Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A(J) NO.52 OF 2023
1. Firoz Khan,
Son of late Sadir Khan,
Aged about 52 years, resident of 482 Nimrani,
Near Masjid, P.S.- Bolokwada, Khalkatta Chowk,
District-Khargeone, Madhya Pradesh.
2. Majahar Khan,
Son of Late Sadir Khan,
Aged about, 36 years, resident of 482 Nimrani near,
Masjid, P.S.- Bolokwada, Khalkatta Chowk,
District –Khargeone, Madhya Pradesh.
……Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. S. Majumder, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing
: 24.09.2024
and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 25.09.2024
Whether fit for reporting
: NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
JUDGMENT & ORDER
T. AMARNATH GOUD(J)
This present criminal appeal has been filed
against the impugned Judgment of Conviction and Sentence dated
31.08.2023, passed by the learned Special Judge (NDPS), Khowai
Judicial District, Khowai, in SPECIAL (NDPS) 36 of 2022, whereby the
learned Special Judge (NDPS), Khowai, convicted the appellants for
committing offence, punishable under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) of Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (for short, NDPS Act), and
sentenced them to suffer Rigorous Imprisonment for a term of 15
(fifteen) years and to pay a fine of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh)
only each, in default to undergo further rigorous imprisonment for
another 6(six) months for committing offence punishable under Sections
20(b)(ii)(C) of NDPS Act.
2.
The
prosecution
case
in
brief,
is
that
Sri
Ranabrata Ghosh, PSI of Police of Teliamura police station lodged a
written complaint before the Officer-in-Charge of Teliamura P.S. on
12.05.2022 alleging inter alia that on 11.05.2022 at 22.10 hours, he
along with other police personnel and TSR personnel left the police
station for night mobile and vehicle checking duty at Teliamura P.S.
area. During the said night, they performed vehicle checking duty at
Teliamura market area in front of State Bank of India, Teliamura Branch
on National Highway-08. At about 01.50 hours of the intervening night
of
11.05.2022
and
12.05.2022,
they
saw
one
vehicle
bearing
registration No. MP 09 GH 3492 (6-wheeler truck) was coming from
Agartala side towards Teliamura. On seeing this, the informant along
with his staff intercepted the said vehicle and was about the check the
same. He also alleged that during the inquiry and on asking questions to
the driver and co-driver of the vehicle, it was found that both of them
were nervous. From their gesture and posture, something was found
that was wrong and fishy. Thereafter, the informant informed the matter
to the Officer-in-Charge of Teliamura P.S. and S.D.P.O., Teliamura over
telephone, and on receipt of this information, within a short span of
time, the Officer-in-Charge of Teliamura P.S. and S.D.P.O of Teliamura
arrived at the spot and in their presence and in presence of independent
witnesses under videography, the checking of the said vehicle was
started. During checking total 75 number of packets of suspected dry
ganja wrapped with brown colour sellotape were found concealed in the
stepney wheel in the backside of the vehicle and in one portion of the oil
tank of the vehicle which was kept inside with one portion of tank by
welding. It is also alleged that on query the driver and co-driver i.e. the
appellants herein, could not give any satisfactory reply regarding the
carrying of the suspected contraband items. Thereafter, the informant
and his staffs arranged one digital weighing machine and after weighing,
it was found that total weight of the suspected ganja was 82.7 kgs. In
the written complaint, it is alleged that the informant detained the
appellants and seized suspected ganja, mobile phones, vehicle, and
thereafter the same were handed over to the Officer-in-Charge of
Teliamura P.S.
3.
On receipt of this written complaint, police
registered a case vide Teliamura PS case No. 48 of 2022, dated
12.05.2022 under Section 20(b)(ii)(C)/25/29 of the NDPS Act and
Section 177 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
4.
After registration of the case, the Officer-in-
Charge entrusted the case to S.I. Ranjan Biswas for investigation. After
investigation police filed charge sheet vide C/S No. 65 of 2022 dated
31.07.2022 against the appellants for committing offences punishable
under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act and Section 177 of the
Motor Vehicles Act.
5.
On receipt of the charge sheet, learned Special
Judge registered the case as SPECIAL (NDPS) 36 of 2022. After
compliance of Section 207 Cr.P.C., charge was framed against the
appellants.
6.
To
prove
the
case,
the
prosecution
side
examined as many as 13 (thirteen) witnesses but the appellant's side
did not adduce any witness. After hearing both the sides, Learned
Special Judge (NDPS), Khowai Judicial District, Khowai, vide impugned
judgment dated 31.08.2023 convicted the appellants for committing
offence punishable under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act.
7.
Being
aggrieved
and
dissatisfied
with
the
impugned Judgment of Conviction and Sentence dated 31.08.2023,
passed by the learned Special Judge (NDPS), Khowai Judicial District,
Khowai, in SPECIAL (NDPS) 36 of 2022, the appellants prefer the instant
criminal appeal.
8.
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel assisted by
Mr. S. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellants as well as
Mr. S. Ghosh, learned Addl. P.P., appearing for the State-respondent.
9.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants submit that the prosecution failed to prove the seizure of the
alleged contraband articles. The contraband articles were seized in
presence of two independent witnesses, namely, Sri Biswajit Saha and
Sri Dhirendra Barman, and two police witnesses. Out of these two
independent witnesses, Biswajit Saha was produced as P.W.-2, who
deposed that he put his signature in the seizure list in his shop and not
in the place of occurrence. On a conspectus of the aforesaid witnesses,
it is revealed that seizure of the contraband articles is doubtful. The
learned Court below ignored the same. The learned Court below failed to
appreciate the deposition of the seizing Officer i.e. P.W.-1. PW-1 in his
deposition did not state anything about what he has done with the
seized alleged contraband articles after seizure. During trial, the
prosecution placed a letter dated 12.05.2022 issued by the Officer-inCharge of Teliamura P.S. for handing over the seized articles to District
NDPS Store. Officer-in-Charge of Teliamura PS appeared in the witness
box, but he did not say anything with regard to the letter dated
12.05.2022. It is further submitted that there is no evidence as to how
the Officer-in-Charge of the P.S. got the alleged contraband items and
how he had handed over the alleged seized articles to the District NDPS
Store. There is a clear doubt about the prosecution case. In the instant
case, the prosecution did not produce the Register of the District NDPS
Store and the same has also created serious doubt about the
prosecution case. P.W.-7, the Deputy Director, SFSL stated that he
received the exhibits from the SDPO Teliamura, but the same was the
confirmed by the SDPO. The stepney wheel where it is alleged that the
seized contravened items were concealed and the sellotape with which it
is alleged that those contravened items were wrapped were not
exhibited as evidence by the prosecution to prove the case.
As such,
the prosecution has not been able to prove the case beyond reasonable
doubt.
10.
To prove the lacuna of the prosecution case and
to point out that the prosecution did not produce the evidence to prove
their case beyond reasonable doubt, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants relied upon Para-80,111,114,117,120 and 122
of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment reported in 2008 AIR SCW 5964
titled as Noor Aga Vs. State of Punjab and ors:-
“80. Sections 35 and 54 of the Act, no doubt, raise
presumptions with regard to the culpable mental state on the part of
the accused as also place burden of proof in this behalf on the
accused; but a bare perusal the said provision would clearly show that
presumption would operate in the trial of the accused only in the
event the circumstances contained therein are fully satisfied. An
initial burden exists upon the prosecution and only when it stands
satisfied, the legal burden would shift. Even then, the standard of
proof required for the accused to prove his innocence is not as high as
that of the prosecution. Whereas the standard of proof required to
prove the guilt of accused on the prosecution is "beyond all
reasonable doubt" but it is `preponderance of probability'on the
accused. If the prosecution fails to prove the foundational facts so as
to attract the rigours of Section 35 of the Act, the actus reus which is
possession of contraband by the accused cannot be said to have been
established.
111. The prosecution alleged that 1.4 kgs heroin was
concealed in a cardboard container for carrying grapes and were
recovered from the appellant at Raja Sansi Airport. Essential key
items necessary to prove the same were:
"i) The cardboard carton allegedly used for carrying the heroin to test
the veracity.
ii) The bulk, which establishes the quantity recovered.
iii) The three homogenous samples of five grams each taken from the
bulk amount of heroin, which would be essential in ascertaining
whether the substance that the accused was allegedly in possession
of was, in fact, heroin.
114. Preservance of original wrappers, thus, comes
within the purview of the direction issued in terms of Section 3.1 of
the Standing Order No. 1 of 1989. Contravention of such guidelines
could not be said to be an error which in a case of this nature can
conveniently be overlooked by the Court.
117. Guidelines issued should not only be substantially
complied, but also in a case involving penal proceedings, vis-`-vis a
departmental proceeding, rigours of such guidelines may be insisted
upon. Another important factor which must be borne in mind is as to
whether such directions have been issued in terms of the provisions
of the statute or not. When directions are issued by an authority
having the legal sanction granted therefore, it becomes obligatory on
the part of the subordinate authorities to comply therewith.
122. Concededly neither any such application was filed
nor any such order was passed. Even no notice has been given to the
accused before such alleged destruction.”
11.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Ghosh, learned Addl.
P.P., appearing for the State has placed reliance upon Paras-11 to 16
and 19 of the Judgment of this Court dated 30.07.2024 passed in
Crl.a(J) No.29 of 2023 and contended that any minor procedural
omissions cannot be treated as gross omissions and acquit the accused
persons. The relevant portion of this Judgment is as follows:““11.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Lodh, learned Special
P.P., appearing for the State-respondent countered the
submission of learned Sr. counsel that the materials which were
seized were not produced before the Court stating that the same
is not necessary.
In this regard learned Spl. P.P. relied upon Paras- 14
and 15 of the recent Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court reported
in (2021) 19 SCC 197 titled as Kallu Khan Vs. State of Rajasthan.
The same is given here-in-under:“14. At this stage, the argument advanced by the appellant
regarding non- production of contraband in the court due to which
benefit of doubt ought to be given to the accused, is required to
be adverted to. In State of Rajasthan v. Sahi Ram , this Court held
that when the seizure of material is proved on record and is not
even disputed, the entire contraband material need not be placed
on b record. It is not a case in which the appellant has proved
beyond reasonable doubt that while sending the samples for
forensic tests, seals were not intact or the procedure has been
materially not followed by protecting the seized substance or was
not stored properly, as specified in Mohanlal in which case the
directions were given to be followed on the administrative side.
However, in the facts of the case, the said judgment is not of any
help to the appellant. 15. Similarly, in Than Kunwar v. State of
Haryana 13, this Court observed that if seizure is otherwise
proved and the samples taken from and out of contraband
material were kept intact; the report of the forensic expert shows
potency, nature and quality of contraband material, essential
ingredients constituting offence are made out and the nonproduction of contraband in the court is not fatal. As discussed
above, the appellant has failed to show that the findings recorded
by two courts suffer from any perversity or illegality on the said
issue and warrant interference.”
Learned Spl. P.P. submits that contravened items
were seized properly and an independent seizure witness is also
there who clearly stated that the articles were seized. Learned
Spl. P.P. on the location of the seized contraband within the
vehicle argued that P.W.-1 in the FIR stated that the same was
found in the boot space/dicky of the car and only SDPO said that
when he opened the back door he found the item. But, all other
witnesses deposed a similar location for recovery of the
contraband items from the vehicle. However, all of the witnesses
deposed that the contraband items were seized from inside the
vehicle. So there is no question about the seizure of the
contraband items from the vehicle that the accused-appellant was
driving.
12.
On the point that who sent the seized item to malkhana,
learned Spl. P.P. submits that in the suo-moto FIR registered by
P.W.-1, it is stated that 'on arrival at PS being Malkhana in charge,
I have kept all the seized articles at BLG PS Malkhana vide
Bishalgarh PS M/R No-02/2022 which refers to Bishalgarh PS GD
entry No.30 Dated-16.02.2022‟ and in his deposition as P.W.-1, he
stated that „ the seized contrabands were later on deposited in the
PS Malkhana by the I.O‟. So, there is no contradiction in his
statement. Further, P.W.-10, the officer-in-charge in his
deposition also stated that S.I. Raju Bhowmik was in charge of
Malkhana on the date of the alleged incident. With regard to how
it was sent, learned Spl. P.P. submits that P.W.-9, the SDPO in his
cross-examination stated that on 16.03.2022 he sent the samples
of SFSL, and from the report, it revealed that the items were
forwarded by the SDPO on 10.03.2022. Though there is a minor
discrepancy, the same can be attributed to typographical mistake
as the document itself is endorsed by the competent authority.
13.
On non-compliance of Section 57 of the NDPS Act,
learned Spl. P.P., relied upon para-9 of the Gurbax Singh Vs. State
of Haryana(supra) wherein it is stated that „It is true that
provisions of Sections 52 and 57 are directory. Violation of these
provisions would not ipso facto violate the trial or conviction."
Learned Spl. P.P., further submits that the appellant was arrested
by the I.O., the detailed report was submitted by the I.O., and
inventory was also prepared by the I.O. Some minor wrongs are
there in the proceeding but the same is not fatal.
In this regard, learned Spl. P.P., also referred to
relevant portion of the Judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reported in (2020) 3 SCC 321 titled as Varinder Kumar Vs. State of
Himachal Pradesh. The same is produced here-in-under:7………Sections 52 and 57 of the NDPS Act being
directory in nature are of no avail to the appellant.”
14.
On the point of compliance of Section 42 of the NDPS
Act, learned Spl. P.P. submits that the same is not required in the
context of the case because the police did not receive any prior
information about the contraband item but the same was found
during checking. On the point of R/G form, learned Spl. P.P.
submits that the same was despatch on 16.02.2022 and received
on 16.02.2022. Further, it was endorsed by the Superintendent of
Police Sepahijala District himself.
15.
On the point of inventory not being prepared at the
spot, learned Spl. P.P. submits that though there is some
procedural fault, the same was prepared by I.O. certified by the
Magistrate, and sent to SFSL with seal and cover. As such, there is
no chance of manipulation. Further, the SFSL certified that the
seized item was a contraband item i.e. „ganja‟ not other things.
16.
With regard to the applicability of Section 42 of the Act,
learned Spl. P.P., again referred to paras-12 and 13 of Kallu Khan
Vs. State of Rajasthan(supra) , the same is produced here-inunder:“
“12. After hearing and on perusal of the record and the evidence
brought, it is apparent that on apprehending the accused, while
making search of the motorcycle, 900 gm of smack was seized to
which seizure and sample memos were prepared, as proved by
the departmental witnesses. In the facts of the case at hand,
where the search and seizure was made from the vehicle used, by
way of chance recovery from public road, the provisions of Section
43 of the NDPS Act would apply. In this regard, the guidance may
be taken from the judgments of this Court in Raju and Sk. Sakkar,
However, the recovery made by Pranveer Singh (PW 6) cannot be
doubted in the facts of this case.
13. Now reverting to the contention that the motorcycle seized in
commission of the offence does not belong to the accused,
however seizure of the contraband from the motorcycle cannot be
connected to prove the guilt of the accused. The trial court on
appraisal of the testimony of witnesses, Constable Preetam Singh
(PW 1), Constable Sardar Singh (PW 2). SI Pranveer Singh (PW 6)
and Constable Rajendra Prasad (PW 8), who were members of the
patrolling team and the witnesses of the seizure, proved beyond
reasonable doubt, when they were on patrolling, the appellant
came driving the seized vehicle from the opposite side. On seeing
the police vehicle, he had taken back the motorcycle which he was
riding. However, the police team apprehended and intercepted the
accused and made the search of vehicle, in which the seized
contraband smack was found beneath the seat of the vehicle.
However, while making search at public place, the contraband
was seized from the motorcycle driven by the accused. Thus,
recovery of the contraband from the motorcycle of the appellant
was a chance recovery on a public road. As per Section 43 of the
NDPS Act, any officer of any of the departments, specified in
Section 42, is having power of seizure and arrest of the accused
from a public place, or in transit of any narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance or controlled substance. The said officer
may detain in search any person whom he has reason to believe
that he has committed an offence punishable under the provisions
of the NDPS Act, in case the possession of the narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance appears to be unlawful. The learned
Senior Counsel representing the appellant is unable to show any
deficiency in following the procedure or perversity to the findings
recorded by the trial court, affirmed by the High Court. The
seizure of the motorcycle from him is proved beyond reasonable
doubt, therefore, the question of ownership of vehicle is not
relevant. In the similar set of facts, in Rizwan Khan, this Court
observed that the ownership of this vehicle is immatial. Therefore,
the argument as advanced by the learned Senior counsel is of no
substance and meritless.”
19. It is admitted position that the appellant herein was the driver
of the vehicle from which the contraband items were seized. All
the witnesses who made search, seizure, and arrest i.e. P.W.-1,
Sri Raju Bhomwik, Sub-Inspector of Police, P.W.-3, Additional
SDJM Bishalgarh, P.W.-5, the constable of Police, P.W.-9, the
SDPO, P.W-10, the O/C Bishalgarh P.S, P.W.-11, the I.O., and
P.W.-2, Sri Goutam Deb, the independent witness have
unequivocally stated that the accused-appellant herein was the
driver of the vehicle at the time of the search and contraband
items were seized from the vehicle which was in possession of the
accused-appellant. On the point of non-compliance of Sections 52
and 57 of the Act, this Court considering the principle given by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the Gurbax Singh Vs. State of
Haryana(supra) and Varinder Kumar Vs. State of Himachal
Pradesh is convinced with the submission of learned Spl. P.P.
Further, the evidence of P.W.-6, Sri Suman Kumar Chakraborty,
Deputy Director (Chemistry Division) TSFSL read with the SFSL
report reveals that all the samples were sealed with the
impression of Magistrate. It is evident that the samples were
drawn in the presence of the Magistrate and sent to the SFSL and
as per the report, the samples were positive for the presence of
'Ganja‟. This Court aligns with the submission of the learned Spl.
P.P., that though there is some minor procedural fault, but, the
same is not fatal and prosecution has been able to prove that the
accused-appellant herein on 16.02.2022 was found in conscious
possession of 70 kgs of dry „Ganja‟ in 5 numbers of plastic sacks
which he was transporting in the said vehicle. Further, this Court
is of the opinion that as the sacks containing contraband items
were multiple and the same could have been hidden in multiple
locations inside the car, it explains the minor discrepancy among
the deposition of the witnesses on the location of the contraband
item inside the vehicle. However, the deposition of the witnesses
are unequivocally clear that the said contraband items were found
inside the crime vehicle. Furthermore, the Judgments as cited by
the learned Spl. P.P. supports and strengthens the case of the
prosecution. In the light of the above discussion and evidence,
this Court is of the opinion that the Judgments as cited by the
learned Sr. counsel appearing for the convict-appellant are not
relevant to the facts of this case.”
12.
Heard and perused the evidence on record.
13.
Before delving into the conclusion let us examine
some important witnesses of this case.
14.
P.W-1 i.e., PSI- Ranabrata Ghosh deposed in the
examination-in-chief that on 11.05.2022 when he was posted at
Teliamura P.S on that day at around 22.10 hours, he along with
Prasenjit Das and other police personnel of the P.S went for a vehicle
checking duty and at around 01.50 hours they noticed one vehicle
bearing No. MP-09-GH-3492 which was coming from Agartala towards
Teliamura. He gave signal to stop the vehicle and accordingly, the driver
of the vehicle, namely, Firoz Khan stopped the vehicle and on
questioning the driver they found him nervous and became suspicious.
Thereafter, he called SDPO, Teliamura P.S and O.C Teliamura P.S on the
spot. In the presence of O.C Teliamura P.S and SDPO Teliamura on
opening the fuel tank and the stepney wheel he and his team found 75
numbers of suspected ganja packets which weighed 82.7 kgs. He
detained the driver and co-driver Firoz Khan and Majahar Khan and
seized the vehicle along with contraband items and mobile from the
possession of the accused persons in presence of SDPO Sonacharan
Jamatia. He seized the alleged contraband and the items and lodged a
suo-moto complaint before O.C Teliamura P.S. The complaint petition is
identified by the witness in two pages and is marked as Exbt. 1 (series)
and the signature of P.W-1 identified in the complaint petition is marked
as Exbt.1/1. The seizure list is also prepared by P.W-1 in the presence of
seizure list witnesses along with his signature which after identification
by the witness is marked as Exbt.2 and 2/ 1. This witness also identified
both the accused i.e., the driver Firoz Khan and co-driver Majahar Khan
before the Court.
15.
PW-2,
Sri.Biswajit
Saha
deposed
in
the
examination in chief that approximately 6 to 7 months back when he
was coming from his house at about 03.00 hours in front of SBI Bank,
near Teliamura P.S and he being the owner of a tea stall opposite to SBI
Bank, noticed police personnel checking one vehicle and ganja packets
were recovered from the fuel tank and the wheel of the vehicle. The
police personnel took his signature and he signed as a seizure list
witness and his signature after identification is marked as Exbt.2/2.
16.
P.W-7, Sri Suman Chakraborty stated in the
examination in chief that on 24.05.2022 their office received one sealed
packet from SDPO Teliamura vide forwarding memo No. 1605 dated
22.05.2022 containing exhibits in connection with Teliamura P.S Case
No.2022/TLM/048 which was received through special messenger
constable Sachindra Jamatia of Teliamura P.S and the exhibits were
endorsed to him for examination and opinion. This witness further
deposed that the exhibits were received in a yellow paper envelope
sealed with seven wax seals with the impression SDPO Teliamura. The
packets also bear case reference number, DR number, address of the
addressee along with the seal and signature of the forwarding authority.
Inside the sealed packets one court sealed yellow colored envelope
marked as Y along with case reference sample drawing certificate by J.M
1" Class, Khowai and S.I of Police Teliamura P.S was found. Inside it
was found one heat-sealed transparent poly packet containing some
greenish brown plant materials with fruiting/ flowering tops, seeds etc.,
which is subsequently marked in the laboratory as CHEM/244/22 (Y)
weighing 37 gms. The exhibits were examined by this witness from
23.06.2022 to 27.06.2022 by the methods mentioned in the report and
on examination the exhibits were found positive for the presence of
ganja (cannabis). The remnants of the exhibits have been returned
separately under sealed cover. This witness prepared the report in 02
(two) pages which is typed in his office computer vide report No.SFSL
747/22/CHEM/244/22 dated 27.06.2022 and was forwarded from the
office of the director of TSFSL vide despatch No. 5781 dated 29.06.2022
and the report along with the remnants has been forwarded to SDPO
Teliamura by this witness as Director-in-Charge. The report in 02 (two)
pages is identified by this witness along with his signature. The said
report is marked as Exbt. 5 (series) and the signature is marked as
Exbt.5/1, and 5/2 respectively. The forwarding report which was
forwarded by this witness along with his signature and identified by the
witness and is marked as Exbt.6 and Exbt.6/1. The remnants that were
returned to SDPO Teliamura in sealed cover bearing No.5781 dated
29.06.2022 is identified by the witness and is marked as Exbt. MO-1 and
the signature of the witness found in the sealed cover is marked as
Exbt. B.
17.
P.W-10, Sri Sonacharan Jamatia deposed in the
examination-in-chief that on 12.05.2022 while he was posted as SDPO
Teliamura P.5 between the intervening night of 11.05.2022 and
12.05.2022 at around 2:00 o'clock in the night he was informed by P.W1 that the vehicle was detained in front of SBI Bank Teliamura Branch
bearing No.MP-09-GH-3492 (six-wheeler truck). He immediately reached
the spot and deposed that the vehicle was checked in is presence and
dry ganja was recovered from the stepney tyre of the vehicle and the oil
tanker amounting to 75 packets of ganja which was recovered packed in
yellow colored cello tape. The said recovered ganja weighed 82.7 kgs.
According to this witness, the vehicle along with the documents of the
vehicle including driving license of the driver two numbers of Mobile
Phone and the documents of the vehicle were seized in his presence.
Two persons who were detained are named as Firoz Khan and Majahar
Khan. The witness identified his signature in the seizure list which is
marked as Exbt. 2/5. The report of the SFSL was forwarded by this
witness to the I.0 through O.C Teliamura P.S for taking necessary action
and he has signed in the first page of the report which has been
forwarded and his signature after identification is marked as Exbt. 6/2.
This witness further deposed that he has given his signature in
03(three) places of the two packets bearing MR No.170/2022 which is
already marked as MO-1. The signature of this witness in three places of
the packets is identified by the witness and is marked as Exbt.M-1
(series). The witness also identified both the accused persons.
18.
P.W-11, Sri Subimal Barman deposed in the
examination-in-chief that on 12.05.2022 he was posted as O.C
Teliamura P.S and on that date, he had registered one case bearing No.
TLM P.S Case No.48 of 2022 under section 20 (b) (ii) (C)/25/29 of NDPS
Act and the case was registered on the basis of suo moto complaint by
P.W-1 and he has identified his signature in the complaint petition which
is marked as Exbt.1/2. This witness also filled up the printed F.I.R form
in his own handwriting bearing his signature which is identified by the
witness and is marked as Exbt. 7 and Exbt. 7/1 and he endorsed the
case to S.I Ranjan Biswas for investigation. This witness has also
prepared the inventory and the said inventory is identified by the
witness along with his signature which is marked as Exbt.8 and Exbt.
8/1 respectively. This witness further deposed that he has informed
about the matter to the Superintendent of Police (C/S) Khowai with
reference to Teliamura P.S GDE No. 46 dated 12.05.2022 and with
reference to Teliamura P.S case No.2022 /TLM/048 dated 12.05.2022
under section 20 (b) (ii) (C) /25/29 of NDPS Act and the said
information was given to SP (C/S) Khowai. The witness further deposed
that he has sent the contraband items to the NDPS Godown and further
made a prayer for sending of seized NDPS Articles to keep in the District
NDPS Store for safe custody. The prayer given by this witness is marked
as Exbt.9 as a whole after identification and the signature is also marked
as Exbt. 9/1.
19.
P.W-12, Sri Ranjan Biswas (I.O. of this case)
deposed in the examination-in-chief that on 12.05.2022 while he was
posted at Teliamura P.S, on that date, O.C Teliamura endorsed this case
to him for investigation and he started the investigation by recording the
statement of the complainant and arrested the accused persons Firoz
Khan and Majahar Khan and also visited the P.O and prepared the handsketch map of the PO along with the separate index. The hand-sketch
map of the PO is identified by this witness is marked as Exbt.10 and is
index is also marked as Exbt.11. This witness also recorded the
statement of other witnesses under section 161 of Cr.P.C and sent the
sample
to
the
SFSL
Narshingarh
and
collected
the
same
after
examination through SDPO Teliamura. The witness further deposed that
under Section 67 of NDPS Act a notice was issued to the owner of the
alleged vehicle and after receiving the notice, the owner of the vehicle
approached through his son and he also found the involvement of
another accused Amjad Khan and arrested him. This witness further
deposed that in the Court when the sample was drawn he along with
O.C. P.S was present and he has withdrawn the seized contraband from
the NDPS Go-down. According to this witness, the entire seizure was
videographed and he had collected the DVD Cassette and the certificate
under section 65b of the Evidence Act with regard to electronics files
enclosed in the DVD. The signature in the DVD cassette is identified by
the witness which is marked as Exbt.M-1. This witness further deposed
that he has submitted GDE extract in connection with Teliamura P.S GDE
No. 46 dated 11.05.2022 and which after identification by the witness is
marked as Exbt.12. In the examination-in-chief this witness admitted
that due to inadvertence and mistake, he have not submitted some
documents in the judicial docket of the court though the said documents
are in the police dockets being in Page No. 36,38, 56 and 57. The
documents are:(1) Receipt copy of the seized contrabands which has been stored in the
NDPS Godown,
(II) Written information given to the Higher Authority i.e., S.P Khowai
after the seizure which was given by then O.C P.S. Subimal Barman,
(III) Prayer to withdraw the deposited contraband items and after
sampling the remaining deposit in connection with MR-266 dated
12.05.2022,
This witness also stated that inadvertently he has
not cited Godown in charge as a witness of this case. The witness
identified the accused persons before the court. The witness further
deposed that the list of samples drawn from the seized material in
connection with TLM P.S Case No. 022/TLM/048 dated 12.05.2022 which
was prepared by him and the sample was drawn on 19.05.2022. The
sample drawn memo is identified by the witness along with his signature
which is marked as Exbt.13 and Exbt.13/1. The witness further deposed
that the sample was drawn in the court in an envelope bearing No.MR
170/2022 bears his signature along with the signature of Judicial
magistrate 1" Class dated 19.05.2022 which is identified by the witness
and is marked as Exbt. 14. This witness further deposed that he has
given a prayer to produce the deposited NDPS articles for the purpose of
drawing of sample. The said prayer along with his signature is identified
by the witness and is marked as Exbt.16 as a whole and Exbt.16/1.
According to this witness, the deposited NDPS article were produced as
per the order of the court and after drawing of sample he has given a
prayer for keeping the remaining stock of NDPS article in the safe
custody and the said prayer along with his signature is identified by the
witness which is marked as Exbt.17 as whole and Exbt.17/1. After
completion of the investigation, he has submitted a charge-sheet against
the accused persons namely Firoz Khan, Majahar Khan and Amjad Khan
vide C.S No. 65/22 dated 31.07.2022 under section 20 (b) (ii) (c)/29 of
the NDPS Act, 1985 against Firoz Khan, Majahar Khan and Amjad Khan.
The witness also identified the accused person before the court.
20.
It is seen from the record that the contraband
items were seized properly and the independent witness has also clearly
stated that the contraband articles were seized. All the witnesses
including the independent witness i.e. P.W.-2 in his deposition stated
that he noticed contraband item were seized from the fuel tank and the
wheel of the vehicle. It is also the admitted position that the appellants
herein were the driver and co-driver of that vehicle which was carrying
those contraband items. All the witnesses who made search, seizure,
and arrest identified that the appellants herein who were the driver and
co-driver of the involved vehicle. At the time of the search, the
contraband items were seized from the vehicle which was in the
possession of the appellants. This Court aligns with the submission of
the learned Addl. P.P. that any minor procedural omissions cannot be
treated as a gross omission and acquit the accused persons as because
the contraband items were recovered from the vehicle which has been
customized specifically for smuggling. Those items were recovered from
the Stepney tyre and modified petrol tank (by way of wielding) of the
said vehicle which was driven by the accused persons herein. As per the
evidence of P.W.-1, the eye witness i.e. P.W.-2, P.W.-10 i.e., the
investigating officer and the seizure list i.e. Exbt. No.2 to 2/5, this is a
case where such huge quantity of contraband items i.e. 82.7 kg of Ganja
was seized from the vehicle which is modified and has been made
customized for smuggling. It appears that it is an organized crime where
this Court has to come down heavily against such narcotic dealers who
are affecting the youths in terms of their career and health. Moreover,
the Judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme as cited by the learned counsel
appearing for the appellants to support his case is not relevant to the
facts of this case.
21.
In view of the above submission made, this
present appeal stands dismissed, and the impugned Judgment and
Order dated 31.08.2023 as passed by the learned Sessions Court stands
confirmed.
As
a
sequel,
stay
if
any
stands
vacated.
Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
Send down the LCRs.
B. PALIT, J
Suhanjit
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SINGHA
2024.09.27 12:39:41
SUHANJIT SINGHA Date:
+05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review