Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.08.28 10:40:24 +05'30'
Page |1
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP (C) No. 573 of 2021
1.
Mrs. Farida, aged about 23 years, W/o (L) Md. Farish Khan
of Sangaiyumpham Part I, Mairenkhun, PO Wangjing & PS
Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur.
2.
Md. Gurbaj, aged about 5 years, S/o (L) Md. Farish Khan of
Sangaiyumpham Part I, Mairenkhun, PO Wangjing & PS
Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur through his mother, Mrs.
Farida (Petitioner No. 1 herein).
… PETITIONERS
-VERSUS-
1.
The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner
(Home), Government of Manipur office at Secretariat South
Block, Babupara, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur—795001.
2.
The Director General of Police, Manipur, Government of
Manipur, office at PHQ, Babupara, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur—795001.
3.
The Commandant, 8th IRB, Government of Manipur.
4.
The Superintendent of Police, Imphal East, Manipur.
5.
The Office in Charge, Porompat Police Station, Imphal East,
Manipur.
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
Page |2
6.
Mrs. Yengkhom Rajshini Devi, MPS, Asst. director, Manipur
Police Training School, Pangei, Imphal East, C/o Director
General of Police, Government of Manipur (incorporated
vide order dated 18-10-202 passed in MC(WP(C)) No. 176
of 2022).
… RESPONDENTS
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
::
.
For the Respondents
::
.
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
Date of Judgment & Order
::
Mr. Juno Rahman S., Adv.
Mr. Sh. Shyam Sharma, GA
02.08.2023
22.08.2023
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
The petitioners have filed the writ petition for
issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to pay
a sum of Rs.20 lakhs or any reasonable amount to compensate
them for the untimely death of their breadwinner Farish Khan.
2.
The case of the petitioners is that the first petitioner
is the legally married wife and the second petitioner is the minor
son of Farish Khan.
Farish Khan is a poor villager of
Sangaiyumpham Part-I, Thoubal District. On 1.8.2021, due to
curfew imposed by the State authorities, Farish Khan could not
go out to any place for earning and he along with four others were
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
Page |3
sitting at playground of K.R. Lane near Imphal River Bank. At
that time, some personnel of 8th IRB led by its Commanding
Officer came to the said playground and chased them shouting
for arrest by the Commanding Officer and surrounded them near
the Imphal river. The IRB personnel arrested Abomcha and the
other four of them including Farish Khan and they were forced to
jump down at the running Imphal river for avoiding their arrest.
But Farish Khan could not swim in the river and he cried for help.
In spite of that, IRB personnel who were standing at the river
bank along with their Commanding Officer seeing helplessness
of Farish Khan floating in the water did not lend a helping hand.
The arrested person requested them to release him for saving
Farish Khan. But the IRB personnel refused to accede to such
request. After about 10 minutes, Farish Khan could not be seen
further. However, three of them could reach western bank of the
Imphal river by swimming. As the water level of the area was
above the height of Farish Khan, he had drowned completely and
his physical appearance had also disappeared. After some time,
the NDRF personnel came there and a search operation was
carried out and the same ended in vain. However, on 3.8.2021
at about 2.00 P.M., Farish Khan was found dead and recovered
from a little distance of Sanjenthong bridge.
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
Page |4
3.
Further case of the petitioner is that because of
excessive acts of the said Commanding Officer, 8th IRB as well
as her escort party the accident occurred and her husband died.
Had he not died in the said incident by way of forceful action of
the personnel of 8th IRB, he might have survived up to the age of
65-70 years as he is a strong and healthy person at the relevant
time. Due to the untimely death of Farish Khan, the petitioners
suffered serious mental torture and their future life is at stake.
Therefore, the State respondents are liable to pay reasonable
compensation to the petitioners.
4.
According to the petitioners, after getting the dead
body on 3.8.2021, the Porompat Police took up a case as
Unnatural Death and an FIR was registered.
A Joint Action
Committee led by one Md. Ajad Khan as Convenor for the death
of Farish Khan was formed for taking action against the said
involved IRB personnel and also for payment of compensation
as well as arrest of involved IRB personnel in causing the death
of Farish Khan. Despite forwarding the memorandum to the
Hon’ble Chief Minister and the Superintendent of Police, no
effective action has yet been taken. Hence, the present writ
petition.
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
Page |5
5.
The respondents 2, 4 and 5 have filed affidavit-in-
opposition stating that based on the information received by the
then Sub-Inspector of Police, a suo moto case was registered on
3.8.2021 and the dead body was brought along with the police
party from Namthapung, KR Lane and kept at JNIMS Morgue
and post-mortem was conducted. Since after completion of postmortem no one came forward to receive the dead body, the dead
body was kept at JNIS Morgue and on 7.8.2021, the elder brother
of the deceased collected the body by observing necessary
formalities.
In due course of investigation, two prosecution
witnesses were examined who have spoken about the incident
and recorded their statements. According to the respondents 2,
4 and 5, the deceased died not due to excessive or negligent act
of the Commanding Officer of 8th IRB or her escort party. The
deceased drowned himself by diving into the river to avoid the
police personnel who were on patrolling duty to enforce the
curfew imposed due to Covid-19 pandemic. Thus, prayed for
dismissal of the writ petition.
6.
Pending writ petition, the Commanding Officer by
name was impleaded as 6th respondent. The 6th respondent filed
affidavit-in-opposition stating that at the relevant point of time,
curfew was imposed in the entire Imphal East District, including
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
Page |6
Hatta where the petitioners and the deceased are residing. It is
stated that no personnel of 8th IRB or Commandant went to the
playground of KR Lane near Imphal River and, as such, the
question of arresting any person does not arise at all.
The
question of arresting some curfew violators and seeing the
deceased person drowning are all concocted allegations without
any legal basis.
The Commanding Officer and her team were
nowhere in the scene or involved in chasing the persons as
respondent No.6 was in her quarters at that relevant point of time
and she reached Checkon only around 5.00 P.M. On the date of
incident after 5.15 P.M. only the Commanding Officer and her
team reached the main road of KR Lane and she came to know
about the incident in which one person drowned after he jumped
into the river seeing the police patrolling car approaching them.
It is stated that in fact the 8th IRB is assisting the Superintendent
of Police, Imphal East in the enforcement of law and order.
Therefore, the State authorities including the 6th respondent are
not liable for any compensation as respondent No.6 has not done
any illegal act. As the Commanding Officer and her team were
not involved in the incident, the question of payment of
compensation does not arise at all. Hence, prayed for dismissal
of the writ petition.
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
Page |7
7.
Mr. Juno Rahman, the learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that in the evening of 1.8.2021, the husband
of the first petitioner had gone out to play football at the football
field located adjacent to KR Lane. While the husband of the first
petitioner and some of his friends were playing football, the
Commandant of 8th IRB and her team came around KR Lane for
enforcement of curfew. Fearing arrest and beating by the police,
the husband of the first petitioner and his friends jumped into the
Imphal River in order to escape arrest. While some of his friends
had escaped by swimming towards Kangla side river bank, the
husband of the first petitioner started drowning at Imphal River.
Although the husband of the first petitioner was drowning, none
of the police personnel moved forward to save his life, nor did the
Commandant of 8th IRB gave any order to her officers to save the
life of the first petitioner’s husband, which resulted in the recovery
of lifeless body on 3.8.2021 by NDRF personnel.
8.
The learned counsel further submitted that a Joint
Action Committee against the drown and death of Farish Khan
was formed with Md. Azad Khan as its convenor and submitted
a memorandum dated 4.8.2021 to the Hon’ble Chief Minister with
a copy to the local MLA and the other Government officials,
including the Superintendent of Police. Despite receipt of the
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
Page |8
memorandum, none of them have taken any steps towards
redressal of the grievance as meted out in the memorandum,
which necessitated the petitioners to file in filing the present writ
petition.
9.
Mr. Sh. Shyam Sharma, the learned Government
Advocate appearing for the respondents 2, 4 and 5 submitted
that the concerned Sub-Inspector of Police registered suo motu
case and during the investigation two prosecution witnesses
were examined who have spoken about the incident. He would
submit that at the relevant point of time, curfew was imposed in
the entire Imphal East District vide the order of the District
Magistrate, Imphal East dated 28.7.2021 passed in Cril. Misc.
Case No.8 of 2021.
10.
The
learned
Government
Advocate
further
submitted that the deceased died not due to excessive or
negligent act of the Commanding Officer or her escort party and
the deceased drowned himself by diving into the river to avoid
police arrest.
Therefore, the State is not liable for any
compensation.
11.
The
learned
Deputy
Government
Advocate
submitted that at the relevant point of time, no 8th IRB personnel
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
Page |9
or Commandant went to the playground of KR Lane near Imphal
river and the question of arresting any person does not arise.
The question of arresting some curfew violators and seeing the
deceased person drowning are all concocted allegations without
any legal basis. The 6th respondent and her team were nowhere
in the scene or involved in chasing the persons as the 6 th
respondent was in her quarters at the relevant point of time.
12.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
13.
The case of the petitioners is that had the police
personnel of 8th IRB not chased the deceased and others, the
deceased might not have jumped down inside the running Imphal
River on the said day and he might not have been died due to
drowning in the Imphal River. The further case of the petitioners
is that when the deceased was drowning, the personnel of 8th
IRB who were standing on the bank of the river have not tried to
rescue the deceased.
14.
The said fact though was disputed by the 6th
respondent by stating that she and her team were nowhere in the
scene or involved in chasing the persons, the statement of one
of the prosecution witnesses stated in the affidavit in opposition
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 10
of the respondents 2, 4 and 5 is to the effect that “while the other
persons crossed the river and ran towards Kangla side, the
deceased person was drowning in the river. While the deceased
person was drowning, some 3-4 police personnel and one
detainee was there”. The said statement of the prosecution
witness namely Sajina clearly shows that at the time of drowning
of the deceased, 3-4 police personnel are present. In the said
affidavit-in-opposition, it has also been stated that on 1.8.2021 at
4.30 p.m. to 5.30 p.m., when Sajina was at the upper side of the
main road near Imphal river bank, two numbers of Gypsy came
along with a woman lady officer for checking of curfew violator.
She saw three police personnel along with stick running towards
the KR Lane playground and chased some five persons. Though
the presence of the personnel of 8th IRB and its Commandant at
the relevant point of time is a matter of evidence and in this
regard, a criminal case is pending, prima facie, it proves the
occurrence and drowning of the deceased into the Imphal river
was because of chasing of the police personnel with sticks. The
pleadings of the parties also prima facie establish that none of
the police personnel moved forward to save the life of Farish
Khan and now the family of the deceased is under disappointed
position and unable to survive.
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 11
15.
The 6th respondent in her affidavit in opposition has
made a contradictory statement. In paragraph 6 beginning, the
6th respondent stated that “on 1.8.2021, no 8 IRB personnel or
Commandant went to the said playground of KR Lane near
Imphal River and as such question of chasing the deceased
person Md. Farish Khan by the CO and her party does not arise
at all”. However, in the same para, the 6th respondent stated that
“on 1.8.2021, the CO came out from her quarters at about 04.45
p.m./4.50 p.m. with her team. House Guard, Constable Premjit
was at the quarters on duty and Personnel Assistant Md. Kalam
and CO’s (caretaker) of her kids all saw CO & her team leaving
the quarters at around 4.45 p.m. …. Thereafter, the CO and her
team went to KR lane (pucca) road and found some curfew
violators and they were asked to go inside their respective
houses”. The aforesaid statement of the 6th respondent clearly
shows that at the relevant point of time the 6th respondent and
her team were patrolling at KR Lane. The 6th respondent being
a State level officer is duty bound to save the life of the deceased
by commanding her team personnel to rescue him. No ordinary
man would be a silent spectator when seeing a person drowning
in the lake or river or tank.
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 12
16.
Even though curfew was imposed at the relevant
point of time and assuming but not admitting the fact that the
deceased was in violation of curfew, that does not give any right
to the IRB team to remain a silent spectator while the deceased
was drowning in front of their eyes. That abetment act of the IRB
personnel has led to loss of a precious life.
17.
Article 21 of the Constitution of India clearly
provides that no person shall be deprived of his life or personal
liberty except according to procedure established by law. That
no procedure established by law would allow an officer to
standby while a citizen of this nation dies in front of him.
18.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Rudu
Sah v. State of Bihar and another, (1983) 4 SCC 141 held:
“10. …… Article 21 which guarantees the right
to life and liberty will be denuded of its
significant content if the power of this Court
were limited to passing orders of release from
illegal detention. One of the telling ways in
which the violation of that right can reasonably
be prevented and due compliance with the
mandate of Article 21 secured, is to mulct its
violators
in
the
payment
of
monetary
compensation. Administrative sclerosis leading
to flagrant infringements of fundamental rights
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 13
cannot be corrected by any other method open
to the judiciary to adopt. The right to
compensation is some palliative for the
unlawful acts of instrumentalities which act in
the name of public interest and which present
for their protection the powers of the State as a
shield. If civilisation is not to perish in this
country as it has perished in some others too
well known to suffer mention, it is necessary to
educate ourselves into accepting that, respect
for the rights of individuals is the true bastion of
democracy. Therefore, the State must repair
the damage done by its officers to the
petitioner's rights. It may have recourse against
those officers.”
19.
Time and again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that compensation can be granted under the public law by the
Supreme Court and High Court in addition to private law remedy
for tortuous action and punishment to wrong doer under criminal
law for established breach of fundamental rights.
20.
In D.K.Basu v. State of West Bengal, (1997) 1 SCC
416, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“44. The claim in public law for compensation for
unconstitutional deprivation of fundamental right
to life and liberty, the protection of which is
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 14
guaranteed under the Constitution, is a claim
based on strict liability and is in addition to the
claim available in private law for damages for
tortious acts of the public servants. Public law
proceedings serve a different purpose than the
private law proceedings. Award of compensation
for established infringement of the indefeasible
rights guaranteed under Article 21 of the
Constitution is a remedy available in public law
since the purpose of public law is not only to
civilise public power but also to assure the citizens
that they live under a legal system wherein their
rights and interests shall be protected and
preserved. Grant of compensation in proceedings
under Article 32 or Article 226 of the Constitution
of India for the established violation of the
fundamental rights guaranteed under Article 21, is
an exercise of the courts under the public law
jurisdiction for penalising the wrongdoer and
fixing the liability for the public wrong on the State
which failed in the discharge of its public duty to
protect the fundamental rights of the citizen.
45. The old doctrine of only relegating the
aggrieved to the remedies available in civil law
limits the role of the courts too much, as the
protector and custodian of the indefeasible rights
of the citizens. The courts have the obligation to
satisfy the social aspirations of the citizens
because the courts and the law are for the people
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 15
and expected to respond to their aspirations. A
court of law cannot close its consciousness and
aliveness to stark realities. Mere punishment of
the offender cannot give much solace to the family
of the victim — civil action for damages is a long
drawn and a cumbersome judicial process.
Monetary compensation for redressal by the court
finding the infringement of the indefeasible right to
life of the citizen is, therefore, useful and at time
perhaps the only effective remedy to apply balm
to the wounds of the family members of the
deceased victim, who may have been the
breadwinner of the family.”
21.
In Nilbati Behera v. State of Orissa and others,
(1993) 2 SCC 746, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“17. It follows that ‘a claim in public law for
compensation’ for contravention of human rights
and fundamental freedoms, the protection of
which is guaranteed in the Constitution, is an
acknowledged remedy for enforcement and
protection of such rights, and such a claim based
on strict liability made by resorting to a
constitutional
remedy
provided
for
the
enforcement of a fundamental right is ‘distinct
from, and in addition to, the remedy in private
law for damages for the tort’ resulting from the
contravention of the fundamental right. The
defence
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
of
sovereign
immunity
being
P a g e | 16
inapplicable, and alien to the concept of
guarantee of fundamental rights, there can be no
question of such a defence being available in the
constitutional remedy. It is this principle which
justifies award of monetary compensation for
contravention of fundamental rights guaranteed
by the Constitution, when that is the only
practicable mode of redress available for the
contravention made by the State or its servants
in the purported exercise of their powers, and
enforcement of the fundamental right is claimed
by resort to the remedy in public law under the
Constitution by recourse to Articles 32 and 226
of the Constitution. This is what was indicated
in Rudul Sah [(1983) 4 SCC 141 : 1983 SCC
(Cri) 798 : (1983) 3 SCR 508] and is the basis of
the
subsequent
decisions
in
which
compensation was awarded under Articles 32
and 226 of the Constitution, for contravention of
fundamental rights.
………..
20. We respectfully concur with the view that the
court is not helpless and the wide powers given
to this Court by Article 32, which itself is a
fundamental right, imposes a constitutional
obligation on this Court to forge such new tools,
which may be necessary for doing complete
justice and enforcing the fundamental rights
guaranteed in the Constitution, which enable the
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 17
award of monetary compensation in appropriate
cases, where that is the only mode of redress
available. The power available to this Court
under Article 142 is also an enabling provision in
this behalf. The contrary view would not merely
render the court powerless and the constitutional
guarantee a mirage, but may, in certain
situations, be an incentive to extinguish life, if for
the extreme contravention the court is powerless
to grant any relief against the State, except by
punishment of the wrongdoer for the resulting
offence, and recovery of damages under private
law, by the ordinary process. If the guarantee
that deprivation of life and personal liberty
cannot be made except in accordance with law,
is to be real, the enforcement of the right in case
of every contravention must also be possible in
the constitutional scheme, the mode of redress
being that which is appropriate in the facts of
each case. This remedy in public law has to be
more readily available when invoked by the
have-nots, who are not possessed of the
wherewithal for enforcement of their rights in
private law, even though its exercise is to be
tempered
by
judicial
restraint
to
avoid
circumvention of private law remedies, where
more appropriate.
……….
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 18
22. The above discussion indicates the principle
on which the court's power under Articles 32 and
226 of the Constitution is exercised to award
monetary compensation for contravention of a
fundamental right. This was indicated in Rudul
Sah [(1983) 4 SCC 141 : 1983 SCC (Cri) 798 :
(1983)
SCR
508]
and
certain
further
observations therein adverted to earlier, which
may tend to minimise the effect of the principle
indicated therein, do not really detract from that
principle. This is how the decisions of this Court
in Rudul Sah [(1983) 4 SCC 141 : 1983 SCC
(Cri) 798 : (1983) 3 SCR 508] and others in that
line
have
to
be
understood
and Kasturilal [(1965) 1 SCR 375 : AIR 1965 SC
1039 : (1965) 2 Cri LJ 144] distinguished
therefrom. We have considered this question at
some length in view of the doubt raised, at times,
about the propriety of awarding compensation in
such proceedings, instead of directing the
claimant to resort to the ordinary process of
recovery of damages by recourse to an action in
tort. In the present case, on the finding reached,
it is a clear case for award of compensation to
the petitioner for the custodial death of her son.”
22.
On 4.8.2021, a Joint Action Committee was formed
to enquire about the drowning and death of Farish Khan and a
memorandum was prepared and submitted to the Hon’ble Chief
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 19
Minister, Manipur State. According to the learned counsel for the
petitioners, despite receipt of the memorandum dated 4.8.2021,
no steps towards redressal have been taken by the respondent
authorities.
23.
On a perusal of the memorandum dated 4.8.2021
of the Joint Action Committee, it has made the following
demands:
“1. The persons related in the dead of Md. Faris
Khan due to drown on Imphal River in
connection with the routine duty by police
(uniform) headed by the team must be terminate
from their service and be fitting punishment as
per law.
2. The deceased person was a daily bread
earner and left behind one minor boy and give
Rs.10 (ten) lakhs only compensation for the
deceased family and along with one suitable
Govt. job to the next of kin.
3. Those involved in the dead of Md. Faris Khan
must be booked as soon as early before the
public.”
24.
The respondent authorities have not commented
upon the receipt of the memorandum of the Joint Action
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 20
Committee dated 4.8.2021. In their affidavit in opposition, the
respondents 2, 4 and 5 have stated that “the deponent has no
comment to offer”, which is a evasive reply filed by the
respondents 2, 4 and 5 in respect of the memorandum of the
Joint Action Committee. It is the bounden duty of the respondent
authorities to show about the steps taken on the memorandum
of the Joint Action Committee dated 4.8.2021 and the progress
in the FIR No.11/PRT-PS/2021 registered under Section 174
Cr.P.C.
However, nothing has been produced by the
respondents to show as to what steps they have taken on the
memorandum.
Therefore, as held by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, the State must make good the damage done by its officers
to the deceased and his family.
25.
A court of law cannot close its consciousness and
aliveness to stark realities. This Court is competent to pass an
appropriate order, sitting under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. Grant of compensation in proceedings under Article 226
of the Constitution for the established violation of the
fundamental rights guaranteed under Article 21 is an exercise of
the Courts under the public law jurisdiction. Considering the facts
and circumstance of the case, this is a fit case to award
compensation to the deceased poor family.
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 21
26.
Coming to the quantum of compensation to be
awarded, the petitioners claim Rs.20 lakhs as compensation.
The Joint Action Committee demanded Rs.10 lakh as
compensation to the deceased family.
As stated supra, the
deceased is a coolie at the relevant point of time and during
curfew of Covid-19, the occurrence took place.
At the time of
occurrence, the deceased was aged 26 years. The first petitioner
is aged about 25 years and the second petitioner is a minor aged
7 years. Due to the untimely death of Farish Khan, the family of
the deceased suffering serious mental torture and disappointed
in the walk of their future life. Considering the financial status of
the petitioners’ family and that the first petitioner lost her husband
at the age of 23 years and the second petitioner lost her father’s
love and affection at the age of 5 years, this Court is of the view
that it would be appropriate to direct the respondent State to pay
compensation of Rs.10.00 i.e. Rs.5.00 lakhs each to the
petitioners.
27.
In the result,
(1)
The writ petition is allowed.
(2)
The respondent State, through the
Principal
Secretary/Commissioner,
Department of Home, Government of
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
P a g e | 22
Manipur, is directed to pay a sum of
Rs.10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs)
as compensation to the petitioners.
(3)
The said amount is directed to be
paid to the petitioners within a period
of six weeks from the date of receipt
of a copy of this order.
(4)
The petitioners 1 and 2 are entitled
Rs.5.00 lakhs each.
(5)
The compensation of Rs.5.00 lakhs in
respect of the second petitioner is
directed
to
be
deposited
in
a
nationalised bank till she attains
majority and the first petitioner is
entitled
to
receive
the
accrued
interest once in three months for the
welfare of the minor.
(6)
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 573 of 2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review