Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 82
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Crl R No. 89/2025
Reserved on: 02.07.2026
Pronounced on: 06 .07.2026
Uploaded on: 06 .07.2026
Whether the operative part or
Full judgment is pronounced: Full
Anjum Rafiq, Age 37 years
S/O Mohd. Rafiq
R/O Village Bani Khet,
Tehsil Surankote,
…..Petitioner(s)
District Poonch
Through: Mr. Mahmood A Shaad, Adv. vice
Mr. Abrar Ahmed Khan, Adv.
1.
Vs
The Union Territory of J&K through
Commissioner/Secretary, Home Department
Civil Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar.
2.
The Station House Officer,
Police Station Thannamandi.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Bhanu Jasrotia, GA
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MA CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
Through the medium of instant Criminal Revision Petition, the petitioner
seeks setting aside of the order dated 06.09.2025 passed by the Court of learned
Additional Sessions Judge (NDPS Cases), Rajouri, (hereinafter referred to as
‘the Trial Court’ for short), whereby his application for release of vehicle i.e.
i20 bearing registration No. JK12B-7073, seized by the respondent/Police
Station, in connection with the case FIR No. 69/2025 for offences punishable
Crl R No. 89/2025
under Sections 8/21/22/25/29 NDPS Act, in his favour, was rejected.
02.
The order impugned has been assailed on the grounds, inter alia, that
without considering the objections filed by the petitioner, the impugned order
has been passed; the petitioner being the registered owner of the vehicle in
question moved an application before the learned Trial Court seeking release of
the same but the learned Trial Court without due application of mind, rejected
the same by holding that vehicle cannot be released in view of fact that owner is
himself involved in the offence and the vehicle is used in the transportation of
narcotics, therefore, it would be required for confiscation; that the impugned
order suffers from illegality, and impropriety, thus deserves to be set aside; that
the vehicle in question has been lying outside the premises of Police Station,
Thannamandi since long and as such the same is likely to be rendered worthless
by being subjected to natural decay; that the petitioner is ready to furnish
superdnama subject to any conditions to be imposed by this Court; and that the
petitioner has been badly suffering, on account of continuous seizure of his
vehicle.
03.
Pursuant to notice, respondents filed report stating that the brief facts of
the prosecution case which led to the seizure of the vehicle in question are that
on 14.05.2025, that a Police Party comprising of Ct. Zulfikar Hussain No.148/R
and SPOs Mohd Azam, Waqar Ahmed and Maroof Khadam during Naka duty
at DKG Thanamandi, while checking vehicles and pedestrians passing through
the Naka point, at 22.45 hours, checked vehicle i20 bearing registration
No.JK12B-7073, driven by its driver from Rajouri, towards Bufliaz, wherein
four persons including the driver of the vehicle were found travelling; that
during checking of the said vehicle, two white coloured polythene pouches were
Crl R No. 89/2025
recovered from the left side of the dash board of the vehicle containing Heroin
like substance weighing approximately 15/16 grams and 2/3 grams each, total
weighing 18/19 grams; that besides heroin like substance, 2 and half strips
containing 26 tablets of Ferrous Sulphate & Folic Acid and one piece of silver
foil and a ten rupee note were also recovered from the dash board of the said
vehicle; that on enquiry, the persons and driver sitting in the said vehicles
disclosed their identities and consequently a case FIR No.69/2025 U/Ss
8/21/22/25/29 of NDPS Act was registered at Police Station Thannamandi,
accused got arrested and vehicle in question was seized during investigation.
04.
The learned counsel for the revision petitioner submitted that the order
impugned dated 06.09.2025 passed by learned Trial Court is illegal as the
petitioner who had earlier approached before the said Court is the registered
owner of the vehicle who has not used the vehicle for commission of the alleged
offence; that the petitioner has no past criminal antecedents and the quantity
allegedly recovered is admittedly intermediate quantity, therefore, the yard stick
which is applied for commercial quantity in releasing the vehicle was not
required to be applied to the present case; that the trial court has not applied the
law laid down by the Supreme Court in its correct perspective.
05.
Learned counsel further argued that the mere fact that the vehicle is
subject to confiscation proceedings, at the conclusion of the trial is no ground to
refuse its release; that if the vehicle is not released in his favour, same is likely
to suffer damage and deterioration on account of vagaries of the weather and
same is also not to serve any purpose to the State except a loss to the
petitioner/registered owner. He submitted that the vehicle may be released in
favour of the petitioner/registered owner subject to any reasonable terms and
Crl R No. 89/2025
conditions which he is ready to abide by. In support of his submissions, learned
counsel has relied upon judgment of Supreme Court in ‘Bishwajit Dey V. The
State of Assam’ reported at 2025 INSC 32.
06.
Learned counsel for the respondent, Per Contra, argued that the vehicle
in question (i20 hyundai) bearing registration No.JK12-B/7073, was being used
for transporting of Narcotic drugs which is heinous offence; that the
petitioner/owner is himself involved in the commission of offence and his
vehicle is required for confiscation as the said vehicle has been used in the
commission of the offence, thus, cannot be released; and that the NDPS Act
does not envisage the interim release of a seized conveyance during the trial;
that the seized vehicle is a material evidence that directly links the accused to
the commission of the offence, particularly since it was used as a means of
transport and conceal the contraband substance; that there is every likelihood
that the vehicle, if released, be used again for transporting/trafficking contraband
substances. He supported the impugned order, asserting that the same does not
suffer from any illegality or infirmity so as to warrant interference by this court
invoking revisional jurisdiction. He prayed that the impugned order be upheld.
Lastly, it is prayed that the seized vehicle be not released.
07.
Heard learned counsel for both the sides at length and perused the
impugned order.
08.
Section 497 of BNSS deals with custody and disposal of seized property
during trial. For the facility of reference, it is reproduced below:
497. Order for custody and disposal of property pending trial in certain
cases.
(1) When any property is produced before any Criminal Court or the
Crl R No. 89/2025
Magistrate empowered to take cognizance or commit the case for
trial during any investigation, inquiry or trial, the Court or the
Magistrate may make such order as it thinks fit for the proper
custody of such property pending the conclusion of the
investigation, inquiry or trial, and, if the property is subject to
speedy and natural decay, or if it is otherwise expedient so to do,
the Court or the Magistrate may, after recording such evidence as it
thinks necessary, order it to be sold or otherwise disposed of.
Explanation.-For the purposes of this section, "property" includes(a) property of any kind or document which is produced before the
Court or which is in its custody;
(b)any property regarding which an offence appears to have been
committed or which appears to have been used for the
commission of any offence.
2)
The Court or the Magistrate shall, within a period of fourteen days
from the production of the property referred to in sub-section (1)
before it, prepare a statement of such property containing its
description in such form and manner as the State Government may,
by rules, provide.
(3) The Court or the Magistrate shall cause to be taken the photograph
and if necessary, videograph on mobile phone or any electronic
media, of the property referred to in sub-section (1).
(4) The statement prepared under sub-section (2) and the photograph
or the videography taken under sub-section (3) shall be used as
evidence in any inquiry, trial or other proceeding under the
Sanhita.
(5) The Court or the Magistrate shall, within a period of thirty days
after the statement has been prepared under sub-section (2) and the
photograph or the videography has been taken under sub-section
(3), order the disposal, destruction, confiscation or delivery of the
property in the manner specified hereinafter.
09.
On a plain reading of Section 497 of the BNSS, 2023, it is clear that the
Crl R No. 89/2025
Trial Court/Magistrate is under an obligation to deal with the seized property
which may have been used in the commission of the offences or regarding
which offence may have been committed, within a period of 15 days, from the
production of seized property, the Court/Magistrate has to prepare a statement of
such property, photograph/videograph the same, which can be used in evidence
and
within
days
from
the
preparation
of
such
statement/videograph/photograph, the seized property is to be ordered to be
disposed of by destruction, confiscation or delivery of the property.
10.
The NDPS Act, as in the present case, has also provisions, as to how
seized property is to be dealt with like vehicles, etc used in the commission of
offences punishable under NDPS Act, are liable to be confiscated, on conclusion
of trial irrespective of conviction, acquittal or discharge of the accused. SubSection (3) of Section 60 NDPS Act, provides for such confiscation, whereas
Section 63 of the Act provides the procedure for confiscation. Sections 60(3)
and 63 of NDPS Act bearing relevance to the issue involved in this case deserve
consideration. The relevant provisions are extracted as under:
"60. Liability of illicit drugs, substances, plants, articles and
conveyances to confiscation –
(1) Whenever any offence punishable under this Act has been
committed, the narcotic drug, psychotropic substance,
controlled substance, opium poppy, coca plant, cannabis
plant, materials, apparatus and utensils in respect of which
or by means of which such offence has been committed,
shall be liable to confiscation.
(2) Any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance [ or controlled
substances]
lawfully
produced,
imported
inter-State,
exported inter-State, imported into India, transported,
manufactured, possessed, used, purchased or sold along
Crl R No. 89/2025
with, or in addition to, any narcotic drug or psychotropic
substance [ or controlled substances] which is liable to
confiscation under sub-section (1) and their receptacles,
packages and coverings in which any narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance [ or controlled substances],
materials, apparatus or utensils liable to confiscation under
sub-section (1) is found, and the other contents, if any, of
such receptacles or packages shall likewise be liable to
confiscation.
(3) Any animal or conveyance used in carrying any narcotic
drug or psychotropic substance [or controlled substances],
or any article liable to confiscation under sub-section (1) or
sub-section (2) shall be liable to confiscation, unless the
owner of the animal or conveyance proves that it was so
used without the knowledge or connivance of the owner
himself, his agent, if any, and the person-in-charge of the
animal or conveyance and that each of them had taken all
reasonable precautions against such use.”
63. Procedure in making confiscation.(1) In the trial of offences under this Act, whether the accused is
convicted or acquitted or discharged, the court shall decide
whether any article or thing seized under this Act is liable to
confiscation For Subsequent orders under section 60 or section
61 or section 62, and, if it decides that the article is so liable, it
may order confiscation accordingly.
(2) Where any article or thing seized under this Act appears to be
liable to confiscation under section 60 or section 61 or section
62, but the person who committed the offence in connection
therewith is not known or cannot be found, the court may inquire
into and decide such liability, and may order confiscation
Crl R No. 89/2025
accordingly:
Provided that no order of confiscation of an article or thing shall
be made until the expiry of one month from the date of seizure, or
without hearing any person who may claim any right thereto and
the evidence, if any, which he produces in respect of his claim:
Provided further that if any such article or thing, other than a
narcotic drug, psychotropic substance [or controlled substance]
the opium poppy, coca plant or cannabis plant is liable to speedy
and natural decay, or if the court is of opinion that its sale would
be for the benefit of its owner, it may at any time direct it to be
sold; and the provisions of this sub- section shall, as nearly as
may be practicable, apply to the net proceeds of the sale."
11.
Perusal of the provisions extracted hereinabove reveals that the
provisions of Section 60 of the NDPS Act, do no bar the consideration of an
application for interim release of conveyance allegedly involved in NDPS Act
during investigation and pending trial of a case. Any order made by a competent
criminal court in respect of the release of conveyance in NDPS case during trial,
shall be temporary on the basis of superdnama/panchnama and subject to the
outcome of the final orders in that behalf at the conclusion of the trial of the
case.
12.
Besides the provisions of Sections 60(3) and 63 of the NDPS Act,
Section 52-A of the Act also deals with disposal of seizures, in the cases under
the Act, under which Central Government has issued Notification to constitute
Drugs Disposal Committees to deal with the seized drugs. Sections 52 and 52-A
of the Act, however, are not applicable to those seized properties which are
subject to confiscation. However the legislature has not given any power to the
Crl R No. 89/2025
Drugs Disposal Committee to decide the claim of a person who place claims on
the conveyance (vehicle) seized under the provisions of NDPS Act for illegal
transporting of any narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, as given by the
legislature to the special court under section 60 and 63 of the Act. Where a
person lays claim for release the vehicle seized under the provisions of NDPS
Act for illegal transportation of any narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances,
there are no provisions in the Notification to decide that claim. In Sections 52
and 52A of NDPS Act, the word 'confiscation' is not used because the trial is yet
to come and it is the discretion of the trial Court "to confiscate or not to
confiscate" the conveyance seized under the NDPS Act as per the legal
provisions. So, in that case, the provisions of Section 60 & 63 of the NDPS Act
would prevail on the provisions of the notification issued by the Central
Government under Section 52A of the NDPS Act. According to the provisions
of Section 60 and 63 of the NDPS Act, seized conveyance cannot be disposed of
without deciding the claim of the person who claimed that conveyance and the
power to decide the claim of such a person is only given by the legislature to
special court under Section 60 and 63 of the NDPS Act.
13.
On perusal of the provisions of Section 60(3) and Section 63 of the
NDPS Act, as mentioned hereinabove, it is clear that the conveyance seized
under the NDPS Act shall be liable to confiscation only when the owner of the
conveyance who is given an opportunity by the Court can not prove that the
conveyance was used without his knowledge or connivance. The Court will have
to decide whether a vehicle seized under the NDPS Act is liable to confiscation
only on conclusion of the trial. There is no provision in the NDPS Act to restrict
the power of the trial Court to release the vehicle in interim custody.
Crl R No. 89/2025
Notwithstanding the fact that the vehicle is liable to be confiscated under
Section 60 of the NDPS Act, it may be released in interim custody in
appropriate cases. Thus, interim custody should not be denied to the owner of
the vehicle, simply because it is liable to be confiscated under Section 60 of the
NDPS Act.”
14.
This court is also conscious of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex
Court in “Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai v. State of Gujarat, AIR 2003
Supreme Court 638” in which it has been held that “ Powers under section 451
Cr.P.C (corresponding to Section 497 (1) of BNSS) is intended to serve various
purposes viz:i) “Owner of the article would not suffer because of its
remaining unused or by its misappropriation;
ii) Court or the police would not be required to keep the
articles in safe custody;
iii) If the proper panchanama before handing over possession
of article is prepared, that can be used in evidence instead
of its production before the Court during the trial. If
necessary, evidence could also be recorded describing the
nature of the property in detail: and
iv) The jurisdiction of the Court to record evidence should be
exercised promptly so that there may not be further chance
of tampering with the articles.”
15.
The provisions of clause (3) of the Section 60 clearly reveal that a seized
conveyance or an animal liable to be confiscated under clause (1) and (2) of the
said section, can be so confiscated unless the owner of the conveyance or animal
proves that same was so used without his knowledge or connivance or of his
agent.
16.
The mere fact that a vehicle used in carrying contraband articles is liable
Crl R No. 89/2025
to confiscation under the provisions of NDPS Act especially under section
60(3), is no bar for giving the interim custody of the same to its registered owner
before passing confiscation order. It is also well settled that under the provisions
of section 497 (1) BNSS corresponding to section 451 of the repealed Criminal
Procedure Code, the court before whom the property is produced, is empowered
to release the vehicle during enquiry and trial of the accused persons.
17.
The object and scheme of various provisions of the Sanhita 2023 and
NDPS Act appear to be: that where the property which has been subject matter
of the offence is seized by the police, it ought not to be retained in the custody of
the court or of the police for any time longer than what is absolutely necessary.
In Nirmal Singh vs State of Punjab reported at 2023:PHHC:037265, it has
been held that no useful purpose would be served by keeping the vehicle seized
under NDPS Act, parked in the premises of Police Station and it will be in the
interest of justice if such vehicle is ordered to be released on 'Superdari' to the
petitioner on his furnishing the requisite undertaking. In Khema vs State of
Rajasthan reported at 2026 INSC 12, it has been held that the fact that a vehicle
seized under NDPS Act is liable to be confiscation under section 60 of the Act is
no ground for denying the interim custody of the vehicle to its registered owner
before passing the confiscation order subject to reasonable conditions. In 2003
C.L.J 3142 Orissa it has been held that a vehicle seized under NDPS Act, if
allowed to remain in the premises of Police Station without any care and
subjected to rain and sun, is likely to deteriorate. That the interim release of said
vehicle subject to final decision of the case and after taking undertaking from
the registered owner that he will produce it as and when required by the trial
court and will not transfer it, will meet ends of justice. In 2002 C.L.J. 2605,
Crl R No. 89/2025
Delhi, it has been held that the interim release of a vehicle seized under, NDPS
Act is not inconsistent with the provisions of NDPS Act. That the pendency of
the trial against the driver accused under NDPS Act is likely to take some time
during which period the vehicle concerned is likely to get further damaged
because of its disuse.
18.
In Hoshar Singh vs State, Crimes 2011 Vol. IV 176 Allahabad, it was
held while making a reference to Hon’ble Apex court judgment titled Basawa
Kom Dyamangouda Patil vs State of Mysore, (1977) 4 SCC 358 that “from the
law laid down by Apex Court, it clearly shows that rejecting the application of
the applicant only on the ground that it may be liable for confiscation and it was
used for transporting the Narcotic Substance was against the law. If the vehicle
is given in the Supurdgi and custody of the owner of the vehicle and later on at
final stage of the case, it is found that the same is liable for the confiscation, the
same Court can direct the owner to produce the vehicle before the Court or the
authority concerned.”
19.
Upon a careful perusal of the NDPS Act, this court is of the view that the
seized vehicle can be confiscated by the trial court only on conclusion of the
trial when the accused is convicted or acquitted or discharged. Further, even
where the Court is of the view that the vehicle is liable for confiscation, it must
give an opportunity of hearing to the person who may claim any right to the
seized vehicle before passing an order of confiscation. However, the seized
vehicle is not liable to confiscation, if the owner of the seized vehicle can prove,
that the vehicle was used by the accused person without the owner’s knowledge
or connivance and that he had taken all reasonable precautions against such use
of the seized vehicle by the accused person.
20.
Crl R No. 89/2025
This Court is further of the opinion that there is no specific
bar/restriction under the provisions of the NDPS Act for return of any seized
vehicle used for transporting narcotic drug or psychotropic substance, in the
interim, pending disposal of the criminal case.
21.
In the absence of any specific bar under the NDPS Act and in view of
Section 51 of NDPS Act, the Court can invoke the general power under Section
497 of BNSS 2023 for return of the seized vehicle pending final decision of the
criminal case. Consequently, the Trial Court has the discretion to release the
vehicle in the interim. However, this power would have to be exercised, in
accordance with law, in the facts and circumstances of each case.
22.
Undoubtedly, the Vehicle is a critical piece of material evidence that
may be required for inspection to substantiate the prosecution’s case, yet the
said requirement can be met by stipulating conditions while releasing the
Vehicle in interim on superdari like Videography and still photographs to be
authenticated by the Investigating Officer, owner of the Vehicle and accused by
signing the said inventory as well as restriction on sale/transfer of the Vehicle.
23.
This Court is of the view that if the Vehicle in the present case is allowed
to be kept in the custody of police till the trial is over, it will serve no purpose.
This court takes judicial notice that vehicles in police custody are stored in open.
Consequently, if the Vehicle is not released during the trial, it will be wasted and
suffering the vagaries of the weather, its value will only reduce.
24.
Having regard to the foregoing reasons, observations made hereinabove
and the aforestated legal propositions enunciated, and on these touchstones, the
view taken by the court below for refusing to release seized vehicle in an NDPS
Act case, on interim, is fallacious, for the reason that there is no such bar either
Crl R No. 89/2025
in the Penal law or Procedural law, the confiscation to be considered, on
disposal of the case by the Trial Court regardless of its outcome- conviction,
consideration of the claim laid in this behalf and affording an opportunity of
being heard to the owner of the vehicle.
25.
Viewed thus, as a consequence of the aforesaid, the Criminal Revision
Petition is allowed and the impugned order is set-aside with following
directions:
(i) that the trial court shall release the vehicle in question, in the interim, on
Supardari of the registered owner after getting prepared a video and still
photographs of the vehicle and after obtaining all information/documents
necessary for identification of the vehicle to be authenticated by the
Investigating Officer, owner of the vehicle and accused by signing the
same; and
(ii) that the petitioner shall file an undertaking to the trial court that he shall
not sell/part with the ownership of the Vehicle in question till conclusion
of the trial and that he shall surrender the Vehicle within one week of
being so directed and/or pay the value of the Vehicle (determined
according to the Income Tax law on the date of its release), if so
ultimately directed by the court.
26.
Disposed of, as allowed.
(MA CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
JAMMU
06.07.2026
Raj Kumar
Whether the order is reportable: Yes/No
Raj Kumar
2026.07.06 17:06
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review