Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) NO 693 OF 2022
Dr. Sujit Chakma
Son of Sri Meghabaran Chakma
Resident of village-79 Tilla, GB Bazaar
PO- Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura,
Pin -799006, Aged about 46 years.
...........Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the
Commissioner & Secretary,
Health & Family Welfare Department,
Government of Tripura, having it‟s office at
New Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala,
PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District- West Tripura.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary to the
Department of Health & Family Welfare,
Government of Tripura, having it‟s office at
New Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala,
PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura.
3. The National Medical Commission,
represented by its Secretary General,
Board of Governors, having it‟s office at
Pocket-14, Sector-8, Dwarka Phase-1,
New Delhi-110077.
4. The Deputy Secretary to the
Department of Health & Family Welfare,
Government of Tripura, having it‟s office at
New Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala,
PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura.
5. The Director, Tripura Health Services,
Government of Tripura, having it‟s office at
PN Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala,
PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub- Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura.
6. The Director of Medical Education,
Government of Tripura, having it‟s office at PN Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura.
..............Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, GA
Date of hearing
:
21/11/2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
22/12/2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The issue falls for consideration in this writ petition is whether a
Government in-service Medical Officer, who belongs to the Scheduled Tribes
community, having all requisite educational and professional qualifications, is
entitled to get the benefit of age relaxation in terms of the provisions of the
Tripura Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991, for
selection to the post of Senior Resident(SR), Department of Surgery, Agartala
Government Medical College & GBP Hospital, Agartala.
2.
Before I delve into the above issue, it would be apposite to go
through the facts, as projected by the writ petitioner in this petition, which are as
under:FACTS:2.1.
The petitioner was initially appointed to the post of Junior Medical
Officer, Grade-IV under the Tripura Health Service(“THS”, for short) on regular
basis vide Memo. dated 16.12.2002 and on his joining he was posted at
Dhanbilash PHC. In the year 2010 he was promoted to the post of Grade-III
THS vide Notification dated 29.05.2010 issued by the Deputy Secretary, Health
& Family Welfare(HFW for short) Department, Government of Tripura. Later
on, the petitioner prosecuted further studies and successfully completed Master
of Surgery in General Surgery, and on his successful completion of MS in
General Surgery, the Under Secretary, HFW Department vide Notification dated
03.06.2013 directed him to be posted in the office of the Medical
Superintendent, District Hospital, Unakoti Tripura, Kailashahar as Medical
Officer(Surgeon), Grade III of THS and in compliance thereto he joined to his
place of posting.
2.2.
The petitioner was thereafter transferred to Agartala Government
Medical College & GBP Hospital(AGMC for short) vide order dated
02.06.2016. After his joining in the AGMC, he successfully completed his
Senior Resident/Registrar-ship under the Department of Surgery, AGMC and at
the same time continued to discharge his duties in the AGMC.
2.3.
The cause of action for filing the present petition came to start with,
primarily, on the first occasion, when the Director of Medical Education(DME
for
short),
Government
of
Tripura
issued
an
Advertisement
dated
11.02.2022(Annexure-15 to the writ petition) inviting applications from the inservice eligible Medical Officers who were serving under the respondents-State
and had completed their MCI/NMC recognized Post Graduate (MD/MS/DNB)
Course from any of the MCI/NMC recognized institution, for absorption from
Tripura Health Services to Tripura Medical Education in the post of Basic
Teacher(Senior Resident/Registrar/Tutor), wherein the age criteria to make one
eligible was fixed as 45 years as on 25.02.2022.
2.4.
It is the case of the petitioner that despite fulfilling all the essential
conditions as mentioned in the said Advertisement dated 11.02.2022, he had
been debarred from participating in the selection process on the pretext that the
age of the petitioner had exceeded the age stipulated in the advertisement dated
11.02.2022, i.e. beyond the upper age limit of 45 years.
2.5.
The petitioner claimed that he being an intending candidate
belonging to Scheduled Tribe Community was entitled to a concession of five
years over the prescribed maximum age limit as contemplated under the
provisions of the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation
Act, 1991, but the State-respondents without considering the provisions of age
relaxation in terms of the said Act had issued the Advertisement dated
11.02.2022 fixing the upper age limit at 45 years, which had seriously and
grossly prejudiced the petitioner as well as other aspiring in-service reserved
category medical officers serving under the Department of Health & Family
Welfare, Government of Tripura.
2.6.
Being aggrieved to the said Advertisement dated 11.02.2022, the
petitioner earlier had preferred a writ petition before this Court, registered as
WP(C) No.207 of 2022, inter alia praying for according relaxation of five years
age to the petitioner, since he belongs to Scheduled Tribe community, as
recognized in the State of Tripura, and also prayed for permitting him to
participate in the selection process, initiated by the Director of Medical
Education(DME), respondent No.6 herein through Advertisement dated
11.02.2022.
2.7.
This Court having heard the learned counsel appearing for the
parties, vide order dated 21.06.2022 disposed of the writ petition directing the
respondents to consider the case of the petitioner with further liberty to submit
representation to the respondents. For the sake of convenience, order dated
21.06.2022 is reproduced here-in-below, in extenso:
“21/06/2022
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. R. Chakraborty,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A.
assisted by Mr. P. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
2.
It is the case of the petitioner that a person belonging to Scheduled Tribe is
entitled to get the benefit of five years relaxation. The petitioner admittedly belongs
to the Scheduled Tribe category and as the said relaxation has not been extended to
the petitioner, hence, the present writ petition.
3.
Admittedly under Article 14,15,16,19, 21 and 311 of the Constitution of India
and the statutory rights, guaranteed under the Tripura Scheduled Castes &
Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991(as amended) and the Tripura Medical
Education (Administrative & Faculty ) Service Conditions Rules, 2015 the persons
belonging to the reserved class are entitled for five years of relaxation in their
employment service. Since the said Constitutional aspect has been made for the
benefit of the petitioner and the similarity placed class of persons, there cannot be
any denial to the right under the statute.
4.
In view of the above, the writ petition is disposed of directing the respondents
to consider the case of the petitioner in its true letter and spirit within a period of one
month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
5.
The petitioner is at liberty to file his representation before the respondents
without any further delay.”
2.8.
Pursuant to aforesaid directions, the petitioner had approached the
respondent-DME with a representation dated 02.07.2022, inter alia praying for
granting age relaxation of five years in his favour, enabling him to participate in
the selection process, in terms of the directions passed by this Court.
2.9.
It is relevant to mention at this stage that in the present writ
petition, the petitioner referred to a communication dated 23.02.2022
(Annexure-20 to the writ petition), issued by the respondent-DME addressed to
the
Secretary
General,
Board
of
Governors,
National
Medical
Commission(NMC for short), by which communication the Director of Medical
Education requested the NMC to grant one-time relaxation of age from 45 years
to 50 years in respect of the Senior Residents working in the State of Tripura, for
the interest of large number of patients of the State and also for smooth
functioning of the AGMC.
In reply thereto, the NMC, with the approval of the Post Graduate
Medical Education Board meeting held on 04.05.2022, communicated its
decision to the DME on the issue of age relaxation, vide letter dated
08.07.2022(Annexure-8 to the writ petition) inter alia stating therein that the
proposal/request made by the DME cannot be agreed to as there is no provision
of age relaxation in the Teachers Eligibility Qualification Regulations(here-inafter referred to as TEQ Regulations, 2022).
2.10.
The representation of the petitioner dated 02.07.2022, is however,
addressed to by the respondents-HFW Department vide impugned order dated
29.07.2022(Annexure-22 to the writ petition) stating therein that as per the
Gazette of India Notification of NMC dated 22.02.2022 published in the
Extraordinary, Part-III, Section IV for the post of Senior Residents and Tutor
Graduate must be below 45 years. Meaning thereby, the representation of the
petitioner for age relaxation has not been acceded to.
2.11.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned order dated
29.07.2022 refusing to relax the age, the petitioner has preferred the instant writ
petition, inter alia praying for the following relief(s):
“(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause as
to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued for
directing them, to transmit the records, relevant to the subject matter of this writ
petition for rendering substantive and conscionable justice to the petitioner and for
quashing/setting aside the impugned Order dated 29.07.2022(Annexure-22 SUPRA);
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause as
to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued for
mandating/directing the respondents, to forthwith revoke/rescind the impugned
Order dated 29.07.2022(Annexure-22 supra), insofar as it negates the benefit of five
years relaxation, in favour of the petitioner, as a member, belonging to the
Scheduled Tribe Category, as recognized in the State of Tripura;
(iii) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause as
to why a Writ of Prohibition and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued for
restraining/prohibiting the respondents, from acting in any manner, in furtherance of
the impugned Order dated 29.07.2022(Annexure-22 infra), insofar as it restricts the
benefit of five years relaxation, in favour of the petitioner, as a member, belonging to
the Scheduled Tribe Category, as recognized in the State of Tripura;
(iv) In the Ad-interim and Interim, to pass an Order in terms of relief(iii) supra;
(v) Call for the records appertaining to this petition;
(vi) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule Absolute in terms of i. to
iv. Above;”
3.
On the aforementioned background facts, I have heard Mr. Somik
Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner. I have also heard Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya,
learned GA appearing for the State-respondents no.1, 2 and 5 as well as Mr. B.
Majumder, learned Dy. SGI appearing for the respondents no.3 and 4, the Union
of India.
4.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner at the
outset submitted that in terms of the provisions under Section 4(1)(d) of the
Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991, the
candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes community are
entitled to a concession of 5(five) years, over the prescribed maximum age limit,
for appointment to any service or post and it is a matter of right for them under
the above-mentioned provision.
4.1.
At this juncture, it would be relevant to extract the provision made
under Section 4(1)(d) of the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
Reservation Act, 1991, which reads thus:
“The members of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes shall be
entitled to a concession of five years over the prescribed maximum age limit for
appointment to any service or post, and also for admission to educational
institutions and undergoing any kind of training.”
4.2.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner vehemently argued that
since there is no provision for relaxation/concession of age under the Medical
Council of India Act, 1956, the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
Reservation Act, 1991 will come into play.
4.3.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner further submitted that the
Central and the State Governments are sovereign in their respective domain
under Schedule VII, Entry-66 of List-I and Entry-25 of List-III of the concurrent
list. Much emphasis being laid upon Entry-25 of List-III of the Concurrent List.
Learned senior counsel contended that State has ample power to frame law in
relation to coordinate and determine the standard of education including service
conditions in medical education in the State. As such, in view of the mandate of
Section 4(1)(d) of the Act of 1991 the petitioner has statutory right to enjoy the
benefit of concession of five years over the upper age limit of 45 years as
provided under TEQ Regulations, 2022.
4.4.
For the sake of convenience, Entry-66 of List-I and Entry-25 of
List-III are reproduced here-in-below:Entry-66 of List-I reads as under:
“Co-ordination and determination of standards in institutions for higher
education or research and scientific and technical institutions.”
Entry-25 of List-III reads as under:
“.....Education, including technical education, medical education and universities,
subject to the provisions of entries 63,64,65 an 66 of list I; vocational and
technical training of labor.”
4.5.
At this stage, it would be useful to extract the relevant provisions of
Section 19(A) of the Medical Council of India Act, 1956, relied upon by the
learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner. Section 19(A) of the MCI
Act, 1956 deals with Standard of Medical Education, which is reproduced herein- below:
“Section 19(A) of the Medical Council of India Act, 1956
STANDARD OF MEDICAL EDUCATION
1. The Council may prescribe the minimum standards of medical education
required other than postgraduate medical qualifications by universities or medical
institutions in India.
2. Copies of the draft regulations and of all subsequent amendments thereof
shall be furnished by the Council to all State Governments and the Council shall
before submitting the regulations or any amendment thereof, as the case may be, to
the Central Government for sanction, take into consideration the comments of any
State Government received within three months from the furnishing of the copies as
aforesaid.
3. The Committee shall from time to time report to the Council on the efficacy
of the regulations and may recommend to the Council such amendments thereof as it
may think fit.”
4.6.
Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner has relied on
the decision of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in Tamil Nadu Medical Officers Assn.
v. Union of India, (2021) 6 SCC 568 wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court held
thus:
“23.4. The Medical Council of India which has been constituted under the
provisions of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 is the creature of the statute in
exercise of powers under List I Entry 66 and has no power to make any provision
for reservation, more particularly, for in-service candidates by the States
concerned, in exercise of powers under List III Entry 25.
23.5. That Regulation 9 of the MCI Regulations, 2000 does not deal with
and/or make provisions for reservation and/or affect the legislative competence and
authority of the States concerned to make reservation and/or make special
provision like the provision providing for a separate source of entry for in-service
candidates seeking admission to postgraduate degree courses and therefore the
States concerned to be within their authority and/or legislative competence to
provide for a separate source of entry for in-service candidates seeking admission
to postgraduate degree courses in exercise of powers under List III Entry 25.
83.3. Having regard to the legal and factual context of this case and
considering the fact that the issue of legislative competence arises in respect of an
entry belonging to shared, and not exclusive field of legislations, in our opinion the
said sub-clause cannot be interpreted to mean that the State is denuded of the
power to make a separate channel of admission to the said courses for in-service
doctors from the State merit list. This is an issue of legislative competence and
the Nazir Ahmad v. King Emperor, 1936 SCC OnLine PC 41: (1935-36) 63 IA 372
: AIR 1936 PC 253 (2) dictum does not come into conflict with the interpretation
we are giving to this clause. Application of that principle solely on the basis of a
Union legislation, without examining the scope of the State's legislative power in
the given context, would be contrary to the constitutional scheme in having
concurrent field of legislation. The said sub-clause does not prescribe specific bar
on the State authorities in providing for such reservation or such separate entry
channel.
84. When a subject falls in a shared field of legislation, there may be cases
where the dominant legislative body may not have had made provisions in a
legislative instrument for which it had power to do so. But in such a situation the
dominant legislative body cannot prevent the secondary legislative body from
making provisions in that regard. We would make it clear here that we are using
the terms “dominant legislative body” to describe the Union Legislature and
“secondary legislative body” to refer to the State Legislature in the context of the
Concurrent List only. We are doing so because in case of repugnancy between two
legislative instruments originating from the Union and the State Legislatures in
relation to any entry therein, the former is to prevail as per the constitutional
scheme. Turning back to the aspect of occupied field, if certain areas of legislative
entry are left void by the Union Legislature, these void areas would come within the
legislative power of the secondary legislative body as the constitutional entry gives
both the legislative bodies co-existing, power to legislate on such subjects.
85. Regulation 9 of the 2000 Regulations is no doubt a self-contained code. But
as we have already observed, it is not an exhaustive code covering all aspects of
admission in postgraduate medical degree courses. The scope of this code and
extent of its operation has been explained by this Court in Yatinkumar Jasubhai
Patel v. State of Gujarat, (2019) 10 SCC 1.
86. Negation of power of the State cannot be a matter of inference, or such
negation cannot be in anticipation that the Union Legislature may make provisions
in future in the vacant legislative space. The authorities in support of this
proposition are West U.P. Sugar Mills Assn. v. State of U.P., (2020) 9 SCC 548,
U.P. Coop. Cane Unions Federations v. West U.P. Sugar Mills Assn., (2004) 5 SCC
430, S.R. Bommai v. Union of India, (1994) 3 SCC and Tika Ramji v. State of U.P.,
AIR 1956 SC 676 Only in cases where the State Legislature makes a law repugnant
to any provision of law made by Parliament, the parliamentary law would prevail.”
5.
On the other hand, to counter the submissions of Mr. Deb, learned
senior counsel, learned Dy. SGI appearing for the respondents-Union of India,
placing reliance upon the decision of Baharul Islam v. Indian Medical Assn.,
2023 SCC OnLine SC 79 tried to delineate the distinctive features of Entry-66
of List-I and Entry-25 of List-III, wherein it was held thus:“85.(i) Entry 25 of List III of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of
India deals with the subject education which is in the Concurrent List under which
both the Parliament or the Union Legislature as well as the State Legislatures have
legislative competence to legislate. However, Entry 25 of List III is subject to, inter
alia, Entry 66 of List I which is the Union List. Entry 66 of List I deals with
coordination and determination of standards in institutions for higher education or
research and scientific and technical institutions. Thus, when any law is made
under Entry 25 of List III by a State Legislature, the same is always subject to Entry
66 of List I. In other words, if any law made by the Parliament comes within the
scope of Entry 66 of List I, then the State Legislation would have to yield to the
Parliamentary law.
Thus, where one Entry is made “subject to” another Entry, it would imply that,
out of the scope of the former Entry, a field of legislation covered by the latter
Entry has been reserved to be specifically dealt with by the appropriate legislature.
(ii) In the instant case, it is held that the IMC Act, 1956 is a legislation made
by the Parliament for the purpose of coordination and determination of standards
in medical education throughout the Country. The said law, along with the Rules
and Regulations made there under are for the purpose of determination of
standards of medical education throughout India. Thus, determination of standards
in medical education in India is as per the IMC Act, 1956 which is a Central Law.
This is in respect of modern medicine or allopathic medicine within the scope of
Entry 66 of List I and not under Entry 25 of List III of the Seventh Schedule.
Therefore, a State Legislature which passes a law in respect of allopathic medicine
or modern medicine would be subject to the provisions of the IMC Act, 1956 and
the Rules and Regulations made thereunder. This would imply that no State
Legislature has the legislative competence to pass any law which would be
contradictory to or would be in direct conflict with the IMC Act, 1956 and the Rules
and Regulations made thereunder. In other words, the standard in medical
education insofar as modern medicine or allopathy is concerned, having been set
by the IMC Act, 1956 and the Rules and Regulations made thereunder or by any
subsequent Act in that regard, such as the Medical Council of India Act, 2019, the
State Legislature has no legislative competence to enact a law which is in conflict
with the law setting the standards of medical education in the context of modern
medicine or allopathic medicine, which has been determined by Parliamentary
Legislation as well as the Rules. In other words, a State Legislature has no
legislative competence to enact a law in respect of modern medicine or allopathic
medicine contrary to the said standards that have been determined by the Central
Law.
In view of the above conclusion, we hold that decision of the Gauhati High
Court holding that the Assam Act to be null and void, is just and proper.
However, the Gauhati High Court has held that the State had no legislative
competence to enact the Assam Act in view of Article 254 of the Constitution on the
premise that the IMC Act and the Rules and Regulations made thereunder were
holding the field and hence, on the basis of the doctrine of occupied field, the
Assam Act was struck down as being repugnant to the Central Law. In view of the
aforesaid conclusion, we are of the view that the said reasoning is incorrect. It is
reiterated that the IMC Act and the Rules and Regulations made thereunder, which
are all Central legislations, have been enacted having regard to Entry 66 of List I
and would prevail over any State Law made by virtue of Entry 25 of List III of
the Constitution.
(iii) Hence, in view of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and the Rules and
Regulations made thereunder, the Assam Act, namely, the Assam Rural Health
Regulatory Authority Act, 2004, is declared to be null and void, in view of the
Assam Legislature not having the legislative competence to enact the said Law.
(iv) Consequently, the subsequent legislation, namely, the Assam Act of 2015
i.e., the Assam Community Professionals (Registration and Competency) Act, 2015,
enacted pursuant to the judgment of the Gauhati High Court, is a valid piece of
Legislation as it has removed the basis of the impugned judgment passed by the
Gauhati High Court. The 2015 Act is also not in conflict with the IMC, Act, 1956.
This is because the Central Act namely, IMC, Act, 1956 does not deal with
Community Health Professionals who would practise as allopathic practitioners in
the manner as they were permitted to practise under the Assam Act, in rural areas
of the State of Assam. Hence, by a separate legislation the Community Health
Professionals have been permitted to practise as such professionals. The said
legislation of 2015 is not in conflict with IMC, Act, 1956 and the rules and
regulations made thereunder. Hence, the Act of 2015 is not hit by Entry 66 of List I
of the Constitution and is within the legislative competence of the State Legislature
under the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution.”
5.1.
Learned Dy. SGI also relied on the decision of Modern Dental
College & Research Centre v. State of M.P., (2016) 7 SCC 353, wherein the
Apex Court held thus:“143. In Preeti Srivastava case [Preeti Srivastava v. State of M.P.,
1999 7 SCC 120: 1 SCEC 742, this Court considered the question whether it
was open to the State to prescribe different admission criteria, in the sense of
prescribing different minimum qualifying marks, for special category
candidates seeking admission to the postgraduate medical courses under the
reserved seats category as compared to the general category candidates. While
considering the question whether norms for admission have any connection
with the standards of education, observing that norms for admission have a
nexus with standards of education or rules of admission which are covered
under Entry 25 of the Concurrent List, it was held that the minimum standards
as laid down by the Central statute have to be complied with by the States. In
paras 35 and 36 it was held as under: (SCC pp. 154-55)
“35. … Both the Union as well as the States have the power to
legislate on education including medical education, subject, inter alia,
to List I Entry 66 which deals with laying down standards in
institutions for higher education or research and scientific and
technical institutions as also coordination of such standards. A State
has, therefore, the right to control education including medical
education so long as the field is not occupied by any Union legislation.
Secondly, the State cannot, while controlling education in the State,
impinge on standards in institutions for higher education. Because this
is exclusively within the purview of the Union Government. Therefore,
while prescribing the criteria for admission to the institutions for
higher education including higher medical education, the State cannot
adversely affect the standards laid down by the Union of India under
List I Entry 66. Secondly, while considering the cases on the subject it
is also necessary to remember that from 1977, education, including,
inter alia, medical and university education, is now in the Concurrent
List so that the Union can legislate on admission criteria also. If it does
so, the State will not be able to legislate in this field, except as provided
in Article 254.
36.It would not be correct to say that the norms for admission
have no connection with the standard of education, or that the rules for
admission are covered only by List III Entry 25. Norms of admission
can have a direct impact on the standards of education. Of course,
there can be rules for admission which are consistent with or do not
affect adversely the standards of education prescribed by the Union in
exercise of powers under List I Entry 66. For example, a State may, for
admission to the postgraduate medical courses, lay down qualifications
in addition to those prescribed under List I Entry 66. This would be
consistent with promoting higher standards for admission to the higher
educational courses. But any lowering of the norms laid down can and
does have an adverse effect on the standards of education in the
institutes of higher education. Standards of education in an institution
or college depend on various factors. Some of these are:
(1) The calibre of the teaching staff;
(2) A proper syllabus designed to achieve a high level of education in
the given span of time;
(3) The student-teacher ratio;
(4) The ratio between the students and the hospital beds available
to each student;
(5) The calibre of the students admitted to the institution;
(6)Equipment and laboratory facilities, or hospital facilities for
training in the case of medical colleges;
(7) Adequate accommodation for the college and the attached
hospital; and
(8) The standard of examinations held including the manner in
which the papers are set and examined and the clinical performance is
judged.”
6.
Mr. Bhattacharyya, learned GA appearing for the State respondents
submitted that the Director of Medical Education, Government of Tripura had
requested the National Medical Commission (NMC) for one-time relaxation of
age limit from 45 years to 50 years in respect of Senior Resident (SR) from the
State of Tripura vide letter dated 23.02.2022 and in reply the National Medical
Commission(NMC) in its letter dated 08.07.2022 has communicated that there is
no provision of age relaxation in the Teachers Eligibility Qualifications(TEQ)
Regulations. So, the Director of Medical Education is not in a position to give
one-time relaxation of age limit from 45 years to 50 years to Scheduled Castes
& Scheduled Tribe candidates in respect of Senior Resident/ Registrar/Tutor for
the State of Tripura without the consent of National Medical Commission
(NMC). Moreover, the Medical Council of India Act, 1956 Rules and
Regulations do not stipulate any provision for age relaxation.
7.
The issue raised in the present writ petition is entirely covered by a
judgment passed by the Constitution Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the
case of Tamil Nadu Medical Officers Association & Ors. Vs. Union of India &
Ors., (2021) 6 SCC 568. In Tamil Nadu Medical Officer Association(supra),
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, while dealing with the issue of reservation in
respect of in-service candidates and to provide a separate source of entry for
such in-service candidates, has categorically held that the State Government
cannot trespass into the legislative zone of “Coordination & Determination of
Standards” as covered by Entry-66 of the Union List, including by lowering of
eligibility criteria for admission as fixed by the Union Legislation i.e. the
Regulation 9(3) read with Regulation (6) of the Postgraduate Medical Education
Regulations, 2000. The said field is exclusively for the Union Legislature and
only such Rules in respect of admission as framed by the State Legislatures
which would not have impact on the subject enlisted under Entry-66 of the
Union List and may not be in conflict. The Hon‟ble Constitution Bench had
further held that the State Government are entitled to make provisions, however,
the candidates must fulfill the basic admission criteria contained in Regulation
(3) read with Regulation 9(6) of the Postgraduate Medical Education
Regulations, 2000 and that the minimum standards mandated by the said
Statutory Regulations for being eligible to pursue Postgraduate Medical Degree
course are adhered to. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court further had conclusively held
that the Regulation 9 as amended vide Notification dated 05.04.2018 grants
benefits to aspiring in-service candidates, however they must qualify the NEET-
PG Examination with minimum eligibility marks as prescribed under the said
Statutory Regulations.
7.1.
In the event of any Rules or Regulations issued by the concerned
State Government in respect of appointment of Medical Teachers in any
Medical College in the Country including the Tripura Scheduled Castes and
scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991, if in conflict with the provisions,
Regulation 6 under Table-1A & 1C of the TEQ Regulations, 2022, published in
the Official Gazette on 22.02.2022, to the said extent of conflict, the said
Rule/Regulation/Act issued by the concerned State Government shall be
repugnant to the TEQ Regulations,2022 in view of Article 254 of the
Constitution of India.
7.2.
In the case of MCI vs. State of Karnataka, (1998) 6 SCC 131, the
Hon‟ble Apex Court, while holding that the Statutory Regulations of the
erstwhile Medical Council of India are binding and mandatory, has further held
that all State enactments, rules and regulations framed by the Universities, etc,
in relation to the course of medicine, to the extent, they are inconsistent with the
Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and the Regulations made thereunder by the
erstwhile Medical Council of India are repugnant by virtue of Article 254 of the
Constitution of India inasmuch as the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 is
relatable to Entry -66 List 1 Schedule VII of the Constitution of India.
7.3.
The above view of three-Judge Bench has been reaffirmed by the
Constitution Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Preeti
Srivastava and Anr. vs. State of M.P. and Ors., (1999) 7 SCC 120. It is held
thus:[SCC p 164 para 57]
“57. In the case of Medical Council of India v. State of Karnataka [(1998) 6
SCC 131] a Bench of three Judges of this Court has distinguished the observations
made in Nivedita Jain [(1981) 4 SCC 296] . It has also disagreed with Ajay Kumar
Singh v. State of Bihar [(1994) 4 SCC 401] and has come to the conclusion that the
Medical Council regulations have a statutory force and are mandatory. The Court
was concerned with admissions to the MBBS course and the regulations framed by
the Indian Medical Council relating to admission to the MBBS course. The Court
took note of the observations in State of Kerala v. T.P. Roshana [(1979) 1 SCC 572,
580] (SCC at p. 580) to the effect that under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956,
the Medical Council of India has been set up as an expert body to control the
minimum standards of medical education and to regulate their observance. It has
implicit power to supervise the qualifications or eligibility standards for admission
into medical institutions. There is, under the Act an overall vigilance by the Medical
Council to prevent sub-standard entrance qualifications for medical courses. These
observations would apply equally to postgraduate medical courses. We are in
respectful agreement with this reasoning.”
Furthermore, in Preeti Srivastava(supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court has held thus:
“52……Under the Indian Medical Council Act of 1956 the Indian Medical Council is
empowered to prescribe, inter alia, standards of postgraduate medical education. In
the exercise of its powers under Section 20 read with Section 33 the Indian Medical
Council has framed regulations which govern postgraduate medical education.
These regulations, therefore, are binding and the States cannot, in the exercise of
power under Entry 25 of List III, make rules and regulations which are in conflict
with or adversely impinge upon the regulations framed by the Medical Council of
India for postgraduate medical education. Since the standards laid down are in the
exercise of the power conferred under Entry 66 of List I, the exercise of that power is
exclusively within the domain of the Union Government. The power of the States
under Entry 25 of List III is subject to Entry 66 of List I.
“53. Secondly, it is not the exclusive power of the State to frame rules and
regulations pertaining to education since the subject is in the Concurrent List.
Therefore, any power exercised by the State in the area of education under Entry 25
of List III will also be subject to any existing relevant provisions made in that
connection by the Union Government subject, of course, to Article 254.”
7.4.
It is pertinent to mention herein that Regulation 6 under the Table
1A & Table 1C of the TEQ Regulations, 2022, as published in the Official
Gazette on 22.02.2022, provides the minimum academic qualifications as well
as teaching and research experience required for appointment to the post of
Senior Resident in any of the branches of any of the medical college/institution
in the Country. Again, Regulation 6 under the Table-1A & Table 1C of TEQ
Regulations, 2022 provides that Senior Residents are those who are undergoing
their residency in the concerned specialty department after obtaining recognized
postgraduate medical qualification and that the candidate must be below the
age of 45(forty-five) years at the time of initial appointment. The tenure post
of Senior Resident are not faculty positions.
8.
The impugned order which is challenged by the petitioner in the
present writ petition is cited as under:“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA HEALTH AND FAMILY
WELFARE DEPARTMENT
F.No.F.30 (106) DME/Estt/Law/22/3404-10
Dated, Agartala, the 29th, July, 2022
ORDER
WHEREAS, Dr. Sujit Chakma, Medical Officer (Surgeon), Gr.-Il of Tripura
Heal Services, Government of Tripura filed a Writ Petition No. W.P (C) 207 of 2022
before the Hort ble High Court of Tripura for the benefit of five years relaxation as
Schedule Tribe category for selection to the post of Senior Resident (SR), Department
of Surgery, A.G.M.C & G.B.P Hospital, Agartala.
AND
WHEREAS, The Hon'ble High Court of Tripura vide Judgment and Order
dated 21- 06-2022 disposed of case with direction to consider the case of the
petitioner in its true letter and spirit within a period of one month from the date of
receipt of a copy of the judgment order.
AND
WHEREAS, The Department received the said Judgment and Order on 01-072022 from the O/o. Assistant Registrar, High Court of Tripura and from the petitioner
on 02.07.2022.
AND
WHEREAS, As per the Gazette of India Notification of National Medical
Commission (NMC) dated 22.02.2022
published in the Extraordinary, Part-III,
Section-IV for the post of Senior Resident and Tutor graduate must be below 45 years
of age.
AND
WHEREAS, The Director of Medical Education, Govt. of Tripura has
requested NMC for one time relaxation of age limit from 45 yrs. to 50 yrs. in respect
of Senior Resident for the State of Tripura vide letter No. 12(6)-DME/GEN/MC/2015
(Sub-l)/1117-18 dated 23.02 2022 and in reply the National Medical Commission in
its letter dated 08.07.2022 vide No. NMC/MCI-23(1) (112)/2022-Med./PG/025142 has
communicated that there is no provision of age relaxation in the Teachers Eligibility
Qualifications (TEQ ) Regulations.
AND
WHEREAS, After evaluation of all facts & aspects it appears that the
petitioner is not entitled to get the benefit of five years relaxation as Schedule Tribe
category in the post of Senior Resident, Department of Surgery A.G.M.C & G.B.P
Hospital, Agartala.
AND
NOW, THEREFORE, after consideration of all aspect, the competent authority
is pleased to order that Consideration entitled to get the benefit of five years
relaxation as Schedule Tribe category in the post of Senior Resident, Department of
Surgery, A.G.M.C & G.B.P Hospital, Agartala cannot be acceded to.
Accordingly, the representation is disposed of.
This is issued with the approval of the Government of Tripura, Health &
Family Welfare Department vide U.O.No.266 dated 27/07/2022.
By order of the Governor,
(Smti. Anima Debbarma)
Deputy Secretary to the Government of Tripura”
9.
On perusal of the above order under challenge, it is evident that
despite the age criteria of 45 years for applying to the post of “Senior Resident
and Tutor Graduate”, as per the Gazette of India Notification of National
Medical Commission (NMC) published in the Extraordinary Gazette, Part-III,
Section-IV vide dated 22.02.2022, the Director of Medical Education,
Government of Tripura had requested the National Medical Council (NMC) for
one-time age relaxation from 45 years to 50 years in respect of the post of
Senior
Resident
for
the
State
of
Tripura
vide
letter
No.12(6)-
DME/GEN/MC/2015(Sub-l)/1117-18 dated 23.02 2022 and in reply the
National Medical Commission intimated vide communication No.NMC/MCIPage 19 of 28
23(1)(112)/2022-Med./PG/025142 dated 08.07.2022 that there is no provision of
age relaxation in the TEQ Regulations. The said communication further reveals
that the petitioner is not entitled to get the benefit of five years relaxation as a
Scheduled Tribe for the post of Senior Resident, Department of Surgery
A.G.M.C & G.B.P Hospital, Agartala.
10.
The merits of the communication dated 08.07.2022 can be viewed
from another angle keeping in mind the submission of Mr. Deb, learned senior
counsel in reference to Entry-25 of List-III of the Seventh Schedule of
the Constitution of India. Entry-25 of List-III of the Seventh Schedule of the
Constitution of India deals with the subject education under which both the
Parliament as well as the State Legislatures have legislative competence to
legislate. However, Entry-25 of List-III is subject to, inter alia, Entry-66 of ListI. Entry-66 of List-I deals with coordination and determination of standards in
institutions for higher education or research and scientific and technical
institutions. Consequently, when any law is made under Entry-25 of List-III by a
State Legislature, the same is always subject to Entry-66 of List-I.
11.
It is now well-settled that norms of education have a direct nexus
with standards of education and the minimum standards as laid down by the
Central statute must be complied with by the States. There is no quarrel that a
State has the right to control education including medication, but, restricted to
the field which is not occupied by any Union Legislation. Age criterion for
appointment to the post of Basic Teacher that includes Senior Resident is
prescribed under Union Legislation. So, any legislation contrary to the Union
Legislation enacted under Entry-66 of List-I, even if, such legislation is made by
the State in exercise of power under Entry-25 of List-III, the law made by the
Parliament as well as the regulations or rules made under Central Act will
prevail. In other words, the new law made by Parliament, or the regulations or
rules made under any Central Act, if repugnant to the law made by the
legislature of a State, then the law made by the State, to the extent of
repugnancy, shall be void. In other words, the law made by Parliament, or the
regulations or rules made under any Central Act, if repugnant to the law made
by the legislature of a State, then the law made by the State, to the extent of
repugnancy, shall be void.
12.
Since the Medical Council of India Act, 1956 is a Central Law, as it
is a legislation formulated by the Parliament, therefore, a State Legislature
which passes a law in respect of reservation under the Tripura Scheduled Castes
and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991 would be subject to the provisions
of the Medical Council of India Act, 1956 and the Rules and Regulations made
thereunder. This would imply that no State Legislature has the legislative
competence to pass any law which would be contradictory to or would be in
direct conflict with the MCI Act, 1956 and the Rules and Regulations made
thereunder. In other words, the standard in medical education, having been set
by the MCI Act, 1956 and the Rules and Regulations made thereunder or by any
subsequent Act in that regard, such as the National Medical Commission Act,
2019, the State Legislature has no legislative competence to enact a law which is
in conflict with the law setting the standards of medical education, which has
been determined by Parliamentary Legislation as well as the Rules. In other
words, a State Legislature has no legislative competence to enact a law in
respect of reservation contrary to the said standards that have been determined
by the Central Law.
13.
In the instant case, Section 4(1)(d) of the Tripura Scheduled Castes
and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991, provides relaxation/concession of
5 years over the prescribed maximum age limit for appointment to any service
or post on the strength of which, the petitioner has filed this petition to permit
him to participate in the selection process for absorption in Tripura Medical
Education Service in the post of Basic Teacher (Senior Resident). There is no
quarrel in the Bar that in the State of Tripura the maximum age limit for
appointment to any post is 40(forty) years. Concession of 5(five) years is given
to SC/ST/PH candidates. So, maximum age limit for appointment to any service
is determined as 45 years for SC/ST/PH candidates as provided under
Section4(1)(d) of Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation
Act, 1991. Admittedly, under Regulation 6 Table-IA of TEQ Regulations, 2022,
the maximum age limit prescribed for the post of Senior Resident is 45 years.
14.
One more important aspect, which has enough relevance in the
context of the case is that the Government of Tripura in exercise of powers
conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India has framed
Tripura Medical Education(Administrative & Faculty) Service Conditions
Rules, 2015(here-in-after referred to as “said Rules of 2015”) to regulate the
method and conditions of the service for persons appointed to the Tripura
Government Medical Education(Administrative & Faculty) Services. Under the
said Rules of 2015 “Service” means the Tripura Medical Education
Service(Administrative & Faculty) service conditions(2d); “MCI” means
Medical Council of India[2(g)]; “Medical College” means Agartala Government
Medical College Agartala(2h) and “Teaching Hospital” means Govind Ballabh
Pant Hospital or G.B.P. Hospital(2i) of the said Rules of 2015.
Rule 3 of the said Rules of 2015 deals with the ‘Constitution of
the Tripura Medical Education(Administrative & Faculty) Service
Conditions Rules and its Classification’. Rule 3 reads as under:
“i. On and from the date of commencement of these rules, there shall
be
a
constituted
Service
to
be
known
as
the
“Tripura
Medical
Education(Administrative & Faculty) Service Conditions.”
ii. The service shall have two wings namely (a) administrative and (b)
faculties for Medical College and its attached Teaching Hospital.
………….”
15.
In the instant case reference to administrative posts being not
relevant, emphasis is given concerning the teaching posts only.
Under Rule 3 of the said Rules of 2015, there is reference to
different teaching posts in Medical College and its attached Teaching Hospitals,
which are as under:
“a. Different Teaching Posts in a Medical College and its attached
Teaching Hospitals are as per norms/guidelines defined in the norms/guidelines
of Medical Council of India and as amended from time to time.
Teaching posts of Medical College are (1) Professor, (2) Associate
Professor, (3) Assistant Professor, (4) Tutor, (5) Registrar/Senior Resident and
(6) Junior Resident.”
Rule 5 deals with the „method of appointment’. For ready
reference, Rule 5 is extracted here-in-below:
“Appointment to different administrative and teaching posts of the
service after commencement of these rules shall be made by the following
methods:
a. Appointment to different administrative and teaching posts of the
Tripura Medical Education(Administrative & Faculty) Service shall
be made as detailed in SCHEDULE-II.
b. The basic teachers who have come from THS, within the period
(2005-2010) and working under AGMC may be appointed as basic
Teacher after getting approval from the appropriate authorities. At
the time of appointment he/she will have to fill up an option form in
Schedule-II and Annexure-I.”
Rule 8 of the said Rules of 2015 prescribes „Eligibility and
Qualification’, which may be extracted here-in-below, for convenience:
“Eligibility and Qualifications for direct recruitment to any post in the
service
A candidate, for direct recruitment to any post in this service, shall
have the Qualification/experience etc. as mentioned in the Schedule-II and satisfy
other conditions as specified in the schedules.”
Rule 9 provides „Initial Constitution of Service’, which is as
under:
“Absorption of administrative & teaching posts
The existing members of Administrative Posts like Director of Medical
Education, Joint Director of Medical Education, Principal of Agartala Govt.
Medical
College,
Superintendent-cum-Vice
Principal,
Deputy
Medical
Superintendent, Medical RMO of GBP Teaching Hospital and Teaching Posts like
Professor, Associate Professor, Assistant Professors of different disciplines of the
Medical College including those basic teachers like Tutor, Registrar/Senior
Resident and Junior Resident of the Agartala Government Medical College, will be
considered as members of Tripura Medical Education(Administrative & Faculty)
Service Conditions on and from the date of commencement of this service.”
Rule 12 of the said Rules of 2015 prescribes the „Age of
appointment and age of superannuation’, which stipulates that “Age of
appointment to any administrative & Teaching Posts shall be as per
Government Rules, where no mention has been made in SCHEDULE-II”.
Rule 14 of the said Rules of 2015 deals with the „Eligibility
Criteria’ which provides that “Qualification, experience and other eligibility
criteria for appointment to different administrative and teaching posts is given
in SCHEDULE-II”.
16.
On summation of the above provisions it comes to light that
Schedule-II appended to the said Rules of 2015 determines/governs the
eligibility and qualifications of a candidate for direct recruitment to any post in
the service. It leads this Court to peruse Schedule-II appended to the said Rules
of 2015.
17.
It is pertinent to mention herein that basic teacher includes Senior
Resident. Essential qualification and experience along with other criteria
required for the post of Basic Teacher are extracted here-in-below in tabular
form:
Category &
No. of Post.
Group-
Basic Teacher
Educational and other
Age
qualifications required for
Appointment
Not more than 40 Essential
qualification
and
A(Gazetted)
Tutor,
years relaxable by experience
84 Posts
Registrar/Senior
5(five)
Resident),
ST/SC/PH
recruitment through TPSC,
candidates and Govt.
failing which by deputation
in-service
from THS.
candidates.
ii. Remaining 50% of the
Name of Post
years
for
i. 50% of the posts by direct
posts by absorption from
Medical Officers of Grade-III
& Grade IV of THS.
Educational
and
other
qualification required for direct
recruitment:
i)
Minimum qualifications as
prescribed by the MCI and
specified in the “Minimum
qualifications for Teachers in
Medical Council Regulations,
1998 published in Part-III,
Section-4 of the Gazette of
India dated 5.2.1998 and as
amended from time to time.
18.
On bare perusal of the above rules of Schedule-II relating to the
post of Senior Resident, it is clear that the age as prescribed for direct
recruitment shall not be more than 40 years, relaxable by 5(five) years for
ST/SC/PH candidates and Govt. in-service candidates.
19.
The Educational and other qualifications for recruitment to the post
of Senior Resident are in consonance with the requirements as prescribed by the
MCI and specified in the “Minimum qualifications for Teachers in Medical
Council Regulations, 1998” published in Part-III, Section-4 of the Gazette of
India dated 05.02.1998 and as amended from time to time. So, the said Rules of
2015 being framed by the Government of Tripura is not in conflict with MCI
Act, 1956 which is a central Act obviously and the Regulations thereof as
amended from time to time. Thus, the age limit under the said Rules of 2015 for
appointment/absorption to the post of Senior Resident is 40 years, which is
relaxable by 5(five) years in case of SC/ST/PH and Govt. in-service candidates.
20.
The petitioner belongs to ST category and is a Govt. in-service
candidate. Admitted fact is that the petitioner having attained the age of 45 years
has sought for further 5(five) years relaxation, which is impermissible even
under Schedule II appended to the said Rules of 2015 framed by the
Government of Tripura.
21.
Now, the question comes as to the power of relaxation, if any to be
exercised by the respondents-State. Rule 29 of the said Rules of 2015
incorporates relaxation clause, which reads as under:“29. RELAXATION:
Where the Government is of the opinion that it is necessary or expedient to do
so, he may, by order, for reasons to be recorded in writing, and, in consultation with
the Commission to relax any of the provisions of these rules with respect to any class
or category of persons, or posts;
Provided that the power shall not be exercised so as to relax essential
qualification, period of experience as prescribed by MCI for appointment to any of
the methods specified in the rules (including promotion) or provisions regarding
pension and age of recruitment.”
22.
On plain reading of Rule 29 quoted here-in-above, it comes to light
that the power of relaxation has been vested to the Government under certain
compelling circumstances, and if the situation so demands, the Government in
consultation with the Commission may relax any of the provisions of the said
Rules of 2015 in respect to any class or category of persons, or posts, after
recording reasons therein for exercising such power.
However, a proviso is seen to have incorporated in Rule 29 which
clearly contemplates that such power of relaxation shall not be exercised so as to
relax age of recruitment and essential qualification, period of experience as
prescribed by MCI for appointment to any of the methods specified in the
rules(including promotion) or provisions regarding pension and age of
recruitment. Rule 29 clearly restricts the power of the respondents-authorities to
relax the age of recruitment of the petitioner in any manner whatsoever.
23.
Age being one of the important and essential criteria in determining
the standard of Medical Education cannot be altered or modified by any State
Legislature inconsistent with or in conflict with the MCI Act, 1956 or the NMC
Act, 2019 and the Regulation 6 under Table-IA and IC of the TEQ Regulations,
2022. State Government may lay down any additional eligibility criteria in its
rule or regulations for better standardization in the area of medical education
without impinging the essential criteria or qualifications what is prescribed by
the Central Regulations or Statutes.
24.
At the cost of repetition, what has emerged in the instant case is
that the said Rules of 2015 enacted by the Government of Tripura determining
the age for applying to the post of Senior Resident is consistent and not in
conflict with the TEQ Regulations, 2022 made under the MCI Act, 1956. As a
corollary, the petitioner has no legal or constitutional right to claim relaxation of
age criteria, or to say it otherwise, to allow him a concession of 5(five) years
over prescribed upper age limit of 45(forty five) years on the strength of Section
4(1)(d) of Tripura Schedule Castes and Schedule Tribes Reservation Act, 1991.
Resultantly, in the backdrop of aforesaid legal principles, the impugned order
dated 29.07.2022(Annexure-22 to the writ petition) issued by the respondentsState rejecting the claim of the petitioner does not survive for consideration and
needs no interference. Hence, the petitioner is not entitled to get
appointed/absorbed in the post of Senior Resident under the respondents.
25.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, the present writ
petition being devoid of any merits stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Snigdha/Dahlia
signed by
SANJAY Digitally
SANJAY GHOSH
2024.02.17
GHOSH Date:
14:48:14 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review