Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.509 of 2023
Dr. Indrajit Das son of Sri Suchitra Mahishya Das aged about 40 years,
resident of Village & P.O. Bilthai, P.S. Panisagar North Tripura, SubDivision, Panisagar, District- North Tripura, Pin-799260.
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura represented by Secretary Health and Family Welfare
Department, Civil Secretariat, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S.
New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. Director of Medical Education, Government of Tripura, Bidurkarta
Choumuhoni, Building of Lal Path Lab, P.S. West Agartala, Agartala, P.O.
Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799001.
3. Dr. Tushar Majumder, Tripura Health Service, Grade-IV, presently posted
at Agartala Government Medical College and GBP Hospital, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura, Pin-799006.
4. Dr. Shimal Sarkar, Tripura Health Service Grade-III, presently posted at
Bimal Sinha Memorial Hospital, Kamalpur, District- Dhalai, Tripura.
..…. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Sankar Lodh, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Dipankar Sharma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment : 19th October, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and also heard Mr. Dipankar Sharma, learned Additional
Government Advocate appearing for the respondents-State.
[2]
Petitioner has approached this Court with a grievance that his
name has been excluded in the revised final merit list published on
05.08.2023 (Annexure-8) whereas respondents No.3 and 4 both belonging to
SC category have been placed above him for the purposes of appointment as
Basic Teacher in the subject of Anesthesiology under the advertisement
dated 11.02.2022 (Annexure-1). The case of the petitioner is encapsulated in
the order dated 14.08.2023 whereby learned counsel for the State was asked
to seek instructions and in the meantime the respondents were restrained
from offering appointment in favour of any candidate in SC category in the
subject of Anesthesiology in AGMC and GBP Hospital, Tripura on the post
of Basic Teacher. The order dated 14.08.2023 is extracted hereunder.
“The grievance of the petitioner is in relation to his exclusion
from the revised final merit list published on 05.08.2023 [Annexure-8] in
which the petitioner has gone down in the merit list and respondents No.3
and 4, both also belonging to the SC category, have been placed above
him. The final merit list notified on 25.04.2023 inclusive of UR or SC
candidates for the subject of Anesthesiology showed the petitioner as the
first candidate who had got 76.67 marks. The private respondent No.4
had got 66.334 marks and respondent No.3 had got 58.19 marks in the
SC category. Even before that, in the provisional merit list published on
11.01.2023 for appointment to the post of Basic Teacher in AGMC and
GBP Hospital in the subject of Anesthesiology under advertisement dated
11.02.2022 [Annexure-1], petitioner had got 85.67 marks, whereas
respondents No.3 and 4 had got 88.19 and 63.334 marks respectively on
evaluation of the eligibility criteria such as API score, seniority in
Tripura Health Services, placement in difficult/remote area and
performance (ACR) as per the criteria prescribed under Rule 3(b) of the
Tripura Medical Education (Administrative & Faculty) Service
Conditions (2nd Amendment Rules), 2021 [Annexure-5] notified on
07.09.2021. Petitioner apprehends that the period of his service spent in a
remote area at Khedacherra Primary Health Centre has been excluded
while preparing the revised merit list.
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
since the amended Rules of 2021 do not prescribe for the criteria for
awarding marks for posting in a difficult/remote area, the only
notification which can be banked upon is dated 07.07.2018 issued by the
Health & Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura
[Annexure-4]. Against the UR category, one Dr. Rajesh Choudhury has
got the maximum marks as per the revised merit list for the subject of
Anesthesiology being 62.31 marks; but since petitioner’s marks have
been reduced in the revised merit list, he has been ousted from being
considered for appointment to one SC vacancy for the said subject.
Instead, in his place, Dr. Tushar Majumder, who is having 58.19 marks,
is going to be appointed. Petitioner has applied under RTI vide
Annexure-9 for seeking information as to the manner in which the
tabulation sheet and declaration of the final merit list has been done; and
on what basis, the marks under the head of difficult/remote area service
has been awarded. However, since the application has been made only on
08.08.2023, till date information has not been supplied.
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for
the respondents-State, seeks short time to obtain instructions.
As such, let the matter appear on 23.08.2023. In the
meantime, the respondents would not proceed to offer appointment to the
post of Basic Teacher in favour of any candidate in SC category in the
subject of Anesthesiology in AGMC and GBP Hospital, Tripura.”
[3]
Respondents have filed their counter-affidavit. It is stated that
the advertisement dated 11.02.2022 invited application from all in service
eligible Medical Officers those who had completed their MCI/NMC
recognized Postgraduate (MD/MS/DNB) course from any MCI/NMC
recognized institution and were presently working under the Health &
Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura, along with all relevant
documents/certificates and service certificates for absorption in 19 vacancy
positions in different disciplines from Tripura Health Services, Government
of Tripura to Agartala Government Medical College, as per Tripura Medical
Education (Administrative & Faculty) Service Condition (2nd Amendment)
Rules, 2021 to the post of Basic Teacher (Tutor/Senior Resident/Registrar).
Candidates were required to submit their application on or before 25.02.2022
within office hours. Subsequently, by notice dated 16.02.2022, the last date
for submission of application was extended up to 5.00 p.m. of 28.02.2022.
Taking through the chronology of dates, the counter-affidavit of the
respondent refers to the provisional common merit list prepared by the
Scrutiny Committee on 11.01.2023 inviting objection from any Medical
Officers regarding the provisional common merit list with supporting
documentary evidence. Initially, writ petitioner was awarded 21.67 marks
under the head of API, 30 marks under the head of seniority, 30 marks under
the head of serving in difficult/remote area and 4 marks under the head of
publication and performance, total 85.67 marks in the provisional merit list.
Respondent No.3, Dr. Tushar Majumder was awarded 19.99 marks under
head of API, 30 marks under the head of seniority, 30 marks under the head
of serving in difficult/remote area and 8.2 marks under the head of
publication and performance, total 88.19 marks. Similarly, respondent No.4
Dr. Shimal Sarkar was awarded 63.334 marks i.e. 17.334 marks under the
head of API, 30 marks under the head of seniority, 12 marks under the head
of serving in difficult/remote area and 4 marks for publication and
performance. After objections by some Medical Officers of the Tripura
Health Services, the Director, Medical Education requested the Director,
Health Services, Government of Tripura to provide fresh details of
information regarding total duration of service in Tripura Health Services
and total duration of service as Medical Officer in difficult/remote area of all
Medical Officers who had applied. Such information was supplied vide
memo dated 13.01.2023. Thereafter, the Scrutiny Committee prepared the
final discipline wise merit list which was published on 25.04.2023
(Annexure-R/2). After publication of discipline wise final merit list, again
objections were raised by Medical Officers about the award of marks under
heading of service in the difficult/remote area where 30% weightage i.e. 6
marks for each year of the difficult/remote area up to maximum of 30 marks
were awarded. The respondents state that the weightage for serving in
difficult/remote area was determined by the notification dated 09.07.2018
(Annexure-4 to the writ petition). But all of these candidates had served for
considerable period in rural areas prior to 09.07.2018. In the earlier merit
list, 30% weightage for serving in difficult/remote area were awarded to
Medical Officers of Tripura health Services (THS, for short) for the period
even prior to the notification dated 09.07.2018. Therefore, after receiving
complaints, the views of the Law Department was obtained as to whether
30% weightage for serving in very difficult/difficult area would be
applicable or not for candidate who served in the rural area prior to the
notification dated 09.07.2018. After consultation/advise from the Law
Department and the information from the Director of Health Services,
Government of Tripura containing the service details of all applicant
Medical Officers vide memo dated 23.06.2023 the Scrutiny Committee
prepared a revised final merit list which was published on 05.08.2023 in
which the writ petitioner was shown at Sl. No.7 with the overall API score
of 55.67 and respondent Nos.3 & 4 were shown at Sl. No.2 & 4 with the
overall API scores of 58.19 and 56.33 marks respectively. In this revised
final merit list, the writ petitioner was awarded 21.7 marks under the head of
API, 30 marks under the head of seniority and 4 marks under the head of
publication and performance. No mark was awarded under the head of
serving in difficult/remote area. On the other hand, the respondents No.3 and
4 were awarded 19.99 and 17.334 under the head of API, 30 each under the
head of seniority and 8.2 and 9 under the head of publication and
performance but no marks were awarded under the head of serving in
difficult/remote area to them also. Even after publication of the revised merit
list dated 05.08.2023, objection was raised by one candidate regarding the
marks awarded up to 2023 under the heading of total service duration. As
per the advertisement dated 11.02.2022 and the corrigendum dated
16.02.2022 the service duration supposed to be calculated to award the mark
under the heading of total service duration was up to 28.02.2022. Therefore,
the Scrutiny Committee again re-verified the process and submitted a revised
final merit list in supersession of all the previous merit list published earlier
i.e. notifications dated 11.01.2023, 25.04.2023 and 05.08.2023 to the
Director of Medical Education, Government of Tripura for further process
which is yet to be published. The appointment to the post of Basic Teacher
(Tutor/Senior Resident) in the Department of Anesthesiology in the category
of SC has been made subject to the final verdict of this Court. The
respondents further state that in the earlier merit list Dr. Manna
Bhattacharjee was awarded 30 marks under the head of serving in
difficult/remote area on his service details but the Scrutiny Committee on the
basis of the memo dated 23.06.2023 supplied by the Director of Health
Services again re-verified the matter and he was awarded 4.5 marks under
the head of serving in difficult/remote area as he was physically serving as a
Medical Officer at Khedachara PHC with effect from 01.06.2021 to
09.03.2022. The committee prepared a revised final merit list in supersession
of all earlier published merit list which has been submitted on 14.08.2023 to
the Director, Medical Education.
[4]
Mr. Dipankar
Sharma, learned
Additional
Government
appearing for the State submits that upon scrutiny of the merit list again after
obtaining opinion of the Law Department and the competent authority,
Director of Health Services now the revised final merit list which has been
submitted by the Scrutiny Committee counting service in difficult/remote
area as per Tripura Medical Education (Administrative & Faculty) Service
Condition (2nd Amendment) Rules, 2021 notified on 07.09.2021 and
published in the extraordinary gazette on 09.09.2021. Learned counsel for
the respondents submits that since the circular for determining the service
duration in a difficult/remote area was published on 07.07.2018 by the
Department of Health & Family Welfare, Government of Tripura
(Annexure-4), petitioner in any case would not be benefited on this criteria
as he has served as a Medical Officer in Khedachara in the North Tripura
District between August, 2007 to February, 2011. Therefore, by any
interpretation of the relevant rules read with the notification dated
07.07.2018 petitioner is not eligible to get any marks for serving in
difficult/remote area. It is further submitted that prior to 07.07.2018 there
was no notification which prescribed the difficult/remote area and difficult
area as in the earlier notification of 2001 determined the urban and rural
area. Mr. D. Sharma, learned Additional Government submits that the
petitioner is, therefore, not entitled to any relief. The writ petition may be
dismissed.
[5]
Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel for the petitioner has referred
to the criteria for absorption prescribed under the Tripura Medical Education
(Administrative & Faculty) Service Condition (2nd Amendment) Rules, 2021
notified on 07.09.2021, published on 09.09.2021 in extraordinary Tripura
Gazette and submitted that there is no reason why the computation of marks
for difficult/remote area ought not to be computed with effect from
07.07.2018 in preparation of the merit list by the respondents. It is submitted
that the prospective application of the Second Amendment Rules 2021 is
taken into account then the criteria (IV) under Clause (b) of Rule 3 would
also be rendered ineffective as weightage for publication and performance
by any candidate prior to the notification of the second amendment rules
could not be taken into account. Such a construction would lead to absurd
results. However, learned counsel for the petitioner has not been able to
countenance that any application of the criteria under Rule 3(b)(III) even if
reckoned from the notification dated 07.07.2018 by the Health and Family
Welfare Department prescribing the difficult/remote area would not come to
the benefit of the petitioner since his period of service in Kedacherra under
North Tripura was between August 2007 to February 2011 when no such
criteria for difficult/remote area was prescribed by the Department of Health
and Family Welfare. He, however, submits that even if the criteria under
Rule 3(b)(III) is applied from the date on which such difficult/remote area
has been prescribed by the notification dated 07.07.2018, the merit list
prepared by the department would suffer from various infirmities. MANY
eligible and meritorious candidates have been disadvantaged due to nonallocation of marks for difficult/remote area service despite having served in
those areas after having come into force of the notification dated 07.07.2018.
It is submitted that the rules have to be interpreted in a manner consistent
with the principles of interpretation so that it does not lead to absurd results.
As such, the department needs to re-visit the merit list on the intelligible
criteria of service in difficult/remote area is concerned reckoning the date of
notification dated 07.07.2018.
[6]
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties at some length. I have also taken note of the relevant rules and the
supporting documents enclosed to the writ petition as well as the counteraffidavit relied upon by learned counsel for the parties for the purposes of
deciding the issue at hand. The pleadings of the writ petitioner projected a
case that in the allocation of marks under Rule 3(b)(III) under the Second
Amendment Rules notified on 07.09.2021 and published on 09.09.2021 in
the Tripura Extraordinary Gazette, the petitioner’s period of service in a
difficult/remote area i.e. Khedachara in North Tripura District during the
period August, 2007 to February, 2011 have not been taken into account
though in the provisional merit list published on 13.01.2023 petitioner was
also allocated 30 marks counting 6 marks for each year of service in
difficult/remote area.
The relevant provisions of the Tripura Medical Education
(Administrative & Faculty) Service Condition (2nd Amendment) Rules, 2021
i.e. Rule (I), (II) and (III) are extracted hereunder for better appreciation of
the case of the parties :
“I. Academic Performance Index (API) based on the carrier marks 30%
weightage [0.3 x (20% of marks in Madhyamik + 20% of marks in HS
(+2) + 0.3 x average percentage of marks in MBBS + 0.3 x % of marks in
MD/MS/DNB)] with deduction of two marks for each additional attempt.
II. Seniority in Tripura Health Service. – 30% weightage (2.5 marks for
each year of service. Maximum upto 30 marks).
III. Difficult/remote area service as Medical Officer under Tripura Health
Service – 30% weightage (6 marks for each year of difficult/remote
service. Maximum upto 30 marks.)”
[7]
On the basis of pleadings on record and from the notification
dated 07.07.2018 (Annexure-4 to the writ petition) it is now clear that the
definition and description of difficult/remote area was for the first time
notified by the Department of Health and Family Welfare, Government of
Tripura in July, 2018. Prior to that notification the existing notification did
not delineate the difficult/remote area. As stated by Ld counsel for the State
and not refuted by the petitioner, there existed a classification of urban and
rural area under the 2001 notification. As such, the advantage of having
served in a difficult/remote area for the purposes of computation of marks
under Rule 3(b)(III) would enure only on the basis of the notification dated
07.07.2018. As such, petitioner does not have a case to seek addition of
marks under Rule 3(b)(III) for having served in a difficult/remote area for
the period August, 2007 to February, 2011. An alternative submission has
been made by learned counsel for the petitioner during the course of
argument that the decision of the respondents to apply the allocations of
marks under Rule 3(b)(III) should be from the date of notification dated
07.07.2018 prescribing the difficult/remote area and not from the date of
publication of the Tripura Medical Education (Administrative & Faculty)
Service Condition (2nd Amendment) Rules, 2021 i.e. 07.07.2021/09.09.2021.
This submission of learned counsel for the petitioner though has no
consequence for the case of the petitioner though may be a plausible one.
However, since the final merit list has already been published on
24.08.2023, as informed by Ld Counsel for the State on instructions, this
Court refrains from making any comments thereupon as it is unnecessary for
the present case.
[8]
Therefore, I do not find any merit in the instant writ petition
and the same is dismissed. Interim order, if any, stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH) CJ
Dipesh
DIPESH
DEB
Digitally signed
by DIPESH DEB
Date: 2023.11.16
18:29:33 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review