Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.476/2023
Pravin Vasanji Maru, Resident of 66
Mr.
of
Son
(39),
Maru
Pravin
Viral
Dr.
1603, CharniRoad East, P.O.
Fanaswadi,LeelataraBuilding 16h floor. flat No.
Mumbai GPO fort, P.S.-LT Marg, Mumbai, PIN-400002.
.Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
Secretary/Directorof Health and
1. The State of Tripura, Represented by
SecretariatComplex, P.0.
Family Welfare Department having its office New
Secretariat,Agartala, West Tripura, PIN- 799010.
Having its office
2. The Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department,
Tripura, PIN
West
New Secretariat Complex, P.O.-Secretariat, Agartala,
799010.
3. The Director, Health and Family Welfare Department, Having his office at
Health Directorate Building, 2nd Floor, Pandit J.N. Complex, Agartala, PIN
799006.
4. Agartala Government Dental College and IGM Hospital, represented by the
Dean/Principal,having his office at Agartala Government Dental College and
IGM Hospital,IGM Chowmuhani,Akhaura Road, Agartala-799001.
5. The Dean/Principal, Agartala Government Dental College and 1GM
Hospital,IGM Chowmuhani,Akhaura Road, Agartala-799001.
6. Tripura Public Service Commission,Representedby the Chairman, Tripura
Public Service Commission,having his office at Near OldSecretariatComplex,
Akhaura Road, Agartala,Tripura, Pin-799001.
7. The Chairman,Tripura Public Service Commission,having his office at Near
OldSecretariat Complex,Akhaura Road, Agartala,Tripura, Pin-799001.
8. The Member(s), Tripura Public Service Commission, having his office at
Near Old SecretariatComplex, Akhaura Road, Agartala,Tripura, Pin-799001.
9.The Secretary,Tripura Public Service Commission,having his office at Near
OldSecretariat Complex,Akhaura Road, Agartala,Tripura,
Pin-799001.
10. The Under Secretary,Tripura Public Service Commission,having his
office
at Near Old Secretariat Complex, Akhaura Road,
Agartala, Tripura, Pin
799001.
..Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Sankar
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Debalay
G.A.,
Mr. Raju Datta,
Advocate.
Lodh,
Mr. D.Debnath, Advocate,
Advocate.
Bhattacharya,
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 18th August, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner,Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya,learned GovernmentAdvocate appearing
for the State respondentsand Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearingfor the
respondents-TripuraPublic Service Commission.
2.
Petitioner submitted Online application on 18.06.2023 under
advertisementNo.05/2023 dated 30.05.2023 (Annexure-1 to the writ petition)
issued by the Tripura Public Service Commission, Agartala (hereinafter
referred to as TPSC), i.e. before the cutoff date and time, i.e. 5.30 p.m. on
19.06.2023 for the post of Assistant Professor in Paediatric & Preventive
Dentistryin AgartalaGovernmentDental College and IGM Hospital, Agartala.
He also sent the hard copies of the applicationand other relevantdocumentson
19.06.2023 through Inland Speed Post. As per the advertisement(Annexure-1)
at paragraph-2the following documents were supposed to be submitted in hard
copies along with the applicationin hard copy by 23.06.2023:
nCandidatesare required to submit self attestedcopy of certificatesin support
of their claims regarding Age, Educational
Qualifications Madhyamik
onwards (all mark sheets and certificates),Attempt Certificate of
BDS, PG
(MDS/DNB), Registration Certificate from the appropriate authority,
Permanent
Resident
Certificate/Citizenship Certificate, Scheduled
Castes/Scheduled Tribes, Experience Certificates, API score (as per
Schedule-VI)and others, if any."
Annexure-3 at page-39 of the writ petition is the Tracking report
of Speed Post which shows that the item reached Agartala Head Post
Office on
20.06.2023 but it was delivered only on 28.06.2023, i.e. after the cutoff date of
23.06.2023 for submission of hard copies. Meanwhile,before the expiry of the
cutoff date for submission of hard copies of the application along with the
prescribedmandatory documents, i.e. 23.06.2023 the respondents-TPSCissued
a notification bearing No.F.11(26-41)-Rectt./TPSC/2023on 21.06.2023
(Annexure-4)which allowed submission of attempt certificateand up-to-date
registrationcertificate by the candidates till 30.06.2023 by 5.30 p.m., failing
which the Scrutiny Committee would take a decision ex parte. Since the
application in hard copy and documents submitted by the petitioner through
Speed Post reached on 28.06.2023,petitionerwas treated as ineligibleand his
applicationwas not subjectedto serutiny.Therefore,petitionerapproachedthis
Court in the present writ petition.
3.
Petitioner apprehended that the extension of time for submiting
only two documents, i.e. attempt certificate and up-to-date registration
certificateapart from other certificateswhich were required to be submitted in
hard copy as per paragraph-2 of the advertisement was done to favour few
selected persons only.Petitioner'scontention is that the TPSC even before the
expiry of the cutoff date, i.e. 23.06.2023 for submitting
hard copy undertook scrutiny of the
2106.2023, i.e. 2(two) days betore the
corrigendumto favour few persons.
application through
applications received by it and on
expiry of the cutoffdate chose to issue a
Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel
for the petitioner, has also
submitted by candidates
contendedthat if the hard copy of the applications
other documents, there was
after 21.06.2023 suffered from shortfall of certain
no reason why the TPSC extended time on
21.06.2023 for submitting hard
copies of only two documents, i.e. attempt certificate
and up-to-date
registration certificate by 30.06.2023. Learned counsel for the petitioner,
therefore, submits that the TPSC has not adhered to uniform and transparent
yardstick in entertainingand scrutinizingapplicationsof eligible persons. The
delay on thepart of the Postal Department is not attributableto the petitioner
since his applicationhad reached the Agartala Office of the Postal Department
on 20.06.2023 itselfand took 8(eight) days' time for being finally delivered in
the Office of the TPsC, i.e. beyond the cutoff date of 23.06.2023. Learned
counsel for the petitioner,therefore, submits that the recruitmentexercise has
sufferedfrom lack of transparencyand applicationof fair standardand uniform
yardsticksin respectof allthe candidates.Therefore,the impugnedrecruitment
exercise is to be interfered and the respondents-TPSCshould be directed to
entertain the applicationof the petitionerand other similarly situated persons
for giving them a fair opportunityto compete.
5.
When the matter was taken up on the first date, i.e. 01.08.2023,
the respondents were asked to file counter affidavit. Respondents No.6 to 10
being the TPSC and its officialshave filed a counter affidavit.Mr.
Raju Datta,
learned counsel for the respondents-TPSC,has drawn the attention of this
Cout to the averments made in the counter
affidavit and in particular.
paragraphs-4,5 & 6. It is submitted that the two documents, i.e. the attempt
are those documents which are
certificateand up-to-dateregistrationcertificate
is no bar on the Commissionto
necessary for computationof API score. There
and documents submitted in hard copy
undertake scrutiny of the applications
before the cutoff date, i.e. 23.06.2023. The
advertisementrelates to filling up
including the one in which the
18(eighteen) posts in 9(nine) disciplines
documents reveals that some of the
petitioneris interested.The scrutiny of the
candidates did not furnish these two
documents. This extension of time was
granted to candidates whose applicationin
hard copy with documents reached
covering all disciplinesand 18
the Commission bythe cutoffdate 23.06.2023
copy with documents have been
posts.No candidatewhose applicationin hard
received by 23.06.2023 has approached this
Court with a grievance that their
despite all mandatory
applications have not been subjected to scrutiny
pointed out that about 62 such
documents supplied in hard copy. It is also
applications in hard copies were received after
the cutoff date. These
applicants were
applicationswere, therefore, not subjected to scrutiny as such
petitionerthat candidates from
held to be ineligible.The apprehensionof the
outside States have been ousted to favour candidates
appearing from the State
of Tripura is also unfounded since about 66 applicants
from various States
including Jammu & Kashmir and Karnataka had been able
to submit their
been
applicationswithin the cutoffdate of 2.3.06.2023.Their applicationshave
serutinized and many of them who were found eligible were also called for
interview.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondents-TPSC has drawn the
attention of this Court to the decisions of the Apex Court renderedin the case
Indiareported in
of Tata Cellularvrs. Union of
Ors. Vrs.
case of Tajvir Singh Sodhi &
(1994) 6SCC 651 and in the
State of Jammu & Kashmir &
344 which have been
reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC
the Bench
decision of this Court rendered by
Ors.
relied upon in a recent
presided over by Hon'ble the
the case of Dr. Sandeep Roy
in
Singh)
Kr.
Aparesh
(Justice
Chief Justice
Comnmission& others [WP(C) No.966 of
Service
Public
Tripura
vrs.
Sarkar
2022]. He has, in particular,relied upon
the reasoning and observationsof
the
that the
thesaid judgment.It is submitted
of
and
paragraphs-11,
Court in
in the decisions of the expert
Apex Court has cautioned interference
recruitmentbodies in judicial review by the
unless
the Apex Court has clearlyheld that
is patently arbitrary and suffers from
made. He, therefore, submits that the
High Courts. It is submitted that
the decision of the recruitmentbody
mala fide, no interference should be
petitioner has not been able to establish
any case of arbitrariness or mala fide
against the TPSC in the recruitment
exercise conducted for filling up various posts in
9(nine) disciplines in the
Medical Colleges of the State. As such, the writ petition
based on imaginary
apprehension and without any enforceable legal right is fit
since no case of arbitrariness or mala fides has
to be dismissed
been established by the
petitioner.
7.
Ihave considered the submissions of learned
parties at length and gone through the pleadings and the
from record.The narration of facts and events
counsel for the
documents placed
have been dealt with in the
hereunder,as they are not in
foregoingparagraphswhich are not being repeated
Annexure-1,the TPSC
dispute. Under the advertisementdated 30.05.2023 at
has undertakenan exerciseto fill up 18posts of
AssistantProfessorin Agartala
Government Dental College & IGM Hospital. Agartala under
the Health &
advertisement
Family Welfare Department., Government of Tripura. The
paragraph-2 quoted
required the applicants to submit the documents as at
hereinabove in hard copies by 23.06.2023 (5.30 p.m.)
along with the printed
candidature shall be treated as
copy of Online application, failing which the
applicationthereafter.It
cancelledand the Commissionwould not entertainany
is not in dispute that though the petitioner
had made Online application on
18.06.2023,the hard copy of the applicationalong with the
reach the Office of the Commission by the
documents did not
deadline, i.e. 5.30 p.m. on
report
23.06.2023.It has been pointed out from the Tracking
Annexure-3, page-39 of the writ petition that though
Agartala Office of the Postal Departmentbut the
of Speed Post at
the item had reached the
same was delivered only on
28.06.2023,i.e. after the cutoff date.
It is not the case of the petitionerthat applicationsin
with documents received after the cutoff
date of 23.06.2023 have been
allowed
entertainedby the TPSC and candidateshave been
recruitment exercise. Petitioner's grievance hinges
Corrigendum/ Notification dated 21.06.2023, by
extended the time limit for furnishing two
hard copy
to participatein the
upon Annexure-4,
which the Commission
documents, i.e. attempt certificate
certificate which were found to be in
and up-to-date registration
shortfall in
30.06.2023 (5.30 p.m.)in hard copies.
some of the applicationsreceived by
through the counter affidavitsought to
The Commissionhas in their averments
justify the extension of time limit to
submit these two documentsonly as they
were necessary for computation of the
API score and as such, mandatory in
respondents-TPSCthat the process of scrutiny of
the
of
stand
the
is
nature. lt
cutoff date, i.e. 23.06.2023 is not
documents received in hardcopy before the
legally impermissible. This plea of the
respondents-TPSCappears to have
has to
sound basis as the recruiting body
documents and applications received in
undertake scrutiny of several
respect of any such recruitment
process.
exercise in order to expedite the recruitment
9.
his
candidate who had submitted
no
that
evident
It is also
application in hard copy by the cutoff
date of 23.06.2023 has come
has not been
with agrievance that his application
ineligible or that the benefit of extension of
entertained and treated
time till 30.06.2023 has not been
granted to them. It appears from the stand of
66 such candidates from far-off States
forward
the respondents-TPSCthat about
like Jammu & Kashmir and Karnataka
also had submittedtheir applicationsin hard copy with
documentsby the cutoff
date of 23.06.2023 and they have been subjected to scrutiny
and have been
called to interviewon being found eligible.
10.
It is also evident from the counter affidavit of the respondentsthat
it is not only the petitioner whose application in hard copy along with
documents reached after the cutoff date of 23.06.2023 but there were 62 such
applicants whose applicationsreached after the cutoff date 23.06.2023 and all
of them were treated as ineligible. As such, on the one hand, the
Commission
cannot be faulted for treating applications received after 23.06.2023 as
ineligible as no extension of time for submitting of hard copies of application
with documents beyond 23.06.2023 was granted nor any application received
in hard copy after 23.06.2023 were entertainedby the Commissionfor scrutiny
and interview. Therefore,on the first plank, since the petitioner'sapplication
had reached on 28.06.2023, the decision of the recruiting body to treat that
applicationas ineligible cannot be found fault with. It, therefore, also appeals
to the Court that extension of time on 21.06.2023 for submitting two
the
certificates which were mandatory for computation of API score to all
recruitment
candidatescovering 9 disciplinesand 18 posts in total in the said
exercise was not actuated by malice to favour few persons.
not been able to show that any individual
Petitioner has also
candidate has been favoured
selectively on account of extension of time for submission
of these two
documents in hard copy by 30.06.2023.
11.
The judgments of the Apex Court on the issue of interference in
judicial review in the decision of recruitmentbody are by now well settled. In
the case of Tajvir Singh Sodhi (supra) the Apex Court has at paragraphs-64to
69 laid down the broad parameters under which the Writ Court should not
interfere. Only on the grounds of mala fide or palpable arbitrariness,
interferencecan be made in such exercise. The wisdom of the recruiting body
to fix a cutoff date cannot be questioned unless they are suffering from
arbitrarinessor are intended to favour few selected persons. The petitionerhas
not been able to make out a case of any such mala fide or ex facie arbitrariness
in the decision of the recruiting body to adhere to the cutoff dates i.e.
23.06.2023 for submission of hard copies of applicationswith documents and
30.06.2023 i.e. the extension of time or submission of two mandatory
documernts, i.e. attempt certificateand up-to-date registration certificate by the
applicantswhich are necessary for computationof API score.
reasons
As such, on acomprehensiveanalysis of the facts, the
12.
recorded and the legal position settled in this regard by the Apex
Court does not find any merit in the writ petition.
Court, this
Accordingly,it is dismissed.
Pending application(s),if any, also stands disposed
of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
Date: 2023.08.23
PULAK BANIK 17:16:42 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review