Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.408 of 2023
1. Dr. Nabanita Debbarma,
daughter of Kishore Debbarma, resident of Chanmari Road No. 4, Kunjaban,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799006
2. Dr. Debasree Das,
wife of Sagnik Pal, resident of Palace Compound, Sakuntala road extension,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799001
3. Dr. Deepanwita Nath,
daughter of Asis Ranjan Nath, resident of Bilthai, Panisagar, P.O. Bilthai, P.S.
Panisagar, North Tripura, Pin- 799260
4. Dr. Anupam Roy,
son of Ajit Kumar Roy, resident of Chandrapur, Jamtala, P.O. Reshambagan,
P.S. East Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799008
5. Dr. Rinu Debbarma,
daughter of Rabindra Debbarma, resident of Ganesh Thakur Lane, Bijoy Kumar
Chowmuhani, Krishnanagar, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin- 799001
6. Dr. Monalisa Debbarma,
daughter of Prabin Debbarma, resident of West Champacherra 2 no. Barai Bari,
P.O. + P.S. Champahour, Khowai, Tripura, Pin- 799201
7. Dr. Twinkle Debbarma,
daughter of Binoy Debbarma, resident of New Volcan Club, North
Banamalipur, P.O. Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799007
8. Dr. Adrena Debbarma,
daughter of Dr. Prabhat Debbarma, resident of Salka Residential Complex,
Gurkhabasti, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. NCC, West Tripura, Pin- 799006
9. Dr. Amartya Debnath,
son of late Ajit Kumar Debnath, resident of Jagaharimura, near Mahatma
Gandhi Play Centre, P.O. Agartala College, P.S. East Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin- 799004
10. Dr. Anindhita Shil,
daughter of Subhash Chandra Shil, resident of Moharcherra, Teliamura, P.O.
Moharcherra, P.S. Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura, Pin- 799203
11. Dr. Mousami Debbarma,
daughter of Nagendra Debbarma, resident of near TRTC office, TK Road,
Krishnanagar, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799001
12. Dr. Yalwkti Jamatia,
daughter of Gulak Bashi Jamatia, resident of Noabari, Killa, P.O. Killa, P.S.
Killa, South Tripura, Pin- 799114
13. Dr. Chandini Debbarma,
daughter of Kirit Debbarma, resident of opposite of Ramkrishna Bhavan, near
Chhatra Sangha Club, Krishnanagar, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, West
Tripura, Pin- 799001
Page 2
14. Dr. Debarun Roy,
son of Bijoy Krishna Roy, resident of Bankumari, P.O. Jogendranagar, P.S.
East Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799004
15. Dr. Helina Debbarma,
daughter of Bikram Debbarma, resident of Santipara, Ambassa, P.O.+ P.S.
Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura, Pin- 799289
16. Dr. Kushal Debbarma,
son of Purniram Debbarma, resident of near Youngs‟ Corner Club, North
Banamalipur, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799001
17. Dr. Shreyata Das,
daughter of Swapan Kumar Das, resident of East side of Old Governor House,
Kunjaban, P.O. Abhoynagar, P.S. NCC, West Tripura, Pin- 799005
18. Dr. Susmita Das,
daughter of Sukha Ranjan Das, resident of Giridhari Palli, Udaipur, P.O.
Radhakishorepur, P.S. Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura, Pin- 799120
19. Dr. Tirtha Debbarma,
son of Tarun Debbarma, resident of Champahaur, P.O. + P.S. Champahour,
Khowai, Tripura, Pin- 799201
20. Dr. Suchita Bhowmik,
daughter of Mihir Chandra Bhowmik, resident of Khas Chowmuhani,
Melaghar, P.O. Khas Chowmuhani, P.S. Melaghar, Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin799115
…..Petitioners
-VERSUS1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Principal Secretary/Secretary, Health and Family Welfare
Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010
2.
The Under Secretary,
Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura, New
Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010
3.
The Deputy Secretary,
Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura, New
Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010
4.
The Director of Health Service,
Government of Tripura, health Directorate Building, 1st Floor, Pandit J.N.
Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin- 799001
5.
The Director of Medical Education,
Government of Tripura, P.B. Das Memorial Building, 2nd Floor, Bidurkarta
Chowmuhani, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001
….Respondents
For Petitioner (s )
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate
For Respondent (s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
:
27.07.2023
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
Page 3
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
By means of filing the present writ petition, the petitioners have prayed
for granting them “No-Objection Certificate” („NOC‟, for short) to pursue
Post Graduate („PG‟, for short) course in Institutions outside the State of
Tripura, and to quash the Notification dated 03.05.2023 issued by the Director
of Medical Education, Government of Tripura (Annexure-5 to the writ
petition), so far the petitioners are concerned.
2.
Briefly stated, the petitioners are Medical Officers serving the Tripura
Health Services („THS‟, for short) Department. The petitioners no. 1, 2 and 3
have been performing since the year 2017 and petitioners no. 4 to 20 are
serving since the year 2021. Their services are placed at different places,
which were/are notified as rural areas and treated as rural service under the
respondents. In response to an advertisement published on 05.01.2023, the
petitioners had applied for obtaining NOC to appear in NEET-PG, 2023. The
petitioners were allowed 4 days leave to appear in the said examination.
Thereafter, they resumed their duties after expiry of 4 days. The petitioners
became qualified to pursue PG course in their respective streams. Thereafter,
they had applied for NOC to appear in counseling for admission in PG course,
but, the respondent no. 4 i.e. Director of Health Services, had not issued NOC
to the petitioners to appear in the counseling process. Such non-issuance of
NOC raises the cause of action for filing the instant writ petition before this
court seeking the above noted reliefs.
3.
I have heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
D. Paul, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. D.
Bhattacharjee, learned GA assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the respondents.
Page 4
4.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has referred to a Memorandum
dated 17.12.2015 (Annexure 1 to the writ petition) wherein guidelines for
issuing NOC in respect of Medical Officers of THS/Tripura Medical
Education (Faculty and condition) services for appearing in Post Graduate
Entrance Examination in different courses of study have been formulated. One
of the conditions laid down in the Memorandum dated 17.12.2015 is that “to
get NOC open category candidate (regular & ad-hoc) will have to complete a
minimum period of 6 (six) months service under this Department”. Mr. Roy
Barman, learned senior counsel has further drawn my attention to the
Memorandum dated 11.01.2023 (Annexure 3 to the writ petition), and
Memorandum dated 03.05.2023 (Annexure 5 to the writ petition), issued by
the Government of Tripura.
5.
Referring to Memorandum dated 11.01.2023, learned senior counsel
appearing for the petitioners has submitted that under the said Memorandum a
Medical Officer must work under Tripura Health Services atleast for 2 (two)
years in rural areas. However, under Memorandum dated 03.05.2023, the said
period of rural services has been extended to further six years for obtaining
NOC from the competent authority. According to learned senior counsel for
the petitioners, this condition as laid down under Memorandum dated
03.05.2023 prevented the petitioners from pursuing PG course, though, they
have become successful and qualified for the same. Mr. Roy Barman, learned
senior counsel has strenuously argued that the Memorandum dated 03.05.2023
has no reasonable nexus, and put unreasonable restrictions for the candidates
to pursue PG courses. Proceeding further, Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior
counsel has argued that the Memorandum dated 03.05.2023 laying down the
policy of issuance of NOC to a Medical Officer is irrational and arbitrary, and
therefore, liable to be set-aside. Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has
Page 5
further informed this court that as many as 40 candidates had been given
NOC, but, they may not get the cut-off marks entailing them to pursue PG
course, and in that eventuality, the petitioners having qualified may be given
the NOC for pursuing PG course. To reinforce his submissions, Mr. Roy
Barman has pressed into service a decision of Madhya Pradesh High Court
(Jabalpur Branch) titled as Diwakar Patel and ors. vs. The State of M.P. and
ors.[Writ Petition no. 16249 & others of 2022] decided on 22.09.2022, and a
judgment of Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India titled as Parmender Kumar and
ors vs. State of Haryana and ors, (Manu/ SC/1336/2011), on the context
“rules of games cannot be changed”.
6.
On the other hand, Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA has submitted that
a good number of Medical Officers, approx. 300 members (50% of the
existing strength) have applied for NOC for appearing in NEET-PG, 2023, but
no one had been provided with NOC from the Department during this year. It
is expected that a good number of them will get seat in the PG courses and if
the respondents allow them to pursue PG course, then, the entire health
system of the State would be collapsed. Learned GA has further argued that
most of the slots of clinical services under THS will remain vacant. Sum and
substance of the submission of learned GA is that the State Medical Services
will be badly affected if NOC is given to the petitioners and other similarly
situated Medical Officers. Added to it, learned GA has referred to Rule 7 and
Rule 50 of CCS (Leave) Rules and, particularly, the Rules relating to granting
of “Study leave” to re-inforce his submission that leave cannot be granted as a
matter of right and it is the discretion of the employer to consider the exigency
in public service before granting leave in any form including study leave.
7.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing for
the parties.
Page 6
8.
Before I advert to the merits of the case, I must say that State has
every right to formulate its own policy keeping in mind the interest of public
as a whole, and the court will not interfere with such policy, unless it suffers
from arbitrariness, illegality or legal or factual malafides or any of the vices
within the scope of Wednesbury reasonableness. In addition, the Court will be
loath to interfere if the policy decision taken by the State has rational nexus
with the objectives it sought to be achieved. To summarize, the Government of
the day has power to formulate its policy and to change the same from time to
time depending upon the exigencies of the situation. Keeping this well
established principle in mind, I have proceeded to decide the instant case on
merits.
[Emphasis supplied]
9.
At the outset, I should refer the Memorandum dated 11.01.2023
(Annexure 3 to the writ petition) where under Clause 1(j), it is laid down that
“a candidate must work under Tripura Health services at least for 2 (Two)
years in rural area”. In supersession of this Memorandum as regards granting
of NOC, the government has come up with another Memorandum dated
03.05.2023 (Annexure 5 to the writ petition) where it is decided that
“conditional NOC will be given to the eligible in-service candidates who have
completed rural service tenure for more than 6 years for following clinical
subjects only i.e., Medicine, Surgery, OBG, Opthalmology, Radiology,
Anesthesia, Pediatrics, Transfusion Medicine, ENT, Ortho, Nephrology,
Radiation Oncology, Respiratory Medicine, Dermatology and FMT”.
10.
Now, firstly, it is to be considered whether such change of policy of
this Clause extending the required tenure of rural services to more than six
years under Memorandum dated 03.05.2023 from two years under
Page 7
Memorandum dated 11.01.2023 suffers from the vice of arbitrariness,
irrationality or has no reasonable nexus the policy makers wanted to achieve.
11.
Having perused the Memorandum dated 17.12.2015 (Annexure 1 to
the writ petition), Memorandum dated 11.01.2023 (Annexure 3 to the writ
petition) and Memorandum dated 03.05.2023 (Annexure 5 to the writ
petition), I find clear distinction in issuance of the aforesaid Memorandums. In
the Memorandums dated 17.12.2015 and 11.01.2023, there is clear distinction
between the use of the words the policy makers had incorporated. In the
Memorandum dated 03.05.2023, for the first time, the framers have
considered the aspect of acute shortage of Medical Officers. The
memorandum has started with the following words:“In view of acute shortage of Medical Officers, the following decisions has been
taken for in-service Medical Officers in respect of NOC for availing PG courses in
super session of earlier order on this issue.
a) Conditional NOC will be given to the eligible in-service candidates who have
completed rural service tenure for more than 6 years for following clinical subjects
only i.e. Medicine, Surgery, OBG, Opthalmology, Radiology, Anesthesia, Pediatrics,
Transfusion Medicine, ENT, Ortho, Nephrology, Radiation Oncology, Respiratory
Medicine, Dermatology and FMT.
b) ***
c) ***
d) ***
e) ***
f) ***
2. This is issued as per approval vide U.O. No. 1303/CM/2023 dated 24.04.2023 of the
competent authority and this order shall take with immediate effect until further
order.”
12.
On bare perusal of the Memorandum dated 03.05.2023, it is
crystallized that the policy makers of this Memorandum have taken into
consideration the acute shortage of Medical Officers within the State hospitals
and Public health Centers (PHCs), and in their counter affidavit, it is clearly
stated that the entire health service system would be collapsed. As such, from
the Memorandum dated 03.05.2023, it is clear that the Government of Tripura,
particularly, the authorities concerned had obvious reasons to re-visit the issue
in respect of granting NOC in favour of a Candidates/Medical Officers
Page 8
intending to pursue PG courses. In my opinion, the said Memorandum dated
03.05.2023 [Annexure 5 to WP(C) 408 of 2023] extending the tenure of rural
services to the extent of more than 6 (six) years does not suffer from any
irrationality, arbitrariness, and such decision is taken in the exigencies of
providing required health services to the people of the State. The State being a
welfare State governed by rule of law would definitely to consider the issue in
consonance to its fundamental and constitutional obligations towards its
people as enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution of India to cater
adequate health and medical services to its populace. „Right to Health‟ is one
of the significant dimensions of Article 21 of the Constitution of India. Every
persons have the right to get themselves adequately and effectively treated.
The people of the State expect better health care and services from a
benevolent Government.
13.
Keeping in view the categorical statements made in counter affidavit
that if the State is prevented from implementing the policy decision dated
03.05.2023, the health service system of the State would be collapsed, one
may unhesitently hold that the change of policy as regards the granting of
study leave to the State‟s Medical Officers has rational nexus to achieve the
object of providing adequate health service towards the people of the State,
and thus, would not warrant interference.
14.
At this juncture, Mr. Roy Barman, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the respondents has eloquently submitted that the State authorities have
failed to justify their actions of changing its policy as regards the period of
rural service from 2 (two) years to more than 6 (six) years within a span of 4
(four) months. I do not find any merit in the submission of Mr. Roy Barman,
learned Senior Counsel.
Page 9
15.
In the opinion of this court, State legislatures being the elected
public representatives are well aware of the ground realities as well as the
basic needs of the people to which the Court has very little idea. As such, it is
exclusively within the domain of the legislatures to lay down appropriate
policy taking into account the best interest of the people. Accordingly, I repel
the submission of learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners that the
respondents-State has arbitrarily changed the policy decision dated
11.01.2023, which prescribed 2 (two) years rural service.
16.
Added to it, it is no longer res integra that to obtain the benefit of
leave is a matter of right. Rule 7 of CCS (Leave) Rules, postulates that:
“7. Right to leave
(1) Leave cannot be claimed as of right.
(2) When the exigencies of public service so require, leave of any kind may be
refused or revoked by the authority competent to grant it, butit shall not be open
to that authority to alter the kind of leave due and applied for except at the
written request of the Government servant.”
Furthermore, Rule 50 of CCS (Leave) Rules, is relevant herein,
which reads as under:
“50. Conditions for grant of study leave
(1) Subject to conditions specified in this Chapter, study leave may be granted to a
Government servant with due regard to the exigencies of public service to enable him to
undergo, in or out of India, a special course of study consisting of higher studies or
specialized training in a professional or a technical subject having a direct and close
connection with the sphere of his duty.
(2) * * * * * *
(3) Study leave shall not be granted unless(i) it is certified by the authority competent to grant leave that the proposed course of
study or training shall be of definite advantage from the point of view of public
interests;
******”
On plain and conjoint reading of above provisions, it crystalizes that
none can claim leave in whatever form as a matter of right, and it can be
denied in the exigencies of public interest.
17.
Undoubtedly, granting of statutory leave definitely will be an
advantage to the government from the point of view of public interest and is
related to sphere of duties to the government servant. Furthermore, the study
Page 10
leave is to be allowed to an eligible candidate to improve the academic
excellence in the relevant establishment. It is also equally true that the
competent authority i.e. the employer is the best authority to determine its
need and overall public interest. It is obvious that before framing any policy
on any issue related to public administration, the government makes thorough
exercise keeping in mind the exigencies of public service and the interest of
the people of the State. In the instant case, it is crystallized that the policy
makers while issuing the memorandum dated 03.05.2023 in supersession of its
earlier policy under Memorandum dated 11.01.2023 have taken into
consideration the acute shortage of Medical Officers in the State, which
compelled the Government to change its policy with an aim to cater better
health service to its people.
18.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, I find no ground
to interfere with the Memorandum dated 03.05.2023. Accordingly, the instant
writ petition stands dismissed being devoid of merit. Pending application(s), if
any, also stands disposed in the above terms.
JUDGE
signed
SAIKAT Digitally
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2023.08.10
KAR
13:13:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review