Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) NO.645 OF 2020
Sri Gopal Roy,
S/o- Lt. Brajabashi Roy,
Resident of Jagaharimura, Near Ramthakur Sangha,
P.S.- East Agartala, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin-799001
……… Petitioner(s)
Vs.
1. The State of Tripura,
(To be represented by the Principal Secretary, Department of
Home, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New
Capital Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN799006.
2. The Director General of Police,
Govt. of Tripura, O/o the DGP, Akhaura Road, Agartala, West
Tripura.
3. The Superintendent of Police, West Tripura,
Govt. of Tripura, O/o the S.P. West Tripura, Akhaura Road,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001.
4. The Dy. Superintendent of Police, Govt. of Tripura,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001.
5. The Officers in Charge,
East Agartala Police Station/NCC Police Station, Govt. of
Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura.
For the Petitioner(s)
……..Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Kar Bhowmik, Spl. P.P.
Mr. E. Darlong, Advocate.
Mr. S. Bal, Advocate.
Date of hearing
: 05.09.2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 13.09.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Originally, the present writ petition was filed under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking the following
reliefs:“a. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why a Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other
order/orders shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to treat the written complaint, dated 04.04.2016,
lodged by the petitioner as FIR under the appropriate provisions of
law(Annexure-2 to the writ petition).
b. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other
order/orders shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to compensate the petitioner by paying Rs-10 lakh as
public law remedy for violation of the petitioners’ fundamental right
to free movement & expression, right to privacy, right to life and
health and right to liberty guaranteed under Article 19 & 21 of the
Constitution of India.
c. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other
order/orders shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to ensure safety & security of the petitioner.
AND
Call for the records pertaining to the instant writ petition
from the custody of the respondents and to make the rules
absolute.
AND
After hearing both the parties pass order/orders as this
Hon’ble High Court considered fit and proper.”
2.
At the inception, when the case was filed, it was
registered and the same was numbered under the nomenclature of
Writ Petition(C) No.645 of 2020. When the matter was listed for
admission, upon the prayer of the learned counsel for the
petitioner, the Hon’ble Single Bench of this Court by order dated
17.12.2020 deleted the prayer clause(1) in paragraph 33. The said
prayer of Clause(1) in paragraph 33 is reproduced here-in-under:-
“a. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any
other order/orders shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to treat the written complaint, dated 04.04.2016,
lodged by the petitioner as FIR under the appropriate provisions of
law(Annexure-2 to the writ petition).”
3.
The said Order dated 17.12.2020 passed by the Hon’ble
Single Bench by which the prayer of Clause(1) in paragraph 33
was deleted is also reproduced here-in-under:“Learned counsel for the petitioner sought to delete
prayer clause (a) in paragraph 33 reserving liberty to file independent
proceedings if so advised. Permission, as prayed for, granted.
Amendment shall be carried out today itself.
The petitioner is ex-Member of Legislative Assembly of
State of Tripura. On 4 th April, 2020 he had written to the Officer-inCharge of New Capital Complex Police Station, making certain
allegations against the Chief Minister. It appears that he had typed the
said letter on a paper carrying State emblem. On 5th April, 2020 one
Advocate Arabinda Deb wrote to the Officer-in-Charge of New Capital
Complex Police Station, Agartala, alleging that the petitioner by use of
the said emblem unauthorizedly committed offence of forgery with a
view to harm and injure the reputation of the Chief Minister. He
requested that necessary legal action against the petitioner be initiated.
On 5th April 2020 itself, the police authorities approached the Judicial
Magistrate, First Class, Agartala, for issuance of a search warrant
against the petitioner. On 5 th April, 2020 the Judicial Magistrate passed
an order recording that without further hearing search warrant cannot
be issued and, therefore, he reserved the prayer and ordered further
hearing on 6 th April, 2020. On 6 th April, 2020 the Judicial Magistrate
passed a detailed speaking order rejecting the request for search
warrant.
The case of the petitioner is that the police authorities
on 5 th April 2020, despite the Judicial Magistrate refusing to grant the
prayer for search warrant, raided the residential premise of the
petitioner. The petitioner has made detailed allegations about the
manner and method of which the said search was carried out. According
to him, on the said date nearly 200 armed police personnel under the
command of Deputy Superintendent of Police, West Tripura, stormed
the residence of the petitioner at about 2.45 p.m. The petitioner was
residing alone at that time. The senior leaders of the political parties
upon learning of the ongoing search arrived at the site and tried to
intervene. However, the petitioner was locked up in the house and the
visitors were not allowed to enter the house. The petitioner was
physically and mentally harassed. The petitioner’s detention continued
for nearly 3 ½ hours. This exposed the petitioner who is a 70 year old
person to grave risk of contacting Coronavirus since the raid was carried
out at a time when Coronavirus was spreading.
In brief, the case of the petitioner is that the entire action
was a result of political vendetta. An illegal search was carried out
despite refusal to grant the permission by the Judicial Magistrate and
brutal use of force would demonstrate the true purpose behind the
entire action.
Notice, returnable for 6 th January, 2021.
Learned Public Prosecutor, Mr. Ratan Datta, waived notice on
behalf of State-respondents
Emphasis added”
4.
Then, subsequently vide Order dated 06.01.2021, passed
by the Hon’ble Single Bench of this Court, the said WP(C) No.645
of 2020 was converted into Writ Petition(Criminal) under Section
482 of Cr.P.C. The said order dated 06.01.2021 reproduced herein-under:“06/01/2021
The petitioner’s grievance revolves around
alleged illegal search of his residential premises by the police
authorities despite rejection of a search warrant by the concerned
Magistrate. This petition is thus primarily under Section 482 of
Cr.P.C. The same may be numbered as Writ Petition(Criminal)
and post it on 3 rd February, 2021 to enable the respondents to
file reply.”
5.
Accordingly, the same was converted into WP(Crl.)
No.1 of 2021 under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. and thereafter as per
roster, the matter was posted before the Hon'ble Division Bench of
this Court on 23.11.2021.
6.
Thereafter on 07.08.2023, when this matter came up
again before the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court, the Hon'ble
Division Bench felt that the matter is not to be heard by the
Division Bench, but the same is to be heard by a Single Bench of
this Court. Accordingly, the matter is now listed before the Single
Bench as per the roster.
7.
Now, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
filed I.A. No.01 of 2023 seeking a prayer to recall the order passed
by this Court dated 06.01.2021 and treating the case as a writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The said
order dated 06.01.2021 which is quoted here-in-above is again
reproduced herein for convenience:“06/01/2021
The petitioner’s grievance revolves around alleged
illegal search of his residential premises by the police authorities
despite rejection of a search warrant by the concerned Magistrate.
This petition is thus primarily under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. The
same may be numbered as Writ Petition(Criminal) and post it on 3
rd February, 2021 to enable the respondents to file reply.”
8.
After hearing both sides on the said I.A., since the
prayer was not opposed by the respondents, this Court by order
dated 12.09.2023 allowed the said I.A. No.01 of 2023 and the Crl.
Petn. No.16 of 2023 has been restored to its originality i.e. WP(C)
No.645 of 2020.
9.
Finally, the prayers made by the petitioner that falls
for consideration in the present writ petition are as under:“b. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other
order/orders shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to compensate the petitioner by paying Rs-10 lakh as
public law remedy for violation of the petitioners’ fundamental right
to free movement & expression, right to privacy, right to life and
health and right to liberty guaranteed under Article 19 & 21 of the
Constitution of India.
c. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to
why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other
order/orders shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to ensure safety & security of the petitioner.”
10.
Biplab
The case of the petitioner in a nutshell is that Sri
Kumar
Deb,
the
then
Chief
Minister
of
Tripura
on
02.04.2020 visited the AGMC & GBP Hospital and made a
statement to the press media persons on camera stating that high
alertness is called for as in Karimganj, Assam and also in Manipur
16/17 corona positive cases have been detected.
11.
Finding fault with the said statement, the petitioner
lodged a written complaint on 04.04.2020 to the Superintendent of
Police, West Tripura District, alleging that fake information was
given by the then Chief Minister of Tripura, Sri Biplab Kumar Deb.
The said written complaint was lodged under Section 182,
505(1)(b) of the Indian Penal Code, before the NCC Police Station,
Agartala. Thereafter, as a counterblast to the written complaint
lodged by the petitioner, against the then Chief Minister of Tripura
on 04.04.2020, Sri Arabinda Deb, an Advocate, who is also an
Assistant Public Prosecutor of learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura
District, lodged a counter compliant on 05.04.2020 to the O.C.
NCC Police Station, alleging that the petitioner has unauthorizedly
used Ashok Chakra, National Emblem while making malicious and
false complaint against the then Chief Minister of Tripura.
12.
On 05.04.2020, a group of armed police personnel
under the command of the DSP West Tripura, respondent No.4
herein, and 11 other police officers including the O.C. East
Agartala, Police Station, O.C. West Agartala Police Station, the
O.C. NCC police station stormed into the residence of the
petitioner. On 05.04.2020, the I.O. of NCC P.S. case No.52/2020
made a prayer to the concerned Court for issuance of search
warrant for the search of the house of the petitioner, but the
learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class Tripura (in-charge being a
Sunday) held that a detailed hearing is needed and posted the
matter on 06.04.2020, before the regular Court. Thereafter a
detailed hearing was done before the learned Addl. Chief Judicial
Magistrate, West Tripura and, the learned Court rejected the
prayer for search by order dated 06.04.2020. But in the meantime
search has been done on 05.04.2020 itself.
13.
Now the petitioner by filing this petition agitated that
the police authorities on 5th April 2020, despite the Judicial
Magistrate refusing to grant the prayer for the search warrant,
raided the residential premise of the petitioner. According to him,
on the said date nearly 200 armed police personnel under the
command of Deputy Superintendent of Police, West Tripura,
stormed the residence of the petitioner at about 2.45 p.m. The
petitioner was residing alone at that time. The senior leaders of the
political parties upon learning of the ongoing search arrived at the
site and tried to intervene. However, the petitioner was locked up
in the house and the visitors were not allowed to enter the house.
In brief, the case of the petitioner is that the entire action was a
result of political vendetta. An illegal search was carried out
despite the refusal to grant permission by the Judicial Magistrate.
14.
Now as such by filing this petition, the petitioner
sought a direction upon the respondents to compensate him by
paying Rs.10 lakhs as a public law remedy for violation of the
petitioners' fundamental right to free movement & expression,
right to privacy, right to life and health and right to liberty
guaranteed under Article 19 and 20 of the Constitution of India.
The Petitioner has also sought direction upon the respondents to
ensure the safety and security to the Petitioner.
15.
On the other hand, the case of the respondents is
that the petitioner has un-authorizedly used the Ashok Chakra, the
National Emblem while making malicious and false complaints
against the then Chief Minister of Tripura. Even during the search
of the premises of the petitioner by the search team, 10(ten) blank
pads having Letterhead with National Emblem symbol printed on it
and scripted as:“ Gopal Chandra Roy, Ex-MLA,
Advisor Tripura State Congress Committee,
President Tripura State Olympic Association,
Ex-President, Tripura Pradesh Congress Committee,
Ex-CLP Leader, Tripura,
Advocate, Tripura High Court,
Owner and Editor of Ganasambad Patrika”
16.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned Sr. counsel assisted by
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate appearing for the petitioner submits that on
05.04.2020,
the
learned
Judicial
Magistrate
1st
Class
while
considering the prayer for the issuing search warrant has recorded
that, no preliminary investigation has been conducted by the I.O.
and the learned Court did not found any material based on which
search warrant can be issued. Later Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate
on 06.04.2020, rejected the prayer for the issuance of the search
warrant. But by conducting the illegal search on 05.04.2020, the
respondents showed utter contempt to the learned Magisterial
Court and showed disrespect to the Court. After perusing the case
record and after hearing the learned Addl. P.P., the learned Judicial
Magistrate 1st Class, did not find any material to issue the search
warrant, as no preliminary investigation was carried out by the I.O.
The respondents on that day itself caused an illegal search in the
house of the petitioner ignoring the salutary observation of the
learned Court, that, issuance of the search warrant is not an empty
formality and as search causes loss of prestige and fame to the
person, whose premises is searched. Despite such observation of
the learned Court, the respondents were so desperate and
arrogant, that, on that day, the respondents conducted an illegal
search, subjecting to petitioners' illegal detention, harassment, etc.
The respondents' defended the search by invoking Section 165 of
the Cr.P.C. But in the counter affidavit, there is no whisper as to
whether the conditions imposed in Section 165 were fulfilled. One
of the basic precondition of invoking Section 165 of Cr.P.C. is that
the I.O. records in writing the grounds of his belief that search is
immediately called for and specify in writing as far as possible, the
things for which search is made. From the counter affidavit, it is
clear that said preconditions have been given a complete goodbye.
Moreover, Condition-(i) of Section 165 of Cr.P.C. as stated above,
was not also attracted as the I.O. could not have reasonable
ground, that investigation cannot be carried on otherwise than by
making a search without undue delay because the learned Judicial
Magistrate 1st class on 05.04.2020, itself after perusing the case
record and prayer for issuing the search came to the specific
finding that no preliminary investigation has been conducted by
the I.O., and the learned Court below was of the view that, there is
nothing on record which is brought out through investigation, that,
otherwise
than
by
making
a
search
without
undue
delay
investigation cannot be carried out. The search of the house of the
petitioner was not called for, for the purpose of investigation and it
was not authorized by law. As such, the search is illegal &
arbitrary. The illegal search and detention of the petitioner was an
infringement on the petitioner's right to life & liberty, including the
right to privacy. For violation of fundamental rights, the petitioner
is entitled to monetary compensation payable by the respondents
under public law.
To
support
his
argument,
learned
Sr.
counsel
appearing for the petitioner pressed into service paras No.2 and
7 of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court passed in case No
Criminal Appeal No.39 of 1958 titled as The State of
Rajasthan Vs. Rehman, which is reproduced here-in-under:“2. The material facts lie in a small compass. The Deputy
Superintendent of the Central Excise, having his head-quarters at
Bharatpur, received information that one Sulled and his son, Rehman,
the respondent herein, had cultivated tobacco but had not paid the
excise duty payable thereon. On September 9, 1953, the Deputy
Superintendent, accompanied by an Inspector of Central Excise, a
sepoy, a chowkidar and two motbirs went to the house of Rehman at 2
p.m., with a view to search his house to find out whether he had stored
tobacco there. When they declared their intention to do so, the
respondent and one Dhamman, it is alleged, obstructed the making of
the search; with the result that the Deputy Superintendent fell down
and received some injuries. The respondent and Dhamman were
prosecuted, and the Munsif-Magistrate, Hinduan, discharged Dhamman
but convicted the respondent under s. 353 of the Indian Penal Code and
sentenced him to undergo three months' rigorous imprisonment. On
appeal, the Additional Sessions Judge came to the conclusion that on
the material then available the search had not been conducted in
accordance with s. 165 of the Criminal Procedure Code and remanded
the case for fresh enquiry. On remand, the Munsif-Magistrate found that
the search was made by the Deputy Superintendent without recording
the reasons as he should under s. 165 of the Criminal Procedure Code
and that the respondent in obstructing him from making the illegal
search did not commit any offence, and, on that finding, the acquitted
the respondent. On appeal, the High Court agreed with the view
expressed by the Munsif-Magistrate and confirmed the order of
acquittal. The State of Rajasthan preferred the present appeal
questioning the correctness of the decision of the High Court.
7. Now we shall look at the provisions of the Criminal
Procedure Code to ascertain which of its provisions regulating the mode
of search are appropriate to the power conferred on the Deputy
Superintendent under r. 201 of the Rules. In the Criminal Procedure
Coded there are four groups of sections regulating the searches
authorised under it. Sections 47, 48, 51 and 52 appear in Ch. V of the
Code which provides for the arrest, escape and retaking of persons.
Section 47 provides for the search of a place entered by persons sought
to be arrested; s. 48 for procedure where ingress is not obtainable; and
ss. 51 and 52 for the search of the arrested persons. The second group
consists of ss. 100, 101, 102 and 103 of Ch. VII of the Code. Section
100 deals with the search for persons wrongfully confined, and the other
sections are general provisions relating to search warrants, duties of
persons in charge of closed places and the requisitioning of persons to
witness searches. Section 153 forms the third group and it falls under
Ch. XIII of the Code which provides for the preventive action of the
police. Under s. 153, a police officer can make a search without a
warrant for the purpose of inspecting or searching for any weights or
measures or instruments for weighing used or kept within the limits of
his station, if he has reason to believe that the weights etc. are false.
The fourth group of sections appear in Ch. XIV which provides for
searches by a police officer during the investigation of a cognizable
offence. The power of search given under this chapter is incidental to
the conduct of investigation the police officer is authorized by law to
make. Under s. 165 four conditions are imposed : (i) the police officer
must have reasonable ground for believing that anything necessary for
the purposes of an investigation of an offence cannot, in his opinion, be
obtained otherwise than by making a search, without undue delay; (ii)
he should record in writing the grounds of his belief and specify in such
writing as far as possible the things for which the search is to be made;
(ii) he must conduct the search, if practicable, in person; and (iv) if it is
not practicable to make the search himself, he must record in writing
the reasons for not himself making the search and shall authorize a
subordinate officer to make the search after specifying in writing the
place to be searched, and, so far as possible, the thing for which search
is to be made. As search is a process exceedingly arbitrary in character,
stringent statutory conditions are imposed on the exercise of the power.
A comparative study of the aforesaid provisions with the provisions of r.
201 of the Rules indicates that searches made by a police officer during
the course of an investigation of a cognizable offence can properly be
approximated with the searches to be made by the authorized officer
under r. 201 of the rules; for, in the former case, the police officer
makes a search during the investigation of a cognizable office and in the
latter the authorized officer makes the search to ascertain whether a
person contravened the provisions of the Act or the Rules which is an
offence. There is also no reason why conditions should be imposed in
the matter of a search by the police officer under s. 165 of the code, but
no such safe-guard need be provided in the case of a search by the
excises under the Rules. We think that the legislature, by stating in s.
18 of the Act that the searches under the Act and the Rules shall be
carried out in accordance with the provisions of the Code relating to
searches, clearly indicated that the appropriate provisions of the Code
shall govern searches authorized under the Act and the Rules. We
therefore hold that the provisions of s. 165 of the Code must be
followed in the matter of searches under s. 201 of the Rules.”
17.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Kar. Bhowmik, Spl. Public
Prosecutor appearing for the State-respondents contended that
this search was justified due to the finding of the letterhead with
the National Emblem printed in the left corner of it. According to
THE STATE EMBLEM OF INDIA (PROHIBITION OF IMPROPER USE)
ACT, 2005 and State Emblem of India(Regulation of Use) Rules
2007, the petitioner cannot use the same as he was an ex-MLA at
the time of the incident and he is not allowed to use the National
emblem. No wrong was committed by the investigating agency.
Further a criminal case that has been lodged against the petitioner
for improper use of the State Emblem is under investigation and
there
is
no
prayer
for
quashing
the
same.
As
such
no
compensation can be granted to petitioner until the unless the
criminal case is alive. In the grab of getting compensation, the
petitioner is trying to put a death nail on the criminal proceeding
because without quashing the criminal case, compensation cannot
be granted. The petitioner is a man of big stature and the
petitioner himself submitted that when police went to his premises
for search, all the senior members of the political party went to his
house. So naturally a large police force was needed to maintain the
law and order and to conduct the search peacefully. Accordingly,
sufficient police were present and conducted search without
infringing the rights of the petitioner.
He further argued that in the Case Dairy, on pages
No. 4, 17, 21, and especially on page- 38, a detailed reasoning has
been given for making the search and they have not violated
Section 165 of Cr.P.C. and other provisions of law. Also at the time
of the search, the I.O. of the case seized 10(ten) blank pads
having letterhead scripted as:“ Gopal Chandra Roy, Ex-MLA,
Advisor Tripura State Congress Committee,
President Tripura State Olympic Association,
Ex-President, Tripura Pradesh Congress Committee,
Ex-CLP Leader, Tripura,
Advocate, Tripura High Court,
Owner and Editor of Ganasambad Patrika”
With the symbol of the National Emblem printed on
the left corner of the letter pad.
To support his argument, Mr. S. Kar Bhowmik,
learned Spl. P.P. appearing for the respondents cited paras No.9,
10,11 and 12 of the
Hon’ble Apex Court Judgment reported in
SCC Online SC 379 passed in Central Bureau of
Investigation Vs. Aryan Singh etc. The same is reproduced
herein under:“9. Having gone through the impugned common
judgment and order passed by the High Court quashing the criminal
proceedings and discharging the accused, we are of the opinion that
the High Court has exceeded in its jurisdiction in quashing the entire
criminal proceedings in exercise of the limited powers under Section
482 Cr.P.C. and/or in exercise of the powers under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
10. From the impugned common judgment and order
passed by the High Court, it appears that the High Court has dealt with
the proceedings before it, as if, the High Court was conducting a mini
trial and/or the High Court was considering the applications against the
judgment and order passed by the learned Trial Court on conclusion of
trial. As per the cardinal principle of law, at the stage of discharge
and/or quashing of the criminal proceedings, while exercising the
powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C., the Court is not required to conduct
the mini trial…………
11……… Therefore, the High Court has erred in
observing at this stage that the initiation of the criminal proceedings /
proceedings is malicious. Whether the criminal proceedings was/were
malicious or not, is not required to be considered at this stage. The
same is required to be considered at the conclusion of the trial. In any
case, at this stage, what is required to be considered is a prima facie
case and the material collected during the course of the investigation,
which warranted the accused to be tried.
12. In view of the above and for the reasons stated
above, when the High Court has exceeded in its jurisdiction in
quashing the entire criminal proceedings and applying the law laid
down by this Court in catena of decisions on exercise of the powers at
the stage of discharge and/or quashing the criminal proceedings, the
impugned common judgment and order passed by the High Court
quashing the criminal proceedings against the accused is unsustainable
and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside. ”
18.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on record.
19.
Now for proper appreciation of the case, it is required
to examine Sections 47, 160, and 165 of Cr.P.C., which is
produced here-in-under:“47. Search of place entered by person sought to be
arrested.
(1) If any person acting under a warrant of arrest, or any police
officer having authority to arrest, has reason to believe that the
person to be arrested has entered into, or is within, any place, any
person residing in, or being in charge of, such place shall, on
demand of such person acting as aforesaid or such police officer,
allow him free ingress thereto, and afford all reasonable facilities for
a search therein.
(2) If ingress to such place cannot be obtained under subsection
(1), it shall be lawful in any case for a person acting under a warrant
and in any case in which a warrant may issue, but cannot be
obtained without affording the person to be arrested an opportunity
of escape, for a police officer to enter such place and search therein,
and in order to effect an entrance into such place, to break open any
outer or inner door or window of any house or place, whether that of
the person to be arrested or of any other person, if after notification
of his authority and purpose, and demand of admittance duly made,
he cannot otherwise obtain admittance: Provided that, if any such
place is an apartment in the actual occupancy of a female (not being
the person to be arrested) who, according to custom, does not
appear in public, such person or police officer shall, before entering
such apartment, give notice to such female that she is at liberty to
withdraw and shall afford her every reasonable facility for
withdrawing, and may then break open the apartment and enter it.
(3) Any police officer or other person authorised to make an arrest
may break open any outer or inner door or window of any house or
place in order to liberate himself or any other person who, having
lawfully entered for the purpose of making an arrest, is detained
therein.
160. Police officer' s power to require attendance of witnesses.
(1) Any police officer, making an investigation under this Chapter
may, by order in writing, require the attendance before himself of
any person being within the limits of his own or any adjoining
station who, from the information given or otherwise, appears to be
acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the case; and such
person shall attend as so required: Provided that no male person
under the age of fifteen years or woman shall be required to attend
at any place other than the place in which such male person or
woman resides.
(2) The State Government may, by rules made in this behalf,
provide for the payment by the police officer of the reasonable
expenses of every person, attending under sub- section (1) at any
place other than his residence.
165. Search by police office (1) Whenever an officer in charge of
police station or a police officer making an investigation has
reasonable grounds for believing that anything necessary for the
purposes of an investigation into any offence which he is authorised
to investigate may be found in any place within the limits of the
police station of which he is in charge, or to which he is attached,
and that such thing cannot in his opinion be otherwise obtained
without undue delay, such officer may, after recording in writing the
grounds of his belief and specifying in such writing, so far as
possible, the thing for which search is to be made, search, or cause
search to be made, for such thing in any place within the limits of
such station.
(2) A police officer proceeding under Sub-Section (1), shall, if
practicable, conduct the search in person.
(3)If he is unable to conduct the search in person, and there is no
other person competent to make the search present at the time, he
may, after recording in writing his reasons for so doing, require any
officer subordinate to him to make the search, and he shall deliver
to such subordinate officer an order in writing, specifying the place
to be searched, and so far as possible, the thing for which search is
to be made; and such subordinate officer may thereupon search for
such thing in such place.
(4)The provisions of this Code as to search-warrants and the
general provisions as to searches contained in section 100 shall, so
far as may be, apply to a search made under this section.
(5) Copies of any record made under Sub-Section (1) or SubSection (3) shall forthwith be sent to the nearest Magistrate
empowered to take cognizance to the offence, and the owner or
occupier of the place searched shall, on application, be furnished,
free of cost, with a copy of the same by the Magistrate.”
20.
Vide order dated 05.04.2020 (Sunday), passed by the
learned Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, a specific finding was given
that no materials was produced to justify the issuance of the
search warrant and learned Court below kept the matter for further
hearing on 06.04.2020. Since 05.04.2020 was Holiday (Sunday)
the case was taken up by an in-charge Judge, but on 06.04.2020,
the same was taken up before a regular Court having Jurisdiction
and the learned Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate, West Tripura,
Agartala passed a detailed order on 06.04.2020 rejecting the
search. But by 05.04.2020 itself, the search has been done.
21.
Here it also becomes relevant for extracting Sections
3, 7(1) (2) of THE STATE EMBLEM OF INDIA(PROHIBITION OF
IMPROPER USE) ACT, 2005:“ 3. Notwithstanding anything contained in any other
law for the time being in force, no person shall use the emblem or any
colourable imitation thereof in any manner which tends to create an
impression that it relates to the Government or that it is an official
document of the Central Government, or as the case may be, the State
Government, without the previous permission of the Central Government
or of such officer of that Government as may be authorised by it in this
behalf.
Explanation.- For the purposes of this section, "person" includes a former
functionary of the Central Government or the State Governments.
7(1). Any person who contravenes the provisions of section 3 shall be
punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years,
or with fine which may extend to five thousand rupees, or with both or, if
having been previously convicted of an offence under this section, is
again convicted of any such offence, he shall be punishable for the
second and for every subsequent offence with imprisonment for a term
which shall not be less than six months, which may extend to two years
and with fine which may extend to five thousand rupees.
(2) Any person who contravenes the provisions of section 4 for any
wrongful gain shall be punishable for such offence with imprisonment for
a term which shall not be less than six months, which may extend to two
years and with fine which may extend to five thousand rupees.
22.
Hear we may also produce Rules 5, 6 and 10 of State
Emblem of India(Regulation of Use) Rules, 2007, published vide
notification Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part-II, Section 3, Sub
Section(i) dated the 4th October, 2007:“ 5. Use of official seals.- The use of emblem in official seal
shall be restricted to the authorities specified in Schedule I.
6. Use on stationery.- (1) The use of the emblem on official
or demi-official stationery shall be restricted to the authorities specified in
the Schedule I aforesaid.
(2) The emblem, when printed or embossed on official or
demi-official stationery, shall appear prominently on the middle of the top
of such stationery.
10. Restriction on the use of the emblem.(1) No
person(including former functionaries of the Government, like former
Ministers, former Members of Parliament, former Member of Legislative
Assemblies, former Judges and retired Government Officials, other than
those authorized under the rules shall use the emblem in any manner.
SCHEDULE-1
(See Rules 5 and 6)
CONSTITUTIONAL OR STATURORY AUTHORITIES, MINISTERS OR
DEPARTMENTS OF THE CENTRAL GOVERNMENT, STATE GOVERNMENT OR
UNION TERRIROTY ADMINISTRATION AND OTHERS GOVERNMENT
FUNCTIONARIES WHICH MAY USE THE EMBLEM.
(I) President, Vice-President, Prime Minister and a Union Minister;
(ii) Governors, Lieutenant Governors, Administrators, if the emblem is
adopted by, or incorporated in the Emblem of, that State or the Union
Territory, as the case may be;
(iii) Office and officers of the Parliament of India:
(iv) Judges and office and officers of the Judiciary;
(v) Office and officers of the Planning Commission;
(vi) Chief Election Commissioner of India, Election Commissioners and
the office and officers of the Election Commission of India;
(vii) Comptroller and Auditor General of India, the office and officers of
the Comptroller and Auditor General of India;
(viii) Chairperson and Members of the Union Public Service Commission
and the office and officers of the Union Public Service Commission;
(ix) Ministries, Departments and offices of the Central Government and
their officers;
(x) Diplomatic Missions abroad and their officers;
(xi) Chief Ministers and Ministers of the States and the Union territories,,
if the emblem is adopted by, or incorporated in the Emblem of, that State
or the Union territory;
(xii) Members of Parliament and members of State or the Union territoryLegislative Assemblies or Councils, as the case may be;
(xiii) Ministries, Department's and offices of the State and the Union
territory Governments and their officers, if the emblem is adopted by, or
incorporated in the Emblem of, that State or the Union territory;
(xiv) Office and officers of the State or the Union territory Legislative
Assemblies or Councils, if the emblem is adopted by, or incorporated in
the Emblem of, that State or the Union territory;
(xv) Commissions and authorities, constituted or established by an Act of
Parliament or set up by the Central Government;
(xvi) Commissions and authorities constituted or established by an Act of
the State Legislature or set up by the State Government, if the emblem is
adopted by, or incorporated in the Emblem of, that State or the Union
territory;”
23.
The Judgment in the State of Rajasthan Vs.
Rehman(supra) relied by petitioner-counsel is referred here-inunder for convenience:“2. The material facts lie in a small compass. The
Deputy Superintendent of the Central Excise, having his head-quarters
at Bharatpur, received information that one Sulled and his son,
Rehman, the respondent herein, had cultivated tobacco but had not paid
the excise duty payable thereon. On September 9, 1953, the Deputy
Superintendent, accompanied by an Inspector of Central Excise, a
sepoy, a chowkidar and two motbirs went to the house of Rehman at 2
p.m., with a view to search his house to find out whether he had stored
tobacco there. When they declared their intention to do so, the
respondent and one Dhamman, it is alleged, obstructed the making of
the search; with the result that the Deputy Superintendent fell down
and received some injuries. The respondent and Dhamman were
prosecuted, and the Munsif-Magistrate, Hinduan, discharged Dhamman
but convicted the respondent under s. 353 of the Indian Penal Code and
sentenced him to undergo three months' rigorous imprisonment. On
appeal, the Additional Sessions Judge came to the conclusion that on
the material then available the search had not been conducted in
accordance with s. 165 of the Criminal Procedure Code and remanded
the case for fresh enquiry. On remand, the Munsif-Magistrate found that
the search was made by the Deputy Superintendent without recording
the reasons as he should under s. 165 of the Criminal Procedure Code
and that the respondent in obstructing him from making the illegal
search did not commit any offence, and, on that finding, the acquitted
the respondent. On appeal, the High Court agreed with the view
expressed by the Munsif-Magistrate and confirmed the order of
acquittal. The State of Rajasthan preferred the present appeal
questioning the correctness of the decision of the High Court.
7. Now we shall look at the provisions of the Criminal
Procedure Code to ascertain which of its provisions regulating the mode
of search are appropriate to the power conferred on the Deputy
Superintendent under r. 201 of the Rules. In the Criminal Procedure
Coded there are four groups of sections regulating the searches
authorised under it. Sections 47, 48, 51 and 52 appear in Ch. V of the
Code which provides for the arrest, escape and retaking of persons.
Section 47 provides for the search of a place entered by persons sought
to be arrested; s. 48 for procedure where ingress is not obtainable; and
ss. 51 and 52 for the search of the arrested persons. The second group
consists of ss. 100, 101, 102 and 103 of Ch. VII of the Code. Section
100 deals with the search for persons wrongfully confined, and the other
sections are general provisions relating to search warrants, duties of
persons in charge of closed places and the requisitioning of persons to
witness searches. Section 153 forms the third group and it falls under
Ch. XIII of the Code which provides for the preventive action of the
police. Under s. 153, a police officer can make a search without a
warrant for the purpose of inspecting or searching for any weights or
measures or instruments for weighing used or kept within the limits of
his station, if he has reason to believe that the weights etc. are false.
The fourth group of sections appear in Ch. XIV which provides for
searches by a police officer during the investigation of a cognizable
offence. The power of search given under this chapter is incidental to
the conduct of investigation the police officer is authorized by law to
make. Under s. 165 four conditions are imposed : (i) the police officer
must have reasonable ground for believing that anything necessary for
the purposes of an investigation of an offence cannot, in his opinion, be
obtained otherwise than by making a search, without undue delay; (ii)
he should record in writing the grounds of his belief and specify in such
writing as far as possible the things for which the search is to be made;
(ii) he must conduct the search, if practicable, in person; and (iv) if it is
not practicable to make the search himself, he must record in writing
the reasons for not himself making the search and shall authorize a
subordinate officer to make the search after specifying in writing the
place to be searched, and, so far as possible, the thing for which search
is to be made. As search is a process exceedingly arbitrary in character,
stringent statutory conditions are imposed on the exercise of the power.
A comparative study of the aforesaid provisions with the provisions of r.
201 of the Rules indicates that searches made by a police officer during
the course of an investigation of a cognizable offence can properly be
approximated with the searches to be made by the authorized officer
under r. 201 of the rules; for, in the former case, the police officer
makes a search during the investigation of a cognizable office and in the
latter the authorized officer makes the search to ascertain whether a
person contravened the provisions of the Act or the Rules which is an
offence. There is also no reason why conditions should be imposed in
the matter of a search by the police officer under s. 165 of the code, but
no such safe-guard need be provided in the case of a search by the
excises under the Rules. We think that the legislature, by stating in s.
18 of the Act that the searches under the Act and the Rules shall be
carried out in accordance with the provisions of the Code relating to
searches, clearly indicated that the appropriate provisions of the Code
shall govern searches authorized under the Act and the Rules. We
therefore hold that the provisions of s. 165 of the Code must be
followed in the matter of searches under s. 201 of the Rules.”
24.
passed
On the other hand, the Supreme Court Judgment
in
Aryan
Singh(supra)
relied
by
the
respondents
supporting their claim that the search was made in accordance
with Section 165 of Cr.P.C. is again reproduced herein for
convenience:“9. Having gone through the impugned common
judgment and order passed by the High Court quashing the criminal
proceedings and discharging the accused, we are of the opinion that
the High Court has exceeded in its jurisdiction in quashing the entire
criminal proceedings in exercise of the limited powers under Section
482 Cr.P.C. and/or in exercise of the powers under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
10. From the impugned common judgment and order
passed by the High Court, it appears that the High Court has dealt with
the proceedings before it, as if, the High Court was conducting a mini
trial and/or the High Court was considering the applications against the
judgment and order passed by the learned Trial Court on conclusion of
trial. As per the cardinal principle of law, at the stage of discharge
and/or quashing of the criminal proceedings, while exercising the
powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C., the Court is not required to conduct
the mini trial…………
11……… Therefore, the High Court has erred in observing at this stage
that the initiation of the criminal proceedings / proceedings is
malicious. Whether the criminal proceedings was/were malicious or
not, is not required to be considered at this stage. The same is
required to be considered at the conclusion of the trial. In any case, at
this stage, what is required to be considered is a prima facie case and
the material collected during the course of the investigation, which
warranted the accused to be tried.
12. In view of the above and for the reasons stated
above, when the High Court has exceeded in its jurisdiction in
quashing the entire criminal proceedings and applying the law laid
down by this Court in catena of decisions on exercise of the powers at
the stage of discharge and/or quashing the criminal proceedings, the
impugned common judgment and order passed by the High Court
quashing the criminal proceedings against the accused is unsustainable
and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside. ”
25.
Admittedly, it is the case where the petitioner has
confined his petition only to the extent of paying compensation.
The said prayer of the petitioner is again reproduced here-inunder:“b. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other
order/orders shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to compensate the petitioner by paying Rs-10 lakh as
public law remedy for violation of the petitioners’ fundamental right
to free movement & expression, right to privacy, right to life and
health and right to liberty guaranteed under Article 19 & 21 of the
Constitution of India.”
26.
Here the petitioner has prayed for compensation for
alleged violation of Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
The same is produced here-in-under:“19. Protection of certain rights regarding freedom of
speech etc
(1) All citizens shall have the right
(a) to freedom of speech and expression;
(b) to assemble peaceably and without arms;
(c) to form associations or unions;
(d) to move freely throughout the territory of India;
(e) to reside and settle in any part of the territory of India; and
(f) omitted
(g) to practise any profession, or to carry on any occupation, trade or
business
(2) Nothing in sub clause (a) of clause ( 1 ) shall affect the operation
of any existing law, or prevent the State from making any law, in so
far as such law imposes reasonable restrictions on the exercise of the
right conferred by the said sub clause in the interests of the
sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of the State, friendly
relations with foreign States, public order, decency or morality or in
relation to contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offence
(3) Nothing in sub clause (b) of the said clause shall affect the
operation of any existing law in so far as it imposes, or prevent the
State from making any law imposing, in the interests of the
sovereignty and integrity of India or public order, reasonable
restrictions on the exercise of the right conferred by the said sub
clause
(4) Nothing in sub clause (c) of the said clause shall affect the
operation of any existing law in so far as it imposes, or prevent the
State from making any law imposing, in the interests of the
sovereignty and integrity of India or public order or morality,
reasonable restrictions on the exercise of the right conferred by the
said sub clause
(5) Nothing in sub clauses (d) and (e) of the said clause shall affect
the operation of any existing law in so far as it imposes, or prevent
the State from making any law imposing, reasonable restrictions on
the exercise of any of the rights conferred by the said sub clauses
either in the interests of the general public or for the protection of the
interests of any Scheduled Tribe
(6) Nothing in sub clause (g) of the said clause shall affect the
operation of any existing law in so far as it imposes, or prevent the
State from making any law imposing, in the interests of the general
public, reasonable restrictions on the exercise of the right conferred
by the said sub clause, and, in particular, nothing in the said sub
clause shall affect the operation of any existing law in so far as it
relates to, or prevent the State from making any law relating to,
(i) the professional or technical qualifications necessary for practising
any profession or carrying on any occupation, trade or business, or
(ii) the carrying on by the State, or by a corporation owned or
controlled by the State, of any trade, business, industry or service,
whether to the exclusion, complete or partial, of citizens or otherwise
21. “Protection of Life and Personal Liberty: No person shall be
deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure
established by law.”
27.
During the course of the argument, learned Sr.
counsel appearing for the petitioner has categorically stated that
his client was not arrested but his premises was only searched.
Learned Sr. counsel made a submission that search was made with
200 Armed Police Personnel, under the command of the DSP, West
Tripura, respondent No.4 herein, and 11 other police officers were
involved. Though in the counter affidavit, the respondents have
denied the same, but they submitted that sufficient numbers of
police personnel with lady officers had conducted the raid.
28.
Here it is to be considered that the petitioner who is
an accused person in this crime against whom the FIR has been
registered by the respondents is a prominent leader. The petitioner
at the time of the alleged incident was an Ex-MLA, Advisory Tripura
Pradesh Congress Committee, President, the Tripura State Olympic
Association, Ex-president of Tripura Pradesh Congress Committee,
Ex-CLD
Leader
Tripura,
Advocate,
Association, Editor Ganasanbad Partika.
Tripura
High
Court
Bar
29.
In view of the prominence of the petitioner in being a
political
leader
mentioned
and
holding
here-in-above,
various
important
positions
anticipating
some
and
law
as
order
problems and disturbance in the locality, the police personnel took
proper precautions during the course of undertaking the search.
Admittedly it is not the case of the petitioner that he was arrested
unlawful detention was made or his liberty was affected. No
specific emphasis is made as to which Right under Article 19 of the
Constitution of India was infringed and also how Article 21 of the
Constitution of India has been violated.
30.
Here, the petitioner has also filed an Interlocutory
application No.1 of 2023 and has sought to decide the matter as a
writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The
prayer portion of the petitioner in I.A No.01 of 2023 is as follows:“ i. Allow the instant application by the petitioner filed
under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. and recall the Order, dated 06.01.2021
passed in WP(C) No.645 of 2020 by the Hon’ble Court and treat the
petition filed by the petitioner as writ petition under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India.
ii. Pass any further Order/Orders as this Hon’ble High
Court considered fit and proper.”
In view of the above prayer, the present I.A. filed by
the petitioner stood ordered.
31.
Now examining the present matter under Article 226
of the constitution of India which is cited supra, unless a case is
made out to give a finding against any action of the respondents
that they have violated the law, it is not for this Court to
straightaway express its opinion that the respondents-Police
Official have violated the law and award compensation for the
same. Moreover, seeking any compensation in the absence of any
such scheme or rules and praying before this Court to invoke the
writ Jurisdiction is illusionary. This Court has no hesitation to say
that in view of the disputed questions of facts, it would not be
proper
to
grant
compensation.
In
view
of
the
facts
and
circumstances, the compensation can only be claimed before the
competent Civil Court but not in writ Court. This Court has not
expressed
any
opinion
that
the
petitioner
is
entitled
to
compensation or otherwise.
32.
This Court is of the opinion that no case has been
made out for compensation and no relief can be granted under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is premature to even
consider the request for compensation as the allegations made by
the petitioner are not established and substantiated. Disputed
questions of facts cannot be gone into in a petition filed under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The petitioner made an
allegation that 200 armed police personnel raided his premises on
5th April 2020 but prima facie the allegation has not been
established. According to the prosecution, the petitioner made a
complaint on a letterhead with the National Emblem printed in the
left corner of it. On search of the premises of the petitioner, the
police seized 10(ten) blank pads having the said letterheads
scripted on them. The said fact has not been denied by the
petitioner. The petitioner in his pleading has not explained the
physical and mental harassment as alleged by him. The petitioner
has not even made out how Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution
of India are infringed by the respondents and the same has not
been explained. It is seen from the record that there was no order
restraining the search made by the respondents on 05.04.2020,
therefore, it cannot be said that the said search was illegal. The
petitioner herein also has made contradictory statements; on one
hand, he accuses the then Chief Minister of Tripura, Sri Biplab
Kumar Deb of giving fake information on COVID-19 infections, and
on the other hand, the petitioner contends that during the COVID
period, so many police officers raided his premises; causing likely
hood of spreading COVID. Thus, if there is COVID, the statement
of the then Chief Minister of Tripura is correct. If there is no
COVID, the allegation of the petitioner that during COVID period,
200 police personnel raided his premises causing likely hood of
spreading COVID fails.
33.
In so far as the relief claimed to provide security and
safety in concerned, it is always open for the petitioner to
approach the concerned authority as per procedure. Since no
specific case is made out ventilating the endangering of life
requiring security and safety measures, no relief can be granted
and thus prayer stands rejected with the above observation.
34.
In view of the above discussion this Court is of the
opinion that the present writ petition is devoid of merits and the
same is liable to be dismissed and thus it is accordingly dismissed.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated and pending application(s),
if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
signed by
RAJKUMAR Digitally
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2023.09.15
SINGHA
15:59:16 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review