The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Resultantly, to sum up, above all are the shortfalls in the case of prosecution. As stated above, complainant himself has deposed that on the first visit, accused no. 1 asked him whether he brought the amount, however it is proved to be a material omission. Hence, when initial demand itself is not proved, or rendered doubtful, case of prosecution cannot be said to be proved beyond reasonable doubt.
16. Perused the judgment under challenge. The above discussed aspects and features does not seem to be considered and appreciated by learned trial court. Crucial aspect of initial demand being found to be a material omission, learned trial court ought not to have accepted the case of prosecution as against accused no.1, more particularly when accused no.2, who had actually accepted the tainted currency, was acquitted and when shadow pancha has candidly admitted that accused no.2 was not aware and had no knowledge as to for what purpose amount was accepted by him. Above discussion also shows CriAppeal-614-2016 -12- that on the date of main trap dated 18.03.2010, there was no work of 7/12 extract with accused as it was already done on 17.03.2010 of which there is admission by PW3 shadow pancha. Resultantly, findings of the trial court as regards to accused no.1, who admittedly did not receive or had not accepted the bribe, ought not to have been held guilty. Hence, following order : The appeal is allowed. The conviction awarded to the appellant Eknath Gorakh Thakkur by learned Special Judge, Dhule in Special Case (ACB) No. 98 of 2010 for offence under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act, on 29.09.2016 stands quashed and set aside. III. The appellant Eknath Gorakh Thakkur stands acquitted of the offence punishable under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act. IV. The ba…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:50921
CriAppeal-614-2016
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 614 OF 2016
Eknath Gorakh Thakkur,
Age : 57 years, Occupation : Talathi,
R/o : Plot No. 56, Laxminagar,
Deopur, Dhule.
… Appellant
[Orig. Accused No.1]
Versus
State of Maharashtra
… Respondent
…..
Mr. Joydeep Chatterji, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mrs. A. S. Mantri, APP for the Respondent-State.
.....
CORAM :
ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.
Reserved on
Pronounced on
: 16.10.2026
: 22.10.2026
JUDGMENT :
1.
Appellant, a convict for offence under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) r/w
13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act) vide
judgment and order dated 29.09.2016 passed by learned Special
Judge, Dhule in Special Case (ACB) No. 98 of 2010, has preferred the
instant appeal questioning the said judgment and order of conviction.
PROSECUTION CASE IN BRIEF
In brief, case of prosecution in trial court was that, complainant
lost his mother and there was land in her name. Including
-2-
CriAppeal-614-2016
complainant, there were three sisters also and these sisters had
relinquished their share and rights and on the strength of
relinquishment deed, complainant made application with Revenue
authorities i.e. Tahasil Office, for removing sisters’ names form 7/12
extract. According to prosecution, to do the said work, there was
demand of bribe of Rs.5000/- and on negotiations, it was reduced to
Rs.3000/-. Complainant approached ACB and put up his grievance,
after which ACB authorities took steps of arranging panchas, planning
trap and finally executing it. At the instance of accused no.1, accused
no.2 accepted the bribe amount and accused persons were duly
apprehended. Learned trial court acquitted accused no.2 but
convicted appellant-accused no.1 alone for offence under Sections 7,
13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act.
SUBMISSIONS
On behalf of the Appellant-Convict :
3.
Learned counsel would submit that there is false implication.
According to him, prosecution failed to prove the charges beyond
reasonable doubt. He would submit that, on the point of demand,
prosecution witnesses i.e. complainant and shadow pancha are not
consistent. Secondly, prosecution’s evidence itself shows that, on the
date of main trap, no work was pending, rather it was already done
-3-
CriAppeal-614-2016
and therefore there was no question of demanding bribe or accepting
it. He pointed out that, here, admittedly case of prosecution was that
bribe was accepted by accused no.2 on behalf of accused no.1, but
learned trial court has, on complete evaluation of evidence, already
acquitted accused no.2. He would also point out that, prosecution
witnesses themselves admit that, accused no.1 did not take bribe and
it was also not recovered from him. In fact, it was found to be kept on
table by accused no.2. That, complainant’s version is also not free
from doubt as, according to him, he had not attached 7/12 extract
(Exh. 40) along with the complaint, but contrary to it is the evidence
of the Investigating Officer, who admits that copy of 7/12 extract was
also accompanying the complaint. Thus, according to learned counsel,
case of prosecution not being proved beyond reasonable doubt, and it
being full of material omissions and contradictions, learned trial court
ought not to have convicted accused no.1 appellant. For above
reasons, he prays to allow the appeal by setting aside the impugned
judgment.
On behalf of the Respondent-State :
4.
Per contra, learned APP would submit that, demand by accused
no.1 is categorically proved by prosecution beyond reasonable doubt
and therefore learned trial court rightly convicted the appellant.
-4-
CriAppeal-614-2016
BRIEF ACCOUNT OF THE EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIAL COURT
5.
It seems that, in support of its case, prosecution has adduced
evidence of in all five witnesses, i.e. PW1 and PW4 are the
sanctioning authorities, PW2 Sadashiv is the complainant, PW3 Dattu
is the shadow pancha and PW5 is the Investigating Officer.
6.
Re-appreciated the evidence. There is no challenge to the
aspect of sanction and this was conceded by learned counsel for the
appellant. Therefore, the only aspect that needs to be ascertained is
whether charges are proved against accused no.1-appellant.
7.
PW2 Complainant’s evidence is at Exhibit 38. He deposed about
approaching accused no.1 Talathi with application for removal of his
sisters’ names from 7/12 extract on the strength of relinquishment
deed. He deposed that, on 15.03.2010 first demand was made by
accused no.1 to the tune of Rs.5000/- but it was reduced to
Rs.3000/-. Then he deposed about second demand on 17.03.2010
and on that day, accused allegedly said that unless Rs.3000/- are
paid, his work would not be done, and therefore he approached ACB
and there, panchas were called and he and pancha were given
necessary instructions and demonstration. In para 8 he deposed that,
he and pancha reached Talathi office and there, he asked accused
-5-
CriAppeal-614-2016
whether his work was done. However, accused no.1 asked him
whether he brought amount, and it was confirmed by complainant
and further, accused asked him to come after half an hour and
therefore he and pancha came back to the raiding party and after half
an hour they again went to the office of accused. He deposed that,
this time also he asked whether his work was done, upon which
accused allegedly said that, had he paid money earlier, that time only
his work would have been done. Then accused gave complainant
copy of 7/12 extract and asked him to give money, upon which
complainant removed amount from his left pocket with right hand
and held it before accused no.1, but accused no.1 said to one person
sitting near him, namely Gautam, to take the amount and accordingly
complainant gave it to Gautam who accepted it, after which
predetermined signal was given.
While under cross, he denied giving 7/12 extract (Exh.40)
while lodging complaint. Then he is questioned about relinquishment
deed and its notarization and whether his sisters made application
and whether they were taken to the Talathi office. He denied meeting
Circle Officer on 17.03.2010. He also denied he and his wife going to
the office of accused no.1 on 18.03.2010. In para 15, he answered
that, when he met accused at around 10.55 a.m., at that time, in the
-6-
CriAppeal-614-2016
office of accused no.1, one Prakash Mali was present and he was also
present there when he came out to give predetermined signal. He
answered that, before he removed amount from the pocket, accused
no. 1 had given him 7/12 extract. In para 18, omission is brought on
the point that, when he went to the office of accused no.1 and asked
him whether his work is done, accused no.1 asked him whether
amount is brought; that accused no.1 gave copy of 7/12 extract and
told him to give money. He is unable to state why above material is
missing from his statement. Thus, it is material omission. In para 22,
he admitted that, accused no.1 has not accepted amount from him.
He also answered that he does not know whether accused no.2 was
knowing or not as to for what purpose money was given. He also
answered that when raiding party came, accused no.2 removed the
amount from his pocket and kept it on the table. Rest is all denial.
8.
On visiting evidence of PW3 shadow pancha, in initial chief, he
deposed about visiting ACB office, being introduced to complainant,
hearing his oral complaint, signing on the written complaint and ACB
officer giving necessary instructions and giving demonstration. In
para 5 he deposed that, he and complainant walked to the office of
accused no.1 and there, complainant met accused no.1 and asked him
whether his work was done, upon which said Talathi asked
-7-
CriAppeal-614-2016
complainant whether he had brought Rs.3000/-, upon which
complainant said “yes”. In para 6, he deposed that, thereafter accused
no.1 told him to wait for half an hour and that he would prepare 7/12
extract. In para 7, he deposed that again after half an hour when he
and complainant went to the office of accused, complainant asked
accused whether his work was done, but again accused asked
complainant whether he brought Rs.3000/- and on that, complainant
said “yes” and accused no.1 told complainant to give the said amount
to one person who was standing there, and accordingly complainant
gave amount of Rs.3000/- to that person who accepted it in his right
hand and kept in his pocket, after which complainant gave predetermined signal.
While under cross, he denied that complainant told him that
accused gave him copy of 7/12 extract on 17.03.2010. He further
answered that on 18.03.2010, one extract was shown to him in the
ACB office which was given by accused no.1, but he answered that,
complainant had not told the date on which 7/12 extract was given to
him by accused no.1. He further answered that, ACB officer asked
complainant as to when he got the 7/12 extract and complainant
answered that on 17.03.2010 he had received the 7/12 extract. In
para 14, he answered that when he and complainant first entered the
-8-
CriAppeal-614-2016
office of accused no.1, he did not ask to give amount that time. He
also answered that, some villagers were present there during both the
visits to the office of accused. He answered that, at the time of trap
panchanama, inquiry was made with one person namely Prakash
Mali. He also answered that, at that time wife of complainant was
also present in the office of Talathi and that, when first time also they
entered the office of accused, wife of complainant was present there.
He again confirmed that during second visit also wife of complainant
was present with him. He answered that 7/12 extract given by
accused no.1 to complainant was also examined under UV light but
no glittering was found over it. He answered that, after giving bribe
amount, accused no.1 gave 7/12 extract.
9.
Therefore, on minute scrutiny of above discussed evidence,
here, there is material omission in the evidence of complainant
regarding which there is admission from him that, after reaching the
office of accused-appellant, when he was asked about the work,
accused had asked whether amount was brought. This omission is
proved through Investigating Officer also. This is material omission
for the reason that, it is on the aspect of very initial demand, which
essentially has to be proved.
-9-
10.
CriAppeal-614-2016
Second feature of this case is that, though complainant claims
that during second visit accused allegedly said to complainant that,
had he paid earlier, his work would have been done, is not stated by
his companion shadow pancha PW3 as his testimony is silent to such
conversation between complainant and accused.
11.
Yet another feature of this case is that, complainant and pancha
witnesses are not consistent on the sequence of give and take of 7/12
extract and currency. According to complainant, accused no.1 initially
handed over 7/12 extract and thereafter asked complainant to pay
currency to accused no.2 Gautam. However, contrary to it, shadow
pancha speaks that initially tainted currency was passed on and
thereafter 7/12 extract was received. If such is the sequence, then
obviously 7/12 extract must also carry anthracene traces, but shadow
pancha admitted in cross that there was no glittering on the 7/12
extract.
12.
Another aspect is that, in cross complainant answered that he
did not tender 7/12 extract (Exh.40) with his complaint. However
Investigating Officer confirms about complaint to be accompanied by
7/12 extract. The Investigating Officer has also admitted that he had
collected the extract of Mutation Entry No. 396 dated 22.01.2010 in
-10-
CriAppeal-614-2016
presence of panchas and as per said extract, entry of relinquishment
deed was already taken by the concerned revenue officer prior to
lodging of the complaint by PW2. Shadow Pancha PW3 also, in cross
para 9 answered that complainant told him that he met accused on
17.03.2010 but shadow pancha denied that complainant told him that
accused also gave copy of 7/12 extract on 17.03.2010 itself. Shadow
Pancha also admitted that complainant had not submitted 7/12
extract along with the complaint, however in further cross, he
answered that ACB officer asked complainant as to when he got the
7/12 extract and complainant told that he had received it on
17/03/2010. Therefore, if this is so, then complainant has already
received 7/12 extract prior to the main trap dated 18.03.2010.
Therefore, doubt arises as to what was the occasion for complainant
to give bribe when his work was already done.
13.
Both, complainant and shadow pancha have admitted that
when they went to the office of accused, at that time, other villagers
were present. Shadow Pancha categorically admitted that one Prakash
Mali was present throughout till pre-determined signal was given.
Under such circumstances, this witness Prakash Mali ought to have
been examined by prosecution, but he has not been examined.
-11-
14.
CriAppeal-614-2016
It is also noticed that, complainant flatly denied that his wife
was accompanying him to the office of accused. But contrary to it,
shadow pancha confirms that on both the visits on the day of main
trap, complainant’s wife was accompanying complainant. However,
she also does not seem to be examined.
15.
Resultantly, to sum up, above all are the shortfalls in the case of
prosecution. As stated above, complainant himself has deposed that
on the first visit, accused no. 1 asked him whether he brought the
amount, however it is proved to be a material omission. Hence, when
initial demand itself is not proved, or rendered doubtful, case of
prosecution cannot be said to be proved beyond reasonable doubt.
16.
Perused the judgment under challenge. The above discussed
aspects and features does not seem to be considered and appreciated
by learned trial court. Crucial aspect of initial demand being found to
be a material omission, learned trial court ought not to have accepted
the case of prosecution as against accused no.1, more particularly
when accused no.2, who had actually accepted the tainted currency,
was acquitted and when shadow pancha has candidly admitted that
accused no.2 was not aware and had no knowledge as to for what
purpose amount was accepted by him. Above discussion also shows
CriAppeal-614-2016
-12-
that on the date of main trap dated 18.03.2010, there was no work of
7/12 extract with accused as it was already done on 17.03.2010 of
which there is admission by PW3 shadow pancha. Resultantly,
findings of the trial court as regards to accused no.1, who admittedly
did not receive or had not accepted the bribe, ought not to have been
held guilty. Hence, following order :
ORDER
I.
The appeal is allowed.
II.
The conviction awarded to the appellant Eknath Gorakh Thakkur
by learned Special Judge, Dhule in Special Case (ACB) No. 98 of
2010 for offence under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC
Act, on 29.09.2016 stands quashed and set aside.
III. The appellant Eknath Gorakh Thakkur stands acquitted of the
offence punishable under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the
PC Act.
IV. The bail bonds of the appellant stand cancelled.
V.
Fine amount deposited, if any, be refunded to the appellant after
the statutory period.
VI. It is clarified that there is no change as regards the order
regarding disposal of muddemal.
[ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, J.]
vre
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review