Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.916 of 2021
WP(C)No.917 of 2021
In WP(C)No.916 of 2021
Dr. Biplab De,
son of Sri Bimal Kanti De,
resident of Ujjayanta Complex, Lane-1,
Akashbani gali, Near North Gate,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. East Agartala,
District: West Tripura, PIN: 799 001
---- Petitioner(s)
-VERSUS1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary & Commissioner
to the Department of Health and Family Welfare,
Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division: Agartala, District: West Tripura
2. The Secretary & Commissioner,
Department of Health and Family Welfare,
Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Sub-Division: Agartala,
District: West Tripura
3. The Secretary & Commissioner,
Department of Finance, Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex
4. The Director,
Directorate of Medical Education,
Government of Tripura,
having his office at Bidurkarta Chowmuhani,
2nd floor of Lal Path Laboratory, Agartala,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
Sub-Division: Agartala, District: West Tripura
5. The Regional Institute of Pharmaceutical
Science & Technology,
Medical Education Directorate, Government of Tripura,
represented by its Principal,
having his office at Abhoynagar, Agartala,
District: West Tripura
6. The Principal,
Regional Institute of Pharmaceutical Science & Technology,
Medical Education Directorate, Government of Tripura,
having his office at Abhoynagar, Agartala,
District: West Tripura
---- Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.917 of 2021
Dr. Rishi Raj Chhetree,
son of late Ram Chandra Chhetree,
resident of village: Ramkrishna Palli,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division: Agartala, District: West Tripura,
PIN: 799 006
---- Petitioner(s)
-VERSUS1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary & Commissioner
to the Department of Health and Family Welfare,
Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division: Agartala, District: West Tripura
2. The Secretary & Commissioner,
Department of Health and Family Welfare,
Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, Sub-Division: Agartala,
District: West Tripura
3. The Secretary & Commissioner,
Department of Finance, Government of Tripura,
having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex
4. The Director,
Directorate of Medical Education,
Government of Tripura,
having his office at Bidurkarta Chowmuhani,
2nd floor of Lal Path Laboratory, Agartala,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
Sub-Division: Agartala, District: West Tripura
5. The Regional Institute of Pharmaceutical
Science & Technology,
Medical Education Directorate, Government of Tripura,
represented by its Principal,
having his office at Abhoynagar, Agartala,
District: West Tripura
6. The Principal,
Regional Institute of Pharmaceutical Science & Technology,
Medical Education Directorate, Government of Tripura,
having his office at Abhoynagar, Agartala,
District: West Tripura
---- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Adv.
Ms. R. Chakraborty, Adv.
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. S. Saha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of Hearing &
Judgment and Order
:
07.02.2022
Whether fit for
reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by
Ms. R. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners and
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents.
[02]
Both the petitions being WP(C)No.916 of 2021 and
WP(C)No.917 of 2021 are combined for disposal by a common
judgment as the relief claimed by the petitioners in these petitions are
identical being set up in the resembling facts. The petitioners have
challenged the corrigendum under No.F.6(69-A)-RIPSAT/PER/20012002/1420-28 dated 10.12.2021 issued by the Principal, RIPSAT
[Annexure-29 in WP(C)No.916 of 2021] and the corrigendum under
No.F.6(67)-RIPSAT/PER/2001-2002/1411-19
dated
10.12.2021
[Annexure-13 in WP(C)No.917 of 2021]. That apart, the petitioners
have urged for prohibiting the respondents from acting on the said
corrigendum dated 10.12.2021. Further, the petitioners have urged this
court for directing the respondents to restore the status of the
petitioner as Associate Professor with effect from 05.06.2014 so far the
petitioner in WP(C)916 of 2021 is concerned and with effect from
19.12.2015 so far the petitioner in WP(C)No.917 of 2021 is concerned.
For purpose of appreciating the challenge against the corrigendum
dated 10.12.2021, the relevant facts may be introduced at the outset.
[03]
The petitioner in WP(C)No.916 of 2021 [Dr. Biplab De] was
initially appointed as the Lecturer in Pharma-Chemistry in the Regional
Institute of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology (RIPSAT for short)
under Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura in
the scale of pay of Rs.8,000-13,500/- with retrospective effect from
19.12.2001, but subject to outcome of WP(C)476 of 2001. The said writ
petition was withdrawn and as a result, in no manner, the appointment
of the petitioner in the post of Lecturer, Pharma-Chemistry has been
impacted by the outcome. In the seniority list published on 08.07.2009,
the petitioner was placed at serial No.1 for the post of Lecturer(degree
course) in RIPSAT. In the course of time, the petitioner No.1 was
selected and appointed to the post of Associate Professor in the Assam
University by the order dated 27.08.2011 [Annexure-11 to the writ
petition] being WP(C)No.916 of 2021.
[04]
The petitioner made a prayer for grant of lien for a period
of two years. By the notification dated 15.09.2011 [Annexure-12 to the
writ petition in WP(C)No.916 of 2021] the petitioner was granted two
years’ lien with effect from 26.09.2022. Prior to issuance of the lien, the
petitioner was released from the post of Lecturer in RIPSAT by the
memorandum dated 24.09.2011. The petitioner joined in the post of
Associate Professor in Assam University on 26.09.2011. But before the
lien expired, the petitioner resumed his duty on 05.10.2012 again as
the Lecturer in RIPSAT.
[05]
The petitioners have referred the AICTE regulation. The
part of the AICTE regulation which had been referred by the petitioners
are as follows:
“…..Clause
(a)
Assistant
Professor/Associate
Professors/Professors in Technical Institutions:
…(ii) An Assistant Professor with completed service of 4 years,
possessing Ph.D. degree in the relevant branch/discipline shall
be eligible, for moving up to AGP of Rs.7,000/-.
….(vii) Assistant Professors with completed service of 5 years
at the AGP of Rs.7,000/- shall be eligible, subject to other
requirements laid down by the AICTE, to move upto the AGP of
Rs.8,000/-.
….(xii) Assistant Professors completing 3 years of teaching in
the AGP of Rs.8000 shall be eligible, subject to other
conditions, that may be prescribed by AICTE as applicable, to
move to the Pay band of Rs.37400-67000 with AGP of Rs.9000
and to be designated as Associate Professor.
(xiii) Associate Professor completing 3 years of service in the
AGP of Rs.9000 and possessing a Ph.D degree in the relevant
discipline shall be leigible to be appointed and designated as
Professor, subject to other conditions of academic performance
as laid down by the AICTE. No teacher other than those with a
Ph.D shall be promoted, appointed or designated as Professor.
The pay Band for the post of Professors shall be Rs.3740067000 with AGP of Rs.10000.”
[06]
The relevant notification dated 05.03.2010 [Annexure-18
to the writ petition in WP(C)916 of 2021] has been enclosed. Pursuant
to the notification dated 05.03.2010, a further notification under
No.F.2(86)/RIPSAT/ESTT/2010-11/2376-90 dated 01.03.2013 has been
issued. By the said notification dated 01.03.2013, the revised pay
structure as introduced by AICTE (All India Council for Technical
Education), was extended to the Teachers working in the degree course
in RIPSAT but it was communicated that even though the said revised
pay structure would be effective from 01.01.006, but the period from
01.01.2006 to 31.12.2008 would be notional and the actual financial
benefit would be available from 01.01.2009. It was categorically
mentioned that such revision will only apply in case of the Teachers who
are in the regular scale of pay and has been appointed through the
prescribed
recruitment
process.
Thus,
by
the
notification
dated
01.03.2013, the notification dated 05.03.2010 [Annexure-18] has been
given effect to with certain modifications. In the notification dated
01.03.2013, it has been provided that Assistant Professor [through
CAS] on completing three years of teaching in the AGP of Rs.8,000/shall be eligible subject to other conditions that may be prescribed by
AICTE to move to the pay band of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of
Rs.9,000/- and he will be re-designated as Associate Professor. It has
been further provided that Associate Professor possessing a Ph.D
degree in the relevant discipline shall on completing three years of
service in the AGP of Rs.9,000/- be eligible to be appointed and
designated as Professor, subject to fulfilling the other conditions viz.
academic performance etc. as laid down by AICTE. No teacher other
than those with a Ph.D shall be promoted/appointed or designated as
Professor. The pay band for the post of Professor shall be Rs.37,400/67,000/- with AGP of Rs.10,000/-.
[07]
The Director of Health Services by the order dated
09.09.2014 [Annexure-20 to the WP(C)No.916 of 2021] granted the
CAS scale in the pay band of Rs.37,400/--67,000/- with AGP of
Rs.9,000/- with effect from 05.06.2014 on completion of three years of
continuous service as Assistant Professor. This fact is not disputed.
Since the petitioner was granted the CAS scale in the pay band of
Rs.37,400/--67,000/-
with
AGP
of
Rs.9,000/-
with
effect
from
05.06.2014. According to the petitioner he became eligible with effect
from 05.06.2017 to be appointed or designated as the Professor in the
scale of pay of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of Rs.10,000/-. The
petitioner’s representation on 03.05.2017 for such designation followed
by the representations submitted on 09.07.2019 and 03.09.2020
(available at Aneexure-20). But his prayer was not yielded to.
[08]
Being aggrieved, the petitioners filed a writ petition being
WP(C)No.437 of 2021. The said writ petition was allowed by the
judgment and order dated 02.07.2021 [Annexure-23 to the writ petition
being WP(C)916 of 2021] with the following observations:
“In view of above submissions of the learned counsel appearing
for the parties to the lis, I am of the opinion that the present
petition may be disposed of with the following directions:
(a) The respondents shall definitely consider the appointment
of the petitioner as professor on completion of three years of
service as Associate Professor;
(b) The respondents shall pay the prescribed pay band with
AGP for the post of professor as indicated in Clause-xiii of the
notification w.e.f. 06.06.2017 i.e. the date after completion of
three years of service as Associate Professor and also pay the
arrears of pay as Professor admissible to the petitioner on
completion of three years of service as Associate Professor
w.e.f. 06.06.2017, considering his entitlement under the
Service Rules;
(c) The respondents shall provide other consequential benefits,
if the petitioner is entitled to, as per service rules; and (d) The
entire process shall be completed within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.”
In furtherance of the said judgment and order dated
02.07.2021, the petitioners submitted a representation to the Principal
Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department on 16.07.2021 for
compliance of the said direction contained in the judgment and order
dated 02.07.2021 for their appointment to the post of Professor in
RIPSAT. But by the order under No.F.1(22)-RIPSAT/2021/5546-51
dated 08.10.2021 [Annexure-25 to the writ petition in WP(C)No.916 of
2021], it has been stated that the petitioner was appointed to the post
of Lecturer in Pharma-Chemistry in RIPSAT and subsequently he was
re-designated as Assistant Professor and thereafter, the petitioner was
allowed CAS in the next higher grade pay of Rs.37,400/-67,000/- with
AGP of Rs.9,000/- with effect from 05.06.2014 for his completion of
three-years continuous service as Assistant Professor, by the order
dated 09.09.2014 issued by the Director of Health Services. But it has
been further observed that the recommendation of Screening cum
Evaluation Committee is required for moving to the higher grade pay
but in case of the petitioner such recommendation was not followed
conformity to the requirement of the regulation of AICTE, the
movement to the pay scale of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of
Rs.9,000/- was found irregular.
[09]
The petitioner was communicated that his prayer cannot
be acceded to. But in all records, according to the petitioner, he had
been shown as the Associate Professor. On the face of such emergence
as noted above, the petitioner had urged for initiation of the contempt
proceeding by filing the petition being CONT.CAS(C)No.87 of 2021.
During
the
said
proceeding
a
corrigendum
under
No.F.6(69-A)-
RIPSAT/PER/2001-2002/1420-28 dated 10.12.2021 has been issued
noting that the petitioner shall be treated as Assistant Professor not as
Associate
Professor.
The
said
corrigendum
dated
10.12.2021
[Annexure-29 to the writ petition in WP(C)No.916 of 2021] has been
fundamentally
challenged
in
this
writ
petition
with
the
other
consequential action emanating therefrom. According to the petitioners
it cannot be denied that the petitioners did not meet the requisite
qualification for CAS, for having the benefit of movement to the higher
scale of pay of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of Rs.9000/- and the
movement to the higher scale has duly been granted. Whether the
respondents had formed a committee for purpose of recommendation or
not was beyond the knowledge of the petitioner. Even if such committee
was not formed, for that the petitioner cannot be blamed. Hence, the
corrigendum dated 10.12.2021 is bad in law and liable to be quashed. It
has been further asserted that before issuing the corrigendum dated
10.12.2021 [Annexure-29], no notice was served on the petitioners. It
was an unilateral order taking away the financial benefits as granted to
the petitioner in conformity to the provisions of AICTE regulation. It has
been also asserted that since the petitioner was rightly granted the
benefit of scale of pay of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of Rs.9,000/with effect from 05.09.2014, the petitioner was/is eligible to get the
subsequent CAS benefit being designated or appointed as the Professor
in the pay band of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of Rs.10,000/-.
Moreover, since the judgment and order dated 02.07.2021 has attained
the finality as the respondents did not prefer any appeal or review
therefrom, the respondents are bound by the said judgment of this
court. A judgment of this court cannot be debased by an administrative
order, such as the corrigendum dated 10.12.2021. The said contempt
petition was on the day of filing the said writ petition pending and as
such this court may not observe whether there was deliberate violation
of
the
said
judgment
dated
02.07.2021
[Annexure-23
of
the
WP(C)No.916 of 2021].
[10]
So far as the writ petitioner being WP(C)917 of 2021 is
concerned, the petitioner of the said writ petition was appointed to the
post of Lecturer in RIPSAT by the notification dated 09.01.2002
[Annexure-7 to the writ petition being WP(C)No.917 of 2021] in the
scale of pay of Rs.8,000-13,500/- following the AICTE regulation vide
the notification dated 05.03.2010 [Annexure-8 to the writ petition being
WP(C)917 of 2021]. According to the petitioner in view of the
notification dated 01.03.2013 as referred before, he was eligible to be
moved to the next CAS pay scale of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with academic
grade pay of Rs.9,000/- for his completion of three years service in the
grade of Assistant Professor. It may be noted that the post of Lecturer
in the degree course in RIPSAT was converted to the post of Assistant
Professor by virtue of the revised pay structure which was given
notional effect from 01.01.2006. By the order under No.F.3(430)HFW/2015 dated 22.12.2015 [Annexure-10 to the writ petition being
WP(C)917 of 2021] the petitioner was granted the scale of pay of
Rs.37,400/-67,000/- with AGP of Rs.9,000/- with designation of the
Associate Professor with effect from 19.12.2015. As it would be evident
from the order dated 28.12.2015 [Annexure-11 to the writ petition
being
WP(C)No.917
of
2021].
According
to
the
petitioner
in
WP(C)No.917 of 2021 [Sri Rishi Raj Chetree] he became eligible to be
appointed or designated as the Professor in the pay band of Rs.37,40067,000/- with AGP of Rs.10,000/- with effect from 19.12.2018. When
the petitioner was not granted the said benefit by designating him as
the Professor with the said AGP, the petitioner filed a writ petition being
WP(C)660 of 2021 which was pending for consideration at the time of
filing the writ petition. The said corrigendum dated 10.12.2021
[Annexure-13 to the writ petition being WP(C)917 of 2021] was issued
by cancelling the designation of the Associate Professor. By the said
corrigendum, the designation was recalled and the petition was
designated from Associate Professor to Assistant Professor. The said
corrigendum has also been challenged by this petitioner stating that the
said corrigendum is untenable for the same reasons as stated by the
writ petitioner of WP(C)916 of 2021.
[11]
The respondents by filing their reply did not dispute the
position taken by the petitioner in respect of the notification dated
01.03.2013. They have categorically contended that according to the
AICTE (Career Advancement Scheme for the teachers and other
academic staff in educational institutions Degree) Regulations, 2012 as
published in the Gazette of India on 08.11.2012 [Annexure-R/3 to the
reply filed by the respondents] for purpose of granting the benefits
under the Career Advancement Scheme (CAS) in the degree level
technical institutions the following conditions are to be observed:
i. A teacher must submit in writing to the University/college
within three months in advance of the due date that he/she
fulfils
all
qualifications
under
CAS
and
submit
to
the
University/College the Performance based Appraisal System
(PBAS)
in
a
proforma
as
evolved
by
the
concerned
University/College duly supported by all credentials as per the
Academic Performance Indicator (API) guidelines as given in
Appendix-I as set out in the said Regulations.
ii. There shall be a screening-cum-Evaluation Committee to be
headed
by
the
Principal/Director
of
the
College
for
verification/evaluation of API Score of the candidates through
PBAS
methodology
designed
by
the
respective
University/Directorate of Technical Education as given in the
tables of Appendix-I of the said Regulations.
iii. There shall also be a Selection Committee for selection of
Assistant Professor, Associate Professor and Professor for direct
recruitment and under CAS as prescribed in Clause-4 of the
AICTE Regulations.
iv. There can be no movement of teacher under the CAS from
the Post of Assistant Professor to the post of Associate Professor
or from the post of Associate Professor to the post of Professor
under the CAS without evaluation of a candidate’s API Score by
the screening-cum Evaluation Committee through Performance
Based Appraisal System (PBAS) and without recommendation of
the Selection Committee.
[12]
The respondents have admitted that while granting the
movement under CAS to the petitioners the following procedure was not
followed in terms of the AICTE regulations 2010 and AICTE regulations,
2012. Therefore, the said movement under CAS to the post of Associate
Professor cannot be held regular inasmuch as the Screening cum
Evaluation Committee did not assess the performance of the petitioner
under PBAS. But they have admitted that the case of the petitioners for
the
post
of
Associate
Professor
is
under
consideration
of
the
Government. The petitioner has filed the rejoinder and questioned the
contention raised by the respondents as regards the procedure.
According to them, in terms of the notification dated 05.03.2010, the
designation is to the post of Associate Professor is automatic. That
apart, they have asserted that for performance based appraisal system,
a proforma as evolved by the concerned University/College, duly
supported by all credentials, as per the Academic Performance Indicator
(API) Guidelines, see Appendix-A, is deducible under AICTE Regulations,
2012. But that was never adopted by the State of Tripura. That apart,
no such proforma has been evolved either by RIPSAT or by the
department of Health & Family Welfare, Government of Tripura. They
have categorically stated in their rejoinder that the AICTE Regulation,
2010 was adopted by the Government, not the AICTE Regulation, 2012.
API score under PBAS system is not mentioned in AICTE Regulation,
2010. Screening cum Evaluation Committee is indicated in AICTE
Regulation, 2010 and the government which adopted the same has
indicated in the notification dated 01.03.2013. It has been further
asserted by the petitioners that AICTE Regulations, 2012 & API score
for CAS is not yet considered by the appropriate authority of the
government taking into account of the local conditions i.e. research
activities and infrastructure to provide such facilities to the faculties, so
that teachers are not to be deprived for achieving individual time bound
benefit i.e. CAS due to the lack of facilities/infrastructure. In this
regard, the basic aim of introduction/adoption of AICTE pay structure is
not violated and hence, the corrigendum that has been issued is
untenable and it is to be interfered with and consequential benefit as is
entitled to the petitioner including their movement to the pay band with
AGP for Associate Professor and Professor [with designation] shall be
granted without further consideration.
[13]
Having appreciated the submission of the learned counsel
for the parties as well as of the records as produced by the respondents
the following questions emerge pertinent for consideration of granting
the reliefs as prayed by the petitioners in these two writ petitions:
(i) Whether in terms of the notification dated 01.03.2013 (op.cit)
is there any requirement of recommendation from the Screening
cum
Evaluation
Committee
after
assessment
through
the
Performance Based Appraisal System (PBAS)?
(ii) Whether the movement to the CAS is automatic after three
years of service?
[14]
In the notification dated 01.03.2013 as issued by the
Health & Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura, it has
been categorically provided in paras 11 & 12 as follows:
“11. CAS:
As recommended in the Regulation duly notified by the AICTE
meant for Degree Level Technical Institutions.
12. Qualification and other measures for recruitment and
maintaining standard:
As recommended in the Regulation duly notified by the AICTE
in respect of Degree level Technical Institutions.”
It definitely implies that whatever regulation AICTE notifies that
shall be binding while granting any benefit under CAS. Even in para-2
(xii) of Annexure-R/2 to the notification dated 01.03.2013, the following
has been provided:
“(xii) Assistant Professors through CAS completing 3 years of
teaching in the AGP of Rs.8,000/- shall be eligible, subject to
other conditions, that may prescribed by the AICTE, to move to
the Pay Band of Rs.37,400/-67,000/- with AGP of Rs.9,000/and to be designated as Associate Professor.”
Similarly, it has been provided in para-2, Clause-xiii that
Associate Professor completing 3 years of service in the AGP of
Rs.9,000/- and possessing a Ph.D Degree in the relevant discipline shall
be eligible to be appointed and designated as Professor, subject to the
other conditions of academic performance as laid down by the AICTE.
No teacher other than those with a Ph.D shall be promoted/appointed or
designated as Professor. The Pay Band for the posts of Professor shall
be Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of Rs.10,000/-.
[15]
There is no dispute that both the petitioners are having the
degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D) in their discipline. Therefore, they
are all eligible to be considered for appointment under CAS to the post
of Professor in the pay band of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of
Rs.10,000/-. But in all the provisions it has been made mandatory that
whatever the AICTE provides that shall be applicable for granting any
benefit under CAS to the teachers working under the technical degree
institutions. In this regard, this court has come across the notification of
the AICTE dated 08.11.2012 in respect of Career Advancement Scheme
(CAS)
for
the
teacher
and
other
academic
staff
in
Technical
Institution(Degree). By the said notification dated 08.11.2012, the
regulation called All India Council for Technical Education (Career
Advancement Scheme for the Teachers and other Academic Staff in
Technical Institutions)(Degree) Regulations, 2012 has been made
applicable
to
all
technical
institutions,
approved
by
AICTE
and
Universities including the institutions deemed to be Universities,
imparting technical education and such other courses/programs and
areas as notified by AICTE from time to time. It has been stated that
the same would come into effect from the date when such date will be
notified. But it has been provided that in the event, any candidate
becomes eligible for promotion under Career Advancement Scheme in
terms of these Regulations on or after 05.05.2010, the promotion of
such a candidate shall be governed by the provisions of these
Regulations. By the said regulation which has been notified on
08.011.2012 a detailed procedure has been provided. For purpose of
reference, those procedures as provided by the All India Council for
Technical Education (Career Advancement Scheme for the Teachers and
other Academic Staff in Technical Institutions)(Degree) Regulations,
2012 are reproduced hereunder:
2.
CAREER ADVANCEMENT SCHEME
2.1
2.2
A teacher who wishes to be considered for promotion under CAS may submit in
writing to the University/College, within three months in advance of the due date,
that he/she fulfils all qualifications under CAS and submit to the University/College
the Performance Based Appraisal System (PBAS) in a proforma as evolved by the
concerned University/College duly supported by all credentials as per the Academic
Performance Indicator (API) guidelines (Appendix 1) set out in these Regulations.
In order to avoid delays in holding Selection Committee meetings in various
positions under CAS, the University/College should immediately initate the process
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
of screening/selection, and shall complete the process within six months from the
date of application. Further, in order to avoid any hardships, candidates who fulfill
all other criteria mentioned in these Regulations, as on 05th March, 2010 and till the
date on which these Regulations is notified, can be considered for promotion from
the date, on or after 5th March, 2010, on which they fulfill the eligibility conditions.
Candidates who do not fulfill the minimum score requirement under the API Scoring
System proposed in the Regulations as per Tables II (A and B) of Appendix 1 or
those who obtain less than 50% in the expert assessment of the selection process
will have to be re-assessed only after a minimum period of one year. The date of
promotion shall be the date on which he/she is successfully re-assessed.
The Selection Committee specifications as delineated in Clause 4 are applicable to
Career Advancement Promotion of Assistant Professor to Associate Professor and
Associate Professor to Professor.
CAS promotions from a lower grade to a higher grade of Assistant
Professor/Associate Professor shall be conducted by a “Screening-cum-Evaluation
Committee” adhering to the criteria laid out as API score in Performance Based
Appraisal System(PBAS) in the Tables of Appendix 1.
The “Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee” for CAS promotion of Assistant
Professors/Associate Professor from one AGP to the other higher AGP shall consist
of:
[1]
“Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee” for University teachers:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
[2]
“Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee” for College teachers:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
[3]
2.8
2.9
2.10
2.11
2.12
The Principal/Director of the College;
Head of the concerned department from the College, where there is no
HOD, Professor as nominated by the Principal/Director from the same
or any other Institution in the jurisdiction of the concerned University;
and
Two subject experts in the concerned subject nominated by the Vice
Chancellor or Acting Vice Chancellor from the University panel of
experts.
For Government/Government Aided/Government Autonomous Colleges:
(i)
2.7
The Vice Chancellor or Acting Vice Chancellor, as the Chairperson of the
selection committee;
The Dean of the concerned Faculty;
The Head of the Department/Chairperson of the School; and
One subject expert in the concerned subject nominated by the Vice
Chancellor or Acting Vice Chancellor from the University panel of
experts
As may be prescribed by the respective State Governments/Board of
Governors
The quorum for these committee in both categories mentioned above shall be three
including one subject expert/University nominee need to be present.
The Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee on verification/evaluation of API score
secured by the candidate through the „PBAS‟ methodology designed by the
respective University/Directorate of Technical Education based on these Regulations
and as per the minimum requirement specified in Tables II and III of Appendix 1 for
each of the cadre of Assistant Professor, shall recommend to the
Syndicate/Executive Council/Board of Management of the University/College about
the suitability for the promotion of the candidate(s) under CAS for implementation.
All the selection procedures outlined above, shall be completed on the day of the
selection committee meeting, wherein the minutes are recorded along with PBAS
scoring proforma and recommendation made on the basis of merit and duly signed
by all members of the selection committee in the minutes.
CAS promotion, being a personal promotion to the incumbent teacher holding a
substantive sanctioned post, on superannuation of the individual incumbent, the
said post shall revert to its original cadre.
The incumbent teacher must be on the roll and active service of the
Universities/Colleges on the date of consideration by the Selection Committee for
Selection/CAS Promotion.
Candidates shall offer themselves for assessment for promotion, if they fulfill the
minimum API scores indicated in the appropriate API system tables by submitting
an application and the required PBAS proforma. They can do so three months
2.13
2.14
2.15
2.16
3.
before the due date of the promotion if they consider themselves eligible. In any
event, the University/College concerned shall send a general circular twice a year
calling for applications for CAS promotions from eligible candidates.
In the final assessment, if the candidates do not either fulfill the minimum API
scores in the criteria as per PBAS proforma or obtain less than 50% in expert
assessment, wherever applicable, such candidates will be reassessed only after a
minimum period of one year.
If a candidate applies for promotion immediately on completion of the minimum
eligibility period and is successful the date of promotion will be made applicable
from the date of completion of minimum period of eligibility.
If, however, the candidate finds that he/she fulfils the eligibility conditions at a later
date and applies on that date and is successful, his/her promotion will be effected
form the date of application.
If the candidate does not succeed in the first assessment, but succeeds in the
subsequent assessment, his/her promotion will be deemed to be from the later date
of successful assessment.
STAGES OF PROMOTION UNDER CAREER ADVANCEMENT SCHEME OF INCUMBENT AND
NEWLY APPOINTED ASSISTANT PROFESSORS/ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR/PROFESSORS:
3.1
Entry level Assistant Professors (Stage 1) would be eligible for promotion under the
3.2
3.3
3.4
3.5
3.6
3.7
3.8
3.9
Career Advancement Scheme (CAS) through two successive stages (stage 2 and
stage 3), provided they are assessed to fulfill the eligibility and performance criteria
as laid down in next clause.
In order to remedy the difficulties of collecting retrospective information and to
facilitate the implementation of these Regulations from 5th March, 2010 in the CAS
Promotion, the API based PBAS will be progressively and prospectively rolled out.
Accordingly, the PBAS based on the API scores of categories I and II as mentioned
in the tables of Appendix I is to be implemented for one year, initially based on the
existing systems in Universities/Colleges for one year only with the minimum annual
scores as depicted in Table II (a) and II (b) for University and College teachers.
This annualized API scores can then be compounded progressively as and when the
teacher becomes eligible for CAS promotion to the next cadre. Thus, if a teacher is
considered for CAS promotion in 2013, one year API scores for 2012-13 alone will
be required for assessment. In case of a teacher being considered for CAS
promotion in 2014, two years average of API scores for these categories will be
required for assessment and so on leading progressively for the complete
assessment period.
Assistant Professor, possessing Ph.D Degree in the relevant discipline shall be
eligible, for moving to the next higher grade of Rs.7000 (stage 2) after completion
of four years service as Assistant Professor.
Assistant Professor possessing M. Phil Degree or a Post-Graduate Degree in
professional courses, approved by the relevant statutory body, shall be eligible for
the next higher grade of Rs.7000 (stage 2) after completion of five years service as
Assistant Professor.
Assistant Professor who does not have Ph.D or M. Phil or a Master‟s Degree in the
relevant professional course, shall be eligible for the next higher grade of Rs.7000
(stage 2) only after completion of six years service as Assistant Professor.
The upward movement from the entry level grade (stage 1) to the next higher
grade of Rs.7000 (stage 2) for all Assistant Professors shall be subject to their
satisfying the API based PBAS conditions laid down by the AICTE in this Regulation.
Assistant Professor who has completed five years of service in the grade of Rs.7000
(stage 2) shall be eligible, subject to meeting the API based PBAS requirements laid
down by these Regulations, to move up to next higher grade of Rs.8000 (stage 3).
Assistant Professor completing three years of teaching in the grade of Rs.8000
(stage 3) shall be eligible, subject to the qualifying conditions and the API based
PBAS requirements prescribed by these Regulations, to move to the Pay Band of
Rs.37400-67000 with next higher grade of Rs.9000 (stage 4) and to be designated
as Associate Professor. However, those joining the Service after 5th March 2010
shall have also named Ph.D in addition to above mentioned requirements to move
to the stage 4.
Associate Professor completing three years of service in stage 4 and possessing a
Ph.D Degree in the relevant discipline shall be eligible he appointed and designated
as Professor and be placed in the next higher grade of Rs.10000 (stage 5) subject
to following:
(a) Satisfying the required credit points as per API based PBAS requirements as
provided in Tables of Appendix 1 and
(b) an assessment by a duly constituted selection committee as suggested for the
direct recruitment of Professor.
Provided that no teacher other than those with a Ph.D. shall be promoted or
appointed as Professor.
[16]
Thus,
it
is
apparent
even
from
the
AICTE
(Career
Advancement Scheme for the Teachers and other Academic Staff in
Technical Institutions)(Degree) Regulations, 2012 that in the event, any
candidate
becomes
eligible
for
the
promotion
under
Career
Advancement Scheme (CAS) on or after 05.03.2010, the promotion of
such candidate shall be governed by the provisions of the said
regulation. Hence, the said Regulation, 2012 is all pervading with effect
from 05.03.2010. In granting the CAS benefits under the notification
dated 01.03.2013 has to be done in terms of the said Regulation, 2012
and there is no escape. But at the same time, this court cannot be
oblivious that if a candidate applied for promotion immediately on
completion of the minimum eligibility period and becomes successful,
the date of promotion will be made applicable from the date of
completion of minimum period of eligibility as provided by the said
Regulation, 2012. Thus, the recommendation of the Screening cum
Evaluation Committee is inalienable part of the upgrading one Teacher
in the technical institution (Degree) under CAS. Candidate who is
eligible for consideration shall apply in writing to Universities/Colleges
within three months in advance of due date that he/she fulfills all
qualifications
under
CAS
and
further
submit
the
data
to
the
Universities/Colleges for assessment under the Performance Based
Appraisal System (PBAS) in a proforma, as evolved by the concerned
University/College duly supported by all credentials as per the Academic
Performance
Indicator
(API)
guidelines
(Appendix
1).
The
base
notification dated 05.03.2010 contains the terms and conditions for
introduction of the revised pay structure for the teachers in the degree
courses in technical institutions i.e. RIPSAT etc. as per the AICTE pay
structure-2006
for
the
present
purpose.
Thus,
the
promotion/upgradation under CAS is not automatic. In the present case
for omission to follow the appropriate procedure, the petitioners cannot
be blamed, and as such the respondents are provided a period of six
months from the day of receipt of a copy of this order to follow the
procedure of Career Advancement Scheme for promoting/upgrading the
petitioners to the posts of Associate Professor and Professor, if found
that the petitioners fulfill the eligibility condition on completion of three
years of service in each stage. During that time, subject to outcome of
that evaluation in terms of the Regulation, 2012 the impugned
corrigendum shall not be given effect to for any purpose. The operation
of the impugned corrigendum in respect of the petitioners shall depend
on the outcome of evaluation of the performance in terms of the said
Regulation, 2012 and recommendation by Screening cum Evaluation
Committee. It is made absolutely clear that the petitioners will be
entitled to get the up-gradation on the date when they completed the
minimum period of eligibility, only if it is found that the petitioners were
eligible for promotion under CAS to the post of Associate Professor from
the date when they had completed three years of service from the date
of their completing the minimum period of eligibility for being
considered for promotion under CAS. The respondents cannot be
allowed to take the advantage of their mistake by not considering the
petitioners when they completed the minimum period of eligibility for
such promotion under CAS, as per procedure laid down by AICTE.
[17]
In the result, the petitioners shall be allowed to avail the
benefits of pay band of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of Rs.9,000/- till
such process is completed within the stipulated period as prescribed
above i.e. within six months from the date of receiving a copy of this
order [from the petitioners].
Having observed and directed thus, these writ petitions
stand allowed, to the extent as indicated above.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Moumita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review