Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.190 of 2023
Dr. Sandip Saha
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
….Respondent(s)
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment and Order (Oral)
03/04/2023
By means of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the selection of respondent no.5 in the post of Assistant
Professor(UR) in Physical Education.
2.
Heard Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for
respondents-TPSC and Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for
respondents-State.
3.
Having
taken into consideration the submission of Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the petitioner, it is clear that the
petitioner substantially challenged the methodology adopted by the
Selection Committee. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that API marks of the petitioner if added, then, the petitioner would have
been selected.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on the corrigendum
dated 13.10.2022 which was issued in pursuance of notification dated
16.01.2021 issued by the Tripura Public Service Commission (for short,
TPSC) wherein the prescribed methodology is as under:
“100% by direct recruitment through TPSC.
Screening API score followed by selection process of interview
with a weightage of 15% and API score weightage of 85% in adherence
of New Recruitment Policy, 2018 and further modification in 2020 and
UGC Regulation, 2018”. (Annexure-2 to the writ petition).
It is the contention of the petitioner that if 15 percent marks is
added with his API score, then, his API score would be 83.
5.
In response to the aforesaid submissions advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner, Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the
respondents-TPSC would contend that out of total 100 marks 85 percent
i.e. 85 marks are meant for awarding API score which include the
weightage mark of 15 percent as per notification dated 13.10.2022
(Annexure-2 to the writ petition) and the balance 15 percent i.e. 15 marks
out of 100 is kept for interview.
6.
Mr. Datta, learned counsel has placed before this Court the overall
merit list of the candidates, which may be reproduced here-in-below, for
convenience:
Sl
No.
Name of
candidate
Father’s Name
Category
Roll No
API
85%
of
API
Score
1.
DR. ADITYA
KUMAR
DAS
SANDIP
SAHA
LT SUKUMAR
DAS
UR
PHY_EDU
-082201
81.00
SUBHASH
CHANDRA
SAHA
KALI PRASAD
SINGH
MOHAMMAD
MUSTAFA
UR
PHY_EDU
-082215
UR
PHY_EDU
-082204
PHY_EDU
-082207
2.
3.
JITENDRA
SINGH
4.
MOHAMMAD
GULAM
SABIR
UR
Total
Marks
obtained
(Out of
100)
Remarks/Age
68.85
Marks
obtained
in
Interview
(Out of
15)
81.85
Recommended
83.00
70.55
80.55
Wait List
38-07-24
83.00
70.55
80.55
32-09-29
81.00
68.85
77.85
5.
MANAS DAS
6.
PRALOY
KANTI
SARKAR
TIPU
SARKAR
BECON
DEBBARMA
7.
8.
DHIRENDRA
KUMAR DAS
SRI NITAI LAL
SARKAR
SC
PHY_EDU
-082206
PHY_EDU
-082210
70.00
59.50
66.50
Recommended
57.00
48.45
60.45
Wait List
ARUN SARKAR
SC
PHY_EDU
-082214
PHY_EDU
-082203
56.00
47.60
58.60
UTTAM
KUMAR
DEBBARMA
HARENDRA
CHANDRA
SARKAR
ST
50.00
42.50
56.50
SC
PHY_EDU
-082212
54.00
45.90
55.90
ST
PHY_EDU
-082205
50.00
42.50
55.50
SC
9.
SANJOY
SARKAR
10.
LALHMANG
-AIHSANGA
SAILO
BIAKCHUNGNUNGA
SAILO
11.
BARIS
RIANG
BHUSHAN
RIANG
ST
PHY_EDU
-082202
56.00
47.60
54.60
12.
PARIMAL
DEBBARMA
LATE MANGAL
DEBBARMA
ST
PHY_EDU
-082208
50.00
42.50
49.50
7.
Recommended
Wait List
In the instant case, the API score of respondent no.5 is 81.00 after
adding 15 percent weightage marks. Thereafter, 85% of total API score of
81.00 obtained by respondent no.5 is taken into account and it comes to
68.85.
8.
It is further contended that the respondent no.5 obtained 13 marks
in interview out of 15 marks and in total he obtained 81.85 marks. The
API score of the petitioner is 83.00 after adding 15 percent of the
weightage marks.
Accordingly, 85% of the API score, if taken into account then, it
comes to 70.55. But, the petitioner obtained 10 marks in interview out of
15 marks and in total he obtained 80.55 (70.55+10).
Since, in total, the respondent no.5 obtained higher marks (81.85)
than that of the petitioner, the name of respondent no. 5 has been
recommended by the TPSC and the name of the petitioner is placed as
wait list candidate at serial no.2.
9.
In view of this, in the opinion of this Court, it is settled that the
Court in exercise of its discretionary and extra-ordinary power of judicial
review will not enter into the merits of the selection process and not to sit
as an appellate authority. The Selection Committee is constituted by the
experts on the subject and they are the best persons to evaluate the fittest
candidate for a particular post, on which the Court has no such expertise.
When all the parameters for selection of a candidate in a particular post
are taken into account, then, the Court should usually refrain itself from
interfering with such selection and evaluation of the merits of the
candidates. The selection of a best possible candidate is the solemn duty
of the Selection Committee and it is absolutely within its domain.
(emphasis supplied)
10.
Unless it is the established case of bias or favouritism or nepotism,
or suffers from patent material irregularities in the constitution of the
committee or its procedure vitiates the selection that offends Article 14
and Article 16 of Constitution of India, the Court will not interfere with
the fair exercise done by the Selection Committee in selecting the
fittest/best candidates.
(emphasis supplied)
11.
In this context, I may gainfully refer to a very recent case, Tajvir
Singh Sodhi & Ors. vs. The State of Jammu and Kashmir & Ors.
decided on 28th March, 2023 in Civil Appeal Nos.2164-2172 of 2023,
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court while dealing with almost a similar
and identical question relying its earlier judgments has held thus:
“Selection Process for Public Employment: Interference by Courts:
12. Before proceeding further, it is necessary to preface our judgment
with the view that Courts in India generally avoid interfering in the
selection process of public employment, recognising the importance of
maintaining the autonomy and integrity of the selection process. The
Courts recognise that the process of selection involves a high degree of
expertise and discretion and that it is not appropriate for Courts to
substitute their judgment for that of a selection committee. It would be
indeed, treading on thin ice for us if we were to venture into reviewing the
decision of experts who form a part of a selection board. The law on the
scope and extent of judicial review of a selection process and results
thereof, may be understood on consideration of the following case law:
i) In Dalpat Abasaheb Solunke vs. Dr. B.S. Mahajan, AIR 1990 SC 434,
this Court clarified the scope of judicial review of a selection process, in
the following words:
"9...It is needless to emphasise that it is not the function of the court to
hear appeals over the decisions of the selection committees and to
scrutinise the relative merits of the candidates. Whether the candidate is
fit for a particular post or not has to be decided by the duly constituted
selection committee which has the expertise on the subject. The court has
no such expertise. The decision of the selection committee can be
interfered with only on limited grounds, such as illegality or patent
material irregularity in the constitution of the committee or its procedure
vitiating the selection, or proved malafides affecting the selection etc…..”
ii) In a similar vein, in Secy. (Health) Deptt. Of Health & F.W. vs. Dr.
Anita Puri, (1996) 6 SCC 282, this Court observed as under as regards
the sanctity of a selection process and the grounds on which the results
thereof may be interfered with:
"9. ... It is too well settled that when a selection is made by an expert body
like the Public Service Commission which is also advised by experts
having technical experience and high academic qualification in the field
for which the selection is to be made, the courts should be slow to
interfere with the opinion expressed by experts unless allegations of mala
fide are made and established. It would be prudent and safe for the courts
to leave the decisions on such matters to the experts who are more
familiar with the problems they face than the courts. If the expert body
considers suitability of a candidate for a specified post after giving due
consideration to all the relevant factors, then the court should not
ordinarily interfere with such selection and evaluation…….”
iii) This position was reiterated by this Court in M. V. Thimmaiah vs.
Union Public Service Commission, (2008) 2 SCC 119, in the following
words:
“21. Now, comes the question with regard to the selection of the
candidates. Normally, the recommendations of the Selection Committee
cannot be challenged except on the ground of mala fides or serious
violation of the statutory rules. The courts cannot sit as an Appellate
Authority to examine the recommendations of the Selection Committee
like the court of appeal. This discretion has been given to the Selection
Committee only and courts rarely sit as a court of appeal to examine the
selection of the candidates nor is the business of the court to examine
each candidate and record its opinion...
xxx
30. We fail to understand how the Tribunal can sit as an Appellate
Authority to call for the personal records and constitute Selection
Committee to undertake this exercise. This power is not given to the
Tribunal and it should be clearly understood that the assessment of the
Selection Committee is not subject to appeal either before the Tribunal or
by the courts. One has to give credit to the Selection Committee for
making their assessment and it is not subject to appeal. Taking the overall
view of ACRs of the candidates, one may be held to be very good and
another may be held to be good. If this type of interference is permitted
then it would virtually amount that the Tribunals and the High Courts
have started sitting as Selection Committee or act as an Appellate
Authority over the selection. It is not their domain, it should be clearly
understood, as has been clearly held by this Court in a number of
decisions…..”
iv) Om Prakash Poplai and Rajesh Kumar Maheshwari vs. Delhi Stock
Exchange Association Ltd., (1994) 2 SCC 117, was a case where an
appeal was filed before this Court challenging the selection of members to
the Delhi Stock Exchange on the ground that the Selection Committee
formed for the aforesaid purpose, arbitrarily favoured some candidates
and was thus, against Article 14. This Court rejected the allegation of
favouritism and bias by holding as under:
“5. …the selection of members by the Expert Committee had to be done
on the basis of an objective criteria taking into consideration experience,
professional qualifications and similar related factors. In the present
cases, we find that certain percentage of marks were allocated for each of
these factors, namely, educational qualifications, experience, financial
background and knowledge of the relevant laws and procedures
pertaining to public issues etc. Of the total marks allocated only 20 per
cent were reserved for interviews. Therefore, the process of selection by
the Expert Committee was not left entirely to the sweet-will of the
members of the Committee. The area of play was limited to 20 per cent
and having regard to the fact that the members of the Expert Committee
comprised of two members nominated by the Central Government it is
difficult to accept the contention that they acted in an unreasonable or
arbitrary fashion…...”
12.1. Thus, the inexorable conclusion that can be drawn is that it is not
within the domain of the Courts, exercising the power of judicial review,
to enter into the merits of a selection process, a task which is the
prerogative of and is within the expert domain of a Selection Committee,
subject of course to a caveat that if there are proven allegations of
malfeasance or violations of statutory rules, only in such cases of inherent
arbitrariness, can the Courts intervene.”
12.
In the light of aforesaid settled principles discussed in Tajvir Singh
Sodhi(supra), if the present case is considered, then, it comes to light that
the petitioner herein neither has alleged any bias or favouritism or mala
fide against the members of the Selection Committee nor has alleged any
material irregularity in the constitution of the Selection Committee.
13.
This Court does not find any procedural defects in the
methodology adopted by the Selection Committee in selecting the best
candidate i.e. respondent no.5 in the post of Assistant Professor (Physical
Education). The Selection Committee recommended the name of
respondent no.5 as he obtained more marks than that of the petitioner.
14.
In the light of above observation and discussions, the present writ
petition is dismissed being devoid of merit. However, there shall be no
order as to costs.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review