The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. The allegation of diversion of nutrition intended for children and mothers is undoubtedly serious. That seriousness must receive due weight, but it cannot substitute for the examination of the material against the individual seeking bail. The stock has been seized and samples have been drawn. The apprehensions concerning interference with the investigation and witnesses can, in the circumstances of this applicant, be addressed by appropriate conditions. Having independently considered both requirements of Section 21(4), as well as the ordinary considerations governing bail, the applicant deserves to be released. Hence, the following order: 9 of 11 BA1840-26 (i) The application is allowed. (ii) Applicant Fardeen Gani Pathan shall be released on bail in Crime No.182 of 2026 registered with Jinsi Police Station, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar, upon executing a personal bond of Rs.50,000/with one or two solvent sureties in the like amount, subject to the following conditions: (a) He shall attend the Investigating Officer on the first and third Saturday of every month between 10.00 a.m. and
12. 00 noon for six months or until filing of the charge-sheet, whichever is earlier, and thereafter whenever called by written notice. (b) He shall not directly or indirectly threaten, induce or influence any prosecution witness or tamper with the evidence. (c) He shall not contact the co-accused, except as necessary for proceedings before the Court, or participate in any unlawful activity. (d) He shall furnish his residential address and mobile number to the Investigating Officer and the Special Court and intimate any change promptly. (e) He shall not leave India without prior permission of the Special Court and shall deposit his passport, if any, before that Court. (f) He shall attend the proceedings before the Special Court unless exempted. 10 of 11 BA1840-26 (iii) The observations in this order are confined to consideration of bail. The Special Court shall decide the case independently, uninfluenced by them. (iv) The application stands disposed of. ( HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.) JPChavan 11 of 11
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:53744
BA1840-26
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 1840 OF 2026
Fardeen Gani Pathan
… Applicant
Versus
The State of Maharashtra and another … Respondents
…
Mr. Dhananjay R. Gavhad, Advocate for the applicant
Mr. K. K.Naik, APP for the Respondents State
CORAM : HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.
Dated : 29th October, 2026
PER COURT :1.
The applicant seeks regular bail under Section 483 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, in connection with Crime
No.182 of 2026 registered with Jinsi Police Station, Chhatrapati
Sambhajinagar, for offences punishable under Sections 3 and 7 of the
Essential Commodities Act, 1955, Section 318 read with Section 3(5) of
the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and Sections 3(1)(ii), 3(2) and
3(4) of the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 1999. His
application for bail was rejected by the learned Special Judge on 4
August 2026.
2.
The prosecution states that information was received that
Kalim Qureshi had stored Government ration supplies in a godown
below M.R. Function Hall at Rahemaniya Colony, Kiradpura, for sale in
the black market. During the inspection of the premises, the police and
the officials of the Supply Department also noticed supplementary
1 of 11
BA1840-26
nutrition supplied through the Women and Child Development
Department. Ganesh Pungale, Child Development Project Officer,
accompanied by supervisors Usha Wankhede and Revti More, therefore
visited the premises on 13 June 2026. Upon inspection, twenty-three
bags of khichdi premix and eighteen bags of cereals and protein
premix, collectively valued at Rs.1,31,200/-, were found. One hundred
and forty empty packets bearing particulars of the Government
nutrition scheme were also found. The seized nutrition was intended
for children between six months and three years of age and for
pregnant and lactating mothers.
3.
The prosecution further states that Sameer Qureshi, who was
questioned at the premises, could not produce a licence or purchase
receipts. He stated that he and his associates purchased ration supplies
from beneficiaries and obtained supplementary nutrition received by
certain parents from Anganwadis in exchange for food grain. The
nutrition was thereafter sold to persons preparing chivda. According to
the prosecution, the accused acted together, removed the nutrition
from the Government packets and collected it in separate bags for sale
for their own monetary benefit. Samples were drawn and the stock was
seized. Crime No.182 of 2026 was consequently registered.
4.
A connected crime, being Crime No.181 of 2026, was
registered at the same police station concerning food grain, an Eicher
vehicle and other articles found at the premises. The narrative of that
FIR records a statement attributed to Sameer that the present applicant
2 of 11
BA1840-26
was their regular driver and that the accumulated grain was
transported through him in the Eicher vehicle to a company in the
Karodi area for sale. During investigation, the provisions of the MCOC
Act were added on the allegation that the accused were acting as
members of an organised crime syndicate headed by Kalim Chotu
Qureshi.
5.
Ld. Advocate for the applicant submits that the applicant is
twenty-five years old and earns his livelihood as a driver. He submits
that the applicant was not present at the premises at the relevant time,
that no property was recovered from his possession and that he had no
knowledge of the alleged diversion of Government supplies. According
to him, the applicant has been implicated on the statements of others
without material showing his conscious participation in the alleged
activity. He further submits that the applicant has no previous criminal
history apart from the connected Crime No.181 of 2026, in which he
has been granted bail. The earlier charge-sheets referred to by the
learned Special Judge concern other accused and cannot, by
themselves, establish the applicant’s membership of the alleged
syndicate.
6.
Ld. Advocate for the applicant further submits that the
requirements of continuing unlawful activity and organised crime have
not been established against the applicant. He relies upon State of
Maharashtra v. Shiva @ Shivaji Ramaji Sonawane , (2015) 14 SCC 272,
and Zakir Abdul Mirajkar v. State of Maharashtra , decided on 24
3 of 11
BA1840-26
August 2022. He also disputes compliance with Section 23(1)(a) of the
MCOC Act and submits that the prosecution must identify the order
under Section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act which is alleged to
have been contravened. Relying upon State of Maharashtra v. Bharat
Shanti Lal Shah, he submits that bail in another offence does not attract
an automatic prohibition under Section 21(5) of the MCOC Act. He
submits that the property has already been seized, the applicant’s
parents depend upon him and his presence can be secured by
appropriate conditions.
7.
Ld. APP opposes the application and submits that Government
supplies intended for vulnerable beneficiaries were diverted for sale in
the black market. He submits that the applicant assisted the other
accused in their organised activity and that the earlier charge-sheets
referred to in the order of the learned Special Judge demonstrate
continuing unlawful activity by the syndicate. He relies upon the
quantity and nature of the seized stock, the alleged role of the
applicant in transporting the grain and the seriousness of the offence.
He further submits that release of the applicant may enable him to
influence witnesses or obstruct the investigation.
8.
The application requires consideration in the light of Section
21(4) of the MCOC Act. The prosecution has opposed bail and,
therefore, the Court must be satisfied that there are reasonable grounds
for believing that the applicant is not guilty of the offence under that
Act and that he is not likely to commit an offence while on bail. In
4 of 11
BA1840-26
Ranjitsing Brahmajeetsing Sharma v. State of Maharashtra, (2005) 5
SCC 294, the Supreme Court explained that this provision does not
require a positive finding of innocence. The assessment must rest upon
broad probabilities, while maintaining the distinction between an order
granting bail and a judgment after trial. The applicant’s antecedents
and the nature of his alleged participation are also relevant to the
likelihood of his committing an offence under the Act while on bail.
9.
The submission that MCOCA cannot apply because no
previous charge-sheet was filed against the applicant personally cannot
be accepted as an absolute proposition. In Zakir Abdul Mirajkar
(Supra), the Supreme Court held that the requirement of more than
one charge-sheet concerns the organised crime syndicate and need not
be satisfied separately against every person alleged to be its member.
Nevertheless, the connection of the particular accused with the
syndicate remains essential. Thus, the earlier cases against the alleged
leader and other members may establish the statutory history of the
syndicate, but the applicant’s participation must still be examined from
the material concerning him.
10.
The learned Special Judge has referred to earlier charge-sheets
against Kalim Chotu Qureshi and other accused. For the present
consideration, even accepting that the prosecution has the requisite
material concerning the alleged syndicate’s earlier activities, that
circumstance does not answer the separate question of the applicant’s
conscious involvement. The conclusion in Shiva @ Shivaji Ramaji
5 of 11
BA1840-26
Sonawane (supra)that previous charge-sheets alone do not establish
the offence under MCOCA must be understood in this sense. That
decision does not dispense with the examination of the present activity
or the particular accused’s connection with it.
11.
Turning to the material concerning this applicant, the FIR
narrative identifies Sameer as the person questioned regarding the
stock, its storage and the absence of purchase receipts. His explanation
concerns the manner in which he and his associates obtained ration
supplies and supplementary nutrition from beneficiaries. Although the
applicant is named amongst the accused, that narrative does not
describe him purchasing or exchanging the supplementary nutrition,
removing it from Government packets, storing it or negotiating its sale.
The allegation specifically identifying his work appears in the
connected FIR, where Sameer is stated to have described him as their
regular driver through whom grain was transported.
12.
A driver who knowingly assists an organised crime syndicate
cannot claim immunity merely because his assigned work is
transportation. In the present case, however, the description of the
applicant as a regular driver must be considered together with the
material showing his knowledge and participation. The documents
placed before the Court do not identify any particular journey
undertaken by him carrying the supplementary nutrition seized in this
crime or any transaction in which he knowingly assisted its diversion.
Nor do they describe any payment or other circumstance connecting his
6 of 11
BA1840-26
work as a driver with conscious participation in the alleged organised
activity. These observations concern the strength of the accusation at
the stage of bail and do not determine the applicant’s defence finally.
13.
The learned Special Judge has observed that the stock valued
at Rs.1,31,200/- was found in the applicant’s possession. That
observation does not find corresponding particulars in the FIR
narrative, which identifies Sameer as the person questioned at the
premises. The general allegation of joint activity cannot, without
examining the applicant’s individual connection, be treated as a
personal recovery from him. The seizure establishes the existence of the
stock and provides material concerning its alleged diversion. Its
quantity and Government origin, however, do not by themselves
establish the applicant’s knowledge or his membership of the alleged
syndicate. On the material available, the allegation against him remains
substantially dependent upon the role attributed to him as a driver,
without sufficient supporting circumstances showing that he knowingly
furthered the organised criminal activity.
14.
The need to examine such individual connection is also
reflected in the Supreme Court’s order dated 27 October 2026 in
Gulamgaus Nasruddin Mukadam v. State of Maharashtra, arising out of
Special Leave Petition (Criminal) Diary No.59067 of 2026. In that case,
the Court granted relief where the implication under MCOCA rested
upon a co-accused’s disclosure without seizure or other material
substantiating the allegation against the applicant. That order turns
7 of 11
BA1840-26
upon its own facts, but it reinforces the distinction between an
allegation made by another accused and material supporting the
particular applicant’s involvement.
15.
The objections concerning prior approval and the precise
control order alleged to have been contravened need not be decided
conclusively in this application. Even proceeding on the basis that the
invocation of MCOCA is procedurally valid and that the seized supplies
were subject to the restrictions relied upon by the prosecution, the
material concerning this applicant falls short of sufficiently connecting
him with knowing participation in the alleged organised crime. The
same consideration is relevant to the accusation of cheating and
unlawful diversion. The applicant is not being granted bail merely
because a particular document is not annexed to his application, but
upon consideration of the role attributed to him in the FIRs and the
prosecution material described in the order rejecting bail.
16.
Upon considering that material as a whole, there are
reasonable grounds, for the limited purpose of Section 21(4), for
believing that the applicant is not guilty of the offences under the
MCOC Act. This satisfaction rests upon the nature of his alleged role,
the absence of a sufficiently supported connection between his work as
a driver and the organised criminal activity, and the distinction
between the recovery at the godown and the allegation against him
individually. It is a tentative assessment for bail and does not amount
to a finding that the prosecution cannot establish its case at trial.
8 of 11
BA1840-26
17.
The second statutory requirement also warrants consideration
independently. The earlier charge-sheets discussed by the learned
Special Judge principally concern the alleged leader and other accused.
They cannot be treated as the applicant’s personal antecedents. The
other case disclosed against the applicant is Crime No.181 of 2026,
registered in connection with the inspection of the same premises. Its
registration cannot, without more, demonstrate a history of repeated
offending by him. Considering his age, occupation, fixed residence, the
limited role presently attributed to him and the absence of other
identified antecedents in the available material, the Court is satisfied
that he is not likely to commit an offence under the MCOC Act while on
bail. Conditions restricting contact with the co-accused and witnesses
and requiring regular attendance will further secure his conduct and
availability.
18.
The allegation of diversion of nutrition intended for children
and mothers is undoubtedly serious. That seriousness must receive due
weight, but it cannot substitute for the examination of the material
against the individual seeking bail. The stock has been seized and
samples have been drawn. The apprehensions concerning interference
with the investigation and witnesses can, in the circumstances of this
applicant,
be
addressed
by
appropriate
conditions.
Having
independently considered both requirements of Section 21(4), as well
as the ordinary considerations governing bail, the applicant deserves to
be released. Hence, the following order:
9 of 11
BA1840-26
ORDER
(i)
The application is allowed.
(ii)
Applicant Fardeen Gani Pathan shall be released on bail in Crime
No.182 of 2026 registered with Jinsi Police Station, Chhatrapati
Sambhajinagar, upon executing a personal bond of Rs.50,000/with one or two solvent sureties in the like amount, subject to the
following conditions:
(a)
He shall attend the Investigating Officer on the first and
third Saturday of every month between 10.00 a.m. and
12.00 noon for six months or until filing of the charge-sheet,
whichever is earlier, and thereafter whenever called by
written notice.
(b)
He shall not directly or indirectly threaten, induce or
influence any prosecution witness or tamper with the
evidence.
(c)
He shall not contact the co-accused, except as necessary for
proceedings before the Court, or participate in any unlawful
activity.
(d)
He shall furnish his residential address and mobile number
to the Investigating Officer and the Special Court and
intimate any change promptly.
(e)
He shall not leave India without prior permission of the
Special Court and shall deposit his passport, if any, before
that Court.
(f)
He shall attend the proceedings before the Special Court
unless exempted.
10 of 11
BA1840-26
(iii) The observations in this order are confined to consideration of
bail. The Special Court shall decide the case independently,
uninfluenced by them.
(iv) The application stands disposed of.
( HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.)
JPChavan
11 of 11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review