Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
14.01.2026
Court No.25
DL/Item No.–15 & 16
[PP/Milan]
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
WPA 28472 of 2024
Faridul Alam
versus
The Union of India & Ors.
With
WPA 9182 of 2025
Tasleema Ara & Anr.
Vs.
The Union of India & Ors.
Ms. Afreen Begum
Ms. Swastika Chowdhury,
Ms. Ilika Nag,
Mr. Dip Dutta,
Mr. Bilal Hasan
….for the Petitioners
Mr. Ashok Kr. Chakraborty, Ld. ASG.,
Mr. Rajdeep Majumdar, Ld. DSG.,
Mr. Atarup Banerjee,
Ms. Amrita Pandey,
Mr. Subit Majumdar,
….for UoI
Mr. Kishore Dutta, Ld. AG.,
Mr. Sk. Md. Galib, Sr. Govt. Adv.,
Ms. Sujata Mukherjee
….for the State
(in WPA 28472 of 2024)
Mr. Kishore Dutta, Ld. AG.,
Mr. Amal Kr. Sen, Ld. AAG.,
Ms. Ashima Das (Sil)
….for the State (in WPA 9182 of 2025)
In Re: WPA 28472 of 2024
1.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition praying for
direction upon the respondents to release the petitioner,
who is at present lodged at Howrah District Correctional
Home on disclosing his destination for residence and on
undertaking to report the local police station.
2.
The petitioner was charged with Section 14 of the
Foreigners Act and on completion of the investigation,
the police has submitted the charge sheet. On 3rd May,
2017 at the time of framing of charge, the petitioner
pleaded guilty for committing offence under Section 14
of the Foreigners Act. The Judicial Magistrate, 7th Court,
Howrah convicted the petitioner and sentenced to suffer
simple imprisonment for one year and three months i.e.
455 days.
3.
It is further ordered that period of detention, if any,
undergone by the petitioner for a period of one year and
three months, i.e. 455 days be set up against the
sentence passed under Section 428 of the Cr.P.C.
4.
It is further ordered that the petitioner being the
Mayanmaree national be repatriated to his native
country at once upon expiry of the sentenced imposed.
5.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner was arrested on 9th February, 2016 and since
then the petitioner is in correctional home. Though, the
learned Magistrate has passed the order of conviction
sentencing the petitioner for one year and three months
and sentenced has been completed on 8th April, 2017
but the petitioner is in correctional home for the last
about 9 years.
6.
On completion of sentence, the petitioner has made an
application before the learned Magistrate on 27th June,
2018 with the prayer for compliance of the order dated
3rd May, 2017, wherein the learned Magistrate has
directed for repatriating the petitioner to his native
country at once on expiry of the sentence.
7.
The learned Magistrate, by an order dated 27th June,
2018, has dismissed the application filed by the
petitioner on the ground that the learned Magistrate has
no jurisdiction to pass any further order once he has
already disposed of criminal case by imposing sentence
upon the petitioner.
8.
The petitioner has relied upon the judgment in the case
of MS Maja Daruwala & Anr. Vs. State of West Bengal
& Anr. in Transferred Case (Criminal) No.1 /2013 dated
16th May, 2025 wherein the Hon’bnle Supreme Court
has passed an order holding that if there is any illegal
migrant as on date in any of the prisons within the State
of West Bengal who has undergone the entire sentence
and is still confined in any of the prison, passed three
years from the date of completion of his/her original
sentence, he/she, be released on bail subject to the
following conditions:“(a) Execution of bond with two sureties of
Rs.1,00,000/-(Rupees one lakh only) each of Indian
citizens;
(b) He or she specifies verifiable address of stay
after release;
(c) Biometric of his/her iris (if possible) and all ten
fingerprints and photos shall be captured and
stored in a secured database before release from
the detention centres. He or she shall report once
every week to the Police Station specified by the
Foreigners Tribunal;
(d) He or she shall notify any change of his or her
address to the specified Police Station on the same
day, and
(e) A quarterly report to be submitted by the
Superintendent of Police (Border) to the Foreigners
Tribunal regarding appearance of such released
declared foreigner to concerned Police Station and
in case of violation of condition, the DFN will be
apprehended
and
produced
before
Foreigners
Tribunal."
9.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted the
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court equally
applicable in the case of the petitioner as the petitioner
is in correctional home even after completion of sentence
in the year 2017 but neither he has been repatriated nor
he has been released from the correctional home.
10. The Welfare Officer of Dum Dum Central Correctional
Home by a letter dated 23rd December, 2025 has
informed the
Superintendent of Dum Dum Central
Correctional Home, Kolkata that if the petitioner is
released from correctional home, he will reside with one
Rintu Monal son of Abdul Aziz Mondal vill: Khurigachi,
Land Mark – near Goldarpara Anganari School, PO:
Bhodai, PS: Amdanga, N. 24 PGS., W.B.
11. The petitioner has produced the said report before this
Court at the time of hearing. On receipt of the said
report, this Court directed the State as well as the FRRO
to verify the address of the person furnished by the
petitioner through the Welfare Officer of Dum Dum
Central Correctional Home whether he is a reliable
person and the petitioner can be released on bail if the
petitioner will reside in the address mentioned above.
12. As per the direction passed by this Court, the State
submitted report stating that Rintu Mondal is a habitual
offender and at least six criminal cases are registered
against him and the state has objected that if the
petitioner is allowed to reside with the said Rintu
Mondal, there is every apprehension that the petitioner
will again commit an offence with Rintu Mondal.
13. The learned DSGI has submitted that the condition for
release on bail as indicated in the order passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court cannot be read in isolation. He
submits that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has passed
several directions imposed several responsibility of the
State of West Bengal but till date the State of West
Bengal has not come forward with any report whether
the State has made any arrangement for keeping the
migrant in a correction home or detention centre.
14. He further submitted that in the order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, it is categorically mentioned that the
State of West Bengal has made a statement before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court that the separate correctional
home/detention centre is likely to be completed within a
period of six months but till date no report is filed.
15. He further submits that the petitioner is a Mayanmaree
national and if the petitioner is allowed to go on bail,
there is every apprehension that he will commit a
further offence and will disturb the peace of State of
West Bengal.
16. The learned DSGI has filed a report praying for time to
file a detailed affidavit within a period of four weeks from
date.
17. Heard the learned Counsel for the respective parties and
perused
the
materials
on
record.
Admittedly
the
petitioner is a Mayanmaree national and he was
apprehended by the police for the offence under Section
14 of the Foreigners Act.
18. The petitioner has pleaded guilty before the learned Trial
Court and was sentenced to suffer simple imprisonment
for one year and three months on 3rd May, 2017.
19. The petitioner has completed his sentence in the year
2017 itself
but there is no
facility of
detention
home/correctional home in the State of West Bengal and
as such the petitioner is detained in the correctional
home itself.
20. Now, the matter is pending before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court with regard to the construction of the correctional
home/detention centre.
21. Now, the question before this Court that whether the
petitioner can be released on bond in terms of the order
dated 13th May, 2025 passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court. Considering the judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, address furnished by the petitioner was
referred to the State as well as the FRRO for verification
of the address and credibility of one Mr. Rintu Mondal.
22. The State authority has verified the address and
credibility of Mr. Rintu Mondal and found that he is
having
several
criminal
antecedents
under
such
circumstances this Court did not find any reason to
allow the petitioner to reside in the house with Rintu
Mondal.
The petitioner subsequently furnished other
two addresses namely, Reyab Ali Molla son of Rahim
Molla vill: Neotala, Land Mark – Mudi Dokan, P.O:
Botaran, P.S: Joynagar, S. 24 PGS., W.B. and another
person namely, Masura Khatun daughter of Dr. Daud
Ali Molla, Vill: Raghunath Pur, Land Mark – Raghunath
Pur School Bari, P.O: Raghunath Pur, P.S: Matiya, N. 24
PGS., W.B. The State authority has also verified the said
addresses of the said two persons and after verification,
a report is submitted before this Court wherein it reveals
that when Reyab Ali Molla lodged at Dum Dum
Correctional Home, he acquainted with the petitioner.
Reyab Ali Molla has categorically stated before the
authority at the time of inquiry that he is not willing to
keep the petitioner at his residence.
As regard the
inquiry of Masura Khatun, it is found that she has
categorically stated before the authority at the time of
inquiry that she does not know any person in the name
of Faridul Alam and she could not recognize him.
23. Considering the report, this Court found that the two
persons’
name
which
has
been
provided
by
the
petitioner is also not ready to allow the petitioner to
reside in their house.
24. Considering the above, this Court has no other options
but to reject the application.
It is true that the
petitioner has completed the sentence in the year 2017
but the petitioner is a foreign national, cannot be
allowed to go freely as Indian Citizen and if he is allowed
to
go
free
only
furnishing
bond,
there
is
every
apprehension that either he will flee away from India
illegally or he will further commit any offence in India.
25. It is further made clear that this order will not prevent
the petitioner to make further application if the
petitioner will find any person who is ready to keep the
petitioner in his residence whose credibility is good.
26. Considering the above, the writ petition being WPA
28472 of 2024 filed by the petitioner Faridul Alam, is
accordingly dismissed.
In Re: WPA 9182 of 2025
27. The Welfare Officer has submitted a letter to the
Superintendent of Dum Dum Central Correctional Home
on 23.12.2025 intimating that if the petitioners, namely,
Tasleeman Ara & Safikul Islam, are released on bail,
petitioners will reside in the house of one Injamul Haque
Tarafdar son of Mosatafa Tarafdar, vill: Kolsur, (land
Mark – Mudi Dokan), PO: Kolsur, PS: Deganga, N. 24
PGS., PIN – 743438, W.B. On receipt of the said details,
this Court has directed the State as well as the FRRO to
verify the address furnished by the petitioners, if the
petitioners are released on bail, they can reside in the
house of Injamul Haque Tarafdar.
28. The State has submitted the report informing that on
inquiry it was found that Injamul Haque Tarafdar is
residing in the said address for long and no discrepancy
has been noted during the inquiry.
29. The learned ASGI has raised objection and submitted
that though the State has filed the report that the
petitioners can reside in the house of Injamul Haque
Tarafdar but the State has not filed any report whether
there is any apprehension that the petitioners will flee
away from India illegally or whether the petitioners will
commit any further offence.
30. The ASGI filed affidavit praying for four weeks time to
file the detailed affidavit.
31. Heard the learned counsel for the respective parties, this
Court find that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
judgment dated 13th May, 2025 has categorically stated
that if any illegal migrant as on date in any of the prison
within the State of West Bengal who was undergone the
entire sentence and is still confined in any of the prison,
passed three years from the date of completion of
his/her original sentence, he/she shall be released
subject of conditions as recorded in the order dated 13th
May, 2025.
32. Considering the above, this Court finds that the
petitioners are convicted by an order dated 3rd May,
2017 and since then the petitioners are in custody. The
petitioners have completed their sentence in the year
2017 itself now we are on 2026 admittedly the State has
not
made
any
provisions
for
correctional
home/detention centre for the illegal migrants.
33. The petitioners have furnished the detailed address of
the persons if the petitioners are released on bail, the
petitioners will reside in the said address. The same has
been verified by the State authority and submitted
report before this Court.
34. The ASGI further submits that if paragraph 17 of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court order is read in isolation, even
then as per Clause (b) of paragraph 17 of the said order,
the FRRO is required to verify the address. The address
furnished by the petitioners were forwarded to the State
as well as the FRRO, State has submitted the report but
the FRRO has not submitted any report for the last two
dates.
35. This Court has directed the authority to verify the
address of the persons concern but till date the FRRO
has not submitted the verification report.
36. Accordingly, this Court has no alternative but to accept
the report of the State. The petitioners are released on
bail subject to the following conditions:(a)
The petitioners shall furnish bond of two sureties
of Rs.1,00,000/- (rupees one lakh) each of the
Indian citizen.
(b)
The petitioners shall furnish their address of stay
to the concern police station as well as to the
FRRO
within
hours
from
release
from
correctional home.
(c)
Biometrics of the petitioners iris (if possible) and
all 10 finger prints and photos shall be captured
and stored in a secured data base before release
from the correctional home. The petitioners shall
report once in every week to the local police
station
specified
by
the
FRRO
where
the
petitioners reside.
(d)
The petitioners shall notify any change of their
address to the specified police station.
(e)
A quarterly report to be submitted by the
Superintendent of Police (Border) to the FRRO
regarding appearance of such released declared by
the foreigners to the concerned police station and
in
case
of
violation
of
the
conditions
the
petitioners shall be apprehended and produced
before the learned jurisdictional Magistrate for
appropriate action.
The sureties bond, if any, furnished by the
petitioners shall be accepted with the satisfaction
of the learned Trial Court.
37. Considering the above, the writ petition being WPA 9182
of 2025 filed by the petitioners, namely, Tasleema Ara
and Safikul Islam, is accordingly disposed of.
38.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be given to the parties upon compliance of all
necessary formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review