Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.779 of 2023
Dr. Anita Das,
W/o: Dr. Rajesh Ranjan Das,
R/o: 79 Tilla Housing Complex, Block-A, Room No:301,
P.O: Kunjaban, Agartala, Tripura, P.S: NCC, Pin: 799006.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Secretary, Department of
Health & Family Welfare Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Building, New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The Under Secretary, Department of Health and Family Welfare, Govt.
of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura.
3. The Director, Department of Health and Family Welfare, Govt. of
Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura.
4. The Superintendent, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala, West Tripura.
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, GA
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
:
16.08.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the impugned transfer order dated 06.12.2023 issued by the
Under Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department, Govt. of Tripura
(Annexure-4 to the writ petition) whereby and whereunder she had been
transferred to Khowai District Hospital, mainly on the ground that her son,
who is aged about 22 years, is suffering from autism, which is evident from
the Disability Certificate dated 09.06.2021(Annexure-1 to the writ petition)
issued by the authority concerned.
2.
Facts:
2.1.
The petitioner is a doctor specialized in Oral Pathology &
Microbiology. She was appointed in the year 1998. The first posting of the
petitioner was at Community Health Centre(CHC), Kalyanpur where she
had served upto 2013. In the year 2013, she was posted at the AGMC &
GBP Hospital, Agartala, Tripura. Thereafter, the petitioner got married to
Dr. Rajesh Ranjan Das, who is also a doctor and now is serving as Associate
Professor in the AGMC & GBP Hospital. The son of the petitioner is
suffering from Autism Spectrum Disorder. It is stated in the writ petition that
the writ petitioner being the mother is the care-giver of her disabled child
suffering from autism. It is pleaded that her son, Sri Hritaban Das needs
constant high support since sometimes he becomes aggressive and shows
abnormal behaviour. The son of the petitioner also needs consultation in
OPD. For this reason, she should not be transferred from her present place of
posting at AGMC & GBP Hospital to any other place, which may cause
serious hindrance to the support system which the petitioner is now
providing to her son. On the aforementioned grounds, the petitioner has
come forward before this Court challenging the said impugned transfer
order.
2.2.
This Court vide order dated 18.12.2023 directed the
respondents to consider the transfer order of the writ petitioner to Khowai
District Hospital and to re-examine the issue. An interim protection was also
given to the petitioner so that she could not be forced to join her new place
of posting. In pursuance of the said order passed by this Court, the Staterespondents under order dated 20.02.2024 expressed their inability to modify
the transfer order. The relevant portion of the order dated 20.02.2024 is
reproduced hereunder:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT
No.F.3(154)-HFW/2023
Dated: 20/02/2024
………..Whereas, it has been decided that Dr. Das will be allowed to leave her work
place at Khowai DH for one hour before completion of the scheduled duty hours for
supporting daily needs of her mentally son Sri Hritaban Das.
AND
Now, therefore, after consideration of all aspects, the competent authority is
pleased to Order that the Department may post Dr. Anita Das to the nearest District of
Agartala i.e. Khowai District Hospital which is merely 44 K.M. away as compared to
Other District, as per approval of the Government.
Accordingly, the representation dated-20/12/2023 is disposed of
By Order of the Governor,
-Sd
Under Secretary to the
Government of Tripura”
2.3.
Thereafter, this Court had passed another order dated
05.03.2024 extending the period of interim protection given to the writ
petitioner and directed to list the matter on 09.04.2024 for filing an affidavitin-opposition. The respondents, accordingly, have filed affidavit-inopposition.
2.4.
From the order dated 23.04.2024 it comes to light that exchange
of pleadings was complete and both the parties had urged this Court to hear
and dispose of the matter finally.
2.5.
In the meantime, the State-respondents have come up with an
application for vacating the said order stating inter alia that the respondents
have re-examined the issue in question and on such re-consideration have
decided to modify the impugned transfer order and they are ready to transfer
the petitioner in Gomati District Hospital, Gomati District instead of Khowai
District Hospital where adequate medical facilities are available for the
autistic persons like the son of the petitioner.
2.6.
This Court vide order dated 13.08.2024 directed the
respondents to clarify certain doubts regarding the availability of medical
facilities in Gomati District Hospital and the establishment of District Early
Intervention Centre(for short, DEIC) and the matter was directed to be listed
today for final hearing and disposal.
3.
On the aforesaid background of facts, I have heard Mr. P. Roy
Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Kohinoor N.
Bhattacharyya, learned GA appearing for the respondents-State.
4.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner:
4.1.
In view of the order dated 13.08.2024, it is submitted by Mr.
Roy Barman, learned senior counsel that the parents, i.e. the petitioner and
her husband had visited Gomati District Hospital and they have placed on
record by way of affidavit that DEIC is only meant for treating the children
of 0 to 6 years. Further, there is no provision for providing treatment to an
autistic person having the age of 22 years.
4.2.
It is strongly argued that the respondents have ignored the
objectives of the RPWD Act, 2016 and did not consider at all the condition
of the son of the petitioner while transferring her to a place away from her
present place of posting. The respondents ought to have considered the fact
that the son of the petitioner sometimes becomes very aggressive and shows
abnormal behaviour. Learned senior counsel has strenuously argued that the
son of the writ petitioner suffers from 90% disability. The transfer of the
petitioner to Gomati District Hospital, Udaipur will interrupt the behavioural
training of her son.
4.3.
Though not alleged in the writ petition but, learned senior
counsel has urged this Court to lift the veil behind the issuance of the
impugned transfer order placing her service to a place other than her present
place of posting. According to him, the transfer order is not bonafide.
To support his arguments, Mr. Roy Barman has given much
emphasis on Section 38 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act,
2016(for short, RPWD Act). Learned senior counsel has also pressed upon a
decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court passed in the case of Vikash Kumar
vs. Union Public Service Commission & Ors, (2021) 5 SCC 370. To
conclude, Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has strongly urged before
this Court that it is a fit case for this Court to interfere with the impugned
transfer order as it is illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory.
5.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents:
5.1.
Opposing the submissions of learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner and to defend the impugned transfer order and subsequent
decision to modify the said order, Mr. Bhattacharyya, learned GA has
submitted that the respondents have re-examined the issue looking into the
interest of the welfare and best well-being of the son of the petitioner.
Having reviewed the entire aspects involving public interest as well as the
interest of the son of the petitioner, the respondents are ready to transfer the
petitioner to Gomati District Hospital (for short, Gomati DH), subject to
approval of the Court. It is found that there is long-standing demand that
Gomati DH needs service of a doctor like the writ petitioner, which will
cater service to not only the people of Gomati District but also the adjacent
districts. Keeping in view the objectives and purpose of RPWD Act, the
respondents have taken into account the facilities and various infrastructures
at Gomati District Hospital so that the treatment of the son of the writ
petitioner is not affected in any manner whatsoever. His ultimate submission
is that the service of the petitioner will be utilized to the patients and the
people at large residing in Gomati District as well as adjacent two districts,
viz, South Tripura and Sepahijala. Learned GA has further submitted that the
support services which the writ petitioner is presently rendering towards her
son shall not in any way be hindered. The petitioner will not be dissociated
in any manner whatsoever from her son. The son being aged about 22 years
would reside with the writ petitioner. So, there is no question of any
dislocation of the writ petitioner from her son.
5.2.
Mr. Bhattacharyya, learned GA has also urged this Court to
consider the fact that the Government of Tripura has established a Dental
Medical College at Agartala where all infrastructures are available. So, the
service of the writ petitioner is urgently required in other districts like
Gomati District wherefrom she would also be able to cater service to the
adjoining areas and districts.
5.3.
Lastly, learned GA has submitted that the petitioner should not
forget the fact that transfer is incidental to service and one has no vested
right to claim his/her posting at a place of his/her choice.
6.
Analysis and Conclusion:
6.1.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing
for the parties.
6.2.
Before I deal with the submissions of learned counsel appearing
for the parties and the merits of the present writ petition, I would like to refer
to the salient features of the RPWD Bill, 2014, which inter alia, are:
“(i) Nineteen specified disabilities have been defined;
(ii) the persons with disabilities enjoy various rights such as right to
equality, life with dignity, respect for his or her integrity, etc., equally with
others;
(iii) duties and responsibilities of the appropriate Government have been
enumerated;
(iv) all educational institutions funded by appropriate Government shall
provide inclusive education to the children with disabilities;
(v) a National Fund is proposed to provide financial support to persons
with disabilities;
(vi) stakeholders' participation in the policy making through Central and
State Advisory Boards;
(vii) increase in reservation in posts from existing three per cent to five per
cent in the vacancies for persons or class of persons with benchmark
disabilities in every establishment and reservation of seats for students with
benchmark disabilities in higher educational institutions;
(viii) setting up of National Commission and State Commission to act as
Grievance Redressal Mechanism, monitor implementation of the proposed
legislation replacing the Chief Commissioner and State Commissioners for
persons with disabilities, respectively,
(ix)guidelines to be issued by the Central Government for issuance of
certificates of specified disabilities;
(x) penalties for offences committed against persons with disabilities; and
(xi) Court of Session to be designated as Special Court by the State
Government in every district to try offences.”
6.3.
It is no more res integra that the scope of RPWD Act is wider
than what it was under the Persons with Disabilities(Equal Opportunities,
Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995(for short, PWD Act).
Keeping in mind the objective of the RPWD Act, I am not in disagreement
with Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel that it is a welfare legislation
to provide sufficient and enough opportunities and benefits to a person
suffering from physical or mental disability. However, in my opinion, it is
equally to be kept in mind that no one should take the advantage of the
RPWD Act. It is true that the interest of the persons with disabilities would
be the paramount consideration and a care-giver of a disabled person
should not be a subject to discrimination. A care-giver is entitled to be
provided with all facilities to support the person with disabilities. Keeping in
mind the aforesaid principles, now, I may proceed to examine whether the
decision of the respondents to transfer the petitioner to Gomati DH in
modification of the impugned transfer order is necessary to be interfered
with by this Court or not.
6.4.
At the outset, I should record that the Government of Tripura in
pursuance of the RPWD Act and in compliance with various guidelines
issued time to time by the Central Government has formulated certain
policies to take care of the interest of the children with physical and mental
disabilities. From the records, it appears that the District Disability Board
has certified that the son of the petitioner suffers from 75% disability. It is
also evident from another certificate that the son of the petitioner sometimes
becomes very aggressive and shows abnormal behaviour.
6.5.
While proceeding to decide the present case, I feel it necessary
to take note of the definitions of some terminologies mentioned in the
RPWD Act. In the RPWD Act, the term „care-giver‟ is defined under
Section 2(d) which means any person including parents and other family
members who with or without payment provides care, support or assistance
to a person with disability.
The term „discrimination‟ is defined under Sub-section (h) of
the Section 2 which enumerates that discrimination in relation to disability,
means any distinction, exclusion, restriction on the basis of disability which
is the purpose or effect of impairing or nullifying the recognition, enjoyment
or exercise on an equal basis with others of all human rights and
fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural, civil or
any other field and includes all forms of discrimination and denial of
reasonable accommodation;
„High support‟ is defined under Section 2(l) which means an
intensive support, physical, psychological and otherwise, which may be
required by a person with benchmark disability for daily activities, to take
independent and informed decision to access facilities and participating in
all areas of life including education, employment, family and community life
and treatment and therapy;
„Person with benchmark disability‟ is defined under Section
2(r) which means a person with not less than forty per cent of a specified
disability where specified disability has not been defined in measurable
terms and includes a person with disability where specified disability has
been defined in measurable terms, as certified by the certifying authority.
„Person with disability‟ is defined under Section 2(s) which
means a person with long term physical, mental, intellectual or sensory
impairment which, in interaction with barriers, hinders his full and effective
participation in society equally with others.
„Person with disability having high support needs‟ is defined
under Section 2(t) which means a person with benchmark disability certified
under clause (a) of sub-section (2) of Section 58 who needs high support.
It is also important to note the definition of „reasonable
accommodation‟ defined under Section 2(y) which means necessary and
appropriate
modification
and
adjustments,
without
imposing
a
disproportionate or undue burden in a particular case, to ensure to persons
with disabilities the enjoyment or exercise of rights equally with others.
Section 2(za) defines „rehabilitation‟ which refers to a process
aimed at enabling persons with disabilities to attain and maintain optimal,
physical, sensory, intellectual, psychological environmental or social
function levels.
6.6.
To decide the present challenge, in my opinion, paramount
consideration is to look upon whether the interest of the son of the petitioner
has properly been taken care of by the State-respondents while
modifying/transferring the writ petitioner from her present place of posting
at Agartala to Gomati DH at Udaipur, Gomati District. From the application
for vacating the said order as well as the submissions advanced by learned
GA for the respondents it comes to fore that due to establishment of the
Dental Medical College at Agartala, having all infrastructures thereof, the
service of the petitioner at her present place of posting at AGMC & GBP
Hospital is not a necessity, rather, public interest demands the posting of the
petitioner at a hospital where such service lacks, leading to increased
sufferings to the people of other districts. The petitioner is specialized in oral
pathology and microbiology. As such, considering public interest the
petitioner is re-considered to be transferred to Gomati District Hospital
wherefrom she would be able to cater service to the bigger districts of the
State of Tripura. The patients as well as the people of those districts now can
avail the service of a specialized doctor in dentistry. During the entire
exercise the respondents have taken care of the interest of the son of the
petitioner too.
6.7.
I have perused various guidelines as relied upon by the
petitioner in her writ petition. Firstly, I should refer to Office Memorandum
dated 8th October, 2018 issued by the Ministry of Personnel, Public
Grievances & Pensions, Department of Personnel & Training, Government
of India where it is notified that the care-givers of persons with disabilities
should be exempted from routine exercise of transfer/rotational transfer,
however, subject to administrative constraints. Para 3 of the said office
memorandum may be extracted hereunder, for convenience:
“ 3. With the enactment of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act,
2016 on April 17, 2017, the following instructions are issued in
supersession of the above-mentioned OMs of even number dated June 6,
2014, November 17, 2014 and January 5, 2016 with regard to the eligibility
for seeking exemption from routine exercise of transfer/rotational transfer:
(i) A Government employee who is a care-giver of dependent
daughter/son/parents/spouse/brother/sister with Specified Disability, as
certified by the certifying authority as a Person with Benchmark Disability
as defined under Section 2(r) of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act,
2016 may be exempted from the routine exercise of transfer/rotational
transfer subject to the administrative constraints.
(ii) The term "Specified Disability" as defined in the Schedule to the
Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, covers (i) Locomotor
disability including leprosy cured person, cerebral palsy, dwarfism,
muscular dystrophy and Acid attack victims (ii) Blindness (iii) Low-vision
(iv) Deaf (v) Hard of hearing (vi) Speech and language disabilities (vii)
Intellectual disability including specific learning disabilities and autism
spectrum disorder (viii) Mental illness (ix) Disability caused due to: (a)
Neurological conditions such as Multiple sclerosis and Parkinson's disease
(b) Blood disorder- Haemophilia, Thalassemia and Sickle cell disease and
(x) Multiple disabilities (more than one of the above specified disabilities)
including deaf blindness and any other category of disabilities as may be
notified by the Central Government.
(iii) The term 'Specified Disability' as defined herein is applicable as
grounds only for the purpose of seeking exemption from routine transfer/
rotational transfer by a Government employee, who is a care-giver of
dependent daughter/son/parents/spouse/brother/sister as stated in Para 3(i)
above…….
-Sd
(G. Srinivasan)
Director(Res)
Tel: 2309 3074”
6.8.
Keeping in conformity with the said office memorandum dated
8th October, 2018, issued by the Government of India, the General
Administration (Personnel &Training) Department, Government of Tripura
came up with an office memorandum dated 15 th November, 2021. The
relevant portion of the said office memorandum may be extracted hereunder,
for convenience:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION (P & T) DEPARTMENT
No.F.23(39)-GA(P&T)/2021/
Dated, Agartala
The 15th November, 2021
MEMO
..……..Considering that transfer of a Government employee who serves
as the main care giver of persons with disability would have a bearing on the
systematic rehabilitation of persons with disabilities, the Government issued
OM of even number dated June 6, 2014 to exempt such employee from
routine exercise of transfer/rotational transfer, subject to administrative
constraints.
2. The scope of disability initially had covered (i) blindness or low
vision (ii) hearing impairment (iii) locomotor disability or cerebral Palsy(iv)
leprosy cured (v) mental retardation (vi) mental illness and (vii) multiple
disabilities, which subsequently, vide OMs of even number dated November
17, 2014 and January 5, 2016, was further extended to include 'Autism,
"Thalassemia' and 'Haemophilia'.
3. With the enactment of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act,
2016 on April 17, 2017, the following instructions are issued in super session
of the above- mentioned OMs of even number dated June 6, 2014, November
17, 2014 and January 5, 2016 with regard to the eligibility for seeking
exemption from routine exercise of transfer/rotational transfer
i A Government employee who is a care-giver of dependent
daughter/son/parents/spouse/brother/sister with Specified Disability,
as certified by the certifying authority as a Person with Benchmark
Disability as defined under Section 2(r) of the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities Act, 2016 may be exempted from the routine exercise of
transfer/ rotational transfer subject to the administrative constraints.
ii. ****
iii. ****
**** ****
**** ****
-Sd
Under Secretary to the
Government of Tripura”
Later on, the Government of Tripura has issued another
memorandum dated 25th November, 2021 wherein in addition to the benefits
of the care-giver under the aforesaid memoranda, following additional
benefits are provided. The relevant portion is reproduced hereunder:
“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION (PERSONNEL & TRAINING) DEPARTMENT
No.F.23(43)-GA(P&T)/2021
Dated, Agartala, The 25th November, 2021
MEMORANDUM
…….(a) The guidelines for posting of caregivers may also take into
consideration the need and requirement of each of the specified disability
separately as in some cases it may not be feasible to shift the dependent
to new place owing to nature of disability. In such cases the posting of
caregiver may be considered at such place which does not hinder the
caregiver to attend to the needs of dependent (disabled person of
specified disability).
b) There may be an arrangement to provide appropriate reliefs to
caregivers, which could include giving a suitable break during working
hours to attend to the dependent person inflicted with specified
disabilities. Such an arrangement would not only enable raising quality
of life of dependent, it would also aid the concerned government
employee to devote quality time when in office. In order to ensure that
only exceptional and genuine cases get covered under this relief, State
Medical Board may be consulted wherever necessary.
3. With the enactment of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016,
this Memorandum is issued as per recommendations of the State Commissioner
for Persons with Disabilities.
-Sd
Under Secretary to the
Government of Tripura”
I find that in view of the said office memorandum dated 25th
November, 2021, the Directorate of Health Services, Government of Tripura
under order dated 16.07.2021 (Annexure-10 to the writ petition) had allowed
the petitioner to leave her workplace for one hour for supporting daily needs
of the son of the writ petitioner.
The above fact has not been disputed by learned senior counsel
appearing for the petitioner.
6.9.
As I have said already that to decide the merits of challenge of
the impugned transfer order, this Court would particularly take into
consideration the interest of the son of the writ petitioner. It is stated and
submitted by learned GA that all treatment facilities are made available in
the Gomati DH for the son of the writ petitioner.
I have perused the concept of setting up of DEIC. These are the
centers advised to be established in various district level hospitals to take
initial steps of screening of children from birth to 18 years of age group for
selected health conditions including defects at birth, deficiencies, diseases
and developmental delays including disabilities under Rashtriya Bal
Swasthya Karyakram (RBSK) through trained and dedicated Mobile Health
Teams. The next vital step is confirmation of preliminary findings, referral
support, management and follow up. Under RBSK, these activities viz.
confirmation, management, referral, tracking and follow-up, needs to be
planned according to the age group of the child. It is also noticed that the
main function of these centers are to provide referral support to children
detected with health conditions during health screening, primarily for
children upto 6 years of age group. A team consisting of Pediatrician,
Medical Officer, Staff Nurses and Paramedics are engaged to provide such
services. There is also a provision for engaging a manager who will carry
out mapping of tertiary care facilities in government institutions for ensuring
adequate referral support.
6.10.
The main challenge of learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner is that DEIC is not meant for treating the patient, like the son of
the writ petitioner. In the affidavit sworn on 15.08.20224, the petitioner has
enclosed some medical prescriptions issued in the year 2010 by the National
Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences. I have also seen the
behavioural report dated 24.06.2013 issued by the National Institute for the
Mentally Handicapped, Andhra Pradesh, wherein it was advised for “Psycho
education to parents”, to start Tab. Resperidone 1 mg/day, to start Tab.
Trihexyphynidil 2 mg/day, if necessary only, if seen EPS. The said report
dated 24.06.2013 also suggested mild improvement.
I have made some research on the effect of the medicines
prescribed as mentioned here-in-above. I find that Tab. Resperidone
prevents aggressive behaviourness of an autism person. From the
prescription dated 11.04.2019 it is found that Sri Hritaban Das, son of the
petitioner has been prescribed Tab. Risperidone and Clonidine. After some
research, I find that Tab. Clonidine is helpful for patients with impulsive
behaviour or hyperactivity.
6.11.
It has come to fore that there is no specialized treatment meant
for managing an autistic person. A person with autism conjointly needs to be
managed. The parents were also adequately trained to manage the
behavioural attitude of Sri Hritaban Das. Moreover, in the instant case, I find
that the parents are doctors. They visited many specialized centers in India
for various advisories to manage their son. On some thorough research made
by this Court, it comes to fore that till today there is no treatment so that an
autism person can be cured. Therefore, the management of such person is the
prime consideration.
6.12.
Furthermore, DEIC is only meant for detection of behavioural
or attitude changes amongst the children as well as the persons from the age
group ranging from 0 to 18 years. What this Court has understood after
having some research that a person with autism needs to be managed or
controlled in their behavioural activities. Medications are given to control
the aggressiveness and other abnormal behaviour of such person.
6.13.
The question is whether the behavioural management of the son
of the petitioner is possible if the petitioner is asked to serve Gomati DH at
Udaipur?
I have taken into consideration that Gomati DH is only one
hour and fifteen minutes journey from Agartala. The doctors serving in
Gomati DH are provided with quarters which are adjacent to the hospital. It
is not necessary to have a specialized center at any hospital for management
of such autistic person. The autistic person may be treated by a Psychiatrist
also. From the list of doctors as submitted by learned G.A., it is revealed that
there are specialized doctors including Psychiatrists at Gomati District
Hospital, as are available in AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala, the present
place of posting of the petitioner. The competent authority has allowed the
petitioner to visit her son in the afternoon for more than an hour to take care
of her son.
6.14.
The competent authority has decided to continue same facilities
as the petitioner is enjoying at present to attend her son. The husband of the
petitioner who is also a doctor can stay at Udaipur and can perform his
duties at AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala without any sort of difficulty.
So, there is no chance of disassociation or dislocation of Sri Hritaban Das
from his parents. Learned G.A. has also submitted that the competent
authority undertakes to co-operate with the petitioner in all respects
considering the advice and modalities of treatment of Sri Hritaban Das. In
this regard, learned G.A. has placed before this Court a communication
made today itself (16.08.2024) by the In-charge, Director of Health Services,
Govt. of Tripura to the Medical Superintendent, District Hospital, Gomati,
Udaipur. The said communication has been kept with the case record.
6.15.
Now the question, as raised by learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner whether the son of the writ petitioner would be deprived of
providing “high support service” as defined under Section 2(l) of the RPWD
Act and “reasonable accommodation” as defined under Section 2(y) of the
RPWD Act? Keeping in mind the definition of high support service noted in
the preceding paragraphs, I am of the opinion that the son of the petitioner
will not in any way be deprived of being provided with high support service
the writ petitioner is rendering towards her son at present at her proposed
new place of posting at Gomati DH.
6.16.
Since all facilities are available in Gomati District Hospital at
Gomati District, there cannot be any hurdle to take her son to Udaipur so
that the supports which she has been providing to her son would be
continued. There is no question of any dislocation or disassociation. There is
no question of experiencing a different environment. At present also both the
parents perform their respective duties and responsibilities with some
additional benefits provided to the writ petitioner to attend her 22 yrs. old
son. There will be no deficiency in providing physical or psychological
support to the son of the writ petitioner. In the instant case, it is not the claim
of the writ petitioner that the respondents have allowed her to abstain from
her daily routine duties at her present place of posting at AGMC & GBP
Hospital. The nature of duties which she has been performing at present
would remain same. So, there will not be any change in extending the
support the petitioner now renders towards her son.
6.17.
Another aspect to be considered that the transfer of the
petitioner to Gomati District Hospital, Udaipur will interrupt the behavioural
training of her son.
6.18.
I have considered the submission of learned senior counsel
appearing for the petitioner. In my opinion, the transfer and posting of the
petitioner to Gomati DH at Udaipur will not in any way interrupt the
behavioural attitude of her son for the reason that all specialized doctors are
available in Gomati DH which have been discussed here-in-above.
6.19.
The autism is not a disease, it is a disorder. There is distinction
between disease and disorder. The autism is incurable since till today there is
no specialized treatment to cure an autistic person. At the cost of repetition, I
reiterate that an autistic person is only to be managed and controlled and for
this, the doctors only prescribe medicines and also train the parents only to
manage and control the behavioural attitudes of autistic persons. In the
present case, the parents of the autistic child themselves are the doctors.
Furthermore, keeping in mind the treatment facilities available at Gomati
District Hospital and the distance between Agartala and Udaipur, I find that
the posting of the petitioner to Gomati District Hospital, Udaipur will not in
any way cause any additional sufferings which the petitioner and her
husband suffer staying at Agartala presently.
This Court is also sympathetic to the condition of the son of the
petitioner but, in my opinion, in such a nature of case, the Court has to
maintain a balance between the public interest vis-à-vis the individual
interest. It is asserted by learned G.A. that service of the petitioner is
urgently needed at Gomati DH which has already been discussed in the
preceding paragraphs of this judgment. After thoughtful and conscious
consideration of the documents and reports time to time issued by the
specialized hospitals for mentally handicapped persons relating to
management modalities of the son of the petitioner, I am of the opinion that
the posting of the petitioner at Gomati DH will not in any manner invite any
hindrance to actively manage the son of the petitioner. As I have already said
that Gomati DH is situated only at a distance of 40-42 Kms. away from the
Agartala city, the parents of Sri Hritaban Das can easily stay together and
give adequate company to him if they both prefer to stay at Udaipur where
the Gomati DH is situated considering the larger public interest. Having
taken into consideration the nature of grounds tried to be projected by the
petitioner in her efforts to desist the impugned transfer order, in my
considered view, she is trying to take advantage of her son.
6.20.
Another important aspect to be considered that the petitioner is
not subjected to “routine” or rotational transfer as she has been at AGMC &
GBP Hospital since 2013 and now with the establishment of Modern Dental
Hospital at Agartala, in the considered view of this Court, the respondents
most reasonably have thought it fit to utilize her service at a place
wherefrom she can cater service to the people of 3(three) districts without
causing any prejudice to the welfare and well-being of her son. Further, such
transfer and posting, in my opinion, will not tantamount to any kind of
discrimination as defined in Section 2(h) of the RPWD Act, relating to the
service of the petitioner at her work place. That apart, the competent
authority while re-considering the transfer and posting has reasonably
accommodated the petitioner at Gomati DH keeping in view the objectives
delineated in Sections 2(l), 2(r), 2(s) , 2(t), 2(y) and Section 58 of the RPWD
Act, 2018.
6.21.
In my ultimate analysis, I hold that a balance be maintained
when fundamental and human rights coupled with the welfare and wellbeing, individual dignity and autonomy of both the care-giver and the
dependent disabled person are adequately protected, then, in the context of
the case, it would not be proper to complain of breach of the rights conferred
upon such persons under various provisions of the RPWD Act. In the instant
case, the facilities available at AGMC & GBP Hospital are equally available
at Gomati DH. More importantly, the petitioner has not specified/identified
any particular facilities or services that are available at AGMC & GBP
Hospital but not at Gomati DH. So, in my opinion, while proposing the
modification of the impugned transfer order to Gomati DH, the respondents
have been able to maintain a balance between public interest and the
personal interest. By striking this balance, in the unique circumstances of the
present case as narrated here-in-before, governments can promote common
good while respecting individual dignity and autonomy of the petitioner and
her 22 yrs. old son deserve.
7.
In light of above discussions and for the reasons recorded here-
in-above, according to this Court, the proposed transfer and posting of the
petitioner to Gomati DH, Udaipur from AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala in
modification of the impugned transfer order does not call for interference.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands dismissed. The stay
order passed on 18.12.2023 hereby stands vacated. Connected applications,
if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Snigdha
SAIKAT
KAR
Digitally signed
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2024.08.28
16:03:12 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review