Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 967/2021
Dr. Mihir Kr. Das,
S/O- Lt. Sachindra Ch. Das,
R/O- Ramnagar Road No.8,
P.O- Ramnagar, Agartala,
District- West Tripura, Pin- 799002
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1.
The Tripura State Pollution Control Board, to be represented by the
Member Secretary, Tripura State Pollution Control Board, P.N. Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799006
2.
The Member Secretary, Tripura State Pollution Control Board, P.N.
Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799006
3.
The Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries, Government of
Tripura, P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799006
4.
Sri Bishu Karmakar, Scientist ‘B’, Tripura State Pollution Control
Board, P.N Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura.
…..Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
:
03.07.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
The main challenge here is the competency of a “full-time Member
Secretary” to act as disciplinary authority under the Tripura State Pollution
Control Board. Said full-time Member Secretary issued the impugned
memorandum dated 20.03.2020 whereby and whereunder he proposed to hold a
disciplinary inquiry against the petitioner under Rule 14 of the CCS (CC&A)
Rules, 1965 (Annexure 3 to the writ petition).
2.
I have heard Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as
well as Mr. Ratan Datta, learned standing counsel appearing for the
respondents-Tripura State Pollution Control Board and Mr. D. Sarma, learned
Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondent-State.
3.
Mr. Nath, learned counsel has submitted that the disciplinary authority is
a statutory authority as contemplated under Rule 12 of the CCS (CC&A) Rules,
1965 (for short, “CCS Rules”) and the exercise of such power of disciplinary
authority is a statutory power. It is the further contention of Mr. Nath, learned
counsel that the post of Member Secretary under the Tripura State Pollution
Control Boards (for short, “TSPCB”) is a statutory post and the power to
initiate a disciplinary proceeding is only vested with such Member Secretary
who is duly appointed through regular recruitment process and holds the post as
permanent member of the Board. Drawing my attention to the notification dated
07.09.2019 (Annexure 6 to the writ petition), Mr. Nath, learned counsel has
contended that Dr. Bishu Karmakar holds the current charge of the duties of the
post of Member Secretary under the respondents no. 1, 2 and 3 i.e. TSPCB, till
regular appointment is made for the said post, and such Member Secretary
merely performing current duties cannot exercise statutory power as a fullfledged Member Secretary to act as disciplinary authority under Rule 12 of the
CCS Rules. Mr. Nath, learned counsel has referred to certain Government of
India’s decisions wherein it is stated that an officer appointed to perform
current duties of an appointment can exercise administrative or financial power
vested in the full-fledged incumbent to the said post, but, he cannot exercise the
statutory powers, whether those powers are derived direct from an Act of
Parliament or Rules.
4.
On the other hand, Mr. Datta, learned counsel appearing for TSPCB has
contended that the appointment of Dr. Bishu Karmakar to hold the charge of
Member Secretary under TSPCB cannot be compared with an officer holding
the current charge of the duties of a certain post. Showing the gazette
notification dated 19.09.2019 (Annexure CA-2 of Counter Affidavit), Mr.
Datta, learned counsel has submitted that Dr. Karmakar is holding the charge of
Member Secretary on full-time basis being duly appointed by the Government
of Tripura, which is permissible under The Water (Prevention and Control of
Pollution) Act, 1974 (here-in-after referred to as “Water Act of 1974”). Mr.
Datta, learned counsel has urged to dismiss the writ petition contending that the
order to initiate disciplinary proceeding against the petitioner under
memorandum dated 20.03.2020 is consistent with the Water Act, 1974.
5.
At the time of hearing, Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-TSPCB has submitted that this petition is squarely covered by the
judgment of this Court dated 29.09.2022 passed in WP(C) 869/2022 titled as
Sri Subrata Majumder Vs. The Tripura State Pollution Control Board & Ors.
6.
I have gone through the aforesaid judgment passed by me in WP(C)
869/2022 (Supra). The relevant portion of the judgment is reproduced here-inbelow for convenience:“5.
I have pondered over the erudite submissions canvassed by learned
counsel appearing for the parties and considered the legal positions.
6.
“Disciplinary Authority” is defined under Rule 2(g) of CCS Rules
which means the authority competent under the CCS Rules to impose on a
Government servant any of the penalties specified in Rule 11of CCS Rules.
Rule 12 of CCS Rules prescribes the powers and functions of the disciplinary
authorities, which reads as under:
“12. DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITIES:
(1) The President may impose any of the penalties specified in Rule 11 on
any Government servant.
(2) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-rule (1), but subject to the
provisions of sub-rule (4), any of the penalties specified in Rule 11 may be
imposed on (a) a member of a Central Civil Service other than the General Central
Service, by the appointing authority or the authority specified in the
schedule in this behalf or by any other authority empowered in this behalf
by a general or special order of the President;
(b) a person appointed to a Central Civil Post included in the General
Central Service, by the authority specified in this behalf by a general or
special order of the President or, where no such order has been made, by
the appointing authority or the authority specified in the Schedule in this
behalf.
(3) *** *** ***
*** *** ***
*** *** ***
(4)) *** *** ***
*** *** ***
*** *** ***
EXPLANATION 1) *** *** ***
*** *** ***
*** *** ***
EXPLANATION 2) *** *** ***
*** *** ***
*** *** ***
7.
On plain reading, it appears that Rule 12(2)(b) of the CCS Rules is
relevant to the issue in controversy. Rule 12(2)(b) clearly lays down that a
person can be appointed to a civil post by the authority under special order of
the President or, where any such order has been made by the appointing
authority.
8.
To clarify the meaning attached to the expression “disciplinary
authority”, the Government of India issued certain orders. One of such orders
relates to the officers performing current duties of a post. It says that an
officer appointed to perform the current duties of an appointment can
exercise administrative or financial power vested in the full-fledged
incumbent of the post, but he cannot exercise statutory powers, whether those
powers are derived direct from an Act of Parliament [G.I., M.H.A., O.M. No.
F. 7/14/16-Ests. (A), dated 24th January, 1963].
Another order speaks that where appointment to hold the current
duties of a post involves the exercise of statutory or such other powers
conferred on the holders of the post, the appointment should also be notified
in the gazette. [G.I., M.F. O.M. No. F. 12(2)-E, II.(A) 60, dated 15th October,
1960].
9.
From the above orders, it becomes clear that an officer appointed to
perform the current duties of a post cannot be treated as full-fledged
incumbent of the post and he cannot exercise statutory powers. However,
statutory or such other powers can be conferred on the holders of the post if
such appointment of the officers is notified in the gazette. To sum up, an
officer merely looking after the current duties of a higher officer is not
competent to exercise the power of disciplinary authority or the appellate
authority of the latter, unless and until the appointment of such officer is
made by appointing authority being duly notified in the official gazette.
10.
At this juncture, I have taken note of the scheme of the Water Act of
1974, which is a central act. It becomes apparent that in pursuance of clause
1 of Article 22 of the Constitution of India, resolutions had been passed by all
the houses of the legislature of the States of Assam, Bihar, Gujarat, Haryana,
Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir, Karnataka, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh,
Rajasthan, Tripura and West Bengal to the effect that the matters relating to
prevention and control of water pollution and the maintaining or restoring of
wholesomeness of water should be regulated in those States by the Law of
Parliament.
11.
Sub-section (2) of Section 1 of the Water Act of 1974 envisages that it
was applied in the first instance to the State of Tripura including other States,
as aforesaid. Sub-section (3) of Section 1 of the Water Act of 1974 provides
that it came into force at once to the aforesaid States. Section 4(2)(f) of the
Water Act of 1974 is required to be noticed in the context of the case. It
provides that:
“4. Constitution of State Boards.— (1) The State Government shall, with
effect from such date, as it may, by notification in the Official Gazette,
appoint, constitute a [State Pollution Control Board], under such name as
may be specified in the notification, to exercise the powers conferred on
and perform the functions assigned to that Board under this Act.
(2) A State Board shall consist of the following members, namely:—
(a) xxxxx
(b) xxxxx
(c) xxxxx
(d) xxxxx
(e) xxxxx
[(f) a full-time member-secretary, possessing qualifications, knowledge and
experience of scientific, engineering or management aspects of pollution
control, to be appointed by the State Government.]”
12.
It is noticed that clause (f) of sub-section (2) of Section 4 was not
enacted in the original Water Act of 1974. Clause (f) was inserted by the
Amendment Act 53 of 1988 in the original enacted Act of 1974 and it came
into force in the State of Tripura w.e.f. 29.08.1988.
13.
Now, if both CCS Rules and Water Act of 1974 are conjointly read, it
is crystallized that the law as conceptualized for the posts of “Current duties
and full-time Member Secretary” is quite distinct and created on different
connotations. The two posts should not be mistaken as equivalent. While Rule
12 of CCS Rules speaks of officers merely performing current duties of a post,
the concept of the post of full-time Member Secretary embodied in Section
4(2)(f) of the Water Act of 1974 is to give the said post a statutory flavour. A
full-time Member Secretary is a statutory post incorporated in the Act of 1974
by Act 53 of 1988 especially for the States of Tripura, Himachal Pradesh and
Union Territories to fulfill certain objects the respective governments wanted
to achieve.
14.
That apart, it is apparent that under Section 4(2)(f) of the Act of 1974,
the State Government is statutorily empowered to appoint a full-time Member
Secretary having qualification, knowledge and experience of scientific,
engineering or management aspects of pollution control. In other words, the
State Government is the appointing authority of a full-time member secretary
of Tripura State Pollution Control Board.
15.
Now what is culled out that a full-time Member Secretary being
appointed by the State Government can exercise all statutory powers which
includes the power of disciplinary authority as contemplated under Rule
12(2)(b) of CCS Rules apart from the powers conferred upon him, and
perform the functions assigned to him in the interest of the State Pollution
Control Board.
16.
Coming to the context of the present case, the Government of Tripura
constituted State Pollution Control Board under the nomenclature Tripura
State Pollution Control Board (for short, „TSPCB‟) at the behest of the
Department of Science, Technology and Environment in terms of Section 4(1)
of the Water Act of 1974. To run and govern the TSPCB, the State
Government has appointed Dr. Bishu Karmakar as a full-time Member
Secretary of the Board. It is not disputed that Dr. Bishu Karmakar possesses
all necessary qualifications, knowledge and experience in the field of
pollution control. It is admitted that Member Secretary is the disciplinary
authority of TSPCB and can exercise the powers of disciplinary authority as
embodied in Rule 12(2)(b) of CCS Rules.
17.
In the case on hand, the State Government being the appointing
authority issued necessary order appointing Dr. Bishu Karmakar as full-time
Member Secretary by way notification published in the official gazette. The
notification for appointment of Dr. Karmakar may be reproduced here-inbelow, for convenience, in extenso:“No. 1966
Registered No. N.E. 930
TRIPURA GAZETTEE
Published by Authority
EXTRAORDINARY ISSUE
Agartala, Thursday, September 19, 2019 A.D. Bhadra 28, 1941 S.E.
PART-1- Orders and Notifications by the Government of Tripura
The High Court, Government Treasury etc.
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY & ENVIRONMENT
No. F.11(68)/DSTE/CC/Pt-I/5597-606
Dated, Agartala the 7th September,
In exercise of the powers conferred by clause (f) of sub-section (2) of section (4) of the
Water (Prevention and control of pollution)Act of 1974 (Act 6 of 1974) and in the
interest of public service, the Governor, Tripura is pleased to order that Shri Bishu
Karmakar, scientist-B, Tripura State Pollution Control Board shall hold the charge of
Member Secretary in the Tripura State Pollution Control Board (TSPCB) on full time
basis with immediate effect and until further orders. Any other work assigned to him
in the Board shall be re-assigned to other officer9s) in the TSPCB, Ex-post facto
approval is also accorded to assignment of the charge of Member Secretary, TSPCB to
Shri Bishu Karmakar, Scientist-B in addition to his assigned duties w.e.f. 13.08.2019.
By order of the Governor
Sd/(Shailendra Singh)
Special Secretary to the
Government of Tripura”
18.
The tenure of appointment of Dr. Bishu Karmakar has been further extended vide
notification dated 6/05/2021 which is also notified in the official gazette of the Government
of Tripura. The notification dated 6/05/2021 is reproduced here-in-below:
“No. 1135
Registered No. N.E. 930
TRIPURA GAZETTEE
Published by Authority
EXTRAORDINARY ISSUE
Agartala, Thursday, June 30, 2022 A.D. Asadha 9, 1944 S.E.
PART-1- Orders and Notifications by the Government of Tripura
The High Court, Government Treasury etc.
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY & ENVIRONMENT
BIGYAN, PRAJUKTI O PARIVESH BHAWAN
GORKHABASTI: P.N. COMPLEX
AGARTALA:TRIPURA
No. F.8(1)/DSTE/ENV/Pt-IX/3106-166
06/05/2021
NOTIFICATION
Dated,
In partial modification of the Notification No. F.11(68)/DSTE/CC/Pt-1/5597-606
dated 07.09.2019 issued by the Department of Science, Technology & Environment,
Government of Tripura, Shri Bishu Karmakar, Scientist-B, Tripura State Pollution
Control Board (TSPCB) holding the Charge of the Member Secretary, TSPCB on full time
basis will continue to hold the Charge of the Member Secretary, TSPCB on full time
basis till completion of the recruitment process of the eligible candidates to this post
of Member Secretary as per the “Tripura State Pollution Control Board [Prevention &
Control of water Pollution (Amendment)] Rules, 2021.
This is issued with the approval of Hon’ble Council of Ministers, Govt. of Tripura vide
Memorandum No. F.1(1)-GA(CAB)/2021-C dated 23.04.2021.
Sd/(Saradindu Choudhury)
Secretary
Govt of Tripura”
19.
The above notifications crystallize that the appointment of Dr. Bishu
Karmakar has been made in exercise of the powers conferred under clause(f)
Sub-section 2 of Section 4 of the Water Act of 1974 by the order of the
Governor.
That the Member Secretary of TSPCB can exercise all statutory
powers and perform all statutory duties as disciplinary authority in the
interest of TSPCB as contemplated under Rule 12(2)(b) of the CCS Rules has
not been disputed by learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. To reiterate, it is the only grievance of the petitioner that Dr. Bishu Karmakar not
being appointed through regular recruitment process and merely holding the
post temporarily acted as disciplinary authority, which is not permissible
under Rule 12 of CCS Rules, since, according to learned counsel for the
petitioner, this power is exclusively vested with a permanent i.e. regularly
appointed Member Secretary.
20.
I am constrained to say that Mr. Nath, learned counsel fails to
visualize the distinctive features as regards the appointment of the officers
performing current duties of the higher post and the full-time Member
Secretary under TSPCB and misconstrued both Rule 12(2)(b) of the CCS
Rules and Section 4(2)(f) of the Water Act of 1974.
21.
I have already stated and analyzed the law that the post of full-time
Member Secretary under TSPCB is a post recognized under the statute
(Water Act of 1974). The incumbent Officer of the said post being duly
appointed under Section 4(2)(f) of the Water Act of 1974 as enumerated herein-above can exercise all statutory powers derived direct from the Act of
Parliament or rules made under various Articles of the Constitution in
addition to the performance of normal day to day administrative or financial
function. Needless to say that CCS Rules, 1965 is framed in exercise of the
powers conferred by proviso to Article 309 and clause (5) of Article 148 of
the Constitution of India.
22.
As a sequel, I do not find any infirmity or legal impediment in the
order passed under impugned memorandum dated 20/03/2020 by Dr. Bishu
Karmakar, the full-time Member Secretary of TSPCB to hold inquiry under
Rule 14 of CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965 against the petitioner herein.
23.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands dismissed being devoid of
merit. However, there shall be no order as to costs..”
Since the factual aspects of the present writ petition is similar and
identical to the subject-matter of the case of Sri Subrata Majumder (supra),
this writ petition is also, therefore, dismissed in the same terms.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed.
SAIKA
T KAR
Digitally signed
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2023.07.21
16:54:33 +05'30'
Rohit
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review