Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Tr.P.(Crl.) No.02 of 2023
Dr. Kaushik Das, Slo Sri Jagat Chandra Das, R/o Arabinda Colony, Amarpur,
P.S. Birganj,Gomati Tripura, Pin-799101
....Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
2. Sri Sankar Banik,S/o Sri Ratan Banik, Vill: Jolaibari, P.S. Baikhora, Dist:
South Tripura, Pin-799141
3. Sri Abhijit Saha, S/oSri Amrit Lal Saha, Vill: Jolaibari, P.S.Baikhora,South
Tripura, Pin-799141
4. SriTitan Paul, S/o Lt. Narayan Chandra Paul, Vill: Jolaibari, P.S. Baikhora.,
Dist: South Tripura, Pin-799141
5. Sri Mithun Banik @ Mitan, S/o Sri Parimal Banik, Vill: Jolaibari, P.S.
Baikhora,Dist: South Tripura, Pin-799141
6. Sri Ganesh Banik, SloLt. Rakhal Chandra Banik, Vill: Natunbazar Sukanta
Colony, P.S: Natunbazar, Dist:Gomati Tripura, Pin-799101
Respondent(s)
Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Anirban Bhattacharjee,Advocate,
Mr. E.L. Darlong, Advocate,
Ms. P.Das, Advocate.
........
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
Mr. P.K. Biswas, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Ratan Datta, Public Prosecutor,
Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.,
Mr. R. Nath, Advocate.
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
17/08/2023
Heard Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner,Mr. Ratan Datta, learned Public Prosecutorfor the respondents-State
andMr. P.K. Biswas, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. R. Nath, learned
counsel, appearing for private respondentsNo.2 to 6.
The petitioner has made a prayer under Section 407 read with
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. for withdrawal and transfer of ST (Type-1) 34 of
2015 from the Court of learned Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur to any other Court of competent jurisdiction within the State of
Tripura.
The learned SessionsJudge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur has,
by the impugned order dated 10.08.2023,rejected the applicationmade by the
accused/petitionerherein under Section 408 of the Cr.P.C for transfer of the
case to any other Sessions Court.
3.
Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner,has drawn the attentionof this Court to the applicationunder Section
408 of the Cr.P.C. at Annexure-5,affidavitof which was sworn on 09.08.2023
and copies thereofwere received by the learned counsel appearing for the five
accused persons on 10.08.2023.By referringto the averments of the application
under Section 408, learned senior counsel has submitted that the accused
entertainslikelihoodof bias in view of certain observationsmade by the learned
Sessions Court in the face of the accused on 05.08.2023 when the arguments
were concluded from both sides and the case was reserved for judgment on
24.08.2023.
Apart from that, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has
drawn the attention of this Court to the order sheet of the Sessions Trial Case
starting from 24.05.2023till01.07.2023 when the case was being heard by the
predecessorPresidingOfficer of the present incumbent. It is submitted that the
evidence is voluminous and therefore the argument on the part of the main
accused i.e. the petitioner could not be concluded at that point of time.
Thereafterthe present incumbent has taken over and the case was taken up for
arguments on 13.07.2023. Thereatter, on 31.07.2023 and on 05.08,2023.
arguments were concluded and judgment reserved. The learned senior counsel
for the accused petitioner herein could not get enough time to
conclude his
arguments, but the case has been reserved for judgment. The learned Sessions
Court, therefore, appears to be in a hurry and there is an apprehensionthat the
approach of the learned Sessions Judge may lead to miscarriage of justice.
5.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has relied upon certain
decisions of the Apex Court such as K. Anbazhagan vrs. Superintendentof
Police and others reported in (2004)3 SCC 767 and Sri JayendraSaraswathy
Swamigal (Il), TN. vrs. State of T.N. and others reported in (2005) 8 SCC
771 in support of his submission that an apprehension of bias against the
Presiding Officer should be duly taken into consideration for fair trial of a
criminal case, as it relates to the life and liberty of an individual. Petitioner is
facing a prosecutionunder Section 302 of the IPC. Learned senior counsel for
the petitionerhas also relied upon Section 407(5) of Cr.P.C. to submit that the
learned Sessions Judge took up the matter on the same date on which the
applicationwas filed and rejected it on non-tenablegrounds.
6.
Mr. Ratan Datta, learned Public Prosecutor for the respondents
State, has strongly opposed the prayer. He has also drawn the attention of this
Court to the petition under Section 408 of the Cr.P.C. [Annexure-5] and in
particular,the averments at paragraph 13 and 19 thereof. It is submittedthat the
order sheet of the Sessions case enclosed to the instant petition shows that on
31.07.2023, the learned senior counsel representing the accused/present
petitioner concluded his arguments. Thereafter, the case was fixed for
05.08.2023 for argument on behalf of the other counsel representingthe other
five accused persons. There was no objection to this on behalfof the petitioner.
On 05.08.2023, again when the learned senior counselsought to submit his
written argument in open Court after conclusion of oral argument, the learned
Trial Court was gracious enough to allow himn to submit it before the judgment
is pronounced. It is submitted that the officer has been posted only in the last
month. There is no allegation of any previous grudge or enmity against the
present petitioner on the part of the present Presiding Officer. The Sessions
Trial is of the year 2015 and it should not be allowed to be lingered at the
behest of one of the accused persons when no other accused person has made
such a request for transfer of the case.Therefore,the impugned order needs no
interference.No grounds have been made out for transfer of the case to any
other SessionsDivisionsince the apprehensionis only imaginary.
7.
Mr. P.K. Biswas, learned senior counsel representingthe private
respondents, has also strongly opposed the prayer. He has further added that if
such an approach on the part of an accused is encouraged, it would amount to
demoralizingthe Court concernedand would affect the administrationof justice
in the State. Therefore,the applicationneeds to be rejected.
Ihave considered the submissionof learned counsel for the parties
and taken note of the facts placed from record. I have also gone through the
order sheets of the Sessions Trial case starting from 24.05.2023 till the
arguments concluded on 05.08.2023. At the outset, it needs to be indicated that
it is aSessions Trial of the year 2015. It is eight years by now when evidence
has been concluded on the part of both the sides in the year 2022 itself, as per
the statementsmade by learned senior counsel tor the petitioner.The arguments
have stretched for a number of dates betore the predecessor of the present
Presiding Officer. However, it is evident that after the present incumbent took
over, the arguments were heard by him on 13.07.2023.The order sheet reads as
under:
"13.07.2023
Ld. P.P. Sri Saktipada Chakrabortystarted his argument.
Heard him partly.
Fix 31-07-2023 for rest part of the argument by the
prosecution.
Thereafter it was taken up on 31.07.2023, when learned senior counsel
representingthe present accused petitionerconcluded his arguments. The order
dated 31.07.2023is also extracted hereunder:
"31-07-2023
Ld. P.P. Sri Saktipada Chakrabortyis present.
1. Ld. Counsel Sri Jyotishmoy Das is allowed to be represented the
accused Koushik Das as per provision U/S.317of Cr.P.C. in the light of specific
prayer made on his behalf.
2. Ld. CounselSri Jyotishmoy Das is led by Ld. Senior Counsel Sri
Samrat Kar Bhowmik.
3. Ld. Counsel Asif lgbal is allowed to be represented the accused Titan
Paul as per provisionU/S.317 of Cr.P.C.in the light of specificprayer made on
his behalf.
4. Accused persons namely Sankar Banik, Mithan Banik, Abhijit Saha
and Ganesh Banik on bail are present with their engaged Counsel Asif lqbal.
5. Today Ld. P.P as well as Ld. Senior Counsel Sri Samrat Kar Bhowmik
have concluded their argument.
6. Ld. Counsel Asif lqbal has verbally prayed for fixing the instant case
on 05-08-2023 for placing his argument in this case.
7. Considered.Prayer is allowed.
8. Ld. Counsel Sri Abir Baran has filed written argument on behalf of
defectocomplainantby supplyingcopy to the other side.
9. Keep it with the case record.
Fix 05-08-2023 for further argument."
9.
It further appears that there was no protest on the part of the
present petitionerregardingconclusionof his argument in a hurried manner on
31.07.2023. On 0S.08.2023, arguments of both the sides were heard and the
case was fixed for judgment on 24.08.2023. It is only thereafter that an
application on 10.08.2023 has been made for transfer of the case from one
SessionsCourt to another SessionsCourt invoking Section 408 of the Cr.P.C. It
further appears that no other accused has objected to the conclusion of
arguments or have supported the allegation of the petitioner that he was not
allowedto complete his arguments in full.This isquite conspicuous.
10.
Mr. Biswas, learned senior counsel, representing the private
respondents/otheraccused persons, has also strongly objected to such a move
on the part of one accused, as it may lead to demoralization of the Court
concerned.
11.
The atterntion of this Court has been drawn to the provisions of
Section 407(5) of the Cr.P.C. The provisionsof the Criminal Procedure Code
have to be read as to advance the interest of justice as they are handmaiden of
justice. The petitioner has not been able to show that any prejudice has been
caused to him on that account. This Court does not find any element of bias
borne from the records against the present Presiding Officer of the Sessions
Court, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur for the reasons indicated hereinabove.
It is therefore not inclined to accede to the prayer of transfer of this case to any
other Session Divisions when the trial is at the fag end. In fact the evidence has
concluded in the year 2022 and the arguments have been concluded on
05.08.2023.The case is posted for 24.08.2023 for judgment. It appears from the
averments made at paragraph 19 of the transfer petition under Section 408 of
the Cr.P.C. that the learned Court has been gracious to allow the
petitioner to
submit his written arguments before paSsing of the judgment; though
314 of the Cr.P.C. requires written submission or
memorandum to the Court
setting forth concisely and under distinct headings in support of the
the oral argumentshave concluded.
Section
case before
12.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the
decision rendered in the case of K. Anbazhagan (supra) which related to
transfer of criminal cases pending against the Chief Minister of the State and
her close relatives/associates from one state to another state. The decision
said case are distinguishableon facts in the present matter. The instant
of the
decision
relates to objections raised on the ground of political vendetta
raising
justice
reasonableapprehensionof likelihoodof bias in dispensationof criminal
In the present case, the incumbent has taken over
the office of the Sessions
Court, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur only one month back
and has
endeavoured to hear and conclude the trial of the case which was pending since
Swamigal
2015.system. The decision in the case of Sri JayendraSaraswathy
(I1), T.N. (supra) relates to inter-state transfer of criminal case
against the
accused who was a religious seer on the allegations of attempt by the
prosecution machinery to demoralize and scare the petitioner'ssenior counsel
by scandalizinghis reputation and casting a slur on his character and conduct.
False cases were lodged against other lawyers appearing for the defence.
13.
The facts of the present case are distinguishablefrom the decisions
cited above. The principle in this regard is well settled that a party should bear
reasonable apprehensionthat justice may not be done to support a prayer for
transfer of acase from one Court to another or from one Session Division to
another Session Division in a state. The petitioner has failed to make out any
case of motivated prosecutionor bias on the part of the PresidingOfticer who
has endeavouredto conclude the trial which is pending since 2015.
14.
In these circumstances,this Court is satisfied that no interference
is required in the impugned order. The petitionerhas failed to make out a case
Page & of 8
for exercise of inherent powers of the High Court. As such, the instant petition
is dismissed.
15.
Pending application(s),if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SIÑGH), CJ
Pijush MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2023.08.21 13:20:56 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review