Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:572
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
ORDER RESERVED ON
: 12 / 11 / 2025
ORDER PRONOUNCED ON : 12 / 02 / 2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R.SAKTHIVEL
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO.3712 OF 2018
AND
C.M.P. NO.20639 OF 2018
M/s.G7 Investment Private Limited
Represented by its Director M.Jaganath
Registered Office: 86, Gokul Towers,
M.S. Ramaiya Road,
Bengaluru – 560 054.
Karnataka State.
...
Petitioner /
Plaintiff
Versus
1.N.Gunasekaran
S/o.Narayanaamy Pilai
196-C, Shyamala Nivas,
Anna Nagar, Kannakurichi,
Salem Town and District – 636 008.
2.Morav Infra Structurals (P) Ltd.,
Represented by its Director G.S.Nandhini
W/o. G.K.Senthilrajan
No.1343, 10th Main Road,
Judicial Layout, GKVK,
Yelahanka, Bengaluru – 560 065.
Page No.1 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
3.G.K.Senthilrajan
S/o.Gunasekaran
No.1343, 10th Main Road,
Judicial Layout, GKVK,
Yelahanka, Bengaluru – 560 065.
4.Kubera City Developers
Represented by its Managing Director
N.R.N.Neethi Mohan
S/o. N.R.Nathan
No.10, Kaaniyaalar Street,
Thiruvarur Town and Taluk.
5.Minor Maha Prabu
Represented by mother and natural guardian
Amutha Manoharan
Thenvadal 6th Street,
Mannargudi Town and Taluk.
6.The Sub Registrar
Sub Registrar’s Office
Mannargudi.
7.The Government of Tamil Nadu
Represented by the District Collector
District Collector’s Office
Thiruvarur.
…
Respondents /
Defendants
PRAYER: Civil Revision Petition filed under Article 227 of Constitution
of India, 1950 praying to set aside the Order dated February 1, 2018 passed
in Memo in O.S.No.52 of 2016 by the Sub Court, Mannargudi.
For Petitioner
:
For Respondent - 2
:
For Respondents 1, 4 & 5:
For Respondent-3
:
For Respondents - 6&7 :
Mr.R.Bharanidharan
Not ready in notice
Served - No appearance
Mr.B.Jawahar
Mr.R.Vigneshwaran
Government Advocate
Page No.2 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
ORDER
Feeling aggrieved by the Order dated February 1, 2018, passed in
the Memo [Check Slip D.No.1740 of 2017 dated October 5, 2017] in O.S.
No.52 of 2016 on the file of 'the Subordinate Court, Mannargudi' ['Trial
Court' for brevity and convenience], the plaintiff in the Original Suit has
filed the present Civil Revision Petition.
2. For the sake of convenience, hereinafter, the parties will be
referred to as per their array in the Original Suit.
3. Case of the plaintiff - Company is that it owns the suit properties
vide various Sale Deeds annexed along with the plaint. It executed a
General Power of Attorney on August 25, 2011 in respect of suit properties
in favour of first defendant. Since the first defendant acted against the
terms and conditions imposed by the plaintiff and also against its interest,
on February 14, 2014, the plaintiff intimated the first defendant that the
aforesaid General Power of Attorney is cancelled. The said fact was also
intimated to the Sub-Registrar Office on March 12, 2014 through plaintiff's
advocate. On March 29, 2014, a Cancellation Deed in respect of the
General Power of Attorney was also registered.
Page No.3 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
3.1. Third defendant is first defendant's son. Third defendant's wife is
one Nandhini, who is the director of the second defendant - Company. The
defendants 1 and 3 and the said Nandhini colluded together and nominally
created the second defendant - Company and further, pursuant to the
General Power of Attorney, fraudulently transferred the suit properties in
parts through multiple sale deeds in favour of second defendant - Company
as well as to defendants 3 to 5. Totally 8 Sale Deeds were fraudulently
executed by them. Six of them were executed before the cancellation of
General Power of Attorney and two of them were executed after
cancellation.
3.2. As per the plaintiff - Company's resolution dated May 14, 2012,
suit properties can be sold only after written approval from it. The first
defendant acted against the said resolution. Moreover, the Sale Deeds
executed by first defendant is against Section 188 of the Companies Act,
2013.
3.3. Further, the considerations mentioned in the eight Sale Deeds
were never remitted to the plaintiff's account. Hence, the aforesaid Sale
Deeds would not bind the plaintiff. Hence the Suit for declaration that the
eight Sale Deeds would not bind the plaintiff and consequently, for
Page No.4 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with the
plaintiff's peaceful possession and enjoyment of suit properties.
4. The plaint was presented in the year 2016, that is to say, before
the Tamil Nadu Court-Fee and Suits Valuation (Amendment) Act, 2017
[Act No.6 of 2017], which came into effect from March 1, 2017. As the
suit properties are all agricultural / ryotwari lands, the plaintiff - Company
valued the Suit’s market value as 30 times the survey assessment on the
lands under unamended Section 7 of the 'Tamil Nadu Court-Fee and Suits
Valuation Act, 1955' ['T.N.C.F. Act' for short]. Thus, the Suit was valued at
Rs.1,10,000/- and a court fee of Rs.8,250.50/- under Section 25 (b) of
T.N.C.F. Act was paid.
5. That being the case of the plaintiff - Company, during the annual
inspection by 'the Principal District Judge, Thiruvarur' ['P.D.J.' for short] in
the year 2016, it was found that the Suit was not properly valued and
correct court fee was not paid. Accordingly, the P.D.J. instructed the Trial
Court to issue Memo / Check Slip. As instructed, the Trial Court issued
Memo which reads thus:
"Subordinate Judge's Court, Mannargudi
OS 52/16
Page No.5 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
Checkslip:
As per Annual Inspection Report 2016 of this Court, the
Hon'ble Principal District Judge, Thiruvarur has instructed
this Court to take steps regarding the following objections.
"Suit for declaration and consequential relief of permanent
injunction. Taken on file on 22.3.2016. Declaratory Relief for
declaring 8 different sale deeds executed in favour of
Defendants, as Null and Void. As the sale value as per plaint is
Rs.1,40,53,700/-, the valuation is incorrect and court fee paid
as deficit. A check slip has to be issued and plaint requires
amendment regarding valuation para and prayer column and
court fee payment details"."
6. The plaintiff - Company filed an objection to the Memo /
Checkslip stating that the plaintiff never sought for the relief of declaration
that the Sale Deeds are invalid. On the other hand, the declaration sought
for by the plaintiff was that the Sale Deeds are not binding it. Hence, there
is no need to pay court fee to the face value mentioned in the Sale Deeds.
Accordingly, the plaintiff - Company contended that the Suit valuation and
the court fee paid is correct.
7. The Trial Court after hearing the plaintiff's side Counsel, found
that the Memo / Check Slip issued is correct and accordingly, directed the
plaintiff to value the Suit and pay court fee under Section 40(a) of T.N.C.F.
Page No.6 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
Act by properly amending the plaint vide Order dated February 1, 2018,
which is the impugned order.
8. Mr.R.Bharanidharan, learned Counsel appearing for the revision
petitioner / plaintiff - Company would argue that the plaint was filed in the
year 2016 and the defendants were set ex-parte. He would further submit
that the plaintiff being the dominus litis, did not choose to pray for
declaration that the Sale Deeds are invalid, instead, it was prayed that the
Sale Deeds would not bind the plaintiff. Proper court fee has been paid
under Section 25 (b) of T.N.C.F. Act for the prayer seeking declaration that
the Sale Deeds are not binding on the plaintiff. While so, when the case
was posted for recording ex-parte evidence, the Trial Court erroneously
issued the Memo / Check Slip. Plaintiff's company has paid the court fee
for the relief it has sought for. If the Trial Court later comes to a conclusion
that the said relief is not maintainable, it is an altogether different story, but
the Trial Court cannot direct the plaintiff to amend the plaintiff and seek a
specific relief, which is solely the prerogative of the plaintiff / dominus
litis. While the defendants can file a petition under Section 12 of T.N.C.F.
Act, the Trial Court cannot suo moto issue such a direction to the plaintiff’s
company; the Trial Court must evaluate the Suit only as framed by the
Page No.7 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
plaintiff. Accordingly, he would pray to allow the Civil Revision Petition
and to set aside the impugned order passed by the Trial Court. He would
rely on Paragraph No.8 of the Judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Kamaleshwar Kishore Singh -vs- Paras Nath Singh, reported in (2002) 1
SCC 304, which reads thus:
"8. It is well settled that the court fee has to be paid on
the plaint as framed and not on the plaint as it ought to have
been framed unless by astuteness employed in drafting the
plaint the plaintiff has attempted at evading payment of court
fee or unless there be a provision of law requiring the plaintiff
to value the suit and pay the court fee in a manner other than
the one adopted by the plaintiff. The court shall begin with an
assumption, for the purpose of determining the court fees
payable on plaint, that the averments made therein by the
plaintiff are correct. Yet, an arbitrary valuation of the suit
property having no basis at all for such valuation and made so
as to evade payment of court fees and fixed for the purpose of
conferring jurisdiction on some court which it does not have, or
depriving the court of jurisdiction which it would otherwise
have, can also be interfered with by the court. It is the
substance of the relief sought for and not the form which will be
determinative of the valuation and payment of court fee. The
defence taken in the written statement may not be relevant for
the purpose of deciding the payment of court fee by the
plaintiff. If the plaintiff is ultimately found to have omitted to
seek an essential relief which he ought to have prayed for, and
without which the relief sought for in the plaint as framed and
filed cannot be allowed to him, the plaintiff shall have to suffer
the dismissal of the suit. These principles of law were
Page No.8 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
overlooked by the trial court in passing the impugned order
which was put in issue before the High Court. We are further of
the opinion that though the revision preferred by the plaintiff
was directed against the order dated 1-3-1997, the real
question arising before the High Court was to find out whether
the suit was properly valued and proper court fee was paid
thereon in accordance with law. While doing so if the High
Court was required to examine the correctness or otherwise of
the order dated 17-12-1996 it should not have felt inhibited
from doing so. In the facts of the present case we are clearly of
the opinion that the High Court was not justified in dismissing
the revision on the ground that the order dated 1-3-1997 was an
order correcting a clerical or typing error only."
9. On the other hand, Mr.Jawahar, learned Counsel appearing for
respondent-3 / defendant-3 would submit that the Memo / Check Slip
issued by the Trial Court is in tune with the T.N.C.F. Act and there is no
need to interfere with it. A holistic reading of the plaint would show that
the ultimate prayer sought for is declaration that the Sale Deeds are invalid.
However, with a view to evade payment of higher court fees, by way of
clever drafting, the prayer for declaration that the Sale Deeds would not
bind the plaintiff has been sought for, which anyways in effect means a
declaration that the Sale Deeds are invalid. In other words, since the
plaintiff is itself a party to the Sale Deeds through its Power Agent, the
plaintiff must first seek cancellation of the Sale Deeds followed by the
Page No.9 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
consequential relief of declaration of title. Declaration that the Sale Deeds
would not bind the plaintiff, which is a further relief, cannot be sought for
in the absence of the main prayer for cancellation. The entire exercise
adopted by the plaintiff is only with a view to evade payment of higher
court fee and hence, the Court has every power to interfere. Accordingly,
he sought to dismiss the Civil Revision Petition. He would rely on
Paragraph Nos.11 and 12 of the Judgment of this Court [Single Judge] in
Chellakannu -vs- Kolanji, reported in 2005 SCC OnLine Mad 390, which
read thus:
"11. It is not as if the Plaintiff alone has executed the
above Sale Deeds. Regarding Item No. 4, the Plaintiff has
executed the Sale Deed along with his Daughter − Jayanthi
and Arjunan and Shanmugam, Son of Poomalai. Likewise, Sale
Deed regarding Item No. 3 was executed by the Plaintiff
Arjunan and Shanmugam, who are the sons of Poomalai. Thus,
the Plaintiff himself is a party to the Sale Deed; when the Party
himself seeks to get rid of the Sale Deeds in substance it
amounts to Cancellation of Decree. The Plaintiff might seek to
avoid the Sale Deeds if he is not a party to the Sale Deeds. But,
since the Plaintiff himself is a party to the Sale Deeds before he
is suing for any relief, the Plaintiff must first obtain the
cancellation of the Sale Deeds.
12. The word “Cancellation” implies that the persons
suing should be a party to the document. Strangers are not
bound by the documents and are not obliged to sue for
Page No.10 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
cancellation.
When
the
party
to
the
document
is
suing, challenging the document, he must first obtain
cancellation before getting any further relief. Whether
cancellation is prayed for or not or even it is impliedly sought
for in substance, the Suit is one for cancellation in the present
case, when the Plaintiff attacks the Sale Deeds as having been
obtained from him under fraud and mis-representation the
Plaintiff cannot seek for any further relief without setting aside
the Sale Deeds."
10. Mr.R.Vigneshwaran, learned Government Advocate appearing
for the respondents 6 and 7 would adopt the arguments advanced by the
learned Counsel appearing for the third respondent.
11. Heard on either side. Perused the evidence available on record.
12. The first defendant being the Power Agent executed 8 Sale
Deeds in favour of the defendants 2 to 5 based on the General Power of
Attorney dated August 25, 2011. According to the plaintiff - Company,
intimation of cancellation of General Power of Attorney was done on
February 14, 2014 and eventually the Cancellation Deed was registered on
March 29, 2014. Out of the 8 Sale Deeds, 6 Sale Deeds were executed on
April 19, 2013, that is to say, before the cancellation of General Power of
Attorney, while the remaining 2 Sale Deeds were executed on April 21,
Page No.11 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
2014 and May 13, 2014 i.e., after the cancellation. Whether the
cancellation of the General Power of Attorney was duly intimated to first
defendant or not is a matter for trial.
13. The plaintiff - Company is a party to all the 8 Sale Deeds
represented through its Power Agent namely first defendant. A cogent and
comprehensive reading of the plaint would make it clear that the plaintiff
wants to cancel the document. In other words, the plaintiff wants to avoid
the Sale Deeds to which it is a party and the same is not possible unless the
Sale Deeds are cancelled or declared as null and void by Court. In effect,
the prayer for declaration that the Sale Deeds are not binding on the
plaintiff tantamount to a prayer for declaration that the Sale Deeds are null
and void. Under such circumstances, the plaintiff - Company ought to have
paid court fee under Section 40 of T.N.C.F. Act or sought for declaration
that the Sale Deeds are invalid by paying court fee on the face value of the
suit properties as mentioned in the Sale Deeds. However, the plaintiff Company has attempted to evade the payment of higher court fees by
means of clever pleadings and the same is not permissible. It is true that
Suit must be evaluated as framed by the plaintiff for the purpose of
valuation and court fees. But when there is an attempt to evade payment of
higher court fee by means of clever pleadings, Court cannot be a mute
Page No.12 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
spectator. In such a circumstance, Court must interfere and direct the
plaintiff to pay appropriate court fee by valuing the Suit properly.
Kamaleshwar Kishore Singh's Case relied on by the learned Counsel for
the revision petitioner in fact supports the above proposition and hence,
does not come to the aid of the plaintiff. To be noted, under Section 12 (1)
of T.N.C.F. Act, even at the time of institution of the Suit itself, the Court
has every power to direct the plaintiff to pay correct court fee. The power
can be exercised by the Court even at a later stage. The defendants are also
entitled to question the same under Section 12 (2) & 12 (3) of T.N.C.F. Act
as the case may be.
14. This Court deems fit to cite here the Judgment of Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Suhrid Singh -vs- Randhir Singh, reported in (2010) 12
SCC 112, wherein it was held as follows:
"7. Where the executant of a deed wants it to be annulled,
he has to seek cancellation of the deed. But if a non-executant
seeks annulment of a deed, he has to seek a declaration that the
deed is invalid, or non est, or illegal or that it is not binding on
him. The difference between a prayer for cancellation and
declaration in regard to a deed of transfer/conveyance, can be
brought out by the following illustration relating to A and B,
two brothers. A executes a sale deed in favour of C.
Subsequently A wants to avoid the sale. A has to sue for
cancellation of the deed. On the other hand, if B, who is not the
Page No.13 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
executant of the deed, wants to avoid it, he has to sue for a
declaration that the deed executed by A is invalid/void and non
est/illegal and he is not bound by it. In essence both may be
suing to have the deed set aside or declared as non-binding.
But the form is different and court fee is also different. If A, the
executant of the deed, seeks cancellation of the deed, he has to
pay ad valorem court fee on the consideration stated in the sale
deed. If B, who is a non-executant, is in possession and sues for
a declaration that the deed is null or void and does not bind
him or his share, he has to merely pay a fixed court fee of Rs.
19.50 under Article 17(iii) of the Second Schedule of the Act.
But if B, a non-executant, is not in possession, and he seeks not
only a declaration that the sale deed is invalid, but also the
consequential relief of possession, he has to pay an ad valorem
court fee as provided under Section 7(iv)(c) of the Act."
15. Further, this Court deems fit to cite here the Judgment of this Court [Single
Judge], in Sivagurunathan -vs- S.Shanmugaraja, reported in 2012-4-L.W.-747,
wherein after following Suhrid Singh's Case [cited supra], it was held as follows:
"11. To determine the Court-fee payable on a Plaint,
certainly it must be decided on the basis of allegations and the
prayer made in the Plaint. We have to look into the allegations
in the Plaint to see what is the substantive relief that is asked
for. Mere astuteness in drafting the Plaint will not be allowed to
stand in the way of the Court looking at the substance of the
relief asked for. If on a proper construction of the Plaint, as a
whole, the Court arrives at a conclusion that the Suit is one for
cancellation, Court-fee for cancellation must be paid.
Page No.14 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
12. The word “cancellation” implies that the person
suing should be a party to the document. Strangers are not
bound by the documents and are not obliged to sue for
cancellation. When the party to the document is suing,
challenging the document, he must first obtain cancellation
before getting any further relief. Whether cancellation is prayed
for or not or even if it is impliedly sought for in substance, the
suit is one for cancellation. In the present case, since the
Plaintiff attacks the Sale Deed as having been obtained under
fraud and misrepresentation for ten acres instead of one acre,
he cannot seek for any further relief without setting aside the
Sale Deed. Though the prayer is couched in the form of seeking
declaration that the document is valid only in respect of one
acre of land and for consequential relief of permanent
injunction restraining the Defendants from interfering with the
possession and enjoyment of the Plaintiff in respect of the
remaining nine acres of land, the relief in substance indirectly
amounts to seeking for cancellation of the Sale Deed. The Trial
Court was right in ordering payment of Court-fee by the
Plaintiff under Section 40 of the Act. Therefore, this Civil
Revision Petition has no merits and is bound to fail."
16. Further, this Court is in full consensus with Chellakannu's Case
relied on by the learned Counsel for third respondent.
17. The P.D.J. being the administrative head of the judicial district,
has every power to administratively verify Suit valuation and payment of
court fee, and direct the Trial Court to issue Check Slip for improper Suit
Page No.15 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
valuation and improper payment of court fee. The administrative order is
subject to judicial order. In furtherance of the administrative direction, the
Trial Court heard the plaintiff's side and then judicially passed an Order
directing the plaintiff to amend the plaint, value the Suit properly and pay
appropriate court fee. The approach of the Trial Court is perfectly correct
and this Court finds no illegality or irregularity with the impugned order.
CONCLUSION:
18. Resultantly, the Civil Revision Petition stands dismissed.
Plaintiff - Company is directed to amend the plaint, value the Suit and pay
correct court fee as ordered by the Trial Court within 30 days from the date
of receipt of a copy of this Order, failing which the Trial Court shall pass
appropriate orders in accordance with law. Keeping in mind the facts and
circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs. Connected
Civil Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
12 / 02 / 2026
Index
Speaking Order
TK
: Yes
: Yes
: Yes
Page No.16 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
To
The Sub Court
Mannargudi.
Page No.17 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.R.P. NO.3712 OF 2018
R. SAKTHIVEL, J.
TK
PRE-DELIVERY ORDER MADE IN
CRP NO.3712 OF 2018
12 / 02 / 2026
Page No.18 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review