The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. In case of recruitment by promotion/ deputation/ transfer made from which promotion/ deputation / transfer to be made ii. Ph. D or Post Graduate Degree in Engineering. 7(seven) years relevant experience in the post of Senior Scientific Officer (R&D) / Senior Scientific Officer (Tech Promotion) in the pay scale Rs.13575- 37000/- (Pay Band – 4, Gr. Pay - 4800), failing which 14 years experience in the pay band scale of Rs. 13757 - 37000/- (Pay Band – 4, Gr. Pay - 4500), failing which 16 years experience in the post of Scientist/ Engineer-B/ Project Officer/ Research Officer (Science)/ Research Officer (Engg) in the pay band scale Rs. 13575 37000/- (Pay Band – 4, Gr. Pay 3700). [10] A close scrutiny of the different schedules prescribed under the recruitment rules for both the posts, as noted above, would leave no room of doubt that these are singular posts. The impression is further strengthened by looking to the educational and other qualifications laid down for both the posts which are not same and similar. In that way application of Rule 10 of the Reservation Rules, 1992 for grouping of these isolated individual posts could also not arise as Rule 10 prescribes that isolated individual posts and small cadres of same class/ group of service having less than four posts shall be grouped together for the purposes of reservation provided that they have the same status, salary and th…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.740 of 2023
Dr. Sujit Das
…………………… Petitioner(s).
Versus
The Tripura State Council for Science & Technology and others
…………………… Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. C.S. Sinha, Advocate,
Mr. D.C. Saha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, G.A.,
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
16/02/2024
Heard Mr. C.S. Sinha, learned counsel together with Mr. D.C.
Saha, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Kohinoor N.
Bhattacharyya, learned Government Advocate and Mr. Ratan Datta, learned
counsel for the respondents.
[2]
The petitioner has approached this Court for consideration of his
case for promotion to the post of Principal Scientific Officer from the post of
Scientist/ Engineer-B by application of the replacement roster policy in terms
of the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991
in particular the schedule under Sections 4 & 5 with the relevant notes
appended thereto.
[3]
Mr. C.S. Sinha, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner is a Scheduled Caste (SC) candidate who joined in Tripura State
Council for Science and Technology (TSCST)/respondent No.1 as Scientist/
Engineer-B and still holds the same post without promotion. He has relied upon
the Annual Report on man in position and vacancy position in services and
posts in the TSCST as contained in the letter dated 4th May, 2023 addressed to
the Director, Directorate for Welfare of Scheduled Castes, Government of
Tripura by the Head of Office & DDO, TSCST, Government of Tripura
(Annexure-2). He has specifically referred to column -3 of the tabular chart at
page-13, which according to him indicates that in Group-A there are 2(two)
posts
of Principal Scientific Officer which comprise [Principal Scientific
Officer (Science &Technology)-1 post and Principal Scientific Officer (Space
Applications)-1 post].
[4]
Mr. Sinha has also referred to the memorandum dated 13th
October, 2023 issued by the member, DPC, Joint Member Secretary, TSCST,
Director DSTE, Tripura State Council for Science & Technology, Government
of Tripura which is a intimation of the meeting of the Departmental Promotion
Committee(DPC) to be held on 31/10/2023 for filing up of 1(one) vacant post
of Principal Scientific Officer in Tripura State Council for Science and
Technology under the department of Science, Technology and Environment,
Government of Tripura, Agartala. He has also referred to subsequent
memorandum dated 30th October, 2023 which has rescheduled the DPC
meeting on 08.11.2023. Annexues-9 & 10, part of the writ petition are
schedules of recruitment rules for the post of Principal Scientific Officer
(Space Applications), Tripura State Council for Science & Technology and
Principal Scientific Officer (Science & Technology), Tripura State Council for
Science & Technology.
[5]
Mr. Sinha has further referred to the representation of the
petitioner addressed to the Scientist/ Engineer-B, TSAC, TSCST. He submits
that as per the said communication his seniority is at 7th position and no vacant
post exists under SC category against the post of Principal Scientific Officer.
He has also refereed to Rule 10 of the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Tribes Reservation Rules, 1992 which relates to grouping of isolated posts.
According to the learned counsel for the petitioner even if the contentions of
the respondents that there are 2(two) posts of Principal Scientific Officer both
having different nomenclature, the two isolated individual posts are to be
grouped for application of the replacement roster policy which applies to a
cadre which has less than 4(four) number of posts.
[6]
Learned counsel for the petitioner has summarized the submission
to the effect that the present stand of the respondents that the posts of Principal
Scientific Officer (Science & Technology) and Principal Scientific Officer
(Space Applications) are two separate posts not forming one cadre in which no
reservation can be applied on the principles of being a single post is not correct.
Both the posts are Principal Scientific Officer. The man in position and
vacancy position indicated in the correspondence dated 4 th May, 2023 do leave
no room of doubt that these posts are forming part of one cadre where the
replacement roster policy should apply in line with the provisions of the
Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991 and the
Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Rules, 1992.
Therefore, the respondent may be directed to consider the case of the petitioner
as the posts falling vacant would accrue to a SC candidate now.
[7]
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned Government Advocate
for the State and Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel for the respondentcorporation both have relied upon the counter affidavit filed by the respondent
No.1. It is their case that the petitioner, the then Liaison Officer of TSCST for
roster verification failed to communicate the authority for roster verification,
the correct factual status of the posts of Principal Scientific Officer (Science
and Technology) and Principal Scientific Officer (Space Applications) by
virtue of its recruitment rules and nature of job, causing a mistaken roster
verification report dated 15.02.2021. That Principal Scientific Officer (Science
and Technology) and Principal Scientific Officer (Space Applications) were
created as Unreserved posts since inception and both have different recruitment
rules and different natures of job. They cannot be clubbed together as a single
post. This has been intimated to the office of the Director, Department of Tribal
Welfare and the Director, Department of Welfare of SCs for roster verification.
As such the contention of the petitioner on the basis of incorrect roster
verification report is not tenable in law or on facts.
[8]
Learned counsel for the respondents have referred to the schedule
of the recruitment rules which prescribes the number of posts i.e. one for both
the class of posts Principal Scientific Officer (Science and Technology) and
Principal Scientific Officer (Space Applications). They have also referred to
the essential educational qualifications which are prescribed in the schedule to
buttress their submission that these two posts do not form the same cadre.
Being single post, no replacement roster policy can be applied. Therefore they
have prayed for rejection of the prayer of the writ petitioner.
[9]
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant documents and the pleadings placed from
record. From the conspectus of facts borne from record and referred to
hereinabove, it appears that the issue at hand is whether the post of Principal
Scientific Officer comprises two posts and forms one cadre where roster
replacement policy under the Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes
Reservation Act, 1991 and Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes Reservation
Rules, 1992 would apply. The correspondences relied upon by the learned
counsel for the petitioner do give scope for confusion as to whether both the
posts form part of the same cadre as the broader nomenclature Principal
Scientific Officer creates such an impression. However, if the schedule to the
recruitment rules annexed by the petitioner at Annexure- 9 & 10 are carefully
examined, it would leave no room for doubt that these two posts are separate
and do not form part of the same cadre. For proper appreciation, the relevant
part of the schedule relating to recruitment rules for the post of Principal
Scientific Officer (Space Applications) (Annexure-9) and Principal Scientific
Officer (Science and Technology) (Annexure-10) are being extracted
hereunder:
i) Annexure-9:
“SCHEDULE
RECRUITMENT RULES FOR THE POST OF PRINCIPAL SCIENTIFIC OFFICER
(SPACE APPLICATIONS), TRIPURA SATE COUNCIL FOR SCIENCE &
TECHNOLOGY
1.
Name of the Post
Principal Scientific Officer (Space
Applications)
2.
No. of Post
1(One) No. post plus additional
posts as and when created
3.
Classification
Equivalent to Group “A”
5.
Method of recruitment Promotion, failing which by
whether
by
direct deputation failing which by direct
recruitment or by promotion recruitment
or by deputation / transfer
and percentage of the
vacancies to be filled by
various methods.
Education
and
other A.
Essential: 1st Class Master
qualifications required for Degree in Pure Science, Geoscience,
direct recruits
Environmental Science, having
honours in Graduation or 1st Class
Bachelor Degree in Engineering and
15 yrs experience in Science/
Technology/ Environment/ Space
Applications related works in Govt./
Semi-Govt.
or
Autonomous
Organisation/
Recognised
Laboratory/ Research Institute/
University/ College out of which 5
years not below the pay band scale
of ₹ 13575- ₹ 37000/- (Pay Band –
4, Gr. Pay- 4800)
B. Desirable : i. Experience in
implementation of National and
State Projects on Remote Sensing,
GIS & Geo-ICT Applications.
ii. Ph. D or Post Graduate Degree in
Geoinformatics.
11.
In case of recruitment by 7(seven) years relevant experience
promotion/
deputation/
transfer made from which
promotion/ deputation /
transfer to be made
in the post of Senior Scientific
Officer or equivalent post in the pay
scale ₹13575- ₹ 37000/- (Pay Band
– 4, Gr. Pay - ₹4800), failing which
14 years relevant experience in the
pay scale of ₹13757 - ₹ 37000/- (Pay
Band – 4, Gr. Pay - ₹ 4500), failing
which 16 years relevant experience
in the post of Scientist/ Engineer-B/
Research Officer (Engineering) in
the pay scale ₹ 13575 - ₹ 37000/(Pay Band – 4, Gr. Pay - ₹3700).
Note: Relevant experience would be
Space Applications or related fields.
ii) Annexure-10:
“SCHEDULE
RECRUITMENT RULES FOR THE POST OF PRINCIPAL SCIENTIFIC OFFICER
(SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY), TRIPURA SATE COUNCIL FOR SCIENCE &
TECHNOLOGY
1.
Name of the Post
Principal Scientific Officer (Science
& Technology)
2.
No. of Post
1(One) No. post plus additional
posts as and when created
3.
Classification
Equivalent to Group “A”
5.
Method of recruitment Promotion, failing which by
whether
by
direct deputation failing which by direct
recruitment or by promotion recruitment
or by deputation / transfer
and percentage of the
vacancies to be filled by
various methods.
Education
and
other A.
Essential: 1st Class Master
qualifications required for Degree in Science having having
direct recruits
honours in Graduation or 1st Class
Bachelor Degree in Engineering and
15 yrs experience in Science/
Technology/ Environment/ Space
Applications related works in Govt./
Semi-Govt.
or
Autonomous
Organisation/
Recognised
Laboratory/ Research Institute/
University/ College out of which 5
years not below the pay band scale
of Rs.13575-37000/- (Pay Band – 4,
Gr. Pay- 4800)
B. Desirable : i. Experience in
Societal
Applications
of
Technologies/
Science
Communication or Popularisation/
Remote
Sensing
&
GIS
Applications/
Promotion
of
Biotechnologies/
Promotion
of
environment friendly technologies.
11.
In case of recruitment by
promotion/
deputation/
transfer made from which
promotion/ deputation /
transfer to be made
ii. Ph. D or Post Graduate Degree in
Engineering.
7(seven) years relevant experience
in the post of Senior Scientific
Officer (R&D) / Senior Scientific
Officer (Tech Promotion) in the pay
scale Rs.13575- 37000/- (Pay Band
– 4, Gr. Pay - 4800), failing which
14 years experience in the pay band
scale of Rs. 13757 - 37000/- (Pay
Band – 4, Gr. Pay - 4500), failing
which 16 years experience in the
post of Scientist/ Engineer-B/
Project Officer/ Research Officer
(Science)/ Research Officer (Engg)
in the pay band scale Rs. 13575 37000/- (Pay Band – 4, Gr. Pay 3700).
[10]
A close scrutiny of the different schedules prescribed under the
recruitment rules for both the posts, as noted above, would leave no room of
doubt that these are singular posts. The impression is further strengthened by
looking to the educational and other qualifications laid down for both the posts
which are not same and similar. In that way application of Rule 10 of the
Reservation Rules, 1992 for grouping of these isolated individual posts could
also not arise as Rule 10 prescribes that isolated individual posts and small
cadres of same class/ group of service having less than four posts shall be
grouped together for the purposes of reservation provided that they have the
same status, salary and the same minimum qualifications prescribed for direct
recruitment. Evidently the minimum qualifications for direct recruitment of
these two posts vary.
[11]
Moreover, prescribing separate schedule for both the posts with an
indication that there is one post of Principal Scientific Officer (Space
Applications) and one post of Principal Scientific Officer (Science and
Technology) again reinforces the view that these two posts do not form part of
one cadre and neither can be grouped for the purposes of reservation and
application of roster reservation policy which the petitioner has strongly harped
upon. Since a construction of the relevant recruitment rules and the schedule
attached thereto, clinch the issue that these two posts do not form part of the
same cadre, there does not arise any question of application of reservation to a
single post as per Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Upon giving
anxious consideration to the rival submission of the parties, this Court is
satisfied that the contention of the petitioner that these two posts form one and
the same cadre and should be subjected to the roster replacement policy is not
correct.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. Pending application(s), if
any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Munna S
MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2024.02.22 10:12:02 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review