The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
3. 10,000-00 10,000-00 25,000-00 25,000-00 10,000-00 10,000-00 73,000-00 73,000-00 1,94,400-00 1,16,640-00 3,72,400-00 2,94,640-00 In view of the aforesaid discussion, I pass the following: 1) The appeal filed under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is allowed in part by modifying the judgment and award passed in MVC No.1245/2009 dated 28.08.2013 on the file of Senior Civil Judge, and MACT, Kudligi. 2) Claimant is entitled for total compensation of Rs. 2,94,640-00 as against Rs. 3,72,400-00 awarded by the Tribunal. - 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:223 MFA No. 101496 of 2014 HC-KAR 3) The compensation shall carry interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till the date of disbursement of compensation. 4) Owner of the vehicle i.e., present appellant shall deposit the compensation amount within eight weeks from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. 5) Deposit and disbursement shall be made as per the award of the Tribunal. 6) Amount in deposit if any shall be transmitted to the Tribunal. 7) Draw modified award accordingly. Sd/(GEETHA K.B.) LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 12
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 9TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 101496 OF 2014 (MV-I)
BETWEEN:
GANGAPPA
S/O. AJJAPPA,
AGE: 51 YEARS,
OCC: OWNER OF TRACTOR AND
TRALEE BEARING NO.KA.35/T-4089
AND TRALEE NO.35/T-4090,
R/O. CHIRABI VILLAGE,
KUDLIGI TALUKA,
BELLARY DISTRICT.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. J.M. ANILKUMAR, ADVOCATE)
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN KATTIMANI
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
AND:
1.
EDDAPPARA HEMANNA
S/O. LAKSHAMAPPA,
AGE: 27 YEARS,
OCC: COOLIE,
R/O. CHIRABI VILLAGE,
KUDLIGI TALUKA,
BELLARY DISTRICT.
2.
KAJJI NINGAPPA
S/O. MOOGAPPA
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
AGE: 33 YEARS,
OCC: DRIVER OF THE TRACTOR AND
TRALEE BEARING NO.KA.35/T-4089
AND TRALEE NO.35/T-4090,
R/O. CHIRABI VILLAGE,
KUDLIGI TALUKA,
BELLARY DISTRICT.
3.
THE MANAGER,
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.,
BRANCH OFFICE, PLOT NO.13C,
DOOR NO.22/18, MAIN ROAD,
PARVATHI NAGAR,
BELLARY-583103.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. M.Y. KATAGI, ADVOCATE FOR R3;
NOTICE TO R1 & R2 IS SERVED)
THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MVC ACT,
PRAYING
TO
SET
ASIDE
JUDGMENT
AND
AWARD
DATED:28.08.2013 IN MVC.NO.1245/2009 PASSED BY THE
LEARNED SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND MACT KUDLIGI AND MAY
KINDLY BE PLEASED TO SET ASIDE THE SAID JUDGMENT AND
AWARD BY ALLOWING THIS APPEAL, IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
This is the appeal filed under Section 173(1) of Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short ’M.V. Act’) praying for setting
aside the judgment and award dated 28.08.2013 in M.V.C
No.1245/2009 on the file of Senior Civil Judge and M.A.C.T.,
Kudligi (for short the ‘Tribunal’) by the owner/appellant.
2.
Parties would be referred with their ranks as they
were before trial Court for the sake of convenience and
clarity.
3.
After service of notice of appeal, the respondent
Nos.1 and 2 - the claimant and driver of the alleged tractor
respectively have not contested the appeal.
4.
The claimant has filed a claim petition U/S.166
of M.V. Act praying for compensation in respect of injuries
sustained my him in the accident that had taken place on
02.01.2009 at about 4 p.m. on Chiribhi Road near DoddaKariyappara Land near Chiribhi involving tractor - trolley
bearing No.KA-35/T-4989.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
5.
It is the contention of claimant that claimant
along with one Benki Hanumanthappa while returning to
their village from the field while they are passing Chiribhi
road near Dodda Kariyappara land, the tractor-trolley by
loading material was driven by its driver in a rash and
negligent manner and came from opposite side and dashed
to the claimant and because of that he sustained grievous
injuries
and
had
taken
treatment
at
SS
Hospital,
Davanagere by spending about Rs.2,00,000/- and he is not
in a position to do any work and sustained disability and
hence prayed for compensation.
6.
After service of summons, respondent No.1-
driver and respondent No.2-owner have not contested the
petition. It is respondent No.3-the insurer appeared through
its counsel and filed written statement wherein respondent
No.3 has denied the entire petition averments and further
took contention that claimant was traveling in the tractor as
an unauthorized occupant and because of fall from the
tractor sustained injuries and thus insurance company is not
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
liable to pay any compensation. It also took contention that
driver of the tractor was not having valid and effective
driving license at the time of accident and took other
contentions available for the owner and the insurer and
prayed for dismissal of the petition.
7.
On behalf of claimant, claimant was examined as
PW1 apart from examining the doctor who issued disability
certificate as PW.2 and marked Exs.P.1 to P.23 and closed
his side before the Tribunal. On behalf of respondents, two
witnesses were examined as RW.1 and RW2, apart from
marking Exhibit R.1.
8.
After recording evidence of both sides and
hearing arguments of both sides, the Tribunal came to the
conclusion that the claimant has sustained injuries in the
accident that had taken place on 02.01.2009 involving the
tractor-trolley bearing No.KA-35/T-4989. But, it is because
the claimant fall from the tractor and he was not the
pedestrian and thus saddled liability on the owner and
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
awarded compensation of Rs.3,72,400/- and exonerated the
insurer.
9.
Aggrieved by the said judgment and award, the
appellant/owner of the tractor-trolley has filed the present
appeal.
10.
Heard arguments of both sides.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellant Sri.J.M.Anil
Kumar would submit that as per complaint averments, the
claimant was pedestrian and there was no fall from the
tractor; further, charge-sheet is filed against the driver of
the tractor. The insurance company has not challenged the
charge sheet. Hence, liability ought to have been fastened
on the insurance company. The tractor-trolley in question
was duly insured with respondent No.3 and hence prayed
for allowing the appeal.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellant would further
submit that the disability assessed by the trial Court is
incorrect. As per the evidence of doctor, it is only 35 to
40% and when there is no specific mention that whether it
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
is for whole body or for particular limb, it is to be
considered for particular limb and thus disability to the
whole body should be construed as 1/3rd of it and thus, the
disability taken by the Tribunal at 20% is incorrect and it
should be taken at 12%.
13.
Learned counsel for insurer Sri.M.Y.Katagi would
submit that the respondent No.3 has produced the records
from SS Hospital, Davanagere as per Ex.R.3 and it clearly
indicates that the claimant had fall from the tractor and
because of that fall, he sustained injuries and hence
considering these aspects rightly, the Tribunal has fastened
the liability only on the owner of the vehicle and the insurer
is not liable to make compensation because the policy
coverage is only for owner cum driver and one employee
which includes the driver and not to any other third party
travelling in the tractor-trolley. The claimant might be the
employee
under
respondent
No.1
or
might
be
the
unauthorised passenger in the tractor cum trolley and
hence, it is not liable to pay compensation.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
14.
driver
Even after service of notice, the claimant and
of
the
tractor-trolley
remain
absent
and
unrepresented.
15.
Having heard the arguments of both sides and
verifying the appeal papers and also trial Court records, the
points that arise for consideration are:
1) Whether fastening the liability on owner by the
Tribunal is incorrect?
2) Whether the disability assessed by the Tribunal is
proper?
16.
My answer to Point No.1 is in the Negative
and Point No.2 in the affirmative for the following:
REASONS:
The case of claimant before the trial Court in nutshell
is that, claimant with another person while going on the
road near Chiribi road near the land of Dodda Kariappara,
the tractor cum trolley bearing No.KA-35/T-4989 came from
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
opposite side and hit the claimant and thereby he sustained
the
accident.
02.01.2009,
Even
the
though
the
accident
occurred
on
complaint
was
being
registered
on
12.01.2009. The certified copy of FIR and complaint as per
Ex.P.1 and P.2 reveal that while the claimant was taking
treatment in the SS Hospital, Davanagere by receiving the
MLC memo, the police officials had been to the hospital and
recorded the statement of claimant and then the case was
registered.
17.
Exhibit R.3 produced by the respondent No.3 is
the admission record of the claimant. It reveals that
claimant had sustained accident on 02.01.2009 at 05.00
p.m. and he was examined in the hospital on the same day
at 10.15 p.m. and admitted to the hospital on 11.10 p.m.
The history of the accident is narrated as fall from tractor to
the ground in Chiribi village, Kudligi taluk, Bellary District
and sustained injury over lower abdomen and left upper
part of thigh; he had passed blood while passing urine.
After completion of X-ray, it is reported that the claimant
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
has sustained fracture of superior and inferior of ramii of
both pelvic bones; fracture of right side sacrum and
prostatic urethra has been damaged. The wound certificate
as per Ex.P.4 issued by the same Hospital establishes the
same
injuries
with
some
multiple
abrasions.
These
documents clearly establish that immediately after the
accident,
the
claimant
was
taken
to
SS
Hospital,
Davanagere, wherein MLC No.1424/2009 is given and thus
it was the duty of the Hospital Authorities to immediately
send MLC report to police officials and also the responsibility
of concerned police officials to come to the hospital and to
record the statement of claimant immediately. It may be
because of lapse of hospital authorities or police authorities,
there is delay of 10 days in lodging the complaint and as
claimant was in the hospital, there was no occasion for him
to go to the police station to lodge the complaint. Hence,
delay in lodging the complaint itself cannot be a ground to
disbelieve the version of claimant that he sustained injuries
in the accident.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
18.
However, it is to be noticed that in the complaint
that the claimant has stated that he has sustained injury
while he was pedestrian and the tractor came from opposite
side and dashed against him. But, Ex. R.3 establishes that it
is the claimant himself has stated that he had fall from the
tractor and sustained injuries. It is to be noted here that
Ex.R.3 establishes that the information was given by
claimant himself to the doctor. Under those circumstances,
stating before police that he was pedestrian is definitely an
afterthought.
19.
The insurance Company has also taken this plea
in its objection statement. In this regard, the administrative
officer of the insurer was examined as RW.1 and stated
these facts in his affidavit evidence. In this regard, he
denied the suggestion that the patient has not given the
history of incident. As discussed above, Ex.R.3 clearly
establishes that the information was given by the claimant
himself and not by any other person.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
20.
Considering these aspects, rightly the Tribunal
came to the conclusion that the claimant was passenger in
the tractor and fall from tractor and thus, Insurance
Company is not liable to make good any compensation
because the insurance coverage is only to the owner cum
driver and the employee, that means any driver and not to
any other employee. Furthermore, it is not the contention of
claimant that he was the employee going in a tractor.
Hence,
the
insurance
compensation,
but,
Company
it
is
the
is
not
liable
to
pay
owner
has
to
pay
compensation.
21.
The learned counsel for appellant would further
submit that as per the evidence of the doctor and disability
certificate as per Ex.P.5, the disability is 35 to 40%. But,
the Tribunal has taken disability to the whole body at 20%
without any basis.
22.
The Tribunal in the judgment has only stated that
the doctor has given disability of 35% and it is on higher
side and has not given disability to the whole body and
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
hence Tribunal has taken the disability to whole body at
20%. It appears to be incorrect because if a disability to a
particular limb is given; then, 1/3rd of it is to be taken for
the whole body. As per the evidence of doctor, it is 35 to
45%. Hence, the disability to whole body ought to have
been taken at 12% instead of 20%.
23.
Except
modification
of
this
percentage
of
disability, the compensation awarded by Tribunal on other
heads is proper and it requires no interference.
24.
Thus, the loss of income due to disability is
Rs.54,000X18X12%=1,16,640/-.
2.
Thus,
the
claimant
is
entitled
for
total
compensation at Rs.2,94,640/- as against Rs.3,72,400/awarded by the Tribunal as under:
Sl.
No.
Heads
Pain
sufferings
Attendants
charges
and
Compensation
Compensation
awarded by the awarded by this
Tribunal
Court
(Rs.)
(Rs.)
50,000-00
50,000-00
10,000-00
10,000-00
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
Loss
of
unhappiness and
discomfort
Future
Medical
expenses
Loss of income
during inpatient
Towards medical
expenses
Loss of income
due to disability.
Total
3.
10,000-00
10,000-00
25,000-00
25,000-00
10,000-00
10,000-00
73,000-00
73,000-00
1,94,400-00
1,16,640-00
3,72,400-00
2,94,640-00
In view of the aforesaid discussion, I pass the
following:
ORDER
1) The appeal filed under Section 173(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 is allowed in part by modifying
the judgment and award passed in MVC No.1245/2009
dated 28.08.2013 on the file of Senior Civil Judge, and
MACT, Kudligi.
2) Claimant is entitled for total compensation of Rs.
2,94,640-00 as against Rs. 3,72,400-00 awarded by
the Tribunal.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:223
MFA No. 101496 of 2014
HC-KAR
3) The compensation shall carry interest at the rate of
6% per annum from the date of petition till the date of
disbursement of compensation.
4) Owner of the vehicle i.e., present appellant shall
deposit the compensation amount within eight weeks
from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
5) Deposit and disbursement shall be made as per the
award of the Tribunal.
6) Amount in deposit if any shall be transmitted to the
Tribunal.
7) Draw modified award accordingly.
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
HMB
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review