Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.S.A. No. 01 of 2016
1.
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia,
S/o late Karma Tshering Pintso Bhutia
@ Sepchung Bhutia.
2.
Shri Karma Sonam Bhutia,
@ Karma Tshering Bhutia,
S/o late Karma Tshering Pintso Bhutia
@ Sepchung Bhutia.
3.
Shri Norbu Sonam Bhutia,
@ Norbu Tshering Bhutia,
S/o late Karma Tshering Pintso Bhutia
@ Sepchung Bhutia.
4.
Mrs. Dawa Doma Bhutia,
W/o late Sandu Bhutia,
@ Sandup Bhutia.
5.
Miss Hissey Palmu Bhutia (minor)
D/o late Sandu Bhutia @ Sandup Bhutia
Represented through her mother Dawa Doma Bhutia.
6.
Master Kalden Dorjee Bhutia (minor)
S/o late Sandu Bhutia @ Sandup Bhutia
Represented through her mother Dawa Doma Bhutia.
7.
Shri Dadul Bhutia,
S/o late Karma Tshering Pintso Bhutia
@ Sepchung Bhutia .
(All are residents of Bermiok Tokal, P.O. Bermiok, P.S. Temi,
South Sikkim)
.… Appellants
versus
1.
Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa)
W/o Passang Sherpa,
R/o Mungrung Busty,
P.O. & P.S. Namchi, South Sikkim.
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
2.
Smt. Diki Palmo Bhutia,
W/o Dr. Thinley Nidup Bhutia
3. Dr. Thinley Nidup Bhutia
(Both are residents of Bermiok Thangsing Block P.O. Bermiok, P.S.
Temi, South Sikkim.)
4. The Secretary,
Land Revenue Department,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok.
5. District Collector,
South District at Namchi
South Sikkim.
6. Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Office of the District Collectorate
South District at Namchi,
South Sikkim.
…. Respondents
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908.
Appearance:
Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. Bhola Nath
Sharma, Advocate for the Appellants.
Mr. S. S. Hamal, Ms. Priyanka Chhetri, Mr. Mahesh
Subba, Ms. Srijana Chettri and Ms. Prasanna Chettri,
Advocates for Respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate for
Respondent. Nos. 4, 5 and 6.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------J U D G M E N T (O R A L)
(07.05.2019)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
This litigation has a long chequered history of almost 15
years with several rounds before this Court itself.
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
2.
Dissatisfied with the judgment and decree passed on
07.04.2016 in Title Appeal No. 03 of 2015 the present Regular
Second Appeal was registered before this Court and on
completion of the pleadings matter taken up for hearing on
27.02.2019.
3.
During the course of arguments, on a query raised by
this Court regarding the possibility of an amicable settlement,
the respective parties and the Counsels submitted that they
were willing to explore the possibility to resolve the matter
amicably.
4.
On 20.03.2019 Mr. U.P. Sharma, learned Advocate and a
trained Mediator was appointed to mediate between the parties
in dispute. Barely a month thereafter the Sikkim State Legal
Services Authority vide communication bearing reference
No.18/SLSA/02/MC dated 27.04.2019 to the Registry of this
Court forwarded the Deed of Compromise stating that the
matter has been amicably settled. The Compromise Deed is
dated 25.04.2019 and it is signed at Gangtok, East Sikkim.
5.
The five Appellants are personally present in Court. The
Appellant No.5 and 6 are minors and are represented by their
mother who is Appellant No. 4. She is also personally present
in Court. The three private Respondents are represented by the
Respondent No. 2 who states that the other two Respondents
have agreed on the Compromise Deed. The Compromise Deed
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
has been signed by all the parties before this Court in the
Regular Second Appeal. The learned Counsels representing the
State-Respondents submit that the Compromise Deed has also
been signed by the State. The Compromise Deed is taken on
record and marked as (X).
The Compromise Deed reads as
under:
“COMPROMISE DEED
This Compromise Deed made on this the 25th day of
April, 2019 at Gangtok, East Sikkim
BETWEEN
1. Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia, s/o Late Karma Tshering
Pintso Bhutia @ Sepchung Bhutia
2. Shri Karma Sonam Bhutia @ Karma Tshering Bhutia, s/o
late Karma Tshering Pintso Bhutia @ Sepchung Bhutia
3. Shri Norbu Sonam Bhutia @ Norbu Tshering Bhutia, s/o
Late Karma Tshering Pintso Bhutia @ Sepchung Bhutia
4. Mrs. Dawa Doma Bhutia, w/o Late Sandu Bhutia @
Sandup Bhutia
5. Miss Hissey Palmu Bhutia (minor), d/o Late Sandu Bhutia
@ Sandup Bhutia Represented through her mother Dawa
Doma Bhutia
6. Master Kalden Dorjee Bhutia (minor), s/o Late Sandu
Bhutia @ Sandup Bhutia @ Sandup Bhutia Represented
through her mother Dawa Doma Bhutia
7. Shri Dadul Bhutia, s/o Late Karma Tshering Pintso Bhutia,
@ Sepchung Bhutia.
All residents of Bermiok Tokal, P.O. Bermoik, P.S. Temi,
South Sikkim (hereinafter referred to as the FIRST PARTY
and which expression shall mean and include their legal
heirs,
successors,
successors-in-interest,
executor,
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
administrators, legal representative, attorney and assigns)
of the first part.
AND
1. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa), w/o passing Sherpa, r/o
Mungrung Busty, P.O. & P.S. Namchi, South Sikkim
2. Smt. Diki Palmoo Bhutia, w/o Dr. Thinley Nidup Bhutia,
r/o Bermoik Thangsing Block P.O. Bermoik, P.S. Temi,
South Sikkim
3. Dr. Thinley Nidup Bhutia, s/o Shri Pala Tshering Bhutia,
r/o Lower Pelling, P.O. & P.S. Pelling, West Sikkim.
(hereinafter referred to as the SECOND PARTY and which
expression
shall
mean
and
include
their
legal
heirs,
successors, successors-in-interest, executors, administrators
legal representatives, attorney and assigned of the second
part.
AND
1. The Secretary, Land Revenue Department, Government of
Sikkim, Gangtok
2. District Collector, South District at Namchi, South Sikkim
3. Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Office of the District Collectorate,
South Sikkim at Namchi.
(hereinafter referred to as the THIRD PARTY of the third part.
WHEREAS the First Party had filed R.S.A. No. 01/2016
(Furden Tshering
Bhutia & Ors. –vs- Payzee Bhutia & Ors)
against the Second Party and Third Party before the Hon’ble
High Court of Sikkim. With the consent of the parties the
matter was referred to mediation at Gangtok where it was
taken up as Mediation Case No. 08 of 2019.
AND WHEREAS during mediation the parties have agreed to
settle their long pending disputes on certain terms and
conditions and desires that for the record the terms and
conditions on which they have agreed to settle their disputes
in writing.
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
NOW THIS
FOLLOWS:
COMPROMISE
DEED
WITNESSETH
AS
1. The landed property i.e. bearing plot no. 257, 258, 332, 333
& 334 measuring 2.892 hectares (approx) situated at
Chalamthang more particularly described in the Schedule
of T.S. No. 02 of 2014 pending before the court of the Ld.
Civil Judge, South Sikkim at Namchi shall be mutated on
the application of the First Party to the First Part in their
joint names from the concern Revenue Office at their
expenses for which the Second Party to the Second Part
shall have no objection.
2. The possession of the aforesaid property described in Para1 of this Compromise Deed is handed over today i.e.
25.04.2019 to the First Party to the First Part by the Second
Party of the Second Part in token thereof the parties have
put their respective seal and signatures.
3. The First Party of the First Part shall withdraw Title Suit
No. 02 of 2014 pending before the Court of Ld. Civil Judge,
Namchi, South Sikkim.
4. A portion of property from the property i.e. plot no. 76, 77
and 78 (more particularly described in T.S. No. 07 of 2014)
shall be handed over by the Second Party to the First Party
with the boundaries as earlier agreed by them on the spot
on 18.04.2019 after demarcation by the surveyor on the
joint application of the parties.
5. The portion of properties (supra) so demarcated by the
surveyor shall be demarcated in the joint names of the First
Party for which the Second Party shall have no objection
and the remaining portion of the properties of schedule of
T.S. No. 07 of 2014 shall be peacefully enjoyed by the
Second Party.
In witness whereof the parties above named have put their
respective signatures on the date, month and year as
mentioned above.
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
FIRST PARTY
SECOND PARTY
Sd/Sd/Sd/Sd/Sd/Sd/Sd/Dawa
(on behalf of Appellant
No. 5 & 6)
Sd/-”
6.
THIRD PARTY
Sd/-
The learned Counsels representing the Appellants and
the private Respondents submits that clause 4 of the
Compromise Deed requires a small clarification with regard to
the extent of land mentioned therein. To ascertain the exact
area comprising the portion of property from the property i.e.
plot nos. 76, 77 and 78 (more particularly described in T.S. No.
07 of 2014) which is required to be handed over to the
Appellants a copy of a map titled “showing the map of Diki
Palmo Bhutia of Thangsing Block, South Sikkim” under the
signature of the VLO, Bermiok Tokal, South Sikkim has been
handed over to the Court by the Appellants. The map has been
duly examined by the Respondent No.2 along with her Counsel
in Court and she states that it is correct. The said map is also
taken on record and marked as (Y).
7.
The parties to the present Regular Second Appeal and
their respective Counsels state that all issues pending between
the Appellants and the private Respondents have been
amicably settled.
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
8.
The learned Counsel for the State submits that when the
parties approaches the authorities for mutation of the
immovable properties in terms of the Compromise Deed it shall
be done. The parties agree to approach the authorities to take
such steps accordingly in right earnest.
9.
It is said that mediation is as ancient as human
civilization. It is not without any reason that this innovation
survives and thrives even today. A dispute which had not been
able to be fully resolved through the process of adversarial
litigation in Court for 15 long years has been amicably settled
through the efforts of the learned Counsels and the Mediator
who has facilitated the parties to reach a common agreement.
10. The Appellants as well as the private Respondents have
realized that it is better to bury their differences and live
peacefully than to litigate in this manner for such a prolonged
period without any complete resolution. This Court records its
appreciation of the yeomen service rendered by the learned
Mediator. This Court also records its appreciation of the ernest
efforts made by the learned Counsels representing not only the
parties in dispute but also the State-Respondents. Quite
clearly, this has been possible only because the learned
Counsels have considered themselves the guardians of their
client’s interest.
R.S.A. No 01 of 2016
Shri Furden Tshering Bhutia & Ors. v. Smt. Payzee Bhutia (Sherpa) & Ors.
11. In view of the Compromise Deed the Appellants shall
withdraw Title Suit No 02 of 2014 pending before the Court of
the learned Civil Judge, South Sikkim at Namchi. The present
Regular Second Appeal No. 01 of 2016 is disposed of in terms
of the Compromise Deed (X) and the map (Y) which shall be
read as part of the Compromise Deed.
Nothing further
remains to be considered and decided. Let a decree be drawn
in terms of the Compromise Deed (X) and the map (Y)
explaining clause 4 of the Compromise Deed.
12. The parties shall bear their own costs.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
07.05.2019
to/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review