Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 723 of 2022
1. Dr. Nibedita Talapatra,
daughter of Sri Tapan Talapatra, wife of Dr. Laxman Bhattacharjee,
resident of Gour Gobinda Ashram Para, Hapania, near TMC College,
PIN- 799014, District- West Tripura
2. Dr. Ashis Das,
son of late Nani Gopal Das, resident of Bagma, P.S. R.K. Pur, Udaipur,
PIN- 799114, District- Gomati, Tripura
3. Dr. Sahini Debbarma,
daughter of late Manoranjan Debbarma, resident of Khakchang Kami, near
Kali Mandir, P.O. Barkathalia-799211, P.S. Sidhai, District- West Tripura
4. Dr. Arpan Chakma,
son of Sri Puspa Ranjan Chakma, resident of Netajinagar, P.O. Kanchanpur799270, P.S. Kanchanpur, District- North Tripura
…..Petitioners
-VERSUS1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Health & Family Welfare, Government of Tripura, New
Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, PIN-799010, P.S. New
Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
2. The Director of Medical Education, at 2nd floor Building, Government
of Tripura, Bidurkarta Chowmuhani, Agartala-799001, West Tripura
3. The Director of Health Services, Government of Tripura, P.N. Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Kunjaban, Agartala, PIN-799006, West Tripura
4. The Principal, Agartala Government Medical College, Government of
Tripura, P.O. Kunjaban-799006, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala, West
Tripura
5. The Medical Superintendent & Head of Department, AGMC & GBP
Hospital, Government of Tripura, P.O. Kunjaban-799006, P.S. New Capital
Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
6. National Medical Commission, represented by its Secretary, Pocket-14,
Sector-8, Dwarka, Phase-1, New Delhi-110077
7. Union of India, represented by the Deputy Secretary, Post Graduate
Medical Education Board, National Medical Commission, Pocket-14, Sector-8,
Dwarka, Phase-1, New Delhi-110077
….Respondents
Page 2
For the Petitioner (s )
:
For Respondent (s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
Date of hearing delivery of
judgment & order
:
22.11.2022
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners being doctors
serving in rural areas of the State of Tripura. The State Medical authorities
selected them to pursue Post Graduate course in the State Medical College.
While selecting and recommending the names of the petitioners, the
respondents-State had determined the merits of the petitioners on the basis
of the marks obtained by them in NEET (PG) examination and All India
ranking with further addition of incentive marks applicable to in-service
candidates serving in rural areas. Incentive marks are awarded at the rate of
10% for each year service in remote/rural/difficult areas maximum upto
30% of marks obtained in NEET (PG) examination. The petitioners had
taken admission after being duly recommended, and at present all of them
are pursuing their courses.
All on a sudden, the petitioners received a memo dated 17.08.2022
(Annexure 18 to the writ petition) wherein it was communicated that their
admission had been cancelled by the Principal of AGMC & GBP hospital,
Agartala (respondent no. 4 herein). This cancellation of admission of the
Page 3
petitioners was caused pursuant to the letter vide no. F.NMC/MCI-23(1)
(115)/ 2022/ PG/027210, dated 22.07.2022 issued by the “National
Medical Commission” (for short, “NMC”). In the said communication, the
NMC has observed thus:“In order to be eligible for admission to Post Graduate Course for
an academic year, it shall be necessary for a candidate to obtain minimum
of marks at 50th percentile in the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test
for Post Graduate courses held for the said academic year. However, in
respect of candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and
Other Backward Classes, the minimum marks shall be at 40th percentile. In
respect of candidates with Benchmark disabilities specified under the
Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, the minimum marks shall be
at 45th percentile for General Category and 40th percentile for SC/ST/OBC.
The percentile shall be determined on the basis of highest marks secured in
the All India Common merit list in National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test
held for post graduate courses.
Provided when sufficient number of candidates in the respective
categories fail to secure minimum marks as prescribed in National
Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test held for any academic year for admission to
Postgraduate Courses, the Central Government in consultation with
Medical Council of India may at its discretion lower the minimum marks
required for admission to Post Graduate Course for candidates belonging
Page 4
to respective categories and marks so lowered by the Central Government
shall be applicable for the academic year only”.
In the said communication, the NMC had referred to Clause 9(3) and
Clause 9(6) of “Medical Council of India Post Graduate Medical Education
Regulations, 2000, (as amended upto May, 2018)” (for short, “NMC
Regulations, 2000”. Just after receipt of the said memo cancelling their
admission, the petitioners have approached this court by way of filing the
present writ petition and the court as an interim measure allowed the
petitioners to pursue their courses till disposal of the writ petition. Today,
the matter has been heard at the admission stage on consent of learned
counsel appearing for the parties to the lis.
2.
I have heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee and Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners. Also heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing
for the respondents- Union of India (respondents no. 6 and 7), and Mr. D.
Bhattacharjee, learned GA assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel
appearing for respondents- State ( respondents no. 1 to 5).
3.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has submitted that while
cancelling the admission of the petitioners in PG courses, the NMC had
misinterpreted and misconstrued the “NMC Regulations, 2000”, as
amended upto 2018. It is the further contention of Mr. Roy Barman,
learned senior counsel that the respondents no. 6 and 7 while asking the
Page 5
State-respondents to cancel the admission of the petitioners vide
communication dated 22.07.2022, did neither take care of the “NMC
Regulations, 2000” nor the State guidelines which was duly notified under
“Educational
Notification”
vide
no.
F.5(6)-DME/PG
(MD)/MS/
Counselling/2021/6381, dated 20.11.2021. The said notification dated
20.11.2021 deals with “The Information Bulletin with consisting
Eligibility, Guideline, Registration, Fees, Security Deposit for Round 2,
Steps of Counselling, Flow Chart, Applicable Bonds etc. in connection
with Tripura State NEET PG (MD/MS/Post MBBS Diploma) 2021”
(here-in-after referred to as Educational Notification, 2021). According to
learned senior counsel, the competent authorities of the State have
correctly added the incentive marks upto 30% for the first 3 years of their
service in rural areas as qualifying marks in determining their respective
merits. It is submitted that said practice has been in vogue in the State of
Tripura for the last many years as stated in para 13 of the affidavit filed by
the petitioners by way of rejoinder. Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior
counsel has relied upon a judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in State
of Uttar Pradesh and others vs. Dinesh Singh Chauhan, reported in
(2016) 9 SCC 749 to justify the addition of incentive marks in determining
the rank/merit of a candidate in the common merit list and admission
thereof in PG courses.
Page 6
4.
On the other hand, Mr. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing for
respondents no.6 and 7 has opposed the aforesaid submission in
vehemence. Learned Dy. SGI has submitted that to pursue PG course a
candidate must first secure the minimum qualifying marks. In other words,
it is the contention of learned Dy. SGI that incentive marks is to be added
only after a candidate secures the minimum qualifying marks as provided
under Clause 9(3) read with Clause 9(6) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000”.
Mr. Majumder, has drawn my attention to the chart as encrypted in the
counter affidavit where the marks secured by the petitioners in NEET and
the respective qualifying marks required to be obtained by each of the
petitioners to get admission in PG courses are mentioned, which are
extracted here-in-below, for convenience, in extenso:
“
Name
Petitioner No. 1 – Dr. Nibedita Talapatra
Category Marks Obtained Marks Required
in NEET-PG-2021 after lowering of
percentile on
12.03.2021
General
Petitioner No. 2 – Dr. Ashis Das
SC
Petitioner No. 3 – Dr. Sahini Debbarma
ST
Petitioner No. 4 – Dr. Arpan Chakma
ST
”
Mr. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI has given much emphasis on
paragraphs 41, 42 and 43 of the counter affidavit to support his submission,
which are reproduced here-in-below:
“41. That, it is submitted that proviso to Regulation 9(4) of the aforesaid Regulations
has to be read inconsonance with Regulation 9(3) &Regulation 9(6) which categorically
provide that no candidate who has failed to obtain minimum eligibility marks in NEETPG so as to be declared qualified in the first instance, can be counselled / admitted in
Page 7
any postgraduate medical course in the Country. A purposive construction of the
aforesaid provisions shall necessarily lead to the conclusion that an in-service candidate
in his respective category must firstly obtain the minimum eligibility marks in NEET-PG
as provided under Regulation 9(3) read with Regulation 9(6), whereafter as he is eligible
for counseling, he may be granted benefit of incentive of marks for each year of service
in remote and / or difficult areas or rural areas upto a maximum of 30% of marks
obtained in NEET-PG Examination.
42. That, it is pertinent to mention here that the benefit of the proviso to Regulation
9(4) of the aforesaid Regulations shall only be available to such in-service candidates
who have secured the minimum marks at the respective percentiles as provided in
Regulation 9(3) read with Regulation 9(6) and have qualified the NEET-PG Test. The
benefit of the proviso to Regulation 9(4) of the aforesaid Regulations shall be provided
to such in-service candidates who have qualified the NEET-PG Test in order to determine
their inter-se merit towards counseling for admission to various postgraduate courses.
43. That, it is submitted that the weightage in marks as an incentive for each year of
service in remote and / or difficult areas or rural areas could be granted to the deserving
in-service candidates only after they have secured the minimum of marks at the
respective percentiles as provided under Regulation 9(3) read with Regulation 9(6) and
cannot be provided in order to qualify the NEET-PG Test.”
Learned Dy. SGI has placed reliance upon the decisions of the Apex
Court in Tamil Nadu Medical Officers Association and others vs. Union
of India and others, reported in (2021) 6 SCC 568 and State of M.P. and
others vs. Gopal D. Tirthani and others, reported in (2003) 7 SCC 83.
5.
Participating in the deliberations, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned GA has
submitted that State has taken care of both the “NMC Regulations, 2000”
as well as State guideline under notification dated 20.11.2021. Ld. G.A.
further submits that according to NMC a candidate must secure qualifying
marks first, and thereafter, incentive marks will be added. In view of the
NMC clarification on the issue followed by instruction
under
communication dated 22.07.2022, the State-respondents had cancelled the
admission of the petitioners.
6.
I have considered the respective submissions of the learned counsel
appearing for the parties on the core issues involved in the writ petition.
Page 8
7.
Before I delve into the merits of the case, it would be gainful to
mention the relevant clauses relating to the core issues raised by the
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the contesting parties.
8.
At the outset, Clause 9(3), 9(4) and 9(6) of the “NMC Regulations
Act, 2000”, may be reproduced here-in-below, in verbatim:
“9 (3). In order to be eligible for admission to Postgraduate Course for an academic
year, it shall be necessary for a candidate to obtain minimum of marks at 50th
percentile in the ‘National Eligibility-Cum-Entrance Test for Postgraduate courses’ held
for the said academic year.However, in respect of candidates belonging to Scheduled
Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and Other Backward Classes, the minimum marks shall be at
40th percentile. In respect of candidates with benchmark disabilities specified under
the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, the minimum marks shall be at 45th
percentile for General Category and 40th percentile for SC/ST/OBC. The percentile
shall be determined on the basis of highest marks secured in the All India Common
merit list in National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test for Postgraduate courses.
Provided when sufficient number of candidates in the respective categories fail to
secure minimum marks as prescribed in National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test held for
any academic year for admission to Postgraduate Courses, the Central Government in
consultation with Medical Council of India may at its discretion lower the minimum
marks required for admission to Post Graduate Course for candidates belonging to
respective categories and marks so lowered by the Central Government shall be
applicable for the academic year only.
9 (4). The reservation of seats in Medical Colleges/institutions for respective categories
shall be as per applicable laws prevailing in States/Union Territories. An all India merit
list as well as State-wise merit list of the eligible candidates shall be prepared on the
basis of the marks obtained in National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test and candidates
shall be admitted to Postgraduate Courses from the said merit lists only.
Provided that in determining the merit of candidates who are in service of
government/public authority, weightage in the marks may be given by the
Government/Competent Authority as an incentive upto 10% of the marks obtained for
each year of service in remote and/or difficult areas or Rural areas upto maximum of
30% of the marks obtained in National Eligibility-cum Entrance Test. The remote
and/or difficult areas or Rural areas shall be as notified by State
Government/Competent authority from time to time.
9 (6). No candidate who has failed to obtain the minimum eligibility marks as
prescribed in Sub-Clause (3) above shall be admitted to any Postgraduate courses in
the said academic year.”
Clause 9(11) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000”, is also relevant,
which reads as under:
Page 9
“9 (11). No authority / institution shall admit any candidate to any postgraduate
medicine course in contravention of the criteria / procedure as laid down by these
Regulations and / or in violation of the judgments passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in respect of admissions. Any candidate admitted in contravention / violation of
aforesaid shall be discharged by the Council forthwith. The authority / institution
which grants admission to any student in contravention / violation of the Regulations
and / or the judgements passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, shall also be liable to
face such action as may be prescribed by the Council, including surrender of seats
equivalent to the extent of such admission made from its sanctioned intake capacity
for the succeeding academic year / years.”
9.
Now, it is pertinent to extract the relevant provisions, as quoted in
the “Educational notification, 2021”.
Clause 1 relates to jurisdiction of University, which is “Tripura
University”. Eligibility criteria for the seat mentioned in clause-1 has been
dealt with in clause-2.1. Clause 2.1.(f), is relevant to the question raised in
this writ petition, which reads as under:
“2.1.(f). A candidate must get qualifying marks in NEET PG-2021 to participate in the
counseling. State in-service candidate must get such qualifying marks after adding
incentives of additional marks. Such addition of incentive marks will not be added in
regard of participating the council for Post MBBS Diploma seats.”
Clause 2.1.A. may be extracted hereunder:
“2.1.A. In-service candidates shall have to fulfil his/her Eligibility Ceiteria & have to
state the number of completed year of service in Rural/Difficult/Remote Areas as
determined by Appointing Authority/Director of Health Services, Govt. of Tripura with
relevant certificates to get the incentives of additional 10% marks per year of Rural/
Difficult/Remote service upto a maximum of 30% marks that he/she obtained in the
NEET PG 2021 for 3 years or more of service in Rural/Difficult/Remote Areas of
Tripura.
Provided that, in determining the merit of candidates who are in service of
Government Service, weightage in the marks will be given as an incentive upto 10% of
marks obtained for each year service in remote and/or difficult areas or Rural areas
upto maximum of 30% of marks obtained in NEET PG 2021 as additional marks to
determine his/her ultimate rank/merit in the Common Merit list of registered
candidates from which selection of candidates of PG courses will be done through
counseling as per merit (Common Merit List) and seat matrix.
The remote/difficult/rural areas shall be as notified by the State Government/
Competent authority from time to time.
For Post MBBS Diploma Courses (at IGM Hospital) such incentives will not be
applicable for in-service Doctors in determining his/her ultimate rank. (As for
sponsored/In-service earmarked seats).”
[Underlined for emphasis]
Page 10
Clause 2.1.B. reads as under:
“2.1.B. In-service candidates of Tripura Health Services to get the incentives for Inservice candidature must have the following eligibility A candidate must be a domicile of Tripura, and
A candidate must pass MBBS Degree from Medical College of Tripura or outside the
State of Tripura &
The candidate must possess No-Objection Certificate from the appointing authority
for appearing NEET PG 2021 from the appointing authority.
The candidate must possess service certificate denoting eligibility from the
appointing authority which would determine the ultimate merit/rank of the candidate
with applicable weightage in marks will not be applicable for an in-service candidate
for selection into post MBBS Diploma Seats.
Sponsorship criteria, study leave or other admissible leave, service bond and
discontinue bond, etc. will be applicable as per State Government Rules/guideline in
respective regard.”
Clause 7 deals with the Selection Process, which reads thus:
“7. Selection is purely on merit basis. It will be strictly on the marks obtained in the
NEET (PG) and All India Ranking and with adding incentives marks for In-service
candidates only irrespective of category as per guidelines. Selection after adding
additional marks as incentive to the NEET PG 2021 score obtained will be applicable
only for State Quota MD/MS seats of AGMC & TMC.”
Clause 3 deals with the „Tripura State Merit List of Candidates, which
reads as under:
“3. Tripura State Merit List of Candidates:3.1. Tripura State Merit List of Registered eligible NEET PG 2021 candidates shall be
prepared from the registered eligible NEET PG 2021 candidate who have registered
their name for Tripura State PG (MD/MS) Counselling 2021 with requisite fees with
relevant documents. The said Merit List will be prepared by NIC, Agartala, Tripura
from the All India Merit List (Ranking) supplied from Assistant Director General (ME),
directorate General of Health Services, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Govt. of
India, New Delhi.
There shall be a common merit list (adding incentives for only eligible In-Service
Candidates) indicating merit position and stating each caste category (ST,SC), EWS,
PWD categories as per information particulars registered by the candidate which will
be published in due course after registration for the counseling by the candidates gets
completed by the schedule date.
Schedule of the counseling (including “registration”, “choice filling”, “allotment result”
will be published shortly in due course.
Seat matrix also will be published shortly in due course.”
10.
One noticeable feature is that the “Educational notification, 2021”
notified by the Government of Tripura is only applicable to the two
Page 11
Medical Colleges of the State. It is not applicable for admission in any
other Medical colleges outside the State of Tripura.
11.
In the opinion of this court, the State Government has legislative
competence under Entry 25 of the concurrent list to frame necessary
guidelines or rules or regulations for accommodating the candidates
hailing from the State and to give weightage in the marks as incentive
for in-service doctors serving in rural areas and to prepare the State’s
own merit list. Moreso, proviso of sub-clause (4) under Clause 9 of “NMC
Regulations, 2000” (as amended upto May, 2018), clearly provides that
State government/competent authority is competent to notify the
remote/difficult/rural areas and in determining the merit of candidates who
are in service of government/public authority, weightage in the marks may
be given by the government/competent authority as an incentive at the rate
of 10% of the marks obtained in each year of service in remote/
difficult/rural areas upto maximum of 30% of marks obtained in NEET.
12.
In the light of Clause 9(4) of “NMC Regulations, 2000”, the State
has formulated its own schemes/guidelines for selection of in-service
candidates to pursue Post Graduate Medical courses. A close reading of
Clause 2.1.f and Clause 2.1.A. of the “Educational Notification, 2021”,
makes it aptly clear that qualifying marks would be determined after
adding incentive of additional marks. This further fortified is available
from the fact that such advantage of addition of incentive marks will not be
Page 12
in case of the candidates who want to pursue Post MBBS Diploma seats.
The intention of the State legislature reflected in Clause 2.1.f is further
clarified in the proviso of Clause 2.1.A, where it is legislated that in
determining the merit of candidates who are in service under the
government, weightage in the marks will be given as an incentive upto
10% of marks obtained for each year of services in remote and/or difficult
areas or rural areas upto a maximum of 30% of marks obtained in NEET
PG, 2021, as additional marks to determine his/her ultimate rank/merit in
the common merit list, and to prepare the final merit list. Thus, it is explicit
that Clause 2.1.f and Clause 2.1.A of the “Educational Notification, 2021”
as notified by the Government of Tripura including its proviso are pari
materia to clause 9(4) “NMC Regulations, 2000.”
13.
Sub-clause 11 of Clause 9 of “NMC Regulations, 2000”, clearly
stipulates that selection of a candidate must be in conformity with the
guidelines of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Tamil Nadu Medical Officers Association (supra) has clearly held that the
State guideline is applicable in the matter of admission of its candidates
against its State quota to pursue PG course in the Medical college of the
State. Furthermore, State‟s Educational Notification, 2021 and the
provisions made therein cannot be said to be repugnant of the Entry 25 of
the concurrent list which empowers the State governments to frame its own
Page 13
scheme for regulating admission for the in-service candidates willing to
pursue PG course in the State‟s Medical Colleges under State quota.
14.
Now, on conjoint reading of Clauses 2.1.(f), 2.1.A., 7 and Clause 3
of State’s “Educational Notification, 2021”, there cannot be any doubt to
hold that selection of a candidate to pursue PG course would be made on
the basis of the marks obtained in NEET PG and All India ranking
alongwith addition of incentive marks for in-service candidates serving in
rural/remote/difficult areas. In other words, the total marks of in-service
candidates serving in notified rural areas would be the total marks
obtained in NEET PG and All India ranking and the ultimate merit list or
the select list would be prepared after adding the weightage in the marks
as incentive at the rate of 10% for each year upto a maximum 3 years.
[[
15.
[Emphasis supplied]
]
Mr. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI has not disputed that the State
government has followed the said provisions and prepared the final merit
list after adding 10% marks for each year maximum upto 30%, but, it is the
only contention that State has not followed the clarifications contained in
“NMC Regulations, 2000”, as stated in paras 41, 42 and 43 of their counter
affidavit.
16.
It is clarified that the State has prepared the merit list of the
candidates willing to pursue PG courses in the Medical colleges under
State quota. In my opinion, while preparing such merit list the State
Page 14
government cannot deviate from its own guideline making provisions of
adding incentive marks for in-service candidates serving in rural areas for
the purpose of computing/awarding total marks to determine merits of the
candidates.
17.
Most noticeable feature is inclusion of the “proviso” under Clause
9(4) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000” qua the proviso under Clause 9.1.A
of State‟s “Educational Notification, 2021”. A “proviso” to main provision
curves out an exception from operation of main provision. However, in
many cases, a “proviso” can be substantive provision and acts as a saving
clause when such “proviso” will not be controlled by the Section. It is not a
separate or independent clause and it cannot be divorced from the main
provision/clause. In other words, the correct way to understand a “proviso”
would be to read it in the context of the main provision and not in isolation.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Tamil Nadu Medical Officers Association
(supra) has approved the State‟s competence in formulating its own
guideline considering the different factors prevailing in the State. While
interpreting Clause 9(4) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000”, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court held thus. [SCC p. 688, para 91]:“91. Clause 9(IV) of the 2000 Regulations stipulates entry into the postgraduate courses
from the two merit lists, one all India and the other that of the State. The same was the
scheme of Clause 9(IV) in its erstwhile form. The dispute in these proceedings, however,
is mainly on admission norms to postgraduate degree courses. If the State authorities
provide reservation for in-service doctors from within the State’s own merit list, our
view is that such an exercise would be relatable to the admission process and the same
would not be in breach of any prohibition flowing from the 2000 Regulations. This would
entail some form of variation of the merit list of the State, but we do not find any
prohibition under the 2000 Regulations against a State undertaking that exercise. Such
Page 15
step undertaken by the State would be relatable to the State’s legislative power derived
from Entry 25 of the Concurrent List and not covered by the 2000 Regulations. We do
not find any repugnancy with the 2000 Regulations if the State authorities create such a
distinct channel of entry.”
18.
The significance of incorporating the “proviso” under Sub-clause (4)
of Clause 9 of the “NMC Regulations, 2000” arose before the Hon‟ble
apex court for consideration. In the case of Dinesh Singh Chowhan
(supra), similar question arose for consideration and interpretation of
Clause 9(4) of “NMC Regulations, 2000”. At para 25.4, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has observed that:“25.4. Clause (IV) is the relevant provision. It provides for reservation of seats in medical
colleges/institutions for reserved categories as per applicable laws prevailing in
States/Union Territories. The reservation referred to in the opening part of this clause is,
obviously, with reference to reservation as per the constitutional scheme (for Scheduled
Caste, Scheduled Tribe or Other Backward Class Candidates); and not for the in-service
candidates or Medical Officers in service. It further stipulates that All India merit list as
well as State wise merit list of the eligible candidates shall be prepared on the basis of the
marks obtained in the NEET and the admission to Post Graduate Courses in the concerned
State shall be as per the merit list only. Thus, it is a provision mandating admission of
candidates strictly as per the merit list of eligible candidates for the respective medical
courses in the State. This provision, however, contains a proviso. It predicates that in
determining the merit of candidates who are in-service of Government or a public
Authority, weightage in the marks may be given by the Government/Competent
Authority as an incentive at the rate of 10% of the marks obtained for each year of
service in specified remote or difficult areas of the State upto the maximum of 30% of
the marks obtained in NEET. This provision even if read liberally does not provide for
reservation for in-service candidates, but only of giving a weightage in the form of
incentive marks as specified to the class of in- service candidates (who have served in
notified remote and difficult areas in the State).”
19.
In practical scenario, it is noticed that a good number of doctors are
not happy with their posting in rural/remote/difficult areas. It is necessary
to be noted herein that in the original “Medical Council of India
Regulation, 2000”, this “proviso” was not found. It was incorporated in
MCI Regulation, 2000 (now known as “NMC Regulation”) by gazettee
Page 16
notification published on 17.11.2009 after Clause 9(2)(d). In the opinion of
this court, by way of incorporating this “proviso” in Clause 9(4) of “NMC
Regulations, 2000”, the law-makers intended to achieve their object of
promoting and encouraging the doctors to serve in rural/difficult/remote
areas, as notified by the State government. Till now, there is dearth of
providing proper and adequate health care facilities in remote and difficult
areas due to want of doctors. For that reason, this “proviso” has been
inserted in Clause 9(4) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000” making provision
for granting incentive marks to the doctors serving in rural areas. Such
holistic decision of the legislatures of this country must be given due
weightage and respect for the interest of the citizens residing in the
rural/difficult/tribal areas. The legislatures have consciously legislated that
to determine the academic merit of the candidate, securing higher marks in
the NEET should not be the sole criteria and academic merit of the
candidate must also be taken into account keeping in mind the services of
those doctors who serve the rural/difficult/remote areas sacrificing their
own personal interest. Moreso, the doctors serving in urban areas are in
better and advantageous position than those of the doctors who serve in
remote areas in the matter of preparing themselves for higher studies.
[Emphasis supplied]
20.
In the case of Dinesh Singh Chowhan (supra), the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has dealt with the object of inclusion of “proviso” under
Page 17
Clause 9(4) of “NMC Regulations, 2000”. It was observed thus:- pp 776,
777, para 44
“44. Dealing with this contention, we find that the setting in which the proviso to Clause
IV has been inserted is of some relevance. The State Governments across the country are
not in a position to provide health care facilities in remote and difficult areas in the State
for want of Doctors. In fact there is a proposal to make one year service for MBBS
students to apply for admission to Post Graduate Courses, in remote and difficult areas
as compulsory. That is kept on hold, as was stated before the Rajya Sabha. The provision
in the form of granting weightage of marks, therefore, was to give incentive to the inservice candidates and to attract more graduates to join as Medical Officers in the State
Health Care Sector. The provision was first inserted in 2012. To determine the academic
merit of candidates, merely securing high marks in the NEET is not enough. The
academic merit of the candidate must also reckon the services rendered for the common
or public good. Having served in rural and difficult areas of the State for one year or
above, the incumbent having sacrificed his career by rendering services for providing
health care facilities in rural areas, deserve incentive marks to be reckoned for
determining merit. Notably, the State Government is posited with the discretion to
notify areas in the given State to be remote, tribal or difficult areas. That declaration is
made on the basis of decision taken at the highest level; and is applicable for all the
beneficial schemes of the State for such areas and not limited to the matter of
admissions to Post Graduate Medical Courses. Not even one instance has been brought
to our notice to show that some areas which are not remote or difficult areas has been
so notified. Suffice it to observe that the mere hypothesis that the State Government
may take an improper decision whilst notifying the area as remote and difficult, cannot
be the basis to hold that Regulation 9 and in particular proviso to Clause IV is
unreasonable. Considering the above, the inescapable conclusion is that the procedure
evolved in Regulation 9 in general and the proviso to Clause (IV) in particular is just,
proper and reasonable and also fulfill the test of Article 14 of the Constitution, being in
larger public interest.”
21.
Various facets of “proviso” have been discussed by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in a catena of decisions. In the case of Prabha Tyagi vs.
Kamlesh Devi, reported in (2002) 8 SCC 90, in para 72 has held thus:“72. In this context, it would be useful to adumbrate on the principles that govern the
interpretation to be given to proviso in the context of main provision.
72.1. The normal function of a proviso is to except something out of the provision or to
qualify something enacted therein which, but for the proviso, would be within the purview
of the provision. As a general rule, a proviso is added to an enactment to qualify or create an
exception to what is in the enactment and ordinarily, a proviso is not interpreted as stating a
general rule. In other words, a proviso qualifies the generality of the main enactment by
providing an exception and taking out as it were, from the main enactment, a portion which,
but for the proviso would fall within the main provision. Further, a proviso cannot be
construed as nullifying the provision or as taking away completely a right conferred by the
enactment.
72.2. In this regard, learned Author, Justice G.P. Singh, in "Principles of Statutory
Interpretation", 15th Edition, has enunciated certain rules collated from judicial precedents.
Page 18
Firstly, a proviso is not to be construed as excluding or adding something by implication i.e.,
when on a fair construction, the principal provision is clear, a proviso cannot expand or limit
it. Secondly, a proviso has to be construed in relation to which it is appended i.e., normally, a
proviso does not travel beyond the provision to which it is a proviso. A proviso carves out an
exception to the main provision to which it has been enacted as a proviso and to no other.
However, if a proviso in a statute does not form part of a section but is itself enacted as a
separate section, then it becomes necessary to determine as to which section the proviso is
enacted as an exception or qualification. Sometimes, a proviso is used as a guide to
construction of the main section. Thirdly, when there are two possible construction of words
to be found in the section, the proviso could be looked into to interpret the main section.
However, when the main provision is clear, it cannot be watered down by the proviso. Thus,
where the main section is not clear, the proviso can be looked into to ascertain the meaning
and scope of the main provision.
72.3. According to Justice G.P. Singh, the learned author, the proviso should not be so
construed as to make it redundant. In certain cases, "the legislative device of the exclusion is
adopted only to exclude a part from the whole, which, but for the exclusion, continues to be
a part of it", and words of exclusion are presumed to have some meaning and are not readily
recognized as mere surplusage. As a corollary, it is stated that a proviso must be so
construed that the main enactment and the proviso should not become redundant or otiose.
This is particularly so, where the object of a proviso sometimes is only by way of abundant
caution, particularly when the operative words of the enactment are abundantly clear. In
other words, the purpose of a proviso in such a case is to remove any doubt. There are also
instances where a proviso is in the nature of an independent enactment and not merely, an
exception or qualifying what has been stated before. In other words, if the substantive
enactment is worded in the form of a proviso, it would be an independent legislative
provision concerning different set of circumstances than what is worded before or what is
stated before. Sometimes, a proviso is to make a distinction of special cases from the general
enactment and to provide it specially.
72.4. At this stage, the construction or interpretation of a proviso could be discussed as
gathered from various judgments of this Court.
72.4.1 In Ishverlal Thakorelal Almaula vs. Motibhai Nagjibhai [AIR 1966 SC 459], while
dealing with the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, this Court held, that a
proper function of a proviso is to except or qualify something enacted in the substantive
clause, which but for the proviso, would be within that clause.
72.4.2. In Durga Dutt Sharma vs. Navaratna Pharmaceutical Laboratories [AIR 1965 SC
980], while considering the proviso to Section 6 of Trade Marks Act, 1940, it was observed
that it would not be a reasonable construction for any statute, if a proviso which in terms
purports to create an exception and seeks to confer certain special rights on a particular
class of cases included in it should be held to be otiose and to have achieved nothing.
72.4.3. In Kedarnath Jute Mfg. Co. Ltd. vs. CTO, [AIR 1966 SC 12], it was observed that: (AIR
p.14, para 8)
"8. …. ‘the effect of an excepting or qualifying proviso, according to the ordinary rules
of construction, is to except out of the preceding portion of the enactment or to
qualify something enacted therein, which, but for the proviso, would be within it".
[See Craies on Statute Law, 6th Edition - P. 217].
In this case, the Court was considering Section 5(2) (a) (ii) of Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act,
1941 and Rule 27-A of Bengal Sales Tax Rules.
72.4.4. In Dattatraya Govind Mahajan Vs. The State of Maharashtra [AIR 1977 SC 915], a
Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, while considering the amendment made to
Maharashtra Agricultural Lands (Ceiling on Holdings) Act, 1961, in the context of Article
31B of the Constitution and the second proviso thereto, reiterated what was stated in
Ishverlal case.
72.4.5. In S. Sundaram Pillai vs. V.R. Pattabiraman [AIR 1985 SC 582], while dealing with
the scope of a proviso and explanation to sub - section (2) of Section 10 of Tamil Nadu
Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960, this Court held that a proviso may have three
Page 19
separate functions. Normally, a proviso is meant to be an exception to something within
the main enactment or qualifying some thing enacted therein which, but for the proviso,
would be within the purview of the enactment. In other words, a proviso cannot be torn
apart from the main enactment, nor can it be used to nullify or set at naught the real
object of the main enactment. Sometimes, a proviso may exceptionally have the effect of a
substantive enactment.
72.5. After referring to several legal treatises and judgments, this Court held in the above
judgment as under:- (S. Sundaram Pillai case [1985 1 SCC 591] SCC p. 610 para 43)
"43. We need not multiply authorities after authorities on this point because the legal
position seems to be clearly and manifestly well established. To sum up, a proviso may
serve four different purposes:
(1) qualifying or excepting certain provisions from the main enactment;
(2) it may entirely change the very concept of the intendment of the enactment by
insisting on certain mandatory conditions to be fulfilled in order to make the
enactment workable;
(3) it may be so embedded in the Act itself as to become an integral part of the
enactment and thus acquire the tenor and colour of the substantive enactment itself;
and
(4) it may be used merely to act as an optional addenda to the enactment with the
sole object of explaining the real intendment of the statutory provision."
72.6. The approach to the construction and interpretation of a proviso is enunciated in the
following cases.
72.6.1. In M. Pentiah vs. Muddala Veeramallappa – [AIR 1961 SC 1107], it was observed that
while interpreting a section or a proviso, if the choice is between two interpretations, the
narrower of which would fail to achieve the manifest purpose of the legislation, one should
avoid a construction which would reduce the legislation to futility and should rather accept
the bolder construction based on the view that Parliament would legislate only for the
purpose of bringing about an effective result.
72.6.2. In Supt. & Remembrancer of Legal Affairs vs. Abani Maity [AIR 1979 SC 1029], this
Court observed that the statute is not to be interpreted merely from the lexicographer's
angle. The Court must give effect to the will and in-built policy of the Legislature as
discernible from the object and scheme of the enactment and the language
employed therein. The words in a statute often take their meaning in the context of a
statute as a whole. They are, therefore, not to be construed in isolation.
22.
In the case in hand, Director of Health Services, Government of
Tripura after examining all necessary certificates required to grant
weightage marks mentioned in clause 2.1.B. added the incentive marks in
favour of the candidates appeared in the selection process and in my
opinion, there is no illegality in the process in selecting the petitioners to
pursue PG course in both the Medical Colleges of the State.
23.
In view of Clause 9(4) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000” qua the
State‟s “Educational Notification, 2021”, I am unable to accept the
Page 20
submission of learned Deputy SGI in respect of the fact that a candidate to
pursue PG course under State quota is to first secure the qualifying marks
and in case they secure the qualifying marks only thereafter weightage in
the marks in the form of incentive would be added to determine the merit
of the candidate to prepare the final merit list. In my opinion, this is an
absurd proposition the learned Deputy SGI has tried to project which will,
if accepted, frustrate the purpose of legislation.
24.
In the opinion of this court, “NMC Regulations, 2000” has its own
statutory flavour. The language of the relevant provisions under both
“NMC Regulations, 2000” and State‟s “Educational Notification, 2021” is
clear, plain and unambiguous. Rule of “interpretation” suggests that, if the
words of the statute are in themselves precise and unambiguous, then, no
more can be necessary than to expound those words in their natural and
ordinary sense. The words themselves do alone in such cases best declare
the intent of the lawgiver. Interpretation of law has two essential purposesone is to clarify to the people governed by it, the meaning of the letter of
the law, the other is to shed light and give shape to the intent of the lawmaker and in this process the court‟s responsibility lies in discerning the
social purpose which the specific provision subserves. [Apex Laboratories
Private Limited vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Large Tax
Payer Unit-II, reported in (2002) 7 SCC 98, para 40].
Page 21
25.
In my ultimate analysis, the relevant provisions under clause 9(3),
9(4) and 9(6) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000” and the provisions
encrypted under the State‟s “Educational Notification, 2021” must be read
and interpreted harmoniously to give weightage to the legislative
intendment. It becomes evident that the respondents no. 6 and 7 have
erroneously interpreted clause 9(4) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000” while
communicating the order dated 17.08.2022. The state-respondents also
could not apply their mind to the provisions made in the “Educational
Notification, 2021”.
26.
In sequel, the communication dated 17.08.2022 made by the
respondents no. 6 and 7 is declared as devoid of merit being inconsistent to
clause 9(4) of the “NMC Regulations, 2000” and runs in contra to the
object the legislature wanted to achieve.
27.
Consequently, the impugned order dated 17.08.2022 cancelling the
admission of the petitioners from pursuing their PG courses issued by the
Principal, AGMC & GBP hospital, Agartala, is hereby set-aside and
quashed. This court hopes and trusts that respondents no. 6 and 7 would
follow this judgment since it is held that they have misunderstood and
misconstrued the relevant provisions in awarding/computing the qualifying
marks in respect of in-service candidate serving in rural/difficult/tribal
areas. It is further clarified that the ultimate merit list pursing PG courses
would be computed on the basis of the marks obtained in NEET PG
Page 22
examination and All India Rank with further addition of incentive marks in
appropriate case(s), as prescribed under clause 9(4) of the “NMC
Regulations, 2000” qua the State‟s guidelines in this respect.
28.
With the aforesaid directions, the instant writ petition stands allowed
and thus disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Saikat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review