Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.K.JAYASANKARAN NAMBIAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
THURSDAY, THE 9TH DAY OF JANUARY 2025 / 19TH POUSHA, 1946
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED19.11.2024
IN WP(C) NO.40431 OF
2024 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT(S)/WRIT PETITIONER :
FEDERAL HOUSE CONSTRUCTION CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD.,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, REGN. NO.E -962,
FEDERAL GARDENS, PULINCHODU, ALUVA, PIN - 683573
BY ADVS.
JOHN NELLIMALA SARAI
ISAC T.PAUL
RESPONDENT(S)/RESPONDENT 1:
THE TAHSILDAR,
KARUMALLOOR VILLAGE, PARAVUR TALUK,
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN - 683513
THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER,
KB JACOB ROAD, FORT KOCHI, KOCHI,
KERALA, PIN - 682001
THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, COLLECTORATE/CIVIL STATION,
KAKKANAD P.O., ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682020
ADV. SMT. RESMITHA RAMACHANDRAN, GP
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 19.12.2024,
THE COURT ON 09.01.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
“C.R”
JUDGMENT
Easwaran S., J
This intra court appeal is preferred by the petitioner aggrieved
by the dismissal of the Writ Petition No.40431 of 2024. We are called
upon
to
decide
whether
a
multi
storied
residential
complex
constructed out of the funds of a group of persons is liable to be taxed
against the owner/person who constructed it or is against the
individual members for whose benefit the said flat is constructed.
2. Succinctly, the brief facts for disposal of the appeal are as
follows:
2.1 The appellant is a house construction society registered
under the provisions of Section 7 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies
Act, 1969. The appellant society purchased the land on behalf of its
members for construction of a multi-storied apartment complex in
Survey No.92/8-3, 8-5, 8-1 and 8-2 located within the Karumalloor
Village, Paravur Taluk. On 11.1.2020, the Occupancy Certificate was
issued by the Karumalloor Panchayath. The appellant states that the
society had constructed the said building for its members and it ought
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
to have been assessed with the tax under the applicable law and not
as a single unit. Although the ownership still vests with the society,
the 120 individual apartments of the building are in possession of its
individual members and hence the members individually are liable to
pay the one time tax under the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975.
2.2.
On 25.1.2021, the Tahsildar assessed the building as a
whole and an amount Rs.39,82,800/- was demanded from the
petitioner as tax. At the time of levy, the society could not execute
individual sale deeds in favour of 120 members since there was some
dispute regarding the quantum of stamp duty to be paid in respect of
sale deeds. The appellant contends that the flats are allotted as per
120 allotment letters and, for which, 120 separate sale agreements
have been executed and that separate electricity connections for 120
flats are taken.
2.3. Aggrieved by the order of assessment, an appeal dated
22.03.2021 was preferred by the appellant which came to be
dismissed on 25.7.2023. It is contended that, while dismissing the
appeal, the Revenue Divisional Officer (R.D.O.) had apparently relied
on a report of the Tahsildar dated 4.5.2022. Aggrieved by the
dismissal of the appeal by the R.D.O., the society preferred a Revision
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
Petition under Section 13 of the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975 which
came to be dismissed by Ext.P7 order. Challenging Ext.P7 order, the
petitioner approached the writ court for a declaration that the
petitioner is not liable to be assessed under the provisions of the
Kerala Building Tax Act and it is the individual owners who are liable
to be taxed. The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition in
limine without even calling upon the State to answer the various
contentions raised in the writ petition. Thus, the appellant is in appeal
before us.
3.
Heard Smt. John Nellimala Sarai, the learned counsel
appearing for the appellant and Smt. Resmitha Ramachandran, the
learned Government Pleader appearing on behalf of the State.
4. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted
that in the light of the Explanation 2 to Section 2(e) of the Kerala
Building Tax Act, 1975, where a building consists of different
apartments or flats owned by different persons and the cost of
construction of the building was met by all such persons jointly, each
such apartments or flat shall be treated as a separate unit. While
issuing the order of assessment, the assessing authority has not taken
into consideration the Explanation 2 to Section 2(e) of the Act and
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
therefore the assessment becomes bad. The learned counsel further
pointed out that, going by the definition of owner under Section 2(i),
the “owner” includes a person who for the time being is receiving, or
is entitled to receive, the rent of any building, whether on his own
account or on account of himself and others. The appellant, which is a
society formed for the purpose of the benefit of the retired officers of
the Federal Bank, cannot, for the purpose of assessment under the
provisions of the Kerala Building Tax Act, be termed as an owner
because, the entire cost of construction has been borne out by the 120
individual members in whose favour, the letter of allotment has been
issued and therefore cannot be assessed as a single unit. The learned
counsel thus submitted that the findings rendered by the learned
Single Judge is unsustainable and that the judgment has been
rendered without referring to the settled position of law.
5.
On the other hand, the learned Government Pleader
supported the order of assessment and contended that in so far as the
ownership of the building has not been transferred, the appellant
continues to be the owner of the building which entitles the 1 st
respondent to assess the building as a single unit.
6. We have considered the rival submissions raised across the
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
Bar.
7. When we examine the scheme of the taxing statute namely,
Kerala Building Tax Act, we find that the definition of an owner is an
inclusive definition. Section 2(i) of the Kerala Building Tax Act is
extracted hereunder :
(i) “owner” includes a person who for the time being is receiving,
or is entitled to receive, the rent of any building, whether on his
own account or on account of himself and others or as an agent,
trustee, guardian or receiver for any other person or who should
so received the rent or be entitled to receive it if the building or
part thereof were let to a tenant.
8.
Therefore, in order to find out the real definition of the
owner, we have to necessarily fall back on the general law. Since the
definition of owner under the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975 is an
inclusive definition, the same will not come to the aid of the appellant.
Admittedly, the appellant still continues to be the owner of the
property. It is immaterial as to whether the flats were constructed by
pooling resources from 120 members in whose name 120 allotment
letters have been issued by the appellant society. The fact remains
that the title of the land vests with the appellant and the undivided
share together with the respective flats is yet to be assigned in the
name of 120 individuals. The mere fact that the flats were constructed
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
by the appellant which is preceded by an agreement of sale and
agreement of construction, that by itself will not confer title on the
120 allottees in whose favour the respective flats were allotted.
9. As stated earlier, since the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975,
does not define the word transfer, we therefore have necessarily to
fall back on the definition of ‘Transfer’ under Section 5 of the Transfer
of Property Act which reads as under:
"Transfer of property" defined. In the following sections
"transfer of property" means an act by which a living person
conveys property, in present or in future, to one or more
other living persons, or to himself and one or more other
living persons; and "to transfer property" is to perform such
act. In this section "living person" includes a company or
association or body of individuals, whether incorporated or
not, but nothing herein contained shall affect any law for
the time being in force relating to transfer of property to or
by companies, associations or bodies of individuals.”
10. A reading of Section 5 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
shows that the transfer of property must take place by an act in
present or in future to one or more living persons. Section 17 of the
Registration Act, 1908 mandates that any transfer of interest
exceeding a value of Rs.100/- must be done by a registered document.
11. Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 defines the
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
sale. Section 54 reads as under:
“ 54. “Sale" defined.- "Sale" is a transfer of ownership in
exchange for a price paid or promised or part-paid and partpromised.
Sale how made.-
Such transfer, in the case of tangible
immovable property of the value of one hundred rupees and
upwards, or in the case of a reversion or other intangible
thing, can be made only by a registered instrument.
In the case of tangible immovable property of a value less
than one hundred rupees, such transfer may be made either
by a registered instrument or by delivery of the property.
Delivery of tangible immovable property takes place when
the seller places the buyer, or such person as he directs, in
possession of the property.
Contract for sale. - A contract for the sale of immovable
property is a contract that a sale of such property shall take
place on terms settled between the parties.
It does not, of itself, create any interest in or charge on such
property.”
12.
Read cumulatively with Section 54 of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882 and Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908, the
irresistible conclusion is that the transfer cannot take place unless a
registered document is executed. When the statute itself provides that
a contract of sale by itself will not create any interest over the
property, we fail to understand as to how the appellant could contend
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
that by mere issuance of allotment letters to 120 individual members,
the appellant is divested of the title over the property and individual
flats.
13. It may be true as the appellant contends that the liability to
pay tax on assessment of a single unit may be less compared to the
assessment of the whole building as a unit.
However, we cannot
remain oblivious of the fact that so long as the appellant continues to
be the owner of the property and the taxable event being the
completion of the building and also in the absence of any registered
document evidencing conveyance of the undivided share along with
the individual flats in favour of 120 allottees before the occurrence of
the taxable event, the appellant cannot escape from the liability to
pay tax.
14.
We also noticed that a similar issue had come
up for
consideration before a learned Singe Bench of this Court in Hi Lite
Realtors (India) LLP. v. Revenue Divisional Officer [2018 (3) KLT 237].
It was concluded by the learned Single Judge that the mere
agreement of sale will not confer any title on the allotees and that the
taxable event being the completion of the building, the owner at the
time of the taxable event has to necessarily bear the liability to pay
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
tax under the provisions of the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975. On a
close scrutiny of various statutory provisions and the reasoning given
by the learned Single Judge, we are of the view that the learned
Single Judge, in the decision above, has rightly deciphered the point
of law and decided the case correctly.
15.
In Sanjay Sharma Vs Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd and Ors
{Civil Appeal 14284/2024 [SLP No 330/2017]}decided on 10-12-2024,
the Supreme Court reiterated the scope of Section 54 of the Transfer
of Property Act, 1882 and held that registration of the sale deed is
essential to complete and validate the transfer and until the
registration is effected, the ownership is not transferred.
16. Coming back to the facts of this case, the learned Single
Judge, while rendering the impugned judgment, has specifically taken
note of the fact that, on the date of completion of the building and the
date on which the occupancy certificate was issued for the building,
the appellant remained to be the owner of the land and building. The
learned Single Judge also found that the Explanation 2 to Section 2(e)
of the Act cannot be interpreted exclusively with reference to the
definition of owner under Section 2(i) of the Act.
17. We find that even today, the appellant remains as the owner
WA NO. 2068 OF 2024
2024:KER:98288
of the property as well as the 120 flats which were constructed by
them. We are not impressed with the argument of the learned counsel
for the appellant and find that merely because 120 allotment letters
were issued to the individual allottees, the appellant will not be
divested of the title over the property unless and until registered
conveyance is executed. Therefore, we are of the considered view that
the decision of the learned Single Judge does not call for any
interference. Consequently, we find that the appeal lacks merit and
hence the same is dismissed. No order as to costs.
Sd/-
Dr. A.K. Jayasankaran Nambiar
Judge
Sd/-
Easwaran S.
Judge
NS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review