Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
DATED : 23.04.2019
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRP No. 9 of 2017
:
Petitioner
Golden Tobacco Limited
versus
:
Respondent
Sikkim Tobacco Limited
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Sudesh Joshi and Ms. Sujatha Shirolker, Advocates for
the Petitioner.
Mr. Manish Kumar Srivastava, Mr. Udai P. Sharma, Mr.
Passang Tshering Bhutia and Mr. Kusan Limboo,
Advocates for the Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J
1.
Assailing the Order dated 18.09.2017, in Civil
Execution Case No. 1 of 2014, the Petitioner is before this
Court inter alia praying that the impugned Order be set aside
and the learned District Judge, East Sikkim, at Gangtok, be
directed to appoint a Commissioner to find out the market
and the present value of the machines to enable execution of
the Order of this Court in CRP No. 03 of 2015 dated
09.03.2017. Further, the learned District Judge be directed to
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
ascertain whether seals on the machines as per the Order of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court are still in place or whether the
machines had been tampered with or damaged by the
Respondent. A direction was also sought to make the
Respondent pay the market value of the machines to the
Petitioner, the Respondent having violated the Order of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court by removing the seals and tampering
with the machines.
2.
Before the learned trial Court, the Petitioner
herein was the Decree Holder and the Respondent was the
Judgment Debtor and shall hereinafter be referred to as D.H.
and J.D. respectively.
3.
The learned trial Court on 18.09.2017 pronounced
the impugned Order rejecting the application filed by the J.D.
under Order XXI, Rule 58, read with Section 151 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter the “CPC”). The J.D. vide
the application had inter alia brought to the notice of the
learned trial Court that vide its Order of 07.08.2017, a
Warrant of Attachment had been issued for the machines of
the D.H., lying in the factory premises of the J.D. at Majhitar,
Rangpo, East Sikkim. Vide
the
same
Order (07.08.2017),
the learned trial Court had also ordered the D.H. to deposit a
sum of Rs. 2,92,86,700/- (Rupees two crores, ninety two
lakhs, eighty six thousand and seven hundred) only, along
with interest at the rate of 15% per annum on the aforestated
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
amount, from the date of Award till the date of payment i.e.
11.09.2017, as per the Award of the learned Arbitrator. The
D.H. failed to comply with the Order of the learned trial Court
and make the deposit. Consequently, in view of this failure,
the J.D. by filing the petition under Order XXI, Rule 58, read
with Section 151 of the CPC prayed that the Order of
attachment passed by the Court on 07.08.2017 be recalled
and the J.D. be permitted to partly realize its dues from the
D.H., through public auction of the machines.
4.
In response to the said application filed by the
J.D., the D.H. had contended that as per the Arbitration
Award dated 28.12.2007 and the Decree of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court, dated 02.02.2010, there was a clear cut
direction to return the twenty one machines to the D.H. This
had been violated by the J.D. by non-compliance. That, the
J.D. had no right to seek permission to auction the machines
instead of returning them to the D.H. That, it “appeared” from
the Report (evidently reference is being made to the Nazir‟s
Report, dated 11.09.2017) that the J.D. had tampered with
the machines and did not want it to be inspected by the D.H.
to prevent them from enjoying the fruits of the Decree. That
the J.D. had filed a Company Petition for executing the
Arbitration Award before the Hon‟ble High Court of Bombay in
a Winding Up Case, i.e. Company Petition No. 03 of 2011,
wherein the Hon‟ble High Court had passed orders and
directed the D.H. to deposit the amount in twelve weeks. In
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
view of this Order, the question of auctioning the machines of
the D.H. does not arise, hence the petition be dismissed.
5.
The learned trial Court on consideration of the
submissions rejected the petition vide the impugned Order
dated 18.09.2017. The learned trial Court in the same Order
referred to its Order dated 07.08.2017 which had been
passed after the D.H. had filed an execution petition, seeking
execution of the Decree. The Order also reflected that the
Nazir of the Court had executed the Warrant on 11.09.2017
and filed the Report of Attachment before the learned trial
Court.
6.
Pursuant to this Report of the Nazir, the records
of the learned trial Court reveal that a “Written Statement”
was filed by the D.H. on 14.09.2017, to the Nazir‟s Report in
addition to his reply to the petition of the J.D. under Order
XXI Rule 58 read with Section 151 of the CPC. The learned
trial Court in the impugned Order besides considering the
petition supra also took into consideration the „Written
Statement‟ against the Report of the Nazir and while agreeing
with the D.H. that the Nazir of the Court is not a Technical
person, however observed that the specifications of the
machines had been mentioned at Serial Nos. 1 to 9 in the
Order dated 07.08.2017, in accordance with which the Nazir
had attached the twenty one machines. The learned Trial
Court while addressing the issues raised in the “Written
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
Statement”
of the D.H. to the Nazir‟s Report, in the
impugned Order dated 18.09.2017, has inter alia further
observed as follows;
“Hence, there is no question of
examination of the machine (sic) by a technical
person.
It is averred that the commercial life of
the concerned machines was 10 years from
March 1983. The machines are very old as
recorded in the Arbitration Award dated
28.12.2007 as such there is no question of the
examination of the working condition of the
machines. Hence, prayer of the Decree holder
is hereby rejected.”
The learned trial Court in the impugned Order would also
observe that, the “Written Statement” of the D.H. to the
Report of the Nazir was in fact an indirect prayer for issuance
of a Commissioner, for inspection of the twenty one machines
lying in the factory premises of the J.D. Referring to the
decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, dated 02.02.2010 and
the Order of this Court dated 09.03.2017, the plea of the D.H.
for sending a technical person to verify the machines was
rejected.
7.
Aggrieved by this aspect of the Order, the instant
Revision has been filed where the D.H. has delved into the
facts of the case at great length and what transpired between
the parties. The attention of this Court was drawn to the
Arbitration
Award
dated
28.12.2007,
the
order
of
the
Supreme Court dated 02.02.2010, the proceedings before the
learned trial Court and also the Order of this Court dated
09.03.2017. It is apposite to state here that this Court is
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
seized of the facts, the Order of this Court in CRP No. 3 of
2015 would be sentinel to this circumstance.
8.
Before this Court, learned Counsel Mr. Sudesh
Joshi for the D.H. submitted that the seals of the machines
had been broken indicating that they had been tampered with
and thereby damaged instead of being returned untampered
to them by the J.D. That, when the Nazir went to the place
where the machines were kept it was lying in the open and
not protected. That, the Report reflects that the Nazir had
attached all the properties with the assistance of the Manager
of the J.D. Company with the assurance that he would not sell
or use it without prior permission of the Court but had failed
to take custody of the machines. He had in fact handed it
over to the Manager of the J.D. Company to keep it in his
custody, thereby defeating the purpose of the attachment
order. Hence, it was urged that a technical person ought to
be appointed to assess the condition of the machines as the
Nazir‟s Report does not state which machines were attached,
the types of machines, the conditions they were in or
identification thereof. That, the learned trial Court be directed
to take necessary steps, as reflected in the prayers.
9.
Learned Counsel for the J.D. submitted that it is
apparent from the records of the matter that the D.H. came
to know that the machines were scrap in the year 1995 itself.
That, in the Arbitration Award dated 28.12.2007 they did not
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
ask for restoration of the machines, neither did the Arbitration
Award or the Order of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court require the
J.D. to return the machines in working order. It is clear that
the machines were of the year 1983 and were to be in
working condition for up to ten years, that period having
lapsed, it is no longer in working condition. That, the
Arbitration Award also clearly indicates that the machines
were not in working order. That, it serves no purpose to
appoint a technical person to assess the condition of the
machines which were already scrap, hence the order of the
learned trial Court requires no interference.
10.
I have carefully heard and considered the rival
arguments forwarded by both learned Counsel and I have
also perused the impugned Order and all records pertaining to
the matter.
11.
What emanates from the records furnished before
this Court is that, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court vide its Order
dated 27.11.1984 in Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 11286
of 1984 and Transfer Petition No. 439 of 1984, transferred
Suit No. 51 of 1983 (Sikkim Tobacco Co. Ltd. Vs. Golden
Tobacco Co. Ltd. and others), Suit No. 3 of 1984 (Himal
Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Golden Tobaco Co. Ltd. and others),
and Suit No. 36 of 1984 (Golden Himal Investment Pvt. Ltd.
Vs. Sikkim Tobacco Co. Ltd. and others), all pending before
the District Judge, Gangtok, Sikkim to the Hon‟ble Supreme
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
Court. The matter between the parties herein was referred to
arbitration and Mr. Justice A.C. Gupta, retired Judge of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court appointed as the Sole Arbitrator.
During the arbitration proceedings, Mr. Justice A.C. Gupta
expressed his inability to proceed in the matter, whereupon,
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court vide its Order dated 07.12.2001,
in I.A. No. 1 in Transfer Case (Civil) No. 12-14/1985,
appointed Mr. S.C. Agarwal, former Judge of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court as the Sole Arbitrator. Mr. Justice S.C.
Agarwal passed the Arbitration Award on 28.12.2007 which
inter alia is as follows;
“1) STL is entitled to retain 3 machines
mentioned at Sr. Nos. 1, 3 and 5 of Annexure
„A‟ to the Statement of Claim.
2) GTC is entitled to return of 21
machines mentioned at Sr. Nos. 1 to 6, 8, 9,
11 to 14, 16 to 20 and 22 to 25 of Annexure „A‟
to the Counter Claim.
3) GTC shall pay to the Claimants
towards
their
claim
an
amount
of
Rs.2,92,36,700=00 within a period of one
month from the date of award. In case GTC
fails
to
pay
the
said
amount
of
Rs.2,92,86,700=00 within a period of one
month it would pay interest @ 15% per annum
on the aforesaid amount of Rs.2,92,86,700=00
from the date of award till the date of
payment.
4) The parties will bear their own costs in
the proceedings.”
12.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the Award,
the D.H. was before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, who vide its
Order, dated 02.02.2010, in “Transferred Case (Civil) Nos.
12-14 of 1985” dismissed the objections filed by the D.H. and
the Award dated 28.12.2007 became a Rule of the Court. The
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
Order of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court dated 02.02.2010 is as
follows;
“ … Objections to the Award dated 28th
December, 2007 given by Hon‟ble Mr. Justice
S.C. Agarwal, former Judge of this Court are
rejected. Decree be prepared in terms of the
Award.
I.A. Nos. 2-5 are accordingly, dismissed.
...”
The D.H. being aggrieved by the Order dated 02.02.2010
supra, preferred a Review Petition bearing No. 2101-2104 and
a Curative Petition bearing No. 21-24 of 2012, both of which
were
disposed
of
by
the
Hon‟ble
Supreme
Court
on
machines
are
13.01.2011 and 22.03.2012, respectively.
13.
So
far
as
the
seals
on
the
concerned, the Arbitration Award reflects that under the
Order of the District Magistrate, East Sikkim at Gangtok,
dated 02.11.1983, the machines were put in possession of
the S.P., East for safe custody till 10.11.1983 and the
machines were put under seal in the factory building. The
learned District Judge issued an interim injunction restraining
removal of machines and maintenance of status quo. The
D.H. moved an application for modification of the said Order
to permit removal of the machines and the J.D. moved an
application for clarification of the Order dated 07.11.1983 to
permit removal of the seals. Both these applications were
dismissed by the learned District Judge by Order dated
11.05.1984.
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
14.
No specific Order of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
pertaining to sealing of machines was pointed out to this
Court by the D.H. It is thus apparent from the records
available before this Court that the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
has made no orders for sealing of the machines. Evidently the
twenty one machines were put under a common seal in the
factory building on the orders of the District Magistrate, East,
Gangtok, Sikkim. That apart, the Arbitration Award reflects as
follows;
“… The learned Sole Arbitrator, on April 4,
1984, passed an order appointing Mr. Mukul
Mudgal, Advocate, as Commissioner to
remove the seals affixed on the factory
building of STL as also the seals on the
three machines stated to be lying outside
the factory building and to see that they
are taken inside the factory building. It
was also directed that two technically qualified
persons, each side to select one, would inspect
the 21 machines lying in the STL premises,
prepare an inventory of the same and also
make an assessment of their present
condition.”
(Emphasis supplied)
15.
Thus, from the extract of the Arbitration Award
supra, it is clear that if at all, three machines which were said
to be outside the factory building were sealed but the twenty
one machines were in the factory building of the J.D., and the
building was sealed. Besides, it is evident from the Arbitration
Award that an inspection of the machines were carried out
and the Technical Expert Mr. Krishnamurthy of the D.H.
Company reported that the twenty one machines were no
longer in working condition. The Award reflects as follows;
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
“… By order dated November 26, 1986,
the learned Sole Arbitrator appointed Mr. Mukul
Mudgal, Advocate as Commissioner for
inspection of the machines and to make a
report whether machines were in order. Mr.
Mudgal was authorized to engage an engineer
to assist him and accompany him during
inspection. Since an inspection had not been
carried out in pursuance of the said order, the
learned Sole Arbitrator, by order dated
December 17, 1994, again gave a direction
regarding inspection of the machines at
Rangpo. In pursuance of the said direction, the
Advocate-Commissioner, Mr. Mukal Mudgal
inspected the machines on June 1, 1995. The
machines were also examined by Mr.
Krishnamurthy, a Technical Expert of GTC, and
the report of the Advocate-Commissioner along
with the Technical Report of Mr. Krishnamurthy
were submitted before the learned Sole
Arbitrator. As per the inspection report
dated June 5, 1995 of Mr. Krishnamurthy,
21 machines are no longer in working
condition and would require extensive
repair at a very high cost to restore them
to a working condition and even this
might not be possible as the machines
might have in fact been reduced to scrap.
…
…………………………………………………………………………….
The total number of machines lying at the
factory premises of STL at Rangpo in Sikkim is
24 as mentioned by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
in the Order dated November 27, 1984. The
learned Sole Arbitrator Mr. Justice A.C. Gupta
also in Order dated April 4, 1985 whereby Mr.
Mukul Mudgal, Advocate was appointed as
Commissioner, has mentioned that 3
machines were stated to be lying outside
the factory building and 21 machines were
lying in the factory premises of STL. …”
(Emphasis supplied)
16.
In this context it is relevant to refer to page No.
82 of the Arbitration Award which at “Claim No. 5” and “Claim
No. 10” has addressed the claim of the J.D. with regard to the
machines but bears no reference to seals on any machine.
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
This is reflected in the following pages of the Arbitration
Award as extracted hereinbelow;
[Page No. 24]
“…On October 13, 1983, a First
Information Report [FIR No.800/83] was
registered at Police Station, Connaught Place,
New Delhi on the basis of a complaint dated
October 10, 1983 made against Mr. B.K.
Sreshtha under Sections 406 and 420 IPC for
misappropriation of machines and on October
26, 1987 warrant was issued by Metropolitan
Magistrate, New Delhi on the basis of the said
FIR authorizing search of the machines and
requiring their production before the Court. On
October 30, 1983, a police party reached the
factory premises of STL in Sikkim, and seized
the machines. Under order of the District
Magistrate, East, Gangtok, Sikkim dated
November 2, 1983 the machines were put in
possession of S.P.[East], Sikkim for safe
custody till November 10, 1983 and the
machines were put under seal in the
factory. …”
[Page No. 115]
“… In pursuance of the said direction,
seals were placed by the Police to secure
safe custody of the machines which were
lying in the factory premises of STL in
Sikkim. …”
[Page No. 117]
…It is, thus, evident that the machines
were initially placed under seal on the
directions of the District Magistrate (East),
Sikkim dated November 2, 1983 which order
was operative till November 10, 1983 but in
the meanwhile Mr. B.K. Shreshta of STL had
obtained an order from the District Judge,
Sikkim, Gangtok, in Suit No. 51 of 1983 on
November 7, 1983, restraining removal of the
machines and for maintaining status quo and
the said order continued till September 25
1984 when it was set aside by Sikkim High
Court in but (sic) that order of the Sikkim High
Court was not implemented during the
pendency of the Special Leave Petition filed by
STL in the Supreme Court. This would show
that sealing
of the
machines
has
continued on the basis of the interim
order which was obtained by STL in Civil
Suit No.51 of 1983 which continued to be
operative till the reference of the dispute
to Arbitration and during the pendancy of
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
the arbitration proceedings also the
machines have remained under seal
because no Interim Award could be made
in favour of either of the parties. GTC
cannot, therefore, be held responsible for
the machines being placed under seal. The
situation that resulted in machines being
placed under seal arose on account of the
refusal on the part of the STL to return the
machines. STL cannot, therefore, raise
objection against the claim of GTC for
damages for wrongful retention of the
machines on the ground that STL cannot
be held responsible for such damages
since the machines were under seal and
they were not utilized by STL. In the
circumstances non-utilisation of he (sic)
machines by STL on account of the machines
having been put under seal cannot be a
justification for denying the claim of GTC for
damages since GTC was deprived of the use of
the machines on account of wrongful retention
of the machines by STL. …”
(Emphasis supplied)
The above extracts clearly shed light on the affixation of
seals.
17.
As far as assessing the present value and market
value of the machines are concerned, the Arbitration Award at
page No. 119 reflects that the expected commercial life of the
machines is ten years, the relevant portion is extracted below
for easy reference;
“… The Replacement Value for each
machine, as on March 1983, has been shown
and the total Replacement Value for the 21
machines is placed at Rs.218.14 lakhs. The
expected commercial life of the machines
is placed as 10 years and Rs.21.814 lakhs
has been taken as depreciation @ 10% for
one year. Rs.39.265 lakhs has been computed
as interest on the capital amount of Rs.218.14
lakhs @ 18% per annum. Entrepreneurs‟ risk
based on 5 years pay back period has been
calculated @ Rs.43.6328 lakh for one year. The
total amount towards hiring charges has been
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
worked out at Rs. 104.707 lakhs for one year
i.e. Rs.8,72,558=00 per month. …”
(Emphasis supplied)
Hence, the commercial life and value of the
18.
machines require no further elucidation. The Arbitration
Award nowhere mentions that the twenty one machines were
to be returned to the D.H. in working condition neither does it
lay down that the status and value of the machines were to
be ascertained before handing over. The Order of this Court
dated 09.03.2017 in C.R.P. No. 03 of 2015 mentions no such
direction
either.
It
is
a
misconception
and
erroneous
assumption of the D.H. which reflects, that the D.H. has failed
to understand the intent and purport of the Arbitration Award
or
the
substance
of
the
Orders
of
this
Court.
It
is
unfathomable as to why the D.H. should aver that “It means
the Respondent has violated Supreme Court order by illegally
opening the seals and tampered the machines of Petitioner
and used for their benefits thereby damaged the very
valuable imported machines of petitioner thereby cheated the
petitioner as well as Hon’ble Supreme Court and disobeyed
the order.” As already discussed hereinabove no order of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court issues with regard to the sealing of
the machines, consequently the question of disobedience
does not arise.
19.
We may also relevantly refer to I.A. No. 4 of 2008
in Transfer Case (Civil) No. 12-14 of 1985 before the Hon‟ble
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
Supreme Court wherein the D.H. had averred inter alia as
follows;
“…9. It is submitted that in view of the above
mentioned facts the claimant has suffered
additional loss quantification whereof will have
a vital bearing on the hearing and disposal of
the Objections filed by the Applicant under
Section 30 of the Arbitration Award, 1940. It
is consequently essential in the interest of
justice that present value of the machines
as on date be assessed in order that a fair
and reasonable disposal of the respective
claims can be arrived at. …”
(Emphasis supplied)
The following prayers had been made by the D.H.;
“a) Appoint a Court Commissioner to
inspect the machines belonging to the
Applicant lying in the premises of Messrs
Sikkim Tobacco Limited and assess of the
present value thereof; and
b) direct the Court Commissioner to
take the help of technically qualified
persons as necessary; and
c) Pass such order or further orders
as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and
proper in the facts and circumstances of
the case.”
(Emphasis supplied)
The prayers of the D.H. in I.A. No. 4 of 2008 were dismissed
by
the
Order
of
the
Hon‟ble
Supreme
Court,
dated
02.02.2010, in “Transferred Case (Civil) Nos. 12-14 of 1985”
supra. In the face of the specific decision of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court, the D.H. cannot reagitate the matter before
the learned trial Court and proceed to approach this Court in
revision seeking valuation of the machines by technically
qualified persons.
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
The argument that the Nazir had not taken
20.
possession of the machines is incongruous and banal as the
Nazir could not have moved the machines and brought it
along with him. It is sufficient that he complied with the
procedure prescribed. The grievance of the D.H. that “it
appeared” from the Report of the Nazir, that, the J.D. had
tampered with the machines has no legs to stand as the
Report of the Nazir dated 11.09.2017 makes no such
statement as evident on its careful perusal neither does the
Report reflect that the machines were in the open as alleged
by the D.H.
From the facts and circumstances reflected above,
21.
it is indeed unequivocally apparent that the instant petition is
devoid of merit and has been filed only to delay compliance
with
the
Award
of
the
Arbitrator.
In
the
aforestated
circumstances, no reason whatsoever emanates to interfere
with the findings of the learned trial Court.
22.
Accordingly, the Revision Petition is rejected and
dismissed with costs of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five
thousand) only, to be paid by the D.H. to the J.D. within
fifteen days from today, failing which the D.H. will be entitled
to interest at the rate of 9% per annum till payment of the
cost imposed.
23.
Court.
Copy of this Order be sent to the learned trial
CRP No. 9 of 2017
Golden Tobacco Limited vs. Sikkim Tobacco Limited
24.
Records of the learned trial Court be remitted
forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
23.04.2019
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review