Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.308 of 2025
Dr. Debasish Datta,
Son of Sri Sushil Datta, resident of Baroj Colony, P.O & P.S Belonia,
Dist. South Tripura, Pin 799155, Aged about 43 years approx.
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
The National Institute of Technology, Agartala,
Represented by it‟s Registrar, Barjala, P.O NIT Agartala, P.S.
Jirania, Dist. West Tripura, Pin 799046.
2.
The Director,
National Institute of Technology, Agartala, Barjala, P.O NIT
Agartala, P.S Jirania, Dist West Tripura, Pin 799046.
3.
The Registrar,
National Institute of Technology, Agartala, Barjala, P.O NIT
Agartala, P.S Jirania, Dist West Tripura, Pin 799046.
4.
The Head of the Department,
Department of Mathamatics, National Institute of Technology,
Agartala, Barjala, P.O NIT Agartala, P.S Jirania, Dist West
Tripura, Pin 799046.
……..Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Arijit Bhowmik, Advocate.
Ms. I. Chakma, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Senior Advocate.
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
29th August, 2025.
Date of delivery
Of Judgment & Order
:
18th November, 2025.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
√
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The National Institute Technology, Agartala, issued an
advertisement dated 22.04.2022 for filling up the post of Assistant
Professor (Grade-I) and Assistant Professor (Grade-II) in different
disciplines. In the general instructions of such recruitment process
as was published by NIT, it is mentioned at Sl. No.15 that written
tests
may
be
conducted
for
candidates
in
the
specified
department(s) for the post of faculty positions. It is further
mentioned therein that based on the performance in the written
test, candidates will be shortlisted for the subsequent selection
process i.e. for presentation and interview, after the documents
verification. The institute may, however, call candidates directly for
presentation and interview, without any written test and in this
regard, the decision of the institute shall be final and binding. The
said clause under Sl. No.15 of the general instructions, as
discussed above, is extracted hereunder:
“15. If required, written tests may be conducted for
candidates in the specified department(s) for the
post of faculty positions. The date and time may be
found in the intimation mail sent to the candidates
and also available in the recruitment website i.e.
https://www.nita.ac.in. In that case, based on the
performance in the Written Test, candidates will be
shortlisted for the subsequent selection process i.e.,
Presentation and Interview after documents
verification.
The Institute may, however, call the
candidates directly for presentation and Interview,
without any written test. With regard to the above,
the decision of Institute shall be final and binding.”
[2]
According to the petitioner, there were four stages of
the said selection process with respect to the discipline of
mathematics
for
which
he
applied
and
they
are-
written
examination, document verification, presentation and interview. It
is also asserted by him that he appeared in a written examination
and qualified the same. His name was placed at Sl. No.97 of the
merit list and he secured 77 marks out of total 120 marks.
[3]
on
Thereafter, a notification was issued by the respondents
25.04.2025
(Annexure
7)
whereby
dates
of
seminar
presentations and document verification for the candidates of the
discipline
„Mathematics‟
were
scheduled
on
28.05.2025
and
29.05.2025 and dates of interview were scheduled on 29.05.2025
and 30.05.2025. The list of candidates who were called for the
seminar presentation followed by interview before the Selection
Committee was also mentioned therein, wherein the roll number of
present petitioner was also reflected under the discipline of
mathematics. It was further mentioned therein that only those
candidates who were recommended based on evaluation of the
seminar presentation would be interviewed by the Selection
Committee and the same procedure was made applicable to the
shortlisted candidates for both pay level 10 and pay level 12. The
petitioner was within the category of pay level 10. The relevant
clause as mentioned in said notification (Annexure 7) is also
extracted hereunder:
“The list of candidates being called for seminar
presentation followed by interview by selection
Committee is given below for pay level 10. It should
be noted that only those candidates, who are
recommended based on evaluation of seminar
presentation will be interviewed by the selection
Committee. This is applicable for shortlisted
candidates for both pay level 10 & 12:”
[4]
Apart from the issuance of said notification, another
letter dated 30.04.2025 (Annexure 8) was also issued by the
respondents to the petitioner intimating that he was provisionally
short-listed
to
appear
for
document
verification
and
presentation/seminar followed by a personal interview as per the
schedule below:
i. Document Verification & Presentation/Seminar:
Date & Reporting Time: 28/05/2025, 9.00 am
Venue: Conference room of International Guest
House, NIT Agartala, Tripura (W) (for Document
Verification)
Respective
Department
(for
Seminar
Presentation on Research Topic; Duration 10-12
minutes)
ii. Personal Interview:
Date & Reporting Time: 29/05/2025; 9.00 am
Venue: Conference room of International Guest
House, NIT Agartala, Tripura (W)
[5]
It was further mentioned in the said letter that call for
personal interview would not confer any right on the petitioner to
be treated as eligible in all aspects for appointment or to be
considered for interview.
[6]
According to the petitioner, as per said letter dated
30.04.2025,
he
appeared
for
document
verification
and
presentation/seminar on the scheduled date i.e. on 28.05.2025 and
time and he also reported for the personal interview the following
day at 9.00 am. However, upon reaching there, he was informed
that he would not be allowed to appear for the personal interview
on that day, as 14 candidates had already been shortlisted for
personal interview on 29.05.2025. Consequently, the petitioner
could not successfully come out in the said selection process and
thereafter he preferred the present writ petition.
[7]
According to the petitioner, there were only two phases
of the selection process i.e. (i) written test and (ii) seminar
presentation and personal interview upon document verification.
Therefore, seminar presentation and personal interview constitute a
single phase, and once he was called for seminar presentation, it
was obligatory for the respondents to allow him to appear before
the interview board for personal interview and such denial of
opportunity to appear before the interview board is illegal and ultra
vires.
[8]
The writ petition has been filed seeking the following
reliefs:
“I. Issue notice upon the respondents,
II. Call for the relevant records,
III. Issue rule calling upon the respondents to show
cause as to why the respondents shall not be
mandated to take the personal interview of the
Petitioner and thereafter consider the Petitioner for
appointment to the post of Asst. Professor GradeII-level 10 against a post reserved for OBC/UR
pursuant to the selection processes initiated by the
Respondents vide advertisement dated 22nd April,
2022.
AND
Issue Rule calling upon the respondents to show
cause as to why the action of the Respondents of
short listing of the candidates for interview vide
notice dated 28.05.2025 shall not be set-aside and
quashed.
AND
Issue Rule calling upon the respondent to show
cause as to why the clause in the notification dated
25.04.2025 viz 'it should be noted that only those
candidates,
who
are
recommend
based
on
evaluation
of
seminar
presentation
will
be
interviewed by the selection committee' shall not be
declared to be illegal, ultra vires of the
Recruitments Rules, unconstitutional and therefore
be set-aside by this Hon'ble Court
IV. And after hearing the parties the pleased to
make rule absolute
AND
In the interim, the pleased to direct the
Respondents to keep one post of Asst. Professor
Grade-II-level 10 in the Mathematics Department in
OBC/UR category vacant for the petitioner till
disposal of the connected writ petition.
AND
Pass any other order/orders as deemed fit and
proper.
AND
For this act of kindness your humble Petitioner as in
duty bound shall ever remain grateful.”
[9]
Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel, during hearing refers
to MHRD guidelines placed under Annexure 10 and submits that
double short-listing in the selection process is not permissible as
per MHRD guideline. The relevant portions of the said guidelines
are also excerpted hereunder:
“GUIDELINES/PROCEDURES TO BE FOLLOWED FOR
FACULTY SELECTION IN NITS AND IIEST
………………………………….
2. As far as the guidelines/procedures to be
adopted for selection of faculty as per the new
Recruitment Rules approved by the Council, the
following is hereby informed that:
…………………………..
(b) All the faculty posts in the institute shall be
filled by direct recruitment only. The procedure for
selection of faculty is given in Appendix – A1.
PROCEDURE FOR SELECTION OF FACULTY IN NIT
SYSTEM
The procedure outlined here has generally, but not
exactly, been followed in most of the IITs. The
procedure is prescribed as a guideline, without
insisting that it be followed religiously. Boards of
Governors may opt for alternative procedures after
examining their merit vis-a-vis the base line
procedure given below.
(Emphasis laid)
1.
The Director will create an "Advisory
Committee on Faculty Recruitment (ACoFAR)" with
a senior member of the faculty as the Chairman.
Normally, he should be the Dean (Faculty Welfare);
but Director shall have the discretion to assign the
responsibility to Dy. Director or another senior
Professor or handle it himself. The Chairman of
ACoFAR shall be authorized to communicate with
Departments, candidates and experts on the advice
of Director. In addition, the Committee shall
discharge the following functions:
a) Examine and advise on distribution of faculty
positions among various Departments;
b) Proactively search for faculty candidates in India
and abroad.
c) Assist the Director in examining, short listing
criteria and preparing panels of short listed
candidates submitted by Departments;
d) Examine and recommend proposals for deviation
in age, formal qualifications, industry experience or
any other criterion or guideline;
e) Reservation of positions for specialization or subspecialization and rank of faculty to be inducted;
and
f) Proactively search for candidates from reserved
categories, and if not available after repeated
attempts, prepare proposals for de-reservation in
accordance with the relevant rules & regulations.
……………………………………………
14. Applications, when received, will be organized,
relevant information summarized, and sent to the
Departments by the Registry, for short listing. The
objectives of short listing are two folds:
(a) …………………………………………….
(b) to select the best candidates from the remaining
list so that the member of candidates to be called
for interview with the experts remains within
manageable limits.
15. Departments will make attempt to set "short
listing criteria" that can be easily implemented. But,
considering the multiple attributes that need to be
considered, it may become necessary to make case
by case exceptions. In all such cases the general
short listing criteria and the reasons for exception,
if any, are to be recorded in writing. Short listing
criteria may include, among others, such conditions
as:
(i) superior academic record - all through first class
career or higher grades in B.Tech/M.Sc/M.Tech,
higher than advertised criteria,
(ii) reputation of institutions from
candidate has obtained his degrees,
where
the
(iii) number of unsuccessful attempts for the same
post [Candidates who have been rejected in the
past may be called only if there is a good reason,
the reason to be recorded in writing.
(iv) specialisation, including micro specialisation,
(v) professional service record - reputation of
organization where experience has been earned,
nature of job, current activities etc.
16. The Departments’ recommendations shall be
placed before the Director for the final short-listing.
The final list of candidates to meet the Selection
Committee will be arrived at in a combined meeting
of the Director, the ACoFAR, the HoD and at least
three senior faculty members of the Department. In
case of a lack of unanimity among the members, the
Director's decisions shall be final for the purpose of
calling a candidate to the interview. The different
viewpoints, however, will be recorded in writing and
placed before the Selection Committee who may
record their own comments for information of the
BOG. The decision of the Board on the selection
shall be final and binding.
………………………………………………….
18. The short listed candidates will be invited by the
Chairman, ACoFAR or the Registrar for personal
interview with the selections committee constituted
in accordance with the NITSER Act, 2007 and the
Statutes of the respective Institutes. In addition,
the individual institutes may seek seminar
presentation in the Departments, and/or any other
form of academic interaction with the faculty. All
such interaction will be open to the faculty and
students of the institute and will be well publicized
in advance to invite a decent audience. The
feedback of the faculty will be communicated to the
Selection Committee by the HoD. Candidates located
outside the country or otherwise not in a position of
attending personal interview, may be interviewed
over video conferencing or be selected in absentia
at the discretion of the Selection Committee.
19. On completion of the interview, the Selection
Committee will record its final recommendations
with signature of every member present. The
Director, as chairman of the committee will be
responsible for writing the recommendation. There
shall be no scope for retaining individual view
points or details of discussion. Any member(s) with
a dissenting opinion may, however, record their
observations. On a separate page (with a reference
in the main page that will be presented by the
Director to the BoG with his own comments on the
observations.
…………………………………..”
[10]
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel strongly argues that it is
the settled law that once a selection process has started, no
alteration can be done midway through the process and in the
present case, when already the petitioner was asked to appear for
document verification and the seminar presentation and thereafter
also on the next date, for interview, the respondent had no
authority to prevent him from appearing before the interview board
on that day. In this regard, Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel relies on
the following decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court:
Tej Prakash Pathak and others vs. Rajasthan
High Court and others; (2025) 2 SCC 1- In this case, the
Constitution Bench while deciding a reference as to whether the
principle that once the recruitment process commences the State
or its instrumentality cannot tinker with the “rules of the game”
insofar as the prescription of eligibility criteria is concerned should
also apply to the procedure for selection, finally held as under:
“65. We, therefore, answer the reference in the
following terms:
65.1. Recruitment process commences from the
issuance
of
the
advertisement
calling
for
applications and ends with filling up of vacancies;
65.2. Eligibility criteria for being placed in the
select list, notified at the commencement of the
recruitment process, cannot be changed midway
through the recruitment process unless the extant
Rules so permit, or the advertisement, which is not
contrary to the extant Rules, so permit. Even if such
change is permissible under the extant Rules or the
advertisement, the change would have to meet the
requirement of Article 14 of the Constitution and
satisfy the test of arbitrariness;
65.3. The decision in K. Manjusree, (2008) 3 SCC
512 lays down good law and is not in conflict with
the decision in Subash Chander Marwaha, (1974) 3
SCC 220 deals with the right to be appointed from
the select list whereas K. Manjusree, (2008) 3 SCC
512 deals with the right to be placed in the select
list. The two cases therefore deal with altogether
different issues;
65.4. Recruiting bodies, subject to the extant Rules,
may devise appropriate procedure for bringing the
recruitment process to its logical end provided the
procedure so adopted is transparent, nondiscriminatory/non-arbitrary and has a rational
nexus to the object sought to be achieved;
65.5. Extant Rules having statutory force are
binding on the recruiting body both in terms of
procedure and eligibility. However, where the rules
are
non-existent,
or
silent,
administrative
instructions may fill in the gaps;
65.6 Placement in the select list gives no
indefeasible right to appointment. The State or its
instrumentality for bona fide reasons may choose
not to fill up the vacancies. However, if vacancies
exist, the State or its instrumentality cannot
arbitrarily deny appointment to a person within the
zone of consideration in the select list.
…………………………………….”
[11]
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel also refers to Clause 18 of
the MHRD guidelines as extracted earlier. He also submits that
MHRD guidelines is binding on NIT and in this regard, he relies on
the following decisions:
(i)
Union of India, represented by the Secretary,
Ministry of Education, Department of Higher Education and
others vs. Subhajit Deb and others; 2024 SCC OnLine Tri
515- This judgment of the Division Bench of this High Court was
rendered in a different context. In that case, the designation of
some Assistant Professors employed in NIT, Agartala on contract
basis was subsequently changed to „Temporary Assistant Professor‟
and „Temporary Faculty‟ during the subsistence of their contract
period, and even their consolidated monthly remuneration was also
reduced. The learned Writ Court while taking note of statutes of
2017, letter issued by MHRD and other relevant documents,
allowed the writ petition and held that the change of designation as
well as the reduction of pay of those petitioners were illegal and
arbitrary with further decision that putting the petitioners against
non-sanctioned posts by changing their designation was illegal. In
the appeal before the Division Bench, learned Deputy S.G.I. on
behalf of Union of India also relied on the statutes as well as the
MHRD letter and other documents. Ultimately, the Division Bench
partly-allowed the appeal but upheld the decision of the learned
Writ Court that change in the status of the writ petitioners from
Assistant
Professor
on
contract
to
„Temporary
Faculty‟
or
„Temporary Assistant Professor‟ and reduction of their pay were
illegal. Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel relies on this judgment to
show that MHRD guidelines are binding on NIT officials and in that
case also they relied on the same.
(ii)
National Institute of Technology and another
vs. Om Prakash Rahi and others; (2022) 13 SCC 348- This
case was against the judgment passed by Division Bench of High
Court of Himachal Pradesh which had upheld the order passed by
the Director of National Institute of Technology, who, without any
selection process for teachers and without the approval of Board of
Governors, granted higher pay band of Rs.37,400-67,000 with AGP
of Rs.9000 to some of the respondents in that case and redesignated
them
as
Associate
Professor
consequent
upon
completion of three years of service in AGP Rs.8000 (6th Central
Pay Commission). The Division Bench had also directed the
appellants to consider their claim for further promotion to the post
of Professor. In the said judgment, Hon‟ble Supreme Court made
the following observations at paragraph No.29:
“29. The Division Bench of the High Court has
proceeded on the premise that after the 2007 Act
has come into force, MHRD is not competent to
issue circulars/guidelines of which a reference has
been made dated 14-3-2012 and 18-3-2013, which
is completely misplaced for the reason that after
the 2007 Act came into force, the appellant
institution was taken over by the Central
Government and being fully funded institution by
the Central Government, CAS was introduced by
MHRD only for accelerated promotion and was not
in contradistinction to the scheme for appointment
available to the teachers under the provisions of
the 2007 Act. At the same time, the respondent
teachers were granted the benefit of AGP Rs.8000
under the same guidelines issued by MHRD dated
14-3-2012 and 18-3-2013 that too on the
recommendations of the Selection Committee and
with the approval of the Board of Governors of
NIT,
Hamirpur,
in
the
given
facts
and
circumstances, to hold that the benefits once
availed under the guidelines dated 14-3-2012 and
18-3-2013 by the respondent teachers while
seeking revision of AGP Rs.8000, the very scheme
will not be applicable while considering for AGP
Rs.9000 and for redesignation as Associate
Professor is otherwise not sustainable in law.”
[12]
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel further relies on a
decision in case of Nitesh Kumar Pandey vs. State of Madhya
Pradesh and others; (2020) 4 SCC 70- This case is relating to
selection of Gram Rojgar Sahayak in the State of Madhya Pradesh
under MGNREG scheme following the guidelines dated 02.06.2012
issued by the Madhya Pradesh State Employment Guarantee
Parishad.
The
said
guidelines
prescribed
both
compulsory
qualifications and desired qualifications. The qualification specified
was with regard to the basic education qualifications and under the
desired qualifications, it referred to „computer examination‟ passed
from any one of the institution mentioned in the memo of General
Administration Department. While selecting such Gram Rojgar
Sahayak in one district, the District Collector issued a revised
timeline schedule for such recruitment incorporating therein the
date of holding computer efficiency test of the selected candidates
and ultimately, some of the selected candidates who could not pass
out the computer efficiency test were not finally selected. When the
matter was challenged before the High Court, the procedure
adopted by the District Collector incorporating in the midway
computer efficiency test to be one of the criteria of selection
process was held to be unjustified. The Division Bench affirmed the
judgment of learned Single Judge and Hon‟ble Supreme Court also
affirmed the same. Before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, one point
was raised from the side of the appellant that the writ petitioners
having participated in the computer efficiency test were estopped
from raising any grievance subsequently. In that context, Hon‟ble
Supreme Court observed as under:
“15. Having taken note of the decisions cited, we
have no doubt in our mind that the well-accepted
position in law is that the person who has acceded
to a position and participated in the process cannot
be permitted to approbate and reprobate. It is a
norm that if a person/candidate having taken note
of a requirement in the notification and even if it is
objectionable does not challenge the same but
despite having knowledge of the same participates
in the said process and takes a chance, on failing
in the process such person/candidate cannot turn
around and assail the same. Though that is the
position in law, the said position of law will not be
applicable to the present case as the facts in the
case on hand is not the same. In the cited case of
Ashok Kumar (2017) 4 SCC 357, it was a situation
where the subsequent notification for written
examination was issued after nullifying the result
of the earlier written examination. The petitioner
therein who had appeared for the examination
earlier, having knowingly participated in the
process by once again appearing for the
examination which was notified had thereafter
challenged, which was a clear case of approbate
and reprobate. On the other hand in the instant
case, firstly, the revised time schedule issued by
the Collector, Rewa cannot be termed as the
recruitment notification indicating all the criteria
for selection; but can only be termed as a time
schedule prescribed pursuant to the recruitment
process as provided under the fresh guidelines
dated 2-6-2012. Therefore, a candidate already in
selection list who has appeared in the computer
efficiency test on the date depicted in the revised
time schedule cannot be considered to have
appeared after having knowledge that the same
will also be a part of the assessment for selection
and
cannot
be
put
on
the
same
pedestal…………………..”
[13]
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel also relies on another
decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of K. Manjusree
vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and another; (2008) 3 SCC 512
wherein at Para 27, three-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court while
taking note of the facts of that case, observed that introduction of
requirement of minimum marks for interview, after the entire
selection process (consisting of written examination and interview)
was completed, would amount to changing the rules of game after
the game was played which was clearly impermissible.
[14]
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel submits that in
the notification dated 25.04.2025 (Annexure 7), common dates for
both the seminar presentation and interview of candidates of all
disciplines were notified as a matter of general information and
there was specifically mentioned therein that the candidates who
were recommended based on evaluation of seminar presentation,
would be interviewed by the selection committee. He further
submits that subsequent letter dated 30.04.2025 (Annexure 8)
addressed to the petitioner containing, both the said dates of
document verification plus seminar presentation and personal
interview was issued in a routine manner following the above said
notification placed under Annexure 7. Therefore, by virtue of the
letter under Annexure 8, the petitioner cannot claim as of right to
be called for personal interview even after his dissatisfactory
performance in seminar presentation. It is also argued by him that
in
the
notification
dated
25.04.2025
(Annexure
7),
it
was
categorically mentioned that the persons who are recommended
based on the performance of seminar presentation would be
interviewed by the selection committee; yet the petitioner did not
lodge any grievance against the term and participated in the
selection process by appearing for document verification and also
for seminar presentation on 28.05.2025 and therefore, he is now
estopped from lodging any grievance merely because he was
unsuccessful in the seminar presentation.
[15]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel further refers to another
notice of the respondents dated 13.03.2025 (Annexure R1) issued
prior to the written examination held on 22.03.2025 wherein it was
stated that the shortlisted candidates will be called for seminar
presentation (physical mode) in the institute and on the basis of
satisfactory performance in presentation, the candidates would
appear for personal interview before the selection committee at the
institute. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel strongly argues on that
point that the petitioner has suppressed the fact of publication of
said notice dated 13.03.2025 by the respondent in his writ petition
and more so, despite said notice was submitted along with the
counter affidavit of the respondents, he did not challenge the same
and therefore, said notification is now binding on him.
[16]
Learned senior counsel also refers to instruction Nos.10
and 12 of the general instructions issued by the respondents
reserving their right to set norms higher than the minimum
eligibility criteria and areas of specialisation, taking into accounts
the specific requirements of the individual departments. Both the
said instruction nos.10 and 12 are reproduced hereunder:
“....................................
10. The Institute has the right to set norms higher
than the minimum eligibility criteria and areas of
specialization while short listing, taking into
accounts the specific requirements of the individual
departments. The short-listing norms may not be
uniform across the departments/posts of the
Institute and shall be binding on all the applicants.
The decision of the Institute related to all matters
pertaining to the recruitment shall be final and
binding on the applicants.
.......................................
12. The essential qualifications, requirements and
credit points are the minimum criteria only for
deciding the eligibility. This shall not ensure shortlistings for further selection processes. The
Institute reserves rights to set a higher criterion for
short listing. The Institute reserves the right to
screen and call only those candidates who are found
prima-facie suitable for being considered by the
Selection Committee. Thus, just mere fulfilling the
prescribed conditions would not entitle the
candidates to be called for presentation and
interview. The Institute reserves the right to
restrict the number of candidates to be called for
interview to a reasonable limit on the basis of
qualifications and experience higher than the
minimum prescribed in the advertisement and other
academic achievements. Candidates are expected to
have good academic records throughout with
education from reputed institutions.”
[17]
According to Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel, MHRD
guidelines depict only a baseline procedure and the NIT has the
authority to change it. In this regard, he also relies on the
guidelines issued by MHRD, as also relied on by the petitioner,
extracted earlier, wherein at the very outset of Appendix-A1
regarding „procedure for selection of faculties in NIT system‟, it is
mentioned that the procedure outlined here has generally, but not
exactly, been followed in most of the IITs. The procedure is
prescribed merely as a guideline without insisting that it would be
followed religiously. Board of Governors may opt for alternative
procedures after examining their merit vis-a-vis the baseline
procedure given below.
[18]
Learned senior counsel lastly argues that there is no
allegation from the side of the petitioner about any bias in the
selection process and therefore, no interference is called for there
against. According to him, the institute is the best authority to
judge as to who would be the best suited person for the required
post under selection and unless there is a specific allegation of
biasness, generally Court does not interfere with such selection
process. Learned senior counsel, in this regard, also relies on Tej
Prakash Pathak (Supra), more particularly, paragraph no.54
which is also extracted hereunder:
“54. As already noticed in Section (A), a recruitment
process inter alia comprises of various steps like
inviting applications, scrutiny of applications,
rejection of defective applications or elimination of
ineligible candidates, conducting examinations,
calling for interview or viva voce and preparation of
list of successful candidates for appointment.
Subject to the rule against arbitrariness, how tests
or viva voce are to be conducted, what questions
are to be put, in what manner evaluation is to be
done, whether a shortlisting exercise is needed are
all matters of procedure which, in absence of rules
to the contrary, may be devised by the competent
authority.
Often
advertisement(s)
inviting
applications are open-ended in terms of these steps
and leave it to the discretion of the competent
authority to adopt such steps as may be considered
necessary in the circumstances albeit subject to the
overarching principle of rule against arbitrariness
enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution.”
[19]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel further relies on the
following decisions:
(i)
Dilip Kumar Garg and another vs. State of
Uttar Pradesh and others; (2009) 4 SCC 753- In this case at
paragraph No.15 it was observed by the Apex Court that Article 14
should not be stretched too far, otherwise it will make the
functioning of the administration impossible. The administrative
authorities are in the best position to decide the requisite
qualifications for promotion from Junior Engineer to Assistant
Engineer, and it is not for this Court to sit over their decision like a
court of appeal.
(ii)
Madan Lal and others vs. State of J & K and
others; (1995) 3 SCC 486- At paragraph No.10, it was observed
by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court that the result of the interview test
on merits cannot be successfully challenged by a candidate who
takes a chance to get selected at the said interview and who
ultimately finds himself to be unsuccessful. It was also further
observed by the Apex Court that Court cannot sit as a court of
appeal and try to reassess the relative merits of the candidates
concerned who had been assessed at the oral interview, nor can
the petitioners successfully urge before the Court that they were
given less marks though their performance were better.
(iii)
Marripati
Nagaraja
and
others
vs.
Government of Andhra Pradesh and others; (2007) 11 SCC
522- Similar principle as laid in Madan Lal (Supra) was also
applied in that case holding that the appellants had appeared in the
examination without any demur and they did not question the
validity of the said question of fixing of the said date before the
appropriate authority and therefore, they were estopped and
precluded from questioning the selection process.
(iv)
Haryana
Public
Service
Commission
vs.
Amarjeet Singh and others; 1999 SCC (L&S) 1451- At
paragraph no.3 it was observed by the Apex Court that when
uniform process had been adopted in respect of all and selections
had been made, it was highly inappropriate for the High Court to
have examined the matter in further detail and to have allocated
marks to the two candidates and thereafter directed the appellant
Commission to select them.
(v)
Dr. Pradeep Jain and others vs. Union of India
and others; (1984) 3 SCR 942- In this case, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court gave emphasis that merit cannot be judged on the
basis of marks only.
[20]
Court has given due consideration to the submissions
made by the parties and also the materials placed before the Court.
In the general instructions against Sl. No.9 it was mentioned that
the institute reserved the right to modify/defer or cancel the
advertisement/recruitment at any stage of processing without
assigning any reasons. Against Sl. No.10 it was also noted that the
institute has the right to set norms higher than the minimum
eligibility criteria and areas of specialization while short listing,
taking into accounts the specific requirements of the individual
departments, and the short-listing norms may not be uniform
across the departments/posts of the Institute and shall be binding
on all the applicants. Against Sl. No.12 it was further mentioned
that the essential qualifications, requirements and credit points are
the minimum criteria only for deciding the eligibility and this shall
not ensure short-listings for further selection processes. The
institute reserves rights to set a higher criterion for short listing.
The institute reserves the right to screen and call only those
candidates who are found prima-facie suitable for being considered
by
the
Selection
Committee.
Thus,
just
mere
fulfilling
the
prescribed conditions would not entitle the candidates to be called
for presentation and interview. It was further noted therein that the
institute reserves the right to restrict the number of candidates to
be called for interview to a reasonable limit on the basis of
qualifications and experience higher than the minimum prescribed
in the advertisement and other academic achievements. Against Sl.
No.13, it is also stated that departments will make attempt to set
"short-listing
criteria"
that
can
be
easily
implemented.
But,
considering the multiple attributes that need to be considered, it
may become necessary to make case by case exceptions. Against
Sl. No.15 further provision was kept that if required, written tests
may be conducted for candidates in the specified department(s)
and based on the performance in the written test, candidates will
be
shortlisted
for
the
subsequent
selection
process
i.e.,
presentation and interview after documents verification. However,
the institute may call the candidates directly for presentation and
interview, without any written test.
[21]
Above said terms and conditions, as depicted in the
advertisement themselves, clearly show that the institute kept its
right reserved to go for further short-listing of candidates, even
after initial short-listing for such selection process in any particular
discipline or department. In the MHRD guidelines for selection of
faculties in NIT and IIEST (Annexure 10), it is also clearly stated at
Appendix-A1 that the procedure was prescribed therein as a
guideline, without insisting that it must be followed religiously.
[22]
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel argues that as per the
guidelines of MHRD at Sl. No.15 of said Appendix A1 prescribes the
short-listing criteria on some other aspects and against Sl. No.16 it
is also mentioned that departments‟ recommendations shall be
placed before the Director for final short-listing and final list of
candidates to meet the Selection Committee will be arrived at in a
combined meeting of the Director, the ACoFAR, the HoD and at
least, three senior faculty members of the Department. But, in the
present case, no such decision regarding second short-listing was
arrived by such a committee. In this regard, it is to be kept in mind
(as also noted hereinabove) that those are merely baseline
recommendations of the MHRD giving liberty to the institute to go
for their own procedure.
[23]
In the present case, there is no dispute that whatever
procedure was adopted by the institute, was made applicable for all
the applicants uniformly. Therefore, as per the decision of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Haryana Public Service Commission
(Supra) when uniform process had been adopted in respect of all
and selections had been made, it would not be appropriate for the
High Court to have examined the matter in further detail.
[24]
Another noticeable fact is that after the advertisement
was issued for such selection process on 22.04.2022, the NIT also
issued another notice on 13.03.2025 (Annexure R1) mentioning
that based on the performance of step-2 i.e. second short-listing of
candidates based on the ratio of number of applications and
number of vacancies, in step-3 the shortlisted candidates will be
called for seminar presentation and on the basis of satisfactory
performance (emphasis laid) in the presentation, the candidates
will appear for personal interview before the selection committee.
After issuance of said notice, written examination was conducted on
22.03.2025. Therefore, the petitioner had knowledge of this
condition
of
recruitment
before
he
appeared
for
written
examination but neither he has challenged said notice in the writ
proceedings nor disclosed the fact of publication of said notice in
his petition. Though it is submitted by Mr. Bhowmik, learned
counsel, that the petitioner had no knowledge of the notice, but
when general notice in this regard was issued by the authority, he
was supposed to know the same. Thus, the explanation as offered
by Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel is not acceptable. It is, therefore,
a case of suppression of material facts by the petitioner in the writ
petition.
[25]
Even in the notification dated 25.04.2025 (Annexure 7)
whereby general notice was published regarding the dates of
seminar presentation and interview for all disciplines, it was clearly
mentioned that only those candidates who are recommended based
on evaluation of seminar presentation would be interviewed by the
selection committee. Said notification was issued on 25.04.2025
and date of his seminar presentation of the petitioner was fixed on
28.05.2025 and date of personal interview was fixed on the
following day. Therefore, he got sufficient time i.e. of more than
one month to challenge the said notification but he did not do so,
rather being fully aware of the said terms of short-listing, he
participated
in
seminar
presentation.
Therefore,
he
cannot
challenge such selection process now just because his performance
in the seminar presentation was not satisfactory to the assessment
of the recruiting authority. Law is fairly settled that if a candidate
takes a calculated chance and appears at the interview, then, only
because the result of interview is not palatable to him, he cannot
turn round and subsequently contend that process of interview was
unfair or the selection committee was not properly constituted.
Said principle has been iterated both in Madan Lal (Supra) and
Marripati Nagaraja (Supra).
[26]
The basic challenge raised by the petitioner in the writ
petition is the change of game in the midway of the selection
process by adding another short-listing term during seminar
presentation. According to Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel such
procedure is not permissible in law and in this regard, he has relied
upon the judgment of the Constitution Bench in Tej Prakash
Pathak (Supra) as noted earlier. In that case, the Constitution
Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court at paragraph no.54 noted
earlier,
clearly
observed
that
subject
to
the
rule
against
arbitrariness, how tests or viva voce are to be conducted, what
questions are to be put, in what manner evaluation is to be done
and whether a short-listing exercise is needed are all matters of
procedure which, in absence of rules to the contrary, may be
devised by the competent authority and often advertisement(s)
inviting applications are open-ended and leave it to the discretion
of the competent authority to adopt such steps as may be
necessary in the circumstances subject to the overarching principle
of rule against arbitrariness enshrined in Article 14 of the
Constitution.
[27]
At paragraph No.65.2 of said decision, it was also
further held that eligibility criteria for being placed in the select list,
notified at the commencement of the recruitment process, cannot
be changed in the midway through the recruitment process unless
the extant Rules so permit, or the advertisement, which is not
contrary to the extant Rules, so permit and even if such change is
permissible under the extant Rules or the advertisement, the
change would have to meet the requirement of Article 14 of the
Constitution and satisfy the test of non-arbitrariness. At paragraph
65.4 it was further clarified that recruiting bodies, subject to the
extant rules, may devise appropriate procedure for bringing the
recruitment process to its logical end provided the procedure so
adopted is transparent, non-discriminatory/non-arbitrary and has a
rational nexus to the object sought to be achieved. As already
discussed earlier, in the advertisement, liberty was kept reserved
by the recruiting authority to devise its own procedure of shortlisting and MHRD guidelines also does not stand as a bar against
the said condition, rather leave it to the institution to adopt the
procedure according to their own need. Moreover, the procedure of
short-listing as devised by the recruiting authority at the time of
seminar presentation has been applied to all the candidates
uniformly and therefore, in no way, it can be termed as arbitrary.
[28]
Considering all these aspects, it is held that the writ
petition is devoid of any merit and therefore, it is liable to be
dismissed. Accordingly, the same is dismissed.
No order as to costs.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Rudradeep
signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally
Date: 2025.11.20 17:47:33 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review