The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
01. 06.1982, the appointment order is to be effective on the date of joining. Since the petitioner is not able to indicate the exact date of joining, her seniority position cannot be asserted in the writ proceedings in face of the disputed facts arising in the present petition. In order to show that the petitioner is still working in the school, she has filed copies of Constitution of School Management Committee in which her name is shown in the category of LE. In Manipur Education Code, 1982, Chapter-VI School Management Committee, Section-I Manipur Aided Secondary Schools (Managing Committee) Rules, 1975 Rule 2 provides composition of School Management Committee consisting of (i) Head Master, (ii) Two Teachers Representatives, (iii) Two Guardians’ Representatives, (iv) One Representative elected by Donors, (v) Founder, (vi) One Member elected by Subscribers and (vii) Four Members of – one from Education Department and 3 local persons interested in Education. WP(C) No. 958 of 2015 Page 6 [14] From perusal of the rules concerning School Management Committee and various orders incorporating the petitioner in the Committee in the category of LE, it is apparent that the name of the petitioner was included in the category of local persons interested in Education. The same could not be a proof of her being a teacher in the School. [15] During the course of hearing, Mr. Juno Rahman, lear…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item No. 32
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 958 of 2015
…..Petitioner/s
Fatima Begum
- Versus –
State of Manipur
.... Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
Order (Oral)
06.08.2024
[1]
Heard Mr. Juno Rahman, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned G.A. for the State respondent and
Mr. L. Sevananda, learned counsel along with Mr. Hodam Shivarex,
learned counsel for private respondent Nos. 5 & 6.
[2]
By the present petition, the petitioner challenged the
entire DPC proceeding held from 26.09.2015 to 29.09.2015 for
appointment of private respondent Nos. 5 & 6 as two approved
Assistant Teachers in Changamdabi Girl’s L.P. Madrassa (Aided) and
consequential relief of considering her recommendation as approved
Teacher on the basis that she is senior to the private respondent Nos.
5 & 6.
[3]
It is the case of the petitioner that she was appointed vide
order dated 01.06.1982 as Assistant Teacher in Changamdabi Girls
L.P. Madrassa with effect from the date of her joining whereas the
WP(C) No. 958 of 2015
Page 1
private respondent Nos. 5 & 6 have been appointed only in the year
2015 in terms of the impugned DPC proceeding. Being senior most,
her case has to be considered. It is the case of the School
Management Committee (respondent No. 4) and private respondent
Nos. 5 & 6 that the petitioner never joined in pursuance of the order
dated 01.06.1982 and as such, she cannot claim seniority from the
date of appointment.
[5]
It is also pointed out that the Headmaster of the School
has stated that since 1984, he did not see the petitioner in the school
during his tenure. The School Management Committee has also
pointed out that in the Attendance Register maintained by the school,
the name of the petitioner is not shown and there is no signature in the
register.
[6]
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned G.A. for the State respondent,
submits that there is no document to show that the petitioner joined to
the post in terms of the appointed dated 01.06.1982.
[7]
Mr. Juno Rahman, learned counsel for the petitioner,
submits that if the appointment of the petitioner is no effective, there
should be no occasion for the School Management Committee to issue
the order dated 21.10.2014 terminating her service. Since her
termination order is set aside by this Court vide order dated 29.11.2017
passed in WP(C) No. 378 of 2017 filed by the petitioner, it is an
admitted fact that she is a Teacher in the school. It is the case of the
petitioner that she is still a Teacher in Changamdabi Girl’s L.P.
Madrassa.
WP(C) No. 958 of 2015
Page 2
[8]
Learned counsel for the respondents has pointed out that
this Court set aside the termination order of the petitioner only on the
ground of not affording any opportunity of being heard and nothing has
been mentioned about the date of joining of the petitioner in pursuance
to the order dated 01.06.1982.
[9]
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the
respondents draws the attention of this Court to the order dated
29.11.2017 passed by this Court that the present petition involved
disputed questions of facts which this Court did not want to interfere.
However, at the request of the learned counsel for the petitioner, some
time was given to produce documents to show that the petitioner is still
serving in the school and senior to the private respondents.
[10]
Pursuant to the above order, the petitioner filed additional
affidavit dated 06.02.2018 whereby in a report submitted by the ZEO,
Zone-II, Imphal East, the name of the petitioner was shown at Serial
No. 30 (Unapproved Teacher) with the date of appointment as
30.05.1982. However, in Annexure – A/14 filed by the petitioner which
is a letter dated 19.05.2015 written by the Head Master of the School to
the ZEO, Zone-II, Imphal East. Annexures – A/13 & A/14 are
reproduced as:
“Annexure – A/13:
THE SCHOOL INFORMATION FOR GRANT-INAID SCHOOLS IN THE JURISDICTION OF THE
INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS, ZONE-II.
1. Name of the School : The Changamdabi Girls LP
Madrassa.
2. Date of recognition : 5/2/1973 No. 3/1/64-SE…
WP(C) No. 958 of 2015
Page 3
3. Year & Date of Extension of Grant-in-aid : Up to date
SL. No. 102.
4. Area of the School Compound with Patta No./with one
jamabandi copy : Khash Land 55x66 feet.
5. Furniture : Bench 11 desk 11 Tab 3 Chair….
6. Teaching Aid if any : …….and other
7. Classwise enrolment :
Class Boys Girls
1(A)-- 22 --13
1(B)-- 18 --16
II--11 --9
Today
=35
=34
=20
8. Particulars of teachers (Certificates in original with
Service Book should be submitted to the Inspector of
Schools, Zone – II before the 7th February, 1993.
Class
Class
Class
Sl. Name of the Teacher
No. with qualification
Date of appointment copy
Approved
Remarks
of
Unapproved
appointment/orders/proceeding
of DPC
Md. Shaheruddin
No.1/YCo180-51
approved
th
Matriculate
Dated 15 Feb. 81
2.
Warish Ali
No.3/5/86-ED(15-11-06
Matriculate
15th October 87
approved
3.
Fatima Bibi
30/5/82
unapproved
B.A.
Full Signatures with Seals:-Sd/-Sd/-Sd/(i)
Head Master
(ii) Secretary
(iii) Chairman
10. Comments for the concerned Officer:-“
“Annexure-A/14:
Office of the
Changamdabi Girls LPS (Aided), Changamdabi
…….
No. 1/1/Appt/2015
Changamdabi, 19th May, 2015
Sir,
The ZEO
Zone-II, Imphal East.
Subject: Application submitted by Miss Fatima Begum for
appointment to the post of Teacher.
Sir,
WP(C) No. 958 of 2015
Page 4
With reference to the application of Miss Fatima Begum for
appointment to the post of Asst. Teacher, I am to state the following
facts for further examination and necessary action.
That, I came to know that she is also serving as a Teacher at
Changamdabi Girls LPS (Aided) after receiving her application forward
by you only.
That, I was serving as a Graduate Teacher since, 1994 and
after 6/7 years, I was promoted to the post of transfer by the School
Managing Board.
That, from the date, I joined my duty in the 1994 till date I do not
Miss Fatima Begum not even a single day in the school.
It is surprised to learnt that she is stated/claiming that she is
serving as a Teacher since, 1.6.1982.
Enclosed: Application (original)
Yours faithfully,
(Sh. Amuchou Singh)
Head Master
Changamdabi Girls LPS (Aided) School.”
[11]
In Annexure – A/15, the Assistant Inspector of School
informed the ZEO, Zone-II, Imphal East vide letter dated 20.05.2015
that the petitioner was not attending duty since 24.06.2011. Annexure –
A/15 is reproduced as:
“The Zonal Education Officer ZEO, Z-II
Porompat Imphal East.
Subject: Submission by Mrs.Fatima Begum for
appointment order o the post of teacher.
Sir,
I have the honour to report that I have inspected
the Changamdabi Girls LP (Aided on 16/05/015 at about
8 am and found that Smt. Mrs. Fatima Begum unapproved teacher of the said School was not attended
and duly since June 24/2011 on wards as per record
mainted by the Head master and also enclosed the report
of the concerned Head Maser in this regard.
Submitted for kind information and n/a.
20th May, 2015
Sd/…Abdul….
C/A/1 of…
Seal:
Asstt.
Inspector of Schools
WP(C) No. 958 of 2015
Page 5
Imphal
East
District,
Zone-II,
Government of Manipur”
[12]
This Court is of the opinion that on perusal of the
documents, they seem to be contradictory to one another and on the
failure of the petitioner to file specific documents indicating her date of
joining in terms of the appointment order dated 01.06.1982, there is no
clear date on which the petitioner joined as Assistant Teacher in the
school in pursuance to the appointment order.
[13]
On plain reading of the appointment order dated
01.06.1982, the appointment order is to be effective on the date of
joining. Since the petitioner is not able to indicate the exact date of
joining, her seniority position cannot be asserted in the writ proceedings
in face of the disputed facts arising in the present petition. In order to
show that the petitioner is still working in the school, she has filed
copies of Constitution of School Management Committee in which her
name is shown in the category of LE. In Manipur Education Code,
1982, Chapter-VI School Management Committee, Section-I Manipur
Aided Secondary Schools (Managing Committee) Rules, 1975 Rule 2
provides composition of School Management Committee consisting of
(i) Head Master, (ii) Two Teachers Representatives, (iii) Two
Guardians’ Representatives, (iv) One Representative elected by
Donors, (v) Founder, (vi) One Member elected by Subscribers and (vii)
Four Members of – one from Education Department and 3 local
persons interested in Education.
WP(C) No. 958 of 2015
Page 6
[14]
From
perusal
of
the
rules
concerning
School
Management Committee and various orders incorporating the petitioner
in the Committee in the category of LE, it is apparent that the name of
the petitioner was included in the category of local persons interested in
Education. The same could not be a proof of her being a teacher in the
School.
[15]
During the course of hearing, Mr. Juno Rahman, learned
counsel for the petitioner, submits that the petitioner is still working in
the school as Assistant Teacher (Unapproved).
[16]
In view of the order dated 29.11.2017 passed in WP(C)
No. 378 of 2018, it is admitted fact which has been taken judicial note
by this Court that the petitioner is still unapproved Assistant Teacher in
Changamdabi Girls LP Madrassa. In view of the fact that the petitioner
is not able to indicate exact date of joining, her seniority cannot be
ascertained in a writ proceeding.
[17]
This Court does not want to interfere with the impugned
DPC proceeding and appointment of the private respondents. It is made
clear that disposal of the present petition shall not bar the School
Management Committee as well as the State respondent from
considering the petitioner as approved Teacher, if she is otherwise
eligible as per rule.
[18]
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
Digitally signed
by KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2024.08.14
14:57:29 +05'30'
With this observation, writ petition is disposed of.
JUDGE
Kh. Joshua Maring
WP(C) No. 958 of 2015
Page 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review