Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 21075 OF 2013 (MV)
BETWEEN:
BHARATHI
HM
BHARATHI H M
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
1.
SMT. G. SUJATHA @ G. SUJATHAMMA
W/O. LATE G.N. MAHANTESHWARAPPA
@ MAHANTESH BHAT,
AGE: 29 YEARS, OCC: HOUSE WIFE,
2.
MINOR G. NAGAENDRA
S/O. LATE G.N. MAHANTESHWARAPPA
@ MAHANTESH BHAT,
AGE:14 YEARS, STUDENT,
3.
MINOR G. SHIVAPRASAD
S/O. LATE G.N. MAHANTESHWARAPPA
@ MAHANTESH BHAT,
AGE:11 YEARS,
APPELLANT NO.2 AND 3 ARE THE MINORS,
REPRESENTED BY HIS NATURAL MOTHER
I.E APPELLANT NO.1.
ALL ARE R/O. VASALA-VILLAGE,
AMARAPURAM MANDAL
MADAKASIRA-TALUK,
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT,
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
1ST CROSS, PARVATHI NAGAR,
BELLARY.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. MANJUNATHA G. PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER,
KSRTC BUS BEARING REG. NO.KA-17/F-1030,
DAVANGERE DIVISION, DAVANGERE.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. S.C. BHUTI, ADVOCATE)
THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MOTOR
VEHICLES ACT PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE LOWER COURT
RECORDS IN MVC NO.587 /2011 DATED 06/08/2012 ON FILE OF
MOTOR
VEHICLE
ACCIDENT
CLAIMS
TRIBUNAL-IIND
AT
BELLARY; SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT IN MVC.NO.587/2011
DATED 06-08-2012 AND ALLOW THE CLAIM PETITION FILED BY
THE APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL AND
CONSIDERED THE COMPENSATION IN MVC NO.587 /2011
MOTOR VEHICLE CLAIMS TRIBUNAL-IIND AT BELLARY, IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
The order sheet reveals that since from three hearing
dates continuously, learned counsel for the appellants
absent.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the respondent.
3.
This is the appeal filed by the claimants under
Section 173(1) of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, ‘M.V.
Act’) challenging the judgment and award dated 06.08.2012
in MVC No.587/2011 on the file of M.A.C.T.-II, Ballari (for
short ‘the Tribunal’), by which the claim petition filed by the
claimants was dismissed.
4.
Parties would be referred with their ranks, as
they were before the Tribunal for the sake of convenience
and clarity.
5.
Claimants have filed claim petition under Section
166 of the M.V. Act praying for compensation in respect of
the accidental death of husband of claimant No.1 and father
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
of claimants No.2 & 3, who was traveling in KSRTC bus
bearing Reg.No.KA-17/F-1030 on 12.01.2011, when the
said bus met with an accident at 03.15 p.m. on NH-4 from
Bengaluru towards Tumkuru.
6.
It is the contention of claimants that the husband
of claimant No.1 succumbed to the injuries sustained by
him in the accident on 17.02.2011 while taking treatment in
the hospital. Hence, they have filed claim petition seeking
compensation under different heads.
7.
appeared
After service of notice, the respondent No.2
through
its
counsel
and
filed
its
objection
statement, wherein it denied the accident that had taken
place on 12.01.2011 due to rash and negligent driving of
respondent No.1. It also denied that the deceased G.N.
Mahanteshwarappa
@
Mahantesh
Bhat
died
due
to
accidental injuries. It contented that only to avoid the
Tractor Bull staying on the middle of the road, the driver of
bus has suddenly applied the break and in that process,
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
Tractor Bull came in contact with the bus and in that
process none of the passengers have sustained injuries.
Hence, prayed for dismissal of claim petition.
8.
On
behalf of claimants, claimant No.1 was
examined as P.W.1, examined doctor as P.W.2 apart from
marking Ex.P.1 to P.159 before the Tribunal. On behalf of
respondents, respondent No.1 was examined as R.W.1
apart from marking Ex.R.1.
9.
After recording evidence of both sides and
hearing arguments of both sides, the Tribunal dismissed the
claim petition on the ground that the claimants failed to
prove that the death of G.N. Mahanteshwarappa was due to
the accidental injuries sustained by him in the road traffic
accident that had taken place on 12.01.2011.
10.
Aggrieved by the said judgment and award, the
appellants-claimants have preferred the present appeal.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
11.
In the appeal memo, the appellants have taken
contention that the deceased G.N. Mahanteshwarappa was
traveling in the bus and sustained injuries in the accident
and he was taken to the District Hospital, wherein it is
observed
that
G.N.
Mahanteshwarappa
had
suffered
mucosal laceration measuring 4x1 cm over inner surface of
lower lip and doctor advised him to get surgery and thus
the said injury was grievous in nature. Afterwards, on the
next day for further treatment he was shifted to Rangadore
Memorial
Hospital,
Bengaluru
and
then
referred
to
NIMHANS, Bengaluru and then to Manipal Hospital, wherein
he succumbed to injuries on 17.02.2011. Hence, the death
of G.N. Mahanteshwarappa was due to the accidental
injuries sustained by him.
12.
Further, the appellants have contended that the
Tribunal has not considered the evidence on record and
dismissed the claim petition, which is improper and against
the sound principles of law. Hence, prayed for allowing the
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
claim
petition
by
allowing
the
appeal
and
to
grant
compensation.
13.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent,
Sri S.C.Bhuti would submit that G.N. Mahanteshwarappa
was suffering from old ailments and because of those
ailments he died on 17.02.2011 in Tumkur Hospital and it is
observed that he has suffered only a lacerated injury on his
lower lip. At any stretch of imagination, the said injury
would not lead to death of a person. But because of the old
ailments, G.N. Mahanteshwarappa died and it is clear from
the discharge summary issued by the hospital as per
Ex.P.8. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
14.
Having heard the arguments of learned counsel
for respondent and upon verifying the appeal papers along
Trial
Court
records,
the
point
that
would
arise
consideration is:
1. Whether the appellants-claimants establish that
the death of G.N. Mahanteshwarappa was due
for
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
to the accidental injuries sustained in the road
traffic
accident
that
had
taken
place
on
12.01.2011 near Sannappanapalya Oordigere
Hobli, within the jurisdiction of Kyathasandra
Police Station?
15.
Finding of this Court on the above point is in
‘Negative’ for the following :Reasons.
16.
The date, time and place of accident that on
12.01.2011 involving KSRTC bus bearing Reg.No.KA-17/F1030 at 03.15 p.m. while the deceased was traveling from
Bengaluru towards Tumakuru is not in dispute.
17.
Ex.P.4-MLC
register
extract
reveals
that
on
12.01.2011 at 3.55 p.m. this G.N.Mahanteshwarappa was
examined by the hospital authorities, who came to the
hospital with the history of road traffic accident and the
doctor found mucosal laceration measuring 4 x 1 cm over
the inner surface of the lower lip and TT injection was
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
prescribed and referred to surgery OPD and medicine OPD
for further needful. Hence, according to the Ex.P.4, the only
injury sustained by the deceased was laceration over her
right lower limb.
18.
On
14.01.2011, this Mahanteshwarappa
was
admitted to Manipal Hospital wherein it was diagnosed that
there was chronic liver failure, right fronto temporo parietal
sub-acute subdural hematoma, chronic renal failure, hypertension and diabetes mellitus.
19.
Ex.P.8 is the case summery. In this document it
is stated that patient came to the hospital with the history
of headaches since 3 days; prior history of minor trauma 3
days ago; he had an episode of seizure in the ER and post
ictal drowsiness; he was initially evaluated at NIMHANS and
later
referred
to
MHB
for
further
management
and
evaluation.
20.
Case
sheet
further
reveals
that
after
the
treatment given to the patient, after the tests conducted to
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
the
patient,
he
was
shifted
to
high
dependency
neurosurgery wards and was managed conservatively on
same medications. He was started on chest and limb
physiotherapy. During the course of his stay, he developed
abdominal distension for which opinion was sorted from
Gastro enterologists and his USG abdomen was reported as
chronic liver disease with splenomegaly and chronic kidney
disease, moderate ascitis with thickening of urinary bladder
wall.
21.
Case sheet further reveals that on 17.02.2011,
he developed sudden bradycardia and desaturation. He was
shifted to NSICU and he was put on ventilatory support. He
was also started on inotropic support. He continued to be in
the same neurological state and the family members were
explained about the grave prognosis and minimal chances
of survival. On 17.02.2011, at 4:30 PM, he had a sudden
episode of bradycardia. His pupils were dilated, fixed and
not reacting to light. He was started on CPR, and stat doses
of Inj. Adrenaline and Inj. Atropine were given. He was
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
continued on his regular medications and inotropic support.
He continued to be in the same State till 04:45 PM. At
04:50 PM, he had sudden cardiac arrest.
22.
Case
sheet
further
reveals
that
despite
all
resuscitative measures, he could not be revived and was
declared dead on 17.02.2011 at 05:00 PM.”
23.
The above averments in the case sheet would
reveal that the patient was having gastro chronic liver
disease with splenomegaly and chronic kidney disease
moderate ascitis with thickening of urinary gland. Ultimately
he died due to sudden cardiac arrest and there was sudden
cardiac arrest and he was declared dead at 05.00 p.m.,
Certificate of death is also produced along with this case
sheet
history.
These
documents
establish
that
G.
Mahanteshwarappa was suffering from a kidney problem
and was also suffering from chronic liver disease and
because of all these ailments, he died on 17.02.2011 at
5.00 p.m.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
24.
The evidence of Doctor-P.W.2 reveals that he
was working at Manipal Hospital, Bengaluru. But, he was
not a treated doctor. His name is not forthcoming in the list
of treated doctors. Even then, he has given evidence on
behalf of the claimants. The doctor in his cross-examination
categorically
admitted
that
at
the
time
of
Mahanteshwarappa admitted to the hospital, the slip of
NIMHANS Hospital, Bengaluru was brought. In that slip, the
history is mentioned that the patient had hit to the rod in
the bus and sustained injury to his chin and it is also
mentioned that he was suffering from blood pressure,
diabetes and Kidney problem and he was on dialysis since
one year prior to admitting to the hospital.
25.
As per the medical records, there was no damage
to the head of Mahantheshwarappa when he was traveling
in the KSRTC bus. He sustained injury only to his lower lip
and not to any other part of the body in the accident. The
alleged accident took place on 12.01.2011, whereas the
husband of claimant No.1 died on 17.02.2011 i.e. more
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
than a month after the accident. If there is a nexus between
the accident and the death, definitely the claimants are
entitled for compensation. However, in the instant case
claimants
failed
to
establish
said
nexus
because
as
discussed above the deceased was suffering from several
other chronic diseases like B.P., diabetes, kidney problem
and
he
was
having
dialysis,
etc.
Under
those
circumstances, it cannot be said that because of lacerated
injury to the right lower lip of Mahanteshwarappa he died in
the accident. Even though the name of P.W.2 is not
mentioned in the treated doctor's list, only to assist the
claimants, he came to the Court and gave evidence even
without summons.
26.
All
these
facts
clearly
and
categorically
established that there is no nexus between the accident and
the death of G. Mahanteshwarappa. Considering these
aspects in a right manner, the Tribunal has dismissed the
claim petition, which needs no interference. Accordingly, the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1774
MFA No. 21075 of 2013
HC-KAR
point under consideration is answered in Negative and this
Court proceeds to pass the following:ORDER
Appeal filed under Section 173(1) of the
Motor
Vehicles
confirming
the
Act,
is
dismissed
judgment
and
award
by
dated
06.08.2012 passed in MVC No.587/2011 by
Member, MACT-II, Bellary.
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SH-up to para 17
HMB- Para 18 to end
CT-MCK
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 3
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review