Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 2043 OF 2007 (INJ)
BETWEEN:
BETWEEN:
G.B JADEPPA,
SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS.
1(a) SMT. HANUMAKKA,
W/O LATE SRI G. B. JADEPPA,
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS,
R/O. NEAR SRIKRISHNA TEMPLE,
PATTANASERAGU, ORUVAI,
HAGARIBOMMANAHALLI,
VIJAYANAGARA DISTRICT - 583 212.
Digitally signed
by NANDINI R
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
1(b) SMT. RAMALINGAMMA,
D/O. LATE SRI G. B. JADEPPA,
W/O. THIMMAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
R/AT #266, HALEOOR,
NEAR SUNKALAMMA TEMPLE,
PATTANASERAGU, ORUVAI,
HAGARIBOMMANAHALLI,
VIJAYANAGARA DISTRICT-583 212.
1(c)
Y. MALLIKARJUNA,
S/O. LATE SRI G. B. JADEPPA,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
R/O. NEAR SRI KRISHNA TEMPLE,
PATTANASERAGU, ORUVAI,
HAGARIBOMMANAHALLI,
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
VIJAYANAGARA DISTRICT-583 212.
1(d) SMT. AMBAMMA,
D/O. LATE SRI G. B. JADEPPA,
W/O SRI DODDASWAMY,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
R/AT WARD NO. 2,
NEAR OLD SCHOOL M. GANGALAPURA,
METRIKI, SANDUR, BALLARI-583 152.
1(e) SMT. GANGAMMA,
D/O. LATE SRI G. B. JADEPPA,
W/O. SRI. NINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
R/AT. LINGADAHALLI, ANATHAPURA,
SANDUR, BALLARI -583 152.
SMT. ERAMMA,
D/O. LATE SRI. G. B. JADEPPA,
W/O. SHANKARAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
R/O. 9TH WARD, NEAR EDURU BASAVANNA TEMPLE,
KURUGODU, HAGARIBOMMANAHALLI,
VIJAYANAGARA DISTRICT - 583 212.
1(f)
1(g) BASAVARAJ G,
S/O. LATE SRI. G. B. JADEPPA,
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS,
R/O. NEAR SRIKRISHNA TEMPLE,
PATTANASARAGU, ORUVAI,
HAGARIBOMMANAHALLI,
VIJAYANAGARA DISTRICT - 583 212.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SMT V VIDYA IYER, ADVOCATE)
AND:
KURUBARA YADERI SUNKAPPA,
SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
1(a) SMT. JADEMMA,
W/O. KODAL GADILINGAPPA,
D/O. LATE K. HEDDERI SUNKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
R/O. SINDIGERI VILLAGE AND POST,
BALLARI TALUK AND DISTRICT - 583 101.
1(b) SMT. UMADEVI,
W/O. GANGADHARA,
D/O. LATE K HEDDERI SUNKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
R/O. GONAHALLI VILLAGE AND
HAMPADEVANAHALLI POST,
HOSAPETE, VIJAYANAGARA DISTRICT-583 201.
1(c) HONNUR SWAMY,
S/O. LATE K HEDDERI SUNKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
R/O. PATTANASARAGU VILLAGE
AND ORAVAI POST,
BALLARI TALUK AND DISTRICT - 583 113.
1(d) BASAVARAJ,
S/O. LATE K. HEDDERI SUNKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,
R/O. PATTANASERAGU VILLAGE
AND ORAVAI POST,
BALLARI TALUK AND DISTRICT-583 113.
1(e) VIRUPAKSHI,
S/O. LATE K. HEDDERI SUNKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS,
R/O. PATTANASERAGU VILLAGE
AND ORAVAI POST,
BALLARI TALUK AND DISTRICT - 583 113.
1(f) SMT. PARVATI,
W/O. KURI GAVISIDDAPPA,
D/O. LATE K. HEDDERI SUNKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
R/O NEAR RAMULAMMA TEMPLE,
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
BANDIHATTI VILLAGE AND POST,
BALLARI TALUK AND DISTRICT - 583 101.
1(g) SHIVA MURTHY,
S/O. LATE K. HEDDERI SUNKAPРА,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
R/O. PATTANASARAGU VILLAGE
AND ORAVAI POST,
BALLARI TALUK AND DISTRICT - 583 113.
1(h) MANJUNATH,
S/O. LATE K. HEDDERI SUNKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS,
R/O. PATTANASARAGU VILLAGE
AND ORAVAI POST,
BALLARI TALUK AND DISTRICT - 583 113.
1(i) SMT. PAVITHRA,
D/O. LATE K. HEDDERI SUNKAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,
R/O/ PATTANASARAGU VILLAGE,
AND ORAVAI POST,
BALLARI TALUK AND DISTRICT - 583 113.
2.
UPPARA SESHAPPA,
SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS.
2(a) SMT. JANAKAMMA,
W/O. LATE SRI UPPARA SESHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
R/O. PATTANASERAGU VILLAGE,
KURUGODU TALUK,
BALLARI DISTRICT - 583 116.
2(b) SMT. LALITHAMMA,
D/O. LATE SRI UPPARA SESHAPPA,
W/O. DEVAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
R/O #96,0,0, AADAPUR VILLAGE,
KOPPAL TALUK, KOPPAL DISTRICT - 583 229.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
2(c) V. CHIDANANDA,
S/O. LATE SRI UPPARA SESHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
R/O. PATTANASERAGU VILLAGE,
KURUGODU TALUK, BALLARI DISTRICT - 583 116.
2(d) SMT. PARVATHAMMA,
D/O. LATE SRI UPPARA SESHAPPA,
W/O. UPPARA BHIMANNA,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
R/O. WARD NO. 02, HOUSE NO. 258,
POTHAPPA KATTE, KOLAGALLU, BALLARI-583 102.
2(e) SMT. LAKSHMI,
D/O. LATE SRI UPPARA SESHAPPA,
W/O. BASAVARAJ,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
R/O. 11TH LINE, WARD NO. 9,
LINGARAJ CAMP GANGAWATI,
KOPPAL DISTRICT - 583 227.
2(f) U. ERANNA,
S/O. LATE SRI UPPARA SESHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
R/O. PATTANASERAGU VILLAGE,
KURUGODU TALUK, BALLARI DISTRICT - 583 116.
2(g) SMT. THAYAMMA,
D/O. LATE SRI UPPARA SESHAPPA,
W/O. SRI RAMANNA,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
R/O. BANDISUNKAPUR,
KHAIRWADGI, LINGSUGUR,
RAICHUR DISTRICT - 584 125.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI S.G. KADADAKATTI, ADVOCATE FOR R2(a TO g);
R1(a) TO R1(i)- NOTICE SERVED)
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC AGAINST
THE JUDGEMENT & DECREE 6.7.2007 PASSD IN R.A.NO.62/2005
ON THE FILE OF THE II ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (DR.DN.), BELLARY,
DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE JUDGMENT
AND DECREE DATED 16.4.2005 PASSED IN O.S NO. 111/99 ON
THE FILED OF THE III ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (JR. DN), BELLARY.
THIS RSA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
16.12.2025, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT
THIS DAY AT BENGALURU BENCH, COURT DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI)
Heard the learned counsel appearing for the appellants
and the learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
2.
Being aggrieved by the judgment of the Trial
Court in O.S.No.111/1999 dated 16.04.2005 and the
judgment of the First Appellate Court in R.A.Nos.62 and
66/2005 dated 06.07.2005, the plaintiff is before this Court
in appeal.
3.
below:
The factual matrix in the case may be stated as
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
a)
The plaintiff contends that he is in lawful
possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule
property, which is described as the land bearing
Sy.No.303A/2A/2A measuring 4 acres out of 7.25
acres situated at Orbhavi Village, Ballari Taluk
bounded
by land of Kariganur Gangappa on the
East, Kanki Jadeppa on the West, Kariganur Erappa
and Kanki Jadeppa on the North and the remaining
plaintiff’s land on the South. He further contended
that the suit schedule property is the ancestral
property and the name of the plaintiff appears in the
record of rights since in the year 1982.
b)
Defendant Nos.1 and 2 are residents of the
same village and are on inimical terms with the
plaintiff. Defendant No.1 is cultivating an extent of
3.25 acres by manipulating the record of rights in
collusion with the revenue authorities.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
c)
The plaintiff alone is in physical possession to
the effect of 7.25 acres and the present suit is only
in respect of the 4 acres of land in the same.
d)
It is alleged that the defendants are claiming
rights over the suit schedule property and tried to
interfere with the same and therefore, there was a
need for filing the present suit.
e)
It is stated that Sy.No.303/A2 was totally
measuring 13.42 acres and it was the ancestral
property of the plaintiff. In the year 1970-71, the
plaintiff had borrowed a sum of Rs,3,200/- from
P.L.D. Bank, Ballari, by mortgaging 4 acres of the
land and for various reasons, he could not repay the
loan and therefore, the Deputy Commissioner
has
auctioned 4 acres of land and distributed to eligible
people.
f)
The beneficiaries under the said auction did
not come forward to purchase it and also the
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
plaintiff repaid the loan amount of Rs.7,211/- to the
Deputy Commissioner and as such, by order dated
10.01.1988 (Ex.P.14) it was reassigned to the
plaintiff.
g)
The defendants though having no right title or
interest
over
the
suit
schedule
property
are
interfering in the possession and therefore, they are
liable to be restrained by an order of permanent
injunction.
4.
The
defendants
appeared
and
filed
written
statement denying the plaint averments. The contention of
the defendants is as below:
a)
Apart from denying the plaint averments, the
defendants denied the title of the plaintiff over the
suit property. They also took up the contention that
since the defendant denies the title, the plaintiff has
to go for a suit for declaration of title.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
b)
It was contended that there is another suit
bearing
O.S.No.422/1998
filed
by
one
Smt.
Thippamma, which is identical to the present suit. It
was also submitted that one Kolli Thimmappa and
another have filed O.S.No.243/99 in respect of the
same property.
5.
On the basis of the above contentions, the
following issues and additional issues were framed by the
Trial Court:
“ISSUES
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that he is in
possession of plaint schedule property as
on the date of suit?
2. Whether the plaintiff further proves that
defendant is interfering with peaceful
possession and enjoyment of plaint
schedule property by plaintiff?
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the
relief sought for?
4. What Order or Decree?
ADDITIONAL ISSUES
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that he has
absolute ownership and title to the suit
schedule property?
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
2. Whether Court fee is paid sufficient and
Court has pecuniary jurisdiction?”
6.
The plaintiff was examined as PW1 and one
witness was examined as PW2 and Exs.P1 to P57 were
marked in evidence. Defendant was examined as DW1 and
three witnesses were examined as DWs.2 to 4. Exs.D1 to
D5 were marked in evidence.
7.
After hearing the arguments, the Trial Court
answered issue Nos.1 and 2 in the ‘affirmative’ and issue
No.3 and additional issue Nos.1 and 2 in the ‘negative’ and
proceeded to dismiss the suit. In other words, the Trial
Court dismissed the suit on the ground that plaintiff has
failed to prove the title and that the Court fee paid is
insufficient.
8.
Being aggrieved, the plaintiff approached the
First Appellate Court in R.A.No.62/2005 and the defendant
No.1
approached
the
First
Appellate
Court
in
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
R.A.No.66/2005. The First Appellate Court framed the
following points for consideration:
1. Whether the trial court is erred in
coming to the conclusion that, the
plaintiff is in possession of suit
schedule property and there is an
interference by the defendants?
2. Whether the trial court is justified in
framing Additional Issue as to the title
and ownership in a bare injunction
suit?
3. Whether the trial court erred in
holding that, the trial court has no
pecuniary jurisdiction?
4. Whether the impugned judgment and
decree needs to be interfered with?
5. What Order?”
9.
After hearing the arguments, the First Appellate
Court answered point Nos.1 and 3 in the ‘affirmative’, point
No.2 in the ‘negative’ and answering point No.4 ‘partly in
the affirmative’, dismissed the R.A.No.62/2005 and partly
allowed R.A.No.66/2005. However, the dismissal of the suit
in O.S.111/1999 was confirmed.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
10.
Being aggrieved, the plaintiff approached this
Court in second appeal. During pendency of this appeal, the
appellant died and his legal representatives are brought on
record. Similarly, respondent No.1 as well as respondent
No.2 also died and their legal representatives are brought
on record.
11.
At
the
time
of
admission,
the
following
substantial question of law was framed by this Court.
“Whether the Courts below had erred
in law in dismissing the suit inspite of
holding
that
the
plaintiff
was
in
possession of the suit property?”
12.
The arguments by learned counsel appearing for
the appellants and learned counsel for the respondents
were heard.
13.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellants
would submit that the Trial Court had come to the
conclusion that the plaintiff is in possession and enjoyment
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
of the suit schedule property which measures 4 acres by
virtue of the proceedings before the Deputy Commissioner
as per Ex.P14. However, the Trial Court had dismissed the
suit on the ground that the Court fee paid is not proper and
that, it had no pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain the suit.
The Trial Court also held that plaintiff had failed to prove his
absolute ownership and title over the suit property. It is
submitted that the suit filed by the plaintiff was only for
injunction
based
on
the
possession
of
the
plaintiff.
Admittedly, the plaintiff had mortgaged the property to the
PLD Bank and the property was brought for auction towards
the recovery of the loan amount. The Deputy Commissioner
had allotted the lands under Section 77 of the Karnataka
Land Reforms Act, 1961 to the people belonging to the
oppressed class and distributed the same to the poor.
However, none had come forward to receive the said
property and therefore, the possession was not given. In
the meanwhile, the plaintiff had deposited the entire
balance of the loan amount and as such, the Deputy
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
Commissioner by virtue of the order which is at Ex.P14,
assigned the entire land to the plaintiff. Therefore, the
plaintiff is in possession and enjoyment of the same.
14.
She further contends that the defendants do not
have any seldom of rights, title or possession over the suit
schedule property and their written statement do not
disclose as to in what capacity the defendants are in
possession. The defendants have simply produced Ex.D3
and few other revenue records to show that their name
appears in the revenue records but it has no basis and as
such, the Trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court
have erred in holding that the plaintiff is not in possession
of the property. It is pointed out by the learned counsel for
the
appellants
that
the
First
Appellate
Court
though
reverses the finding regarding the pecuniary jurisdiction; it
holds that revenue proceedings had not been concluded.
Therefore, it holds that when the revenue proceedings had
not concluded, it cannot be held that the plaintiff is in
possession of the property. It is submitted that these
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
findings of the Trial Court as well as the First Appellate
Court are in no way concerned to the possession of the
plaintiff for the suit schedule property. Ex.P14-the order of
the Deputy Commissioner reverting/reassigning the land to
the plaintiff is conclusive and therefore, the effect of Ex.P14
was not considered by the Trial Court as well as the First
Appellate Court. Hence, she seeks to decree the suit by
setting aside the judgments of the Trial Court and the First
Appellate Court.
15.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents submits that the Exs.D3, D4 and D5 clearly
show that the name of the defendants were appearing in
respect of the suit schedule property. He submits that a suit
filed by one Thippamma was also in respect of the suit
schedule property and this aspect was admitted by PW1 in
the cross-examination. Therefore, the finding in the said
suit would be relevant and as such, the case of the plaintiff
is doubtful. It is contended that the entry of the name of
the defendants in a revenue record is in no way effectively
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
rebutted by the plaintiff and therefore, the judgment of the
First Appellate Court is justifiable.
16.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents/defendants has also placed reliance on the
judgment in the case of T.L. Nagendra Babu v. Manohar
Rawal1, wherein it was held that though there was no
specific issue on the point, the Court can give a finding on a
legal plea taken in the written statement and the Court
cannot dispose of the legal plea in a casual manner. He also
relied on the judgment in the case of Akkamma and
others v. Vemavathi and others2, wherein it was held
that in a suit for declaration and injunction, application filed
after delay of 26 years, possession is not proved and title is
proved; there is no bar in the Specific Relief Act to grant the
stand-alone declaratory decree. He also relied on the
judgment in the case of Anathula Sudhakara v. P. Buchi
Reddy (dead) by LRs and others3, wherein it was held
2005 (1) KCCR 447
2022 (3) KCCR 2273 (SC)
(2008) 4 SC 594
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
that under Section 100 of CPC, re-examining the questions
of fact and going into the questions which were not pleaded
is not permissible. He also relied on the judgment in the
case of Darayas
Bamanshah Medhora v. Nariman
Bamanshah Medhora4 wherein it was held that appeal
against only one decree is not maintainable when the other
decree is not questioned. Lastly he relied on judgment in
the case of K.H. Eshwarappa v. Rathnamma and
others5 where it was held that in a bare injunction suit
against the defendants, despite the title of the property
being in dispute, the same requires adjudication and
therefore, a suit for injunction is not maintainable. He also
relied on the judgment in the case of Naganna Dead by
LRs Smt. Devamma and others v. Siddaramegowda
(since deceased) by LRs and others6 wherein, it was
held that in a suit for title and recovery of possession, the
plaintiff must prove their own title through clear and
AIR 2002 Gujarat 166
2025 (1) KCCR 869
2025 INSC 369
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
convincing evidence and cannot rely on the weakness of the
defendant's case.
Analysis and conclusion:
17.
Learned counsel for the appellant contended that
the entire property bearing Survey No. 303A/2A/2A totally
measured 7 acres 25 cents and it was his ancestral property
with effect
from
and the plaintiff's name
was
appearing in the record of rights. It was his contention that
the defendants are residents of the same village and they
are in inimical terms with the plaintiff and the record
showed that defendant No.1 is in cultivation to the extent
of 3.25 acres. It is his allegation that defendant No. 1
managed to manipulate the entry of his name in the records
in collusion with the revenue authorities and in fact, it is the
plaintiff who is the cultivator to the extent of 7.25 acres.
However, the plaintiff has restricted his claim in respect of 4
acres only. He has further contended that there were
changes in the survey numbers from time to time and the
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
plaintiff had borrowed a loan of Rs.3,200/- by mortgaging 4
acres of the land to the PLD bank, Ballari and since he could
not redeem the land, it was brought for sale and then it was
purchased
by
the
Deputy
Commissioner,
Ballari,
for
distribution of the same to the downtrodden. Since none
came forward to purchase it, the Deputy Commissioner,
Ballari, reverted the land in favour of the plaintiff in the
year 1987–1988 and the land was reassigned to the plaintiff
by way of an order since the plaintiff had paid the dues to
the
Deputy
Commissioner.
It
is
contended
that
the
defendants obstructed for the possession and enjoyment of
the plaintiff in respect of the said 4 acres of land and as
such, he sought for an injunction.
18.
In order to prove this aspect, the plaintiff has to
establish that where exactly the land measuring 4 acres is
situated in the total area measuring 7.25 acres. Obviously,
the plaintiff is not seeking any injunction in respect of 3.25
acres which he claims that it belongs to him.
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
19.
The Trial Court had framed an issue in respect of
title also since the defendants had denied the title of the
plaintiff. In fact, the said issue of ownership over the suit
schedule
property was a subject matter of another suit,
which was filed by Thippamma through the plaintiff. The
Trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court have
considered the question of possession and the interference
by
the
defendants
over
the
suit
schedule
property
measuring 4 acres. There are some disputes in respect of
the record of rights as observed by both the Courts. It is
pertinent to note that 4 acres of land out of 7.25 acres was
mortgaged and it was in the hands of the PLD Bank and
later with the Government and thereafter, it had reverted
back to the plaintiff. A perusal of these documents, which
are at Exhibit P45, P46, P47 and P48 show that the said 4
acres of land was reverted back to the plaintiff. Obviously,
these documents do not mention the boundaries of the said
4 acres of land. This aspect had been observed by a
Division Bench of this Court, in Writ Appeal No. 4621/2001,
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
which was disposed of on 22.03.2005. This Court has also
noticed that the plaintiff, while borrowing certain sum of
money from the PLD Bank, Ballari has mortgaged 4 acres of
land out of 13 acres comprised in Survey No. 303/A2
situated in Orbhavi Village, Ballari taluk as a security and
later in pursuance to the Reconveyance Deed executed by
the Deputy Commissioner, the land reverted back to the
plaintiff. The said reconveyance was quashed by the learned
Single Judge, but the same was reversed by the Division
Bench of this Court and as such, the reconveyance of the
mortgage of property has been established. However, in
para 2 and 3 of the Judgment, this Court notices as below:
"2. We have heard the learned Counsel for the parties
and perused the material documents appended to the
writ appeal. There is a serious controversy between
the parties on the question whether the Government
re-conveyed the same land which was mortgaged by
the appellant. When it is the contention of the
appellant that it is so, that claim is disputed by the
third respondent. At the time of hearing, it was
brought to our notice that the appellant has already
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
instituted the following two suits in the Civil Court: i)
Suit O.S No.111/99 in the Court of the Principal Civil
Judge and M.F.C., Bellary, for perpetual injunction,
and (ii) Suit O.S No. 422/98 on the file of the same
Court for declaration and both the suits are pending
adjudication.
We
are
also
told
that
the
third
respondent herein is a party to both the suits.
3. The above noted controversy which arises out of
the pleadings of the parties could very well be for
decision of the Civil Court on the basis of the
evidence that may be adduced by the parties. For the
limited purpose of deciding this appeal suffice it to
state that it is not within the legitimate power of this
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution to
pronounce upon the validity of Re-Conveyance Deed.
That could be done only by a competent Civil Court.
Therefore, that part of the order of the learned Single
Judge quashing Annexure"F" cannot be sustained,
and accordingly, we set aside the part of the order of
the learned Single Judge insofar as he has quashed
Annexure "F" dated 16.01.1988. However, we have
no good reason to interfere with the order of the
learned Single Judge insofar as he has quashed
Annexure "G", the order of the Tahsildar dated
04.11.1988. All the contentions raised by the parties
in this proceedings with regard to the question
whether the same land which was mortgaged by the
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
appellant in favour of the P.L.D. Bank while borrowing
loan has been reconveyed under Annexure "F" dated
16.1.1988, are left open to be agitated before the
Civil Court."
This observation clearly show the real controversy between
the parties.
20.
Now the question is, whether the 4 acres of the
land which was reconveyed by the Deputy Commissioner in
favour of the plaintiff is identifiable and the possession has
been established. Obviously, the present suit is only for
injunction and a question of title is not involved. Though the
Trial Court had framed an issue regarding the title, the First
Appellate Court has rightly considered this aspect and held
that the issue regarding title could not have been framed by
the Trial Court when another suit in respect of the title is
pending. There cannot be any qualm about this finding of
the First Appellate Court. It is worth to note that in a suit
for injunction, the pleadings in respect of the title to the
property are not available. The parties had not adduced the
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
evidence in respect of the title. But only such of the
documents pertaining to the title which would prima facie
show the possession are produced. Therefore, framing an
issue at the fag end of the trial, at the time of judgment is
not proper. On this count also, when the pleadings are only
in respect of injunction, an issue framed and decided would
create complications, as such issue would be bereft of any
pleadings of the parties. Therefore, finding of the First
Appellate Court in respect of an additional issue framed by
the Trial Court concerning the title cannot be faulted with.
21.
Insofar as the possession is concerned, in para
21 of the judgment, the First Appellate Court observes that
though PW1 had stated that record of rights is entered in
the name of the defendants and he had questioned the
same through application preferred before the Tahsildar, in
cross-examination he had stated that he has given 1.46
acres to Sheshappa through an agreement and 6.71 acres
went to Hanumantappa and the remaining land was given
by Basappa to the plaintiff. The First Appellate Court
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
observes that there have been transactions by the plaintiff
and it concerns to 13.42 acres. Therefore, it observes that
the internal transactions between the parties are not
properly authenticated through reliable document so as to
confirm the possession with specific boundaries. Hence, it
holds that the possession of the plaintiff over the property
measuring 4 acres in the said survey number is not
ascertainable.
22.
The perusal of the documents would show that
the survey sketches are not available in respect of the 4
acres of land which is claimed by the plaintiff. Admittedly,
there are transactions between the parties in respect of
13.42 acres and it is evident that the bifurcation of these
portions which were alienated are not available. In other
words, out of 13.42 acres, there is no records to show how
7.25 acres came in the hands of the plaintiff and out of it he
had mortgaged only 4 acres in which portion of 7.25 acres
is also not available. The mortgage and reconveyance deeds
show that 4 acres out of 7.25 acres was the subject matter
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
and it does not specify the boundary. If that is so, the
reconveyance remains to be a paper re-conveyance and
therefore, the identification of the 4 acres in the suit survey
number should have been established by the plaintiff. It is
not known why the plaintiff is seeking the injunction only in
respect of 4 acres leaving out 3.25 acres. The plaintiff has
not disclosed as to why 3.25 acres is not in dispute and the
plaint is silent in respect of the remaining portions of the
property which totally measures 13.42 acres.
23.
Be that as it may, the flow of title to the plaintiff
from his ancestors is also not available on record. Though
the question of title is not involved in the present suit, when
the plaintiff asserts that the land had flowed to him from his
ancestors, the flow of title was coupled with a possession is
also to be established. Therefore, when the possession of
13.42 acres and later it reduced to 7.25 acres and now the
claim is only in respect of 4 acres has not been properly
explained by the plaintiff in the plaint, this aspect has been
considered by both the Courts. It is also pertinent to note
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
that the observations of this Court in the writ appeal show
that the identity of the four acres of land is in dispute.
Consequently, unless the possession over the four acres of
land is established with proper documents, it is not possible
for any Court to only rely on the revenue records and
presume a possession of the plaintiff.
24. It should be borne in mind that revenue records
if they are kept in due course of business by the Revenue
Department, attain the character of an evidence showing
the possession of the property. But there have been
disputes between the parties and certain entries have also
been made without following the due procedure. In that
circumstance, the revenue entries cannot be documents
which really depict the possession over the property. In
fact, this aspect was considered by the Trial Court. It may
be noted that the disputes in respect of the revenue entries
cannot be a ground to ascertain the possession. They would
only aid the Court in ascertaining the possession. It seems
the plaintiff based on the documents and the revenue
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
entries wants to assert his possession. However, the
revenue entries though show that plaintiff was reconveyed
with 4 acres by the Deputy Commissioner, they failed to
show where exactly the 4 acres of land is situated in the
total extent of 7.25 acres or 13.42 acres. The survey
sketches which are available do not specify the 4 acres of
land over which the plaintiff is asserting possession.
25.
Under these circumstances, there being several
transactions in respect of the suit survey number between
the parties and there being several bifurcations in the
revenue records without there being a survey sketch in that
regard, it is not possible to hold that the plaintiff is in
possession. Obviously, the reliance of the plaintiff is on
several mutation entries and documents which are not
chronologically depicted. Under these circumstances, a
mere
suit
for
injunction
without
there
being
any
ascertainment of flow of title and the corresponding revenue
entry is not sustainable.
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
26.
Therefore, this Court does not find any reason to
hold that the Trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court
had erred in holding that the possession of the plaintiff was
not established. It is pertinent to note though the trial Court
holds that the legal possession of 4 acres is shown, there
are revenue disputes and therefore, injunction cannot be
granted. Of course, the said finding was not sustainable
which has been rectified by the First Appellate Court. First
Appellate Court notices that though the revenue entries
show 4 acres of land in the name of the plaintiff, the
location of the said 4 acres of land is not established and
therefore, it is not possible to grant any injunction. In other
words, the substantial question of law is to be read as if it
is pertaining to the identification of the property. The First
Appellate Court has nowhere held that the plaintiff was in
possession of the property. Obviously, the point No.1 and 3
framed by the First Appellate Court has been answered in
the affirmative to mean that the trial Court had erred in
holding that the plaintiff is in possession of the property.
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:789
RSA No. 2043 of 2007
HC-KAR
27.
Therefore, this Court do not find any merit in the
present appeal and as such, the same is hereby dismissed.
Sd/(C M JOSHI)
JUDGE
tsn*
List No.: 19 Sl No.: 2
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review