The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. In the light of above discussion, no substantial question of law arises even after considering the appeal in the light of Raj Kumar Soni and Another vs. State of U.P. and Another, (2007) 10 SCC 635 and Vithalbhai Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India, 2005 AIR SCW 1509 and the position existing at the date when the suit was instituted.
13. There is no perversity in the findings of the first appellate Court, so no substantial question of law arises for consideration in this -8- present appeal. This Second Appeal is not fit to admit. Hence, this Appeal is dismissed. [
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE GAJENDRA SINGH
SECOND APPEAL No. 987 of 2023
BETWEEN:DR. GOPAL PRASAD TIWARI S/O
SHRI SHAMBHU PRASAD TIWARI,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION: DOCTOR R/O H.NO.
124, SIMROL ROAD DR. AMBEDKAR
NAGAR
MHOW
DISTT.INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(NILESH AGRAWAL, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT )
AND
SMT. SADHANA SINGH TOMAR W/O
LATE SHRI RAJENDRA SINGH
TOMAR, AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE R/O
H.NO. 21, MAIN STREET DR.
AMBEDKAR NAGAR MHOW DISTT.
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(MURTUZA BOHRA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT [R-1].)
..............................................................................................................................................
Reserved on
Pronounced through video conferencing
at Jabalpur
:
:
20.12.2023
30.01.2024
................................................................................................................................................
01.
This second appeal has been preferred challenging the
judgment dated 20.03.2023 passed by learned Fifth Additional
District Judge, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, Mhow, District Indore in Civil
Regular Appeal No.28-A/19 arising out of judgment dated 30.04.2019
Signed by: HIMANSHU
KOSHTA
Signing time: 30-01-2024
19:18:35
-2-
in Civil Suit No.109-A/2014 by IV th Civil Judge, Class I, Indore
(M.P.) whereby the decree of eviction has been passed against the
appellant/tenant/defendant on the ground of Section 12(1)(f) of M.P.
Accommodation Control Act, 1961.
02.
The facts as mentioned before the trial Court are that the
respondent/plaintiff filed the civil suit on 14.10.2014 for the vacant
possession of the portion of house no.21, Main Street, Mhow, Indore
that was in the possession of defendant/appellant on the ground of
12(1)(a), 12(1)(c) and 12(1)(f) of M.P. Accommodation Act, 1961
claiming that the defendant/appellant is the tenant of suit
accommodation at the rate of Rs.2500/- per month rent on the basis of
rent
note
dated
01.02.2008
from
the
husband
of
the
respondent/plaintiff. The death of husband of plaintiff was occurred in
the year 2010. An Amount of Rs.97,500/- is due for the period of
01.08.2011 to 31.07.2014 and the accommodation is required to
bonafide for the purpose of starting business of clothe of his major
son and no alternative accommodation is available in the city and the
defendant has created the nuisance.
03.
The appellant/defendant filed his written statement admitting
that he executed the agreement dated 01.02.2008 in favour of the
plaintiff and her husband. Additionally, he submitted that after the
death of Rajendra Singh, other heirs of Rajendra Singh have not been
joined as plaintiff. The tenancy was started for the first time on
01.12.1985 and an amount of Rs.1,00,000/- was also deposited and
that amount has not been returned to him. The agreement dated
Signed by: HIMANSHU
KOSHTA
Signing time: 30-01-2024
19:18:35
-3-
04.02.2008 is in the nature of agreement to sale.
The amount
mentioned in the agreement has not been repaid to him. He never
denied the tile of plaintiff. The plaintiff has not approach the Court
with clean hands. She has created documents in the nature of gift
deeds to show the absence of all suitable alternative accommodation
and prayed for dismissal of suit.
04.
Learned trial Court framed the 11 issue and the ground
mentioned in 12(1)(f) was decided as not proved and suit filed by the
Dr. Gopal Prasad Tiwari for specific performance of contract was
decreed partially allowing only refund of Rs.3,87,700/- with interest.
05.
Challenging the judgment dated 30.04.2019 passed by Fourth
Civil Judge, Class – I, Mhow in Civil Suit No.109-A/2014 an appeal
was filed by the respondent/Smt. Sudha Singh. The Appellate Court
reversing the findings of trial Court regarding bonafide requirement
of the suit accommodation decreed the suit of Sadhna Singh Tomar on
the ground of 12(1)(f) of M.P. Accommodation Control Act, 1961 and
ordered eviction of appellant from suit accomodation.
06.
Challenging the judgment dated 20.03.2023 passed by Fifth
Additional District Judge, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, Mhow, District
Indore in Civil Regular Appeal No.28-A/19 , this second appeal has
been preferred and proposed 10 substantial questions of law which are
being referred as below :1. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in reversing the decree passed by the
learned trial Court which had dismissed the suit
Signed by: HIMANSHU
KOSHTA
Signing time: 30-01-2024
19:18:35
-4-
filed by the respondent/plaintiff for eviction,
recovery of rent and mesne profits?
2. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in reversing the decree passed by the
learned trial Court which had given cogent
reasoning for dismissing the suit filed by the
respondent and has not found any ground tenable
for eviction under Section 12(1)(f) of M.P
Accommodation Control Act, 1961, especially
when the learned first appellate Court has
affirmed the finding of the learned trial Court
under
Section
12(1)(a)
and
(c)
of
M.P
Accommodation control Act 1961?
3. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in taking a view possible other then he
view taken by the learned trial Court?
4. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in not considering that, if the best
evidence is available with either of the parties
then the same should be produced, otherwise
adverse inference against that party should be
drawn?
5. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in not considering the fact that, plaintiff
has not came with the clean hands and has
Signed by: HIMANSHU
KOSHTA
Signing time: 30-01-2024
19:18:35
-5-
suppressed material facts from the Court and
thus not entitled for any relief from the Court?
`
6. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in not considering the fact that, trial
Court is the best judge for interpretation of the
evidence lead before him and first appellate court
should deprecate to take a view other than the
view taken by the trial Court?
7. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in reversing the judgment passed by the
learned trial Court without assigning just and
proper reason thereof?
8. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in passing the impugned judgment
without following the provision of Section 12(6)
of M.P Accommodation Control Act 1961?
9. Whether, the learned First Appellate Court was
justified in passing the impugned judgment
without considering the fact that the suit filed by
the plaintiff was pre-mature and contrary to the
terms of admitted agreement dated 01.02.2008
especially when the payment taken by the
plaintiff was not repaid by her?
`
10. Whether the judgment and decree passed by
the learned Appellate Court below suffer from
Signed by: HIMANSHU
KOSHTA
Signing time: 30-01-2024
19:18:35
-6-
infirmity and perversity on account of misappreciation and non-appreciation of material
pieces of evidence available on record, thus
liable to be set-aside?
07.
Firstly, Court is dealing with the proposed question no.9 in
which it is stated that in the light of agreement dated 01.02.2008
(Exhibit-D/2), the suit of the plaintiff is premature.
08.
The amount mentioned in Exhibit-D/2 has been repaid in
execution of the decree passed in Civil Suit No.5A/16.
09.
In the case of a statutory tenant, the relationship is not
governed by contract and eviction can be sought only on the ground
available in M.P. Accomodation Control Act, 1961. Thus, the
objection regarding bar to institute the suit referring the agreement
Ex.D-2 is not sustainable and it does not render the suit as pre-mature.
10.
Now we are considering the other proposed questions of law.
The conclusion of the appellate Court in para 29, 30 and 31 are based
on proper appreciation of evidence.
He gave cogent reasons for
discarding the reverse finding of the trial Court regarding bonafide
requirements of the suit house for the business of his major son and
non-availability of alternative suitable accommodation as the house
nos.284, 482 and 483 are residential and the suit house is nonresidential.
11.
In Rishi Kumar Govil v. Maqsoodan, (2007) 4 SCC 465, it
is held that the bona fide personal need being a question of fact
should not be normally interfered. Relevant para-14 of the judgment
Signed by: HIMANSHU
KOSHTA
Signing time: 30-01-2024
19:18:35
-7-
is being referred as below :
“14. In Ragavendra Kumar v. Firm Prem
Machinery & Co., AIR 2000 SC 534, it was held
that it is the choice of the landlord to choose the
place for the business which is most suitable for
him. He has complete freedom in the matter. In
Gaya Prasad v. Pradeep Srivastava, AIR 2001
SC 803 it was held that the need of the landlord
is to be seen on the date of application for
release. In Prativa Devi v. T.V. Krishnan, (1996)
5 SCC 353 it was held that the landlord is the
best judge of his requirement and courts have no
concern to dictate the landlord as to how and in
what manner he should live. The bona fide
personal need is a question of fact and should
not be normally interfered with.”
12.
In the light of above discussion, no substantial question of law
arises even after considering the appeal in the light of Raj Kumar Soni
and Another vs. State of U.P. and Another, (2007) 10 SCC 635 and
Vithalbhai Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India, 2005 AIR SCW 1509 and the
position existing at the date when the suit was instituted.
13.
There is no perversity in the findings of the first appellate
Court, so no substantial question of law arises for consideration in this
Signed by: HIMANSHU
KOSHTA
Signing time: 30-01-2024
19:18:35
-8-
present appeal. This Second Appeal is not fit to admit. Hence, this
Appeal is dismissed.
[
(GAJENDRA SINGH)
JUDGE
HK
Signed by: HIMANSHU
KOSHTA
Signing time: 30-01-2024
19:18:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review