Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 63
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No.747/2023
Reserved on: 10.07.2026
Pronounced on: 16.07.2026
Uploaded on: 16.07.2026
Whether the part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Gandharb Singh Chib
S/O Ranjha Singh Chib
R/O House No.45, Sec. 1,
Upper Roop Nagar
Jammu.
…....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Rahul Pant, Senior Adv. with
Mr. Vivek Jamwal, Advocate.
Vs.
Sahil Manhas,
S/O Balbir Singh
R/O K B Nagar,
Bantalab, Jammu
.…. Respondents
Through: Mr. J. P. Gandhi, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
On a complaint moved by respondent- Sahil Manhas alleging that on
05.08.2023 when he was called to the Janipur Police Station in a case lodged by
one- Anshuman Singh Chib, one- Gandharb Singh Chib along with six other
persons started misbehaving and abusing him, in presence of SI Maqbool and Ct.
Mushrat Manhas and when he resisted and tried to move out of the room, the said
Gandharb Singh Chib, Ankush Singh and Gourav Chib and two unknown persons
stopped his way and attacked, in the office of the SHO, due to which, he received
multiple injuries all over the body, the learned Judicial Magistrate (Sub Registrar
Jammu) vide order dated 14.08.2023 directed SHO, P/S Janipur to register a case
for investigation.
2.
CRM(M) No.747/2023
Petitioner Gandharb Singh Chib, accused in the above complaint, has filed
this petition invoking inherent jurisdiction vested in this court in terms of Section
482 of the CrPC (akin to Section 528 of BNSS, 2023) seeking quashing of the
order dated 14.08.2023, whereby in the complaint titled ‘Sahil Manhas V. UT of
J&K and Ors.’ filed by the respondent, a case was ordered to be registered.
3.
The impugned order has been assailed on the ground that the respondent-
complainant has implicated the petitioner in a false and frivolous case and that the
learned Magistrate has passed the order without application of mind, insomuch so
that in terms of law, the complainant is first required to file a complaint of his
grievances to the Police Station concerned and in case of no action taken, he can
approach the Senior Superintendent of Police concerned for his grievances and if it
also meets the same fate, then he has an option of approaching a court seeking
direction for registration of the case, however, in the case on hand, the
complainant placed on record a copy of the complaint addressed to Incharge,
Police Station, Janipur dated 05.08.2023, wherein the petitioner has not been
named as an accused, as the complainant has specifically shown the names of
culprits as his son Ankush, Gourav Chib besides two unknown boys and that in his
application to the SSP, Jammu on 08.08.2023, he has also named the culprits as
Ankush, Gourav Chib and some unknown persons, without disclosing the name of
the petitioner herein; that in his complaint before the court, the complainant,
however, improvised his version by stating the name of the accused as Anshuman
Singh Chib, Gandharb Singh Chib (petitioner herein) and Ankush Chib; that
besides petitioner, his son Anshuman Singh Chib and Ankush Chib have been
named in the complaint; the impugned order has been assailed and sought to be
quashed being an abuse of the process of law, to implicate the petitioner, who is an
innocent person.
4.
CRM(M) No.747/2023
Pursuant to notice, the respondent-complainant Sahil Manhas, filed reply,
controverting the assertions made in the petition, pleading that he was assaulted by
the petitioner, along with his sons Anshuman Singh Chib and Ankush Chib
besides one Gourav Chib in the premises of Police Station Janipur when he had
gone there in connection with case registered against him; that he was brutally
assaulted by all of them and that he moved application, then and there, to the SHO
Police Station concerned to take action in the matter, that he had to go to
Government Hospital Sarwal to seek treatment for his injuries, where he was
attended to in the Emergency as a case MLC No.4662 and that he had received
injury on his left eye regarding which he had also placed on record photographs;
that there being no action on the part of SHO concerned, on 08.08.2023, he moved
an application to the SSP concerned, who also did not take any action in the
matter, as such, he was compelled to approach the court of law, with a complaint
whereupon the impugned order was passed by the learned Magistrate directing the
police concerned to register a case, however, before the case could be registered,
the petitioner has challenged the order impugned through the medium of the
petition on hand, and it was prayed to reject the petition, being without any merit
and substance.
5.
Mr. Rahul Pant, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner has
argued that the impugned order has been passed by the learned Magistrate without
due application of mind as he has overlooked the applications earlier moved by the
complainant/respondent to the SHO P/S Janipur and SSP concerned, wherein the
petitioner had not been named as an accused and that it was an afterthought on the
part of the respondent/complainant to implicate the petitioner as well, when he
approached the court of learned Magistrate for the first time, the name of the
petitioner was introduced as an accused. He argued that the impugned order is
CRM(M) No.747/2023
vitiated for the aforesaid reasons to the extent of petitioner and is liable to be
quashed.
6.
Mr. J.P. Gandhi, learned counsel, appearing for the respondent/complainant
argued that in view of an incident having taken place near Aap Shambu Mandir on
05.08.2023, the respondent/complainant was summoned as an accused at the
Police Station on 08.08.2023 where he was assaulted by the petitioner Gandharb
Singh Chib and his sons, besides some other persons in presence of the police,
however, no action was taken despite an application in his behalf moved to the
SHO concerned and that SSP concerned had also not taken any action on his
application moved before him, as such, he was compelled to move a complaint to
the learned Magistrate who passed the order as was legally required, as such, there
is not illegality in the order passed by the learned Magistrate and that inherent
power vested in this court has to be used sparingly and the impugned order having
been perfectly passed in accordance with law does not call for any interference at
this stage.
7.
Mr. Gandhi further argued that this petition is not maintainable in view of
law laid down by the Apex Court in ‘HDFC Securities Ltd. & Ors. v. State of
Maharashtra & Anr’ reported at (2017) 1 SCC 640 and of this court in the case
‘O.P. Kakroo & Anr. V. Rajan Gandhi & Anr’ reported at 2017 (3) JKJ 397.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their submissions and
perused the file.
9.
The petitioner has assailed the order dated 14.08.2023 passed by the
learned Judicial Magistrate (Sub Registrar) Jammu, in complaint titled ‘Sahil
Manhas V. UT of J&K & Ors’ directing SHO Police Station Janipur to register a
CRM(M) No.747/2023
case for investigation. The petitioner has not waited for registration of the crime,
so as to throw a challenge to the FIR to be registered pursuant to the impugned
order.
10.
The Apex Court in a case titled ‘HDFC Securities Ltd. & Ors. V. State of
Maharashtra & Anr.’ reported as (2017) 1 SCC 640 where a similar petition
assailing the order passed by the learned 10th Metropolitan Magistrate, Andheri,
directing Juhu Police Station to register an FIR, had been dismissed by the High
Court of Bombay on the premise that this order cannot be challenged and only
the FIR registered pursuant to the order can be challenged by the accused. The
Apex court held that the order passed under Section 156(3) CrPC requiring
investigation by the police cannot be said to have caused an injury of irreparable
nature, which, at this stage, requires quashing of the investigation; that the stage
of cognizance would arise only after the investigation report is filed before the
Magistrate, as such, in their opinion, the High Court had correctly assessed the
fact and the law in that situation and held that filing of the petitions under
Article 227 of the Constitution or under Section 482 of CrPC are nothing but
premature.
11.
This court had also in a case titled ‘O P Kakroo & Anr. V. Rajan Gandhi
& Anr’ reported as 2017 (3) JKJ 397 relying the aforestated Supreme Court
judgment held that petition under Section 561-A CrPC (akin to Section 482 of
CrPC and now Section 528 of BNSS, 2023) is not maintainable.
12.
The Judgment dated 25.08.2021 passed by a Co-ordinate Bench in CRMC
No.219/2014 (2021:JKLHC-JMU:615) and relied by the learned senior counsel
for the petitioner, being not applicable is not relevant in this case, as it was the
CRM(M) No.747/2023
case as to whether the order directing registration of the case was based on
reasons or not, which is not the subject matter of this petition, as the impugned
order has been passed assigning plausible reasons.
13.
It is an admitted case that the petitioner had challenged the order passed
by the learned Magistrate directing investigation of the case and had not
challenged the FIR, if any, registered pursuant to the impugned order.
14.
Having regard to the law laid in the judgments discussed hereinabove, the
petition filed by the petitioner to challenge the impugned order whereby
investigation was ordered and not the FIR, the petition is held to be not
maintainable being premature and is liable to be dismissed on that count, in view
of law laid down by the Apex Court and this court earlier.
15.
Viewed thus, the petition is dismissed alongwith application(s) and
impugned order is upheld, warranting no interference. Interim direction dated
04.09.2023 shall stand vacated.
(
) (M.A Chowdhary)
Judge
Jammu:
16.07.2026
Rajkumar
Whether the order is speaking?
Whether the order is reportable?
Raj Kumar
2026.07.16 18:04
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review