Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
02.02.2026
M/L No.333
Court No.6
(gc)
CO 4556 of 2025
Dulal Chandra Pahari & Ors.
Vs.
Sri Shankarasis Pahari & Ors.
Mr. Jayanta Das,
Ms. Soumita Ghosh
…..for the Petitioners.
Mr. G.K. Das,
Mr. Kapil Ch. Sahoo
…for the Opposite Parties.
1. The petitioners are aggrieved by an order dated
November 15, 2025 passed by the learned Civil Judge
(Junior Division), Dantan, Paschim Medinipur in Title
Execution Case No.1 of 1997. The said execution case
arises out of a judgment and decree dated March 5,
1988 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Dantan, Paschim Medinipur.
By the order
impugned, the learned Court allowed the application
seeking police help and directed the S.P., Paschim
Medinipur to furnish and report on the police cost
required in respect of one Sub-Inspector of Police, two
Assistant Sub-Inspectors of Police, six male police
constables and six female constables from Belda Police
Station. The petitioners allege that without registering
the application for police help as a J. Misc. Case, the
same could not have been allowed.
I find that the
decree-holder sought for execution of the decree passed
in Title Suit No.192 of 1985 by filing Title Execution
Case No.1 of 1997.
The suit for eviction was decreed
some time in 1988 till now the decree-holders have not
been able to execute such decree owing to the
resistance of the petitioners, although, the judgment
debtor did not challenge the decree by filing an appeal.
It also does not appear that the petitioners had been
successful at any stage in challenging the executability,
discharge
and
satisfaction
of
the
decree.
The
petitioners claimed through the judgment-debtor and
they were brought on record only in the execution as
the legal representatives/heirs of the judgment-debtor.
The decree is binding on them.
2. The learned Court found from the bailiff’s report that on
October 29, 2025, the bailiff was obstructed by the
petitioners during the execution of the decree. It was
apparent from the report that on account of the
resistance, execution could not be carried out by the
Court bailiff. In order to achieve proper and smooth
execution of the decree, the prayer for police help was
allowed and the S.P., Paschim Medinipur was asked to
file a report with assessment of cost. It is informed to
the Court that the report for such cost was received by
the
learned
Court
deposited the same.
and
the
decree-holders
have
3. An execution case can be dismissed if the decree is
inexecutable or cannot be satisfied or discharged on
certain
legal
grounds.
The
objection
that
the
application for police help should have been registered
as a J. Misc. Case is only an issue of technicality. The
petitioners participated in the proceeding and opposed
such prayer. Not every application for police help is an
application under Order 21 Rule 97 of the Code of Civil
Procedure. There is nothing on record which would
show that the petitioners were armed with any order of
a competent forum which prevented the execution of the
decree. Execution of the decree is the duty of the court.
The
bailiff
cannot
be
obstructed.
If
they
resist
execution, it is the duty of the court to ensure execution
with the aid and assistance of the police.
4. Reference is made to the decision of Rahul S. Shah v.
Jinendra Kumar Gandhi and Ors., reported in (2021)
6 SCC 418, the Hon’ble Apex Court directed as follows:“41. Having regard to the above background,
wherein there is urgent need to reduce delays in
the
execution
proceedings
we
deem
it
appropriate to issue few directions to do
complete justice. These directions are in exercise
of our jurisdiction under Article 142 read with
Article 141 and Article 144 of the Constitution of
India in larger public interest to subserve the
process of justice so as to bring to an end the
unnecessary ordeal of litigation faced by parties
awaiting fruits of decree and in larger perspective
affecting the faith of the litigants in the process
of law.
42. All courts dealing with suits and execution
proceedings shall mandatorily follow the below
mentioned directions:
***
42.9. The court should allow taking of evidence
during the execution proceedings only in
exceptional and rare cases where the question of
fact could not be decided by resorting to any
other expeditious method like appointment of
Commissioner or calling for electronic materials
including photographs or video with affidavits.
42.10. The court must in appropriate cases
where it finds the objection or resistance or claim
to be frivolous or mala fide, resort to sub-rule (2)
of Rule 98 of Order 21 as well as grant
compensatory costs in accordance with Section
35-A.
***
42.12. The executing court must dispose of the
execution proceedings within six months from
the date of filing, which may be extended only by
recording reasons in writing for such delay.
42.13. The executing court may on satisfaction
of the fact that it is not possible to execute the
decree without police assistance, direct the
police station concerned to provide police
assistance to such officials who are working
towards execution of the decree. Further, in case
an offence against the public servant while
discharging his duties is brought to the
knowledge of the court, the same must be dealt
with stringently in accordance with law.”
5. Reference is made to the decision of Gaya Nath vs
Amulya Chandra reported in AIR 1957 Cal 252. This
judgment supports the view that an application for
police help is essentially different from an application
under Order 21 Rule 97 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
The court held as follows:“12. If the decree cannot be effectively executed
without police help the decree-holder may apply to
the Court for the grant of such help. An application
for police help is essentially different from an
application under order 21 rule 97 though the two
applications are often joined in one petition. This
Court has framed special rules for dealing with
applications for police help (See Manual of the Court
of Small Causes, Calcutta, Volume II, Part 4,
Chapter IV, page 54, rules 137 and 137A to 137D;
Civil Rules and Orders, Volume I, page 80, rule 261;
Original Side Rules, Chapter 17, rules 14A to 14D.
13. An order for police help vitally affects all
persons in actual possession of the property. With
the powerful backing of such an order all persons in
actual possession whether they are bound by the
decree or not are likely to be evicted brevi
manu from the property summarily. Relief by way of
restoration of possession obtained by an application
under Order 21. rule 100 is poor consolation for a
person who is unlawfully dispossessed. The Court
should, therefore, proceed with great caution in
granting police help. The Court should not hesitate
to give such aid if execution of its process is
unlawfully obstructed and its process cannot be
executed without such aid.”
6. Thus, the application may not be under Order 21 Rule
97 of the Code of Civil Procedure but a simple
application for assistance to the court bailiff in the
course of delivery of possession. This need not be
registered as a J. Misc Case. Reference is made to the
decision of Bandana Das vs Saroj Kumar Das
reported in (2009) 1 CHN 878 , the court held as
follows:“(16). In the facts of the instant case, taking into
consideration the pleadings of the decree - holder
in his application for police help under Rule 208
of the Civil Rules and Orders, there was no
occasion for the learned Court below to reject the
application, by observing, inter alia, that
complaint of obstruction and resistance was
required to be made by the decree-holder under
Order XXI Rule 97 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 and the provision of Rule 208 of the Civil
Rules and Orders would be attracted only
thereafter. It appears that the learned Court
below not only failed to take into consideration
the specific pleadings contained in the
application of the decree-holder, reproduced
hereinbefore, but also lost sight of the scope of
Rule 208 of the Civil Rules and Orders, which
has been discussed in detail hereinbefore.
(17). The scheme of the various provisions of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, entrusts an
obligation upon the Court to ensure that a valid
decree passed by it is not frustrated by reason of
resistance of someone or some persons who
cannot even lay a bona fide claim of not being
bound by the decree and therefore entitled to
resist eviction in execution of the decree.
(18). Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908, provides for execution of decrees and
orders. The elaborate provisions of the various
rules and sub-rules thereunder provides the
Court mechanism to enable execution of its
decrees and orders. In my view, as observed
hereinbefore, such procedural law cannot be
used to obstruct a valid decree being put into
execution, by reason of resistance of someone or
some persons who cannot even lay a bona fide
claim of not being bound by the decree and
therefore entitled to resist eviction on execution
of the decree. In fact, Order XXI Rule 97 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, is a facilitator to
the process of execution and not a hindrance.”
7. The petitioner contends that apart from the decretal
property, the petitioners are being removed from their
possession outside the decretal property. This issue is
not germane for a decision at this stage.
8. Under such circumstances, the revisional application
fails and is dismissed.
9. There shall be no order as to costs.
10. Parties are to act on the server copy of this order.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review