Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:SHC:91-DB
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWANATH SOMADDER, CHIEF JUSTICE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari,
aged about 66 years,
Son of late Tika Ram Bhandari,
Resident of Balwakhani,
Gangtok, Sikkim,
Pin – 737101.
…..Appellant
versus
1. State of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms,
Training and Public Grievances,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, Sikkim,
Pin- 737102.
2. Department of Health Care and Family Welfare,
Through the Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, Sikkim,
Pin: 737102.
….. Respondents
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Appeal under Chapter V Rule 148 of the Sikkim High Court
(Practice and Procedure) Rules, 2011
[ against the impugned judgment dated 27th August, 2024 passed by the learned
Single Judge in W.P.(C) No. 39 of 2020 in the matter of
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Another ]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Ms Laxmi Chakraborty, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Aarohi Bhalla, Additional Advocate General with Mr. Thinlay
Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate for the Respondents No. 1 and 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
JUDGMENT
( 7th August, 2025 )
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
The short question that arises for consideration
before this Court is whether the appellant/petitioner is
entitled to Super Speciality and Performance Allowance (for
short, the Allowance) of Rs.2,00,000/- per month from June
1988 to June 1991 and thereafter, Rs.3,75,000/- per
month, till date of his retirement, in terms of notification
bearing no. 158/GEN/DOP dated 19.12.2018 (for short,
notification dated 19.12.2018)?
2.
The learned Single Judge concluded that the
appellant was not entitled to the Allowance. It was also held
that in view of the rectification of the notification dated
19.12.2018 by notification bearing no. 200/GEN/DOP dated
06.02.2019 (for short, notification dated 06.02.2019), the
question on retrospectivity received a quietus.
3.
Unsatisfied with the impugned judgment, the
appellant raises the question once again for an appellate
determination.
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
4.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellant as
well as the respondents. The learned counsel for the
appellant submits that in terms of the notification dated
19.12.2018, the petitioner is entitled to the Allowance as
sought for. Paragraph 2 (iii) of notification dated 19.12.2018
makes the Allowance admissible to the petitioner as he was
an existing member of the Sikkim State Health Service with
requisite
experience.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents submits that the impugned judgment does not
suffer from perversity or errors apparent on the face of the
record.
5.
The appellant contends he obtained MBBS Degree from
King George’s Medical College, Lucknow in the year 1981; he
completed Master of Medicine (Medicine) in 1985 and
thereafter completed D.M. (Cardiology) from King George’s
Medical College in 1987; the appellant was appointed in the
year 1988 as Consultant (Cardiology) in the Health & Family
Welfare Department; on 08.06.2011, the State re-designated
the post of the appellant from Director General of Health
Service to that of Director General-cum-Secretary, Health
Care & Human Services and Family Welfare Department; his
service was extended on 25.07.2016, 31.08.2017 and
25.08.2018; and retired on superannuation on 31.08.2019.
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
6.
After
the
issuance
of
notification
dated
19.12.2018, the appellant on 21.01.2019 processed an
official noting to the Government of Sikkim claiming the
Allowance of Rs.2,00,000/- per month, from June 1988 to
June 1991 and thereafter, Rs.3,75,000/- per month, till his
retirement. On 23.04.2019, the appellant made a written
representation to the Commissioner-cum-Secretary of the
Department of Health Care, Health Services and Family
Welfare, Government of Sikkim, requesting him to consider
his office note. In response, vide letter dated 07.05.2019, the
Special Secretary informed the appellant that he was eligible
for such Allowance only from 19.12.2018 to 31.01.2019. The
appellant issued several legal notices and thereafter, filed
the writ petition on 24.11.2020, which was considered and
dismissed by the learned Single Judge.
7.
The notification dated 19.12.2018 reads as under:
“GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL, ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS,
TRAINING AND PUBLIC GRIEVANCES
GANGTOK
No:
158/GEN/DOP
Dated: 19/12/18
NOTIFICATION
The State Government is hereby pleased to grant
incentive to doctors on appointment as Consultant, Selection
Grade II with minimum qualification as Doctorate of
Medicine (DM) or Magister Chirurgiae (M. Ch.) from a
recognized Medical College strictly as per norms of Medical
Council of India (MCI) through direct recruitment in the
Sikkim State Specialist wing of the Sikkim State Health
Service under Health Care, Human Services and Family
Welfare Department, Government of Sikkim as Super
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Speciality and Performance Allowance with effect from the
date of joining service, as under; namely:(i)
Super Speciality and Performance Allowance for the
doctors having clinical/teaching experience of more
than 03 (three) years as Specialist: Rs.3,75,000/- per
month.
(ii)
Super Speciality and Performance Allowance for the
doctors having clinical/teaching experience as
Specialist of less than 03 (three) years: Rs.2,00,000/per month.
2. The Super Speciality and Performance Allowance
shall be in addition to existing pay and allowances applicable
to the posts in the appropriate grade scale of pay under the
relevant rules and shall be extendable to the members of
teaching faculty of the Medical Colleges under the
Government of Sikkim. The entitlement of the Allowance is
subject to fulfilment of following terms, namely:(i)
The Allowance is automatically added at the time of
initial appointment with effect from the date of joining
service. Those joining with less than 03 (three) years
experience with Rs.2,00,000/- lakhs per month Super
Speciality and Performance Allowance will be entitled
for enhancement to Rs.3,75,000/- lakhs per month on
completion of 03 (three) years experience.
(ii)
For the grant of Super Speciality Performance
Allowance, period of experience in clinical and teaching
field while rendering super speciality service shall be
reckoned. Therefore, the candidates from General
Duty and Public Health Wing who joins the rank by
mode of absorption on acquirement of Post-Doctorate
degrees shall also be entitled for Super Speciality and
Performance Allowance on acquirement of required
experience as Super Specialist.
(iii)
The Allowance is admissible to the existing members of
the Sikkim State Health Service subject to accessible
experience.
(iv)
This Allowance is subject to review by Super Speciality
Board/competent authorities from time to time.
By order and in the name of the Governor.
Sd/(SIPORAH G. TARGAIN, SCS)
SPECIAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT
………………………………………”
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
8.
The notification dated 06.02.2019 reads as under:
“GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL, ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS,
TRAINING AND PUBLIC GRIEVANCES
No: 200/GEN/DOP
Dated: 6/2/19
NOTIFICATION
In
partial
modification
to
Notification
Number:158/GEN/DOP, dated:19/12/2018, in para 1, after
the word Performance allowance”, for the words “with
effect from the date of joining service”the following words
“with effect from the date of issue of Notification”shall be
substituted.
By order and in the name of the Governor.
Sd/(Tenzing Gelek) IAS
COMMISSIONER-CUM-SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT
OF
PERSONNEL,
TRAINING AND PUBLIC GRIEVANCES
TO
THE
GOVERNMENT
ADMINISTRATIVE
REFORMS,
………………………………………”
9.
Notification dated 19.12.2018 indicates that:
a) it was an incentive scheme envisaged by the
Government.
b) the incentive was to grant Allowance to doctors
on appointment as Consultant, Selection Grade–II
with
minimum
qualification
as
Doctorate
of
Medicine (DM) or Magister Chirurgiae (M.Ch.) from
a recognized Medical College strictly as per norms
of Medical Council of India.
c) the appointment envisaged in the notification
dated 19.12.2018 was through direct recruitment
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
in the Sikkim State Specialist Wing of the Sikkim
State Health Service.
d) the amount of Allowance offered was higher (i.e,
Rs.3,75,000/- per month) for doctors having
clinical/ teaching experience of more than 3 years
as Specialist.
e) the amount of Allowance offered was lesser (i.e,
Rs.2,00,000/- per month) for doctors having
clinical/teaching experience as Specialist of less
than 3 years.
f) the Allowance was to be in addition to the
existing pay and allowances applicable to the post
in the appropriate grade scale of pay and was
extendable to members of teaching faculty of
Medical
Colleges
under
the
Government
of
Sikkim.
g) the entitlement of the Allowance was subject to
fulfilment of the following terms, namely:(i)
The Allowance was to be automatically added at
the time of initial appointment with effect from the
date of joining service.
(ii)
The period of experience in clinical and teaching
field while rendering super speciality service was
to be reckoned. Therefore, the candidates from
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
General Duty and Public Health Wing who joins
the rank by mode of absorption or acquirement of
Post-Doctorate degrees shall also be entitled for
the
Allowance
on
acquirement
of
required
experience as Super Specialist.
(iii)
The Allowance was admissible to the existing
members of Sikkim State Health Service subject
to accessible experience.
(iv)
The Allowance was subject to review by Super
Speciality Board/competent authorities from time
to time.
10.
The notification dated 19.12.2018 was prospective
in nature. It was not made retrospective either by explicit
words or by implication.
11.
The notification dated 19.12.2018, when on its
plain language postulated prospective operation, it cannot
be treated to be operative retrospectively. More so, when the
notification dated 19.12.2018 postulates financial benefits to
the eligible incumbents.
12.
The State is entitled to make policy decisions and
policy decisions are prospective in nature unless made
explicitly retrospective.
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
13.
The
notification
dated
06.02.2019
partially
modified the notification dated 19.12.2018 replacing the
words “with effect from the date of joining service” with the
words “with effect from the date of issue of Notification”. The
learned Single Judge has held that the notification was
clarificatory in nature and we do not seek to differ from that
view.
14.
The
letter
dated
07.05.2019
informed
the
appellant that he was eligible for such incentive only from
19.12.2018 to 31.01.2019. This was the stand taken by the
State in its counter as well. 19.12.2018 was the date of
notification granting incentive to the doctors and 31.01.2019
was the date of the petitioner’s superannuation. Therefore,
the stand of the respondents that the petitioner was eligible
to get the Allowance for the period was correct.
15.
Notification
dated
19.12.2018
makes
the
allowance admissible to the existing members of the Sikkim
State Health Service subject to accessible experience. It,
however,
does
not
make
the
incentive
applicable
retrospectively to grant the Allowance to existing members of
the Sikkim State Health Service who had obtained the
requisite experience much prior to the issuance of the
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
notification dated 19.12.2018. It was a policy decision taken
by the Government, conceived at that point of time, when
the notification dated 19.12.2018 was issued.
16.
The learned Single Judge while examining the
issues also examined Rule 4(1) and (2) of the Sikkim State
Health Service Rules, 1993 and observed that the words
“appointed day” as appears in the said Rule would be April
26, 1975, as laid down in Article 371F of the Constitution of
India. With respect, the observation has been made without
examining Rule 2(a) of the Sikkim State Health Service
Rules, 1993 which defines the words “appointed day”.
According to Rule 2(a), the “appointed day” would be “the
date from which the provisions of these rules come into force”.
Since, the Sikkim State Health Service Rules, 1993 was
published in the Sikkim Government Gazette on 18.10.1993
that would be the “appointed day” as per Rule 1(2).
Therefore, it would not be possible for us to concur with the
findings of the learned Single Judge made pursuant to the
above observation.
17.
The
notification
dated
19.12.2018,
being
prospective in nature, we find it unnecessary to examine the
various issues raised by the parties and examined by the
2025:SHC:91-DB
W.A. No. 03 of 2024
Dr. K. Bhandari vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
learned Single Judge with regard to the petitioner’s grade or
clinical/teaching experience as a Specialist prior to his
entitlement. The respondents have themselves agreed and
granted the Allowance to the petitioner prospectively.
However, we are in agreement with the learned Single Judge
that the petitioner was not entitled to the Allowance
retrospectively.
18.
We, therefore, see no reason to interfere with the
impugned judgment rendered by the learned Single Judge as
in an intra-Court writ appeal, the Appellate Court must
restrain itself and interference with the judgment passed by
the learned Single Judge is permissible only if the judgment
of the learned Single Judge is palpably perverse or suffers
from an error apparent in law. We find no such palpable
perversity or error apparent in law.
19.
Accordingly, the writ appeal stands dismissed.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
bp
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review