Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:51134
WP.14527-26.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.14527 OF 2026
Eknath Chandrabhan Ghogare,
Age : _ years, Occu. Agriculture,
R/o Loni Khurd, Taluka Rahata,
District Ahilyanagar.
… Petitioner
Versus
1.
The State of Maharashtra,
Through its Secretary,
Co-operation, Marketing and
Textiles Department, Mantralaya,
Mumbai 400 032.
2.
The State Co-operative Election Authority,
Maharashtra State, Pune,
Through its Commissioner/Secretary.
3.
The District Co-operative Election Officer
and Divisional Joint Registrar,
Co-operative Societies, Nashik Division,
Gruhnirman Bhavan, Gadkari Chowk, Nashik.
4.
The Returning Officer,
and District Deputy Registrar,
Co-operative Societies, Ahilyanagar,
Office at: Hall of the Chahurana Branch
of the said Bank, Second Floor, Ahilyanagar.
5.
The Ahmednagar District Central
Co-operative Bank Ltd., (ADCC Bank)
Head Office: Station Road,
Ahilyanagar-414 001,
Through its Chief Executive Officer.
6.
Dr. Sujay Radhakrishna Vikhe Patil,
Age: 45 years, Occu.: Political Leader/ Doctor,
R/o: At Post Loni Bk., Tq. Rahata,
Dist. Ahilyanagar.
… Respondents
WP.14527-26.odt
...
Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr. Prateek R. Talwar a/w Mr.
Rishab R. Talwar.
AGP for Respondent/State : Mr. S. K. Tambe.
Advocate for Respondent Nos.2 to 4 : Mr. S. K. Kadam.
Advocate for Respondent No.5 : Mr. V. R. Dhorde.
Advocate for Respondent No.6 : Mr. V. D. Hon (Senior
Advocate) i/b Mr. A. D. Ostwal.
...
CORAM :
MANJUSHA A. DESHPANDE, J.
RESERVED ON
: 16.10.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 22.10.2026
JUDGMENT :
1.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard with the
consent of the respective parties.
2.
The petitioner in this Writ Petition has raised challenge
to the order dated 06.10.2026, passed by respondent
No.4/Returning Officer. The objection raised by the petitioner
to nomination of respondent No.6 in the election of respondent
No.5/Bank has been turned down. Thus, being aggrieved by
the said order, the petitioner is approaching this Court.
3.
The petitioner’s name is included in the voters list of
respondent No.5/Bank in his capacity as an authorized
representative of Vividh Karyakari Seva Sahakari Society, Loni
WP.14527-26.odt
Khurd. His name is included in the list of voters for Primary
Agricultural Credit Supply/Vividh Karyakari Seva Sahakari
Societies, Grain Bank Co-operative Societies and other similar
societies constituency in Taluka Rahata, for the election of the
Board of Directors of respondent No.5/Bank for the term from
2026 to 2031.
4.
Learned advocate Mr. Talwar submits that, the petitioner
is a voter of the very constituency from which respondent No.6
is contesting election. According to the petitioner, respondent
No.6 has under his own signature executed a registered
Indenture of joint and several liability and notarized
‘Hamipatra’ in favour of respondent No.5/Bank, thereby
binding himself personally and jointly to repay the restructured loan of respondent No.5/Bank on behalf of Dr.
Baburao Bapuji Tanpure Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. It is
submitted that, the said Karkhana is admittedly in default of
the loan availed from respondent No.5/Bank. Since respondent
No.6 has undertaken to repay the loan of respondent
No.5/Bank in capacity of one of the Directors of the Dr. Bapuji
Tanpure
Sahakari
Sakhar
Karkhana,
by
executing
an
agreement it is a primary responsibility of respondent No.6 to
WP.14527-26.odt
clear the dues of Karkhana, which they owed to respondent
No.5/Bank. It is further submitted that, since respondent No.6
with the other Directors has undertaken to repay the loan of
the bank in case of failure of the Karkhana to pay the same,
being a ‘guarantor’ he has been made a nominal member of the
bank. It is submitted that, he has been added as a nominal
member of the bank as per bye law No.11 of the standard bye
laws for the District Central Co-operative Bank. Since the Dr.
Bapuji Tanpure Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana, has defaulted in
repayment of the loan even after re-structuring the loan,
respondent No.6 owes responsibility to repay the loan. In view
of the Hamipatra, that has been executed by all the Directors of
the sugar factory, they are jointly and personally responsible
for the repayment of re-structured loan.
5.
He further submits that, the ‘Karkhana’ of which
respondent No.6 is an expert Director, had obtained various
loans and had become non performing asset on 31.10.2012.
The Bank issued a notice under Section 13(2) of the
Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and
Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (in short “SARFAESI
Act”) on 19.09.2013 for its dues of about 57.08 crores. On
WP.14527-26.odt
24.04.2017, possession of the movable and immovable assets
of the factory were taken over under Section 14 of the
SARFAESI Act. It is submitted that, the Board of Directors by its
resolution dated 15.04.2017, requested the bank to restructure
the overdue loan and to hand over the factory to the Board of
Directors. Accordingly, a resolution was passed to convert the
overdue amount of Rs.8973.82 lakhs together with the legal
expenses, in the long term re-structured loan. One of the
condition in the bank’s sanction letter was that, after the bank
executes supurtnama of assets in favour of the factory, the
entire responsibility of running of the factory shall be that of
Board of Directors and a registered ‘Hamipatra’ by existing
Board of Directors, shall be executed in furtherance thereto.
The Hamipatra has been executed by all the Board of Directors
including respondent No.6, who claims to be the ‘expert
Director’.
Therefore, according to the petitioners, since the
Karkhana is unable to repay the loan, it is now the
responsibility of the guarantor, who has undertaken to repay
the loan, as a result of which, the guarantors are defaulter of
the bank.
6.
It is submitted that, Section 73CA(1)(i) of the
WP.14527-26.odt
Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 (in short “MCS
Act”), provides the disqualifications for becoming member of a
committee. No person is eligible for being nominated elected,
co-opted or for being a member of committee if he is a
defaulter of any society. Thus, according to him, the word ‘any
society’ is wide enough and includes the petitioner who is the
guarantor for the Karkhana. Since respondent No.6 has failed
to discharge his duty as a guarantor, he is a defaulter as per
Section 73CA(1)(i) of the MCS Act.
7.
In support of his submission, he has relied on the
decision of this Court in case of Damodar Shamrao Pande Vs.
State of Maharashtra and others [2017(1) ALL MR 822] ,
where this Court has held that, the provisions of Section
73CA(1)(i) of the MCS Act in clear and unambiguous terms
provide that a person will be disqualified to be a member of
the Committee, if he is defaulter of ‘any’ Society. He, therefore,
submits that in view of aforementioned decision of this Court,
it is sufficient that a member is defaulter of any society for
disqualifying him. He further submitted that, as per Section
128 of the Contract Act 1872, the liability of a surety is
coextensive with that of the principle debtor, unless it is
WP.14527-26.odt
otherwise provided by the contract. Thus, according to him, in
view of Section 128 of the Contract Act, it is the liability of
respondent No.6 to repay the loan and since it is an admitted
position that the Karkhana is in default of the loan, thus, the
respondent No.6 is undoubtedly a ‘defaulter’. It is submitted
that, the rules and bye laws are made to ensure purity of
administration of the Co-operative Societies and if respondent
No.6 is allowed to be elected, who himself is a defaulter, it
would be against the very object of the bank, which he would
be representing. He would not be in a position to secure the
interest of the bank, of which, he himself is a ‘defaulter’.
8.
Reliance is placed on the decision of Murlidhar Bhaulal
Malu and others Vs. Sudhakar Honaji Patil and another [AIR
1988 Bom. 256]. It is submitted that respondent No.4 has
passed an order without calling any record and ignoring the
submissions made on behalf of the petitioner. He would further
submit that, without due consideration of the rules and in
absence of record, a cryptic and unreasoned order has been
passed
by
respondent
No.4.
Thus, according
to
him,
respondent No.4 has failed to exercise the jurisdiction
conferred on him under Rule 25 of the Maharashtra State Co-
WP.14527-26.odt
operative Societies (Election to Committee) Rules, 2014 (in
short “Rules of 2014”). It is submitted that it was the duty of
the Returning Officer to examine the nomination papers and
all the objections while conducting a summary inquiry. While
doing so, he was bound to take into consideration the objection
raised by the petitioner, about the disqualification of
respondent No.6, which is against the rules and bye laws of the
MCS Act. He, therefore, submitted that, interference by this
Court is necessitated for restraining respondent No.6 from
contesting the election of respondent No.5/Bank.
9.
Learned Senior Advocate Mr. V. D. Hon appearing for
respondent No.6, who is the contesting respondent, raises a
preliminary objection to the maintainability of the present Writ
Petition on the ground that, as per the election programme for
respondent No.5/Bank, the election process is now at a very
advance stage. As per the election programme, valid
nominations have been declared on 07.10.2026 itself. Thus, at
this stage, the interference of this Court is not warranted. The
only remedy now available to the petitioner is in the form of
raising election dispute as provided under Rule 78 of the Rules
of 2014.
10.
WP.14527-26.odt
He would further submit that, the petitioner has not
come before this Court with clean hands, since he has
suppressed the fact that, his own nomination has been
rejected. Therefore, he does not have any right to challenge the
nomination of respondent No.6, before this Court. He further
submitted that, there are various constituencies provided under
the bye laws of respondent No.5/Bank, the respondent No.6
has filed his nomination from the constituency of Primary
Agricultural Co-operative Societies and Grain Bank Cooperative Societies and other similar societies etc. whereas the
petitioner had filed in his nomination from the constituency of
Agricultural
Allied
Societies
and
Agricultural
Produce
Processing and Marketing Societies, hence, thus there is no
conflict of interest.
11.
He further submitted that, although it is claimed by the
petitioner that respondent No.6 is a defaulter, till date, no
order or any declaration has been issued by any Authority or
Court declaring respondent No.6 to be the defaulter of
respondent No.5/Bank.
According to him, for passing any
order or declaring an individual to be a defaulter, remedy
WP.14527-26.odt
under Sections 79, 85, 88 is required to be resorted for seeking
such declaration. He submitted that respondent No.4 has
rightly passed order under Rule 25 of the Rules of 2014.
12.
It is submitted that, as provided under Rule 25, after
scrutiny of the nomination papers, on the grounds provided in
Rule 25(2) of the Rules of 2014, respondent No.4 did not find
that the candidature of respondent No.6, violative of the Act,
Rules and the bye laws. Therefore, he has accepted the
nomination of respondent No.6. He further submitted that
against the rejection of nomination, there is a remedy provided
under Section 152(A) of the MCS Act. But, no such remedy is
provided if the nomination form is accepted. This is for the
obvious reason that, the legislature in its wisdom as thought it
fit not to provide any such remedy with an intention to
minimize interference in the election process.
13.
In support of his submission, he has relied on the
decision of this Court in Writ Petition No.3493 of 2021,
Shrikant Bhimraoji Gawande Vs. District Co-operative Election
Officer and Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-op. Societies,
Amravati and others, where this Court has made the above
WP.14527-26.odt
observations, while considering Section 152(A) of MCS Act,
which provides a remedy only against the rejection of
nomination form and no remedy is provided if the nomination
form is accepted. Thus, according to him, once the nomination
form of respondent No.6 is accepted, the only remedy available
to the petitioner is filing dispute as provided under Rule 78 of
the Rules of 2014. In support of his submission that, after the
election process has commenced, the Court should normally
not interfere, he would rely on the decision of Shrikant
Gawande (supra), which takes into consideration the various
decisions, about interference of the Courts, in the election
process. More particularly, referring to the decision in Shri.
Sant Sadguru Janardan Swami Vs. State of Maharashtra and
others [2001 (8) SCC 509] as well as Pandurang Laxman
Kadam and others Vs. State of Maharashtra and others
[2016(4) ALL MR], it is held by this Court that, in fact hands
off policy in regard to interference by the Courts in election,
has been reiterated by the Hon’ble Apex Court in case of State
of Goa Vs. Fouziya Imtiaz Shaikh and another [2021 SCC
Online SC 211]. It is held that, at times it is not possible for the
Returning Officer, to decide upon the objections raised,
WP.14527-26.odt
considering the limited nature of inquiry to be conducted by
him, in limited time frame, while deciding the question of
validity of the nomination, hence it would not be appropriate
to expect an indepth inquiry, while considering the objections
to the nomination of a candidate.
14.
Learned advocate Mr. Kadam appearing for respondent
Nos.2 to 4 submitted that, the procedure under Rule 25 of the
Rules of 2014, is summary in nature. By drawing attention of
this Court to Rule 25(5) of the Rules of 2014, he submitted
that, according to the procedure prescribed under this rule, on
the appointed date, the Returning Officer is required to decide
objection to the nomination. Thus, except summary inquiry, the
Returning Officer is not able to go into the disputed questions
of fact as well as law. Only in case an adjournment is sought,
time is allowed to rebut the allegations made against the
candidate not later than the next day before the publication of
list of valid nomination. The Returning Officer is bound to take
decision on the date, on which, it is adjourned. He, therefore,
submitted that in spite of the limitations as provided in the
Rules of 2014, respondent No.4 has conducted a summary
inquiry while passing the order impugned. He has recorded all
WP.14527-26.odt
the submissions and the grounds raised to the nomination of
respondent No.6, as can be seen from the impugned order.
Only after recording the objection of the petitioner and also
granting an opportunity to respondent No.6, he has passed a
reasoned order holding that, since respondent No.6 was an
expert Director of Dr. Baburao Bapuji Tanpure Co-operative
Sugar Factory, merely because he has given an undertaking
while he was Director of the Sugar Factory, it would not be a
bar for him to be nominated as per Section 73CA of the MCS
Act. He has relied on decision of this Court in Writ Petition
No.3312 of 2026, Shri. Nagnath Ramrao Patil Vs. The State of
Maharashtra and another, where it is held that, just because
respondent is a guarantor, he cannot be termed as a ‘defaulter’.
15.
He therefore submitted that, Respondent No.6 is not a
defaulter of respondent No.5/Bank, in his personal capacity as
provided in Section 73 CA(1)(f)(i) and (ii) of the MCS Act. It
is further submitted that, in fact the ‘Karkhana’ is already taken
over by the Bank, therefore, there is no question of expert
Director of the Karkhana being declared as a defaulter. Further
relying on Section 73CA(1)(i)(f) he would submit that, the
District Central Co-operative Bank would be governed by
WP.14527-26.odt
Clause (f) of Section 73CA(1)(i). Only in cases falling under
the three categories provided under section 73CA (1)(i)(f), a
person or a society would be a defaulter. Since respondent
No.6 does not fall in any of the three categories, he cannot be
termed as a defaulter.
16.
He would rely on the decision of this Court at its
Principal Seat in case of Ramdas Yashwanta Mandlik
(Deceased) through legal heirs and another Vs. B. Y. Pagare
Authorized Officer and Assistant Registrar Co-operative
Societies and others in Letters Patent Appeal No.219 of 2006 in
Writ Petition No.6911 of 2025 decided on 17.10.2025. where
this Court has decided about the role of an expert Director in
the Managing Committee of a society. According to this Court,
once bye laws provide for appointment of an expert Director,
who would have no right to vote in the meetings of the
Managing Committee, then certainly the role of an expert
Director is deemed to be advisory. In such circumstances, even
if an expert Director endorses his signature on a document like
minutes of meetings it cannot have any significance.
17.
Hence, according to him, considering the limited scope
WP.14527-26.odt
of Rule 25, the inquiry is conducted by respondent No.4, when
objection is raised to the nomination of respondent No.6 within
the limited time as available to him. The grounds raised by the
petitioner needs to be decided by leading evidence, as it
involves disputed question of facts and interpretation of
provisions of law.
18.
After hearing the respective parties, the following
undisputed facts emerge. (i) The elections of the Board of
Directors of respondent No.5/Bank for the term 2026-2031 has
been declared. The list of voters has already been finalized.
(ii) Presently, as per the election programme, even the
nomination forms have been filled in, for which last date was
07.10.2026 and now it is at the stage for withdrawal of
nominations for which the last date is 21.10.2026. (iii) The
petitioner has filed the objection to the nomination of
respondent No.6, on 06.10.2026. (iv) The Objection is raised
on the ground that, respondent No.6 is an expert Director of a
sugar factory i.e. Dr. Baburao Bapuji Tanpure Sahakari Sakhar
Karkhana Ltd., who is a defaulter of respondent No.5/Bank.
(v) The loan of the respondent/sugar factory is re-structured
on 26.05.2017, while doing so, guarantee is taken from the
WP.14527-26.odt
Directors of the Bank to the effect that, in case the bank fails to
make repayment of the loan, it would be responsibility of the
Directors of the Bank. It would be collective as well as personal
responsibility of the Directors of the Bank to repay the loan of
respondent No.5/Bank, for which and Indenture of joint and
several liability has been executed on 17.07.2017.
19.
It is claimed that, respondent No.6 being a guarantor
and an expert Director of the Karkhana, who has defaulted in
repayment of loan would suffer disqualification under Section
73CA(1)(i) of the MCS Act, which reads thus :
“73CA. [ [Disqualification of committee and its members.]
[(A1) In the case of a society, which gives loans to
members
for
purchasing
machinery,
implements,
equipments, commodities or other goods, or which deals in
such goods, no member, who or whose member of the
family is a dealer in such goods or is a director of a
company or a partner in a firm carrying on business in
such goods, in the area of operation of the society shall be
eligible for being elected or nominated as a member of the
committee of such society;]
Explanation. - For the purposes of this sub-section, the
expression "family" shall have the same meaning as
explained in the Explanation 1, to sub-section (2) of
section 75.
(1)
Without prejudice to the other provisions of this Act
or the rules made thereunder in relation to the
WP.14527-26.odt
disqualification of being member of a committee, no
person shall be eligible for being appointed, nominated,
elected, co-opted or, for being a member of a committee, if
he (i)
is a defaulter of any society;
Explanation. - For the purposes of this clause, the term
"defaulter" includes(a) in the case of a primary agricultural credit
society, a member who defaults the repayment of the crop
loan on the due date;
(b) in the case of term lending society, a member
who default the payment of any instalment of the loan
granted to him;
(c) in the case of any society,(i)a member who has taken anamat or advance; or
(ii)a member who has purchased any goods or
commodities on credit or availed himself of any services
from the society for which charges are payable; and fails to
repay the full amount of such anamat or advance or pay
the price of such goods or commodities or charges for such
service, after receipt of notice of demand by him from the
concerned society or within thirty days from the date of
withdrawal of anamat or advance by him or from the date
of delivery of goods to him or availing of services by him,
whichever is earlier;
(d)in the case of non-agricultural credit societies, a
member who defaults the payment of any instalment of the
loan granted;
(e)in the case of housing societies, a member who
defaults the payment of dues to the society within three
months from the date of service of notice in writing served
by post under certificate of posting demanding the
payment of dues;
WP.14527-26.odt
(f)[ in the case of District Central Co-operative
Bank or of the State Co-operative Bank, a member, if he,(i),
(w.e.f.
14-2-2013).](i)is
a
person
who
represents a society other than a primary agricultural
credit co-operative society on the board of a District
Central Co-operative Bank or the State Co-operative Bank,
if the society to whom he represents has committed a
default towards the payments of such Bank for a period
exceeding ninety days;
(ii)is a person who is a defaulter of a primary
agricultural credit co-operative society or is an office
bearer of a defaulting primary agricultural co-operative
credit society;(iii)is a person who represents a society
whose Managing Committee is superseded.]”
This objection raised by the petitioner was turned down
by respondent No.4 referring to the decision of this Court in
Writ Petition No.3312 of 2026 in Shri. Nagnath Ramrao Patil
Vs. State of Maharashtra and others. Thus, the issues that
arises for consideration before this Court are ;
(i)
Whether the order passed by respondent No.4
in capacity of the Returning Officer as provided
under Rule 25 of the Rules of 2014, suffers from any
error?
(ii)
Whether Respondent No.4 is empowered to
disqualify Respondent No.6, on the ground that, he is
a guarantor for the loan availed by a sugar factory?
21.
WP.14527-26.odt
So far as the maintainability of the present Writ Petition
is concerned, it is the settled position of law that judicial
interference in election matter is not warranted, once the
election process has commenced. The only exception would be
when the order passed by the Election Officer is patently illegal
or erroneous or passed without jurisdiction and the error is so
egregious that, the illegality or error cannot be allowed to be
continued. At the same time, it also needs to be appreciated
that, the election process cannot be disturbed at the instance of
an individual grievance, when such grievance is brought before
the Court at an advance stage. More particularly, when the
objection to the nomination is rejected. If at all the nomination
is rejected, which causes a prejudice to the rights of an
individual, it needs to be addressed, at the earliest, for which a
remedy is already provided under Section 152(A) of the MCS
Act which reads thus :
“152A. Appeal against rejection of nomination paper at
election.
(1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or
the rules or the bye-laws made thereunder, a person
aggrieved by the, rejection of nomination of a candidate
at the election of a committee of any society, may file an
appeal to the Registrar within three days of the date of
WP.14527-26.odt
rejection of the nomination. The Registrar shall dispose of
such appeal within ten days of the date of receipt of such
appeal and the decision of the Registrar in appeal shall be
final and no further appeal or revision shall lie against the
decision of the Registrar in such appeal. [In the case of a
society, an appeal shall lie to the officer as may be
specified by the State Co-operative Election Authority,
who shall dispose of such appeal within ten days from the
date of receipt of such appeal and the decision of the such
officer, shall be final]
(2)
Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or
the rules or the bye-laws made thereunder, the list of
validly nominated candidates shall be subject to the
decision of any appeal filed under sub-section (1), and
the period between the date of scrutiny of nomination
papers and the last date of the withdrawal of
candidatures shall not be less than fifteen days.].”
22.
On reading of the aforementioned provision, it is
manifest that this remedy is provided only against the rejection
of nomination and no remedy is provided if the nomination
form is accepted.
23.
This Court in case of Shri. Shrikant Gawande (supra) has
already considered the scope of Section 152(A) of the MCS Act
and the reasons behind not providing remedy against the
acceptance of nomination form. The relevant observations in
the aforementioned decision is reproduced hereinunder :
“18.
WP.14527-26.odt
The contention of Shri Samarth, learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner regarding absence of any remedy
under section 91 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies
Act, 1960, against the impugned action, has to be viewed in
light of the position that with an intention to minimize,
interference in the election process the Legislature while
providing a remedy against the rejection of a nomination
paper, has intentionally refrained, from providing any remedy,
against the acceptance of nomination paper, as that is a
ground, permissible to be raised in the election petition filed
after the entire process is over, which is also a reason why the
acceptance of nomination ought not to be interfered with.”
24.
This Court in case of Shri. Someshwar Sahakari Sakhar
Karkhana Ltd., Someshwar Nagar Vs. Shriniwas Patil [1992
Mh.L.J. 883] had framed an issue as to whether preparation of
list of voters for elections to the Managing Committee of a
specified society in accordance with the provisions of
Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act and the Maharashtra
Specified Co-operative Societies Elections to Committees Rules
1971, is an intermediate stage in the process of election. This
Court relying on the decision of Division Bench of this Court in
Special Civil Application No.2550 of 1972, in case of Ganesh
Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Election and Osmanabad Bank
Election Case, this Court has held that, the preparation of list
WP.14527-26.odt
of voters for election of Managing Committee of a specified
society is an intermediate stage in the process of election.
Thus, it would not be proper for the Court to interfere in an
petition under Article 226 of Constitution of India. When the
dispute relates to the intermediate stage in process of election,
it would be better to leave the parties to raise the necessary
dispute by way of substantive election petition.
25.
So as to cause interference, at such advanced stage,
there has to be an order that is patently erroneous and
perverse on the face of it. In the present case, on perusal of
the order passed by respondent No.4, he seems to have
recorded all the grounds raised by the petitioner in the
impugned order. He has recorded all the objection raised by
the petitioner. The parties have been represented through their
respective advocates, who have filed their written submissions.
After taking into consideration, the documents placed on
record by the respective parties, respondent No.4, has decided
the objection raised by the petitioner in accordance with the
procedure provided under Rule 25 of Rules of 2014, which is
reproduced hereinunder :
WP.14527-26.odt
“25. Scrutiny of nomination papers.-(1)
On the date fixed, for the scrutiny of nomination papers
under rule 18, the candidates, one proposer of each
candidate duly authorized in writing by each candidate, may
attend at the time and place appointed in this behalf, and the
Returning Officer shall give or cause to give them all
reasonable facilities for examining the nomination papers of
all candidates which have been delivered as required by rule
20. No other person shall be allowed to attend the scrutiny of
nomination.
(2)
The Returning Officer shall then examine the nomination
papers and shall decide all objections which may be made to
any nomination and may, either on such objection or on his
own motion, after such summary inquiry, if any, as he thinks
necessary reject any nomination on any of the following
grounds, that is to say:-(a)
that the candidate is disqualified for being chosen
to fill the seat by or under the Act, the Rules and the
bye-laws;
(b)
that the proposer or seconder is disqualified from
subscribing a nomination paper;
(c)
that there has been a failure to comply with any of
the provisions of rule 21 or 23;
(d)
that the signature of the candidate or the proposer
or the seconder on the nomination paper is not
genuine.
(3)
Nothing contained in clause (c) or (d) of sub-rule (2) shall
be deemed to authorize the rejection of the nomination of
any candidate on the ground of any irregularity in respect of
a nomination paper, if the candidate has been duly
nominated by means of another nomination paper in respect
of which no irregularity has been committed.
(4)
The Returning Officer shall not reject any nomination paper
on the ground of any defect which is not of a substantial
character.
(5)
The Returning Officer shall hold the scrutiny on the date
appointed in this behalf under rule 18, and shall not allow
any adjournment of the proceedings, except when such
proceedings are interrupted or obstructed by riot or open
WP.14527-26.odt
violence or by causes beyond his control:
Provided that, in case any objection is raised by the
Returning Officer or is made by any other person, the
candidate concerned may be allowed time to rebut it, not
later than the next day before the publication of list of valid
nomination and the Returning Officer shall record his
decision on the date to which the proceedings have been
adjourned.
(6)
26.
The Returning Officer shall endorse on each nomination
paper his decision accepting or rejecting the same and, if the
nomination paper is rejected, he shall record in writing, a
brief statement of his reasons for such rejection, and a copy
of such statement shall be immediately supplied on demand
to the candidate or to the proposer concerned. The copy of
such statement shall be sent invariably to the SCEA or
District Co-operative Election Officer, as the case may be.”
On bare perusal of the Rule 25 Sub Clause (2), it is
evident that, after any such objection is filed, the Returning
Officer is supposed to conduct a summary inquiry and if he
thinks fit, reject any nomination on the ground enumerated
under Sub clause (2). Although it is claim of the petitioner
that, that the case of the petitioner would fall under Rule 25(2)
(a), as the nomination of respondent No.6 is against the
provisions of the Act, Rules as well as bye laws of the society.
In my view considering the limited scope of the powers
conferred on the Returning Officer to scrutinize the nomination
papers and decide the objections immediately. Only a summary
inquiry is possible. The issue whether the ‘guarantor’ of the
WP.14527-26.odt
loan would fall under the category of ‘defaulter’ cannot be
decided in a summary inquiry.
It requires evidence and
interpretation, of provisions, of rules and bye laws, which is
not possible while deciding the objection to the nomination.
27.
So far as the contention of the petitioner that, the
impugned order is cryptic, without assigning appropriate
reasons and passed without non-application of mind is
concerned, according to Rule 25(6) of the Rules of 2014, the
Returning Officer is required to endorse his decision accepting
or rejecting the nomination, but only while rejecting the
nomination, it is necessary for him to record in writing the
reasons for such rejection. This provision is made with a view
to enable the aggrieved party to redress his grievance by
availing remedy, of filing an appeal under Section 152A of the
MCS Act. So far as allowing the nomination is concerned, it is
not necessary to record reasons as to why such nomination is
allowed. However, since objection is raised by the petitioner to
the nomination of respondent No.6, respondent No.4 has
recorded the reasons for allowing the nomination, by a
speaking order. The order passed by respondent No.4
commensurates with his limited powers and time available at
WP.14527-26.odt
his disposal, while deciding the objection to the nomination. It
is beyond the purview of the powers of respondent No.4 to
decide the issues raised by the petitioner. Thus, I do not find
any jurisdictional error in the order passed by respondent No.4
vide order dated 06.10.2026.
28.
Pertinently, though respondent No.6 is an expert Director
of Dr. Baburao Bapuji Tanpure Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd.
he has categorically stated that, he has not taken any loan in
his personal capacity from Respondent No.5/Bank, nor is he a
defaulter of the said bank or of any other society. It is also not
disputed that, although much stress is given on the fact that,
respondent No.6, owes collective responsibility with other
Directors as per the Indenture executed by him in capacity as a
Director, but the petitioner has not placed on record any order
or declaration that respondent No.6 is a defaulter of
respondent No.5/Bank.
29.
The petitioner is contesting election of respondent
No.5/Bank,
in
the
representative
capacity
from
the
constituency of service resource society, service co-operative
society and multi purpose co-operative societies among the
WP.14527-26.odt
various constituencies provided under bye-law No.30 of the
Respondent No.5/Bank. He is nominated by one Vividh
Karyakari Seva Sahakari Society, Loni Budruk and he is not
representing the sugar factory of which he is claimed to be a
defaulting guarantor.
30.
So far as the ‘defaulter’ of a society is concerned, Section
73CA of the MCS Act, is the relevant provision which governs
the disqualification of committee and its members.
As has
been rightly pointed out, a ‘defaulter’ in context with election
to respondent No.5, would mean a defaulter as contemplated
under Section 73CA(i)(f), and the three categories provided
under clause (f), would disqualify a person or a society from
representing in the elections of respondent No.5/Bank. It is
not the case of the petitioner that, the respondent No.6 would
be governed by Clause (i) of Section 73CA(1)(f) of the MCS
Act. Similarly, the society to whom Respondent No.6 represents
i.e. the Vividh Karyakari Seva Sahakari Society, Loni Budruk is
not a defaulter of respondent No.5/Bank. Thus, the case of the
petitioner would not fall under item (i) and (ii) of sub clause
(f). Thus, the petitioner is neither a defaulter of an Primary
Agriculture Credit Co-operative Society, in his personal
WP.14527-26.odt
capacity nor is he a office bearer of a defaulting Primary
Agriculture Co-operative Society. As such he would not incur
disqualification as provided under Section 73CA(1)(f) of the
MCS Act.
31.
Admittedly, respondent No.6 has been nominated by a
society other than the sugar factory, who is not a defaulter of
respondent No.5/Bank, and till date he is not declared
defaulter at any point of time by any Court of law or an
authority under the MCS Act, thus he would not incur
disqualification.
32.
So far as applicability and scope of Section 73CA(1)(f) is
concerned, this Court had an occasion to deal with somewhat
similar situation, where the exclusion of petitioner from the
‘voters list’ was subject matter of challenge on the ground of
being a ‘defaulter’ of some other society. This Court has taken
a view that on a conjoint reading of Section 73CA(1)(f) and
Section 27(10) of MCS Act, a person can said to be a ‘defaulter’
if he is exercising his voting right in the elections of the society,
of which he is a member and a defaulter. But, when he is
neither exercising his voting right in the election of his parent
WP.14527-26.odt
society nor contesting the election of the Managing Committee
of the society, of which he is a member, in such situation
provisions of Section 27(10) as well as 73CA(1)(i)(f) of MCS
Act would not be attracted.
The relevant portion of the
decision in Writ Petition No.12431 of 2026 in Vilas Bhausaheb
Dabhade Vs. The State of Maharashtra and others is
reproduced hereinunder :
“28.
In the present case also, the Petitioner is allegedly
defaulter of some other Society, but he is neither casting this
vote in the election of his parent society, nor contesting the
election of managing committee. As such the disqualification
provided under Section 27(10) as well as 73CA(1)(I)(f) of
the MCS, Act, will not be attracted. The Petitioner having
been appointed as delegate to cast vote for Respondent no. 6
– Society, Section 27(3) of the MCS, Act, will be applied, and
the disqualification, if any incurred to Respondent no. 6 –
Society, will apply to the Petitioner. Since none of the
contesting respondents have raised any doubt about the
entitlement of Respondent no. 6, to cast vote in elections of
Respondent no. 8 – Bank, there is no disqualification
attached to Respondent no. 6 to participate in election of
Respondent no.8 and exercise it’s right through delegation of
the Petitioner. The disqualification as a defaulter, if any,
incurred by the Petitioner will be applicable only while he
proposes to vote in the election of the Society of which he is a
member, or proposes to become a committee member. The
disqualification will not be applicable when the Petitioner is
exercising his right in representative capacity as a delegate of
WP.14527-26.odt
Respondent no. 6.”
33.
In the wake of the aforementioned observations, prima
facie this Court is of the view that, the petitioner would not
incur disqualification. However, the objections raised by the
petitioner, can be decided only by raising dispute as provided
in Section 91 of the MCS Act and Rule 78 of the Rules of 2014.
Although this Court has answered the issues raised by the
petitioner to some extent, but the observations made by this
Court are prima facie.
34.
In my view, the order passed by Respondent No.4 in
exercise of powers under Rule 25 of Rules of 2014 does not
suffer from any error or perversity. It is beyond the powers of
Respondent No.4 to decide the disqualification of the
nomination of Respondent No.6, on the basis of the grounds
raised by the petitioner. Thus, causing interference in the
election process, at this advanced stage, would not be
advisable, in view of the settled position of law, laid down by
the catena of judicial pronouncement, by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court as wel as this Court. No case is made out by the
petitioner for causing any interference in the impugned order
WP.14527-26.odt
passed by respondent No.4. As such, the Writ petition stands
dismissed.
35.
However, it is made clear that, the observations made by
this Court are prima facie, and the petitioner is at liberty to
agitate his grievance, by raising dispute under Section 91 of
MCS Act read with Rule 78 of Rules of 2014, which can be
decided on its own merits.
36.
Rule is discharged.
(MANJUSHA A. DESHPANDE, J.)
…
vmk/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review