Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:THC:616
TRHC010014452025
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.502 of 2025
Dr. Mihir Kr. Das,
Aged about 60 years, Son of Late Sachindra Ch. Das, resident of Ramnagar
Road No.8, Agartala, PO Ramnagar, Agartala, District West Tripura, 799002.
–Versus–
….. Petitioner(s)
1.
The Tripura State Pollution Control Board,
To be represented by the Member Secretary, Tripura State Pollution
Control Board, P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN
799006.
2.
The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary, Department of Law, New
Secretariat Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799010.
3.
The Member Secretary,
Tripura State Pollution Control Board, P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799006.
4.
The Chairperson,
Tripura State Pollution Control Board, P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799006.
5.
The Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries,
Government of Tripura, P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN 799006.
6.
Life Insurance Corporation of India,
To be represented by the General Manager (Pension and Group
Schemes), Silchar Divisional Office, Meherpur, P.O. Silchar, District
Cachar, Assam-788015.
……..Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Senior Advocate.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate.
Mr. Sayantan Talapatra, Advocate.
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
14th May, 2026
Whether fit for reporting or not :
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
The petitioner was working as Scientist-C in Tripura State
Pollution Control Board [in short, TSPCB] and went on retirement on
31.03.2021. When he was in service, the Member Secretary, TSPCB vide
memorandum dated 20.03.2020, initiated a departmental inquiry against the
petitioner. In that departmental proceeding, after submission of his written
statement, he also filed a written objection raising his objection that the
disciplinary proceeding which was initiated against him by the Member
Secretary was junior to him. The inquiring authority thereafter referred the
matter to the Disciplinary Authority for instruction. Having getting no response,
the petitioner filed W.P.(C) No.967 of 2021 challenging the memorandum
regarding initiation of departmental proceeding against him. A Coordinate
Bench of this Court vide judgment and order dated 03.07.2023, dismissed the
said writ petition. However, the Division Bench on appeal bearing No. W.A.
No.98 of 2023 allowed the prayer of the petitioner vide judgment and order
dated 19.03.2024 with the following observation and direction:
“[13] We are, therefore, of the view that interest of justice would be
better served if the disciplinary proceeding is initiated afresh on the
memorandum of charges by a disciplinary authority who is not
subordinate to the petitioner in the organization.
[14] As such, the impugned memorandum of charges dated 20.03.2020
whereby the disciplinary proceedings had been initiated under the
orders of Mr. Bishu Karmakar, Member Secretary, TSPCB cannot be
sustained in the eye of law. It is accordingly quashed. The
TSPCB/Disciplinary Authority shall initiate a fresh proceeding in respect
of the same charges against the petitioner and take a decision on
conclusion thereof in accordance with law in a time bound manner.
Accordingly, the instant appeal is allowed on the aforesaid point and to
the extent indicated above.”
[2]
Now, it is the case of the petitioner that after the said judgment of
the Division Bench, the respondent No.1 by issuing a notification on
02.07.2024 [Annexure-8] appointed one Dr. K. Sasikumar, IFS, Chairman,
TSPCB to act as the Disciplinary Authority.
[3]
Thereafter, the petitioner raised his objection vide communication
dated 28.02.2025 [Annexure-9], raising his objection that by the judgment of
the High Court, the TSPCB was not authorized to declare the Chairman of the
said Board as Disciplinary Authority. Meanwhile, according to the petitioner,
3[three] different memoranda are issued on 03.09.2024 [Annexure-10],
05.09.2024 [Annexure-12] and 21.09.2024 [Annexure-14] whereby, 3[three]
departmental proceedings are now initiated against the petitioner by said
Chairman of TSPCB.
[4]
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel referring to the Rules of
Tripura State Pollution Control Board Employees’ Group Gratuity Assurance
Scheme, wherein the definition of employment is mentioned to the effect that
the ‘Employer’ shall mean the ‘Member Secretary’, Tripura State Pollution
Control Board. Learned senior counsel also referred Rule 2(g) of CCA(CCS)
Rules, wherein it is mentioned that "disciplinary authority" means the authority
competent under these rules to impose on a Government servant any of the
penalties specified in Rule 11 of sub rules.
[5]
Learned senior counsel contends that the Chairman of the said
Board being an IFS is not the accepting authority here and therefore, he cannot
act as the Disciplinary Authority in this case and as such, departmental
proceedings initiated against the petitioner are liable to be quashed.
Thereafter, it appears that vide order dated 22.04.2025, passed in three
disciplinary proceedings [Annexure-17,18 & 19 respectively], the inquiring
authority has taken note of the objection as raised by the petitioner and has
closed down the inquiry against the petitioner in all three departmental
proceedings. Learned senior counsel also submits that despite the inquiry
being closed, the benefit of commutation pension has not been allowed by the
respondent No.1 in favour of the petitioner. As the departmental proceedings
are already closed down by the Inquiring Authority, learned senior counsel
does not press any relief regarding quashing of said proceedings but presses
only for the relief of commutation of pension.
[6]
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel led by Mr. Roy Barman,
learned senior counsel further adds that the pensionary benefits are the
property of an employee as recognized under Article 300A of the Constitution
and therefore, without any valid authority, same cannot be withheld. Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel also submits that commutation of pension is
also the part of such pensionary benefits and here in this case, there is no
pendency of any departmental proceeding against the petitioner. Therefore,
there is no scope for the respondent to withhold the commutation benefit of the
petitioner. To gain support of his submission, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel also relies on a decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
State of Jharkhand and others vs. Jitendra Kumar Srivastava and
another; (2013) 12 SCC 210 wherein the respondent was governed by Bihar
Pension Rules and the Department though sanctioned 90% of the provisional
pension to the respondent but withheld remaining 10% thereof along with his
salary for his suspension period and also did not pay the benefit of leave
encashment and gratuity. Hon’ble Supreme Court referring to Rule 43 (b) of
said Bihar Pension Rules observes that the State Government had the power
to withhold or withdraw the pension or any part of it when the pensioner is
found to be guilty of grave misconduct either in a departmental proceeding or in
a judicial proceeding but said provision does not empower the State to invoke
the said power while the departmental proceeding or the judicial proceeding
were pending and were not disposed of. Withholding of pension under said
Rule is permissible only when a finding is recorded either in the departmental
inquiry or in judicial proceedings that the employee has committed grave
misconduct in the discharge of his duty while in his office. It is also observed by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in the said decision that the right to receive pension is
recognized as a right to property and a person cannot be deprived of his
pension without the authority of law, which is the Constitutional mandate
enshrined in Article 300A of the Constitution. It is also further observed that on
the basis of a circular, which is not having the force of law, the employer
cannot withhold even a part of pension or gratuity and accordingly, the appeal
filed by the State of Jharkhand was dismissed.
[7]
Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel representing respondent Nos.1,3
and 4 submits that the present petitioner is not governed by CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972 rather his pension is regulated by the Rules of the Tripura State
Pollution Control Board Employees’ Group Superannuation Scheme for
extension of defined pensionary benefit to the employees/officers of State
Pollution Control Board and as per said Rules, more particularly Rule 13, the
Department has the authority to withhold the commutation of a percentage of a
pension till completion of departmental or judicial proceeding, if any, pending
against an employee. The relevant Rule 13 is extracted hereunder:
“13. Commutation of Pension:
If the member, so desire, a part of corpus may be commuted for
the single payment, provided that such payment shall not exceed
one third of corpus.
However, an employee or pensioner against whom departmental
or judicial proceedings are pending is not eligible to commute a
percentage of his pension till completion of such proceedings.”
[8]
Mr. Datta, learned counsel submits that most illegally the inquiring
authority dropped all the three departmental proceedings vide order dated
22.04.2025 in violation of CCS (Pension) Rules. According to Mr. Datta,
learned counsel said CCS (Pension) Rules never authorize an inquiring
authority to examine and to close down an inquiry on the ground of its
maintainability rather when a Department refers the matter for inquiry to an
inquiry officer, he is duty bound to give his findings either in a positive or in a
negative manner. Therefore, the order passed by the inquiring authority on
22.04.2025 in all the three departmental proceedings was totally without
jurisdiction and they also thereafter sent a letter to the inquiring authority on
28.04.2025 (Annexure CA-9) with a request to review the aforesaid orders and
to inquire into the charges framed against the petitioner by the disciplinary
authority. Mr. Datta, learned counsel also submits that despite sending of such
letter, the matter is pending before the inquiring authority for more than one
year without any response. Therefore, according to Mr. Datta, learned counsel,
it cannot be said that the departmental proceeding is already over and as such,
the Department has the authority to withhold the commutation benefit of the
petitioner. Learned counsel also contends that the decision as referred by Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel of the petitioner does not fit in within the facts
of this case rather the decision was rendered relying on a different pension
rules applicable in the State of Bihar.
[9]
Mr. Sayantan Talapatra, learned counsel for respondent No.6
submits that they are ready to comply with the direction(s) whatsoever is
passed by this Court in this writ petition.
[10]
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, learned counsel for respondent No.2
simply submits that they are only formal party in this writ petition.
[11]
Court has considered the rival submissions of the parties, and has
also considered the materials placed by them.
[12]
It is a fact that at present, there is no departmental proceeding
pending against the petitioner as same has been, either legally or illegally,
closed down by the inquiring authority vide order dated 22.04.2025.
Simultaneously, it is also true that for restoring the same, the respondent
department has already sent a letter to the inquiring authority but without
disposing the same, said inquring authority has kept it pending for a long
period without any explanation. It is also further noticeable that due to said
stagnating situation the petitioner having gone on retirement is not being able
to get the benefit of commutation till date and is under sufferance. It is also
admitted fact that all other pensionary benefits have already been released in
favour of the petitioner by the department without any objection or resistance
from their part.
[13]
Court has also gone through the charges as was framed against
the petitioner in those departmental inquiries. There is no allegation specifically
mentioned in those charges about any sort of defalcation of any amount or any
pecuniary loss caused to the department by the petitioner. Considering all
these aspects, it appears to this Court that when a petition has already been
filed by the department to the inquiry officer for restoring the departmental
proceeding, it is obligatory for the said inquiring authority to dispose of the
same and to communicate the decision to the said department without delay
but without any action thereupon, said inquiring authority has kept it pending
for uncertain period. Simultaneously, it also true that for pendency of said
communication of the department to the inquiring authority, the petitioner
cannot be made sufferer. If in any case, said departmental proceedings are
again restored and after inquiry the petitioner is punished and he is required to
refund any amount to the department then only the question of recovery from
or payment to be made by the petitioner, would arise. Therefore, there is no
justification at this stage to withhold the amount of the commutation benefit for
uncertain period.
[14]
Considering all these aspects, the writ petition is allowed. The
respondent Nos.1 and 3 are directed to provide the benefit of commutation of
pension to the petitioner along with interest @ 7% per annum thereupon from
the date when it felt due till payment, within two months of receipt of copy of
this order on submission of an undertaking by the petitioner to respondent
Nos.1 and 3 that in case in future, he is required to pay any amount to the
department, he will be liable to return so. Simultaneously, respondent No. 5 is
also directed to dispose of the petition dated 28.04.2025 of respondent Nos.1,3
and 4 within two weeks of receipt of copy of this judgment in accordance with
law.
With the above said terms and direction, the writ petition is
disposed of.
No order as to costs.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.05.16 16:13:34 +05'30'
Rudradeep
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review