Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 28th JUNE, 2017
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RFA No.13 of 2016
Appellant
:
Dr. Yogesh Verma,
S/o Late T. C. Verma,
R/o Central Referral Hospital Manipal Quarters,
P.O. Tadong,
P.S. Sadar, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Shri Shiv Kumar Agarwal,
S/o Late Ram Chandra Agarwal,
C/o Shri Suresh Agarwal,
R/o 4th Floor, Verma Building,
National Highway,
P.O. Gangtok,
P.S. Sadar, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Suresh Agarwal,
S/o Late Ram Chandra Agarwal
R/o 4th Floor, Verma Building,
National Highway,
P.O. Gangtok,
P.S. Sadar, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI
Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Udai P. Sharma with Mr. Ugen Lepcha and Mr. Anup Gurung,
Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Advocate for the Respondents.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
and
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
CO No.03 of 2016
:
Appellants
1.
Shri Shiv Kumar Agarwal,
S/o Late Ram Chandra Agarwal,
C/o Shri Suresh Agarwal,
R/o 4th Floor, Verma Building,
National Highway,
P.O. Gangtok,
P.S. Sadar, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Suresh Agarwal,
S/o Late Ram Chandra Agarwal
R/o 4th Floor, Verma Building,
National Highway,
P.O. Gangtok,
P.S. Sadar, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
Dr. Yogesh Verma,
S/o Late T. C. Verma,
R/o Central Referral Hospital Manipal Quarters,
P.O. Tadong,
P.S. Sadar, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
Cross Objection under Order XLI Rule 22
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Advocate for the Appellants.
Mr. Udai P. Sharma with Mr. Ugen Lepcha and Mr. Anup Gurung,
Advocates for the Respondent.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Aggrieved and dissatisfied with the Judgment and
Decree, both dated 28-06-2016, passed by the Learned District
Judge, East Sikkim, at Gangtok, in Eviction Suit No.01 of 2014,
dismissing the suit of the Plaintiff, the instant Appeal has been
preferred. A Cross Objection was also filed by the Defendants
assailing the finding of the Learned Trial Court in Issue no.1.
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
2.
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
The Regular First Appeal and the Cross Objection are
being taken up together and disposed of by way of this common
Judgment as they arise out of the same impugned Judgment.
3.
The Appellant was the Plaintiff before the Learned Trial
Court, while the Respondents were the Defendants therein.
They
shall be referred to in terms of their appearance in the Learned Trial
Court.
4.
The Plaintiff had filed a Suit for Eviction and other reliefs
under Sections 4, 5 and 12 of the Gangtok Rent Control and Eviction
Act I of 1956 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act of 1956”), which
are extracted hereinbelow for convenience;
“GANGTOK RENT CONTROL AND EVICTION ACT I OF 1956
(Received assent of His Highness the Maharaja of Sikkim
on 3Ist May 1956)
Preamble. Whereas it is deemed expedient and necessary
to control rent and eviction of accommodation in Gangtok
Bazar premises ; it is hereby enacted as follows :…………………………………………………………………………………………….
1.
………………………………………………………………………
2.
………………………………………………………………………
3.
………………………………………………………………………
4.
A Landlord may not ordinarily eject any
tenant.
When, however, the whole or part of the
premises are required for the bonafide occupation of the
landlord or his dependents or for thorough overhauling
(excluding additions and alterations) or when the rent
in arrears amount to four months rent or more, the
landlord may evict the tenant on filing a suit of ejectment
in the Court of the Chief Magistrate. The tenant so evicted
shall, however, have the first right to re-occupy the
premises, after over-hauling, on such enhanced rent as
may be fixed by the Sikkim Darbar before it is let out to
any other tenant.
5.
No tenant shall sub-let the premises, either
in whole or in part, to a third party without the consent of
the Landlord.
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
6.
………………………………………………………………………
7.
………………………………………………………………………
8.
………………………………………………………………………
9.
………………………………………………………………………
10.
………………………………………………………………………
11.
………………………………………………………………………
12.
No tenant shall make any additions or
alterations to the building, or damage the structure in
any way, save in the course of ordinary wear and tear,
without the approval in writing of the landlord, failing
which the landlord shall have the right to evict such
tenant.
……………………………………………………………………”
13.
5.
The Plaintiff‟s case briefly narrated is that, he is the
owner of one flat measuring 15' x 20', presently in the occupation of
the Defendants, on the 4th floor of “Verma Building”, situated on the
National Highway, Gangtok.
The property earlier belonged to his
sister, Mrs. Karuna Khanna (nee Verma, hereinafter referred to as
“P.W.2”), for which rent was tendered by the Defendant No.1 in her
name. On 01-05-2013, the suit property came to be mutated in the
Plaintiff‟s name vide Exhibit 8, i.e., letter of the Sub-Registrar,
informing
him
of
mutation
of
the
property
in
his
name.
Consequently, P.W.2 sent a letter, Exhibit „A‟, by registered post on
21-05-2013 to the Defendant No.1, duly received by him on 22-052013, requesting him to attorn as a tenant under the Plaintiff, for
the suit premises. No heed being paid, a legal Notice was issued on
25-05-2013, by the Plaintiff to the Defendant No.1, requiring the
Defendants to hand over vacant possession to the Plaintiff.
The
Defendant No.1 while responding to the legal Notice on 09-09-2013,
denied any relationship of landlord and tenant between him and the
Plaintiff, asserting that P.W.2 was the owner thereof and he had not
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
been informed of the change of such ownership.
The Plaintiff
accordingly sought for eviction of the Defendant No.1 on the
following four grounds, viz.; that he required the premises for his
bona fide use and occupation having retired from Government
service, although he is reemployed elsewhere and has taken up
residence at the hospital quarters.
That, the Defendant No.1 has
defaulted in payment of rent from May 2013, besides sub-letting the
premises
to
Defendant
No.2,
and
carrying
out
unauthorised
alterations and additions in the suit premises.
6.
The Defendant No.1 for his part averred that he was
inducted as a tenant of Late Tek Chand Verma, the Plaintiff‟s father,
in 1981. On his death in March 2005, P.W.2 had received the suit
property in her share and the rent thereof was being collected by
Rakesh Verma, her brother, on her behalf.
Although he admitted
receipt of Exhibit „A‟, however, he denied awareness of the transfer
of ownership of the suit property in the name of the Plaintiff and
that, except the legal Notice dated 25-05-2013, which also was sent
sans any Registered Deed, neither Exhibit 8, nor Exhibit „A‟,
mentioned such transfer, hence, he continued tendering rent to
P.W.2, through Rakesh Verma.
While denying the landlord-tenant
relationship between him and the Plaintiff, claimed that the
additions and alterations were carried out with the due permission of
Tek Chand Verma and he had not sub-let the premises, but was in
joint occupation with the Defendant No.2, his younger brother and
other family members. Hence, the Suit be dismissed.
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
7.
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the Learned
Trial Court framed the following issues;
(i)
Whether the Plaintiff is the absolute owner of the suit
premises and whether a Landlord-Tenant relationship exists
between them? (Onus on the Plaintiff)
(ii)
Whether the Defendant No.1 has defaulted in the payment of
monthly rent in respect of the suit premises since the month
of May 2013? (Onus on the Plaintiff)
(iii)
Whether the
Defendant No.1 has made
additions and
alternations to the suit premises and has sublet the same suit
premises to the Defendant No.2? (Onus on the Plaintiff)
(iv)
Whether the Plaintiff requires the suit premises for his bona
fide occupation? (Onus on the Plaintiff)
(v)
8.
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs claimed?
The Learned Trial Court while deciding Issue No.1
reached the following findings;
“34.
The mutation order dated 01.05.2013 (Exhibit8) produced by the plaintiff for the first time on
18.08.2015 shows the plaintiff to be the owner of the suit
premise (sic). Hence, at the moment it is undeniable that
the plaintiff is the owner of the suit premise (sic). The
first part of issue No.1, whether the plaintiff is the
absolute owner of the suit premise (sic) has to be
answered in affirmative (sic).
However, I hasten to
mention that before the institution of the suit, defendant
No.1 was unsure of the same.
35.
..………….. The second part of issue No.1,
whether landlord-tenant relationship exists between
them, is answered in affirmative. …………….……”
The remaining Issues being Issue No.2 to Issue No.5 were
decided in favour of the Defendants and the Suit of the Plaintiff
dismissed.
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
9.
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
Before this Court, the arguments advanced by Learned
Counsel for the Plaintiff were that, during his employment in
Government service, he resided in Government accommodation
deducting rent from his salary. Although after his retirement, he is
reemployed in another Hospital, but is in occupation of hospital
accommodation, towards which house rent is deducted from his
salary, besides he is not assured of permanent accommodation,
hence, the bona fide requirement of the suit premises.
Secondly,
the Defendant No.1 has defaulted in payment of house rent from
May 2013, apart from altering the suit premises without the
Plaintiff‟s
written
permission,
which
therefore,
are
sufficient
grounds, as per Law, to evict him. The ground of sub-letting was
not pressed before this Court. It was next contended that no
infirmity
obtains
in
the
decision of the Learned Trial Court in
Issue No.1, which found him to be the owner of the suit premises in
view of Exhibit 8, hence the provisions of Section 109 of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (for short “T.P.A.”) falls into place.
To fortify his submissions, attention of this Court was invited to the
provisions of Sections 8, 106 and 109 of the T.P.A. and the decisions
in―
1.
3.
5.
(i)
Phiroze Bamanji Desai vs. Chandrakant M. Patel and
Others1;
(ii)
M/s. Hajee K. Assainar & Co. vs. Chacko Joseph2;
(iii)
Vasantkumar Radhakisan Vora (Dead) by his Lrs. vs.
Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay and Another 3;
(iv)
Shiv Sarup Gupta vs. Dr. Mahesh Chand Gupta4;
(v)
Revankumar R. Gaikwad vs. Bachchubhai P. Jethwa5;
(vi)
Keshar Bai vs. Chhunulal6.
AIR 1974 SC 1059
(1991) 1 SCC 761
AIR 2007 Bombay 132
2.
4.
6.
AIR 1984 Kerala 113
(1999) 6 SCC 222,
(2014) 11 SCC 438
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
10.
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
Resisting the stand taken by the Plaintiff, it was
canvassed by Learned Counsel for the Defendants that, Exhibit „C‟ a
registered document, indicates that the property belongs to P.W.2,
consequently Exhibit 8, relied on by the Plaintiff for ownership,
mutation for which was directly from the name of Tek Chand Verma
(his father), is an invalid document, in view of Exhibit „C‟. In this
context, attention of this Court was drawn to the provisions of
Sections 107, 122 and 123 of the T.P.A. which mandates that a
registered instrument be executed between the parties, but no such
instrument exists between them. That, no sale in terms of Section
54 of the T.P.A. has taken place between the Plaintiff and P.W.2.
Reliance was also placed on Sections 22 and 101 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 (for short “Evidence Act”). It was urged that in
the absence of compliance of any of the provisions supra, it is
evident that a fraud has been committed by the Plaintiff with regard
to Exhibit 8, hence, the Plaintiff is not the owner of the premises.
That, the letter of attornment, Exhibit „A‟, being devoid of a date
was not exhibited by the Plaintiff. The contents therein required the
Defendant No.1 to attorn immediately, but the absence of a date
therein resulted in vagueness, while Exhibit 8 was filed subsequently
by the Plaintiff, without leave of the Court.
It is also speculated
that, had the Defendant No.1 paid rent to the Plaintiff on the basis
of Exhibit „A‟, in all likelihood P.W.2 would
have
raised the plea,
that, the rent had been erroneously paid since Exhibit „A‟ did not
bear her signature, as her signature allegedly affixed on Exhibit „A‟
differs from that on Exhibit „C‟.
The Acknowledgment Card
purported to be that for Exhibit „A‟ does not reflect as to what
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
document was delivered to the Defendant No.1. That, the evidence
of P.W.2 does not reveal that she had transferred the property to
the Plaintiff.
She has merely deposed that the premises was
mutated in the name of the Plaintiff since 01-05-2013 and hence,
the Defendant No.1 was to attorn as the tenant of the Plaintiff.
11.
That, the ground of bona fide requirement of the Plaintiff
is only a ruse to evict them from the suit premises as the Plaintiff
has
always
availed
of
Government
accommodation
and
on
retirement is living in quarters provided by the hospital, where he is
employed. The crux of the Suit is the escalating commercial rates in
the area, resulting in the collusive suit between the Plaintiff and
P.W.2,
to
evict
the
Defendants.
In
order
to
buttress
his
submissions, reliance was placed on Rangammal vs. Kuppuswami and
Another7.
To establish that when the Plaintiff has not proved his title
and the title relied on is invalid in law, succour was drawn from
Bajranglal Shivchandrai Ruia
vs. Shashikant N. Ruia and Others8.
Reliance was also placed on Kailash vs. Nanhku and Others9. Support
was also taken from Uppalapati Veera Venkata Satyanarayanaraju and
Another vs. Josyula Hanumayamma and Another10,
wherein a Single
Judge although in agreement with three other Judges to dismiss the
Appeal, by a separate Judgment, held that attornment is complete
the moment the tenant agrees to acknowledge the new landlord to
be his landlord. Thus, as in the instant case, he has not attorned to
the Plaintiff, it is evident that he has not acknowledged the Plaintiff
7. (2011) 12 SCC 220
8. (2004) 5 SCC 272
9. (2005) 4 SCC 480
10. AIR 1967 SC 174
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
to be his landlord and the question of default does not arise nor can
the other grounds for eviction come into play.
12.
In Cross Objection, the grounds taken by the Defendant
No.1 was that the Learned Trial Court had reached an erroneous
finding that the Plaintiff was the owner of the suit premises as no
registered instrument evidencing such transfer by P.W.2, to the
Plaintiff existed. That, the suit property had fallen in her share, vide
Exhibit „C‟, a Partition Deed, between the offspring of Tek Chand
Verma, for which she had been collecting rent. That, Exhibit 8 was
filed only with the amended Plaint instead of the first Plaint,
although no leave of the Court was sought to file an additional
document.
Hence, Exhibit 8 could not be relied on as it was
objected to at the trial stage, despite which the Learned Trial Court
considered it, without deciding upon its admissibility.
Even
assuming that Exhibit 8 is admissible in evidence, it is clear that the
property was mutated to the Plaintiff‟s name from that of Tek Chand
Verma, who was not the owner as on 01-05-2013, P.W.2 being the
owner thereof.
Per contra, it was claimed by the Plaintiff that no
error obtains in the said decision.
13.
I have considered the rival contentions of both Learned
Counsel at length and given due consideration to their submissions.
I have also carefully considered the documents on record and the
pleadings as well as the impugned judgment.
Thus, what requires consideration of this Court is ―
14.
(i)
Whether a jural relationship exists between the Plaintiff and
the Defendant No.1 as landlord and tenant?
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
(ii)
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs sought, on
grounds put forth by him?
15.
Taking up the first question for consideration, it is no
one‟s case that the Suit is for declaration of title, it is indeed a Suit
for
eviction,
thus,
the
pivotal
argument
of
Defendant
No.1
concerning Exhibit 8 is taken up. Exhibit 8 reads as follows;
“GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
EAST DISTRICT COLLECTORATE
GANGTOK-SIKKIM
Memo No.
5/DC/E/DCE
Dated Gangtok
1/5/013
.
To,
Dr. Yogesh Verma
S/o Lt. T.C Verma
Gangtok.
Sub: Mutation
Reference your application dated: Nil on the subject cited
above, you are hereby informed that a property as shown
in the schedule below has been mutated in your name
from Lt. Tek Chand Verma .
SCHEDULE OF THE PROPERTY
One of the two shop space on the Northern site of the
ground floor (NH-31A Level) and the entire first floor and
entire fourth floor being part of the seventh storied RCC
building built on plot no.III, Block C,NH-31 A ,Gangtok.
Sd/seal
Sub-Registrar,
Gangtok”
16.
The letter thus postulates that the property, as identified
in the letter, has been mutated in the name of the Plaintiff. It is not
disputed that the property so described is the suit property.
The
moot point would be whether this document confers title to the
Plaintiff. The consequences of a mutation have been discussed by
this Court in Karma Doma Gyatso alias Babila Kazi vs. Mrs. Kesang
Choden & Ors.11 which
Pradhan and
11.
while referring to the case of Arjun Kumar
Others vs.
AIR 2009 Sikkim 6
12.
Ram
Kumar Mazi12, held
that
Civil Revision 3 of 2005, decided on 28-09-2005
mere
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
recording of
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
name(s) in the record of rights, including
does not confer any right or title to any land.
khatiyan,
Thus, mutation
proceedings not being judicial proceedings, no question relating to
proprietary rights in immovable rights are determined in such
proceedings.
In (Thakur) Nirman Singh and Others vs. Thakur Lal
Rudra Pratap Narain Singh and Others13,
it was held that, mutation
proceedings are much more in the nature of fiscal inquiries,
instituted in the interest of the State, for the purpose of ascertaining
which of the several claimants for the occupation of certain
denominations of immovable property, may be put into occupation
of it, with greater confidence that the revenue for it will be paid.
Such proceedings are not evidence that the successful applicant was
in possession as sole legal owner, in a proprietary sense, to the
exclusion of all claims of the other members of the family as coowners, or for maintenance or otherwise, as revenue authorities
have no jurisdiction to pronounce upon the validity of such a claim.
In Smt. Sawarni vs. Smt. Inder Kaur and Others14, it was, inter alia,
held that, mutation of a property in the revenue record does not
create or extinguish title nor has it any presumptive value on title.
It only enables the person in whose favour mutation is ordered to
pay the land revenue in question. This was reiterated in Municipal
Corporation, Gwalior
Thus,
what
vs. Puran Singh alias Puran Chand and Others15.
emerges
from
the
gamut
of
decisions
hereinabove, is that, mutation does not confer title.
would be apposite for the instant case.
13.
14.
15.
AIR 1926 PC 100
AIR 1996 SC 2823
(2015) 5 SCC 725
reflected
The same
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
17.
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
What is relevant for the present purposes is that,
despite
the
Defendant
No.1
raising
arguments
on
the
non-
compliance of Sections 54, 107, 122 and 123 of the T.P.A., P.W.2
has no quarrel with the signature appearing on Exhibit „A‟, given the
fact that, she has identified Exhibit „A(a)‟ on Exhibit „A‟ as her
signature and admitted that the suit property had been recorded in
the name of the Plaintiff. If the Defendant No.1 was suspicious of
the authenticity of Exhibit „A‟, all that he was required to do to clear
the air on this issue, was to either approach the Plaintiff or P.W.2 or
in her absence Rakesh Verma, who was collecting the rent on her
behalf. P.W.2 has clearly admitted that the property belongs to the
Plaintiff, merely because, electricity bills are still being issued in her
name does not establish that the property is hers in the face of her
denial. In this context, the provisions of Section 58 of the Evidence
Act are thus applicable. In any event, the Defendant No.1 was also
free
to
approach
grievances
the
regarding
appropriate
forgery
if
Authorities
he
deemed
to
redress
his
it
relevant
or
appropriate. In the light of the above facts, I see no reason as to
why the Defendant No.1 should take up cudgels on behalf of P.W.2,
who is not aggrieved by the entire situation, and neither is there any
acrimony between her and the Plaintiff, with regard to the
ownership of the suit property. In other words, on the admission of
P.W.2, the suit property does indeed belong to the Plaintiff and it is
not the place of the Defendant No.1 to question the Plaintiff‟s
ownership.
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
18.
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
The Law on this aspect is well-settled, inasmuch as, in a
Suit for eviction the title of the Appellant cannot be adjudicated
upon. In Keshar Bai6, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that;
“15. The High Court has expressed that the
respondent was justified in asking the appellant to
produce the documents. Implicit in this observation is the
High Court's view that the respondent could have in an
eviction suit got the title of the appellant finally
adjudicated upon. There is a fallacy in this reasoning. In
eviction proceedings the question of title to the properties
in question may be incidentally gone into, but cannot be
decided finally.
16.
A similar question fell for consideration of
this Court in Bhogadi Kannababu [(2006) 5 SCC 532]. In that
case it was argued that the landlady was not entitled to
inherit the properties in question and hence could not
maintain the application for eviction on the ground of
default and sub- letting under the A.P. Tenancy Act. This
Court referred to its decision in Tej Bhan Madan v. Addl.
District Judge [(1988) 3 SCC 137] in which it was held that a
tenant was precluded from denying the title of the
landlady on the general principle of estoppel between the
landlord and the tenant and that this principle, in its basic
foundations, means no more than that under certain
circumstances law considers it unjust to allow a person to
approbate and reprobate. Section 116 of the Evidence Act
is clearly applicable to such a situation. This Court held
that even if the landlady was not entitled to inherit the
properties in question, she could still maintain the
application for eviction and the finding of fact recorded by
the courts below in favour of the landlady, was not liable
to be disturbed. The position on law was stated by this
Court as under: (Bhogadi Kannubabu case, SCC p. 538,
para 19)
“19. In this connection, we may also point
out that in an eviction petition filed on the ground
of sub-letting and default, the court needs to
decide whether relationship of landlord and tenant
exists and not the question of title to the
properties in question, which may be incidentally
gone into, but cannot be decided finally in the
eviction proceeding.”
In the backdrop of this decision, it is elucidated here that the
question of title is not relevant and reiterated that it is not the place
of the Defendant No.1 to make enquiries about such.
19.
Now, addressing the question of attornment, it is the
contention of the Defendant No.1 that on account of the doubts of
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
the authenticity of Exhibit „A‟ in view of Exhibit „C‟, he refused to
attorn to the Plaintiff as his tenant. That, so long as, he does not
accept the Plaintiff as his landlord, the attornment cannot be
complete.
20.
On this point, useful reference may be made to Section
109 of the T.P.A. which deals with the rights of the lessor‟s
transferee. The underlying principle of the Section is that the rights
attached to property which arise out of the possession and control of
property will pass with the property. For convenience, the Section is
reproduced hereinbelow;
“109. Rights of lessor’s transferee.—If the
lessor transfers the property leased, or any part thereof,
or any part of his interest therein, the transferee, in the
absence of a contract to the contrary, shall possess all the
rights, and, if the lessee so elects, be subject to all the
liabilities of the lessor as to the property or part
transferred so long as he is the owner of it; but the lessor
shall not, by reason only of such transfer cease to be
subject to any of the liabilities imposed upon him by the
lease, unless the lessee elects to treat the transferee as
the person liable to him:
Provided that the transferee is not entitled to
arrears of rent due before the transfer, and that, if the
lessee, not having reason to believe that such transfer
has been made, pays rent to the lessor, the lessee shall
not be liable to pay such rent over again to the
transferee.
The lessor, the transferee and the lessee may
determine what proportion of the premium or rent
reserved by the lease is payable in respect of the part so
transferred, and, in case they disagree, such
determination may be made by any Court having
jurisdiction to entertain a suit for the possession of the
property leased.”
On a bare reading of the Section, it is clear that the Section
does not insist that the transfer of the landlord‟s rights can take
effect only if the tenant attorns. We may also beneficially refer to
the decision in Vasantkumar Radhakisan Vora3 wherein it was, inter
alia, held that —
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
“13. It is no doubt true that per se Section 109
T. P. Act does not apply to the facts of this case. It
contemplates transfer of lessor‟s right inter vivos. But
when right, title and interest in immovable property stand
transferred by operation of law, the spirit behind Section
109 perforce would apply and successor in interest would be
entitled to the rights of the predecessor. This is what the
learned Single Judge of the High Court in the impugned
judgment has held and we approve of the view as correct.
We accordingly, hold that the notice terminating the tenancy
of Vasantkumar would enure to the benefit of the
respondent and it could be availed of by the respondent to
lay the suit for ejectment.”
21.
The decision clarifies that attornment by a tenant is not
necessary, in which situation Exhibit „A‟ falls into place, the
document being admitted, by P.W.2.
It stands to reason that the
Plaintiff is the owner of the suit property and consequently, it cannot
be denied that a jural relationship of landlord and tenant exists
between the Plaintiff and the Defendant.
22.
The next question that arises now is with regard to the
admissibility of Exhibit 8. This document was filed subsequently by
the Plaintiff. Order VII Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
(for short “CPC”) deals with production of document on which the
Plaintiff sues or relies. The provision reads as follows;
“14. Production of document on which plaintiff
sues or relies.—(1) Where a Plaintiff sues upon a
document or relies upon document in his possession or
power in support of his claim, he shall enter such
document in a list, and shall produce it in Court when the
plaint is presented by him and shall, at the same time
deliver the document and a copy thereof, to be filed with
the plaint.
(2)
Where any such document is not in the
possession or power of the plaintiff, he shall, wherever
possible, state in whose possession or power it is.
(3) A document which ought to be produced in
Court by the plaintiff when the plaint is presented, or to
be entered in the list to be added or annexed to the plaint
but is not produced or entered accordingly, shall not,
without the leave of the Court, be received in evidence on
his behalf at the hearing of the suit.
(4)
…………………………………………………………….”
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
23.
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
The provision is self-explanatory and in view of the
specific mandate therein, I am inclined to agree with the argument
of Learned Counsel for the Defendants that while filing Exhibit 8, the
provisions of Order VII Rule 14 of the CPC ought to have been
complied with.
No leave of the Court was sought to file the said
document. The records of the Learned Trial Court reveal no
reference to Exhibit 8, when the prayer for amendment under Order
VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the CPC was put forth by the
Plaintiff.
It is also evident that the Defendant No.1 objected to
Exhibit 8, when the Plaintiff was re-examined after filing of the
amended Plaint, on the ground that the document was not filed
along with the original Plaint, nor had the Plaintiff sought leave of
the Court to exhibit the document subsequently.
Besides, on
walking through Order XIII Rule 3, of the CPC, it specifically lays
down that the Court may at any stage of the Suit reject any
document which it considers irrelevant or otherwise inadmissible,
recording the grounds of such rejection. Thus, the above provision
of Law requires the Court to either allow or reject any document
which may be found to be either irrelevant or inadmissible by a
speaking order.
In Smt. Lachungmu Lepcha and Another vs. Shri
Gyatso Lepcha and Others16,
this Court had issued directions for
compliance of Order XIII Rule 3 of the CPC to the Subordinate
Courts in Sikkim, which apparently have not been adhered to. The
Learned Trial Court has failed to comply with the mandate of Law as
provided in Order VII Rule 14 of the CPC or Order XIII Rule 3 of the
CPC. In the said circumstances, it is evident that Exhibit 8 could not
16.
RFA No.15 of 2013, decided on 12-08-2015
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
have been admitted in evidence and is, therefore, not eligible for
consideration.
24.
The question of admissibility of the Exhibit 8 having thus
been settled, it is now required to be considered, Whether the
Plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs claimed?
The evidence of the
Plaintiff reveals categorically that, he was a Government Doctor
serving as Principal Chief Consultant and Medical Superintendent in
the STNM Hospital, Gangtok and was residing at the STNM Hospital
Doctors quarters, for which monthly rent of Rs.9,000/- (Rupees nine
thousand) only, was being deducted from his salary. Thereafter, he
retired from Government service and is now employed at the Central
Referral Hospital, Tadong, but once again in occupation of Doctors
quarters at the Hospital premises, deducting rent from his salary
while the Defendant No.1 continues to remain in occupation of
premises owned by him.
In Shiv Sarup Gupta4, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while
25.
referring to a Full Bench decision of the High Court of Madhya
Pradesh in Damodar Sharma and Another vs. Nandram Deviram17 held
that; Pandey, J., recording the majority opinion emphasised the
distinction
between
the
expressions
“genuinely
requires”
and
“reasonably requires” and said;
“15. ………………………………….……………………………
“It is wrong to say that „genuinely requires‟
is the same as „reasonably requires‟. There is a
distinction between the two phrases. The former
phrase refers to a state of mind; the latter to an
objective standard. „Genuine requirement‟ would
vary according to the idiosyncrasy of the individual
and the time and circumstances in which he lives
17.
AIR 1960 MP 345
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
and thinks. Reasonable requirement belongs to the
„knowledge of the law‟ and means reasonable not
in the mind of the person requiring the
accommodation but reasonable according to the
actual facts. In my opinion, in this part of Section
4(g), the landlord is made the sole arbiter of his
own requirements but he must prove that he, in
fact, wants and genuinely intends to occupy the
premises. His claim would no doubt fail if the Court
came to the conclusion that the evidence of „want‟
was unreliable and that the landlord did not
genuinely intend to occupy the premises.”
In Phiroze Bamanji Desai1 it was observed that juridical
possession of other premises by a landlord cannot be considered in
determining the need of the landlord. In Sait Nagjee Purushotham &
Co. Ltd. vs. Vimalabai Prabhulal and Others18 it was observed that, it is
always the prerogative of the landlord that if he requires the
premises in question for his bona fide use for expansion of business
the tenants cannot be heard to say that the landlord already have
their business at other places. The tenant cannot dictate terms to
the landlord and advise him what he should do and what he should
not.
It is for the landlord to choose the nature and place of
business. Thus, what categorically emerges from all of the above is
that there must be an element of genuine need and not a
mere desire on the part of the landlord. On the touchstone of the
aforesaid decisions and while considering the plight of the Plaintiff
and the fact that he has had to move from Government quarters
to Doctors‟ quarters paying rent, when he owns private premises
which the Defendants continue to occupy, there is no doubt that
his requirement is not a mere desire, but a genuine requirement,
in
other
words, it is a bona fide requirement for his own
occupation.
18.
(2005) 8 SCC 252
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
26.
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
The next ground raised was with regard to the default
in payment of rent. Evidently, from the month of May 2013, rent
has not been deposited by the Defendant No.1.
In this context,
when we peruse the evidence of the Defendant No.1, he has
admitted receipt of Exhibit „A‟. He also admits that he was sending
the rent by Post in the name of P.W.2, however, after the Money
Orders for the rent was returned to him, with the endorsement that,
P.W.2 did not reside in the said address, he, admittedly, made no
effort to verify her address, but continued to send the Money Orders
in the previous address.
He refused to accept the reality of the
contents of Exhibit „A‟ and continued to forward the rent to P.W.2,
who had already requested him to attorn to the Plaintiff as his
tenant. The act of the Defendant No.1 has thus resulted in default
of payment of rent from May 2013.
27.
The ground of sub-letting requires no discussion, not
having been pursued before this Court.
28.
Coming to the question of eviction on the ground of
alterations and additions made to the suit premises, Section 8 of the
T.P.A. deals with operation of transfer and provides that unless by
the terms of the deed the transfer is limited, a transfer of property
passes forthwith to the transferee all the interest which the
transferor is then capable of passing in the property. The general
principle being that a person cannot transfer to another more than
what he or she is entitled, ofcourse, it may be added that the
method of such transfer is immaterial, inasmuch as it could be by
sale, gift, mortgage or lease.
The alternations/additions were
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
carried out in 1992, when neither P.W.2 nor the Plaintiff were the
owners of the suit premises.
P.W.2 could not have passed on a
better title than she had as apparent from the aforesaid legal
position. Thus, this ground is not available to the Plaintiff.
29.
Hence, in consideration of the totality of the facts and
circumstances, the evidence and documents on record and the
foregoing discussions, it is concluded that there is undoubtedly a
jural relationship between the Plaintiff and the Defendant No.1 as
landlord and tenant. The Plaintiff is entitled to the eviction of the
Defendants on grounds of bona fide use and occupation of the
Plaintiff himself and on account of default of rent by the Defendant
No.1 from the month of May 2013.
30.
With regard to the decision in Issue No.1, although this
Court has arrived at a finding of ownership on a different footing
from that of the Learned Trial Court, nevertheless, it cannot be
denied that the Plaintiff owns the suit premises and is thus the
Defendants‟ landlord.
31.
Appeal allowed. Cross Objection dismissed.
32.
The Defendants shall vacate the suit premises on or
before 31-12-2017 and hand over vacant possession to the Plaintiff.
The Defendant No.1 shall pay the arrears in rent from the month of
May 2013, till the time that he hands over vacant possession of the
suit premises to the Plaintiff as ordered herein.
RFA No.13 of 2016 and CO No.03 of 2016
Dr. Yogesh Verma
33.
vs. Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another
&
Shiv Kumar Agarwal and Another vs. Dr. Yogesh Verma
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Trial Court
for information.
34.
No order as to costs.
35.
Records of the Learned Trial Court be remitted forthwith.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
28-06-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review