Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Jay Sengupta
CRR 1438 of 2020
Gaurav Upadhyay & Anr.
Vs
State of West Bengal & Anr.
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Rajdeep Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Rudrajit Sarkar
Mr. Aditiya Kanodia
Mr. Soumya Raha
Ms. S. Ahmed
.....Advocates
For the State
:
Mr. Madhusudan Sur, Ld. APP
Mr. Dipankar Paramanick
.....Advocates
Heard lastly on
:
08.04.2026
Judgment on
:
07.07.2026
Jay Sengupta, J:
1.
This is an application for quashing of a proceeding in G.R. Case No.
2875 of 2019 presently pending before the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Paschim Bardhaman and arising out of Jamuria Police Station Case No. 445
of 2019 under Section 420/120B of the Penal Code.
2.
Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has
submitted and has relied on the written notes as follows. The petitioners
have preferred the instant revisional application seeking for quashing of the
proceedings of G.R. Case No. 2875 of 2019 which arose out of Jamuria Police
Station Case No. 445 of 2019 dated 07.12.2019 under Section 420 of the
Indian Penal Code, pending before the Court of the Learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Paschim Bardhaman. The Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Ltd. is a
joint venture project of the West Bengal Power Development Corporation
Ltd., the Durgapur Projects Ltd. and EMTA Coal Ltd. (erstwhile Eastern
Minerals and Trading Agency). In the said joint venture company the
Secretary of Department of Power is the Chairman of the company, apart
from him the Board consists of nominees from West Bengal Power
Development Corporation Ltd., nominees from Durgapur Projects Ltd.,
District Magistrate, Burdwan, MLA, Jamuria and nominees from EMTA Coal
Ltd. Directors of Bengal Emta Coal Mines Ltd. were a) Bikash Mukherjee, b)
Ujjal Kumar Upadhyay, c) Gaurav Bagaria. But, the Directors of EMTA were
a) Nitai Mishra, b) Gaurav Bagaria, c) Gaurav Upadhyay, d) Aditya Keshri, e)
Ambika Kumari, f) Arpita Dey (Company Secretary). The present petitioners
are neither the Directors of the Joint venture company nor do they have any
active control over the business or affairs of Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Ltd. in
any manner whatsoever. The allegations leveled by the opposite party were
that the opposite party No. 2 was engaged by Eastern Minerals Trading
Agency (EMTA) who was in charge of operation of Tara East-West Coal Mine
for the purpose of carrying out plantation and maintenance in EMTA Coal
Ltd., By Pass road side Tara O.C.P. vide work order dated 02.09.2014 and for
constructing a “Saila Bala Mukta Mancha” at Saila Bala Balika Vidyalaya
vide verbal order of the Executive Director of EMTA Coal Ltd. dated
22.02.2013. That the opposite party No. 2 claims that EMTA reimbursed him
at the rate of Rs. 6/- per tree only towards digging and plantation, but failed
to pay any further amount towards maintenance of the plantation from 2014
to 2018. That the opposite party No. 2 submitted a claim to EMTA on
28.02.2017 which are alleged to have not been cleared. After completion of
the purported investigation charge sheet was submitted bearing No. 29/2020
dated 31.01.2020 under Section 420/120B of the Indian Penal Code against
the Petitioners and three others. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
“Manohar Lal Sharma Vs. Principal Secretary & Others (Writ Petition (CRL)
120 of 2012)” by a judgment and order dated 25.08.2014 and 24.09.2014
respectively cancelled 204 Coal blocks including Tara East-West Coal Mine
(under jurisdiction of Jamuria Police Station) and the origin of the purported
cause of action of the instant dispute. Subsequent to the said cancellation of
204 Coal Blocks including Tara East-West Coal Mine, the Government of
India promulgated “The Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015 and the
Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Rules 2014 to deal/administer/regulate the
Coal Mines in India including the aforesaid cancelled Coal Blocks. Thus,
Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Ltd was forced to forthwith stop all commercial
activity in the said mines leading to a complete stoppage of revenue. The
entity responsible for payment of bills of vendors is Bengal EMTA Coal Mines
Limited and not EMTA. The bills in dispute and the statement of accounts as
well as the ledgers of the complainant were addressed to Bengal EMTA Coal
Mines Limited and not to EMTA. Therefore, the arraignment of the Private
Partner in the Public Private Partnership is non-est and bad in law. The
present petitioners are neither the Directors of the joint venture company nor
do they have any active control over the business or affairs of Bengal EMTA
Coal Mines Ltd. in any manner whatsoever. There have been regular
payments from Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Ltd. to the complainant. It was
never the intention of Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Limited to cheat and/or
defraud and/or misappropriate any or part of the sums of money payable to
the complainant and there have been regular payments to such effect.
Therefore, the basic mens rea to commit an offence is lacking in the present
set of facts and no criminality can be attached to the same. This admittedly
civil dispute has been given a criminal color by the complainants in
conspiracy with the Jamuria Police Station where there already exists
evidence of part payment and alternative forum for payment of dues. Similar
frivolous prosecution has been quashed by this Hon'ble Court in another
instance. In similar circumstances, a criminal complaint had been lodged by
one M/s G.S. Atwal & Company against EMTA Coal Ltd. (the company), the
petitioners and one Ujjal Kumar Upadhyay, wherein the said proceedings
had been challenged by the petitioners before this Hon'ble Court being CRR
No. 4999 of 2023 and this Hon'ble Court has been pleased to pass an order
dated 25.06.2024 quashing the proceeding mentioned therein. Delay in filing
of complaint and filing of multiple FIRS pertaining to the same set of facts.
The opposite party No. 2 also failed to explain the delay towards filing of the
said complaint which is filed on 07.12.2019 against an alleged default from
2014 to 2018. Moreover, Jamuria Police Station has also initiated multiple
proceedings pertaining to the same set of facts arising out of the same facts
in dispute which is per se, bad in law. The multiple proceedings being - 1)
Jamuria PS Case 301/2017, 2) Jamuria PS Case 325/2017, 3) Jamuria PS
Case 326/2017, 4) Jamuria PS Case 327/2017, 5) Jamuria PS Case
328/2017, 6) Jamuria PS Case 329/2017, 7) Jamuria PS Case 330/2017, 8)
Jamuria PS Case 331/2017, 9) Jamuria PS Case 406/2019, 10) Jamuria PS
Case 407/2019, 11) Jamuria PS Case 445/2019. Your petitioners submit
that the dispute is totally civil in nature and cannot be colored as criminal
acts being death with Jamuria Police Station. Your petitioners submit that
non-payment of dues to factors beyond the control of the petitioners and
government policies cannot be termed as cheating or misappropriation of
property. Under such circumstances, it would be just and proper for this
Hon'ble Court to quash the impugned proceedings or else would cause severe
miscarriage of justice. Your petitioners submit that from the bare perusal of
the complaint, it would transpire that no overt act has been attributed to any
of the petitioners against any of the offences alleged against them. The
charge under Section 420/120B of the Indian Penal Code cannot be
substantiated
in
absence
of
any
evidence
to
show
that
the
said
representation by the accused was false to the knowledge of the accused at
the time it was made. However, subsequent act of non-fulfilment of such
promise cannot be brought under the purview of cheating as provided under
Section 420/120B of the Indian Penal Code. To attract 420 the complainant
or the prosecution must show that there is deception from the very inception.
It is only the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India judgment and order dated
25.08.2014 and 24.09.2014 respectively, cancelling the 204 coal blocks
including the Tara (East & West) Coal Mines operated by Bengal EMTA Coal
Mines Ltd. ('BECML). Owing to the aforementioned cancellation of the above
Coal Mines, the situation became worse and as such BECML could not pay
the rest of the money which is pending. Even if we take the entire allegation
to be true, it will not attract the element of cheating. In conspectus of facts of
the instant case, there exists no allegation against the petitioners of any
wrongdoing. The rudimentary ingredient of a criminal offence of „actus reus‟,
far less of „mens rea‟ do not exist in the allegations of the instant case, qua
the petitioners. It is most respectfully submitted that the absurdity and
implausibility of the allegations leveled in the petition of complaint emanate
from the fact that no offences have been committed by the petitioners.
Moreover, it is apparent that the instant case is manifestly attended with
mala fide and the proceeding has been maliciously instituted by the opposite
party no. 2 with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the petitioners
and with a view to spite them due to private and personal grudge. It is a well
settled principle of the Indian Penal Code that no person can be held
vicariously liable for an act of his employee or agent or subordinate, unless
specifically mentioned in the Code. It would be apparent from the materials
on record that the inducement, if any, as alleged therein concerns the
executives of Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Ltd. The Directors of the joint venture
company would be liable for any dispute raised by any creditor in the course
of their commercial transactions. In order to compel the directors to clear
dues by arraigning their relatives in criminal prosecution is per se illegal and
continuing of such proceeding would be a gross abuse of the process of law.
Reliance is placed on - (2000) 4 SCC 168 [Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma &
Ors. -Vs- State of Bihar & Anr.]; (2005) 10 SCC 336 [Uma Sankar Gopalika Vs- State of Bihar & Anr]; (2009) 3 SCC 78 [Y.Y. Jose & Anr. -Vs- State of
Gujarat & Anr]; (2011) 13 SCC 412 [Thermal Limited -Vs- K.M Johny & Ors];
(2015) 8 SCC 293 [Vesa Holdings -Vs- State of Kerala]; (2019) 9 SCC 148
[Satish Chandra Ratanal Singh -Vs- State of Gujarat]; (2022) 7 SCC 124
[Vijay Kumar Ghai & Ors. -Vs- State of West Bengal]; (2022) 14 SCC 572
[Mitesh Kumar J. Sah - Vs- State of Karnataka & Ors]; (2023) 5 SCC 360
[Sarbjit Kaur -Vs- State of Punjab & Anr].
3.
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor representing the State has
submitted and has relied on the written notes as follows. Fact of the case is
that on 07.12.2019 Jamuria Police Station received a written complaint of
Manilal Sadhu son of Manik Chandra Sadhu, Proprietor of M/s. Manilal
Sadhu, Churulia, Police Station-Jamuria, District – Paschim Bardhaman
against i) Ujjal Upadhyay (MD),, ii) Gourav Upadhyay (Director), iii) Saugata
Upadhyay (Director), iv) Biswanath Dutta (Chief Executive Office), v) Nimai
Chandra Mukherjee (Executive Director), vi) Pradip Mazumdar (Finance
Manager), all of Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Ltd. to the effect that the
complainant‟s Company was engaged by Eastern Minerals Trading Agency
(EMTA) at Tara East West Coal Mines for carrying out plantation and
maintenance of trees, civil works of said mine. A total claim of Rs. 6,84,000/-
against EMTA was due for the said work. Since 2014 to 2018 the
complainant was unable to realize the claim as the EMTA has left the said
mine all of a sudden, keeping outstanding dues of Rs. 6,84,000/- of the
complainant‟s company unpaid till date. On the basis of the written
complainant Jamuria Police Station Case No. 445 of 2019 under Section
420/120B of the Indian Penal Code was registered for investigation. During
investigation I.O. examined all the available witnesses and recorded their
statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and send notice under Section 41A
Cr.P.C. to all the FIR named accused persons on several occasions, but none
turn up. During investigation the investigating officer collected the Xerox
copy of the bills which were issued by the complainant‟s company against
the claims. During investigation, as per the contents of the FIR and the
statements of witnesses recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and materials so
collected by the Investigating Officer it is revealed that petitioner No. 1
Gourav Upadhyay and petitioner No. 2 Saugata Upadhyay both are Directors
of Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Ltd. It is evident from the materials on record
collected during investigation a prima facie charge under Section 420 IPC
has been well established against all the FIR named accused persons and
accordingly after completion of investigation, Investigating Officer submitted
charge sheet in this case vide Jamuria Police Station Case No. 29 of 2020
dated 31.01.2020 under Section 420/120B IPC against i) Ujjal Kumar
Upadhyay, ii) Gourav Upadhyay, iii) Saugata Upadhyay, iv) Biswanath Dutta
showing absconding in the said case with a prayer for issuing warrant
against all the above noted absconding accused persons.
4.
I heard the learned counsels for the parties and perused the revisional
application, the case diary and the written notes of submissions.
5.
It appears that the concern where the petitioners were Directors was
one EMTA Coal Ltd. (the erstwhile, the Eastern Minerals and Trading
Agency). Although there are some bills in the Case Diary directed at EMTA
Coal Ltd., there was a relevant agreement between the Bengal EMTA Coal
Mines Ltd. and the informant and others, thereby indicating the involvement
of the second concern. In the entity being the Bengal EMTA Coal Mines Ltd, a
joint venture project of the West Bengal Power Development Corporation Ltd,
the Durgapur Projects Ltd. and the EMTA Coal Ltd., the Secretary of
Department of Power was the Chairman of the company. Apart from him, the
Board consisted of nominees from the West Bengal Power Development
Corporation Ltd., Durgapur Projects Ltd., a District Magistrate, Burdwan,
MLA, Jamuria and the nominees of EMTA Coal Ltd. The present petitioners,
as claimed by them, apparently were not the Directors of the joint venture
company and claimed that they did not have any active control over the
business affairs of the said company. Therefore, the present petitioners
cannot be held vicariously liable for any act or omission committed by the
said joint venture company.
6.
It is an admitted fact that by judgement and order dated 25.08.2014
and 24.09.2014 passed by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in the case of Manohar
Lal Sharma (supra), the allocation of 204 coal blocks were cancelled,
including at the concerned mine. Consequently, the Government of India
promulgated the Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015 and the
corresponding Rules to deal with, administer, regulate the Coal Mines of
India including the cancelled coal blocks. This prompted the joint venture
company to stop all commercial activities in the said mines leading to a
complete stoppage of revenue, as claimed by the petitioners. In other words,
there were reasonable grounds for the joint venture company or a related
associate to plunge into financial trouble and thus, any non-payment of dues
after the cancellation of such coal blocks can hardly be attributed to a
deliberate guilty mind.
7.
Moreover, the business with the de facto complainant was going on for
some time and part payments were allegedly made.
8.
In view of the above, it cannot be said that there was necessary mens
rea to commit an offence of cheating.
9.
A criminal proceeding can hardly be invoked merely for recovering
money.
10.
Additionally, there is the issue of vicarious liability as canvassed on
behalf of the petitioners.
11.
Reliance has been placed on several decisions in this regard as also in
respect of matters where part payments were made.
12.
Reference may also be made to the decisions in Vir Prakash Sharma,
(2007) 7 SCC 373 on whether non-payment or under-payment of price of
goods amounts to cheating or criminal breach of trust; Binod Kumar, (2014)
10 SCC 663 on the deprecation of efforts to settle civil disputes and claims,
which do not involve criminal offence, by applying pressure through criminal
prosecution; Medmeme LLC, (2018) 13 SCC 374 and Vinod Natesan, (2019) 2
SCC 401 on whether offences of cheating or criminal breach of trust would
be attracted if an accused merely fails to pay the dues; and Sk Alagh, (2008)
5 SCC 662 regarding vicarious liability.
13.
There is also a significant delay in lodging the FIR.
14.
In a matter involving similar issues, a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
was pleased to quash the proceedings in G.R. Case No. 1742 of 2022 under
Sections 406, 417, 420, 120B of the Penal Code that was pending before the
Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bankura where the petitioners were the
EMTA Coal Ltd. and some of its Directors.
15.
In the present case too neither is there any ingredient of criminal
breach of trust as nothing had been entrusted upon the petitioners nor is
there a prima facie case of cheating made out, especially in the absence of
the required mens rea. This would be evident from a plain reading of the first
information report and the other materials available in the case diary.
16.
In view of the above discussions and in the interest of justice, the
impugned proceeding is quashed so far as the present petitioners are
concerned.
17.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order be supplied to the parties,
if applied for, as early as possible.
(Jay Sengupta, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review