Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A.(J)15 of 2023
Dwipjoy Das @ Tamal,
son of late Sunil Das,
resident of Sukantanagar, P.S. Kumarghat,
District : Unakoti Tripura
---- Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura,
to be represented by the
Ld. Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Tripura, Agartala
---- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. K. Nath, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.
Date of Hearing &
Judgment & Order
:
05.02.2024
:
NO
Whether fit for
reporting
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
(Per : Justice T. Amarnath Goud)
Heard Mr. K. Nath, Learned counsel appearing for the
appellant as well as Mr. S. Ghosh, Learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the
State-respondent.
2.
This is an appeal under Section 374(2) of Cr.P.C. against
the judgment dated 08.02.2023 passed by the Learned Session Judge,
Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar in Case No.Sessions Trial 11(U/K) of
2019 (T-1), whereby and where under the Learned Sessions Judge
convicted the appellant for commission of an offence punishable under
Section 302 of IPC and sentenced to him to suffer RI for life and also to
pay fine of Rs.40,000/- only in default to undergo further RI for six
months.
3.
The case of the prosecution as revealed in the written
ejahar submitted by the complainant namely Sri Sanjit Das is that on
06.04.2018 at about 07:00 hrs. a quarrel was going on between the
mother of the complainant and the mother of the accused Dwipjoy alias
Tamal Das, at the house of the complainant at Sukantanagar under
Kumarghat P.S. and suddenly, the accused became furious and pushing
punch to the complainant’s mother namely Smt. Jatana Das. On the
same date, time and place the accused Dwipjoy alias Tamal Das
physically assaulted the father of the complainant namely Sushil Das by
a wooden lathi on his forehead and as a result of which he received
grievous injury on his head and during treatment, he succumbed to his
injuries at Dharmanagar Hospital at about 16:00 hrs.
4.
On
the
basis
of
this
written
ejhar
KGT
P.S.
Case
No.027/2018 under Section 302 of IPC was registered against the
accused person namely Dwipjoy alias Tamal Das and the case was
endorsed to SI Suman Saha for investigation. On completion of the
investigation, IO submitted charge sheet vide No.24/2018 and under
Sections 323/302 of IPC dated 30.06.2018 against the accused person to
face trial in the open Court of law.
5.
On 26.07.2018, the then Learned CJM, Unakoti, Kailashahar
after receiving the charge sheet transferred the case record to the Court
of Learned Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class, Kailashahar, Unakoti and
cognizance of offence was taken by the then Learned Judicial Magistrate,
1st Class, Kailashahar on 31.07.2018 under Sections 302/323 of IPC
against the accused Sri Dwipjoy alias Tamal Das and on 18.03.2019, this
Court received the case record on commitment and on 04.04.2019
charge under Sections 323/302 of IPC was framed against the accused
by the then Learned Sessions Judge, Unakoti, Kailashahar and trial
began accordingly.
6.
To substantiate the charge, the prosecution has examined
as many as 09(nine) witnesses. Defence case as revealed from the trend
of the cross-examination of the prosecution witnesses and examination
of the accused under Section 313(1)(b) of Cr.P.C. is of total denial and
defence side inclined to adduced defence evidence and accordingly,
accused has examined 03(three) witnesses in support of his defence.
7.
At the time of hearing, Mr. K. Nath, Learned counsel
appearing for the appellant submitted that the Learned Court below at
the time of appreciation of evidence on record did not consider the
evidence on record of the accused-appellant and his witnesses and came
to a wrong finding that the present appellant committed murder of the
deceased and urged for setting aside the judgment and order of
conviction passed by the Learned Sessions Judge. He has also drawn the
attention of the Court referring the evidence of the witnesses and
submitted that there is no direct evidence on record that the present
appellant also had the intention to cause murder or death of the
deceased, rather, the deceased assaulted and caused hurt to his sister
and at the time of rescue of his sister, the alleged firewood somehow
inflicted on the head of the deceased and he himself sustained injury and
ultimately succumbed to his injury but this part of evidence was not
considered by the Learned Court below.
8.
Finally, Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that if
at all the Court considers the appellant to be guilty, in that case, the
charge to the extent punishable under Section 304 Part-II of IPC lies
against him and prayed for converting the sentence from Section 302 to
Section 304 Part-II of IPC.
9.
During the course of his submission, Mr. K. Nath, Learned
counsel appearing for the appellant has relied on a judgment of the apex
Court in Deepak versus State of Uttar Pradesh (now Uttarakhand)
reported in (2018) 8 SCC 228 where it has been stated as follows :
“7. On consideration of the entirely of the evidence, it
can safely be concluded that the occurrence took place
in the heat of the moment and the assault was made
without premeditation on the spur of time. The fact that
the appellant may have rushed to his house across the
road and returned with a sword, is not sufficient to infer
an intention to kill, both because of the genesis of the
occurrence and the single assault by the appellant,
coupled with the duration of the entire episode for 1 ½
to 2 minutes. Had there been any intention to do away
with eh life of the deceased, nothing prevented the
appellant from making a second assault to ensure his
death, rather than to have run away. The intention
appears more to have been to teach a lesson by the
venting of ire by an irked neighbour, due to loud playing
of the tape recorder. But in the nature of weapon used,
the assault made in the rib-cage area, knowledge that
death was likely to ensue will have to be attributed to
the appellant.”
10.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Ghosh, Learned Addl. P.P.
appearing for the State-respondent strongly opposed the submission of
the Learned counsel appearing for the appellant and submitted that there
is clear evidence regarding the involvement of the accused-appellant
with the alleged offence so there is no scope to show any lenient view or
mercy to the appellant because the accused on the relevant day at the
alleged occurrence of offence by a piece of firewood caused hurt to the
deceased to his head for which he sustained fatal injury and ultimately
succumbed to death. So, Learned Addl. P.P. urged for upholding the
conviction of the appellant awarded by the Learned Trial Court.
11.
We have heard detailed argument of Learned counsel of
both the parties and also gone through the evidence on record. However,
before coming to the conclusion of the appeal let us revisit the evidence
on record of the prosecution as well as the accused adduced before the
Learned Trial Court.
12.
PW-1, Shri Sanjit Das has deposed that on 06.04.2018 at
about 7/8 am an alteration took place in between his mother and his
cousin brother and sister. His aunty was also present there. At that time,
his father was sleeping in the house. Hearing sound of their altercation,
his father woke up. In the meantime, his cousin brother namely Tamal
Das @ Dipjoy Das gave a blow to his mother. His father came in front of
the door of their hut and asked Tamal why he was doing so. At that time
by means of fire wood Tamal gave a stroke on the head of his father to
which his father fell on the earth. His father was shifted to Kumarghat
hospital and from Kumarghat he was referred to Dharmanagar hospital.
On that day, he was at Jumpui and over phone his mother informed him
the above incident and hearing the fact, he came to Kumarghat but in
the mean time, his father was shifted to Dharmangar. As such, again he
went to
Dharmanagar. At about 4/4-30
pm his father
died at
Dharmanagar hospital. At about 6/7 pm, he reached at Dharmanagar.
On that night, dead body of his sister was not handed over to him. On
the next day morning postmortem examination was held over the dead
body of his father and thereafter, the dead body was handed over to him
and he brought the dead body of his father and thereafter, the dead
body was handed over to him and he brought the dead body of his father
to his house at Sukanta Nagar, Kumarghat. It is to be mentioned here
that after death of his father again he came to Kumarghat at night and
lodged a written complaint to the OC, Kumarghat PS. One Suman Das
wrote the complaint petition to his dictation and he put his signature in
it. Witness identified his signature in the complaint petition and on his
identification his signature in the complaint petition is marked as
Exbt.1/1. On 07.04.2018 police visited his house and seized the firewood
by which Tamal assaulted his father under a seizure list and in the
seizure list myself stood as witness. On identification by this witness his
signature in the seizure list dated 07.04.2018 marked as Exbt.2/1. He
was unable to identify the firewood which was seized by the police.
Witness identified the same in the Court and the identification has been
marked as Exbt.M.O.1. Accused Tamal is present in the court and is
identified.
13.
In the cross-examination he has deposed that his elder
uncle died about 5/6 months prior to the said incident. They used to
reside separately in separate mess but in the same house. He born in the
same house. There are four separate huts in the same house. Their hut
is in the northern viti and two huts of the accused persons are in the
eastern viti. In the southern viti their one hut is under construction. Their
hut is of bamboo made with GCI sheets. There is a courtyard surrounded
by all the four huts. There is a stack of firewood in between their two
huts. The family of accused persons maintained by his aunty and her
daughter namely Mithu. They used to do private tuition and in the
morning students used to come in their house. By profession his father
was a driver of Tripper. Nothing more relevant came out during crossexamination except denial.
14.
PW-2, Jatana Das has deposed that on 06.04.2018 at about
7/7-30 am his neighbour namely Supriya Nath visited his house to collect
ash from his katcha oven. At that time, his elder sister-in-law namely
Bakul Pal Das started quarrel with him over filthy issue. In the
meantime, her daughter namely Mitu and son namely Tamal @ Dipjoy
Das came forward and also joined with their mother and quarreled with
him. At that time, Tamal also gave him a blow on his chest. At that time,
his husband was sleeping, woke up and came out and asked them the
reason of their doing so. At that moment, Tamal by taking a firewood
gave a stroke on the forehead of his husband to which he fell on the
earth. With the help of Supriya he took him inside the room also poured
some water in his head also arranged for shifting him to Kumarghat
hospital along with his another sister-in-law namely Niva Deb. From
Kumarghat
her
husband
was
referred
to
Dharmanagar
hospital.
Accordingly, she shifted him to Dharmanagar. It is to be mentioned that
her son Sanjit Das was at Jumpui on that day and as such, she conveyed
the information to her son over phone in between 9 am to 10 am. As
referred by Kumarghat hospital she shifted her husband to Dharmanagar
along with Abha and Babul Dey who are also her sister-in-law and the
husband of said sister-in-law. CT scan was done and necessary
treatment were also rendered but ultimately at about 4/4-30 pm her
husband expired in the said hospital. At about 6/7 pm her son Sanjit
came to Dharmanagar hospital. In the meantime, dead body of her
husband was shifted to hospital morgue. In the hospital, the police
personnel visited and prepared the surathal report over the dead body of
her husband and in the said surathal report, she stood as witness. On
identification by this witness her signature in the surathal report has
been marked as Exbt.3/1. After arrival of her son, they came to
Kumarghat. On the next day postmortem examination was held over the
dead body of her husband and thereafter, the dead boy was handed over
to them. On the date of incident on their return to Dharmanagar her son
namely Sanjit lodged FIR in Kumarghat PS. On 07.04.2018 police
personnel visited their house and seized one piece of firewood as it was
used by Tamal to assault her husband under a seizure list and in that
seizure list herself stood as witness. Witness identified her signature in
the seizure list and it has been marked as Exbt.2/2. Witness also
confirmed the Exbt.M.O.1 to be the same which was seized by the police
from her house as the weapon of offence. Accused Tamal was also
present in the Court and was identified.
15.
During cross-examination she has deposed that a police
officer of Dharmanagar talked with her in Dharmanagar District Hospital
after death of her husband. She has stated to the police at Dharmanagar
that there was quarrel in between herself and Bakul Pal Das and
thereafter, her daughter and son also joined with her and quarreled with
he. She has sted to the police that Tamal assaulted her husband by a
firewood. It is a fact that Bakul Pal Das and her daughter Mitu used to do
private tuition in her house at various time. Husband of Bakul Pal Das
died about 5/6 months back of that incident. In their family, there are
only the above named persons. They used to maintain their family by
their own income. Nothing more relevant came out during crossexamination except denial.
16.
PW-3, Supriya Nath has deposed that he is an adjacent
neighbour of the complainant of this case. She has deposed that on
06.04.2018 at about 7/7-30 am she visited their house to collect ash
from katcha oven while Jatana Das was collecting ash from the oven
suddenly the mother of Tamal came to that place which is the Baranda of
the homestead of the complainant. Mother of Tamal started using filthy
language attacking Jatana Das to which Jatana asked mother of Tamal
about the reason of her such act and conduct. In the meantime, Mitu and
Tamal came also came to that place and they also joined in the quarrel in
favour of their mother. At that time, Tamal gave a blow to Jatana Das. In
the meantime Sushil Das, husband of Jatana also came out from his
room and asked Tamal and his sister why they are doing so and in the
meantime, Tamal by taking a firewood gave a stroke on the forehead of
Sushil Das to which Sushil Das fell on the earth. Thereafter, herself and
Jatana poured some water on his head and also took him inside the
room. After arranging for shifting of Sushil Das she left their house and
came back to her house. Probably after 4/5 days the police personnel of
Kumarghat P.S. produced her before the Court at Kailashahar and
therein her statement was recorded by a Magistrate. Her signatures were
also obtained in the said statement. The contents also read over to her
by the Magistrate. Witness identified her signature in her statement
which was recorded under Section 164 of Cr.P.C. On her identification
her signatures in her statement recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C. in
three sheets are marked as Exbt.4/1 to Exbt.4/3. Tamal is present today
in the Court and is identified. In c/w this case police also visited the
house of the complainant and therefrom seized the firewood which was
used by Tamal in assaulting Sushil on the date of incident under a
seizure list and in that seizure list herself stood as witness. On
identification by this witness her signature in the seizure list dated
07.04.2018 in c/w seizure list of the firewood has been marked as
Exbt.2/3. Witness also confirmed the firewood to be the same and the
same already has been marked as Exbt.M.O.1. During cross-examination
save and except denial nothing relevant came out.
17.
PW-4, Debabrata Das has deposed that about one year back
one day at about 7/7-30 am he was in a booth office of BJP political
party by the side of the road in between his house and the house of
Sushil Das. At that time, he heard hue and cry from the house of Sushil
Das and hearing the same himself and some others who were in the said
booth office went to that house and found Sushil Das was sitting on the
earth touching his head by his hand. Thereafter, Sushil was shifted to
Kumarghat hospital. He heard that Tamal assaulted Sushil by a lathi. He
died in Dharmanagar hospital where he was referred from Kumarghat.
Accused Tamal is present today in the Court and is identified.
18.
During cross-examination, he has deposed that at a
distance of 100 miter from his shop, house of Sushil is situated. Distance
between BJP booth office and the house of Sushil is about 60/70 miter.
Rashendra Debnath who was the booth president at that time and he
also rushed to the house of Sushil. The mother and sister of Tamal are
private tutor by profession. While he rushed to their house there were
about 25/30 persons in that house.
19.
PW-5, Abha Das (Dey) has deposed that about one year
back one day at about 8-30 am wife of her brother namely Sushil
informed her over phone that Tamal who is also son of her another
brother namely Sunil Das assaulted Sushil by a firewood on his head.
Hearing this fact, she rushed to Kumarghat hospital. Sushil was referred
to Dharmanagar hospital and as such, she also went to Dharmanagar
along with her husband and wife of Sushil namely Jatana. There in the
attending doctor rendered treatment to Sushil but about 4 pm he died in
the said hospital. Police personnel visited the hospital. In the hospital
daroga also obtained her signature and the signature of her husband in a
paper. Witness identified her signature on the inquest report and on her
identification her signature in the inquest report has been marked as
Exbt.3/2. At about 7 pm son of Sushil also visited Dharmanagar hospital.
Keeping the dead boy of her brother at Dharmanagar hospital they came
to Kumarghat. Tamal is present today in the Court and is identified.
20.
During cross-examination she has deposed that Daroga of
Dharmanagar P.S. recorded her statement and she has stated to Daroga
of Dharmanagar that Tamal assaulted Sushil by a firewood on his head
which was informed to her by the wife of Sushil over phone. Nothing
more relevant came out.
21.
PW-6, Ranjit Kr. Nath has deposed that on 26.04.2018 he
was posted at Dharmanagar P.S. as ASI of police. On that day, vide
Dharmanagar
GD
entry
No.31
dated
06.02.2018
he
came
to
Dharmanagar District Hospital and prepared surathal report over the
dead body of Sushil Das, son of late Lalit Mohan Das of Sukanta Palli,
Kumarghat after observing proper formalities in presence of the
witnesses and this is his said surathal report bearing his signature. On
identification the surathal report is marked as Exbt.3/3 as a whole and
signature has been marked as Exbt.3/2. Thereafter, he has prepared
dead body challan forwarding to M.O., Dharmanagar hospital for
postmortem examination and this is his said dead body challan and on
identification the same has been marked as Exbt.5. He has also
examined and recorded the statement of Jatana Das, Abha Dey and one
Babul Deb who are the witnesses of the preparation of surathal report.
During cross-examination nothing relevant came out.
22.
PW-7, Suman Das has deposed that on 06.04.2018 one
Monojit @ Sudip Das who was known to him approached him for writing
an FIR on his behalf and then he wrote FIR as per his version an put his
signature as scribe in the said FIR. Witness identified the written FIR and
his signature thereon on identification the FIR has been marked as
Exbt.1/2 as a whole and his signature has been marked as Exbt.1/3.
During cross-examination nothing relevant came out.
23.
PW-8, Suman Saha has deposed that on 07.04.2018 he was
posted at Kumarghat P.S. as SI of Police. On that day O/C Kumarghat
namely P.S. Jayanta Karmakar registered Kumarghat P.S. case No.27/18
under Section 302 of IPC and endorsed him for investigation. During his
investigation, he visited the P.O., examined the complainant and another
witness i.e. PW-2 and recorded their statement and then he arrested the
FIR named accused namely Dipjoy Das. Later on, again he visited the PO
and prepared hand sketch map and separate index of the PO, on
identification the same are marked as Exbt.6 and 6/1 and then seized
one dry wooden file from the house of the complainant by which the
accused allegedly hit over the head of the deceased, preparing seizure
list, on identification the seizure list marked as Exbt.2/4 as a whole. He
also arranged one eye witness Supriya Nath and accordingly recorded
their statement and thereafter arranged her getting recorded statement
under Section 164 of Cr.P.C. Thereafter, he has further recorded
statements of two witnesses. Thereafter, he has collected SCD report
and Post mortem examination report of the deceased Sushil Das
prepared by ASI Ranji Kr. Nath. He has also examined and recorded
statement of scribe of the FIR. At last, on completion of investigation and
having found prima facie case he has filed charge sheet against the FIR
named accused Dipjoy Das vide Kumarghat PS charge sheet No.22/18
dated 30.06.2018 under Section 302 and Section 323 of IPC. This is his
said charge sheet bearing signature and it has been marked as Exbt.7(6
sheets). The seized wooden file (M.O.1) is identified by the witness,
witness also identified the accused in the dock.
24.
In the cross-examination he has deposed that along with
SCD report of deceased Sushil Das prepared by SI Ranjit Kr. Nath and
also received 161 statement of witnesses Jatana Das, Abha Dey and
Babul Dey recorded by ASI Ranjit Nath of Dharmanagar P.S. ‘H’
mentioned in his P.O. index indicates shop of Debabrata Das and except
his shop there are no other residential house or other shop situated near
by the PO. It has been further revealed in his investigation that the
father of the accused had died before the accident of the deceased. The
family of accused consists of his mother namely Bakul Pal(Das) and
sister Mitu Das. He has also found that after death of father of the
accused his sister and mother maintained the family of the accused by
way of private tuition. Noting more relevant came out during crossexamination.
25.
PW-9, Dr. Ashish Kr. Sen has deposed that on 07.04.2018
he was posted in the District Hospital, Dharmanagar and on that day, as
directed by the Hospital Super he conducted the autopsy of Sushil Das
aged about 52 years, son of late Lalit Mohan Das of Kumarghat. The
postmortem was started at 11 am. He found fracture on the skull over
the left fronto parietal area. Duromater under the skull was ruptured.
The brain was damaged and liquefied and mixed with blood. Time of
death is about 24 hours from the time of postmortem examination.
Cause of death was head injury and injury to the brain caused by impact
with a hard object. This is the report prepared by him and the signature
has been marked as Exbt.A. The witness confirms that Exbt.M.O.1 cause
the injuries in his postmortem report.
During cross-examination it has been stated that the injury
cannot happen by accidental fall on a heap of firewood. The Exbt.M.O.1
is a piece of firewood. Nothing more relevant came out during crossexamination.
26.
We have heard arguments of both the sides and gone
through the evidence on record i.e. the evidence of the prosecution as
well as the accused adduced before the Court in course of trial. From the
evidence on record, it appears that on 06.04.2018 at about 7/8 am in
the morning a hot altercation took place in between the mother of the
informant and his cousin brother and sister. That time, his aunt was also
present there and his father was sleeping in the room. Hearing the
sound, his father woke up and in the mean time his cousin brother Tamal
Das @ Dipjoy Das gave a blow to his mother and when his father came
in front of the door of the hut and asked the appellant as to why he was
doing so, that time the appellant by means of a firewood which has been
seized by the IO gave a stroke on the head of his father for which he fell
down on the earth and he was immediately shifted to Kumarghat
Hospital and from there he was further referred to Dharmanagar Hospital
and on that hospital his father succumbed to death. The case was
accordingly registered and the IO after completion of investigation laid
charge sheet against the present appellant.
27.
We have also gone through the postmortem examination
report which was proved by the prosecution of this case. At the same
time as already stated in the course of examination the appellant desired
his
willingness
to
adduce
witnesses
in
support
of
his
defence,
accordingly, the appellant himself was examined in support of his
defence and he has also adduced two more other witnesses to
substantiate his defence.
28.
Further, from the evidence on record of the accused, it
appears that on 06.04.2018 at about 6/6.30 am in the morning he was
sleeping in his house at Sukantanagar and his elder sister and mother
runs by doing private tuition. He woke up after hearing hue and cry of
his sister and saw that his uncle Sushil Das (since deceased) was
assaulting his sister by firewood and he tried to stop him and his uncle
was weak and he intervened. That time, the sister fell down under the
firewood and after that, they took their uncle inside the house and his
sister was admitted in the hospital and on the following day, she was
discharged and admitted the death of his uncle, Sushil Das. The
prosecution from the trend of cross-examination of the accused could not
raise any doubt to disbelieve the prosecution story.
29.
DW-2, Malabika Das the sister of the accused-appellant also
deposed in the same manner that the deceased Sushil Das assaulted her
by firewood on the left thigh and she raised hue and cry. That time, the
appellant Dipjoy came outside the room and he tried to take back the
firewood from the hand of his uncle he fell down on the firewood and got
hurt on his head due to fall. The prosecution by the trend of crossexamination could not raise any doubt to discard the evidence of said
witness, DW-2.
30.
Similarly, DW-3 Smt. Nikita Paul is also a student who was
undergoing private tuition in the residence of the accused on that day.
She also deposed that on the alleged day in course of quarrel she found
that the deceased was assaulting Malabika i.e. DW-2 with a firewood and
that time, the father of Malabika came to intervened his uncle and when
he tried to pull the said firewood from the hand of his uncle, he suddenly
fell down on the firewood and got injury. The prosecution by the trend of
cross-examination also could not raise any doubt to the evidence of said
witness.
31.
Thus, from the evidence on record of the prosecution as well
as the accused appellant it appears that on the relevant day some
dispute cropped up amongst both the parties and at that time the
deceased was assaulting the sister of the accused-appellant by a piece of
firewood and when the appellant came forward to save his wife, that
time either by the firewood he sustained injury of his own or he fell down
on the firewood for which he sustain fatal injury to his head and
ultimately succumbed to his single injury.
32.
From this set of evidences it is clear that the accused had
no intention to kill the death of his uncle and there was no prior
provocation to cause death of his uncle by firewood for which in our
considered view Section 302 of IPC as determined by the Learned Trial
Court below was not proper for upholding the conviction of the appellant
under the said provision of law.
33.
Rather in our considered view after going through the
evidence on record it appears that this is a case where the appellant can
be convicted under Section 304 Part-II of IPC i.e. culpable homicide not
amounting to murder and accordingly, we have decided to convert the
sentence from Section 302 of IPC to Section 304 Part-II of IPC which we
hereby do.
34.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby
allowed with modification that the appellant be convicted under Section
304 Part-II of IPC in place of Section 302 of IPC for a period of five
years. The period of detention undergone by the convict in custody be
set off accordingly.
35.
With the above observation, this appeal is accordingly
allowed in part to the extent as indicated.
The appeal stands disposed of .
Send down the LCRs.
A copy of this order be communicated to the Learned Court
below for doing the needful.
JUDGE
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.02.08 14:51:44 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review