Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
SHAMURAILATPAM Digitally
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.03.20 11:51:17 +05'30'
SUSHIL SHARMA
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022
Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022
1. The Food Corporation of India through the Chairman
& Managing Director, 16/20 Barakhamba Lane, New
Delhi- 110001.
2. The Executive Director (Zone), Food Corporation of
India (NE), Zonal Office (NE), Publication Building,
G.S. Road Lachit Nagar, Guwahati, Assam-7.
3. The Deputy General Manager (R), Food Corporation
of India, Regional Office, Manipur, Old Assembly
Complex, Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
4. The General Manager (R), Food Corporation of
India, Regional Office, Nagaland, Regional Office,
House No. 105, Bank Colony, Dimapur, Nagaland –
797112.
… Applicants
-Versus1. M/S Zenith Enterprise, having its Branch Office at
M.G. Avenue, P.O & P.S. Imphal through its
Proprietor namely Johnson Keishing, aged about
58 years old, S/O (L) Miba Keishing, a permanent
resident of Marung Lane, New Checkon, P.O. &
P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795002.
...... Respondent
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |2
MC (WP(C)) No.399 of 2022
Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
1. The Food Corporation of India through the Chairman
& Managing Director, 16/20 Barakhamba Lane, New
Delhi- 110001.
2. The Executive Director (Zone), Food Corporation of
India (NE), Zonal Office (NE), Publication Building,
G.S. Road Lachit Nagar, Guwahati, Assam-7.
3. The Deputy General Manager (R), Food Corporation
of India, Regional Office, Manipur, Old Assembly
Complex, Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
4. The General Manager (R), Food Corporation of
India, Regional Office, Nagaland, Regional Office,
House No. 105, Bank Colony, Dimapur, Nagaland –
797112.
… Applicants
-Versus1. M/S Zenith Enterprise, having its Branch Office at
M.G. Avenue, P.O & P.S. Imphal through its
Proprietor namely Johnson Keishing, aged about
58 years old, S/O (L) Miba Keishing, a permanent
resident of Marung Lane, New Checkon, P.O. &
P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795002.
...... Respondent
2. The W.A.C. Enterprises through its proprietor,
having its Head Office at Tushen Chanhong
Village, Ukhrul District, Manipur – 795142.
… Proforma Respondents
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |3
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Applicants
::
Mr. W. Darakishwor, Sr.PCCG
For the Respondents
::
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. S. Gunabanta, Adv.
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
14.02.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
14.03.2023
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
These petitions have been filed by the petitioners
herein to vacate the interim order dated 28.9.2022 passed in
WP(C) No.819 of 2022 and the interim order dated 30.11.2022
passed in WP(C) No.1012 of 2022.
2.
The petitioners are the respondents in the writ
petitions.
3.
W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022 has been filed by the writ
petitioner to quash the impugned third re-tender NIT dated
29.8.2022 issued by the Regional Office of the FCI at Dimapur,
Nagaland for appointment of Road Transport Contractor for the
route Ex-Dimapur to FSD Thoubal as the same is illegal and to
direct the respondents therein to prove reasonable allocation of
work to the writ petitioner in terms of the appointment order dated
6.12.2021.
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |4
4.
W.P.(C) No.1012 of 2022 has been filed by the writ
petitioner to quash the impugned order dated 30.5.2022
appointing the private respondent therein as ad-hoc road
transportation contract from RH, Dimapur to FSD Thoubal so far
as the contract period extendable by three months in terms of the
speaking order dated 20.9.2022 and the RTI reply dated
20.9.2022 and to direct the respondents therein allowing
allocation of the work program for transportation of rice from
Railhead, Jiribam to FSD Thoubal to the writ petitioner.
5.
On 28.9.2022, when W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022 came
up for admission, this Court passed the following interim order:
“[1] Heard Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner and perused the
record.
[2] Admit.
[3] Notice returnable by 10.10.2022.
[4] Mr. D.JuliusRiamei, learned counsel takes
notice for the FCI and hence, no formal notice
is required.
[5] Post this matter on 10.10.2022 as first item.
[6] Registry is directed to delete the name of
Mr. W.Darakishwor, learned Sr.PCCG and
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |5
print the name of Mr.D.JuliusRiamei, learned
counsel for the respondents.
[7] Till such time, the respondents are directed
not to finalize the tender.”
6.
Similarly, on 30.11.2022, when W.P.(C) No.1012 of
2022 came up for admission, this Court passed the following
order:
“[1] Heard Mr. S.Gunabanta, learned Jr.
counsel to Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner and perused the
records.
[2] Admit.
[3] Issue notice, returnable by 20.12.2022.
[4] Since Mr. W.Darakishwor, learned senior
panel counsel takes notice, no formal notice is
required.
[5] Mr. S.Gunabanta, learned counsel for the
petitioner prayed this Court for interim order
whereas Mr. W.Darakishwor, learned senior
panel counsel for the respondents has
strongly objected for granting the interim order
stating that as per the contract rule, the period
for contract may be extended for further period
of 3 (three) months, apart from this, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court passed an order in
favour of respondents, Mr.W. Darakishwor,
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |6
learned
senior
panel
counsel
for
the
respondents also pointed out that this writ
petitioner
has
not
participated
in
the
proceedings and hence, he has no right to file
the writ petition and therefore, he seeks time
to file counter affidavit by praying not to grant
any interim order.
[6] The prima-facie, it is made clear that the
contract given to the private respondents is
expired on 29.11.2022 and from today
onwards, there is no order of extending the
period for contract to the private respondents.
Therefore, the private respondents have no
right to continue the work. Therefore, there
shall be an interim order directing the
respondents not to extend the period of
contract till the next date of hearing.
[7] The respondents are at liberty to file an
application for vacating the interim order along
with counter affidavit.
[8] Post the matter on 20.12.2022 as first item
after the motion cases.”
7.
Aggrieved by the said interim orders passed by this
Court, the petitioner Food Corporation of India (FCI) has filed
these petitions contending that all the tenders for road transport
contractor are invited online by the FCI in Government e-Market
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |7
Place portal and, thus, there is no question of favouring any
contractor by the FCI. The portal is a Government platform
wherein any eligible firm can participate in any tender from any
corner of the country. As such the first respondent himself can
also participate in any tender floated by any FCI office located in
any corner of the country.
8.
It is submitted that Manipur is a landlocked State
and its two lifelines are NH-2 – Dimapur to Imphal and NH-37 –
Jiribam to Imphal and the primary objective of FCI is to cater to
the NFSA requirement and the foodgrains are issued from the
FCI godowns under the FCI regional office, Manipur. There are
8 FCI godowns in Manipur region, namely FSD Sangaiporou;
FSD Bishnupur; FSD Senapati; FSD Ukhrul; FSD Jiribam; FSD
Sangaiprou; FSD Sawombung; FSD Thoubal and FSD
Churachandpur and the regular road transport contractor is
already in position from Dimapur. Further, for FSD Thoubal and
Churachandpur, there are ad-hoc transport contractors in
position from Dimapur.
9.
It is further submitted that unfortunately, NH-37 was
completely cut-off for almost three months from mid-May 2022 to
last part of July 2022 and the rail line was also cut-off due to
heavy rain. Therefore, it became imperative that in order to tide
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |8
over such an unfortunate situation and to meet NFSA
requirement, the FCI needs to position regular road transport
contractor Ex-Dimapur to FSD Thoubal. Accordingly, FCI,
Regional Office, Dimapur being the dispatching region, invited
tender for appointment of regular road transport contractor ExDimapur to FSD Thoubal for a period of two years vide NIT dated
4.5.2022. However, no bids were received. The tender was
again re-invited by the FCI Regional Office, Dimapur vide NIT
dated 28.5.2022, but no bids were received. Again the tender
was re-invited vide NIT dated 21.7.2022, but again no bids were
received. Finally, fourth time NIT dated 29.8.022 was invited
wherein one bidder, namely M/s.SA Ngamo Agency participated
and the value of the tender has been estimated at Rs.17.68 crore
after considering the ad-hoc transportation rate and stocks likely
to be inducted during the two years contract period.
10.
According to the petitioners, the FCI undertakes
movement of stock on least cost basis, as FCI is running and
financed by the Government of India from public exchequer and
the transportation is to be done on economic routes and decision
taken by the FCI to move stocks from Dimapur to Thoubal at a
cheaper rate is in public interest and for the FCI, no one is
influential and all the tenders are finalized based on merits only.
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |9
The FCI Regional Office, Manipur, vide letter dated 28.12.2020
stated that at a time when there was a departmental letter posted
at FSD Dimapur and handling cost was very high and capacity of
the FSD Thoubal was only 2500 MT and later on, due to increase
in norms, the capacity of FSD Thoubal has been increased to
3132 MT.
11.
It is stated by the petitioners that by the end of
January, 2023, all the departmental labour who were previously
posted in FSD Dimapur had been transferred from FSD Dimapur
on 24.1.2022 and 28.1.2022. Thereafter, contract labour was
positioned in FSD Dimapur and handling cost at FSD Dimapur
has come down exponentially. Therefore, the primary object of
the FCI is not only to cater NFSA requirement, but also to
undertake movement of stocks on least cost basis. The
first
respondent is an existing transport contractor in the road of ExDimapur to FSD Ukhrul as the tender was awarded by FCI
Regional Office, Dimapur. Therefore, there is no question of
favour in inviting the tender as alleged by the first respondent.
12.
The case of the petitioners is that the existing
transport rate from rail-head/FSD Jiribam to FSD Thoubal is
Rs.4071/- per MT for the entire distance awarded to the first
respondent and, on the other hand, the transport rate quoted by
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 10
M/s. SA Ngamo Enterprise from Dimpaur to FSD Thoubal which
is kept under abeyance by this Court is Rs.3763/- per MT for the
entire distance which is lower by Rs.308/- per MT for the entire
distance compared to the first respondent. Therefore, the
financial implication or loss to the FCI will be around
Rs.1,37,04,768/- if the stock is moved from Jiribam to Thoubal
which is against the imperative policy of least cost policy.
13.
The arguments of the learned counsel for the
petitioners is summarized as under:
That the first respondent has no locus
standi to challenge the impugned third
re-tender NIT dated 29.8.2022 issued by
the
Regional
Office,
appointment
of
contractor
from
the
Dimapur
road
Dimapur
for
transport
to
FSD
Thoubal, because the first respondent
never participated in the NIT dated
29.8.2022 floated by the FCI Regional
Office, Dimapur and, hence, the first
respondent
has
no
legal
right
to
challenge the said NIT.
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 11
The petitioner FCI is not a necessary
party or proper party in the writ petition
and on that count alone, the writ petition
being W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022 is not
maintainable and consequently, the
interim order dated 28.9.2022 is liable to
be vacated.
In
the
re-tender
dated
29.8.2022,
M/s.Ngamo Agency participated and the
said Agency became a successful
bidder both in technical bid as well as
financial bid and the first respondent
knowingly failed to implead M/s.Ngamo
Agency as party respondent in W.P.(C)
No.819 of 2022 and the interim order
dated 28.9.2022 passed in the said writ
petition affected the rights of the said
successful bidder.
It is the duty of the FCI that the
transportation
is
to
be
done
on
economical roads and the decision of
the FCI
to move the stocks from
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 12
Dimapur to Thoubal at cheaper rate is in
public interest.
From the interim order dated 28.9.2022
passed in W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022, the
FCI incurred loss of about Rs.30 lakh
and if it continued for one year, then the
FCI will cause losses for more than
Rs.1,37,04,768/-.
Vide interim order dated 28.9.2022
passed
by
this
Court,
the
first
respondent was allowed to take the
foodgrains at higher rates from FSD
Jiribam despite having cheaper rates of
transportation from FSD Dimapur to
Thoubal.
The first respondent is presently carrying
foodgrains from FSD Dimapur to Ukhrul
Depot on the basis of least cost policy.
In addition to that, the first respondent is
also carrying foodgrains from FSD
Jiribam to Sangaiprou Depot and FSD
Jiribam to Sawombung on the basis of
the least policy despite having existing
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 13
contractor M/s.WAC& MS WI Enterprise
from FSD Dimapur to Sangaiprou and
FSD Dimapur to Sawombung.
The first respondent cannot dictate the
FCI to do what they want by thinking for
their benefit only.
The
EMD
deposited
by
the
first
respondent is Rs.2 crore something,
which is refundable and the estimated
cost for carrying foodgrains for the said
two road is Rs.17 crore and before filing
the writ petition, the first respondent has
given allocation for more than Rs.6
crore.
As per Clause XVI(b) of the MTF, the
FCI has the exclusive right to appoint
one or more contractors for any or all the
services and to divide the work between
such contractors in any manner that the
FCI may decide and no claim shall lie
against the FCI by reason of such
division of work.
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 14
The FCI have clearly stated in paragraph
8 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed in
W.P.(C) No.326 of 2020 that the
movement programme is allotted to the
transport contractor on the basis of
requirement at the receiving end and on
least cost basis.
The FSD Sangaiprou is fed from
Railhead Jiribam @ Rs.3531/- per MT
for
the
entire
distance;
Railhead
Dimapur @ Rs.3533/- per MT for the
entire distance and Railhead Furkating
@ Rs.3884/- per MT for the entire
distance.
However, due to higher
charge of handling cost at Dimapur, the
total cost would be Rs.4901/- per MT.
However, the FCI has to transport stock
even at higher rate in case of disruption
in movement in lower cost route due to
blockade by landslide period.
The NIT dated 17.5.2022 had been
invited in public interest and if any order
for stay of appointment order dated
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 15
30.5.2022 is passed, there is possibility
that monopoly of one contractor in single
route will lead to more drainage of public
exchequer since FCI will be deprived of
exploration of movement of foodgrains
on least cost basis.
It is not true that the action of the FCI in
its attempt to extend the contract work
period of the private respondent in terms
of impugned order dated 30.5.2022
would be a case of having been guided
for
polarizing
the
public
sector
transportation from Dimapur, Nagaland
for vested interest and for favouring
contractors
and
others
who
are
influential in Dimapur.
14.
To fortify his submission, the learned counsel for the
petitioners relied upon the following decisions:
(i)
Haji Enterprise v. FCI, (2018) 1 GLT
383.
(ii)
Vikash Construction v. FCI, (2017) 2
GLT 432
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 16
(iii)
S.A.Ngamo Agency v. FCI, (2021) 3
GLT (MN) 862
(iv)
JagdishMondal v. State of Orissa and
others, (2007) 14 SCC 517.
(v)
Sri Ram Builders v. State of Madhya
Pradesh and others, (2014) 14 SCC
102.
Arguing so, a prayer has been made to vacate the
interim orders passed in the writ petitions.
15.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the first
respondent submitted that the impugned order dated 30.5.2022
appointing the private respondent as ad-hoc road transportation
contractor from RH, Dimapur to FSD Thoubal arose due to a
contingency situation on the collapse of the Irang Balley Bridge
on the Jiribam Road and disruption of railways line in LamdingBadarpur Section in the month of April-May, 2022 during which
the first respondent has been appointed as regular road transport
contractor of FCI for the route RH, Jiribam to FSD Thoubal.
However, the petitioner has not allotted any work during the
period due the collapse of the Irang Bally Bridge. The said
IrangBalley Bridge as well as disruption in the railways has been
repaired and restored and the first respondent would be entitled
to transportation of foodgrains of FCI from RH, Jiribam to FSD
Thoubal.
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 17
16.
The learned counsel for the first respondent would
submit the regular road transport contract of the first respondent
is still subsisting till December, 2023, inasmuch as the capacity
of the godown at FSD, Thoubalis only 3132 MT. Therefore, as
the regular road transport contract of the first respondent is still
subsisting till December, 2023,there is no point to appoint
another road transport contractor.
17.
The learned counsel for the first respondent argued
that the transportation from Dimapur is not the least cost route
because of high handling cost at Dimapur godown, the same
shall be substantiated by affidavit filed in W.P.(C) No.326 of
2020, wherein the FCI has taken a stand that handling charges
is very high at Dimapur. The stand of the FCI in the instant case
is contradictory and inconsistent with its earlier stand taken in the
said petition.
18.
The learned counsel for the first respondent further
submitted that the first respondent was appointed as road
transport contractor from Jiribam to Thoubal after having
participated in the public tender of the FCI is entitled to freedom
of trade and commerce where it shall be entitled for
transportation of food grains till December, 2023, as it has been
neither terminated nor the first respondent has defaulted any
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 18
terms and conditions of the contract. The FCI, if considered that
Jiribam route is expensive and against the least cost factor ought
to have done away with the grant of contract work for
transportation by asking to deposit huge amount of Rs.2.64 crore
and making it sitting idle without any work since June,2022 till
date. But appointing the private respondent on ad-hoc basis with
condition of depositing hardly Rs.10 lakh and allotting all works
for transportation to the small capacity of godown at Thoubal
itself shows mala fide and arbitrariness on the part of FCI.
19.
The learned counsel for the first respondent next
submitted that the appointment of ad-hoc contract was issued on
30.5.2022 and upon expiry of 6 months, the FCI authority has
neither processed for extension of the contract period nor learned
counsel for the FCI informed about the extension of the contract
or subsistence of the contract at the time of passing of the interim
order dated 30.11.2022 in W.P.(C) No.1012 of 2022. Therefore,
the first respondent should not be blamed for the fault of the FCI,
inasmuch as the prayer of the first respondent is for not extending
the terms of the contract beyond 6 months as contained in the
order dated 30.5.2022.
20.
The learned counsel for the first respondent added
that consequent upon passing of the interim order dated
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 19
30.11.2022 in W.P.(C) No.1012 of 2022 and the interim order
dated 28.9.2022 in W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022 and further
extension, the FCI has allotted the work at the line of 2300 MT
for transportation to the route of the first respondent i.e. ExJiribam to Thoubal vide office letter dated 30.12.2022. The FCI
by attempting to appoint regular road transport contractor from
Dimapur to Thoubal have favoured the contractor at Dimapur
thereby depriving the first respondent’s fundamental right of
freedom of trade and commerce. Out of 8 godown in Manipur
Region, namely FSD Sangaiprou, FSD Bishnupur, FSD
Senapati, FSD Ukhrul, FSD Jiribam, FSD Sawombung, FSD
Churachandpur and FSD Thoubal, FSD Sangaiprou and FSD
Sawombung are feded from RH Riribam by regular road
transport contractor and the godown concerned with the first
respondent i.e. Thoubal and that of Churachandpur is fed by adhoc transport contract from Dimapur.
21.
The learned counsel for the first respondent lastly
submitted that the attempt of the FCI for appointment of regular
road transport contractor from Dimapur though failed on two
different occasion indicates the intention of the FCI for favouring
the contractor at Dimapur and that the mala fide intention of the
FCI for floating NIT for appointment of regular road transport
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 20
contractor from Dimapur is an arbitrary exercise of power and the
same has to be interfered with by this Court.
22.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
23.
Assailing the impugned re-tender NIT dated
29.8.2022, the first respondent/writ petitioner filed W.P.(C)
No.819 of 2022 primarily on the ground that the arbitrary action
of the respondent General Manager (R), FCI, Regional Office,
Nagaland in floating the tender having guided for polarizing the
public sector transportation from Dimapur, Nagaland for vested
interest and for favouring contractors and others, who are
influential in Dimapur is liable to be quashed, as the same was
issued with an ill-motive and mala fide intention to favour certain
third parties, thereby depriving the freedom of trade and
commerce enjoyed by the first respondent. Further, the
impugned re-tender was issued against the decision of the
Regional Office of FCI at Imphal, Manipur by the Regional Office
of FCI at Dimapur, Nagaland despite the fact that the Regional
Office at Imphal for catering the need of the State of Manipur.
The Regional Office at Dimapur, Nagaland without appreciating
the ground realities of Manipur that the first respondent was
already operating for the route RH Jiribam to FSD Thoubal for
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 21
the godown capacity of 3132 MT, only for vested interest and for
favouring contractors and others who are influential in Dimapur,
has issued the impugned re-tender.
24.
The main contention of the first respondent in the
writ petitions is that despite being appointed as regular road
transport contractor of FCI for the route RH Jiribam to FSD
Thoubal vide appointment order dated 6.12.2021 for two years,
the authorities of the FCI have failed to allocate any quota of work
for the reason best known to them and, therefore, this Court may
be pleased to pass an appropriate order/direction to the FCI
authorities for providing reasonable allocation of work to the first
respondent in terms of the appointment order dated 6.12.2021
for protecting the right and interest.
25.
As could be seen from the appointment order dated
6.12.2021, it is clear that the first respondent M/s.Zenith
Enterprises was appointed as road transport contractor for
transportation of food grains/allied materials etc. from RH/FSD
Jiribam to FSD Thoubal for a period of 2 years on regular basis
at the quoted rate of Rs.4071/- per MT for the entire distance with
effect form 7.12.2021 to 6.12.2023.
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 22
26.
On the other hand, it is the say of the FCI that in
view of the disruption of rail connectivity in the Limding Badarpur
section and collapse of Irang Bridge during mid-May, 2022 till the
last part of July, 2022, there was utmost necessity to feed FSD
Thoubal by road from Dimapur and, accordingly, the FCI, RO
Nagaland has positioned limited ad-hoc transport contracts
within the DoP of GM(R) for a period of 6 months, extendable by
another 3 months at the rate of Rs.3768/- per MT for the entire
distance vide appointment order dated 30.5.2022. The period of
the said contract is from 2.6.2022 to 1.12.2022. However, the
existing transport contract of the first respondent from Jiribam to
FSD Thoubal has been awarded at the rate of Rs.4071/- per MT
for the entire distance i.e. from 7.12.2021 to 6.12.2023.
27.
According
to
the
FCI,
the
FCI
undertakes
movement of stock on least cost basis, as FCI is running and
financed by the Government of India from public exchequer and
it is imperative that transportation is to be done on economical
routes and the decision taken by the FCI to move stocks from
Dimapur to FSD Thoubal at cheaper rate is in public interest.
Therefore, the prayer of the first respondent to allot work to them
is fit to be out rightly rejected.
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 23
28.
This Court finds no force in the aforesaid
submission made by learned counsel for the FCI for the simple
reason that once the contract for transportation of food grains
from FSD Jiribam to FSD Thoubal for a period of 2 years from
7.12.2021 to 6.12.2023 was awarded in favour of the first
respondent, citing the disruption of rail connectivity in the
Lumding Badarpur section and collapse of Irang Bridge during
mid-May 2022 till last part of July, 2022, the authorities of the FCI
cannot award or appoint another contractor in the place of the
first respondent by stating that the transportation is to be done
on economical routes and the decision of the FCI to move stocks
from Dimapur to FSD Thoubal at cheaper rate is in public
interest.
29.
The claim of the petitioners that between May and
July 2022, there was complete cut-off of the road due to heavy
rain, which is the reason for appointing ad-hoc contractor is not
an excuse for appointing the private respondent, when the
existing contract in favour of the first respondent has not been
terminated and the same subsists till December 6, 2023. Thus,
when the contract awarded in favour of the first respondent
subsists, the unilateral decision of the FCI in appointing the adhoc contractor is unacceptable. Nothing on record to show that
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 24
due notice was given to the first respondent before the ad-hoc
appointment was made in favour of the private respondent.
30.
The contention of the petitioners that since the first
respondent never participated in the impugned re-tender, it has
no legal right to question the same, cannot be countenanced for
the reason that if a person participated and unsuccessful in the
tender process filed a writ petition questioning the awarding of
tender, then the said submission made by the petitioners is valid.
In the present case, as stated supra,when the contract awarded
in favour of the first respondent subsists, the FIChas awarded adhoc contract in favour of the private respondent. The said act of
the FCI is not appreciable.
31.
On behalf of the FCI, an argument was canvassed
to the effect that the interim order dated 28.9.2022 affects the
right of the private respondent. This Court is of the view that such
an argument cannot be canvassed by the FCI on behalf of the
private respondent.
32.
Placing reliance upon the decision of the Gauhati
High Court in the case of Haji Enterprises, supra, the learned
counsel for the petitioners submitted that the FCI as public
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 25
authority is duty bound to go for cheaper expenditure to
safeguard the public interest.
33.
It is no doubt true that the primary objective of FCI
is not only to cater to the NFSA requirement, but also to
undertake movement of stock on least cost basis as FCI is run
and financed by the Government of India from public exchequer.
The least cost basis and the transportation on economical routes
pleaded by the petitioners are to be examined by the FCI before
awarding contract in favour of the first respondent. It is not the
case of the petitioners that without seeing all these things,
including the cost aspect, the tender was awarded in favour of
the first respondent. Once the tender has been awarded in
favour of the first respondent taking into consideration of the
ground reality prevailed at the relevant point of time, later on
changing their mind, the FCI for one reason or the other cannot
contend that the first respondent has been awarded at the rate of
Rs.4071/- per MT for the entire period, which is very high. When
the FCI themselves stated in the earlier round of litigation in
W.P.(C) No.326 of 2020 that handling charges at Dimpaur is very
high, it cannot contend that the first respondent has quoted high
value. In view of the above, the decision in Haji Enterprises,
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 26
supra, relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioners is
not favour to them.
34.
The learned counsel for the petitioners, by placing
reliance upon another decision of the Gauhati High Court in the
case of Vikash Construction, supra, submitted that where it is in
public interest, the Court will not interfere because public interest
must override any consideration of private loss or gain.
35.
This Court is in full agreement with the proposition
that where it is in public interest, the Court will not interfere
because public interest must override any consideration of
private loss or gain. On the other hand, when the authority of the
Government like FCI acts unfairly contrary to their earlier stand,
the Courts can interfere in the acts done by the authorities.
36.
In the instant case, admittedly, the first respondent
was awarded contract from 7.12.2021 to 6.12.2023 and their
contract period subsists till December 6, 2023, inasmuch as the
capacity of the godown at FSD, Thoubal is only 3132 MT. While
that being so, without terminating the contract awarded to the first
respondent, awarding of ad-hoc contract to the private
respondent amounts to unfair acts of the FCI. Therefore, the
decision in Vikash Construction is not applicable to the case on
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 27
hand. As rightly canvassed by the first respondent, prima facie,
there is no point to appoint another road transport contractor in
the place of the first respondent.
37.
The next argument of the learned counsel for the
petitioners is that the allocation of quota of rice is not a matter to
be decided in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India and, therefore, the writ petitions at the hands of the first
respondent are not maintainable. In support, the learned counsel
placed reliance upon the decision in the case of S.A. Ngamo
Agency, supra. This Court perused the said decision and find
that in the given facts and circumstances, the decision in S.A.
Ngamo Agency, supra, is not applicable, as the factual matrix of
the issue involved in the said case and in the present case are
entirely different. That apart, in the instant case, there is no point
in deciding the issue of allocation of quota of rice.
38.
The argument of the learned counsel for the first
respondent that the non-sanctioning of the work as contemplated
in the contract till date is a clear case of arbitrary exercise of
power, breach of law and violative of the freedom of trade and
commerce cannot be brushed aside, as the contract between the
FCI and the first respondent is due to expire in December, 2023.
No explanation is forthcoming from the side of the FCI as to why
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 28
the work has not been allotted to the first respondent despite the
route becoming operational.
39.
The learned counsel for the petitioners by relying
upon the decision in the case of National High speed Rail
Corporation Limited v. Montecarlo Limited and another, (2022) 6
SCC 401,submitted that in contract and tenders, the test to be
made are – (i) Whether the process adopted or decision made
by the authority is mala fide or intended to favour some; or
whether the process adopted or decision made is so arbitrary and
irrational that the court can say; “the decision is such that no
responsible authority acting reasonably and in accordance with
relevant law could have reached”?; and (ii) Whether the public
interest is affected? and if the answers to the above questions
are in negative, then there should be no interference under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Adding further, the
learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the FCI acted
bona fide and in accordance with the relevant law. Therefore,
applying the aforesaid decision, the Court cannot interference in
the tender process.
40.
In National High Speed Rail Corporation Limited,
supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 29
“48. Even while entertaining the writ petitioner
and/or granting the stay which ultimately may
delay the execution of the Mega projects, it
must be remembered that it may seriously
impede the execution of the projects of public
importance and disables the State and/or its
agencies/instrumentalities from discharging the
constitutional and legal obligation towards the
citizens. Therefore, the High Courts should be
extremely careful and circumspect in exercise
of its discretion while entertaining such petitions
and/or while granting stay in such matters Even
in a case where the High Court is of the prima
facie opinion that the decision is as such
perverse and/or arbitrary and/or suffers from
mala fides and/or favouritism, while entertaining
such writ petition and/or pass any appropriate
interim order, High Court may put to the writ
petitioner’s notice that in case the petitioner
loses and there is a delay in execution of the
project due to such proceedings initiated by
him/it, he/they may be saddled with the
damages caused for delay in execution of such
projects, which may be due to such frivolous
litigations initiated by him/it. With these words
of caution and advice, we rest the matter there
and leave it to the wisdom of the Court(s)
concerned, which ultimately may look to the
larger public interest and the national interest
involved.”
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 30
41.
As stated supra, the tender period of the first
respondent subsists till December 6, 2023 and the tender
awarded to the first respondent has not been terminated and the
first respondent is also ready to continue their work. Therefore,
the present case is distinguishable from the facts involved in the
aforesaid decision. The question of delaying the execution of the
work does not arise in the instant case, as the FCI has unilaterally
stopped the allocation of work in favour of the first respondent.
Therefore, in the given facts and circumstances of the present
case, this Court is of the prima facie opinion that the decision of
the FCI in appoint ad-hoc contractor is in violation of the terms
and conditions stipulated in the appointment of the first
respondent, which warrants interim orders in favour of the first
respondent.
42.
It is settled law that in issuing the interim order, the
tests to be applied are – (i) whether the petitioner has a prima
facie case; (ii) whether the petitioner would suffer an irreparable
loss of his prayer for interim order is disallowed; and, (iii) whether
the petitioner would suffer an irreparable loss if his prayer for
interim order is disallowed.
The phrases ‘prima facie case’,
‘balance of convenience’ and ‘irreparable loss’, are words of
width and elasticity to meet myriad situations presented by man’s
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 31
ingenuity in given facts and circumstances but they must always
be hedged with a sound exercise of judicial discretion to meet the
ends of justice. A prima facie case implies the probability of the
petitioner obtaining a relief on the material placed before the
Court. Every piece of evidence produced by either party has to
be taken into consideration in deciding the existence of a prima
facie case.
43.
In the light of above, when this Court examines the
case on hand, the materials produced by either side prima facie
would prove that the first respondent is entitled to freedom of
trade and commerce i.e. it is entitled for transportation of food
grains till December, 2023, as the first respondent has neither
been terminated nor has defaulted any terms and conditions of
the contract. If the FCI considered that Jiribam route is expensive
and against the least cost factor, it ought not to have done away
with the grant of contract work for transportation by asking to
deposit huge deposit amount of Rs.2,64,24,045/- and making the
first respondent sitting idle without any work since June, 2022 till
date. But appointing the private respondent on ad-hoc basis with
a condition of depositing hardly Rs.10 lakh and allotting all works
for transportation to the small capacity of godown at Thoubal
itself shows mala fide and arbitrariness on the part of the FCI.
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 32
The admitted case of the parties is that the private respondent
has deposited Rs.10.00 lakh, whereas the first respondent
deposited Rs.2,64,24,045/- as security deposit. Thus, this Court
is of the view that a prima facie case has been made out by the
first respondent.
44.
It is well settled that in order to obtain an interim
order, the party who seeks for grant of such interim order has to
prove that he has made out a prima facie case to go for
trial/enquiry, the balance of convenience is also in his favour and
he will suffer irreparable loss and injury, if interim order is not
granted. But it is equally well settled that when a party fails to
prove prima facie case to go for trial/enquiry, the question of
considering the balance of convenience or irreparable loss and
injury to the party concerned would not be material at all, that is
to say, if that party fails to prove prima facie case to go for
trial/enquiry, it is not open to the Court to grant interim order in
his favour even if, he has made out a case of balance of
convenience being in his favour and would suffer irreparable loss
and injury, if no interim order is granted.
45.
The law is also well settled that there must be some
material on record in support of the claim of legal right put forward
by the person who seeks interlocutory relief and such material
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 33
must either by itself or in the light of material placed before the
Court by the opposite party, satisfy the Court that it could at that
stage and under those circumstances act on it. This is precisely
what can be comprehended by the expression prima facie case.
46.
As stated supra and as prima facie proved by the
first respondent, a prima facie case has been made out by the
first respondent for grant of interim order and the balance of
convenience is also with the first respondent who is continuing
as regular transport contractor of FCI till December, 2023 for the
FSD Thoubal and if the impugned re-tender is finalized in favour
of the private respondent, irreparable loss would be caused to
the first respondent.
47.
For all the reasons stated above, this Court is of the
view that the first respondent has established prima facie case,
balance of convenience and the irreparable loss to get the interim
order. Only after taking note of the aforesaid judicial action, this
Court granted the interim orders directing the respondents in the
writ petitions not to finalize the tender and not to extend the
contract in favour of the private respondent respectively. Since
the interim orders of this Court are based on prima facie
evidentiary proof, there is no valid ground to interfere with the
aforesaid interim orders. Therefore, this Court is of the view that
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 34
the interim orders granted by this Court needs to be made
absolute.
48.
In the result, MC (WP) Nos.398 and 399 of 2022 in
W.P.(C) Nos.819 and 1012 of 2022 are dismissed. The interim
order dated 28.9.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022 and
the interim order dated 30.11.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.1012
of 2022 are made absolute.
49.
It made clear that the opinion expressed by this
Court in this order is only a prima facie opinion for dealing with
only the interim relief prayed and not a view expressed on the
main matter.
50.
Since pleadings are completed, the Registry is
directed to list the main writ petitions for hearing on 11.04.2023,
as the tender awarded in favour of the first respondent is going
to expire on December 6, 2023.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
MC (WP(C)) No.398 of 2022(Ref:- WP(C) No. 819 of 2022) and MC(WP(C)) No. 399
of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review