Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:52114
WP14808.2026.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 14808 OF 2026
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12778 OF 2026
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12780 OF 2026
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12781 OF 2026
1.
Ghanshyam Onkarlal Agrawal,
Age. 71 years, Occ. Agriculture,
R/o. Plot No. 40, Chanda Gauri Nagar
Yawal Road, Chopda,
Tq. Chopda, District Jalgaon.
2.
Chopda Kasbe Vividh Karyakari Seva
Sahakari Society Limited Chopda,
Tq. Chopda, District Jalgaon,
Through its authorized officer
Rajendra Tanaji Mahajan
Age. 58 years, Occ. Service,
Motha Mali Bala Chopda
Tq. Chopda, District Jalgaon.
… Petitioners
Versus
1.
The District Co-operative Election
Authority and the Divisional
Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies,
Nashik Division, Nashik.
2.
The District Deputy Registrar
Co-operative Societies, Jalgaon
District Jalgaon and the Returning Officer
for the election of Jalgaon District Central
Co-operative Bank Ltd. Jalgaon.
3.
The Assistant Registrar,
Co-operative Societies, Chopda,
WP14808.2026.odt
Tq. Chopda, District Jalgaon.
… Respondents
...
Advocate for Petitioner : Mr. V.D. Hon (Senior Counsel) a/w.
Mr. Harshvardhan A Kahad i/b. Mr. A.V. Hon.
Addl. G.P. for Respondent/s – State : Mr. K.S. Hoke Patil
Advocate for Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 : Mr. V.H. Dighe
Advocate for Intervenor in CA no. 12778/2026 : Mr. R.N.
Dhorde i/b. Mr. V.R. Dhorde
Advocate for Intervenor in CA no. 12781/2026 : Mr. H.V. Patil
Advocate for Intervenor in CA no. 12780/2026 : Mr. V.D.
Salunke h/f. M.V. Salunke
…
CORAM : MANJUSHA A. DESHPANDE, J.
DATE : 26.10.2026
JUDGMENT :
1.
Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith and heard
finally with the consent of the parties.
2.
The Petitioners are challenging the order dated
13.10.2026 passed by the District Co-operative Election
Authority
and
Divisional
Joint
Registrar,
Co-operative
Societies, Nashik, Division Nashik.
It is the case of the petitioners that, Petitioner no. 1
is a member of Petitioner no. 2 – Society. Petitioner No. 2 –
Society, is a member of Jalgaon District Central Co-operative
Bank Limited, Jalgaon (JDCC). The name of Petitioner no. 2 –
Society, is included in the provisional voters’ list of the JDCC in
the ensuing elections for the year 2026 to 2031. The impugned
WP14808.2026.odt
order is challenged by the Petitioners on the background of the
fact that, initially the name of one Smt. Rama Pravin Gujrathi
was forwarded to be included in the provisional voters’ list as a
delegate of the Petitioner no. 2 – Society. Petitioner no. 2 –
Society, had passed a resolution on 27.08.2026, which was
forwarded to Respondent no. 3 – Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Society, Chopda. Accordingly, the name of Smt.
Rama Pravin Gujrathi was included in the provisional voters’
list. However, due to the ill-health of Smt. Rama Pravin
Gujrathi, on advice of doctor she resigned as a delegate of the
Society on 25.09.2026, and requested that, any other member
may be considered for representing the Society. Her resignation
dated 25.09.2026, a meeting of the society was called and on
05.10.2026, a fresh resolution was passed accepting resignation
of Smt. Rama Pravin Gujrathi and the same meeting the
members of the managing committee, resolved to substitute
Petitioner no. 1 in place of Smt. Rama Gujrathi. This resolution
was passed by majority of the members of the management
committee on 05.10.2026.
3.
After receiving the resolution passed by Petitioner
WP14808.2026.odt
no. 2, Respondent no. 1 has called report from Respondent no. 3
– Assistant Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Chopda, and
thereafter, has passed the impugned order in exercise of powers
under Rule 11 of the Maharashtra Co-operative (Election to
Committee) Rules, 2014 (for short ‘the Rules of 2014’). While
passing this order Respondent no. 1 has refused to substitute the
name of Petitioner no. 1 in place of Smt. Rama Pravin Gujrathi,
on the ground that Rule 10 (4) of the Rules of 2014, permits
substitution of name of a representative, upon his resignation as
a member and not in case of resignation by a delegated
representative. Even though, it is stated in the resolution passed
by the Society that the representative has resigned due to illhealth. Respondent no. 1 has held that such substitution is
contrary to the provision, for substitution under Rule 10 (4) of
the Rules of 2014, thereby refused to make change in the name
of representative of Petitioner no. 2 – Society.
4.
The Learned Senior Advocate V.D. Hon, submitted
that even though, the name of Smt. Rama Pravin Gujrathi was
included in the provisional voters’ list on the basis of the
resolution passed by Petitioner no. 2 – Society. She has
WP14808.2026.odt
communicated her inability to represent the Society, due to her
ill-health. Upon bed rest advised by the doctor, she has tendered
her resignation as a delegate of the Society on 25.09.2026.
While doing so she has tried to ensure participation of
Petitioner no. 2 in the election of JDCC bank by requesting to
substitute her name in the voters’ list. In view of her resignation
a meeting was immediately called for substitution of the voter
on behalf of Petitioner no. 2 – Society in the voters list. The
said meeting was convened on 05.10.2026, in which the
majority members of the managing committee decided to send
the name of Petitioner no. 1, as a delegate to be included in the
voters’ list in place of Smt. Rama Pravin Gujrathi. This
resolution was forwarded by the Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Societies to Respondent no. 1 on 05.10.2026, itself
and the impugned order has been passed on 13.10.2026.
5.
He submits that upon receiving the order dated
13.10.2026, the Petitioners have immediately approached this
Court by filing Writ Petition on 17.10.2026, for which
circulation has been granted on 21.10.2026. This Court has
issued notice on 21.10.2026 and considering the urgency, notice
WP14808.2026.odt
was made returnable on 26.10.2026.
6.
He submitted that considering that the voters’ list has
already been finalized and at any moment the election
programme is likely to be declared, the matter therefore is
required to be decided at the earliest. Referring to Rule 10 (4) of
the Election Rules 2014, he submitted that Respondent no. 1
has passed the impugned order applying totally perverse
interpretation to Rule 10 (4) of the Election Rules 2014. It is
submitted that this Rule takes care of the emergent situation, so
as to ensure that a society does not go unrepresented in the
elections. There are various eventualities that may arise after
preparation of the provisional voters’ list, till the voting rights
are exercised, such as death of a representative, disqualification
of a representative on adjudication by the competent authority
or resignation by a representative. In addition to aforementioned
eventualities,
there
may
be
various
other
unforeseen
eventualities that may require substitution of the representative
of a Society.
7.
In the present case, a valid resolution has been passed by
Petitioner no. 2, by a majority committee members accepting
WP14808.2026.odt
the resignation of Smt. Rama Pravin Gujrathi and nominating
Petitioner no. 1 as a delegate in place of Rama Gujrathi. This
resolution delegating name of the Petitioner is validly passed
and not challenged by any of the member of their Society. It is
submitted that, since Rule 10 (4) of the Election Rules 2014
provides that a change in the name is permitted not later than
five days before the last date for making nominations. A valid
resolution has been passed much prior to the declaration of
nomination by the District Co-operative Election Authority.
8.
He submits that Rule 10 (4) of the Election Rules
2014, has been incorporated so as to ensure that the member of
the federal Society does not go unrepresented. In support of his
submission, he would rely on decision of this Court in case of
Sangali Urban Co-operative Bank Versus The State of
Maharashtra, reported in 2015 (5) ABR 339, where this
Court has taken a view that although Rule 10 (4) postulates a
time frame within which the application is to be made for
substitution, a purposive interpretation is required to be given to
the said Rule. Strict application of said Rule cannot be
expected. In appropriate cases the delegate can be allowed to be
WP14808.2026.odt
changed.
9.
Reliance is also placed on the decision of this
Court in Writ Petition no. 11797/2021, in Dr. Suresh
Shamrao Patil Versus The State Co-operative Election
Commission, and Others. The Subject matter of the Writ
Petition was in respect of the same Society, involving the
present Petitioner no. 1, whose name was forwarded to
substitute name of the nominated candidate, Smt. Rama Pravin
Gujrathi, who also happen to resign as a delegate of Petitioner
no. 1 – Society for the elections conducted in the year 2021,
where this Court has taken a view that as per Rule 10(4), a
Society can change representative in the event of circumstances
like death or newly elected committee or resignation by existing
representative. When an objection was raised for such
substitution, the objection was turned down by this Court.
10.
He submits that although Rule 10 (4) of the Rules
of 2014, is clear and it permits substitution of the name of
representative due to perverse interpretation of that Rule by
Respondent no. 1, grave prejudice is caused to the Petitioner. As
consequence of the order, Petitioner no. 2, would go
WP14808.2026.odt
unrepresented in the elections of the Jalgaon District Central
Co-operative Bank.
11.
It is submitted that although the Petitioners have
taken all the possible and appropriate steps as provided in the
Rules of 2014, the petitioner right to vote has been taken away
due to the absurd interpretation given to Rule 10 (4) of the
Rules of 2014. The case of the petitioner is also supported by
intervention application filed by Smt. Rama Pravin Gujarathi.
Advocate Shri V.D Salunke, has supported the challenge raised
by the petitioners. He submitted that the order impugned is
passed, in an arbitrary manner, thus interference at the hands of
this Court is necessary.
12.
In response to the intervention Application filed by
one Jijabai Sahebrao Patil as well as the intervention
Application filed by Yogesh Shivaji Patil. Mr. Hon, submitted
that the intervenors are not necessary parties to the present Writ
Petition, since the challenge is limited to the extent of the order
passed by Respondent no. 1. The proposed intervenors were not
parties before Respondent no. 1. They have not filed any
objection to the resolution nominating the Petitioner no. 1.
WP14808.2026.odt
Hence, they cannot be allowed to intervene in the present writ
petition.
13.
Per contra, Mr. V.H. Dighe for all the Respondents
submitted that Rule 10 (4) of the Rules of 2014, provides that,
only in case of resignation by a representative of the
membership of the Society, substitution can be permitted. In the
present case, the resignation tendered by Smt. Rama Pravin
Gujrathi was limited to the extent of her nomination as a
delegate to represent the Society and participate in the elections.
Only in case all the ties as a member of Society are severed by
way of resignation, such substitution is permissible and it would
be in consonance with the Rule 10 (4) of the Rule of 2014. He
submitted that if at all the Petitioners are aggrieved by the order
passed by the District Co-operative Election Authority, they
have a remedy of filing dispute under Section 91 read with Rule
78 of the Rule of 2014.
14.
He further submitted that the election programme
of the Jalgaon District Central Co-operative Bank, has already
been declared on 23.10.2026. According to the Election
programme, the eligible candidates would be filling their
WP14808.2026.odt
nominations between 26.10.2026 and 30.10.2026. Hence
according to him, since the election programme has been set in
motion, any order passed at this stage would amount to causing
interference in the elections of the Jalgaon District Central Cooperative Bank.
He further submitted that it is the consistent view
reflected in catena of judicial pronouncement of this Court as
well as Hon’ble Supreme Court that, once the election
programme is declared it should not be interfered, by the Courts
by passing any orders. He would submit that, even preparation
of provisional voters’ list is regarded as an intermediate stage of
election and this Court has, therefore, refused to cause
interference even in the provisional voters’ list. Thus according
to him this Court should not interfere at this stage since election
programme has already been declared, any changes /
substitution is permissible in voters list only five days prior to
the last date of making nominations. This view has been taken
in the decision of this Court in the case of Dattatraya Genaba
Lole and Others Versus Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies and Others, reported in 2022 (1) Bom.
WP14808.2026.odt
C.R. 471.
15.
Learned Senior Advocate Mr. V.R. Dhorde, as well
as Mr. Hanumant V. Patil, who have filed respective
Applications for intervention on behalf of Jijabai Sahebrao Patil
and Yogesh Shivaji Patil, respectively, have opposed the prayer
made by the Petitioner on the ground that, only in case the
representative resigns from the membership of society whom he
represents. Rule 10 (4) of the Rules of 2014, permits
substitution of representative that too before five days of the
last date for nomination. They have also relied on certain
decision of this Court as well as Hon’ble Supreme Court to
contend that, interference by this Court at this stage is not
permissible.
16.
I have heard the learned Advocate for the Petitioner
as well as the learned Advocate representing contesting
Respondents. So far as tenability of the intervention application
is concerned, the Applicant Jijabai Sahebrao Patil is the member
of Petitioner no. 2 – Society, who is opposing the substitution of
name of Petitioner no. 1. The Application for intervention filed
by her would not be permissible for the reason that she has not
WP14808.2026.odt
filed any objection to the resolution passed by Petitioner no. 2
and she was not a party to the proceedings before respondent
no. 1, hence intervention application at this stage cannot be
allowed.
17.
Similarly, the Applications filed by one Mukesh
Ramesh Patil and Yogesh Shivaji Patil, respectively, cannot be
allowed since they are also not party to the proceeding before
the respondent no. 1 and the Petitioner no.2 – Society has
unanimously passed the resolution for substitution of name of
Petitioner no. 1. Hence the intervention application, of the
above applicants are not maintainable.
18.
So far as challenge to the impugned order is concerned,
the issue involved in the present Writ Petition is :
i.
Whether
substitution of
name of
the
representative of a society, who has resigned as a
delegate is permissible under Rule 10(4) of the
Election Rules of 2014 ?
ii.
Whether at this stage it would be permissible
to make changes in the voters’ list in view of
declaration of the election programme ?
19.
WP14808.2026.odt
It is not in dispute that one Smt. Rama Pravin
Gujrathi was initially nominated to represent the Petitioner no.
2 – Society in the ensuing elections of the Jalgaon District
Central Co-operative Bank, by way of resolution passed by the
Managing Committee on 27.08.2026. In view of her inability to
represent Petitioner no. 2 as its delegate, she tendered her
resignation as a delegate of Petitioner no. 2. On receiving her
resignation a meeting for substituting her name was called
immediately on 05.10.2026 and a valid resolution by the
majority of managing Committee members has been passed,
accepting her resignation and validly nominating Petitioner no.
1. This resolution is not challenged by any member of Petitioner
no. 2 – Society. Respondent no. 3 on receiving the resolution,
has forwarded it to the Respondent no. 1 with positive
recommendation. In spite of that Respondent no. 1 has refused
the substitution of Petitioner no. 1 as a delegate of Petitioner no.
2 Society, by holding that Smt. Rama Pravin Gujrathi has not
tendered her resignation of her membership of the petitioner no.
2 - Society, but has given resignation to her nomination by
petitioner no. 2, which is not in consonance with Rule 10 (4) of
WP14808.2026.odt
the Election Rules, thereby refusing the proposal for
substitution of name of petitioner no.1 in the voters list in
exercise of his powers under Rule 11 of the Elections Rules.
Rule 10 (4) of the Election Rules of 2014, reads thus :
“Rule - 10. Particulars to be included in the
provisional list of voters for the societies
having society or society and individuals as
members:
(4) A society which has communicated the
name of its representative shall, by like
resolution, be permitted to change the name
of its representative only in case of death of
the representative or where there is newly
elected committee of the member society not
later than five days before the last date for
making nominations.”
20.
This Rule has been introduced by way of
amendment on 03.08.2021. By way of this amendment, the
change in name of representative is permitted only in case of
death of representative or resignation by the representative or if
such representative is found to be disqualified on adjudication
by the competent authority under the provisions of law. This
newly introduced eventualities permitting substitution of names
had fallen for consideration of this Court in Writ Petition no.
11797/2021, decided on 26.10.2021. Incidentally, in similar set
WP14808.2026.odt
of facts objection was raised to the substitution of name of
Petitioner no. 1 in the said Writ Petition which incidently
involved Petitioner no. 1 and same candidate namely Smt.
Rama Pravin Gujrathi who had resigned even then in the year
2021, expressing her inability to represent Petitioner no. 2 –
Society in the elections. This Court has turned down the
challenge raised to the substitution, of present Petitioner no. 1
and upheld his inclusion in the voters list. The only difference is
that the challenge to the substitution of his name before the then
District Co-operative Election Authority, was turned down by
him, whereas in the present case the Respondent no. 1 himself
has refused to substitute the name of Petitioner no. 1.
21.
On perusal of Rule 10(4) of the Rules of 2014,
among the various eventualities provided in the said Rule,
resignation by the representative is one of eventualities. This
eventuality of resignation by the representative is not further
qualified by providing that the representative should resign as a
member of the Society and only case of such resignation of
membership it is permissible to substitute the name. This
provision does not make a distinction between the resignation
WP14808.2026.odt
as a delegate and a resignation as a member. The Respondent
no. 1 by interpreting the aforementioned provision has
overstepped his jurisdiction. It is not within the powers of
respondent no. 1, to interpret provisions of law. He has to act
strictly in accordance with the provisions of law as provided in
the statute books while conducting the Elections.
Even though, this Court as well as the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has issued a word of caution about causing
interference interfere in the elections, once the election
programme is declared. However, while doing so it is also held
that, in exceptional cases, such interference is necessary, where
there is a patent error of law by applying non-existent Rules or
where a binding provision are ignored.
After taking into consideration various decision of
this Court as well as the Hon’ble Supreme Court on the issue of
causing interference in the voters’ list, availability of alternate
remedy; and interference by the Court in the election process, A
Division Bench of this Court in Dattatray Genaba Lole and
Others (Supra), has made following observations:
WP14808.2026.odt
“8.4 The only circumstance in which the
Courts would be inclined to interfere in a
challenge to an election process at an
intermediate stage would be when the order or
action under challenge is patently and
demonstrably illegal, such as, for example, by
applying a non- existent rule or provision to the
election process or failing to adhere to a
mandatory provision. The intervention in such
cases has been explained as enabling or
assisting the process of the election rather than
thwarting or stalling it. Also, one of the
important aspects to consider is the precise
stage of the election process and the delay, if
any, in the filing of the petition.”
22.
In
another
decision
of
this
Court
about
permissibility of interference in the election process this court
in the case of Ankushbhau Juglal Bhaghele Versus State of
Maharashtra and others, reported in 2022 (4) Mh.L.J. 539,
has made following observations, which is reproduced here
under :
“7. The illegality is not of minor or
technical nature and the writ Court cannot
turn a blind eye and be a mute spectator
on the jurisprudential logic that the
election process has commenced and the
writ Court ought to be loathe to interfere.
The ‘Laxman Rekha’ as I have observed
supra, can be crossed, as long as the writ
Court treads cautiously and with extreme
circumspection.”
WP14808.2026.odt
Thus, there are decisions where this Court has
made exception to the general rule that, the Courts should not
interfere in the matters of Election, once the election process
has commenced. It is held that in cases where there is a patent
illegality or non-adherence to the Rules of election, interference
by Courts is necessary, Courts cannot be silent spectator and
allow such illegality to perpetuate, in case it is brought to the
notice of the Court.
23.
This Court had an occasion to consider the
permissibility and legality of substitution of representative of a
Society, as provided in Rule 10 (4) of the Election Rules of
2014, and strict adherence to the time frame prescribed under
the said sub-Rule in case of Sangali Urban Co-operative
Bank Ltd. (supra). While deciding the aforementioned issue
this Court has made following observation :
“9. In so far as rule 10(4) of the said Rules is
concerned, as indicated above, it is in two
eventualities that the change in delegate is
permitted i.e. the death of the representative or
a newly elected committee comes into being.
The said rule postulates the time frame within
which the application is to be made. The
underlying principle of the said rule is
therefore to see to it that the member society
WP14808.2026.odt
does not go unrepresented. Hence in case of the
death of the representative, there can be a
change in the delegate as also when a newly
elected committee takes office, the underlying
principle behind the second circumstance
seems to be that the management of the
member society nominates a delegate of its
choice. The time frame that is stipulated in the
said rule has to be considered in the said
context. If the time frame is to be construed
strictly and there is no flexibility in it then it
may happen that the society may go
unrepresented in the case of death if the change
is not sought within the time stipulated in rule
10(4) or in the event the newly committee
comes into being and the request is not sought
within the time frame, the member society may
then be foisted or saddled with a delegate who
is not of its choice and in respect of whom it
does not have confidence. Hence a purposive
interpretation would have to be given to the
said rule. In my view, therefore in the facts of
the instant case, which can be said to be
peculiar in nature on account of the fact that
the results of the elections of the Petitioner
Bank were declared on the last date of filing of
the nominations, for the Respondent No.3
federation, the said rule 10(4) of the Rules in so
far as the time period mentioned therein cannot
be strictly applied. Ultimately the endeavour is
always to see that the change of the
representative or delegate is in keeping with the
democratic principles and that on technicalities
it should not happen that the democratic
process is thwarted. There can be no
gainsaying of the fact that the Respondent No.4
herein is not a person of the choice of the
present Board of Directors of the Petitioner
Bank which has been elected on 12/5/2015. He
is no more the Director of the Petitioner Bank
WP14808.2026.odt
having lost in the elections and therefore also
not entitled to represent the Petitioner Bank.
Hence the possibility of a constant acrimony
between the Board of Directors and the
Respondent No.4 cannot be ruled out. The
Respondent No.4 also would not be in position
to put across the view point of the Board of
Directors of the Petitioner Bank as he has
failed to get elected in the elections which took
place on 12/5/2015 and is therefore not a part
of the Board of the Petitioner Bank For the
aforesaid reasons and in the peculiar facts of
the present case, the strict application of rule
10(4) in so far as the time frame is concerned,
is not warranted. Hence in appropriate cases
the delegate can be allowed to be changed and
the time frame mentioned in the said rule 10(4)
cannot be construed as a fetter to permit such
change.”
24.
The above observations are made by this court,
when Rule 10 (4) of the Rules of 2014, provided only two
eventualities for substitution of the representative, in case of
death of representative or newly elected committee coming into
being. This Court has taken a view that although the Rule
postulates time frame within which application is to be made,
the object behind such Rule is required to be appreciated. The
object being that a member Society does not go unrepresented
and the member Society nominates the delegates of its choice. It
is held that, if the said Rule is applied rigidly, the Society would
WP14808.2026.odt
remain unrepresented. This Court has therefore, observed that
Rule 10 (4) in so far the time line given in the said Rule is
concerned cannot be applied rigidly, strict application of this
Rule is not warranted. The technicalities should not result in
halting the democratic process of elections. In appropriate cases
delegate can be allowed to be changed and the time frame
mentioned cannot be considered as a fetter to permit such
change.
25.
If we consider the present case in the light of the
observations made in the decisions referred supra, a valid
resolution accepting the resignation of Smt. Rama Pravin
Gujrathi and nominating Petitioner no. 1 has been passed on
05.10.2026, it was already forwarded to Respondent no. 1 on
05.10.2026, itself by Respondent no. 3. Thus, the petitioner
have taken necessary steps to effect change in the name of
representative well within the time prescribed. However the
order impugned has been passed by Respondent no. 1 after
eight days of receiving such resolution. Thus, Respondent no.1
has also failed to take appropriate decision ensuring the
compliance of the time line which is binding on the Petitioners
WP14808.2026.odt
as well as Respondents equally.
26.
In this regard, it would be profitable to refer the
observations made by the Co-ordinate bench in the case of
Murlidhar Rangrao Gaikwad Versus State Co-operative
Election Authority, in Writ Petition no. 4072 of 2025, which is
reproduced herein under, which reads thus :
“74. In the light of the above pronouncement of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Deoraj (supra),
and the principles laid down in Pandurang
Hindurao Patil (supra), Chandrakant Mahadev
Patole (supra), Ahmednagar Zilla(supra),
Ashok Kumar (supra), and Pundlik(supra), the
legal position that emerges is that in election
matters governed by the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960, where the Court
is satisfied that the impugned action of the
Returning Officer -- whether in acceptance or
rejection of a nomination paper -- is ex facie
illegal, patently erroneous, or vitiated by a
jurisdictional infirmity, the High Court would
be justified in invoking its extraordinary writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution. Such interference is permissible
even at an intermediate stage of the election
process, so long as it does not require
postponement or disruption of any stage of the
election. The object of judicial intervention in
such cases is not to interfere with the
democratic process, but to uphold its sanctity
by preventing grave illegality that may
otherwise vitiate the entire election and render
post-election remedies illusory. This principle
is in consonance with the well-established legal
proposition that the right to contest an election
WP14808.2026.odt
must be exercised in accordance with law, and
any action by the Returning Officer that
violates statutory requirements -- such as
failure to consider material disqualification or
non-compliance with mandatory provisions of
the Rules or Bye-laws -- is amenable to judicial
scrutiny at the pre- election stage.”
In the instant case immediately after, passing of the
order by Respondent no. 1, the Petitioners have approached this
Court by filing this Writ Petition on 17.10.2026, which was
heard by this Court 21.10.2026. Thus, there is no delay as such
on the part of the Petitioners in diligently taking steps for
substituting the name of Smt. Rama Gujrathi and raising
challenge to the impugned order.
27.
So far as the objection to the change in the voters’
list in view of the declaration of the election programme is
concerned, Rule 10 (4) itself permits making such change by
way of substitution in the voters’ list not later than five days
prior to the last date for making nominations. In the instant
case, the last of date of filing nominations is 30.10.2026. Five
days prior to the last day was 25.10.2026,which was a Sunday
and, immediately thereafter, today when the matter is listed and
WP14808.2026.odt
heard which is virtually fifth day prior to last day of
nomination. Thus, in my view if such substitution, which is
permissible as per Rule 10(4) of the Rules of 2014, is not
allowed Petitioner no. 2 – Society would go unrepresented in
the upcoming elections of the Jalgaon District Central Cooperative Bank, who would be against the spirit of democratic
process of elections. More particularly when the Petitioners
have promptly taken appropriate steps well within the time
frame by forwarding the resolution to the Respondent no. 1,
who has taken almost 8 days, for passing the Impugned order,
by overstepping his jurisdiction. The Respondent no.1 while
passing the order has interpreted, something that is not provided
in the Statute, which amounts to arbitrary exercise of powers,
thereby depriving Petitioner no. 2 – to participate in the election
of the Jalgaon District Central Co-operative Bank. As a result of
setting aside the impugned order, it is not likely to cause any
disruption in the election programme, that has already
commenced, since the only change that would be made is
substitution of the representative of Petitioner no. 2 in the
voters’ list. Hence, I pass the following order :
WP14808.2026.odt
ORDER
i.
The Writ Petition is allowed.
ii.
The Order passed by Respondent no. 1 – district
Co-operative Election Authority, dated 13.10.2026, is set
aside.
iii.
Respondent no. 1 is directed to include name of
Petitioner no.1 Ghanshyma Onkarlal Agrawal, as a
delegate of Petitioner no. 2 – Chopda Vividh Karyakari
Seva Society Limited, in the final voters’ list of Jalgaon
District Cooperative Bank Limited to represent Petitioner
no. 2 – Society.
iv.
The
Learned
Advocate
appearing
for
Respondent no. 1 shall communicate the order passed by
this Court to the Authority immediately.
v.
Civil Applications stand disposed of.
vi.
Rule is made absolute in the above terms.
( MANJUSHA A. DESHPANDE, J. )
SPC
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review