Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.966/2022
Dr. Sandeep Roy Sarkar, S/O. Narayan Chandra Roy Sarkar, R/O. Chinaihani,
Usha Bazar, (Near CPWD Office), P.O.:- Airport, Agartala, West Tripura, Age39 years.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. Tripura Public Service Commission (TPSC), To be represented by the
Secretary, TPSC, Akhaura Road, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
2. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
3. The State of Tripura, To be represented by the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner, Department of Higher Education, Govt. of Tripura, New
Secretariat Complex, Khejurbagan, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799010.
4. The Director, Department of Higher Education, Govt. of Tripura, Siksha
Sadan, Office Lane, Agartala, West Agartala, PIN:-799001.
5. Dr. Nabamita Nath, D/O. Satyendra Kumar Nath, Assistant Professor,
Department of Human Physiology, Netaji Subhash Mahavidyalaya, Udaipur,
Gomati Tripura, P.O.-R.K. Pur, PIN-799114.
6. Dr. Satyapriya Roy, S/O. Milan Chandra Roy, Assistant Professor,
Department of Human Physiology, Government Degree College, Kamalpur,
Kamalpur, Dhalai Tripura, P.O.-Kamalpur, PIN-799255.
7. (Dr.) Dulal Chandra Ray, Former Dean & Head, Department of Ecology &
Environment Science, Assam University, Silchar, Assam-788011.
8. Dr. Priyanka Gite, Professor, Faculty of Commerce, C 1/1 Jodhpur Colony,
Benaras Hindu University, Varanasi-221005, Uttar Pradesh.
9. Dr. Ashutosh Kumar, Associate Professor, Department of History, Faculty of
Social Sciences, Benaras Hindu University, Varanasi-221005, Uttar Pradesh.
10. Dr. Debraj Panigrahi, Associate Professor, Department of Sanskrit, Tripura
University, Suryamaninagar-799022, West Tripura, Tripura.
11. Dr. Pritha Pandit Roy Chowdhury, Assistant Professor, Department of
Political Science, Cooch Bihar College, Siliguri-734001, West Bengal.
(Notice to the Respondents Nos.5 to 11 be served through the O/o the Tripura
Public Service Commission (TPSC), To be represented by the Secretary, TPSC,
Akhaura Road, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001)
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate,
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate,
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate,
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate.
WP(C) No.967/2022
Dr. Shankha Subhra Bhadra, S/O. Lt. Dipak Lal Bhadra, R/O. Ramnagar Road
No.-1, Bi Lane-1, P.O.:- Ramnagar, Agartala-799002, West Tripura, Age-38
years.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. Tripura Public Service Commission (TPSC), To be represented by the
Secretary, TPSC, Akhaura Road, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
2. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
3. The State of Tripura, To be represented by the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner, Department of Higher Education, Govt. of Tripura, New
Secretariat Complex, Khejurbagan, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799010.
4. The Director, Department of Higher Education, Govt. of Tripura, Siksha
Sadan, Office Lane, Agartala, West Agartala, PIN:-799001.
5. Dr. Basudeb Bhattacharya, S/O. Bhakti Prasanna Bhattacharya, Assistant
Professor, Department of Commerce, Dasaratha Deb Memorial College,
Lalcherra, Khowai, Tripura, PIN-799202.
6. Dr. Sayan Saha, S/O. Narayan Chandra Saha, Assistant Professor,
Department of Commerce, Ambedkar College, Fatikroy, Unakoti Tripura, PIN799290.
7. (Dr.) Dulal Chandra Ray, Former Dean & Head, Department of Ecology &
Environment Science, Assam University, Silchar, Assam-788011.
8. Dr. Priyanka Gite, Professor, Faculty of Commerce, C 1/1 Jodhpur Colony,
Benaras Hindu University, Varanasi-221005, Uttar Pradesh.
9. Dr. Ashutosh Kumar, Associate Professor, Department of History, Faculty of
Social Sciences, Benaras Hindu University, Varanasi-221005, Uttar Pradesh.
10. Dr. Debraj Panigrahi, Associate Professor, Department of Sanskrit, Tripura
University, Suryamaninagar-799022, West Tripura, Tripura.
11. Dr. Pritha Pandit Roy Chowdhury, Assistant Professor, Department of
Political Science, Cooch Bihar College, Siliguri-734001, West Bengal.
(Notice to the Respondents Nos.5 to 11 be served through the O/o the Tripura
Public Service Commission (TPSC), To be represented by the Secretary, TPSC,
Akhaura Road, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001)
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate,
Mrs. P. Chakraborty, Advocate,
Ms. Ankita Pal, Advocate,
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 04th August, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, Mr. Raju
Datta, learned counsel for the respondents-Tripura Public Service Commission
(TPSC, for short), Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate
assisted by Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents-State and Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mrs. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel, and Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior
counsel appearing for the private respondents.
2.
Both the writ petitions have been heard together as they relate to
recruitment under the same advertisement No.08/2022 issued by the TPSC
though relating to different subjects of Human Physiology and Commerce in
the individual cases but having same grounds of challenge. In both the writ
petitions, the procedure adopted for computation of API score by application of
Clause 10.0 of the UGC Regulations, 2018 by the selection committee as
approved by the TPSC though are not being questioned in view of the issue
having been squarely answered in a similar challenge in the case of Dr.
Jayanta Dhar vrs. The State of Tripura & others in WP(C) No.90 of 2023 and
other connected matters, judgment dated 17th May, 2023 but the petitioners
have questioned the applicability of the guidelines framed by the TPSC in
matters of giving weightage to the API score and the interview score.
3.
The first issue which needs to be answered in both the writ
petitions is whether the weightage of marks for API score as 85% should also
have been followed in the component of personal interview by giving 15%
weightage to the absolute marks obtained in the personal interview. The
petitioners have also taken a plea that in case the answer to this issue is in the
negative and the application of weightage of 85% to the marks of API alone is
accepted with absolute marks under personal interview added to it, the noncounting of marks for their teaching experience in the Holy Cross College is
not in accordance with law despite the petitioners fulfilling the criteria
prescribed under sub-clauses (a) to (f) of Clause 10.0 of the UGC Regulations,
2018.
4.
This Court proceeds to answer the first issue at the outset as the
answer thereto would be relevant for dealing with the second issue raised by
the writ petitioners. The relevant documents on which learned counsel for the
petitioners and the respondents-TPSC, the respondents-State and the private
respondents have relied upon are the terms of the advertisement No.08/2022 at
Annexure-1. Apart from laying down the eligibility criteria of educational and
other qualifications, it prescribes that the selection procedure will be governed
by as per Annexure-A and Annexure-B of the notified schedule of the post of
Assistant Professor, Government (General) Degree Colleges. Annexure-A and
B, therefore, become relevant and are extracted hereunder:
ANNEXURE-A
Table: 3B
Criteria for Short-listing of candidates for Interview for the post of Assistant
Professor, in Colleges
Sl.
No.
1.
Academic Record
Graduation
80% and
above=21
2.
Post-Graduation
80% and
above=25
3.
M. Phil
4.
5.
Ph.D.
NET with JRF
NET
SLET/SET
Research Publications (2
marks for each research
publications published in
Peer-Reviewed or UGClisted Journals)
Teaching/Post Doctoral
Experience (2 marks for
one year each)#
Awards
International/National
Level (Awards given by
International
Organizations/Government
of India/Government of
India recognized National
Level Bodies
State-Level (Awards given
by State Government)
60% and
above=07
6.
Score
60% to less
than 80%
=19
60% to less
than 80%
=23
55% to 45%
to
less than less than
60%=16 55%=10
55% (50% in case of
SC/ST/OBC
(noncreamy layer/PWD) to
less than 60%=20
55% to less than 60%=05
# However, if the period of teaching/post-doctoral experience is less than one year
then the marks shall be reduced proportionately.
Note:-(A) (i) M.Phil + Ph.D ---Maximum
-25 Marks
(ii) JRF/NET/SET---Maximum
-10 Marks
(iii)In awards category-Maximum
-03 Marks
(B)
Number of candidates to be called for interview shall be
decided by the college.
(C)
Academic Score---------------84
Research Publication---------06
Teaching Experience---------10
--------------------------------------TOTAL---------100
(D) SLET/SET score shall be valid for appointment in respective State
Universities/Colleges/Institutions only.
ANNEXURE-B
Selection Procedure for the post of Assistant Professor in Government (General)
Degree Colleges, as per latest UGC Regulation:
1.
The overall selection procedure shall incorporate
transparent, objective and credible methodology of analysis of
the merits and credentials of the applicants based on the
weightage given to the performance of the different relevant
parameters and his/her performance on a grading system
proforma, based on Appendix-II, Table 3B of the UGC
Regulation, 2018 as amended.
2.
The Academic score as specified in Annexure-II, Table
3B for Colleges, shall be considered for short-listing of the
candidates (Maximum 5 candidates for each post notified) for
interview.
3.
TPSC shall constitute Selection Committee and fix
qualifying cut off mark (if any) for interview as per UGC
Guideline 2018 as amended time to time.
4.
As per State's New Recruitment Policy vide Notification
No.F.20(1)-GA(P&T)/18 dated 05-06-2018, maximum of 10%
weightage of total marks may be allocated for the Interview/
Personality Test for selection purpose. Accordingly 10 marks for
Interview/Personality test is fixed for the post of Asstt. Professor,
Government (General) Degree Colleges.
5.
Merit list will be formed by TPSC aggregating the 90% of
marks obtained by the candidate as per API score and interview
marks scored by the candidate and following other instruction in
the latest guideline.
6.
Five members, including three subject experts, shall
constitute the quorum of the Selection Committee.
5.
Emphasis is placed by the learned counsel for the petitioners upon
a notification dated 13.10.2022 which reads as under:
CORRIGENDUM
Ref:
Commission's Advt. No.08/2022 dated 24.03.22 for the post of
Assistant Professor, Group-A Gazetted, Govt. (General) Degree
Colleges under the Education (Higher) Department, Govt. of
Tripura.
In pursuance of the notification dated No.F.1(435)-DHE/Estt/
(G)/2019/226(04) dated 16-01-2021 the Commission is pleased to issue
corrigendum at para 5 of Annexure 'A' as Screening API score followed
by selection process of interview with a weightage of 15% and API
score weightage of 85% in adherence of New Recruitment Policy, 2018
and further modification in 2020 and UGC regulation, 2018. (enclo
Notification).
Others terms and conditions will remain unchanged.
For further information please visit www.tpsc.tripura.gov.in
Sd/- (13.10.2022)
(Smt. K. Debbarma)
Under Secretary
Tripura Public Service Commission.
6.
The aforesaid notification has to be read in conjunction with the
earlier notification of the Government of Tripura dated 16.01.2021 which reads
as under:
NOTIFICATION
The Recruitment Rule for the post of Assistant Professor,
Government (General) Degree Colleges has been notified vide
No.F.1(435)-DHE/Estt(G)/2019 dated 27.08.2020.
In partial modification of the said Notification issued by this
Department it is hereby notified that in the Point no.5 i.e. Method of
recruitments whether by direct recruits or by promotion or by
deputation/transfer and percentage of the vacancies to be filled by
various method appeared in the Schedule of the Recruitment Rules of
the said notification, the following shall be substituted in place of the
existing.
"100% by direct recruitment through TPSC.
Screening API score followed by selection process of interview with a
weightage of 15% and API score weightage of 85% in adherence of
New Recruitment Policy, 2018 and further modification in 2020 and
UGC Regulation, 2018.
Selection process is enclosed as Annexure-A".
This is issued with the concurrence of GA(P&T) Department
vide their U.O. No.190/GA(P&T)/21 dated 13.01.2021.
Rest of the contents of the said Notification and Schedule shall
remain unchanged.
By order and in the name of the Governor
Sd/-(16.01.2021)
Joint Secretary to the
Government of Tripura
Education (Higher) Department.
7.
Rival submissions have been made on the proposition as to
whether these two notifications if read together would mean granting of
weightage of 85% to API score and 15% in personal interview or not. The
answer thereto at the first blush lies in reading Clause-4 of Annexure-B quoted
above with Annexure-A which lays down the criteria for short-listing of
candidates for interview for the post of Assistant Professor in colleges. Out of
100 marks, 85% marks is allotted to API score and 15 is left to personal
interview. A combined reading of the notification dated 16.01.2021 and
13.10.2022 along with Annexure-B and A which are to be read with the terms
of the advertisement No.08/2022 do leave no room of doubt that while out of
total marks, 15 marks are allotted to interview while in computing the API
score out of total marks obtained under the API category 85% weightage is
only to be given. This is a formula which has been devised by the Education
(Higher) Department as per the State's New Recruitment Policy vide
notification dated 05.06.2018 and followed by the TPSC as per its
Corrigendum dated 13.10.2022 with the only difference that the interview
marks would be 15 instead of 10.
8.
Laying down of a formula in any case for such recruitment
process lies in the domain of the administrative body or experts such as, the
Public Service Commission. The Court does not have the wherewithal to
substitute a formula devised by an expert body with its own, as any such
attempt would not be foolproof and vulnerable to various shortcomings in its
application which the Court is not in a position to deal with. But apart from that
if the application of the formula has been made in a non-discriminatory
transparent manner to all the candidates, the Court would be loath to interfere
in the matter which is in the domain of the expert body. Apart from the above,
Table 3B in itself indicates that weightage has been given on several categories
such as, of the academic record perhaps for the reason that academic scores
awarded by different Examination Boards and Universities cannot be said to be
standardized across the country. It is the experience that some Examination
Boards or Universities award higher percentage of marks to its students while
some are more conservative in evaluation of papers. As such, in a criteria for
evaluation by the Public Service Commission for recruitment to the post of
Assistant Professor, Professor, Associate Professor in different colleges under
the State, the Government Department and TPSC have in their wisdom
consciously chosen to give a weightage criteria to the total API marks scored.
The same logic or reasoning would not apply to counting of the marks of
interview which are either 10% or 15% in such recruitment exercise. If
weightage of 15% is extended to even the maximum personal interview marks
in such recruitment exercise which is 15 in this case, the whole purpose of
personal interview would be defeated as 15% of even 15 marks could at best be
2.25. This could hardly be an evaluation of the personality of the candidate
appearing. Though this issue was also touched upon in the case of Jayanta
Dhar (supra) by the parties but since no specific pronouncements have been
made in this regard, this Court has, therefore, felt it necessary to deal with the
instant legal issue posed by the petitioners herein. For the aforesaid reasons,
this Court is, therefore, satisfied that on a construction of the terms of the
advertisement, Table 3B at Annexure-A, the notification dated 16.01.2021 read
with 13.10.2022, the formula devised by the Education (Higher) Department
and the TPSC for evaluation of the API score, 85% of weightage is to be given
whereas the marks scored in the personal interview has to be added in absolute
terms. The first question posed at the outset is, therefore, answered in the
following manner and against the petitioners.
9.
Coming to the second issue at hand, both the petitioners have
relied upon the certificates or letters issued by their employer to contend that
they fulfill the criteria prescribed under sub-clauses (a) to (f) of Clause 10.0 of
the UGC Regulations, 2018 for counting the teaching experience for the term
they have spent in the same Holy Cross College.
Petitioner Dr. Sandeep Roy Sarkar in the first writ petition has on
his part relied upon a notice dated 25.01.2018 at Annexure-5, the letter of
appointment dated 01.07.2021 at Annexure-6, a pay slip for the month of July,
2021 at Annexure-7, and an experience certificate dated 25.04.2022 issued by
the Principal, Holy Cross College at Annexure-8, to buttress this point.
Petitioner Dr. Shankha Subhra Bhadra in the second writ petition
has relied upon similar certificates and appointment letter issued by the same
Holy Cross College such as, the appointment letter dated 25.06.2013 at
Annexure-5, an experience certificate dated 28.04.2022 issued by the Principal,
Holy Cross College at Annexure-6, Pay slips for the month of July, 2022 to
September, 2022 at Annexure-8 and a certificate of appreciation dated
24.02.2021 issued by the Department of Business Administration, Assam
University, Silchar at Annexure-9.
10.
The computation of API scores in both the cases prepared by the
TPSC have been annexed to the writ petitions at Annexures-9 & 10
respectively. The footnote thereunder conveys that marks for teaching
experience in some cases have not been allotted because the documents
submitted/attached by the candidates do not fulfill conditions stipulated in
Clause 10.0 [sub-clauses (a) to (f)] of the UGC Regulations, 2018. Apart from
that the notes at the bottom also convey that only awards that have been
conferred by the International/National Level (Awards given by International
Organizations)/ Government of India/Government of India recognized National
Level Bodies and State Level awards have been considered for awarding marks
in that category.
11.
In the case of the petitioner No.1 Dr. Sandeep Roy Sarkar, the first
letter dated 25.01.2018 at Annexure-5 does not in explicit terms satisfy the
conditions as are prescribed under sub-clauses (a) to (f) of the Clause 10.0 of
the UGC Regulations, 2018 and in particular, paragraphs-(i), (ii) and (iii) of
sub-clause (f) of the UGC Regulations, 2018. Annexure-6 is dated 01.07.2021
which is shown as letter of appointment. If this is considered to be the letter of
appointment, then there cannot be any question of having 5(five) years of
teaching experience to claim API score of 10 for teaching experience since the
cutoff date for submission of the applications under Advertisement No.08/2022
was 04.05.2022 only. The pay slips are also starting from July, 2021. This
Court is, therefore, not in a position to disregard the marking of scores for
teaching experience in the case of the petitioner No.1 as the documents
submitted/attached by him do not fulfill the conditions stipulated in sub-clauses
(a) to (f) of Clause 10.0 of the UGC Regulations, 2018. This Court is not an
appellate body of the Public Service Commission. Therefore, cannot sit in
judgment as an expert on the evaluation of a document in exercise of the
powers of judicial review on the Wednesbury principles of reasonableness to
be applied in this context in writ jurisdiction.
12.
So far as the petitioner No.2 is concerned, there is apparent
infirmity in the appointment letter dated 25.06.2013, which shows his effective
date of appointment as 01.07.2013 and the experience certificate which shows
that he has been working from 01.07.2010 (Annexure-6) in the said Holy Cross
College in the Department of Commerce.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has sought to dispel this
discrepancy but reference to paragraph-9 of his writ petition would reinforce
the view that petitioner had set up his case as having served as Assistant
Professor as Regular Faculty in the Holy Cross College w.e.f. 01.07.2010 only
till date whereas the letter of appointment which is Annexure-5 is dated
25.06.2013. It is another matter that this letter does not also refer to the
particular subject in which he has been appointed as Assistant Professor in
Holy Cross College.
13.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the private
respondent No.6, has specifically drawn the attention of this Court to the
Brochure of the Holy Cross College at page-110 of WP(C) No.967 of 2022
which itself shows the date of commencement of the Department of Commerce
in that college from 2016. As such, when the documents submitted by a
candidate like the petitioner herein are not clear and candid and fail to fulfill
the terms of the advertisement read with the sub-clauses (a) to (f) of Clause
10.0 of the UGC Regulations, 2018, the decision of the expert Scrutiny
Committee, which is the part of Annexure-10 at pages-47-48 of the instant writ
petition [WP(C) No.967 of 2022], is not liable to be interfered in writ
jurisdiction.
14.
For the same reasoning as recorded hereinabove in the case of the
petitioner Dr. Sandeep Roy Sarkar, this Court would be loath to interfere in the
matter lying in the domain of experts in the matter of evaluation of API scores
and particularly, in matters of teaching experience of the Assistant Professors.
On the application of Wednesbury principles of reasonableness and on
consideration of the relevant documents submitted by the petitioner in support
of his teaching experience, this Court is not in a position to reach to a
conclusion that the decision of the Scrutiny Committee is irrational and that no
reasonable person acting thereupon could have reached to such a conclusion.
The principles of Wednesbury reasonableness as are well settled and referred
to in the case of Tata Cellular vrs. Union of India reported in (1994) 6 SCC
651, paragraphs-74, 77, 80 and 81 are being extracted hereunder:
"74.
Judicial review is concerned with reviewing not the merits of the
decision in support of which the application for judicial review is made,
but the decision-making process itself.
xxx
77.
xxx
xxx
The duty of the court is to confine itself to the question of
legality. Its concern should be:
1. Whether a decision-making authority exceeded its powers?
2. Committed an error of law,
3. Committed a breach of the rules of natural justice,
4. Reached a decision which no reasonable tribunal would have
reached or,
5. Abused its powers.
Therefore, it is not for the court to determine whether a particular
policy or particular decision taken in the fulfilment of that policy is fair.
It is only concerned with the manner in which those decisions have been
taken. The extent of the duty to act fairly will vary from case to case.
Shortly put, the grounds upon which an administrative action is subject
to control by judicial review can be classified as under:
(i) Illegality : This means the decision-maker must understand
correctly the law that regulates his decision-making power and
must give effect to it.
(ii) Irrationality, namely, Wednesbury unreasonableness.
(iii) Procedural impropriety.
The above are only the broad grounds but it does not rule out
addition of further grounds in course of time. As a matter of fact,
in R. v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex Brind [(1991) 1
AC 696] , Lord Diplock refers specifically to one development, namely,
the possible recognition of the principle of proportionality. In all these
cases the test to be adopted is that the court should, “consider whether
something has gone wrong of a nature and degree which requires its
intervention”.
xxx
80.
xxx
xxx
At this stage, The Supreme Court Practice, 1993, Vol. 1, pp.
849-850, may be quoted:
“4. Wednesbury principle.— A decision of a public authority
will be liable to be quashed or otherwise dealt with by an appropriate
order in judicial review proceedings where the court concludes that the
decision is such that no authority properly directing itself on the
relevant law and acting reasonably could have reached it. (Associated
Provincial Picture Houses Ltd. v. Wednesbury Corpn. [(1948) 1 KB
223 : (1947) 2 All ER 680] , per Lord Greene, M.R.)”
81.
Two other facets of irrationality may be mentioned.
(1) It is open to the court to review the decision-maker's
evaluation of the facts. The court will intervene where the facts taken as
a whole could not logically warrant the conclusion of the decisionmaker. If the weight of facts pointing to one course of action is
overwhelming, then a decision the other way, cannot be upheld. Thus,
in Emma Hotels Ltd. v. Secretary of State for Environment [(1980) 41 P
& CR 255] , the Secretary of State referred to a number of factors which
led him to the conclusion that a non-resident's bar in a hotel was
operated in such a way that the bar was not an incident of the hotel use
for planning purposes, but constituted a separate use. The Divisional
Court analysed the factors which led the Secretary of State to that
conclusion and, having done so, set it aside. Donaldson, L.J. said that he
could not see on what basis the Secretary of State had reached his
conclusion.
(2) A decision would be regarded as unreasonable if it is
impartial and unequal in its operation as between different classes. On
this
basis
in R. v. Barnet
London
Borough
Council,
ex
p
Johnson [(1989) 88 LGR 73] the condition imposed by a local authority
prohibiting participation by those affiliated with political parties at
events to be held in the authority's parks was struck down."
15.
Reliance is also placed on a decision of the Apex Court in the case
of Tajvir Singh Sodhi & Ors Vs State of Jammu & Kashmir & Ors, reported
in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 344 (Paragraphs 64 to 69) on the scope of judicial
interference in decisions of expert recruitment bodies like Public Service
Commissions.
16.
The second writ petitioner Dr. Shankha Subhra Bhadra has relied
upon a certificate of appreciation furnished by the Workshop Patron and Head,
Department of Business Administration, Assam University, Silchar dated
24.02.2011. However, the criteria laid down for evaluation of API score under
Table 3B (Annexure-A) clearly provides that such 3 marks could be awarded
for International/National Level (Awards given by International Organizations/
Government of India/Government of India recognized National Level Bodies
and not for certificate of appreciation for participating in a Group Discussion
like the one in which the petitioner has participated i.e. dated 24.02.2011 at
Annexure-9. The above plea also fails to satisfy the requirement for counting of
API score on that criteria as also taken note of by the Screening Committee at
the bottom of the footnote of the API scores notified on 15.10.2022 for all such
candidates who appeared for the Commerce subject (Annexure-10, dated
15.10.2022).
17.
Since the second plea of the petitioners examined above also do
not make out a case for interference in the evaluation of API score so far as
teaching experience is concerned, the comparative merit list prepared by the
TPSC for the purposes of recruitment to the two subjects with which these two
writ petitioners are concerned, i.e. Human Physiology and Commerce cannot
be said to suffer from any illegality, arbitrariness or discrimination vis-à-vis the
petitioners and the private respondents.
18.
As such, on a totality of the facts and circumstances noted above,
the discussions, the legal propositions raised and answered and the reasons
recorded hereinabove, this Court does not find any merit in these two writ
petitions. They are accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
2023.08.08
PULAK BANIK Date:
17:17:17 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review