Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
BEFORE:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE SHAMPA DUTT (PAUL)
W.P.A. 29525 of 2025
Eastern Coalfields Limited
Vs.
Shiuly Bauri & Ors.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. S.M. Obaidullah, Adv.
Mr. Nikhil Kumar Roy, Adv.
For the Opposite Parties
:
None.
Judgment reserved on
:
08.07.2026
Judgment delivered on
:
31.07.2026
SHAMPA DUTT (PAUL), J.:1.
The writ application has been preferred challenging, an Award dated
19.06.2025, passed by the respondent no.7 being the learned
Presiding Officer, Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cumLabour Court, Asansol, in reference case no. 02 of 2020.
2.
Vide the impugned award, the learned CGIT granted relief as follows:“The widow of the deceased employee is also
entitled to monetary compensation under Clause
9.5.0 (iii) of NCWA-VI at the prevailing rate from
10.12.1996 i.e., the date of death of the employee till
employment is granted to the daughter. The Industrial
Dispute is accordingly allowed in favour of the
dependent daughter and widow of the deceased
employee.
Hence,
Ordered
that the Industrial Dispute is allowed on
contest against the management of Pandaveswar
Area of Eastern Coalfields Limited. The management
of
ECL
is
directed
to
grant
compassionate
employment to Shiuly Bauri within a period of 3
(three) months from the date of communication of the
Award. Smt. Sakuntala Bauri, widow of the Late
Khudiram Bauri is entitled to Monthly Monetary Cash
Compensation (MMCC) at the prevailing rate from the
date of death i.e., 10.12.1996 till compassionate
employment/appointment is granted to the daughter.
The management of Eastern Coalfields Limited is
directed
to
pay
the
arrears
of
the
monetary
compensation to the widow of the deceased employee
within
(three)
months
from
the
date
of
communication of the Award. Let an award be drawn
up in light of my above findings. Copies of the Award
in duplicate be sent to the Ministry of Labour,
Government of India, New Delhi for information and
Notification.”
3.
The petitioner’s case herein is that the father of the respondent No. 1
and husband of the respondent No. 2 namely- Khudiram Bauri was
posted as a chainman at Pandabeshwar area of Eastern Coalfields
Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "ECL" in short). During his service
tenure, the said Khudiram Bauri expired on 10.12.1996. The said
Khudiram Bauri died leaving him surviving his wife and two
daughters namely- Shiuli Bauri and Doli Bauri as dependents. After
the death of the said Khudiram Bauri, the respondent No. 2, being
his wife applied before the management of ECL for her appointment
on compassionate grounds. However, the management did not
provide any employment to the respondent No. 2, on the ground that
she had crossed the maximum age for employment as per the
provisions of National Coal Wage Agreement. Thereafter, the
respondent No. 1, being the daughter of the said Khudiram Bauri
submitted an application before the management of ECL for her
appointment on compassionate grounds. The said application filed by
the respondent No. 1 was processed by the said management and the
respondent No. 1 was asked to appear before the Screening
Committee of the management of ECL and she was found fit for
employment in the Initial Medical Examination (hereinafter referred to
as "IME" in short). Thereafter, the area management, forwarded the
proposal for employment of the respondent No. 1 to the ECL
Headquarters.
4.
On
27.02.2007,
ECL
Headquarters
rejected
the
proposal
for
employment on the ground that the respondent No. 1 was below the
age of 18 years at the time of death of the said deceased employee
namely- Khudiram Bauri. It is stated that the respondent No. 1 has
applied for compassionate appointment after expiry of 10 years from
the date of death of her father and submitted the said application
before the competent authority of ECL on 26.06.2006.
5.
It is stated that, in terms of the provisions of National Coal Wage
Agreement, if a female dependent is below the age of 18 years at the
time of death of the deceased employee, she is not entitled to
compassionate appointment.
6.
After rejection of the claim for compassionate appointment by the
management of ECL, the respondent No. 3, being Koyla Mazdoor
Congress
raised
an
industrial
dispute
before
the
Labour
Commissioner in respect of the employment of the respondent No. 1
namely Shiuli Bauri.
7.
The
Deputy
Director,
Ministry
of
Labour
and
Employment,
Government of India, being the respondent no. 9 herein, by a
corrigendum dated 22.06.2023 issued an order of reference in respect
of the said industrial dispute and referred the said dispute to the
Presiding Officer, Central Government Industrial Tribunal cum
Labour Court, Asansol being the respondent no.7 herein.
8.
In the said order of reference, the schedule by way of a corrigendum
is as follows:"Whether the action of the management of Pandabeshwar
area office of M/s. ECL over denial of employment to the
dependent's
daughter
Shiuli
Bauri
and
denied
of
payment of monetary compensation to the wife of the late
Khudiram Bauri, Ex-Chainman are legal and justified? If
not, to what relief the dependent's daughter and the wife
of the deceased are entitled to".
9. The order of reference was modified by a corrigendum dated
22.06.2023 by the Deputy Director, Ministry of Labour and
Employment, Government of India, being the respondent no.9 herein.
10. It appears that the sole ground on which the prayer of the respondent
no. 1 was rejected was that the said medical board observed that the
age of the respondent No. 1 was assessed as 18 years on 03.10.1997.
Therefore, her
date of birth was taken as 03.10.1979. The
management of ECL rejected the claim of the respondent No. 1 on the
ground that, at the time of death of the deceased employee, the
respondent No. 1 was only 17 years 2 months 7 days and, since
she was a minor, she was not entitled to employment under the
provisions of National Coal Wage Agreement. The said respondent No.
1 never applied for reassessment of her age before the appropriate
authority and/or the management of the petitioner.
11. It is the further case of the petitioner that, from perusal of the service
records of the deceased employee, the age of the respondent No.2
was mentioned as 27 years as on 01.04.1987. Therefore, she would
attain 60 years on 01.04.2020. It is thus stated that the respondent
No. 2 is not entitled to any monetary compensation since she has
completed 60 years on 01.04.2020.
12. It is further stated that under NCWA-VI, a female dependent is
entitled to monetary compensation only upto the age of 60 years, and
not beyond that age. Admittedly the respondent No. 2 crossed the age
of 60 years on 01.04.2020. Therefore, the petitioner states that she is
thus
not
entitled
to
any
monetary
compensation
from
the
management of the petitioner.
13. The petitioner is also aggrieved by the fact that the tribunal has
granted monetary compensation to the respondent no.2, on the
ground that the respondent no.2 has crossed the age of 60 years in
the year 2020.
14. Supplementary affidavit has been filed on behalf of the petitioner,
annexing a document to show that the management has granted
maintenance
allowance
Rs.2000/-
per
month
in
lieu
of
compassionate appointment since September, 1998 till the age of
superannuation or the date of death whichever is earlier.
15. A copy of the nomination form submitted by the deceased, annexed
herein shows, that the respondent no.2 in the nomination form
has been shown to be aged about 27 years as on 01.04.1987 and the
respondent no.1 as 9 years.
16. In spite of service none appears for the respondents. Written notes
were filed on behalf of the petitioner herein. It appears from the
written notes, that the prayer for compassionate appointment of the
respondent no.2 was rejected on the ground that she had crossed the
maximum age for employment as per the provision of National Coal
Wage Agreement, on the other hand, the respondent no.1 being the
daughter was said to be below the age of 18 years at the time of death
of the employee.
17. It appears from the copy of the nomination form filed by way of
supplementary affidavit that the respondent no.1 was aged about 9
years as on
01.04.1987.
Admittedly, the employee died on
10.12.1996. Another contention of the petitioner herein is that the
respondent no.1 applied for compassionate appointment after expiry
of 10 years from the date of death of her father.
18. Neither in the writ application nor in any other document it has been
placed before the Court as to when the respondent no.2 had filed her
application for compassionate appointment.
19. Admittedly, the said application of the respondent no.2 was rejected
on 27.02.2007.
The respondent no.1 as per the statement of the
petitioner herein filed the application for compassionate appointment
on ……. (date not provided by the petitioner herein) but it appears
that from the document marked as annexure P1 that the respondent
no.1 submitted document in support of her prayer for compassionate
appointment before the authority on 26.06.2006.
20. The petitioner rejected the application for compassionate appointment
of the respondent no.2 being the mother of the respondent no.1 on
27.02.2007, on the ground of being over age and as such this court
finds no delay in the making of the application by the respondent no.
1 before the authority concerned.
21. The petitioner herein has wrongly taken the plea of delay of 10 years
which it appears is only to deprive the respondent no. 1 of her right of
compassionate appointment.
22. It further appears that the petitioner has acted on the report of the
Medical Board, which assessed the age of the respondent no.1 as 18
years, as on 03.10.1997 and thereby assessed her age as 17 years 2
month 7 days on the date of death of her father i.e. on 10.12.1996.
The Board thus held that the respondent no.1 was below 18 years on
the date of death of her father. As to how the medical board of the
petitioner could come to such decision is assessment best known to
them.
23. Admittedly, from the copy of the nomination form which has been
placed by the petitioner themselves, it appears that the respondent
no.1 was aged about 9 years on 01.04.1987.
24. The said entry in the nomination form was never disputed by the
petitioner and was never challenged. As such if the age of the
respondent no.1 is 9 years on 01.04.1987, her age on the date of
death of her father on 10.12.1996, would be 18 years 8 month 9
days. As the said entry in the nomination form has never been
challenged by the petitioner, the same cannot be ignored, by placing
the respondent no.1 before the Medical Board constituted by the
company, with an intention to deprive the respondent no. 1 of her
right to compassionate appointment.
25. The petitioner has enclosed the copies of the NCWA IV in support of
his contention. Heard the learned Counsel for the petitioner. On
perusal of the materials on record and the impugned award, the
relevant findings of the learned tribunal is reproduced herein:“13. The admitted position in this case is that Khudiram
Bauri was a permanent employee of ECL and posted at
Pandaveswar Area. He died in harness on 10.12.1996,
leaving
behind
Shakuntala
Bauri,
his
widow
and
dependent daughters namely, Shiuly Bauri and Doli Bauri.
On the basis of an application submitted by Shiuly Bauri,
claiming employment she was referred for her preemployment medical examination before the IME Board.
The report of the IME dated 25.09.1997 has been placed
by the management as Exhibit M-1. It appears from the
report that the Board found her fit for job and her age, as
per appearance, was recorded as 18 years as on
03.10.1997. It appears from the documents that there is
some mismatch between the date on which the report was
prepared i.e., 25.09.1997 and the date on which the IME
Board assessed her age on the basis of her appearance
i.e., on 03.10.1997. The assessment could not have been
done after the date of submission of the report. The
criteria considered for recording the age of Shiuly
Bauri was on the basis of her statement and the age
as recorded in the Service Record of the deceased
employee. As per Service Record Excerpt the age of Shiuly
Bauri was 9 years on 01.04.1987. Therefore, if her age
was 9 years on 01.04.1987 as per the Service Record
maintained by the company, Shiuly Bauri had already
attained 18 years on the date of death of her father
and her age should have been 18 years and 8 months.
The management of ECL has produced Exhibit M-6 which
is a letter dated 11/12.09.1998 addressed to Shiuly Bauri
where the Competent Authority approved maintenance
allowance at the rate of Rs 2,000/- per month to the
daughter of the deceased in lieu of employment in place of
her father. There was no clear communication to the
dependent daughter of deceased that her prayer for
employment was rejected on any ground. It is gathered
from Exhibit M-2, a letter dated 22/27.02.2007 issued by
Personnel Manager (Empl), ECL Headquarters, addressed
to the Personnel Manager (IC), Pandaveswar Area,
informing that the age of female dependent was assessed
as 18 years as on 03.10.97, hence her date of birth is
inferred as 03.10.79. According to the management the
concerned female dependent (i.e., daughter) was aged 17
years 2 months 7 days as on date of death of her
deceased father and she was below 18 years of age
therefore she is not entitled to employment as per
provision of NCWA. From this letter dated 22/27.02.2007
the final decision of the Competent Authority, refusing
employment to the dependent daughter has come to light,
after passage of 11 years from the date of death of
Khudiram Bauri.
14. The relevant provision regarding employment to female
dependent is provided in Clause 9.5.0 (ii) of NCWA-VI,
which
either
allows
employment
or
monetary
compensation to a female dependent in case of death of an
employee while in service. It provides 45 years as the
upper age limit for female dependent for exercising their
option either for employment or monetary compensation. A
female dependent above 45 years of age is vested with the
right to receive monetary compensation only and she does
not have any right to employment.
15. According to the Service Record Shiuly Bauri
completed her 18 years and few months on the
death of her father, where it was clearly laid down
that her age was 9 years as on 01.04.1987. The
Service Record Excerpt of Khudiram Bauri was produced
by the union as Exhibit W-2 and the age of Shiuly Bauri,
recorded therein, appears as 9 years. From the various
documents relating to educational qualification of Shiuly
Bauri, it appears that she appeared in Matriculation
Examination under Bihar School Examination Board,
Patna in the year 2000 (Exhibit W-6) and her Intermediate
Examination under Jharkhand Academic Council, Ranchi
in the year 2004 (Exhibit W-8) Therefore, there was no
occasion for Shiuly Bauri to produce the certificates or
admit card of such examinations bearing her date of birth
at the time of her appearance before the IME Board Under
such circumstances the IME Board was required to
rely upon the age of Shiuly Bauri, as it appeared in
the Service Record of the deceased employee or by
holding her Ossification Test. Be that as it may, the
provisions of Clause 9.5.0 (ii) of NCWA-VI vests the right to
the dependent to exercise her option between employment
and monetary compensation to a female dependent below
the age of 45 years.
In
the
case
of
Sukumoni
Hembram
Alias
Sukumoni Mejhan vs The Union of India and Others
[MAT 27 of 2024], the Hon'ble High Court at Calcutta
held:
“41. Clause 9.5.0 (ii) vests the right of exercising an
option between employment and monetary compensation
with a female dependent below 45 years. Once a right
stand vested it can be taken away by a process approved
by law. In a given case, when the female dependent is
below 45 years but above 18 years she can opt for either
grant of employment or monetary compensation. If she
opts for employment employer has no choice but grant her
the employment. However, if such female dependent is a
minor on the date of death of the deceased employee, she
cannot be denied the right of exercising the option between
employment and monetary compensation in terms of
clause 9.5.0 (ii) on the plea of the Mines Act, or otherwise
Right to employment or monetary compensation stood
vested in the female dependant under clause 9.5.0 (ii)
notwithstanding she being a minor on the date of death.
This vested right can be taken from her only by a process
approved by law."
The Hon'ble High Court further held that:
“44. Clause 9.5.0 (iii) of the NCWA provides for a
scenario where there is a minor male dependent in the
family of the deceased employee and such family
seeks to preserve the right of such male dependent to
receive employment on his attaining the age of an
adult. Clause 9.5.0 (iii) does not govern the right of a
female dependent, in a family of the deceased
employee, where there is no male dependent, to receive
employment or monetary compensation."
The Hon'ble High Court further noted that Clauses
9.3.0 to 9.5.0 of the NCWA does not specify financial
solvency or delay to be disqualifications for receipt of
compassionate appointment or monetary compensation.
The Hon'ble High Court allowed the appeal and directed
the
respondent
authorities
to
grant
compassionate
appointment to the appellant as expeditiously as possible,
and preferably within a period of 4 weeks from date, upon
compliance with necessary formalities. A Special Leave
to Appeal was preferred before the Hon'ble Supreme
Court of India against the judgment and order
passed by the Division Bench of the High Court,
which was dismissed, finding no reason or ground to
interfere with the same.
In
the
submitted
instant case
her
application
the
dependent
claiming
daughter
compassionate
employment in place of her dead father within a period of
less than 1 (one) year from the date of death of her father.
At the time of her application, she had already attained
the age of majority. The dependent daughter is therefore
entitled
to
provisions
get
of
compassionate
Clause
9.5.0
(ii)
employment
of
as
per
NCWA-VI.
The
management by denying employment to her acted in
arbitrary and illegal manner, bypassing the provisions of
settlement which is binding upon them under Section 18(3)
of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The management has
no occasion to deny such employment to the dependent
daughter of the deceased employee on the ground of delay
or that the family of the deceased has been able to wade
over financial hardship, which arose immediately after the
death of the employee. In the instant case the delay in
disposing the matter is attributable to the management of
ECL.
The widow of the deceased employee is also entitled
to monetary compensation under Clause 9.5.0 (iii) of
NCWA-VI at the prevailing rate from 10.12 1996 i.e., the
date of death of the employee till employment is granted to
the daughter. The Industrial Dispute is accordingly
allowed in favour of the dependent daughter and widow of
the deceased employee.
Hence,
ORDERED
that the Industrial Dispute is allowed on contest
against the management of Pandaveswar Area of Eastern
Coalfields Limited. The management of ECL is directed to
grant compassionate employment to Shiuly Bauri within a
period of 3 (three) months from the date of communication
of the Award. Smt. Sakuntala Bauri, widow of the Late
Khudiram Bauri is entitled to Monthly Monetary Cash
Compensation (MMCC) at the prevailing rate from the date
of death i.e., 10.12.1996 till compassionate employment /
appointment is granted to the daughter. The management
of Eastern Coalfields Limited is directed to pay the arrears
of the monetary compensation to the widow of the
deceased employee within 3 (three) months from the date
of communication of the Award. Let an award be drawn
up in light of my above findings. Copies of the Award in
duplicate be sent to the Ministry of Labour, Government of
India, New Delhi for information and Notification.”
26. It further appears that in the nomination form the respondent no.2
was aged about 27 years as on 01.04.1987. The said declaration
was also not disputed by the petitioner herein and as such the age
of the respondent no.2 as on 10.12.1996 is a little above 36 years and
as such she had not crossed 45 years of age and thus the conduct of
the petitioner rejecting her application stating that she was over age,
was malafide and thus also wrong, prima facie to deprive the
respondent no. 2 of her legitimate right, which is a clear abuse of
process of law and has also caused severe prejudice to both the
respondent no. 1 and 2, as their applications have been rejected in a
total biased/unjust manner only to deprive the respondent no. 1 and
2 of their lawful right.
27. Thus from the said facts and evidence as discussed above, it appears
that both the respondents being 1 and 2, daughter and wife of the
deceased workman have been deprived of their lawful entitlement, by
disregarding the age of the respondents as provided in the
nomination form, which was never challenged.
28. As to the basis of ascertain their age, it appears that the sole
intention was only to deprive the respondents no. 1 and 2, unjustly,
which is clear abuse of process of law.
29. Considering the said facts, the impugned award dated 19.06.2025, in
reference case no. 02 of 2020, passed by the Central Government
Industrial Tribunal, requires no interference and the writ application
is accordingly dismissed.
30. WPA 29525 of 2025 is thus disposed of.
31. Applications,
if
any,
connected
thereto
stand
disposed
of
consequently.
32. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
33. Photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, be given to
the parties on priority basis upon compliance of all formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review