Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 449 of 2021
1. Dr. Ankita
Bhattacharjee, D/o- Sri Jagabandhu
Bhattacharjee, R/o- South East Corner of Govt. Press
Quarter, Bardowali, Taltala, Agartala, West Tripura, Age29.
2. Dr. Subarna Debnath, D/o- Sri Rajkumar Debnath, R/o –
Ashram Chowmuhani, Dhaleshwar, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN- 799004, Age- 28.
………………..Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura,
(Represented by the Principal Secretary, Department of
Health & Family Welfare, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Complex, P.O – Secretariat Complex, Agartala, West
Tripura).
2. The Secretary, Department of Health, Govt. of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, P.O –Secretariat Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura.
3. The Director, Department of Health, Govt. of Tripura,
Pandit Neheru Complex, Agartala, West Tripura . PIN 799006 .
4. The Medical Superintendent, Agartala Govt. Medical
College & GBP Hospital, P.O- Kunjaban, Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN -799006.
5. Tripura Public Service Commission, Represented by it’s
Secretary, Akhaura Road, P.O- Agartala, P.S-West Tripura,
Dist:- West Tripura, PIN -799001.
6. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission,
Akhaura Road, P.O- Agartala, P.S- West Tripura, Dist :West Tripura, PIN -799001.
7. Sanjoy Aine, S/o- Chandan Aine.
8. Akash Bhowmik, S/o- Tapas Bhowmik.
9. Debaleena Dasgupta, D/o- Debabratra Dasgupta.
10. Kakali Roy, D/o- Hirendra Lal Roy.
11. Sougata Saha, S/o- Goutam Kumar Saha.
12. Debalin Paul, S/o-Late Dhirendra Paul.
13. Sanghamitra Dhar, D/o- Dipal Dhar.
14. Ronit Das, S/o- Ranjit Kumar Das.
15. Prasenjit Shil, S/o- Ranjit Kumar Shil.
16. Debarun Roy, S/o- Bijoy Krishna Roy.
17. Diptanu Chakraborty, S/o Tapan Chakraborty.
18. Subhrangshu Biswas, S/o- Sudip Biswas.
19. Babita Debnath, D/o- Ranjit Debnath.
20. Subranil Ghosh, S/o- Subhasish Ghosh.
21. Saurav Lodh, S/o- Tapan Kumar Lodh.
22. Shaolima Ghosh, D/o- Tapan Ghosh.
23. Anindita Shil, D/o- Subhash Chandra Shil.
24. Baishali Saha, D/o- Arjun Saha.
25. Paramita Debnath, D/o- Narayan Chandra Debnath.
……….. Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. SM Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate
Ms. Ankita Pal, Advocate
Date of hearing and
delivery of judgment
and order
:
18.10.2023.
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment and Order (Oral)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Samarjit
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel and Mr. Kawsik Nath, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners. Also heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned GA representing the Staterespondents as well as Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel representing respondents No.5 &
6 [Tripura Public Service Commission (TPSC)]. Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior
counsel assisted by Ms. Ankita Pal, learned counsel is present on behalf of respondents
No. 7, 8, 10, 12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 20 & 21 and Mr. S. Lodh, learned Legal Aid counsel is
present on behalf of respondents No. 9, 13, 14, 19, 23 & 24.
[2]
The instant writ petition has been preferred under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India for direction to the respondents No.5 & 6 to modify the select list
published vide notification, dated, 15.06.2021 for the post of Junior Medical
Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS, for incorporating the names of
the petitioners in the select list, above the respondents Nos.7 to 25, after adding 10 marks
to the petitioners for performing duty of COVID patients at Obstetrics & Gynecology
Ward, AGMC & GBP Hospital. And further, to pass an interim order, restraining the
respondents No.1 to 4 from giving appointment to the respondents No.7 to 25 in the post
of Junior Medical Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS, till the
disposal of the writ petition.
[3]
The case of the petitioners in brief is that vide Notification dated,
15.06.2021, the Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission (TPSC for short) have
published the list of recommended candidates for the post of Junior Medical
Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS. In the said list of
recommended candidates, the names of the petitioners did not appear. According to the
petitioners, they were illegally deprived of awarding of 10 marks, earmarked for
candidates who have performed duty of COVID 19 patients at health institutions under
the Government of Tripura. The petitioners performed duty of COVID 19 patients at
Obstetrics & Gynecology Ward, AGMC & GBP Hospital. It is opined that the petitioners
are entitled to 10 marks and in that event, the names of the petitioners would have been
in the select list, above the private respondents No.7 to 25 whose names appear at the
serial nos.17 to 35 of the select list, notified on 15.06.2021.
[4]
The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, vide Advertisement
No.03/2021, dated, 08.05.2021, invited online applications in prescribed format from the
citizens of India for selection of candidates for recruitment to the post of Junior Medical
Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS, Group-A, Gazetted under the
Health & Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura. The advertisement
contained the prescribed requisite qualification regarding eligibility. As per the said
advertisement, total number of vacancies in the post of Junior Medical Officer/General
Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS, was shown as 164 including reserved and
unreserved categories of candidates. As per the advertisement dated 08.05.2021, the
following conditions were to be fulfilled by a candidate for getting appointment through
the selection process:
“Selection Process:
(a) As per service rule the Recruitment process will comprise of 02 (two)
steps viz.- i) Short listing of candidates on the basis of API calculation
(Academic Performance Index) (100 marks) & 10 marks for the
candidates who have performed duty of Covid-19 positive patients in the
different health institutions of the Govt. of Tripura, ii) Interview process
(05 marks).
(b) On the basis of total API scoring, including 10 marks for duty of
Covid-19 positive patient, a limited no. of candidates, maximum 3(three)
times of total vacant posts (in category wise), will be selected merit wise
for interview.
(c) It is also mentioned here that candidate(s) scoring marks equal to that
of the last qualified candidate in the API scoring shall also be called for
interview.
(d) The final selection will be made in order of merit on the basis of the
marks obtained by a candidate in the API calculation (out of 110) and by
adding the marks obtained in the Interview/Personality Test. (Out of 05).
(e) In the list of recommendation, merit position of candidates securing
equal marks will be finalized as per their seniority of age. The same
procedure is to be followed for preparing waiting list, if there be any.
Further provided that, in the list of recommendation,
merit position of candidates securing equal marks in aggregate and also
of the same age will be decided on the basis of percentage of marks
obtained in the minimum educational qualification prescribed in
Recruitment Rules/ Service Rules.”
[5]
Thereafter, another Notification was issued by the TPSC on 20.05.2021
notifying that “10 marks for the candidates who have performed duty of Covid-19
positive patients in the different health institutions of the Govt. of Tripura” as mentioned
in Para-(a) of selection process of the aforesaid advertisement, will be provided as a one
time measure.
[6]
The petitioners have requisite qualification for the post of Junior Medical
Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS, in terms of the Advertisement,
dated, 08.05.2021, issued by the TPSC. The petitioners obtained MBBS Degree and
thereafter got admission to the Post Graduate Course in Obstetrics & Gynecology at
Agartala Government Medical College. Both the petitioners applied for the post of Junior
Medical Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS. The petitioners along
with the applications, enclosed all necessary documents, including certificates, dated
12.05.2021, issued by Professor & Head, Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology,
Agartala Government Medical College. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioners that
during the Corona period, expected mothers and other patients with Gynecological
problems, who were COVID positive were admitted and treated at the Obstetrics &
Gynecology Ward of the AGMC & GBP Hospital, where the petitioners are serving as
Post Graduate Junior Resident (Academic). It is also submitted on behalf of the
petitioners that as per the Register, maintained in the Obstetrics & Gynecology Ward of
AGMC & GBP Hospital, 141 cases of Vaginal Deliveries of COVID positive expected
mothers were handled at the Obstetrics & Gynecology Ward, AGMC & GBP Hospital
and 53 cases of Cesarean Section of COVID positive patients were similarly handled at
Obstetrics & Gynecology Ward. Further, 12 Minor Operations & 7 Major Operations of
COVID infected patients were also handled during COVID period at the Obstetrics &
Gynecology Ward, AGMC & GBP Hospital.
[7]
The petitioners submitted duly filled up API calculation sheet for
recruitment to the post of Junior Medical Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, GradeIV of THS. They mentioned total API score out of 100 and also stated “YES” in respect
to Column “Whether performed duty of Covid-19 positive patients in different health
institutions of the Govt. of Tripura (Yes or No)”. But, while appearing in the interview,
they were compelled to write “NO” against the said column in premeditated format.
[8]
On 15.06.2021, the Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission
(TPSC for short) have published a Notification with the list of recommended candidates
for the post of Junior Medical Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS.
In the said list of recommended candidates, the names of the petitioners did not appear as
they had not been awarded with 10 marks earmarked for candidates who have performed
duty of COVID 19 patients at health institutions under the Government of Tripura.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners have preferred the instant writ petition.
[9]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners
submits that, the petitioners are illegally deprived of awarding of 10 marks, earmarked
for the candidates who have performed duty of COVID 19 patients at health institutions
under the Government of Tripura. The petitioners performed duty of COVID 19 patients
at Obstetrics & Gynecology Ward, AGMC & GBP Hospital. Learned senior counsel
submits that petitioners are entitled to 10 marks and in that event, the names of the
petitioners would have been in the select list, above the private respondents No.7 to 25
whose names appear at the serial nos.17 to 35 of the select list, notified on 15.06.2021.
Both the petitioners have not been given 10 additional marks for performing duty of
COVID 19 positive patients and if they were allowed 10 marks then total score of the
Petitioner No.1 would be 76.65 (API 66.65 + 10 for COVID duty) & the Petitioner No.2
would be 78.53 (API 68.53 + 10 for COVID duty). Hence, learned senior counsel for the
petitioners prays that the instant writ petition be allowed by this Court considering the
fact that the petitioners are illegally deprived of by the official respondents.
[10]
On the contrary, Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate
representing the State submits that offer of appointment was issued to the 156 selected
candidates on the basis of recommendation of TPSC. Out of the total vacancies of 164
nos. of posts, the said 156 nos. of candidates were selected for the post of Junior Medical
Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS maintaining all formalities. He
contended that since the petitioners have not complied with the procedure contemplated
in the selection process though they have submitted certificates issued by Professor &
Head, Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Agartala Government Medical College,
their case was not considered for awarding with the additional marks and their selection
was rejected.
[11]
Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents No.5 & 6
(Tripura Public Service Commission) submits that the TPSC has only processed the list
with the information which has been supplied by the Directorate of Health Service,
Government of Tripura and the selection list has been prepared as per the Notification
dated 08.05.2021 and the memorandum dated 07.05.2021.
[12]
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel appearing for respondents
No. 7, 8, 10, 12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 20 & 21 submits that the respondents who have got 10
marks for duty in COVID period and selected for the post of Junior Medical
Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS are Respondents No.7, 8, 10,
15, 17, 18 & 21. He has also informed that the respondents who have been selected for
the said post but have not been awarded with 10 marks for duty in COVID period, are
Respondents No.12, 16 & 20.
[13]
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for respondents No. 9, 13, 14,
19, 23 & 24 contends that the respondents who have got 10 marks for duty in COVID
period and selected for the post of Junior Medical Officer/General Duty Medical Officer,
Grade-IV of THS are Respondents No.13 & 14. He has also informed that the
respondents who have been selected for the said post but have not been awarded with 10
marks for duty in COVID period, are Respondents No.9, 19, 23 & 24. He submits that it
is the employer who is best suited to decide the requirements a candidate must possess
according to the needs of the employer and the nature of work. The respondents (selected
candidates) herein, have been appointed following all formalities in the selection process.
He has further placed reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in Maharashtra
Public Service Commission Versus Sandeep Shriram Warade and others reported in
(2019) 6 SCC 362, the relevant portion of the same is quoted hereunder:
“9. The essential qualifications for appointment to a post are for the
employer to decide. The employer may prescribe additional or desirable
qualifications, including any grant of preference. It is the employer who is
best suited to decide the requirements a candidate must possess according
to the needs of the employer and the nature of work. The court cannot lay
down the conditions of eligibility, much less can it delve into the issue
with regard to desirable qualifications being on a par with the essential
eligibility by an interpretive re-writing of the advertisement. Questions of
equivalence will also fall outside the domain of judicial review. If the
language of the advertisement and the rules are clear, the court cannot sit
in judgment over the same. If there is an ambiguity in the advertisement or
it is contrary to any rules or law the matter has to go back to the
appointing authority after appropriate orders, to proceed in accordance
with law. In no case can the court, in the garb of judicial review, sit in the
chair of the appointing authority to decide what is best for the employer
and interpret the conditions of the advertisement contrary to the plain
language of the same.”
[14]
Admittedly, the entire process of selection in the notification issued by
the Tripura Public Service Commission (TPSC) on 08.05.2021 which has already been
quoted earlier, does not indicate that the certificate of Director, Medical and Health
Services needs to be enclosed. The petitioners complied with the all conditions and
insofar as duty of COVID 19 positive patients certificate is also concerned, they have
submitted certificates issued by their concerned Head of the Department indicating that
during the COVID 19 pandemic situation, they rendered medical services to the patients
in the Department of Obstetrics & Gynaecology and performed deliveries to the pregnant
women. Accordingly, they are entitled for 10 marks as per the Memorandum dated
07.05.2021 of the Government issued in this regard. There is a lot of correspondence
made between the Government and the Tripura Public Service Commission but, in a bare
reading of the memorandums issued by the Government do not indicate that they are
made available in the public domain through their website.
[15]
It is also not expected by the Government that once a notification by all
means, is issued time to time, they need to supplement their original selection conditions
making it tailor made for the reasons best known to them and they deprived the genuine
candidates who performed their duties risking their lives during the COVID period.
[16]
It appears that the official respondents could have performed their duties
with more care but, in the present case, it appears that in a casual manner, the
respondent- Tripura Public Service Commission has acted with premeditated mind. The
format which has already been prepared and signatures have been obtained during the
course of interview which categorically indicates in the column “Whether performed
duty of COVID-19 positive patients in different health institutions of the Govt. of
Tripura after completion of Internship (Yes or No)”. The said format is as follows:
“TRIPURA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
AGARTALA
Particulars of relevant academic records, declaration regarding duty of COVID-19 positive patient’s in different health institutions of
the Govt. of Tripura & details of Permanent Registration Certificate
Advt No. 03/2021 dated 08.05.2021 and subsequent Addendum
dated 17.05.2021 & Notification dated 12.05.2021 & 20.05.2021
No. of Post:- 64 Nos. (UR-35, SC 28 & ST-101)
Name of the post :- Junior Medical Officer/ General Duty
Medical Officer
Date of interview : 09.06.2021.
Name of the Department :- Health & Family Welfare Department.
Name of the candidate
:-
Father’s Name
:
Roll No.
:TABLE –A
Aggregate of MBBS
Examination marks
obtained
in
all
MBBS
Examinations
Total marks allotted
in
all
MBBS
Examinations
a
b
Whether performed duty of COVID-19
positive patient’s in different
health
institutions of the Govt. of Tripura after
completion of Internship ( Yes or No)
No
%
of
marks
[(Aggregate
of
MBBS Examination
marks obtained in all
MBBS Examinations
÷
Total
marks
allotted in all MBBS
Examinations) x 100]
c
Number
of
additional attempt
in MBBS Course
Marks deducted
for each additional
attempt in the
MBBS Course [
Number
of
additional attempt
x2] marks
Total API score (
out of 100)[c-e]
d
e
f
Whether certificate issued by the Director, Health Service, Govt.
of Tripura
Allotted marks (
10 marks)
No
TABLE –B
Permanent Registration Certificate
Name of Issuing Authority
Date of Issue
Registration Number
I do hereby declare that the above statement made by me is true & correct to the best of my knowledge. Any kind of false
declaration will be liable for rejection of my candidate at any stage.
Full Signature of the Applicant”
[17]
This format was not required as the petitioners themselves in their own
hand-writing submitted duly filled up API calculation sheet for recruitment to the post of
Junior Medical Officer/General Duty Medical Officer, Grade-IV of THS along with the
application. They mentioned total API score out of 100 and also stated “YES” in respect
to Column “Whether performed duty of Covid-19 positive patients in different health
institutions of the Govt. of Tripura (Yes or No)”. To put it into controversy, the official
respondents said that the case of the petitioners could not be considered since they have
not forwarded the applications through the Director, Department of Health, Government
of Tripura and the certificate issued by the Head of the Department cannot be accepted.
In this regard, this Court has ordered an inquiry on 24.08.2023, to be conducted by the
Principal Secretary, Department of Health & Family Welfare, Govt. of Tripura and to
obtain a report to ascertain whether the content which is issued by the HOD to say that
the petitioners rendered their services to the COVID-19 patients during the pandemic
were correct or not. Accordingly, the inquiry was conducted and report has been
submitted by the official respondents along with the additional counter affidavit dated
17.10.2023 and as per report, the contents of the certificates issued by the Head of the
Department in favour of the petitioners are correct. The internal correspondence and
issuance of supplementary instructions to the main notice dated 08.05.2021 of Tripura
Public Service Commission either through itself or through the respondents No.1 to 4
cannot be appreciated. Once a Notification and selection process is on, it should be
reasonably presumed that with all cautious, the selection authorities and the Government
in its selection agency have acted with a due diligence but, in this case the official
respondents acted in a unfair manner. This Court has no hesitation to say the action of
the official respondents is totally highhanded, arbitrary putting the petitioners to suffer
and deprived the society of eminent doctors who are service oriented and away from
their service from 2020-21 onwards.
[18]
In the selection list, the names of the petitioners did not appear. As per
the selection list, petitioner No.1 got 66.65 marks and the petitioner No.2 got 68.53
marks. But, if they were allowed 10 marks and were not deprived, then total score of the
Petitioner No.1 supposed to have been 76.65 (API 66.65 + 10 for COVID duty) & the
Petitioner No.2 supposed to have been 78.53 (API 68.53 + 10 for COVID duty).
[19]
Hence, this Court feels that the petitioners are entitled for addition of 10
marks and accordingly, Petitioner No.1 will get 76.65 marks (API 66.65 + 10 for COVID
duty) & the Petitioner No.2 will get 78.53 marks (API 68.53 + 10 for COVID duty). This
Court declares that they are entitled to get their additional marks and thus, their suitable
rank should be placed in the selection list. Hence, the writ petition is liable to be allowed
by declaring the action of the official respondents as illegal, highhanded and arbitrary
and direct the official respondents to place the petitioners in their suitable rank in the
selection list and accordingly provide them appointment as per procedure forthwith.
Since, it is indicated in the counter affidavit submitted by the State that there are 8
vacancies (out of 164 sanctioned post, 156 were recruited), both the petitioners can be
accommodated in the employment.
In view of the above, the appointment already provided to the unofficial
respondents will not be disturbed and admittedly, they are not the aggrieved parties. This
Court is conscious and it is not sitting over as a selection official nor reviewing the
selection norms. But, this Court is finding fault with the manner in which the official
respondents have acted in the process of adopting the selection procedure and committed
irregularities depriving the legitimate rights of the petitioners. This Court finds that the
action of the official respondents in not providing employment to the petitioners as
illegal, arbitrary & highhanded and declare that the petitioners are entitled for
employment.
In view of the above there shall be a direction to the official respondents
to provide employment to the petitioners forthwith. Accordingly, this instant writ petition
is allowed.
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall also
stand closed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
GHOSH
Date: 2023.10.19 13:31:41 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review