Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/dr-menka-bharti-vs-the-border-security-force-and-7-ors-20220530/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Constitutional

Dr. Menka Bharti vs The Border Security Force and 7 Ors.

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Tripura High Court
Date
30 May 2022
Case No.
WP(C) 951/2019
Result
Allowed
Bench
S. Talapatra
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

02. 07.2017 Remarks Dr. A C Bhardwajan, Commandant (Medical) Ftr. Hqrs. BSF, Shillong (Technical Reporting officer ) gave remarks that: “Needs to improve interaction with troops on Border.” Dr. A C Bhardwajan, Commandant (Medical) Ftr. Hqrs. BSF, Shillong (Technical Reporting officer ) gave remarks that: “She needs to improve her interaction shill with troops.” Shri Vijay Singh, Commandant, 123 Bn BSF (Admn I.O) gave remarks that: “She perform routine work of Unit MI Room without taking any initiative to perform extra in the interest of the force.” Shri Vijay Singh, Commandant, 123 Bn BSF (Admn I.O) gave remarks that: “She perform routine duty of unit MI Room and reluctant to take initiative her own.” Grading Awarded Good Good Good Good Since the adverse remarks in PPARs and APARs for the period as indicated in the table have been expunged by this court, the Director General, Border Security Force shall reassess and award the grading as befitting to the petitioner. It is made absolutely clear that the allegations as brought against the petitioner shall not be taken into consideration as those were not on the basis of the assessment of performance of the petitioner. Since the adverse remarks have been expunged by this court, the petitioner‟s performance shall be reviewed only on the basis of the remarks of the Reporting Officer. Hence, this writ petition stands allowed to the extent…

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA WP(C)No.951 of 2019 Dr. Menka Bharti, Chief Medical Officer, wife of Dr. Raj Kumar Gupta, resident of 48th Battalion, Border Security Force, P.O. Khasiamangal, P.S. Teliamura, District: Khowai, PIN: 799 205 Permanent Address: Dr. Menka Bharti, Chief Medical Officer, wife of Dr. Raj Kumar Gupta, M/S Moti Chand Santosh Kumar, Moti Mahal, Laha Patti Ballia (U.P.) 277 001 ---- Petitioner(s) -VERSUS1. The Border Security Force, represented by its Director General, Block No.10, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003 2. Special Director General (Eastern Command), Border Security Force, 20/1, Guru Saday Road, Kolkata-700 019 3. The Commandant (Medical), Frontier Head Quarters, Border Security Force, Shillong, Meghalaya-793 006 4. The Deputy Inspector General, Border Security Force, Jowai, Shillong, Meghalaya-793 006 5. The Commandant, 44th Battalion, Border Security Force, Narayanpur, Malda, West Bengal-732 141 6. The Commandant, 44th Battalion, Border Security Force, Mawpat, East Khasi Hills, Shillong, Meghalaya-793 012 7. Dr. A.C. Bhardawajan, then Commandant (Medical), now posted as DIG (Medical), Composite Hospital, Frontier Head Quarter, Border Security Force, Shillong, Meghalaya 8. Sri Vijay Singh (Commandant), Border Security Force, National Crime Records Bureau, East Block-7, R. K. Puram, New Delhi- 110066 For Petitioner(s) For Respondent(s) : : ---- Respondent(s) Mr. A. Bhaumik, Advocate Mr. B. Majumder, ASGI. Date of hearing : 02.02.2022 Date of delivery of Judgment & order Whether fit for reporting : 30.05.2022 : YES HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA Judgment & Order For challenging the adverse remarks in the Annual Performance Appraisal Reports (APAR for short) of the petitioner for the period (i) from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 (ii) from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016 (iii) from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 and (iv) from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017 the petitioner has approached this court as according to her those remarks as recorded, have been recorded firstly, without properly assessing her performance and secondly, the representations that the petitioner filed against such remarks were rejected by the orders dated 28.02.2018 and 18.09.2018. 02. The petitioner has been working as the General Duty Medical Officer (in the rank of Assistant Commandant) in the Border Security Force with effect from 04.08.2006. According to the petitioner, she has been discharging her duties and responsibilities to entire satisfaction of the appropriate authority and without any blemish whatsoever. The performance of the petitioner has been assessed Very Good or Outstanding in the APARs till 31.03.2016. The petitioner has been awarded two commendation cards by the Senior Level Officers and one DG‟s commendation Roll in 2018. One commendation card was issued in October, 2016 in recognition of her excellent performance during the visit of Bangladesh students and BGB delegations to Meghalaya from 2-5 October, 2016. 03. In para-7 of the writ petition, the petitioner has asserted that in the APAR for the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2016 it has been reported as follows: “She performs routine works of Unit MI room without taking any initiative to perform extra in the interest of the Force.” The performance appraisal records of the petitioner for the period from 01.04.2009 to 17.09.2009 [Annexure-2 to the writ petition] from 05.11.2009 to 31.03.2010 [Annexure-3 to the writ petition], from 01.04.2010 to 31.03.2011 [Annexure-4 to the writ petition], from 01.04.2011 to 31.03.2012 [Annexure- to the writ petition], [Annexure-6 to the 31.03.2014 [Annexure-7 from writ to 01.04.2012 petition], the writ from to 31.03.2013 12.07.2013 petition] and to from 01.04.2014 to 23.12.2014 [Annexure-8 to the writ petition] have been produced with the writ petition to demonstrate the assessment results of the petitioner‟s performance as recorded in those APARs. It has been also contended by the petitioner since the petitioner that was transferred from 44th Battalion to 123rd Battalion during the middle of the year 2015, APAR of the petitioner for the said period from 2015-2016 was prepared by bifurcating the period of assessment into two spells in the following manner: (a)From 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 by the Commandant (ADM of 44th Battalion BSF), (b)From 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016 by the Commandant Administrative (ADM, 123rd Battalion BSF. During the entire period of 2015-16 the above units remained under the Command of Sri N.D. Bahuguna, DIG Border Security Force, Jowai, Shillong, Meghalaya being the Reviewing Officer. 04. The petitioner has asserted quite unambiguously that the petitioner had discharged all duties as was assigned, to the entire satisfaction of the appropriate authorities including the other superior officers. The petitioner had carried out the annual medical examination and review medical examination of all medical personnel of the units took initiative to make them aware of various infectious and communicable diseases. Thus, it has been stated by the petitioner that the Administrative Reviewing Officer had closely seen the performance of the petitioner. Hence, the competence of the petitioner during the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 while the petitioner was posted in the 44th Battalion, BSF she was given 7.19 with the following remarks in the APAR: “A well disciplined, hardworking MO takes keen interest in functioning of unit MI room. Overall she is a „very good‟ medical officer.” 05. On 15.04.2016, the Commandant of 123rd Battalion, BSF did initiate for assessment and grading of the petitioner. Finally, the petitioner was graded Very Good. To the utter surprise of the petitioner, on 08.06.2016 meaning after lapse of 10 months, the Commandant (Medical) Frontier Headquarters, BSF, had endorsed the adverse remarks in both the APARs of the petitioner for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 and from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016. The remarks are reproduced hereunder: “(a) From 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 „with an attitude to learn she works with cool mind sincerely needs to improve interaction with troops on border‟. I grade her as „Good‟. (b) From 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016 „Mo who takes and interest in her work and tries to learn the professional work. She needs to improve her interaction skill with troops. I grade her as „Good‟.” 06. Consequently, the petitioner was downgraded to overall numerical grading of 5.60 and the petitioner was graded as „good‟ which has badly affected the career progression of the petitioner like promotion and financial up-gradation. Dr. T. Biswas, the Inspector General (Medical) had also graded with the said remarks as put on on 23.06.2016. The remarks of the Technical Reporting Officer for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 and from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016 in a routine manner without any strong rationally. Those adverse remarks were endorsed by the Inspector General, BSF, Meghalaya Frontier, Shillong. Again for the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 and from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017, the adverse remarks as recorded in the APAR of the petitioner are produced hereunder: “(a) She performs routine work of Unit MI room without taking any initiative to perform extra in the interest of force. (b) She performs routine duty of Unit MI room and reluctant to take initiate on her own.” In the adverse remarks in the APAR with effect from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 are available in Annexure-11, whereas the adverse remarks for the period from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017 are available at Annexure-12 to the writ petition. 07. The petitioner has contended that adverse remarks reflect the performance of the petitioner in the poor light and hence, those adverse remarks have affected the career progression. Such remarks were recorded without providing any opportunity to the petitioner. However, for appraising the performance, no notice is initially required but when the competent authority records adverse remarks then a notice to be sent to the concerned employee/officer by communicating the adverse remarks in verbatim. The Government employee/officer should be allowed to file representation if such remark according to the Government employee/officer is not the reflection of the objective assessment or bad for any other reason. If such opportunity is not given, that amounts to denial of natural justice inasmuch as the employee/officer in that event does not get any opportunity to have his say over such remarks. In para-18 of the writ petition, the petitioner has stated that even though she was dutiful with rectitude but on one occasion when the petitioner was asked to appear before the Board, she could not appear in time for unavoidable circumstances. Even though the petitioner reached the station, she could not beat the time when she was asked to report. The petitioner was served with an advisory by the Commandant (Medical) on 29.02.2016. Except the said minor incident no other incident will be available which may be called as the petitioner‟s deviant act. The Advisory dated 29.02.2016 does not speak of any adverse comment. Despite that, the petitioner has been graded 5.60 which is clearly a downgrading for her career. The petitioner was downgraded to 5.60. 08. On 08.01.2018 by a communication, the petitioner was apprised of the adverse remarks in her APAR from the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 and from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017. The petitioner was made aware that the petitioner might file a representation against those adverse remarks within 15(fifteen) days from the day of receipt. In the APAR the adverse remarks as indicated above was communicated to the petitioner on 08.01.2018 but prior to recording of the adverse remarks, the petitioner was not informed or asked to improve. While specifying the said statement in the writ petition, the petitioner did not disclose or refer under what provision, the respondents are so obligated to notice her. The letter that was sent to the petitioner on 08.01.2016 is enclosed as Annexure-13 to the writ petition. 09. In response thereof, the petitioner filed a detailed representation firstly on 20.01.2018 seeking expunction of the adverse remarks made in APAR for the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 and from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017. In the representation, the petitioner has stated that the said adverse remarks are entirely uncalled for. The petitioner has highlighted her outstanding performance all through. Even the reasons assigned for recording such adverse remarks is not serious and had not been clearly spelt out why such remarks, which are highly prejudicial to the petitioner, had been recorded. The representations by the petitioner were filed on 21.08.2018 and 18.09.2018 but rejected by the respondents by observing that the representations are devoid of merit. The orders of rejection have been enclosed with the writ petition under Annexures-15 & 16. In the Annual Performance Appraisal Report (APAR), the Reporting Officer had given the petitioner 7.19 as numerical grading for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 and numerical grading of 7 for the period from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016. But the Reviewing Officer had entered the adverse remarks in the APAR for the aforesaid period and downgraded the numerical grading to 5.6 and graded her as Good instead of Very Good as was given by the Reporting Officer. The inconsistency according to the petitioner is apparent on the face of the records and hence, it may be taken note of that when the Reporting Officer graded the petitioner Very Good on the basis of numerical grading, the reviewing authority downgraded her to Good. It has been further stated by the petitioner that those assessment recorded in the APAR is untenable. In para-26 of the writ petition, the petitioner has averred that ACR and APAR of the petitioner had been Very Good and Outstanding except for the years 01.04.2015 to 02.07.2017 when the petitioner was downgraded by the officers namely Dr. A.C. Bharadwajan, the then Commandant (Medical) and Sri Vijay Singh, Commandant, 123rd Battalion. 10. The petitioner has further asserted that the representations filed by the petitioner, as stated, were rejected by the orders dated 28.02.2018 and 18.09.2018 by a person who is not competent to consider those representations. After posting of the petitioner to the 44th Battalion from 123rd Battalion, APAR of the petitioner from 03.07.2017 to 31.03.2018 has been again Outstanding with numerical grading 8.0. In the APAR from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017, it has been recorded in respect of the petitioner as follows: “A well disciplined honest lady Medical Officer having good medical professional knowledge. She has a positive attitude and always willing to help.” Thus, the petitioner was graded Very Good. But this time also the Technical Reviewing Officer graded the petitioner as Good. In this backdrop, the petitioner has launched the challenge and urged for the reliefs as noted above. 11. The respondents filed the reply but did not controvert the factual matrix relating to the recording of the adverse remarks or downgrading from Very Good to Good. According to them, the petitioner had all opportunities for filing the reply. The respondents have formed a table to show the adverse remarks made in the PPAR/APAR of the petitioner. The said table is reproduced hereunder: S/N Nomenclature 1. PPAR Period From To 01.04.2015 25.08.2015 2. APAR 26.08.2015 31.03.2016 3. APAR 01.04.2016 31.03.2017 4. PPAR 01.04.2017 02.07.2017 Remarks Dr. A C Bhardwajan, Commandant (Medical) Ftr. Hqrs. BSF, Shillong (Technical Reporting officer ) gave remarks that: “Needs to improve interaction with troops on Border.” Dr. A C Bhardwajan, Commandant (Medical) Ftr. Hqrs. BSF, Shillong (Technical Reporting officer ) gave remarks that: “She needs to improve her interaction shill with troops.” Shri Vijay Singh, Commandant, 123 Bn BSF (Admn I.O) gave remarks that: “She perform routine work of Unit MI Room without taking any initiative to perform extra in the interest of the force.” Shri Vijay Singh, Commandant, 123 Bn BSF (Admn I.O) gave remarks that: “She perform routine duty of unit MI Room and reluctant to take initiative her own.” Grading Awarded Good Good Good Good 12. The respondents have claimed to have followed the instructions contained in the DOP&T OM No.21011/1/2005Estt(A)(Pt-II) dated 14.05.2009. The petitioner was provided a copy of PPAR for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 and a copy of APAR for the period from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016. On 15.06.2017, the petitioner submitted a representation to the Special Director General (Eastern Commandant) BSF against the adverse remarks endorsed and grading awarded by Dr. A. C. Bhardwajan, Commandant (Medical) Ftr HQrs, BSF, Shillong (Technical Reporting Officer) in PPAR for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 and APAR for the period from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016. The Additional Director General (EC) BSF, being the competent authority, has turned down the representation of the petitioner inasmuch as the petitioner could not adduce any material to substantiate her plea raised in the representation. It is well settled that malafide is easier to allege than to proof. The burden of proof lies on the person who alleges it. 13. Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has pointed out that in accordance with instructions contained in DOP&T OM No.21011/1/2005-Estt(A)(Pt-II) dated 14.05.2009, the petitioner was provided copies of APAR for which the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 and PPAR for the period from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017 containing adverse remarks through IPP (Intranet Prahari Project) a dedicated communication network of BSF for her information and representation, if any. The representation dated 20.01.2018 [Annexure-R/2] was rejected after consideration. It has been held that the representation was devoid of merit. But the petitioner has candidly admitted that on 22.02.2016 a medical re-categorization board was held at the Composite Hospital, BSF, Shillong at 12.00 PM to assess the medical category in respect of one Shri S K Sarkar. The said medical re-categorization board was verbally conveyed by the Commandant (Medical) HQr Meghalaya Frontier, BSF. But the petitioner was absent in the said medical board. That had caused, according to the respondents, undue and unavoidable delay in processing of the case. As such, the petitioner was given a show cause to explain the reason for not adhering to the order of the higher authorities by the letter dated 22.02.2016 [Annexure-R/3 to the reply filed by the respondents]. Thereafter, the petitioner was advised to be more cautious in future. It has been further asserted by the respondents that on another occasion also i.e. 02.01.2017, the petitioner was directed to carry out medical examination of six personnel of 123 Bn BSF to ascertain consumption of liquor. But the petitioner did not carry out the said examination as per the procedure laid down in the BSF Medical Directorate Manual (Page No.320) and thus the petitioner was advised to enrich her professional competence and to adopt correct procedure with responsibilities by the letter dated 20.01.2017 [Annexure-R/5 to the writ petition]. 14. period Being aggrieved by those adverse remarks for the from 01.04.2015 31.03.2016, 01.04.2016 02.07.2017, the to to petitioner 25.08.2015, 31.03.2017 filed & 26.08.2015 to 01.04.2017 to representations but those representations were rejected. Those adverse remarks have been sought to be expunged by means of this writ petition. 15. what On scrutiny of the reply filed by the respondents surfaces can briefly be stated. According to the respondents, they have followed the DOP&T office memorandum dated 14.05.2009. PPAR for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 and APAR for the period from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016 containing adverse remarks are under challenge. It has been stated that with the communication the petitioner was apprised of her right to file the representation within 15 days, if any. Accordingly, the petitioner filed the representation dated 15.06.2017. By the said representation, the adverse remarks as endorsed or the grading as awarded by Dr. A C Bhardwajan, Commandant (Medical) Ftr HQrs, BSF, Shillong has been challenged. The Additional Director General (EC) BSF, being the competent authority, had examined the said representation. On careful consideration of the relevant facts noted in the official records the said representation was rejected. Even though in the representation, the allegation of malice or malafide has very strongly been raised but no material to substantiate such allegation has been placed along with the representation or otherwise, when the law is well settled that the person who brings the allegation of malice or malafide had the solitary obligation to substantiate such allegation. As a result, the representation was rejected by confirming the adverse remarks. 16. While rejecting the representation, it has been observed that the petitioner was not active to the expected level in discharging her duties. The decision as regards rejection of the representation was communicated by the letter dated 18.09.2018 [Annexure-16 to the writ petition]. Hence, the respondents have categorically denied the allegations that no opportunity was given to file the representation but in respect of giving any notice prior to recording the adverse remarks, the respondents have laid down the relevant fact in respect of her failure to attend the re-categorization board causing unwarranted delay in processing the case. The petitioner was show-caused to explain why she had failed to adhere the direction of the superior authority to attend the said recategorization board. The reply the petitioner filed did not satisfy the competent authority. As a result, she was issued a formal advisory on 29.02.2016 [Annexure-R/4 to the reply] directing her to be cautious in future. Similarly, the petitioner was, according to the respondents, directed to carry out medical examination of six personnel of 123rd Battalion, BSF to ascertain whether they did consume liquor. On that occasion, the petitioner did not carry out medical examination as per the prescribed procedure. Again the petitioner was „advised‟ to enrich her professional competence and to adopt correct procedure with responsibility, by the letter dated 20.01.2017 [Annexure-R/5 to the reply]. Thus, the respondents have claimed that such action was taken to upgrade her performance and to give her opportunity to come out of her casual attitude etc. They have further stated that the petitioner has an attitude which is not conducive in discharging the duties assigned to her. In respect of the past gradings of the petitioner, the respondents have quite categorically referred to para-2.26 of Chapter-I of APAR Procedure and Instructions-2012 [Annexure-R/6] which provides that the report should neither contain any assessment pertaining to a period prior or subsequent to the reporting period, nor should the assessment be based on a single or isolated instance. The Annual Performance Assessment Reports (APAR)/Part Performance Assessment Reports (PPAR) of the petitioner pertains to a specific period i.e. from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015, 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016, 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 and 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017. The said period has been assessed on the basis of the conduct and overall performance of the petitioner. 17. In response to the challenge, it has been stated that as per the circular on recording of ACR (now APAR) in respect of Doctors serving in the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) issued by the MHA Pers-II vide under No.1-45024/7/2005-PersII dated 19.07.2006 reported/reviewed on the Medical Officer two fronts i.e. has to Technical be and Administrative (Adm) separately. The grading given and remarks endorsed in APAR and PPAR as averred in para-10 of the writ petition pertains to the Administrative Reporting Officer/ Administrative Reviewing Officer. The gradings given and the remarks endorsed by the Technical Reporting Officer are independent. Apart from the views of Administrative Reporting Officer and Administrative Reviewing Officer, the Technical Reporting Officer has assessed the petitioner on technical and professional ground. Therefore, the grading given and the remarks endorsed by the Administrative Reporting Officer and Administrative Reviewing Officer cannot bind the views and assessment of the Technical Reporting Officer. During the period of the assessment, as noted before, Technical Reporting Officer gave the adverse remarks as it was felt that the petitioner needs to improve interaction with „troops‟. The respondents however have admitted the fact relating to the annual inspection by the petitioner. The Deputy Inspector General, Sector Headquarter Jowai had given 7.00 numerical grading on 19.05.2016 in the APAR of the petitioner for the period from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016 not from 26.08.2016 to 31.03.2016, as claimed by the petitioner. 18. The respondents have categorically stated that as per APAR procedure and Instructions-2012 (Para-2.46) the Technical Reporting Officer had to submit APAR to Technical Reviewing Officer after endorsing his remarks by 30.06.2016. The Technical Reporting Officer had endorsed his remarks on 08.06.2016 i.e. well before the prescribed time limit. Thus, the respondents have contended that the Technical Reporting Officer has assessed the petitioner on technical and professional grounds in his independent capacity. The grading given in the remarks endorsed by the Administrative Reporting Officer and Administrative Reviewing Officer cannot bind the Technical Reporting Officer. Thus, the averment of the petitioner that the Technical Reporting Officer downgraded APAR has been denied. The Technical Reporting Officer had initiated APAR on the technical front and graded the petitioner as per her actual professional performance. The grading given by the Technical Reporting Officer is the initial grading, as such, the same cannot be termed as downgrading as averred by the petitioner. 19. In para-14 of the reply, filed by the respondents, they have further elaborated their stand as follows: “As such, the Technical Reviewing Officer has acted lawfully while agreeing with the remarks of Technical Reporting Officer in the PPAR and APAR of the petitioner for the period from 1st April, 2015 to 25th August, 2015 and 26th August, 2015 to 31st March, 2016, respectively. It is denied that the IG BSF, Meghalaya Frontier has endorsed any adverse remarks in the said PPAR/APAR of the petitioner, whereas, being the Accepting Authority, he has agreed to the remarks of Reporting/Reviewing Officers. Therefore, the averments made by the petitioner in this para are baseless and misleading, hence, denied.” 20. In the reply they have reiterated the fact relating to their advisories on two different occasions, in support of the endorsement made in APAR/PPAR following the DOP&T office memorandum dated 14.05.2019. The respondents have categorically averred that in the entirety of the case and after due consideration, the representation dated 15.06.2017 [Annexure-R/1 to the reply] was rejected by the Additional Director General (Eastern Command), BSF being devoid of merit and the said decision was communicated to the petitioner by the speaking order dated 28.02.2018. Another representation of the petitioner dated 20.01.2018 against the adverse remarks in her APAR for the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 and PPAR from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017 was also examined and disposed of, by a reasoned speaking order dated 18.09.2018. As such, the averments of the petitioner in respect of malice, ill-motive and illegality on the part of the Technical Reporting Officer in the matter of endorsing the adverse remarks and gradings, do not provide any ground to interfere. It has been also stated that the orders dated 28.02.2018 and 18.09.2018 were sent to the petitioner under signature of the Staff Officer of the Addl. Director General (Eastern Command) himself. They have also reiterated that the grading/s awarded to the petitioner in the previous years cannot be considered for any purpose. They have also categorically resisted that the remarks of the Technical Reporting Officer in APAR of the petitioner from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 as referred by the petitioner has no connection with the remarks of Administrative Reporting Officer in the said APAR. Thus, they have urged this court that the petitioner does not have any locus standi to maintain this writ petition. 21. The petitioner on 06.03.2020 filed a short rejoinder almost reiterating in the stand taken in the writ petition. But a little bit of recalibration of the statements has been made by the petitioner. The petitioner has asserted that during the assessment period, there was no warning/admonition on the petitioner. Thus, the petitioner has admitted that during the remaining period, the assessment has contained some adverse remarks. Those were made against her due to purported advisories issued before recording those remarks. Now, the petitioner has made an endeavour to pursue this court to go to the final details of the factual matrix. For purpose of reference, paras 9.V and 9.VI are being reproduced hereunder: “V. That, the petitioner denies the contents of Para 2 (vi) of the Counter Affidavit under reply and states that the statements/averments/facts are arbitrary and illegal on the ground that the Petitioner had conducted the Medical Examination of all the six-personnel in accordance with the professional competency as done earlier and being done by the other Medical Officers of the Border Security Force. This was never objected by the AIO/TRO during the entire career of the Petitioner. The six (6) personnel consumed liquor illegally within the campus area without the knowledge of Unit Commandant which itself reflects the poor quality of Command and Control of the Commandant and also shows the professional in-competency in non-maintenance of high order of discipline among the troops for which action should have been taken against the concerned officer(s) for their dereliction of duties as Commandant etc., and for the breach of security and intelligence in unit. VI. That, the Petitioner denies the contents of Para 3 of the Counter Affidavit under reply and states that the statements/averments/facts are arbitrary and illegal on the ground that on 22.06.2016, the Petitioner had taken permission from the concerned Presiding Officer for visiting the Passport Office as the appointment was accorded by the concerned Civil Department much earlier that the detail is said Medical Board and Presiding Officer had agreed and changed the timing of Medical Board from 1200 hrs to 1600 hrs. Accordingly, the said Medical Board was also conducted on the same day and no such undue delay has been made as alleged by the Respondents. This was also explained to the authority concerned by the Petitioner in form of reply to the explanation. Hence, it was not deliberate and willful.” [Emphasis added] 22. This court cannot make any inquiry even on the basis of the strong denial by the respondents. The petitioner thus, framed three questions, as relevant for adjudication of the writ petition: (a) Whether any specific policy exists in BSF for BOP/Borders particularly to be attended by the Medical Officers indicating the number of visits they make, which has been alleged to have been deviated by the petitioner and the deviant act got reflected in the APAR/PPAR? (b) Whether any policy is prescribed in BSF for type of interaction to be carried out by the Medical Officers with the troops other than those related to professional conversation and whether the petitioner has violated that prescription APAR/PPAR? in resulting in adverse remarks in (C) Whether any policy exists in BSF describing the nature of extra duties those may be performed by the Medical Officers of the unit and, which one was not performed by the petitioner during the period under reports? 23. According to the petitioner, the respondents for purpose of fudging the main issues before this Court have quoted the incidents, which are not reflected in APAR/PPAR. But regarding the division of writing APAR by the officers of two wings viz., the professional wing and the administrative wing, the petitioner has not made any categorical response. In para9.9, the petitioner has stated that the Administrative Review Officer and the Technical Review Officer had not visited all the BOPs when the petitioner had visited all BOPs during the tenure and hence, such type of unwarranted and preconceived advisory/adverse remarks in APAR/PPAR was issued to put the petitioner in difficulty in achieving the career progression like promotion etc. The Administrative Reporting Officer had not specified what type of initiative to have been taken by the petitioner in extra in the interest of force other than the professional ones. However, the petitioner had actively taken part in such activities which were recognized by IG, BSF, Shillong by issuing Commendation Card during the period under report and hence, the respondents were deliberate to put forth the questioned remarks for distracting the main issues. 24. In support of their contentions, Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has placed his reliance on a decision of the apex court in Union of India and Another vs. Major Bahadur Singh reported in (2006) 1 SCC 368 where it has been observed as under: “The modalities provided for recording and communication of adverse entries clearly indicate as to in which cases the communication of adverse or advisory remarks are to be made. Word "Advisory" is not necessarily adverse. Great emphasis was laid on the instructions dated 21.8.1989 titled "Reflection and Communication of adverse and advisory remarks in the Confidential Reports". The same reads as follows: The actual pen picture comprises the brief comments given at Paragraphs 13(e)/19(a) of the ACR forms for Majors to Colonels or Paragraphs 13/15 of the ACR Form for Captains and below. Therefore adverse/advisory remarks, if any, should be endorsed in these paragraphs/sub paragraphs only. The information to be given under the Column "Verbal or Written Guidance for Improvement" (i.e. Para 18(b)/19(b) or Para 15/16) is only to support the adverse/advisory remarks reflected in the pen picture. If there are no adverse/advisory remarks reflected in the pen picture, there is no requirement of including details of verbal or written guidance for improvement given to the ratees during the reporting period. It is reiterated that "Performance Counselling is a continuous process and, therefore, the ratee must be given appropriate "Guidance for improvement" as and when noticed. A reading of the instructions clearly indicate that there are different stages: first is the counseling, second is the guidance and third is the consequences of the officer failing to show desired improvement. Only when an officer fails to show the desired improvement the adverse/advisory remarks are included in his Confidential Report so that cognizance is taken for his weakness while planning his future placements. The High Court has clearly overlooked these aspects and on that ground alone the judgment is vulnerable. Additionally, it is noticed that the writ- petitioner had merely made a grievance of non-communication but the High Court quashed the entry for 1989-90 which is clearly indefensible. In the fitness of things, therefore, the High Court should re-hear the matter and consider the grievances of the writ-petitioner in the background of the parameters which clearly exist. We make it clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case as the matter is being remitted to the High Court for fresh consideration.” 25. In this regard, a reference has been made to Deb Dutt vs. Union of India and Others reported in (2008) 8 SCC where the apex court has observed that communication of all entries be made by the concerned officer for upgradation or for appreciation of his performance, which may provide the very foundation for better performance. That apart, it has been observed in Deb Dutt (supra) by the apex court as follows: “We further hold that when the entry is communicated to him the public servant should have a right to make a representation against the entry to the concerned authority, and the concerned authority must decide the representation in a fair manner and within a reasonable period. We also hold that the representation must be decided by an authority higher than the one who gave the entry, otherwise the likelihood is that the representation will be summarily rejected without adequate consideration as it would be an appeal from Caesar to Caesar. All this would be conducive to fairness and transparency in public administration, and would result in fairness to public servants. The State must be a model employer, and must act fairly towards its employees. Only then would good governance be possible.” 26. In addition to those two reports, Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel has placed his reliance on M.A. Rajasekhar vs. State of Karnataka and Another reported in (1996) 10 SCC 369 where the apex court has having referred to the factual matrix of that case, observed that while making the adverse remarks, specific instances shall be referred as regards the failing to discharge the duty, so that the concerned officer can have a fair opportunity to correct himself or can make his representation appropriately. If, no such opportunity, is given, usually no adverse remarks should be recorded. 27. Mr. B. Majumder, learned ASGI has submitted that from the detailed reply as submitted by the respondents, it will transpire that for recording adverse remarks, the petitioner was given ample opportunity for representation against those adverse remarks. When the representation was filed by the petitioner, a superior officer namely, Addl. Director General had taken the exercise of consideration and thereafter, by the orders dated 28.02.2018 and 18.09.2018 respectively for the periods from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 and for the period from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017 rejected the representations dated 20.01.2018 and 28.02.2018. It would be apparent from the orders dated 28.02.2018 and 18.09.2018 that all aspects relating to grievances and the grounds have been met by the said orders. Hence, there is no impropriety or infirmity in recording the adverse remarks in APAR for the period from 01.04.2015 to 31.03.2016 and PPAR from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017. For the above reason, according to Mr. Majumder, learned ASGI, this writ petition merits no further consideration. In support of his contention, Mr. Majumder, learned ASGI has relied on a decision of the apex court in Union of India & Ors vs. E.G. Nambudiri reported in AIR 1991 SC 1216 where the apex court has laid down that when any administrative decision is challenged before the constitutional court for judicial review, the reason for the decision may be placed before the court. The superior authority while considering the representation of a government servant against adverse remarks, is not required by law, to act judicially, but they were under obligation to record or communicate reasons for his decision to the government servant. The decision rejecting the representation does not adversely affect neither vest any right to the government servant nor does it vest with any civil consequences. In many cases, having regard to an infinite variations of circumstances, it may not be possible to disclose reasons for the opinion formed about the work and conduct or character of the Government Servant. In that very case, the adverse remarks as contained in the report were partly expunged but the other part of the adverse remarks was, after scrutiny, maintained. It has been also observed in E.G. Nambudiri (supra) that these remarks are neutral in nature, and they do not form adverse comments upon the respondent's work, conduct or character. As regards the remarks at Serial No. 6, they are self-explanatory, which show that in spite of oral and written warnings, the respondent [the officer who had been assessed] did not improve. If the superior authority was not satisfied with the explanation of the respondent as contained in his representation, what reasons could be stated, except that the authority was not satisfied with the explanation. The superior authority was not obliged to write detail judgment or order giving details of the warnings or the materials on which he formed the opinion. Thereafter, it has been observed as follows: “There is no dispute that there is no rule or administrative order for recording reasons in rejecting a representation. In the absence of any statutory rule or statutory instructions requiring the competent authority to record reasons in rejecting a representation made by a Government servant against the adverse entries the competent authority is not under any obligation to record reason. But the competent authority has no licence to act arbitrarily, he must act in a fair and just manner. He is required to consider the questions raised by the Government servant and examine the same, in the light of the comments made by the office awarding the adverse entries and the officer counter-signing the same. If the representation is rejected after its consideration in a fair and just manner, the order of rejection would not be rendered illegal merely on the ground of absence of reasons. In the absence of any statutory or administrative provision requiring the competent authority to record reasons or to communicate reasons, no exception can be taken to the order rejecting representation merely on the ground of absence of reasons. No order of an administrative authority communicating its decision is rendered illegal on the ground of absence of reasons ex facie and it is not open to the court to interfere with such orders merely on the ground of absence of any reasons. However, it does not mean that the administrative authority is at liberty to pass orders without there being any reasons for the same. In governmental functioning before any order is issued the matter is generally considered at various levels and the reasons and opinions are contained in the notes on the file. The reasons contained in the file enable the competent authority to formulate its opinion. If the order as communicated to the Government servant rejecting the representation does not contain any reasons, the order cannot be held to be bad in law. If such an order is challenged in a court of law it is always open to the competent authority to place the reasons before the Court which may have led to the rejection of the representation. it is always open to an administrative authority to produce evidence alinude before the court to justify its action.” [Emphasis added] 28. Having appreciated the submission of the counsel representing the petitioner and the respondents and scrutinized the material records including the records those are produced by the respondents, this court would make an initial comment that the respondents were not under any obligation to give notice to the petitioner before recording the adverse remarks as communicated. If the authority before whom such representation is made is satisfied with the rationale advanced by the government employee/officer against whom such adverse remarks have been recorded, such remarks would be expunged. In the case in hand, since the adverse remarks as recorded against the petitioner in APAR for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 (the remarks is good), APAR for the period from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016 (the remark is good) APAR for the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 (the remarks is good), and PPAR for the period from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017 (the remarks is good). These remarks have been shown in the table reproduced in para-11 of this judgment. The remarks in PPAR for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 and APAR for the period from 26.08.2015 to 31.03.2016 are exactly identical that the officer [the petitioner] needs to improve interaction with „troop on border‟ or „needs to improve interaction with „troops‟‟. So far APAR for the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017 is concerned remarks that in under challenged is „She performs routine works of Unit MI room without taking any initiative to perform extra in the interest of the Force‟. 29. In PPAR for the period from 01.04.2015 to 25.08.2015 the remarks is almost the same as made in APAR for the period from 01.04.2016 to 31.03.2017. The remarks is she performs routine work of Unit MI room without taking any initiative to perform extra in the interest of the force. In the other remarks as recorded in PPAR from 01.04.2017 to 02.07.2017 it has been recorded that „she performs routine duty of Unit MI room and reluctant to take initiate on her own‟. Those have been categorically challenged by the petitioner in her representation succinctly contending that on the basis of those remarks she had been downgraded but those remarks are vague and unspecified and there is no record that the petitioner was ever asked or shown what kind of interaction the petitioner might have with the troops in the border or with the troops. Even there is no reference what kind of extra work, the petitioner could have done in the Unit MI room which has been stated to be „extra‟ in the interest of the force. The duties as attached to a particular post are broadly available in the records or in their service conditions. But „extra work‟ without description is highly vague. Unless somewhere the petitioner was asked to do any such specified extra work by the superior and which are not unlawful, the petitioner was bound to do that. There is no record to show that the petitioner was deviant from compliance of such order or she was defiant. So far the deficiencies relating to the interactions with the troops are concerned, are absolutely vague. It is not understandable what kind of interactions the petitioner was supposed to carry out. Whether those were related to medical intervention considering his/her position as the Chief Medical Officer attached to the 44th Battalion is not made perceivable. What is more surprising is that several deficiencies have been taken into consideration in order to downgrade the petitioner to good. But there is no remarks or reflections in PPAR or APAR, but it is admitted that those remarks as reflected in the reply filed by the respondents were considered in order to downgrade the petitioner. Such act is highly arbitrary. One isolated incident where the petitioner was asked to show cause why she had not adhered to the order of the superior as regards the board meeting has been taken into consideration going beyond the DOPT instruction. The said show-cause proceeding was closed with an advisory to be cautious in future. That apart, the petitioner did not get any other advisory or guidance to be followed. Suddenly, those adverse remarks were made. Some incidents have been referred by the respondents in their reply as regards the medical duties etc. or to follow the medical procedure with responsibility, but those were only brought to the notice of the petitioner by way of the said reply. It may be noted here that the respondents have referred to para-2.26 of Chapter1 of APAR Procedure and Instruction, 2012 [Annexure-R/6 to the reply] where it has been categorically provided that the report should neither contain any assessment pertaining to a period prior or subsequent to the reporting period, nor should the assessment be based on a single or isolated instance. In the present case the respondents have given undue weightage to one instance of failure in attending the board meeting. Such absence has been explained by the petitioner. The respondents ought to have avoided to take consideration of single or isolated instance. Other two instances have been revealed in the reply only, filed by the respondents. This court is constrained to observe that those instances were adequate in making adverse remarks. Adverse remarks flows from one advisory. But other advisories advisories were not passed to the petitioner either for guidance or for making the petitioner cautious. As such, the petitioner cannot be expected to follow those advisories which were not available even in the official records or in the condition of service. The petitioner has correctly stated that those advisories are so vague that nothing could be gathered from those advisories. Why the Chief Medical Officer will interact with the troops in the border or interact with the troops in other place, unless there are guidelines, prescribed by the competent authority. The petitioner has categorically stated that her devotion has been underrated severely. Her method of discharging the duties has been questioned. 30. As such, this court is of the view that those remarks as recorded against the petitioner for the aforesaid period are wholly unwarranted as there is no material to sustain those remarks in view of the discussion made hereinabove. The report of the technical reporting officer has come in complete contrast to that of the administrative reporting officer. Administrative Reporting Officer graded the petitioner very good and only on the basis of those observations, the petitioner was downgraded to good. Therefore, the order of rejection dated 28.02.2018 and 18.09.2018 are the outcome of non-application of mind to the relevant facts as borne in the records. Hence, those orders are interfered with and set aside. In Major Bahadur Singh (supra), it has been observed that advisory is not necessarily adversarial. In the present context, even there is no reference to any instruction which clearly obligates the petitioner to perform „extra duty‟ nor the petitioner was in a position to conceive her extra duty from any source. That apart, there had been no other advisory to the petitioner for discharging her duties. In Major Bahadur Singh (supra), the apex court having referred to the instruction dated 21.08.1989 has categorically observed that reading of the instructions clearly indicate that there are three stages: first is the counselling, second is the guidance and third is the consequences of the officer‟s failing to show desired improvement. Only when an officer fails to show the desired improvement, the adverse remarks are made and included in the confidential report, so that cognizance is taken of his weakness while planning his future placements. In this case, there is no instruction or advisory on interaction with the troops in border nor had there been any other why the petitioner can perform some extra work in the MI Unit. Those advisories as recorded in PPAR/APAR are vague and does not cull out any specific meaning which can be translated into action or performance. 31. Thus, this court is of the view that those adverse remarks as shown in the separate table below are absolutely unwarranted and hence, those are expunged from the service records of the petitioner. S/N Nomenclature 1. PPAR Period From To 01.04.2015 25.08.2015 2. APAR 26.08.2015 31.03.2016 3. APAR 01.04.2016 31.03.2017 4. PPAR 01.04.2017 02.07.2017 Remarks Dr. A C Bhardwajan, Commandant (Medical) Ftr. Hqrs. BSF, Shillong (Technical Reporting officer ) gave remarks that: “Needs to improve interaction with troops on Border.” Dr. A C Bhardwajan, Commandant (Medical) Ftr. Hqrs. BSF, Shillong (Technical Reporting officer ) gave remarks that: “She needs to improve her interaction shill with troops.” Shri Vijay Singh, Commandant, 123 Bn BSF (Admn I.O) gave remarks that: “She perform routine work of Unit MI Room without taking any initiative to perform extra in the interest of the force.” Shri Vijay Singh, Commandant, 123 Bn BSF (Admn I.O) gave remarks that: “She perform routine duty of unit MI Room and reluctant to take initiative her own.” Grading Awarded Good Good Good Good Since the adverse remarks in PPARs and APARs for the period as indicated in the table have been expunged by this court, the Director General, Border Security Force shall reassess and award the grading as befitting to the petitioner. It is made absolutely clear that the allegations as brought against the petitioner shall not be taken into consideration as those were not on the basis of the assessment of performance of the petitioner. Since the adverse remarks have been expunged by this court, the petitioner‟s performance shall be reviewed only on the basis of the remarks of the Reporting Officer. Hence, this writ petition stands allowed to the extent as indicated above. It is further directed that the Director General, BSF shall complete the assessment as indicated above within a period of two months from the date when a copy of this order be furnished by the petitioner. In the result, the writ petition stands allowed. There shall be no order as to costs. Records, as produced by the respondents, be returned to Mr. B Majumder, learned Asst. SG forthwith. JUDGE Moumita

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Tripura HC judgments →