification
dated 22.10.2013, which is the sole basis of the contention of the
learned senior counsel, seeking transfer of the title suit in the instant
transfer petition to the subordinate Court. In view of this fact, being in
the knowledge of the Petitioner, the Petitioner ought to have sought
transfer of the pending title suit from the court of Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Silliguri, West Bengal to the court of the Civil Judge, Gangtok in
the transfer petition filed in the Supreme Court of India, which was not
done. The Supreme Court, having examined all aspects of the matter,
directed transfer of the matter from the Court of Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Silliguri, West Bengal to the original jurisdictional Court,
namely, the District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok. In normal course,
the Petitioner was entitled to seek transfer of the case from District Court
to subordinate Court on the basis of change of pecuniary jurisdiction.
However, in the case on hand, when the issue stands settled by the
Supreme Court in the transfer petition, filed by the Petitioner after
change
of
pecuniary
jurisdiction,
interference
in
the
order
may
tantamount to the modification of the order dated 19.09.2016 passed by
the Supreme Court. Thus, it is improper on the part of the High Court to
interfere with the order passed by the Supreme Court in the transfer
petition.
11.
Thus, in the aforestated conspectus of the facts, this Transfer
Petition is not entertainable by this Court at this stage.
Tr. P. (C) No. 01/2017
Goshir Gyaltsab Rinpoche vs. Karmapa Charitable Trust & Ors.
12.
Resultantly, the Transfer Petition is dismissed. No order as
to costs.
Chief Justice
20.05.2017
pm
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review