The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. 06.2010 (as extracted earlier), clearly protect the pay of the promotee while on deputation. This provision was also communicated to the petitioner by the Intelligence Bureau and certainly, having found that his promotion and pay are now protected, he expressed his willingness to continue on deputation even in a lower post. Now, suddenly, the respondent Assam Rifles authority, in surprise, cannot change the date of his promotion to his prejudice and that too without his any fault. In fact his earlier promotion order was also not quashed or modified by them. [18] Therefore, the action of the respondent Assam Rifles authority by suddenly changing the date of giving effect of his promotion from 16.01.2019 is found to be totally arbitrary and unreasonable. When they, on their own part, did not discharge their duties by asking the petitioner to return back to his parent department following the notification of 1989, they cannot make the petitioner sufferer for their own fault. [19] Considering all these aspects, the writ petition is allowed. It is directed that respondents shall give effect to the promotion of the petitioner to the post of Hav.(GD) from the date
01. 02.2016 in place of 16.01.2019 and necessary fixation of his pay shall be done with effect from said date. Arrears, if any, shall be paid to the petitioner within 3(three) months of the date of receipt of this judgment along with interest at the rate of 7% per annum thereupon accordingly. Liberty will be there to the respondents to examine whether there remains any further dues to the petitioner in this regard after making necessary adjustment of the amount already paid to him due to grant of MACP under 15 MACP Scheme as averred by them. With such observation and directions, the writ petition is disposed of. Interim application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of accordingly. +05'30' Saikat Sarma
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.724 of 2024
G/184375 Havildar (General Duty) Anil Kumar
18- Assam Rifles C/o.- 99APO, PIN- 932018.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.The Union of India,Represented by the Secretary, Government of
India, Ministry of Home Affairs, New Delhi.
2.The Director General of Assam Rifles, Shillong- 793011, Meghalaya.
3.The Commandant, 18 Assam Rifles, C/o.- 99 APO, PIN - 932018.
….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Dulal Ch. Saha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B.Majumder, Dy. S.G.I.
Date of hearing and
Delivery of Judgment/
Order
:
18.03.2026
Whether fit for reporting :
Yes No.
=B=E=F=O=R=E=
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
Judgment and Order (Oral)
Heard Ld. Counsel of both sides.
[2]
The petitioner, when working as a Rifleman (GD), went on
deputation from his parent Department, Assam Rifles to Subsidiary
Intelligence Bureau (for short-Intelligence Bureau), Mumbai for a
period from December, 2015 to December, 2018. While he was on
such deputation, only after 2 months, a promotion order was issued by
Assam Rifles authority vide notification dated 02.02.2016 promoting
him to the post of Hav.(GD) w.e.f. 01.02.2016. The Assam Rifles
authority also communicated the said fact of promotion of the
petitioner to Intelligence Bureau vide their letter dated 01.03.2016 with
a request to carry out the promotion of the petitioner w.e.f.
01.02.2016.
[3]
On receiving such request, the Intelligence Bureau vide
their letter dated 22.03.2016 asked the Assam Rifles authority to send
a copy of his promotion order to them for effectuating said promotion
and subsequently, said Intelligence Bureau also issued a
memorandum dated 28.04.2016 notifying such promotion of the
petitioner w.e.f. 01.02.2016 and simultaneously, they also quoted the
relevant provision contained in DOP&T OM No.6/B/2009-Estt.(Pay II)
dated 17.06.2010 (extracted below), and asked for his written
willingness to continue on deputation or otherwise, by virtue of his
promotion to the rank of Hav.(GD) and in case of willingness to
continue on deputation, he would work as SA/G in Intelligence Bureau
(which according to Ld. Counsel of the Respondents is the equivalent
rank of Rifleman, GD) till the time he completes his normal/ extended
tenure of deputation:
“2.
The provision contained in DOP&T OM No.6/B/2009Estt.(Pay II) dated 17.06.2010 is as under:
If during the period of deputation, on account of
proforma promotion in the parent cadre the official concerned
becomes entitled to a higher Pay Scale/Pay Band & Grade Pay
in the parent cadre vis-à-vis that of the ex-cadre post, the
official shall complete his/her normal/extended tenure of
deputation already sanctioned with the approval of the
competent authority. The pay shall be regulated as under:
If the Grade pay of the officer in the parent cadre
becomes higher than that of the deputation post after getting
proforma promotion, he may be allowed the pay in the pay band
+ Grade Pay of the post to which he is promoted till the time he
completes the normal/extended period of deputation (if he gets
proforma promotion in the extended period) already
sanctioned, if he so opts. No extension in the period of
deputation shall be allowed to him after completing the
sanctioned period of deputation.
3. The above cited rule position may please be brought to the
notice of Shri Anil Kumar. His written willingness to continue
on deputation or otherwise by virtue of his promotion to the
rank of Hav(GD) may please be sent to us early. In case of
willingness to continue on deputation, he will work as SA/G in
IB till the time he completes his normal/extended tenure of
deputation.”
[4]
As it appears from the said communication, the basic
intention of the said Intelligence Bureau was to communicate to the
petitioner that as per said Office Memorandum dated 17.06.2010
[Annexure-R/12] he would be getting the pay scale of his promotional
post but he should have to discharge his duty in the lower grade.
Perhaps the Intelligence Bureau was alert to the fact that in future the
petitioner might raise a grievance that despite being promoted to a
higher post, he was being compelled to work in the lower post on his
humiliation and therefore, as a matter of caution they perhaps sought
for such an option in advance. The reason for drawing such
impression by the Court will be more discernable from another
communication of Intelligence Bureau as will be mentioned in later
paragraph
[5]
The petitioner, thereafter, submitted his willingness to
work in the post of SA/G in Intelligence Bureau till completion of his
tenure of his deputation.
[6]
The said Intelligence Bureau, again on 15.06.2016, sent
another letter to Assam Rifles authority requesting them to send his
Pay Fixation Order so that his pay can be fixed from their end. The
Assam Rifles authority vide their letter dated 11.07.2016, raised their
confusion to the Intelligence Bureau and sought clarification as to
whether the individual was permitted to continue deputation in the
rank of Rifleman (GD) till normal tenure of deputation as individual
applied or promoted to Hav.(GD) as per their earlier letter dated
01.03.2016. In reply to that letter, the Intelligence Bureau vide their
communication dated 26.07.2016 informed that consequent upon
grant of proforma promotion under NBR in his parent department, the
petitioner could not be adjusted in the equivalent rank of Hav.(GD) till
the completion of his normal/extended tenure. However, he might be
allowed the pay in the Pay Band + G.P of the post to which he is
promoted. Therefore, his pay, on promotional post, might be fixed at
the end of Assam Rifles authority and a copy of the same might be
sent to them with his ‘Service Book’ at the earliest. The Assam Rifles
authority thereafter sent one restricted message dated 16.08.2016
[Annexure-R/6] confirming the fact of promotion of the petitioner to the
post of Hav.(GD) w.e.f 01.02.2016 and his assumption of duties as
Hav.(GD) w.e.f 03.02.2016. It was further mentioned that pay and
allowances had already been fixed under MACPS.
[7]
However, after he returned to his parent department, on
his joining there on 16.01.2019, a list dated 04.03.2020 was published
by Assam Rifles authority showing the fact of promotion of different
persons including the present petitioner giving effect of promotion on
different dates and in the case of the petitioner, his date of promotion
as Hav.(GD) was shown to be w.e.f. 16.01.2019 in place of
01.02.2016.
[8]
Thereafter, on 07.09.2021, an internal correspondence
was made by a Captain of Assam Rifles on behalf of the Commandant
of 18 Assam Rifles to Mahanideshalaya, Assam Rifles, Director
General Assam Rifles, Shillong requesting that his promotion to the
post of Hav.(GD) be given effect from 01.02.2016 instead of
16.01.2019. Reference to a notification issued by the Government of
India, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions,
Department of Personnel and Training dated 30.11.2012, was also
made in this regard.
[9]
But according to the petitioner, no response was received
thereafter. The petitioner then sent an Advocate Notice on 29.06.2023
ventilating his grievances regarding the change in the date of his
promotion and in turn, the Assam Rifles authority gave a reply
referring to the guidelines contained in para nos. 17.4.1-17.4.2 of
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions Department of
Personnel and Training Memorandum dated 10.04.1989 (extracted
hereunder) and informed that the petitioner had proceeded on
deputation on his own volition and expressed his willingness to
continue his deputation in the rank of Rifleman (GD) instead of
assuming the rank of Hav.(GD) to avoid repatriation to his parent unit
and therefore, in view of above provision, the petitioner was not
entitled to promotion-cum-seniority w.e.f. 01.02.2016 and therefore, he
was granted promotion w.e.f. 16.01.2019:
“17.4.1. If the panel contains the name of a person who has
gone on deputation or on foreign service in the public interest
including a person who has gone on study leave, provision
should be made for his regaining the temporarily lost seniority
in the higher grade on his return to the cadre. Therefore, such
an officer need not be reconsidered by a fresh DPC, if any,
subsequently held, while he continues to be on
deputation/foreign service/study leave so long as any officer
junior to him in the panel is not required to be so considered by
a fresh DPC irrespective of the fact whether he might or might
not have got the benefit of proforma promotion under the NBR.
The same treatment will be given to an officer included in the
panel who could have been promoted within the currency of the
panel but for his being away on deputation.
17.4.2. In case the officer is serving on an ex- cadre post on his
own volition by applying in response to an advertisement, he
should be required to revert to his parent cadre Immediately
when due for promotion, falling which his name shall be
removed from the panel. On his reverting to the parent cadre
after a period of two years he will have no claim for promotion
to the higher grade on the basis of that panel. He should be
considered in the normal course along with other eligible
officers when the next panel is prepared and he should be
promoted to the higher grade according to his position in the
fresh panel. His seniority, in that event, shall be determined on
the basis of the position assigned to him in the fresh panel with
reference to which he is promoted to the higher grade. (If the
panel contains the name of an officer on study leave, he should
be promoted to the higher post on return from the study leave.
He should also be given seniority according to his position in
the panel and not on the basis of the date of promotion)”
[10]
Being aggrieved thereby, the petitioner filed WP(C)
No.762 of 2023 and a coordinate Bench of this Court disposed of the
matter on 22.01.2024 with a direction to the respondent No.2 to
consider the prayer of the petitioner for restoration of proforma
promotion w.e.f. 01.02.2016 in place of 16.01.2019 in accordance with
law. However, the Court refrained itself from making any observation
on the merit of the case.
[11]
On receipt of said direction issued by the High Court, the
competent authority of Assam Rifles disposed of the matter on
1.5.2024 again by rejecting the claim of the petitioner, on the same
ground based on which it was rejected earlier. Therefore, the present
writ petition has been filed by the petitioner again with the following
reliefs:
“a. admit this petition;
b. call for the records;
c. issue writ in the nature of Mandamus calling upon the
respondents to show cause as to why the promotion of
petitioner to the post of Hav.(GD) should not be effected from
01.02.2016 with all consequential service benefits;
d. issue writ in the nature of Certiorary calling upon the
respondent to show cause as to why the order in letter dated
04.09.2023 should not be declared bad in law;
e. issue writ in the nature of Certiorary calling upon the
respondent to show cause as to why the order in letter dated
04.03.2020 should not be declared bad in law so far as illegal
and arbitrary fixation of date of effect of promotion in the post
of Hav.(GD) as 16-01-2019 is concerned.
f. issue writ in the nature of mandamus calling upon the
respondent to show cause as to why the next promotion of
petitioner to next higher post of warrant officer should not be
considered, inasmuch as with his service in the post of
Hav.(GD) from 01.02.2016 he has acquitted eligibility for
promotion to Warrant officer.
g. pass any other relief(s) which Your Lordship may deem fit
and proper in this case....”
[12]
At the time of hearing, Ld. Counsel Mr. Dulal Ch. Saha
submits that the Office Memorandum dated 17.06.2010, as issued by
the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions
Department of Personnel and Training, Govt. of India, clearly indicates
that on such proforma promotion the petitioner is entitled to get all the
financial benefits from the date when he was so promoted and without
any basis, now, his such date of promotion cannot be changed,
altering it to 16.01.2019.
[13]
Ld. Counsel Mr. Dulal Ch. Saha also submits that the
petitioner’s future prospect in service has been seriously affected by
the change in the date of his promotion for no fault of his own, as his
juniors have now become senior to him. Ld. Counsel further submits
that his client was never asked by Assam Rifles authorities i.e. his
parent department for repatriation there, otherwise he would not stay
on deputation in Intelligence Bureau and without asking for his
repatriation, the department cannot now change his date of promotion
to his serious prejudice by relying on said notification dated
10.04.1989.
[14]
Ld. Dy. S.G.I, Mr. B. Majumder, on the other hand,
submits that on his own volition the petitioner opted to remain on
deputation to derive benefit of the same and despite being asked, he
did not opt to return to his parent department. Therefore, as per said
notification dated 10.04.1989(quoted supra), he is not entitled to get
the benefit of promotion during such deputation. Accordingly, the
Assam Rifles authority rightly gave effect of his promotion to the post
of Hav.(GD) on his return to the parent department. So far the matter
of claim of pay of the petitioner is concerned, Ld. Dy. S.G.I, Mr.
Majumder submits that already he is getting pay at par with other
Hav.(GD) as he had been granted the benefit of one financial upgradation under Modified Assured Career Progression Scheme on
01.09.2008. Ld. Dy. S.G.I, therefore, prays for dismissal of this writ
petition.
[15]
The Court has given due consideration to the
submissions of Ld. Counsel of both sides as well as to the relevant
documents relied upon by the parties and the relevant rules as
referred by them and quoted hereinabove.
[16]
As it appears, there is nothing in the record to show that
prior to the grant of proforma promotion to the petitioner, he was
asked by his parent department for his repatriation there following the
said notification dated 10.04.1989 which also clearly envisages that in
case the officer is serving on an ex-cadre post on his own volition by
applying in response to an advertisement, he should be required to
revert back to his parent cadre immediately when due for promotion,
falling which his name shall be removed from the panel. Nowhere it is
claimed by Assam Rifles authority that, before the process of his
promotion was initiated by the department, they asked the petitioner to
return to the parent department, prior to the preparation of the panel
for such promotion in compliance with the said provision. Rather, they
on their own way issued the notification dated 02.02.2016 promoting
the petitioner to the post of Hav.(GD) w.e.f. 01.02.2016 and
accordingly made correspondence with the Intelligence Bureau to
carry out such promotion order.
[17]
The relevant rules, as embodied in Notification dated
17.06.2010 (as extracted earlier), clearly protect the pay of the
promotee while on deputation. This provision was also communicated
to the petitioner by the Intelligence Bureau and certainly, having found
that his promotion and pay are now protected, he expressed his
willingness to continue on deputation even in a lower post. Now,
suddenly, the respondent Assam Rifles authority, in surprise, cannot
change the date of his promotion to his prejudice and that too without
his any fault. In fact his earlier promotion order was also not quashed
or modified by them.
[18]
Therefore, the action of the respondent Assam Rifles
authority by suddenly changing the date of giving effect of his
promotion from 16.01.2019 is found to be totally arbitrary and
unreasonable. When they, on their own part, did not discharge their
duties by asking the petitioner to return back to his parent department
following the notification of 1989, they cannot make the petitioner
sufferer for their own fault.
[19]
Considering all these aspects, the writ petition is allowed.
It is directed that respondents shall give effect to the
promotion of the petitioner to the post of Hav.(GD) from the date
01.02.2016 in place of 16.01.2019 and necessary fixation of his pay
shall be done with effect from said date. Arrears, if any, shall be paid
to the petitioner within 3(three) months of the date of receipt of this
judgment along with interest at the rate of 7% per annum thereupon
accordingly.
Liberty will be there to the respondents to examine
whether there remains any further dues to the petitioner in this regard
after making necessary adjustment of the amount already paid to him
due to grant of MACP under 15 MACP Scheme as averred by them.
With such observation and directions, the writ petition is
disposed of.
Interim application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of
accordingly.
JUDGE
MUNNA
SAHA
SAHA
Date: 2026.03.23 10:31:21
+05'30'
Saikat Sarma
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review