Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 06
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No.: CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
Reserved on: 19.02.2026
Pronounced on: 12.03.2026
Uploaded on: 12.03.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced:- Full
Fazal Hussain S/o Sh. Noor Mohd.
R/o Gundi, Tehsil Budhal, District
Rajouri
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Ms. Deepika Mahajan, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Atharav Mahajan, Advocate
vs
.…. Respondent(s)
State of Jammu and Kashmir
Through: Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Per Sanjay Parihar ‘J’
1. The present appeal has been preferred by the appellant challenging the
judgment of conviction and order of sentence passed by the learned Trial
Court whereby the appellant has been convicted for the offence punishable
under Section 302 of the Ranbir Penal Code and sentenced to undergo
imprisonment for life along with a fine of ₹5,000/-The appellant has
questioned the legality and correctness of the impugned judgment primarily
on the ground that the conviction has been recorded mainly on the basis of
the testimony of PW-2 Shah Begum, the minor daughter of the deceased,
who has been projected as the sole eye-witness to the occurrence. It is
contended that the Trial Court misdirected itself in placing reliance upon
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
the testimony of a child witness without properly appreciating the
contradictions appearing in her statement and without testing her testimony
against the surrounding circumstances of the case.
2. The prosecution case, in brief, is that on 30.05.2002 at about 06:45 a.m.,
PW-1 Bagh Hussain produced the injured Wazir Mohammad in an
unconscious condition and informed that the deceased and the appellant
were sharing a common room at Roop Nagar, Jammu. According to the
prosecution, the appellant suspected that the deceased had developed illicit
relations with his wife and on that account, bitterness had arisen between
the two. On the date of occurrence, at about 06:00 a.m., the appellant
allegedly assaulted the deceased with a “gainti”, causing grievous head
injuries which rendered him unconscious. The information was recorded at
Police Post Chinore vide DD No. 24 dated 30.05.2002 which ultimately led
to registration of FIR under Section 307 RPC. The injured was taken to
GMC Jammu for treatment. During investigation the appellant was arrested
and is stated to have made a disclosure statement leading to the recovery of
the alleged weapon of offence, namely a gainti, from the bushes near the
place of occurrence. The deceased later succumbed to the injuries in the
hospital and consequently the offence was converted into one under Section
302 RPC, whereafter the appellant came to be charge-sheeted and tried.
3. In order to prove its case, the prosecution examined several witnesses
including PW-1 Bagh Hussain, PW-2 Shah Begum, the minor daughter of
the deceased, PW-3 Baldev Raj (Constable), PW-4 Sudesh Kumar, PW-5
Rattan Singh, PW-6 Khan Mohammad, PW-7 Zakir Hussain, PW-8 Piyare
Lal, PW-9 Jagbir Singh (Naib Tehsildar), PW-10 Farooq Iqbal (Patwari
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
Halqa), PW-11 Dr. Manju Tickoo and PW-14 Sub-Inspector Bhupinder
Singh, the Investigating Officer of the case. After the closure of the
prosecution evidence, the appellant was examined under Section 342 RPC
to explain the incriminating circumstances appearing against him. The
appellant denied the prosecution case in its entirety and pleaded that he had
never shared a common room with the deceased. He also denied having any
dispute with the deceased relating to accounts and asserted that he had
vacated the room much prior to his arrest and had been residing with his
wife at Roop Nagar. The appellant also denied making any disclosure
statement leading to the recovery of the alleged weapon of offence and
claimed that he had been falsely implicated.
4. The learned Trial Court, upon appreciation of the evidence on record,
concluded that the deceased had suffered a homicidal death and that the
weapon of offence was a gainti. The Court relied upon the disclosure
statement allegedly made by the appellant and the recovery of the said
weapon at his instance. The Trial Court further placed considerable reliance
upon the testimony of PW-2 Shah Begum and held that she was a natural
witness who had no reason to falsely implicate the appellant. The Court
also observed that minor inconsistencies appearing in her testimony did not
affect the core of the prosecution case and, on that basis, the appellant was
found guilty and convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302
RPC.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has contended that the
conviction recorded by the Trial Court is unsustainable in law as the entire
prosecution case rests upon the testimony of a child witness which, in the
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
absence of corroboration, cannot safely be relied upon. It is further
submitted that the statement of PW-2 was recorded after a considerable
lapse of time and therefore the possibility of tutoring cannot be ruled out. It
is also argued that the testimony of PW-2 suffers from material
contradictions with her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and
that the alleged recovery of the weapon of offence is doubtful as the
independent witnesses to the recovery have not supported the prosecution
case. It is also urged that the prosecution has failed to prove the alleged
motive of illicit relations between the deceased and the wife of the
appellant.
6. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent has supported the
judgment of conviction and submitted that merely because PW-2 is a child
witness, her testimony cannot be discarded if it inspires confidence.
According to the respondent, the Trial Court has rightly appreciated the
evidence on record and has correctly relied upon the testimony of PW-2
which clearly establishes the involvement of the appellant in the
commission of the offence.
7. Before examining the evidence on record, it would be appropriate to notice
the settled legal position regarding the evidentiary value of the testimony of
a child witness. In Rameshwar vs. State of Rajasthan AIR 1952 SC 54, the
Supreme Court held that the testimony of a child witness cannot be rejected
merely on the ground of age, although as a rule of prudence courts
generally seek corroboration. The same principle was reiterated in Panchhi
vs. State of U.P 1998 7 SCC 177, where it was observed that the evidence
of a child witness must be scrutinized carefully as children are susceptible
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
to tutoring. Similarly, in Dattu Ramrao Sakhare vs. State of Maharashtra
1997 5 SCC 341, the Supreme Court held that a child witness, if found
competent and reliable, can form the basis of conviction, but the court must
be satisfied that the testimony is free from tutoring. The principle was again
reiterated in State of U.P. v. Krishna Master AIR 2010 SC 3071, wherein it
was held that the testimony of a child witness should be evaluated with
caution and careful scrutiny.
8. Another aspect which assumes importance in the present case relates to the
testimony of witnesses who have not supported the prosecution case. The
legal position regarding hostile witnesses is also well settled. In Sat Paul v.
Delhi Administration AIR 1976 SC 294, the Supreme Court held that the
evidence of a hostile witness is not to be discarded in its entirety and the
court can rely upon that part of the testimony which is found to be credible.
In Koli LakhmanbhaiChanabhai vs. State of Gujarat AIR 2000 SC 210, it
was reiterated that even if a witness is declared hostile, the portion of his
testimony which supports the prosecution case may still be relied upon.
However, in State of Rajasthan v. BhawaniCr Appeal no. 421 of
1996(D.O.D 31.07.2003), the Supreme Court observed that where material
witnesses turn hostile and their earlier statements are not properly proved,
the prosecution case becomes doubtful.
9. In the present case, PW-1 Bagh Hussain, who had taken the injured to the
hospital and was the first person present at the scene of occurrence, has not
supported the prosecution case and was declared hostile. Similarly, the
independent witnesses to the alleged recovery of the weapon of offence,
namely PW-4 Sudesh Kumar and PW-5 Rattan Singh, have also not
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
supported the prosecution case regarding the disclosure statement and
recovery of the gainti. Thus, the entire prosecution case substantially hinges
upon the testimony of PW-2 Shah Begum, the minor daughter of the
deceased.
10. Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties and perusing the record of the
case, the core question that arises for consideration is whether the
prosecution has been able to establish the guilt of the appellant beyond
reasonable doubt. The entire edifice of the prosecution case substantially
rests upon the testimony of PW-2 Shah Begum, the minor daughter of the
deceased, who has been projected as the sole eye-witness to the occurrence.
Therefore, the reliability, credibility and evidentiary worth of her testimony
assume pivotal importance for determination of the present appeal.
11. Examining the testimony of PW-2 Shah Begum in the light of the aforesaid
principles, it is noticed that her version does not find adequate
corroboration from other material witnesses. PW-1 Bagh Hussain, who had
accompanied the deceased and was the first person to remove the injured to
the hospital, has not supported the prosecution case and was declared
hostile. His testimony, far from strengthening the prosecution case, merely
establishes that the deceased was found lying injured and that he had taken
him to the hospital. He categorically denied having witnessed the appellant
assaulting the deceased. Thus, the prosecution has been deprived of an
important link in the chain of events which could have otherwise lent
assurance to the version of the alleged eye-witness.
12. Equally significant is the circumstance that the independent witnesses
associated with the alleged recovery of the weapon of offence have also not
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
supported the prosecution. PW-4 Sudesh Kumar and PW-5 Rattan Singh,
who were cited as witnesses to the disclosure statement and recovery of the
gainti, have not affirmed the prosecution version regarding such recovery.
In fact, the testimony of PW-5 suggests that the alleged weapon was lying
in the police station and that the documents relating to its seizure were
prepared there. In these circumstances, the recovery of the weapon of
offence becomes highly doubtful and does not inspire confidence.
13. The legal position regarding hostile witnesses is well settled. In Sat Paul
(supra) the Supreme Court held that the testimony of a hostile witness is not
to be rejected in toto and the Court may rely upon that part of the testimony
which is found to be credible. However, in the present case, the portions of
testimony of the hostile witnesses which remain on record do not materially
advance the prosecution case. On the contrary, their statements create doubt
regarding the manner in which the investigation was conducted and the
circumstances under which the alleged recovery was effected.
14. Another aspect which weakens the prosecution case is the failure to
establish the alleged motive. The prosecution had sought to attribute motive
to the appellant on the ground that he suspected the deceased of having
illicit relations with his wife. However, none of the witnesses examined by
the prosecution have substantiated this allegation. Even PW-1 Bagh
Hussain, who was acquainted with both the parties, has not stated anything
suggestive of such relationship. In the absence of any cogent material
establishing motive, the prosecution case loses an important supporting
circumstance, particularly when the case rests upon the testimony of a
single witness.
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
15. Further scrutiny of the testimony of PW-2 Shah Begum reveals certain
material discrepancies between her statement recorded during investigation
under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and her deposition before the Court. In her
earlier statement she had stated that she along with her father had gone to
the appellant for settlement of accounts and that the appellant assaulted the
deceased at that time. However, in her deposition before the Court she
introduced a different version by stating that the deceased was washing
clothes outside the room when the appellant came from behind and
assaulted him with a gainti. This variation is not merely a minor
inconsistency but goes to the root of the prosecution story regarding the
manner in which the occurrence had taken place.
16. It is well settled that while minor discrepancies in the testimony of
witnesses may not affect the prosecution case, contradictions which
materially alter the prosecution version cannot be lightly ignored. In State
of Rajasthan v. Bhawani (supra), the Supreme Court observed that when
material contradictions appear in the testimony of crucial witnesses and
such contradictions remain unexplained, the Court must exercise caution in
placing reliance upon such evidence.
17. The medical evidence, though indicating that the death of the deceased was
homicidal, does not conclusively connect the appellant with the
commission of the offence. The medical expert has opined that the injuries
could have been caused by a blunt object and could also occur by fall on a
hard surface. Therefore, the medical evidence does not conclusively
support the prosecution version regarding the use of the alleged weapon of
offence.
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
18. In criminal jurisprudence, it is a cardinal principle that the prosecution
must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt and the burden of proof never
shifts. Where the evidence on record gives rise to two possible views, the
one favourable to the accused must be adopted. In Sharad Birdhichand
Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1984 SC 1622, the Supreme Court
reiterated that suspicion, however strong, cannot take the place of proof.
19. Applying these principles to the present case, the cumulative effect of the
circumstances discussed above clearly indicates that the prosecution has not
been able to establish the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt.
The testimony of the sole eye-witness suffers from material inconsistencies,
the independent witnesses have not supported the prosecution regarding the
recovery of the weapon, and the alleged motive has remained unproved.
These circumstances create a reasonable doubt regarding the prosecution
version. In such a situation, the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt,
which is a fundamental principle of criminal law and an essential safeguard
against wrongful conviction.
20. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is persuaded to agree with the
submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant that the finding of
conviction recorded by the learned Trial Court has been arrived at without a
proper and holistic appreciation of the evidence on record. The material
contradictions and inconsistencies appearing in the testimonies of the
prosecution witnesses have not been adequately considered, nor have the
surrounding circumstances been examined in their correct perspective. The
cumulative effect of these deficiencies renders the impugned judgment of
conviction and the consequent sentence legally unsustainable and perverse.
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
21. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The judgment of conviction and order
of sentence passed by the learned Trial Court against the appellant are set
aside. The appellant is acquitted of the charge under Section 302 RPC. He
shall stand discharged from the bail bonds furnished by him. The record of
the Trial Court be returned forthwith along with a copy of this judgment. In
view of the acceptance of the appeal and the acquittal of the appellant,
Reference for confirmation of sentence No. 7/2010 also stands declined.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
Jammu
12.03.2026
Vishal Sharma
Whether the judgment is reportable?
Yes
Whether the judgment is speaking?
Yes
CRA No. 15/2010 c/w
CONF No. 7/2010
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review