Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul)
WPA 27637 of 2025
Eastern Coalfields Limited
Vs
Union of India & Ors.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Manik Das.
For the Union of India
:
Mr. S. N. Dutta.
Judgement reserved on
:
25.06.2026
Judgment delivered on
:
10.07.2026
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.:
1.
The writ application has been preferred challenging an award dated 23rd
May, 2025 passed in Reference Case No. 13 of 2011 by the Learned
Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Asansol.
2.
Vide the impugned
award, the learned Tribunal has been pleased to
hold as follows:“In this context, it may be pointed out that rights and
liabilities of employees working under ECL flows from
the decision taken in the Joint Bipartite agreement
between the representative of management and the
union. In the clause 8.1.1 of chapter VIII in NCWA,
it is provided that HRA would be paid to the
employees who have not been provided with any
residential
accommodation.
Clause
8.1.3 lays
down that House Rent Allowance to the employees in
urban areas shall be paid as per Government
notification/clarification
as
provided
in
earlier
agreements and shall be applicable from 01.01.2009
on revised basic. In the present case, the workman
after
allotment
of
quarters
in
his
favour
surrendered the same. The circular issued by the
management on 28.06.2006 amounts to recession and
alteration of the terms of the previous agreement for
the Coal Industry (JBCCI), which is contrary to the
terms laid down in such bipartite agreement. The
decision taken by the management and reflected in
their circular is a unilateral decision and cannot be
said to have any binding force on the employees
unless such terms are introduced as a result of a
collective decision of union representative as well as
management.”
3.
Finally, the learned Tribunal was pleased to direct as follows:“Hence,
ORDERED
The Industrial Dispute is allowed on contest in favour
of Dipak Karmakar, the aggrieved workman. The
management of Bejdih Colliery, Sodepur Area, ECL is
directed to pay House Rent Allowance to the workman
from 01.03.2007 till his superannuation. The arrears
of House Rent Allowance shall be paid within three
months from communication of the Award. Let an
Award be drawn up on the basis of my above
findings. Let copies of the Award in duplicate be sent
to the Ministry of Labour, Government of India, New
Delhi for information and Notification.”
4.
The petitioner’s case is that the petitioner herein is a colliery mining
company and is a subsidiary of Coal India Limited and the private
respondent no.5 was employed as a mechanical fitter.
5.
The specific case of the petitioner is that Clause 8.1.1 of both the
NCWA - VII and the NCWA - VIII suggest that a non-executive
employee in the coal mining sectors will not be eligible for HRA if
he/she has been provided with residential accommodation by the
employer. Clause 8.1.2 further supports and clarifies the provision
contained in Clause 8.1.1 thereby clearly establishing that once a
residential accommodation is allotted to or provided with, the nonexecutive employee concerned will not be eligible for any HRA.
6.
It is further stated that the respondent No. 5 was allotted a quarter
being Quarter No. NHS/36/359 (hereinafter referred to as the "said
quarter") situated at Ranisayar within the precincts of the Bejdih
Colliery under the Sodepur Area of ECL where the respondent No. 5 was
working at the relevant point of time.
7.
In the year 2010, the respondent No. 5, claiming HRA for the period
after his surrendering of the Quarter, raised a purported industrial
dispute through the respondent No. 4 before the conciliatory machinery
of the Government of India whereupon conciliation proceedings were
initiated.
8.
Such conciliation having been failed, the Government of India, Ministry
of Labour, the respondent No. 1 herein, by the order No. L22012/75/2011-IR(CM-II) dated 11-07-2011 referred the purported
dispute for adjudication by the Central Government Industrial Tribunal
cum Labour Court, Asansol (hereinafter referred to as the "CGIT") under
section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 for adjudicating the
following issue: “Whether the action of the management of Bejdih
Colliery of M/s ECL in discontinuation of HRA to Shri Dipak
Karmakar, Mech. Fitter is legal and justified?
To what relief the
workman concerned is entitled to?”
9.
After adjudication in the Reference Case being 13 of 2011, the learned
Tribunal held as noted above.
10. Hence, the writ application was filed being aggrieved with the said award
principally on the ground that the learned Tribunal while making the
impugned Award, failed to consider the provision contained in Clause
8.1.2 of the NCWA and while making the impugned Award, failed to
appreciate that entitlement to HRA occurs only when the employer fails
to provide the employee with a residential accommodation and not when
the employee, after being provided with a residential accommodation by
the employer, vacates or surrenders such accommodation.
11. In course of hearing the petitioner has filed written notes wherein the
petitioner has reiterated his case, as made out in the writ application
and has, thus, prayed for setting aside of the impugned order on the
ground that the same is not in accordance with law.
12. National Coal wage agreement-VII, provides clause:“8.1.0 HOUSE RENT ALLOWANCE
8.1.1 The existing House Rent Allowance of Rs.75/- per month
will be increased to Rs.100/-per month with effect from 1.7.2004
and will be paid to those employees who have not been provided
with residential accommodation.
8.1.2 Payment of House Rent Allowance will be regulated
as indicated below:
(a) Employees excepting those who have been allotted the
following types of house individually will be eligible for House
Rent Allowance at the rate of Rs.100/- per month.
(i) Any pucca house consisting of one or more rooms with common
or separate latrine and bath.
(ii) House under New Housing Scheme, Low Cost Housing Scheme
or single room, arch type tenements with latrine and bath.
(b) If a double roomed house has been allotted to two workmen,
both the allottes shall be entitled to 50% of house rent allowance
each i.e., Rs.50/- per month per head.
(c) If single roomed house is allotted to more than one person or if
a double roomed house is allotted to more than two persons, all
the allottes shall be eligible for House Rent Allowance at the rate
of Rs.100/- per month.
(d) Employees who have been allotted a seat in the barracks or
mess or hostel shall be eligible for House Rent Allowance at the
rate of Rs. 100/- per month.
(e) Where husband and wife both happen to be employees and
where any one of them is allotted the same house of the type
referred to in Clause (a) above, they shall not be entitled to House
Rent Allowance.
(f) Employees who have been allotted single room or Arch type
tenement however will be entitled to House Rent Allowance if the
house
is
not
provided
with
separate
or
common
latrine/bathroom.”
13. National Coal Wage agreement VIII provides:“8.1.0 HOUSE RENT ALLOWANCE
8.1.1 The existing House Rent Allowance of Rs.100/- per month
will be increased to Rs.150/-per month with effect from 1.1.2009
and will be paid to those employees who have not been provided
with residential accommodation.
8.1.2 Payment of House Rent Allowance will be regulated
as indicated below:
(a) Employees excepting those who have been allotted the
following types of house individually will be eligible for House
Rent Allowance at the rate of Rs.150/- per month.
(i) Any pucca house consisting of one or more rooms with common
or separate latrine and bath.
(ii) House under New Housing Scheme, Low Cost Housing Scheme
or single room, arch type tenements with latrine and bath.
14. Vide an officer order dated 28.06.2006, it was clarified by the Dy. Chief
Personnel
Manager
(Estd./MP)
to
the
General
Manager
of
Sodepur/Sripur/Satgram Areas as follows:“……………..the
employees
working
in
the
Establishment/Offices situated & failing under Kulti &
Jamuria Municipalities which are the constituents of
Asansol Urban Area classified as "C" class cities shall be
entitled to get House Rent Allowance as per NCWA-VII on
the following terms & conditions.
1. That the employees who are living in the company's
accommodation shall not be granted/sanctioned
House Rent allowance even in the event of vacating of
company's accommodation.
2. That the employees essential/statutory categories
shall not be allowed to stay outside the colliery
premises.
CGM/GM
in
charge
of
Area/Establishments
should
ensure
providing
company accommodation within the considerable
distance of the Mine/Establishments for such
category of employees.
3. That the CGM/GM should also ensure to allot all
vacant quarters to the eligible as per House Allotment
norms. Furthermore, the employees who have been
allotted quarters and not be shifted are not entitled
House Rent allowance………………”
15. The schedule to the order of reference dated 11.07.2011 is:“THE SCHEDULE
"Whether the action of the management of Bejdih Colliery of
M/s. ECL in discontinuation of HRA to Shri Dipak
Karmakar, Mech. Fitter is legal and justified? To what relief
the workman concerned is entitled to? "
the
16. The tribunal has examined whether discontinuation of House Rent
Allowance to Dipak Karmakar is justified and whether the workman is
entitled to any relief.
17. On the facts as admitted:i.
That the workman was allotted Qtr No. NHS/36/359 and as such
was not paid any HRA.
ii.
Subsequently he surrendered the quarters and claimed HRA on
the ground that there is no settlement between the union and
management regarding stoppage of House Rent Allowance to the
employees on vacating their quarters.
iii.
The management/petitioner herein have stated that a notification
relating to payment of House Rent Allowance to non-executive @
10% of basic pay has been circulated by letter No. ECL/CMD/C6/WBE-1/498 dated 28.06.2006 with certain guidelines which
clearly laid down that in the event of vacation of standard
quarters by the employees concerned, they will not be entitled to
House Rent Allowance. Such circular was issued with the due
consideration of the provisions of NCWA-VII and for proper
utilization of a large number of company's quarters and further to
discourage vacating of allotted quarters by the employees for
getting 10% House Rent Allowance. That no employee of BMP
Group has been granted 10% House Rent Allowance after vacating
their standard quarter.
18. The tribunal finally on its findings held:-
“9. ………… Clause 8.1.3 of NCWA-VII provides that House
Rent Allowance shall be paid to the employees in urban areas
as per Government notification/clarification on the subject as
followed in the previous agreement and other related issues
would be discussed and decided in the standardization
committee. The provisions clearly disclose that payment of
House Rent Allowance to an employee of the company is his
basic right. He is entitled to exercise his right if the
management in any manner withholds the payment of House
Rent Allowance without arriving at any understanding or
agreement affecting such right. In this context, it may be
pointed out that rights and liabilities of employees working
under ECL flows from the decision taken in the Joint Bipartite
agreement between the representative of management and
the union. In the clause 8.1.1 of chapter VIII in NCWA, it is
provided that HRA would be paid to the employees who have
not been provided with any residential accommodation.
Clause 8.1.3 lays down that House Rent Allowance to the
employees in urban areas shall be paid as per Government
notification/clarification as provided in earlier agreements
and shall be applicable from 01.01.2009 on revised basic. In
the present case, the workman after allotment of quarters in
his favour surrendered the same. The circular issued by the
management on 28.06.2006 amounts to recession and
alteration of the terms of the previous agreement for the Coal
Industry (JBCCI), which is contrary to the terms laid down in
such
bipartite
agreement.
The
decision
taken
by
the
management and reflected in their circular is a unilateral
decision and cannot be said to have any binding force on the
employees unless such terms are introduced as a result of a
collective
decision
management.”
of
union representative
as
well
as
19. The tribunal has taken into consideration the memorandum of
settlement at page 47 to the writ application with another similarly
placed employee, who as per the said settlement was granted relief as
follows:“TERMS OF PAYMENT OF HRA
1. The employee will not make any claim for payment of
arrears in lieu of HRA in respect of past service at Bejdih
Colliery till 05.12.2014.
2. Claim for payment of HRA made by the workman at ECL
HQ's will be considered from the date of issuance of Office
Order and no arrears will be claimed by him. The employee
will be paid HRA till he is allotted a quarter at ECL HQ's.
3. The payment of HRA will be governed as per the Company's
Rule applicable to the other employees of ECL, HQ, the
decision of the management from time to time in this regard
will be binding on the employee.
4. The dispute thus stands wholly settled & binding on both
the parties. No party will raise this issue in any forum in any
manner in future.”
20. The said employee was to be paid HRA till he was allotted a quarter. The
settlement was given effect on 05.07.2016, the date of the said
memorandum was signed.
21. It appears that the said settlement in substance was considered to be a
fresh application for allotment of a quarter by the employee.
22. In the Divisional Engineer, G.I.P. Railway vs Mahadeo Raghoo &
Anr., 1955 AIR 295, decided on 2nd March, 1955, the Supreme Court
held:-
“…………Rule 3(i) of the Statutory Rules framed by the
Government and put into effect on 1st November 1947 runs
as follows:
"The house rent allowance will not be admissible to those
who occupy accommodation provided by Government or
those to whom accommodation has been offered by
Government but who have refused"
Held, that the house rent allowance is admissible only so
long as an employee is stationed at one of the specified
places and has not been offered Government quarters. The
rules distinctly provide that the allowance will not be
admissible to those who occupy Government quarters or
those to whom such quarters have been offered but who
have refused to take advantage of the offer. Once an
employee of the description given above has been offered
suitable house accommodation and he has refused it, he
ceases to be entitled to the house rent allowance and that
allowance ceases to be "wages" within the meaning of the
definition in s. 2(vi) of the Act because it is no more payable
under the terms of the contract.
The grant of house rent allowance does not create an
indefeasible right in the employee at all places wherever he
may be posted and in all circumstances, irrespective of
whether or not he has been offered Government quarters.”
23. The principles and guidelines as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in very clear. In cases of entitlement of house rent allowances, the
following rules/laws are applicable:a) House rent allowance is admissible only so long as an employee is
stationed at one of the specified places and has not been offered
Government quarters.
b) The allowance will not be admissible to those who occupy
Government quarters or those to whom such quarters have been
offered but who have refused to take advantage of the offer.
c) Once an employee of the description given above has been offered
suitable house accommodation and he has refused it, he ceases
to be entitled to the house rent allowance and that allowance
ceases to be "wages" within the meaning of the definition in s. 2(vi)
of the Act because it is no more payable under the terms of the
contract.
d) The
grant
of
house
rent
allowance
does
not
create
an
indefeasible right in the employee at all places wherever he may
be posted and in all circumstances, irrespective of whether or not
he has been offered Government quarters.
24. Thus considering all these facts, more so the memorandum of
settlement dated 05.07.2016 in respect of a similarly placed employee,
the impugned award dated 23rd May, 2025 passed by the learned
Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Asansol is
hereby quashed and set aside.
25. The writ application is disposed of with the direction that the petitioner
shall allot a quarter in favour of the worker, if he has not
superannuated, at the earliest, treating the date for application/prayer
for fresh allotment of a quarter as 10.07.2026.
26. The workman shall not be entitled to any arrears of HRA as claimed, but
will be paid HRA on and from this date till he is allotted a quarter (not in
case he has superannuated).
27. The payment of HRA will be governed as per the Company's Rule
applicable to the other employees of ECL, HQ, the decision of the
management from time to time in this regard will be binding on the
employee.
28. WPA 27637 of 2025 is disposed of.
29. Connected application, if any, stands disposed of.
30. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
31. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties expeditiously after due compliance.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review