Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..1..
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 368 OF 2016
JUDGMENT DATED 15.12.2015 IN OP NO.414/2013 OF FAMILY COURT,
PALA
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
DR.YAKOB MARTIN KOCHERIC, AGED 34 YEARS
S/O.MARTIN OBIE JACOB, AGED 34 YEARS,KOCHERY HOUSE,
PARAKKULAM ROAD,IRINJALAKKUDA, THRISSUR
BY ADVS.
SRI.A.T.ANILKUMAR
SMT.V.SHYLAJA
RESPONDENT/COUNTER PETITIONER:
DR.LISA BABU JOSEPH, AGED 33 YEARS, D/O.BABU JOSEPH
IRS, KIZHAKKETHOTTIYIL HOUSE, VATTUKULAM
PO,KADAPOOOR KARA, KANAKKARI VILLAGE, MEENACHIL
TALUK
BY ADVS.
SMT.ANU GEORGE
SRI.MOHAN JACOB GEORGE
SMT.P.V.PARVATHI
SMT.REENA THOMAS
SRI.SIBY CHENAPPADY
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
07.03.2025, ALONG WITH MAT.APPEAL.262/2016, 492/2016, THE COURT
ON 02.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..2..
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 262 OF 2016
JUDGMENT DATED 15.12.2015 IN OP NO.413/2013 OF FAMILY COURT,
PALA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
DR.LISA BABU JOSEPH
D/O.BABU JOSEPH, IRS, KIZHAKKETHOTTIYIL HOUSE,
VATTUKULAM PO, KODAPOOR KARA, KANAKKARY VILLAGE,
MEENACHIL TALUK, KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, PIN-686 596.
BY ADVS.
SRI.MOHAN JACOB GEORGE
SMT.ANU GEORGE
SMT.P.V.PARVATHI
SMT.REENA THOMAS
SRI.SIBY CHENAPPADY
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
DR.YAKOB MARTIN KOCHERIE
AGED 37 YEARS
S/O.MARTIN OBIE JACOB, KOCHERY HOUSE, PARAKULAM
ROAD, IRINJALAKUDA, THRISSUR-680 121.
MARTIN OBIE JACOB
AGED 66 YEARS
KOCHERY HOUSE, PARAKULAM ROAD, IRINJALAKUDA,
THRISSUR-680 121.
MARY MARTIN
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, W/O.MARTIN OBIE JACOB, KOCHERY
HOUSE, PARAKULAM ROAD, IRINJALAKUDA, THRISSUR-680
121.
BY ADV SRI.A.T.ANILKUMAR
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..3..
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
07.03.2025, ALONG WITH MAT.APPEAL.368/2016 AND CONNECTED CASE,
THE COURT ON 02.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..4..
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
ND
WEDNESDAY, THE 2
DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 492 OF 2016
JUDGMENT DATED 15.12.2015 IN OP NO.413/2013 OF FAMILY COURT,
PALA
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS:
DR. YAKOB MARTIN KOCHERIE, AGED 34 YEARS
S/O.MARTIN OBIE JACOB, AGED 34 YEARS,KOCHERY HOUSE,
PARAKKULAM ROAD,IRINJALAKKUDA, TRISSUR.
MARTIN OBIE JACOB, AGED 63 YEARS
KOCHERY HOUSE, PARAKKULAM ROAD,IRINJALAKKUDA,
TRISSUR.
MARY MARTIN, AGED 58 YEARS
W/O.MARTIN OBIE JACOB, AGED 58 YEARS,KOCHERY HOUSE,
PARAKKULAM ROAD,IRINJALAKKUDA, TRISSUR.
BY ADV SRI.A.T.ANILKUMAR
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
DR. LISA BABU JOSEPH, D/O BABU JOSEPH IRS, AGED 33
YEARS, KIZHAKKETHOTTIYIL HOUSE, VATTUKULAM P.O.,
KADAPOOR KARA, KANAKKARI VILLAGE, MEENACHIL TALUK
BY ADVS.
SMT.ANU GEORGE
SRI.MOHAN JACOB GEORGE
SMT.P.V.PARVATHI
SMT.REENA THOMAS
SRI.SIBY CHENAPPADY
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
07.03.2025, ALONG WITH Mat.Appeal.368/2016 AND CONNECTED CASES,
THE COURT ON 02.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..5..
JUDGMENT
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, J.
These appeals arise from the judgment dated 15.12.2015 in
O.P.Nos. 413 and 414 of 2013 on the files of the Family Court,
Pala.
Since
the
parties
are
the
same
and
the
issues
are
interrelated, the appeals were heard together and are being
disposed
of
by
this
judgment.
The
parties
are
hereinafter
referred to as, the “husband” and the “wife”.
2.
Mat.
Appeal
No.262
of
is
filed
by
the
wife
challenging the dismissal of her claim in OP No.413 of 2013 for
return of gold ornaments weighing 101 sovereigns, money and other
valuables. Mat. Appeal No. 492 of 2016 is filed by the husband
against the dismissal of his counter claim in OP No.413 of 2013
to recover the value of articles worth ₹13,90,000/-. Mat. Appeal
No.368 of 2016 is filed by the husband, challenging the decree in
OP No.414 of 2013, granting custody of the minor child to the
wife.
3.
The brief facts leading to the afore original petitions
are as follows: The marriage between the parties was solemnized
on 14.02.2004 and a male child was born in their wedlock. Both
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..6..
husband and wife are doctors.
4.
According to the wife, the husband and his family
demanded ₹20,00,000/-, 101 sovereigns of gold ornaments and a car
as
dowry.
instalments,
Her
father
gave
as
patrimony.
₹20,00,000/-
She
was
also
lakhs,
in
four
provided
with
sovereigns of gold ornaments. It is alleged that out of the 101
sovereigns of gold ornaments given to her, 80 were sold by the
husband and his family for their own needs. The wife claimed that
the patrimony given was not sufficient enough for purchasing a
car
and
hence,
her
father
gave
an
additional
amount
of
₹2,00,000/- to the husband for utilising the said amount for
purchasing a TATA Indica car. The wife claims that with the afore
amount and by availing a car loan, the car was purchased and she
had repaid the loan in 60 equal monthly instalments of ₹3,925/from
her
professional
income,
totalling
to
an
amount
of
₹2,35,500/-. It is the claim of the wife that, as demanded by the
parents-in-law,
her
parents
gave
a
washing
machine
worth
₹22,000/- and household articles worth ₹50,000/-. She further
claimed that for pursuing the husband’s postgraduate studies in
Chennai, her father was forced to give ₹5,00,000/- and the
balance amount was obtained by selling 80 sovereigns of gold
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..7..
ornaments.
She
further
alleged
that,
while
the
husband
was
studying in Chennai, an amount of ₹6,00,000/- was transferred
during March, 2007 to August, 2010 for his personal expenses and
an amount of ₹46,000/- was given on 20.06.2008 and ₹1,50,000/during June, 2009. Further, a laptop worth ₹56,000/-, a camera
worth ₹15,000/-, a mobile phone worth ₹24,000/-, and an amount of
₹25,000/- for repairing his car were given to him. According to
the wife, due to the cruelty of the husband, she left the
matrimonial home on 02.10.2010. Thereafter, the wife filed OP
No.413 of 2013 for return of gold ornaments, money and other
valuables.
5.
The husband refuted all the allegations raised by the
wife. He contended that the marriage was preceded by a five-year
love affair. There was no demand from his family for money or
gold ornaments. It was decided between the parties that the
bride's side would provide gold, clothing, and other materials
for the family members, and also bear the costs of the betrothal
ceremony. It was also decided that the groom's side would bear
the costs of the marriage. The husband further contended that the
wife did not wear 101 sovereigns of gold ornaments and no money
was paid to the husband or his family. He also denied the
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..8..
allegation that money was given for the purchase of the car. He
further contended that the wife neither brought any articles nor
gave any amount for his studies in Chennai. According to him, the
laptop, camara, mobile phone etc., were purchased with the funds
provided by his father, who had returned from abroad and was
quite wealthy. It was further contended that, when the husband
and his family members were away from home, the wife took away
all the articles therefrom worth ₹13,90,000/-; and thus, he filed
a counter claim for ₹13,90,000/-.
6.
The Family Court, on an elaborate consideration of the
issue, dismissed the original petition filed by the wife for
return of gold and other articles, and the counter claim filed by
the husband. The original petition filed by the husband for
custody of the minor child was also dismissed.
7.
the
wife;
We have heard Sri.Siby Chennappady, learned counsel for
and
Sri.A.T.Anil
Kumar,
learned
counsel
for
the
husband.
Mat. Appeal No. 262 of 2016
8.
In Mat. Appeal No.262 of 2016, the wife alleged that,
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..9..
as demanded by the husband and his family members, 101 sovereigns
of gold ornaments and an amount of ₹20,00,000/- was given by her
father as patrimony in four instalments before the marriage,
i.e.,
₹7,00,000/-
₹4,50,000/-
on
on
24.12.2003,
23.01.2004,
₹6,00,000/-
₹2,50,000/-
on
on
18.01.2004,
07.02.2004.
The
engagement was in September, 2003, and the betrothal was on
07.02.2004. In order to prove entrustment of the amount, the wife
relied on Exts.A5 to A7 and Ext.B68 series. In order to prove the
quantity of ornaments, Ext.A8 photograph and Exts.A9 & A10 bills
were relied on. Ext.A13 series was relied on to prove the sale of
gold ornaments. According to the wife, an amount of ₹20,00,000/was paid on different dates and Ext.B68 (fl), Ext.B68 (cz),
Ext.B68
(cy)
and
Ext.B68
(cp)
payslips
reveal
deposit
of
₹1,50,000/- each, totalling to ₹6,00,000/-, by the husband’s
father on 19.01.2004 in the Irinjalakuda branch of different
banks, viz., the South Indian Bank, Federal Bank, Lord Krishna
Bank, and the Dhanalakshmi Bank. It is the case of the wife that
an amount of ₹20,00,000/- was entrusted to the husband and his
family, and their own documents prove its deposit in different
banks. It is also her case that the gold ornaments kept in the
locker were utilized towards his personal needs and an amount of
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..10..
₹3,20,000/- was given to the husband on 23.01.2007 for his higher
studies
by
selling
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments.
To
substantiate the above contention, she relied on Ext.B53, which
reveals that the locker was operated on 22.01.2007 by the mother
of the husband.
9.
On the other hand, the husband denied the entrustment
of gold ornaments and contended that he and his family had
provided gold ornaments for the wife. The husband also contended
that while he and his family members were away from their house
on 02.10.2010, the wife’s father came to their house and the wife
left the matrimonial home taking all the gold ornaments and other
articles
therefrom,
worth
₹13,90,000/-.
The
husband
filed
a
counter claim in the original petition for recovering the afore
amount.
He
denied
all
the
allegations
raised
by
the
wife.
According to him, even prior to the marriage, fixed deposits were
made in the name of the wife, and his family was well off with
sufficient fixed deposits even prior to the marriage. He further
contended that his mother was having a locker facility and was
operating the said locker from 2002 onwards. The husband produced
Ext.B53 to prove that, even prior to the marriage, the locker was
being operated by his mother in 2002, 2003 and 2004. Admittedly,
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..11..
the
parties
were
living
separately
from
02.10.2010.
It
is
contended that even thereafter, the locker was being operated by
his mother till 2012. He denied the wife’s allegation that the
locker was operated on 22.01.2007 to take her gold ornaments. The
husband relied on his own deposition and Exts.B33 to B37 and B48
to B52 photos to prove that the ornaments were with the wife and
she used to wear the same while attending functions, when they
were leading a cordial life. In order to prove their financial
capacity,
the
husband
relied
on
Ext.B61
series
of
deposit
confirmation/renewal advice of HDFC Bank and Ext.B69 series of
gold purchase bills. According to the husband, no amount was
spent by the wife towards his educational expenses and the amount
transferred from the wife’s account was the amount deposited by a
rentee of his father, one Mr.Keller.
10. Firstly, we shall consider the claim for return of 101
sovereigns of gold ornaments. It is the claim of the wife that at
the time of marriage, she was wearing 101 sovereigns of gold
ornaments, out of which 80 were sold by the husband and his
family for their own gain. She relied on Exts.A9, A10 and A13
purchase bills to prove purchase and sale of gold ornaments.
According to the wife, her father was working as Additional
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..12..
Commissioner
of
Income
Tax
and
her
mother
was
a
Central
Government employee and they were wealthy enough to give her 101
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments.
While
examined,
the
wife/PW1
deposed that the gold ornaments were purchased through three
sources; (1) withdrawal of amounts from various banks, (2) sale
of house at Ahmedabad and furniture therein, and (3) sale of
rubber trees standing in the property of her father. It was also
testified by the wife/PW1 as well as her father/PW2 that her
elder sister was married giving 101 sovereigns of gold ornaments
and also an amount of ₹15,00,000/-. The learned counsel for the
wife relied on a catena of decisions namely, Rajesh P.P. &
Another v. Deepthi P.R. [2021 (4) KHC 242], Pankajakshan Nair v.
Shylaja & another [2017 (1) KHC 620], Syamini S. Nair & others v.
Sreekanth R. [2022 (3) KHC 145] and Binitha v. Hareendran [2023
KHC 99], Jubairiya M.K. v. Abusalih & Another [2013 (2) KHC 304],
Bexy Michael v. A.J.Michael [2010 (4) KHC 376], Ajitha Kumari &
Another v. K.D.Jayasekharan [2016 (5) KHC 664], Syamini S. Nair &
Others v. Sreekanth R. [2022 (3) KHC 145], in support of his
contention that, when the bride comes to the matrimonial home
after marriage, there is possibility of ornaments being entrusted
to the elders and it is for the husband to prove that it was
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..13..
taken back by the bride when she left the matrimonial home. The
husband, on the other hand, contended that since they were having
a love affair, no money or gold was demanded and the family of
the husband had purchased gold ornaments for the wife.
11. A perusal of Exts.A9 and A10 gold purchase estimate
reveals purchase of 80 sovereigns of gold ornaments. Further,
Ext.A13 documents reveal that 40 sovereigns of gold ornaments
were sold in 2007. It is the case of the wife that 80 sovereigns
of gold ornaments belonging to the wife were sold and the husband
went for higher studies utilising the said amount. It is admitted
that the husband went for higher studies at the Raga’s Dental
College, Chennai, on 23.01.2007. Ext.B53 document also reveals
that the locker was operated on 22.01.2007, which substantiates
the case of the wife. The husband contended that his mother had
been operating the locker since 2002 and the operation of the
locker on 22.01.2007 was not for taking the wife’s gold ornaments
or for selling the same. The husband relied on the judgment of
this Court in Abubakkker Labba & Another v. Shameena K.B. and
Another [2018 (3) KHC 219) and argued that unless there is
sufficient evidence from the wife to prove entrustment of gold
ornaments with parents of the husband after marriage, they cannot
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..14..
be held liable to return the same. The wife relied on Ext.13
series to prove the sale of 40 sovereigns of gold ornaments,
which reveals sale of only 40 sovereigns. Other than the oral
evidence adduced and the contentions raised, there is no evidence
to prove the sale of remaining 40 sovereigns of gold ornaments.
However, as regards the claim for sale of 40 sovereigns of gold
ornaments belonging to the wife, we are convinced that the oral
evidence and the documents produced by the wife prove beyond
doubt that her gold ornaments were sold to utilize for the higher
studies of the husband. As regards the claim of the remaining 40
sovereigns of gold ornaments alleged to have been appropriated by
the husband, we are of the view that satisfactory evidence has
not been adduced by the wife.
12. The value of gold ornaments in the year 2007 was around
₹8,000/-. It is the specific case of the wife that an amount of
₹3,20,000/- was given to the husband on 23.01.2007 for his higher
studies in the afore college. PW2 has also deposed that the
amount for purchasing gold was arranged by selling his house and
furniture at Ahmedabad, by selling rubber trees standing in his
property and also by withdrawal of amounts from various banks.
However, a perusal of Exts.A28 and A30 reveals sale of the house
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..15..
at Ahmedabad and the agreement for selling the furniture therein
was on 18.03.200. As per Ext.A30 sale agreement, PW2 received an
amount of ₹2,00,000/-. Exts.A32, A34 & A36 statements of accounts
also reveal that the amounts were withdrawn from the accounts
maintained by the parents of the wife. Moreover, Ext.A8 marriage
photos show that a substantial quantity of gold ornaments were
worn by the wife. As regards the family status of the wife, the
depositions of the wife/PW1 as well as her father/PW2 cannot be
disbelieved that they were not financially stable to give 101
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments.
In
Rajesh
P.P.
(supra)
and
Pankajakshan Nair (supra), this Court held that once it is proved
that gold ornaments were entrusted to the husband, the burden is
on the husband to prove as to how the same was dealt with and
also that, if it is his case that it was taken by the wife when
she left the matrimonial home, the burden is on him to prove the
same. In the case on hand, no evidence has been adduced by the
husband
other
than
his
own
oral
testimony
to
disprove
the
contentions of the wife. Hence, in the absence of such evidence,
the husband is accountable for the quantity of gold ornaments
misused by him. During cross-examination the wife has testified
that she was in possession of 20 sovereigns of gold ornaments
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..16..
when she left the matrimonial home. Therefore, on an appreciation
of the oral evidence as well as the documents on board, we find
that out of 80 sovereigns of gold ornaments, 40 sovereigns were
utilized by the husband for his own needs. On the basis of the
foregoing discussion and on an appreciation of the materials, we
are unable to agree with the finding of the Family Court. Hence,
we hold that the wife is entitled for return of 40 sovereigns of
gold ornaments.
13.
As
regards
the
claim
of
entrustment
of
a
sum
of
₹20,00,000/-, it is the case of the wife that the amount was paid
in four instalments, even before the betrothal. The engagement
was in September, 2023, and the betrothal was on 07.02.2004.
According to the wife, an amount of ₹7,00,000/- was paid on
24.12.2003; ₹6,00,000/- on 18.01.2004; ₹4,50,000/- on 23.01.2004;
and ₹2,50,000/- on 07.02.2004, totalling to ₹20,00,000/-. On a
perusal of Exts.A5, A5(a), A6 and A7, it is seen that a total
amount of ₹15,00,000/- was deposited in the name of the wife,
husband,
father-in-law
and
in
the
name
of
four
persons
on
25.03.2004 and 29.03.2004. According to the wife, these deposits
were made immediately after the marriage.
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..17..
14. The husband denied the afore allegations and relied on
Exts.B68 series to show that they were well off and they had
several deposits even prior to the marriage. Exts.A5 & A5(a)
passbook, Ext.A6 cash receipt and Ext.A7 bank statement reveal
that the deposits were made after the marriage; and there is no
evidence forthcoming to prove the source otherwise by the husband
regarding the deposits made in the name of the wife, husband and
his
family
Commissioner
members.
of
The
Income
wife’s
Tax
and
father
her
was
the
Additional
mother
was
a
central
government employee. Their elder daughter got married in 2002 by
giving ₹15,00,000/- and 101 sovereigns of gold ornaments. It is
the case of the husband that after the marriage of the elder
daughter, the wife’s family was not financially sound to give
₹20,00,000/- and 101 sovereigns of gold ornaments to the second
daughter/wife. It is also contended by the husband that they had
a car loan of ₹2,00,000/- and a housing loan of ₹8,50,000/-,
however, that cannot be taken as a reason for finding that the
wife’s family was not financially well off. PW1/wife has deposed
that her parents had arranged the funds for giving ₹20,00,000/and
for
purchasing
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments
by
withdrawals from various banks, by sale of a house and furniture
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..18..
therein and also by sale of rubber trees standing in the property
of
PW2/wife’s
father.
PW2
also
deposed
in
tune
with
PW1,
testifying that he has arranged the fund by selling his house at
Ahmedabad and furniture therein and also by selling rubber trees
in his property and by withdrawals from various banks.
15. A perusal of Ext.A28 sale deed reveals that the house at
Ahmedabad was sold for ₹5,00,000/- on 18.03.2003, i.e., after the
marriage of the elder daughter. Ext.A30 agreement also reveals
that the furniture in the above house was sold for ₹2,00,000/-.
Exts.B38, B39 and B61 to B69 reveal that the husband and his
family deposited amounts in the name of the wife as well, even
long before the marriage. The husband contended that the deposits
in Exts.A5 to A7 are the amounts renewed from earlier deposits.
However, Ext.A6 cash receipt as well as Ext.A7 FD ledger extract
does not reflect that the deposits were renewal deposits. Hence,
the contention of the husband that the deposits made as per
Exts.A5 to A7 were renewal deposits, cannot be accepted. The
handing over of the afore amounts was proved through PW1, PW2 &
PW3 (wife’s mother). It is also relevant to note that as per
Ext.B68 series, fixed deposits totalling to ₹6,00,000/- were made
on 19.01.2004. It is the case of the wife that an amount of
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..19..
₹6,00,000/- was entrusted to the husband’s family on 18.01.2004.
It is discernible from Ext.B68 series that on the very next day,
deposits totalling to ₹6,00,000/- were made by the husband’s
family in different banks at Irinjalakuda. This justifies the
wife’s
case
that
the
amounts
were
deposited
utilizing
the
patrimony given by her father. The evidence adduced and the
documents produced substantiate the claim of the wife. Hence, we
are of the opinion that the Family Court was not correct in
finding that there was no evidence to prove that the husband and
his family had received ₹20,00,000/- prior to the marriage. The
said finding is set aside. We hold that the wife is entitled to
recover from the husband ₹20,00,000/- given as patrimony.
16. In addition to the wife's claim of ₹20,00,000/- given to
the husband at the time of marriage, she made a further claim of
₹19,23,065/-, allegedly given to the husband after marriage. It
is alleged that the said amount includes funds entrusted for
purchasing
a
car,
repayments
made
towards
the
car
loan,
capitation fee paid to the husband for higher studies, the
amounts entrusted to the husband during the period from 20072010, value of articles such as washing machine, mobile phone
etc. During cross-examination, the wife deposed that an amount of
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..20..
₹5,00,000/- was paid to the husband on 20.12.2006 to secure
admission for his higher studies, for which she relied on Ext.A44
sale deed dated 06.12.2006. According to her, an amount of
₹2,00,000/- was given by her father on 04.03.2004 for purchase of
the car; a total amount of ₹2,35,500/- was repaid by the wife
from her income in 60 instalments towards car loan; ₹5,00,000/was paid towards capitation fee for MDS admission of the husband;
a total sum of ₹6,00,000/- was transferred to the husband for his
expenses in Chennai during 2007-2010; ₹46,000/- was paid on
20.06.2008
and
₹1,50,000/-
was
paid
during
June,
2009,
and
₹25,000/- was paid in April, 2010, for car repair in Chennai.
Further, it is alleged that a washing machine worth ₹22,000/-,
household articles worth ₹50,000/-, a laptop worth ₹56,000/-, a
camera worth ₹15,000/- and a mobile phone worth ₹24,000/- were
given to the husband.
17. Regarding the claim of ₹2,00,000/- alleged to have been
given by the parents of the wife to purchase the car, and the
claim of ₹2,35,000/- alleged to have been made by the wife
towards repayment of car loan, no documentary evidence has been
adduced by the wife. A perusal of Exts.B24 and B25 reveals that
the car loan was availed by the husband from ICICI Bank and the
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..21..
amounts have been remitted in instalments by way of cheque as
reflected in Ext.B24. Ext.B25 is the statement of accounts, which
shows that multiple cheques were cleared towards the car loan.
Since the wife failed to substantiate the above claims, we are
inclined to disallow the same. Further, regarding the claim of
the wife regarding washing machine, laptop, camera and the amount
spent for repairing the car, purchase of movables and household
articles, no satisfactory evidence has been adduced. Hence, we
are not inclined to allow the said claim.
18. As regards the claim for ₹5,00,000/- allegedly paid for
higher studies of the husband, the wife relied on Ext.A13 series
vouchers evidencing sale of gold ornaments. Since we have already
found that the wife is entitled for return of 40 sovereigns of
gold ornaments from the husband, we are not inclined to allow the
claim for return of ₹5,00,000/- alleged to have been spent
towards the husband’s higher studies. To prove the claim of
₹6,00,000/-
also,
the
wife
failed
to
adduce
any
supporting
evidence.
19. As regards the claim of the wife regarding the amount of
₹1,50,000/- paid to the husband by PW4, who is her father’s
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..22..
brother, the husband admits receipt of ₹1,50,000/-. If at all
there is any claim for ₹1,50,000/-, it ought to have been raised
by PW4 from the husband. The said payment was in 2008, i.e.,
after four years of marriage. As regards the claim of ₹6,00,000/alleged to have been spent by the wife for the husband's expenses
in Chennai, the husband contended that a rentee of his father,
one Mr.Keller, was depositing the rent in the account of the wife
and that amount was transferred by the wife to the husband on
several occasions, which is evidenced by Ext.A14. Relying on the
judgment in Royson Mathew v. Minimol K. & Others [2020 (3) KHC
307], the husband argued that there may be several transactions
between spouses during the time when marriage was subsisting and
such amount cannot be sought to be recovered by either of them,
unless there are sufficient pleadings and evidence to show that
such entrustment was not gratuitous or was under threat, coercion
etc. There has to be pleadings and evidence to suggest that
entrustment was for a specific purpose or under trust, to make
out a case to recover the amount. Here, the wife failed to adduce
any evidence to show that such payments, if at all made, were
from her own savings or made under threat, coercion etc. and
hence, we are not inclined to allow the said claim as well.
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..23..
Mat. Appeal No.492 of 2016
20. In Mat. Appeal No. 492 of 2016, the husband challenges
the dismissal of his counter claim in OP No.413 of 2013 to
recover the value of articles worth ₹13,90,000/-. As regards the
counter claim for ₹13,90,000/- put forward by the husband, it
includes the value of ornaments and articles alleged to have been
taken by the wife from the house of the husband. The husband
alleged that while leaving the matrimonial home, the wife took
away various ornaments and articles. The details of the counter
claim for ₹13,90,000/- are as follows:
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
Various gold ornaments such as chains,
necklaces, bangles, rings etc. of the
respondents weighing about 75 sovereigns
Diamond necklace with pendant
A pair of diamond earrings
Expensive sarees
Cash lost from almirah
Compensation for taking away the lock and
key
Total
₹11,25,000/₹72,000/₹29,000/₹78,000/₹76,000/₹10,000/₹13,90,000/-
21. Though such claims are raised, no evidence other than
his own oral evidence as DW1 has been adduced by the husband to
prove that all those items were taken by the wife when she left
the matrimonial home. Hence, we are of the opinion that the
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..24..
Family Court was right in dismissing the counter claim put
forward by the husband; and therefore, we decline interference.
Mat. Appeal No. 368 of 2016
22. When the appeals were taken up for hearing, the learned
counsel on either side submitted that both the husband and the
wife have remarried. Further, the learned counsel for the husband
submitted that the relief sought for in Mat. Appeal No. 368 of
2016 has become infructuous since the minor child, viz., Neil
Yakob Kocherie, born on 28.03.2005 in their wedlock, has attained
majority, and hence, Mat. Appeal No.368 of 2016 can be dismissed
as infructuous.
Accordingly, the appeals are disposed of, as follows:
a) Mat.Appeal No.262 of 2016 is partly allowed. The husband is
directed
to
return
to
the
wife
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments or its present market value and an amount of
₹20,00,000/- within one month from today, in default of
which, the wife will be entitled to realize the same with
interest @6% per annum from the date of filing of original
petition till realisation, from the husband personally and
Mat.Appeal No.262/2016, 368/2016& 492/2016
2025:KER:27787
..25..
from his assets, both movable and immovable. The decree and
judgment of the Family Court are modified to the above
extent. No costs.
b)Mat. Appeal No. 492 of 2016 is dismissed. No costs.
c)Mat. Appeal No. 368 of 2016 is dismissed as infructuous. No
costs.
SD/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
SD/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
bka/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review