Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RP NO. 446 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 17/11/2023 IN OP(KAT) NO.444 OF 2022 OF
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
REVIEW PETITIONER/S:
DR. ANUSREE
AGED 34 YEARS
D/O RAJAN M.K., MADATHIL HOUSE, EDACHERY P.O., VADAKARA,
KOZHIKODE KERALA, PIN - 673502
BY ADVS.
K.M.GEORGE
CHITHRA P.GEORGE
MATHEWS P.GEORGE
RESPONDENT/S:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, SOCIAL JUSTICE
DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN
- 695001
THE SECRETARY
AYUSH DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
THE DIRECTOR
INDIAN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE, AROGYA BHAVAN,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
THE KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE
COMMISSION, PATTOM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004
DR.BISMI.H.B
W/O SYED ALI.T, BAITHUL HUDA, MEKKONE, CHANDANATHOPE.P.O,
KOLLAM, PIN – 691014
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:2:-
2025:KER:31614
SABIRA.K.R
W/O ABDUL HAKEEM, BAITHUL BADAR, VIKKAP, KARIPPODE.P.O,
PALAKKAD, PIN - 678503
DR.RADHIKA MENON
D/O RAMACHANDRAN, 250, INFINITY BY URBAN TREE, PORUSGRADEN,
PHASE 2, VANGARAM, CHENNAI, PIN - 600095
DR.SHIMA SHAJU.E.S
AGED 33 YEARS
D/O SHAJU BASTIN, ELENJIKAL HOUSE, EDAVILANGU P.O, THRISSUR,
PIN - 680671
ASHWATHY V NAIR
AGED 31 YEARS
D/O V.N.VELAYUDHAN NAIR, PLAMAKKAL HOUSE, EZHUPUNNASOUTHP.O,
CHERTHALA, ALAPUZHA, PIN - 686537
TESSY DALIYA.K.J
AGED 31 YEARS
D/O JOSE VINCENT, KANAKODETHU HOUSE, EZHUPUNNASOUTH.P.O,
CHERTHALA, ALAPUZHA, PIN - 688537
DR. GAGANA G.S
AGED 36 YEARS
D/O V.P.GOPALAKRISHNAN, SREESRUTHY, TC 51/2474(1), NRWA
A45/6, ROSELANE, ARAMADA P.O., THIRUMALA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,, PIN - 695032
DR.SUCHITHRA S
AGED 32 YEARS
D/O V.N.SATHYANATHAN, VAZHAPILLIL HOUSE, KUNNUKARA P.O.,
ERNAKULAM,, PIN - 683578
ASWATHY VISWAN
AGED 33 YEARS
PALAYIL HOUSE, ADIMALY P.O, IDUKKI-685 561, NOW RESIDING AT
VALYAPARAMBIL HOUSE, AYARKUNNAM P.O., KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, PIN
- 685564
SREEKALA MOHAN
AGED 33 YEARS
D/O.T.L.MOHAN, THEKKEATTATHUVEEDU, ST.THOMAS NAGAR-64,
MANGAD P.O., KOLLAM DISTRICT, PIN - 691015
ADDITIONAL R15 DR. DINSHA DINESAN
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:3:-
2025:KER:31614
AGED 28 YEARS, W/O. SUKESH S. JAYAN, KADAVIL HOUSE, EDAKOCHI
P.O, COCHIN IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED 19/12/2024 IN IA
2/2024 IN RP 446/2024
BY ADVS.
V.M.KRISHNAKUMAR
ROSHEN.D.ALEXANDER
MAYA M.(K/897/2019)
TINA ALEX THOMAS
HARIMOHAN
KOCHURANI JAMES
SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER SHRI A.J.VARGHESE
THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 12.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RP.513/2024, THE COURT ON 03.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:4:-
2025:KER:31614
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RP NO. 513 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 17/11/2023 IN OP(KAT) NO.107 OF 2023 OF
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
REVIEW PETITIONER/S:
DR. ANUSREE.M.
AGED 34 YEARS
D/O RAJAN M.K., MADATHIL HOUSE, EDACHERY P.O, VADAKARA,
KOZHIKODE KERALA, PIN - 673502
BY ADVS.
K.M.GEORGE
CHITHRA P.GEORGE
MATHEWS P.GEORGE
RESPONDENT/S:
SUDHEENA.S
AGED 32 YEARS
W/O ARJUN SANTOSH, RESIDING AT BISMILLAH MANZIL,
PLACHERY.P.O, PUNALUR, KOLLAM, KERALA, PIN - 691331
SUJINA.P.V
AGED 31 YEARS
W/O DR.FAZIL HAMZA, RESIDING AT DHANYA HOUSE, VELLACHAL,
KODAKKAT.P.O, KASARGOD DISTRICT KERALA, PIN - 671310
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:5:-
2025:KER:31614
DEEPNA.M
AGED 34 YEARS
W/O DR.DILEEPA.K, RESIDING AT PRANAVAM, ADUTHILA,
PAYANGADI.P.O, KANNUR, KERALA., PIN - 670303
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, SOCIAL JUSTICE
DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN
- 695001
THE SECRETARY
AYUSH DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
THE DIRECTOR
INDIAN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE, AROGYA BHAVAN,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER SHRI A.J.VARGHESE
THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 12.03.2025,
ALONG WITH RP.446/2024, THE COURT ON 03.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:6:-
2025:KER:31614
ORDER
Dated this the 3rd day of April 2025
A.Muhamed Mustaque, J.
The backlog vacancies for persons suffering from locomotor
disability for appointment to the post of Medical Officer (Ayurveda)
are to be considered by this Court. The issue in regard to filling up of
the vacancies for differently abled candidates (hereinafter referred to
as ‘DA candidates’) from 07/02/1996 to 18/04/2017 was considered
by the Tribunal, and ordered to report the vacancies during the above
period. This Court, based on an additional statement filed by the
Director of Indian System of Medicine in O.P.(KAT). No. 444/2022,
noted that reservations were made for DA candidates in the 2009
ranked list, 2013 ranked list and the 2014 ranked list; and set aside
the order of the Tribunal to set apart reservations for DA candidates
from 1996 onwards.
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:7:-
2025:KER:31614
2.
There was a dearth of data in regard to the vacancies from
1996 onwards for DA candidates. The Tribunal decided the matter as
though no such reservations based on vacancies were made up to
18/04/2017. This Court decided the matter from a different angle
based on the law on carry forward, on the ground that the
reservations were made in the previous notifications, which resulted
in the ranked lists of the years 2009, 2013 and 2014.
If the
reservations were reckoned from 1996 onwards in the previous
notifications, the judgment of this Court requires no reconsideration,
warranting review.
3. Essentially, the question in this matter revolves around the
factual calculation of vacancies from 1996 onwards and making
available such vacancies in the previous notifications.
4. However, we note that the applicant in O.A.No.1439/2021
before
the
Tribunal
did
not
produce
the
notification
dated
14/12/2017. In the notification, it is specifically stated that 3% of
the vacancies are reserved for DA candidates. There was no fixation
of any vacancies in the notification. It is stated that the notification
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:8:-
2025:KER:31614
was issued as against vacancies anticipated. Thus, it is clear that
there was no calculation of 3% vacancies from 1996 onwards to
accommodate the claim of DA candidates. In such a situation, the
remedy is to challenge the notification claiming reservations from
1996 onwards.
In the absence of any such challenge, the Court
cannot entertain such a plea for reservation after the ranked list is
published. If vacancies as such are reckoned from 1996 onwards for
DA candidates, depending upon the number of vacancies notified,
accommodating general candidates would be minimal or nil. A
notification establishes a level playing field for all, including those
seeking adequate representation through reservations. If the
notification does not provide for the required reservations, the proper
remedy is to challenge it. The rules set in the notification apply
equally to everyone and cannot be altered after the process has
begun, as doing so would disrupt the rights of others. Furthermore,
the PSC cannot exceed the rules of the notification to modify
allocations beyond the predefined norms.
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:9:-
2025:KER:31614
5.
The applicant before the Tribunal challenged a general
order of the Government dated 06/05/2017 issued by the Social
Justice Department fixing 3% reservation for DA candidates based
on cadre strength. According to the applicant/petitioner herein, the
3% reservation should be against the vacancies occurring in a post,
in the light of the judgment of the Apex Court in Union of India and
Others v. National Federation of the Blind and Others [2013
KHC 4816]. The second prayer of the applicant in O.A No.
1439/2021 was to compute the backlog vacancies in the post of
Medical Officer (Ayurveda) from 1996 to 2017. This prayer requires
meritorious consideration if the backlog vacancies had not been
adverted in the earlier notifications. The above contention raised by
the petitioner has merit based on the National Federation of the
Blind (supra). Therefore, the official respondents are bound to
compute the backlog vacancies from 1996 onwards and also have to
find out whether the computed vacancies from 1996 onwards have
been made available in the previous notifications before making fresh
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:10:-
2025:KER:31614
requests in the future to the PSC for appointment in the post of
Medical Officer (Ayurveda).
6.
In the absence of a challenge to the notification dated
14/12/2017, the relief sought by the applicant/petitioner herein
could not have been entertained by the Tribunal. It is seen that the
ranked list was already published on 08/07/2020, and it was
challenged before the Tribunal on 29/07/2021. Therefore, the plea
for reservation from 1996 onwards cannot be entertained at a
belated stage when a ranked list was already published and
appointments were made thereon. The general direction in the
National Federation of the Blind (supra) only points out the right
of DA candidates for reservation from 1996 onwards; thus, conferring
the right of the DA candidates to demand for reservation from 1996
onwards. Such a demand cannot be raised after the publication of
the ranked list, without questioning the notification itself. Therefore,
by reserving liberty to the DA candidates to raise such a demand for
reservation from 1996 onwards, the review petitions stand disposed
of. We make it clear that we have left open the question as to the
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:11:-
2025:KER:31614
demand for reservation from 1996 onwards. Our observation and
findings based on the carry forward rule are accordingly modified,
leaving open the question as above.
Sd/-
A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE, JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JUDGE
ms
[RP Nos.446/2024 IN OP(KAT)444/2022
& RP No.513/2024] IN OP(KAT)107/2023
-:12:-
2025:KER:31614
APPENDIX OF RP 446/2024
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
Annexure R15(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DTD. 31.10.2023 IN
OP(KAT) NO. 396/2023 AND CONNECTED MATTERS.
Annexure R15(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE ADVICE MEMO ISSUED BY THE 3RD
RESPONDENT TO THE APPLICANT HEREIN BEARING NO.
RIF(2)11200/18/GW DTD. 07.07.2023.
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
Annexure R6(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE RANKED LIST PUBLISHED BY KERALA
STATE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION ON 04.01.2025
Exhibit R6(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE REPORTING VACANCIES PERFORM
HAVING ID.NO.35520 ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR OF
INDIAN MEDICAL SYSTEM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review