Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27922
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 601 OF 2022
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 28.02.2022 IN OP NO.2527 OF 2011
OF FAMILY COURT, ERNAKULAM
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
GEORGE O. THETTAYIL, AGED 69 YEARS
S/O.OUSEPH, THETTAYIL HOUSE, ANGAMALY KARA,
VENGOOR.P.O., ANGAMALY VILLAGE, ALUVA TALUK,
ERNAKULAM, PIN- 683 572.
BY ADVS.
T.K.SAJEEV
M.V.JOY
SANDHRA.S
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
ROSILY P.P, AGED 72 YEARS, THETTAYIL HOUSE,
MILLUPADY, VENGOOR.P.O., ANGAMALY VILLAGE,
ALUVA TALUK, ERNAKULAM, PIN- 683 572.
BY ADVS.
CHACKO C A
C.M.CHARISMA(K/424/2002)
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
26.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
2025:KER:27922
Mat Appeal 601/22
JUDGMENT
Devan Ramachandran, J.
Through this appeal, the appellant calls into question the
correctness
of
the
judgment
of
the
learned
Family
Court,
Ernakulam, in OP.No.2527/2011.
2.
The above mentioned Original Petition was filed by
the appellant seeking declaration of title over the property
covered by Ext.A1 Sale Deed, asserting that it was purchased by
him with his own funds, but conceding that it was registered in
the name of his wife.
As per his case, the entire amount
required for the purchase of the property covered by Ext.A1 came
from his own sources, and that the respondent never had any
income of her own at that point of time or thereafter.
He
contends that the respondent has no title, ownership or right over
the
property
and
hence
that
he
is
entitled
to
have
the
declarations sought for in the Original Petition granted to him.
3.
The respondent, in refutation, asserts that she had
2025:KER:27922
Mat Appeal 601/22
purchased
the
property
covered
by
Ext.A1,
investing
the
consideration obtained by the sale of another extent - which had
earlier been settled in her favour by her father through Ext.B2
Settlement Deed; and that the Sale Deed of that property, of the
year 1984, is Ext.B3.
She reiterates that the sale proceeds from
Ext.B3 was invested to purchase the property involved, namely
that covered by Ext.A1; and that, thereupon, she took a loan
from a Bank - as evidenced by Ext.B9 thereon.
to cause construction
She predicated that the renovation of the building was
done with the assistance of her son; but that, when she was
tortured by the appellant for transfer of the said property to him,
she acceded in part, by executing Ext.B10 - which is a gift deed
of the SRO, Angamaly - in his favour, involving an extent of 1.78
Ares. She thus prayed that this Original Petition be dismissed.
4.
The learned Family Court allowed the parties to trial
and the appellant produced Exts.A1 to A33
documents in his
favour (many of the said documents relating to his plea for
Mat Appeal 601/22
2025:KER:27922
divorce, which was subsequently granted); while, the respondent
produced Exts.B1 to B21 documents on her side and deposed as
RW1, along with RW2 and RW3. The appellant testified as PW1;
and the learned Family Court after analyzing the evidence on
record, dismissed the Original Petition, holding, inter alia, that
“proprietary transactions and conveyances effected between the
spouses when they were living in connubium without much
independent bargaining has to continue as such, though the
marital consortium between them has been loss for ever” (sic).
5.
We have examined the evidence available intently; and
as is evident from it, the appellant’s specific case is that he
purchased Ext.A1 with his own funds, but in the name of the
respondent, on 07.11.1984. To prove his income, he has produced
Ext.A13; while, to establish that he made construction on the
property, he relies on Exts.A12 and A15 – which are copies of
letter/certificate issued by a Bank, along with Ext.A14 Building
Estimate, as also Ext.A16 Service Certificate issued by the KTS.
2025:KER:27922
Mat Appeal 601/22
To further prove that he had obtained a loan for the purpose of
acquisition of the property and construction of the building on it,
he relies on Ext.A17 and A18, namely the ‘Gehan’ registered in
favour of a Co-operative Bank and a petition to the Labour
Officer respectively; as also Ext.A27 and A28, which are certain
quotations stated to be qua the construction in question.
6.
However,
in
contravention
of
the
above,
the
respondent relies on Ext.B2, which is the Settlement Deed in her
favour, stated to have executed by her father with respect to
another property; and testified that she sold it through Ext.B3, to
purchase the property covered by Ext.A1. She contends that she
made constructions on the property and has sought to prove it
through Ext.B5 Sanction Letter; Ext.B6 Estimate and Plan; Ext.B7
Purchase Bills; Ext.B8 Building Tax Receipts; as also Ext.B9 which
is a loan document – to establish that she availed a loan from a
particular Bank. Pertinently, she also has a case that she was
tortured by the appellant for transfer of the property in his name
Mat Appeal 601/22
2025:KER:27922
and that, to put a quietus to such, she executed Ext.B10 Gift
Deed in his favour with respect to 1.78 Ares of property covered
by Ext.A1 Sale Deed.
7.
Before we proceed to analyse the evidence on record,
there is an issue we must certainly first address.
8.
Going by the pleadings on record, particularly the
averments in the Original Petition filed by the appellant, he does
not have a case that he purchased the property in his then wife’s
name on account of a fiduciary arrangement, or on an assurance
from her that she would return it to him whenever he wanted.
He does not have a case that the acquisition was made for his
exclusive benefit and that it was entrusted to the respondent on
his behalf for such purpose. On the contrary, his case is that he
spent money and purchased the property in his wife’s name, but
without any explanation for having done so.
9.
The question that, therefore, arises is, whether the
transaction, as asserted by the appellant – even taking it to be
Mat Appeal 601/22
2025:KER:27922
true for the sake of argument – would amount to one intended
for his benefit; and if so, whether he would be then eligible to
seek a declaration of title, in the manner as he has prayed.
10.
It is apodictic, going by the settled law that covers the
field, that even assuming that an acquisition is made by one in
favour of another, then cemented by the registration of a
document in favour of the latter, there is an assumption of title
in favour of such person, unless it is rebutted in a manner known
to law. The well-established criteria for doing so is the presence
of vitiating elements of misrepresentation/fraud/duress, which by
express admission, the appellant does not even impute against the
respondent. As we have said above, his only case is that he
purchased the property in the name of his wife because they
were married at that time.
11.
In contra-distinction, it is the singular case of the wife
that the sale consideration for the property covered by Ext.A1
came out of the sale of the property covered by Ext.B2, which
Mat Appeal 601/22
2025:KER:27922
was earlier settled in her favour by her father. She has also
proved that she spent for its construction, relying on Ext.B9; and
her case is further fortified because, admittedly, a portion of the
property was subsequently gifted by her in favour of the
appellant, through Ext.B10. When this Gift Deed is unequivocally
admitted by the appellant, one fails to understand how he now
says that he is the owner of the rest of the property because, had
that been so, he would not have accepted the gift, but would
have insisted that the entire property be transferred in his name.
The very factum of the gift having been accepted by him –
admittedly and without reservation even before us – would prove
beyond all reasonable doubt that he was also fully aware that the
title of the property in question is exclusively in the name of the
respondent; and that it is only through a further action from her
side, either through a gift deed or otherwise, can he obtain
transfer of the same.
12.
In fact, in Ext.B10 Gift Deed, there is a specific recital
2025:KER:27922
Mat Appeal 601/22
that the respondent is the exclusive owner of the property
covered by Ext.A1 and that she is gifting an extent of 1.78 Ares
in favour of the appellant.
13.
when
Coming back to the initial proposition indited above,
there
is
not
even
a
whisper
of
fraud/misrepresentation/duress in the execution of Ext.A1 sale
deed in the name of the respondent – even assuming ex
arguendo that the entire proceeds came out of the income of the
appellant – it would not be possible for him to seek a
declaration, merely because the matrimonial union between the
parties have broken down. As said above, the very factum of the
registration of the property through Ext.A1 in favour of the
respondent gives rise to a valid assumption in law that she has
exclusive title to it and it is only if it is able to be rebutted by
the appellant in the manner as is known to law, can he seek any
relief.
14.
In
the
case
at
hand,
the
evidence
led
by
the
2025:KER:27922
Mat Appeal 601/22
respondent,
through
the
documents
and
testimony
above
mentioned, certainly premises that she paid for the purchase of
the property and financed the construction on it, through a bank
loan and rental income; and we, therefore, cannot find the
learned Family Court to have erred in any manner in the
impugned judgment.
15.
We are justified in our view as afore because, in
Ext.A1, the specific recital is that the entire Sale Consideration
has been paid by the respondent, without even a sotto voce
mention that the appellant had financed it in any manner.
In the afore circumstances, this Appeal is dismissed.
Sd/DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
JUDGE
Sd/M.B. SNEHALATHA
JUDGE
RR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review