Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.90/2023
Dr. Jayanta Dhar, S/O. Sri Adhir Chandra Dhar, R/O. Vill.-Hapania Hospital
Chowmuhani, P.O.:-ONGC, Badharghat, P.S.:-Amtali, District:-West
Tripura, Aged about:-35 years, by profession-Asst. Professor, PIN- 799014.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.:-Kunjaban, P.S.:-New Capital
Complex, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
2. The Director of Higher Education, Higher Education Department, Govt.
of Tripura, P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura,
PIN:-799001.
3. The Tripura Public Service Commission, Represented by its Secretary,
Akhaura Road, P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura,
PIN:-799001.
4. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road, P.O.:Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
5. The Under Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road,
P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
6. Smt. Sthiti Dasgupta, D/O-Lt. Haripada Dasgupta.
7. Sri Ankur Sarkar, S/O-Subodh Sarkar.
8. Smt. Priyanka Bhowmik, D/O-Manindra howmik.
9. Smt. Binita Basfore, D/O- Lt. Rabi Basfore.
10. Sri Debakanta Debbarma, S/O- Astaram Debbarma.
11. Smt. Juthika Naukham, D/O- Mahendra Naukham.
Notice upon Respondent No.6 to 11 to be served through the Respondent
No. 2.
………Respondent(s).
Along with
WP(C) No.1021/2022
Dr. Anindita Choudhury, W/O. Sri Animesh Majumder, D/O. Sri Durga
Sankar Choudhury, R/O. Dhaleshwar, Road No.17, P.O.:-Dhaleshwar, P.S.:East Agartala, District:-West Tripura, PIN- 799007, Age:-36 years.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.:-Kunjaban, P.S.:-New Capital
Complex, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
2. The Director of Higher Education, Higher Education Department, Govt.
of Tripura, P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura,
PIN:-799001.
3. The Tripura Public Service Commission, Represented by its Secretary,
Akhaura Road, P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura,
PIN:-799001.
4. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road, P.O.:Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
5. The Under Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road,
P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
6. Smt. Sthiti Dasgupta, D/O-Lt. Haripada Dasgupta.
7. Sri Ankur Sarkar, S/O-Subodh Sarkar.
8. Smt. Priyanka Bhowmik, D/O-Manindra howmik.
9. Smt. Binita Basfore, D/O- Lt. Rabi Basfore.
10. Sri Debakanta Debbarma, S/O- Astaram Debbarma.
11. Smt. Juthika Naukham, D/O- Mahendra Naukham.
Notice upon Respondent No.6 to 11 to be served through the Respondent
No. 2.
………Respondent(s).
WP(C) No.1022/2022
Dr. Amal Debnath, S/O. Lt. Banka Bihari Debnath, R/O. College Tilla, Lake
View Quarter, P.O.:- College Tilla, P.S.:-East Agartala, District:-West
Tripura, PIN- 799004, Aged about:-42 years.
………Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.:-Kunjaban, P.S.:-New Capital
Complex, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
2. The Director of Higher Education, Higher Education Department, Govt.
of Tripura, P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura,
PIN:-799001.
3. The Tripura Public Service Commission, Represented by its Secretary,
Akhaura Road, P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura,
PIN:-799001.
4. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road, P.O.:Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
5. The Under Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road,
P.O.:-Agartala, P.S.:-West Agartala, District:-West Tripura, PIN:-799001.
6. Smt. Sthiti Dasgupta, D/O-Lt. Haripada Dasgupta.
7. Sri Ankur Sarkar, S/O-Subodh Sarkar.
8. Smt. Priyanka Bhowmik, D/O-Manindra howmik.
9. Smt. Binita Basfore, D/O- Lt. Rabi Basfore.
10. Sri Debakanta Debbarma, S/O- Astaram Debbarma.
11. Smt. Juthika Naukham, D/O- Mahendra Naukham.
Notice upon Respondent No.6 to 11 to be served through the Respondent
No. 2.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate,
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate,
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Advocate,
Mrs. P. Chakraborty, Advocate,
Mr. Subendu Noatia, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 17th May, 2023.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Petitioners in all these writ petitions are aggrieved by their nonselection to the post of Assistant Professor in Government Law College,
Tripura. Such exercise was undertaken vide Advertisement No.06/2022
[Annexure-8 to WP(C) No.90 of 2023]. Since the issues of law are common
in all the writ petitions, for convenience sake, the relevant material facts and
documents being referred to hereinafter are from WP(C) No.90 of 2023
except the distinguishing facts of individual petitioners in the other
connected writ petitions as shall be referred to at the relevant places
hereinafter. The essential qualifications for appointment to the post of
Assistant Professor, Group-A Gazetted, in Government Law College in
Tripura under the Education (Higher) Department, Government of Tripura
against the permanent 11 (eleven) vacancies notified in total with breakup of
Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST) and Un-reserved (UR) are
incorporated in the advertisement. The relevant educational and other
qualifications prescribed thereunder are extracted hereinbelow for proper
appreciation:
"EDUCATIONAL & OTHER QUALIFICATIONS:
(I)
ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATIONS:
Eligibility (A or B):
(A) (i) A Master's Degree with 55% of the marks (or an
equivalent grade in a point-scale wherever the grading system
is followed) in a concerned/ relevant/ allied subject from an
Indian University, or an equivalent degree from an accredited
foreign University.
(ii)
Besides fulfilling the above qualifications, the
candidates must have cleared the National Eligibility Test
(NET) conducted by UGC or the CSIR or a similar test
accredited by the UGC like SLET/SET or who are or have
been awarded a Ph. D degree in accordance with the
University Grants Commission (Minimum Standards and
Procedure for Award of M. Phil/Ph. D Degree) Regulations,
2009 or 2016 and their amendments from time to time as the
case may be exempted from NET/SLET/SET :
Provided, the candidates, registered for the Ph. D
programme prior to July 11, 2009 shall be governed by the
provisions of the then existing Ordinances/By Laws/
Regulations of the Institution awarding the degree and such
Ph. D candidates shall be exempted from the requirement of
NET/SLET/SET for recruitment and appointment of Assistant
Professor or equivalent position in Universities/ Colleges/
Institutions subjects to the fulfillment of the following
conditions:a)
The Ph. D degree of the candidate has been awarded in
regular mode;
b)
The Ph. D thesis has been evaluated by at least two
external examiners;
c)
An open Ph. D viva voce of the candidate has been
conducted;
d)
The candidate has published two research papers from
his/her Ph. D work, out of which at least one each in a referred
journal;
e)
The candidate has presented at least two papers based
on his/her Ph. D work in conferences/ seminars/ sponsored/
funded/supported by the UGC/ ICSSR/ CSIR or any similar
agency.
The fulfillment of these conditions is to be certified by
the Registrar or the Dean (Academic Affairs) of the
University concerned.
Note:- NET/SLET/SET shall also not be required for such
Masters Programmes in disciplines for which NET/SLET/SET
is not required by the UGC, CSIR or similar test accredited by
the UGC, like SLET/SET.
OR
(B)
The Ph. D degree has been obtained from a foreign
university/institution with a ranking among top 500 in the
World University Ranking (at any time) by any one of the
followings: (i) Quacquarelli Symonds (QS) (ii) The Times
Higher Education (THE) or (iii) the Academic Ranking of
World Universities (ARWU) of the Shanghai Jiao Tong
University (Shanghai).
(II)
RELAXATION ALLOWED
A relaxation of 5% shall be allowed at the Bachelor's
as well as the Master's level for the candidates belonging to
Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe/ Differently abled { (a)
Blindness and low vision; (b) Deaf and Hard of Hearing; (c)
Locomotor disability including cerebral palsy, Leprosy cured,
dwarfism, acid attack victims and muscular dystrophy; (d)
Autism, intellectual disability, specific learning disability and
mental illness; (e) Multiple disabilities from amongst persons
under (a) to (d) including deaf-blindness } for the purpose of
eligibility and assessing good academic record for direct
recruitment. The eligibility marks of 55% marks (or an
equivalent grade in a point scale wherever the grading system
is followed ) and the relaxation of 5% to the categories
mentioned above are permissible, based only on the qualifying
marks without including any grace marks procedure.
A relevant grade which is regarded as equivalents of
55% wherever the grading system is followed by a recognized
university at the Master's level shall also be considered valid.
The time taken by candidates to acquire M. Phil and/or
Ph. D Degree shall not be considered as teaching/research
experience to be claimed for appointment to the teaching
positions. Further the period of active service spent on
pursuing Research Degree simultaneously with teaching
assignment without taking any kind of leave, shall be counted
as teaching experience for the purpose of direct recruitment/
promotion.
OR
As amended by UGC time to time.
(III) DESIRABLE:
Knowledge in Bengali or Kokborok.
Age:- Maximum 40 years of age as on 13.05.2022
Upper Age-limit is relaxable by 5(five) years in case of
SC/ST/PH candidates and Government Servants. However,
the SC/ST/Govt. Servant will not get the further relaxation of
5(five) years over and above relaxation of 5(five) years which
they are already entitled to get as SC/ST candidates.
The last date of submission of online application is
13.05.2022 (upto 5.30 PM). The application (s) received
after the closing date will not be entertained.
* Selection procedure: The selection procedure will
be governed as per Annexure-A & Annexure-B of the
notified scheduled of Assistant Professor, Government
Law College in Tripura."
2.
Though the advertisement contains Annexure-A and B devising
the selection procedure for the notified scheduled post of Assistant
Professor in Tripura but surprisingly the writ petitioner has not enclosed the
same though they are available in the counter affidavit of the respondentTripura Public Service Commission (hereinafter referred to as TPSC) and
are, indeed, material to determining the controversy at hand. Annexure-A is
enclosed in the counter affidavit of TPSC as Annexure-R/4 at page-126 of
WP(C) No.90 of 2023, whereas Annexure-B is enclosed in the counter
affidavit of TPSC as Annexure-R/6 at page-136 of WP(C) No.1021 of 2022.
The relevant part of Annexure-A and B are also extracted hereunder:
ANNEXURE-A
SELECTION PROCEDURE FOR THE POST OF ASSISTANT PROFESSOR,
GOVERNMENT LAW COLLEGE AS PER LATEST UGC REGULATION.
1.
The overall selection procedure shall incorporate
transparent, objective and credible methodology of analysis of
the merits and credentials of the applicants based on the
weightage given to the performance of the different relevant
parameters and his/her performance on a grading system
proforma, based on Appendix-II, Table 3B of the UGC
Regulation, 2018 as amended.
2.
The Academic score as specified in Annexure-II, Table
3B for Colleges, shall be considered for short-listing of the
candidates (Maximum 5 candidates for each post notified) for
interview.
3.
TPSC shall constitute Selection Committee and fix
qualifying cut off mark (if any) for interview as peer UGC
guideline 2018 as amended time to time.
4.
Screening API score followed by selection process of
interview with a weightage of 15% and API score weightage
of 85% in adherence of New Recruitment Policy, 2018 and
UGC Regulation, 2018. Accordingly 15 marks for interview/
personality test is fixed for the post of Asstt. Professor,
Government Law College, out of which 1 mark is reserved for
assessment of the Desirable qualification i.e. knowledge of
Bengali or Kokborok.
5.
Merit list will be formed by TPSC aggregating the
85% of marks obtained by the candidate as per API score and
interview marks scored by the candidate and following other
instructions in the latest UGC guideline.
ANNEXURE-B
Criteria for Short-listing of candidates for Interview for the post of Assistant
Professor, Govt. Law College
Sl.
No.
1.
Academic Record
Score
Graduation
80% and
above=21
2.
Post-Graduation
80% and
above=25
3.
M. Phil
60% and
above=07
60% to less
than 80%
=19
60% to less
than 80%
=23
55% to 45%
to
less than less than
60%=16 55%=10
55% (50% in case of
SC/ST/OBC
(noncreamy layer/PWD) to
less than 60%=20
55% to less than 60%=05
4.
5.
6.
Ph.D.
NET with JRF
NET
SLET/SET
Research Publications (2
marks for each research
publications published in
Peer-Reviewed or UGClisted Journals)
Teaching/Post Doctoral
Experience (2 marks for
one year each)#
Awards
International/National
Level (Awards given by
International
Organizations/Government
of India/Government of
India recognized National
Level Bodies
State-Level (Awards given
by State Government)
# However, if the period of teaching/post-doctoral experience is less than one year
then the marks shall be reduced proportionately.
Note:-(A) (i) M.Phil + Ph.D ---Maximum
-25 Marks
(ii) JRF/NET/SET---Maximum
-10 Marks
(iii)In awards category-Maximum
-03 Marks
(B)
Number of candidates to be called for interview shall be
decided by the college.
(C)
Academic Score---------------84
Research Publication---------06
Teaching Experience---------10
--------------------------------------TOTAL---------100
(D) SLET/SET score shall be valid for appointment in respective State
Universities/Colleges/Institutions only.
3.
The petitioner Dr. Jayanta Dhar in WP(C) No.90 of 2023
approached this Court on being aggrieved by his non-selection with the
following prayers:(i)
To award API score for Teaching/Post Doctoral
Experience for the service rendered by the petitioner in ICFAI Law College,
ICFAI University, Tripura as Assistant Professor (w.e.f. 17.06.2019 to
30.06.2022) and the service rendered after Ph.D. in connection with the
Recruitment
Process
for the
post
of
Assistant
Professor
under
Advertisement No.06/2022 dated 07.03.2022;
(ii)
Respondents be asked to show-cause as to why by
notification dated 06.09.2022 the Scrutiny Committee introduced a criteria
that teaching experience will only in conformity with the Clause 10.0 (a to f)
of the UGC Regulations, 2018 be counted towards Teaching/Post Doctoral
Experience under Column 7 of Annexure-B to the Advertisement dated
07.03.2022;
(iii)
For quashing the notification dated 03.11.2022 and the
consequential appointments of the private respondents.
4.
Petitioner Dr. Anindita Choudhury in WP(C) No.1021 of 2022
also made similar prayer except that she asked for counting her Teaching/
Post Doctoral Experience in ICFAI Law College, ICFAI University, Tripura
as Assistant Professor from 21.07.2017 till date.
5.
Petitioner Dr. Amal Debnath in WP(C) No.1022 of 2022 also
made a similar prayer except that he asked for counting his Teaching/Post
Doctoral Experience as Post Graduate Teacher (Law subject) under the
Department of Higher Education, Government of Tripura w.e.f. 04.03.2011
till date under the instant advertisement.
6.
As the grounds of challenge raised by the individual writ
petitioners are almost identical, so it would be proper to refer to the relevant
Clause 10.0 of the UGC Regulations, 2018 as amended which is Annexure13 to the WP(C) No.90 of 2023 and is extracted hereunder:
"10.0 Counting of Past Services for Direct Recruitment
and Promotion under CAS
Previous regular service, whether national or
international, as Assistant Professor, Associate Professor or
Professor or equivalent in a University, College, National
Laboratories or other scientific/professional organizations
such as the CSIR, ICAR, DRDO, UGC, ICSSR, ICHR, ICMR
and DBT, should count for the direct recruitment and
promotion under the CAS of a teacher as Assistant Professor,
Associate Professor, Professor or any other nomenclature,
provided that:
(a)
The essential qualifications of the post held were not
lower than the qualifications prescribed by the UGC for
Assistant Professor, Associate Professor and Professor, as the
case may be.
(b)
The post is/was in an equivalent grade or of the prerevised scale of pay as the post of Assistant Professor
(Lecturer), Associate Professor (Reader) and Professor.
(c)
The concerned Assistant Professor, Associate
Professor and Professor should possess the same minimum
qualifications as prescribed by the UGC for appointment to
the post of Assistant Professor, Associate Professor and
Professor, as the case may be.
(d)
The post was filled in accordance with the prescribed
selection procedure as laid down in the Regulations of the
University/State Government/Central Government/Institutions
concerned, for such appointments.
(e)
The previous appointment was not as guest lecturer for
any duration.
(f)
The previous Ad-hoc or Temporary or contractual
service (by whatever nomenclature it may be called) shall be
counted for direct recruitment and for promotion, provided
that:
(i)
the essential qualifications of the post held were not
lower than the qualifications prescribed by the UGC for
Assistant Professor, Associate Professor and Professor, as the
case may be;
(ii)
the incumbent was appointed on the recommendation
of a duly constituted Selection Committee/Selection
Committee constituted as per the rules of the respective
university;
(iii) the incumbent was drawing total gross emoluments not
less than the monthly gross salary of a regularly appointed
Assistant Professor, Associate Professor and Professor, as the
case may be; and
(g)
No distinctions shall be made with reference to the
nature of management of the institution where previous
service was rendered (private/local body/Government), while
counting the past service under this clause."
7.
Vide notification dated 06.09.2022 issued by the TPSC, the
candidates were instructed to go through the Extract of minutes of Scrutiny
Committee and submit representation with supporting documents, if there
be any to the Commission's secretariat by 15.09.2022. It was further
clarified that with regard to Teaching/Post Doctoral Experience (2 marks for
each one year), candidates intending to claim such experience will have to
submit documents strictly in conformity with the Clause-10.0 (Para-a to f as
the case may be) of the UGC Regulations, 2018, failing which their
Teaching/Post Doctoral Experience will not be counted.
8.
It is the case of the petitioners that the Scrutiny Committee of
TPSC has evolved a procedure to count the Teaching Experience of
individual candidates which is not provided for under the advertisement nor
the UGC Regulations lay down such criteria. Clause 10.0 of the UGC
Regulations do not deal with the issue of counting of Teaching Experience
rather it deals with counting of past services for direct recruitment and
promotion under CAS. The relevant resolution of the Scrutiny Committee
enclosed at Pages-46 to 49 are also extracted hereunder as they are material
for dealing with the instant issue:"(i) The Teaching Experience**
Education Institution has been considered.
of
Higher
(ii)
If the period of teaching/Post-doctoral
experience is less than one year then the marks shall be
reduced proportionately.
(iii) Other criteria for calculation of API scores/
Academic Record & Research Performance have been
followed as per UGC Regulations-2018 and the API
calculation methodology as published in the advertisement.
**Teaching/Post-doctoral Experience in terms of Clause10.0 of UGC REGULATIONS ON MINIMUM
QUALIFICATIONS FOR APPOINTMENT OF TEACHERS
AND OTHER ACADEMIC STAFF IN UNIVERSITIES
AND COLLEGES AND MEASURES FOR THE
MAINTENANCE OF STANDARDS IN HIGHER
EDUCATION, 2018 relates to Higher Education
Institution."
9.
As is evident from the above resolution, the Scrutiny
Committee resolved to count Teaching/Post-doctoral experience in terms of
Clause-10.0 of the UGC Regulations on minimum qualifications for
appointment of teachers and other academic staff in Universities and
Colleges and measures for the maintenance of standards in Higher
Education, 2018 relating to Higher Education Institutions.
10.
Petitioner Dr. Jayanta Dhar got 68.20 marks in the UR category
as per total marks, i.e. 85% of API + interview, whereas the last
recommended UR candidate got total marks of 76.85 (Sl. No.5 of the
Recommended List). Petitioner Dr. Anindita Choudhury got 65.66 marks in
the same UR category compared to the last recommended candidate who got
76.85 marks. Petitioner Dr. Amal Debnath got 59.06 marks in the same UR
category compared to the last recommended candidate who got 76.85 marks.
While petitioner Dr. Jayanta Dhar and Dr. Anindita Choudhury claimed for
counting their Teaching experience as Assistant Professor in ICFAI Law
College, Tripura for the relevant periods, the other petitioner Dr. Amal
Debnath claimed for counting his Teaching experience as a Post Graduate
Teacher in the Education Department of the Government of Tripura from
04.03.2011.
11.
In this background, it is useful to refer to the criteria laid down
under the advertisement, in particular Annexure-A and B referred to and
quoted supra. As per the essential qualifications prescribed under the
Advertisement No.06/2022, a candidate should have Master's Degree with
55% of the marks or an equivalent grade in a point-scale. Besides the above
qualification, he should have cleared the National Eligibility Test (NET)
conducted by the UGC or the CSIR or a similar test accredited by the UGC
like SLET/SET or who have been awarded a Ph. D degree in accordance
with the University Grants Commission (UGC) Regulations of 2009 or 2016
and their amendments from time to time as the case may be exempted from
NET/SLET/SET.
12.
Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioners, has
also pointed out to the relaxation granted in this criteria under (II),
specifically the last paragraph thereof which allows counting of teaching
experience for the period of active service spent on pursuing Research
Degree simultaneously with teaching assignment without taking any kind of
leave. As per the selection procedure prescribed under Annexure-A and B
for the notified post of Assistant Professor, the overall selection procedure
would be based on a grading system proforma as per Appendix-II, Table-3B
of the UGC Regulations, 2018 as amended. The Academic score as
specified in Annexure-II, Table 3B for Colleges shall be considered for
short-listing of the candidates (maximum 5 candidates for each post
notified) for interview. TPSC shall constitute Selection Committee and fix
qualifying cut off marks (if any) for interview as per UGC guideline, 2018
as amended time to time. Screening API score followed by selection process
of interview with a weightage of 15% and API score weightage of 85% in
adherence to New Recruitment Policy, 2018 and UGC Regulation, 2018
shall be followed. Accordingly, 15 marks for interview/personality test is
fixed for the post of Assistant Professor, Government Law College, out of
which 1 (one) mark is reserved for assessment of the desirable qualification,
i.e. knowledge of Bengali or Kokborok. Merit list will be formed by TPSC
aggregating the 85% of marks obtained by the candidate as per API score
and interview marks scored by the candidate and following other
instructions in the latest UGC guideline. Rest of the clauses of Annexure-A
prescribe for the constitution of the Selection Committee for the post of
Assistant Professor in Colleges. Annexure-B which has been extracted
hereinabove as well lays down the criteria for short-listing of candidates for
interview for the post of Assistant Professor, Government Law College and
in particular, at Clause-7 prescribes 10 marks for Teaching/Post Doctoral
Experience (2 marks for each one year).
13.
The combined reading of the advertisement along with
Annexure-A in particular unerringly points out to the criteria prescribed
under UGC Regulations, 2018 as amended from time to time. For counting
of Teaching Experience, the Scrutiny Committee referred to Clause-10.0 of
the Regulations of 2018 (extracted hereinabove). Clause (f), in particular,
deals with the case of the present petitioners as two of them Dr. Jayanta
Dhar and Dr. Anindita Choudhury have submitted their applications
claiming Teaching Experience as Assistant Professor in ICFAI Law
College, Tripura [which are at page-51, Annexures-12 to WP(C) No.90 of
2023 and at page-49, Annexure-10 to WP(C) No.1021 of 2022 respectively]
along with appointment letter dated 14.06.2019 in respect of petitioner Dr.
Jayanta Dhar [at page-36, Annexure-7 to WP(C) No.90 of 2023] and
appointment letter dated 20.07.2017 in respect of petitioner Dr. Anindita
Choudhury [at page-113, Annexure-R/3 to the counter affidavit of TPSC in
WP(C) No.1021 of 2022]. Dr. Amal Debnath, the third writ petitioner, has
claimed appointment on the basis of being a Post Graduate Teacher under
Education Department of the Government of Tripura. The petitioners'
contention that Clause-10.0 of the Regulations of 2018 could not have been
taken into consideration for counting of Teaching Experience as they relate
to counting of past services for direct recruitment and promotion under CAS
does not merit acceptance as in the first place the instant advertisement itself
relates to appointment through direct recruitment to the post of Assistant
Professor and in the second place, petitioners and others claim Teaching
Experience on the basis of their service in the concerned University or Law
College.
14.
Clause (f) of 10.0 lays down three criteria for counting of past
services-(i) the essential qualifications of the post held should not be lower
than the qualifications prescribed by the UGC for Assistant Professor,
Associate Professor and Professor, as the case may be; (ii) the incumbent
was appointed on the recommendation of a duly constituted Selection
Committee/Selection Committee constituted as per the rules of the
respective university; and (iii) the incumbent was drawing total gross
emoluments not less than the monthly gross salary of a regularly appointed
Assistant Professor, Associate Professor and Professor, as the case may be.
While in the case of the petitioners Dr. Jayanta Dhar and Dr. Anindita
Choudhury, sub-clauses (ii) and (iii) of Clause (f) of 10.0 do not stand
fulfilled, on a bare perusal of their appointment letters as Assistant Professor
under the ICFAI University, the petitioner Dr. Amal Debnath was not
working as an Assistant Professor rather as a Post Graduate Teacher also on
contractual basis. In the case of the first two petitioners, it is apparent from a
perusal of their appointment letters that they were appointed on contractual
basis and the appointment letters do not indicate as to whether they were
appointed on the recommendation of a duly constituted Selection
Committee or the total gross emoluments that they were withdrawing were
not less than the monthly gross salary of a regularly appointed Assistant
Professor. The appointment letter of petitioner Dr. Amal Debnath at
Annexure-4 to WP(C)1022/2022 also don’t show that such appointment
was made pursuant to the recommendation by a duly constituted Selection
Committee in conformity with the Clause (f) of UGC Regulations, 2018. He
obtained Ph.D. on 23.07.2019 only. The decision of the Scrutiny Committee
to rely upon Clause-10.0 of the Regulations, 2018 has been questioned by
the petitioners for counting of Teaching Experience. However, it is not in
dispute that on the one hand, the Advertisement No.06/2022 and AnnexureA and B specifically refer to the UGC Regulations of 2018 and that
Teaching Experience for computation of API scores could be reckoned only
with reference to Clause-10.0 which deals with counting of past services for
direct recruitment and promotion under CAS, on the other hand, the
procedure evolved by the Scrutiny Committee applies without any
discrimination to all candidates. The procedure has not only been uniformly
followed but is transparent also. There are no allegations of mala fides by
any of these writ petitioners against the Scrutiny Committee or any member
of the TPSC. The procedure and the criteria for counting of Teaching
Experience of all candidates having been applied uniformly, petitioners
cannot either make out a claim of arbitrariness in the selection procedure.
On this criteria, all candidates whether petitioners or private respondents or
other candidates who have not been selected stand on the same footing. As
such, this Court is of the considered view that the instant grounds of
challenge to the selection procedure laid down by the TPSC is not amenable
to be questioned in writ jurisdiction.
15.
It is also not in dispute that the results of the Scrutiny
Committee were duly notified and each of these petitioners have duly
represented in terms of the Notification dated 06.09.2022 [Annexure-10 to
WP(C) No.90 of 2023] and that, a Review Committee had duly examined
the representations of all such 25 candidates including these petitioners.
These petitioners along with other candidates who were called for interview
have also duly put their signatures on the API score before participating in
the interview.
16.
While the petitioners contend that there cannot be any estoppel
in laying down a challenge after having participated in an interview for the
reason that the selection procedure was itself vitiated, Mr. Raju Datta,
learned counsel for the respondents No.3 to 5-TPSC, Mr. Debalay
Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate appearing for the respondents
No.1 & 2-State, and Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mrs. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for private respondents
No.6 to 8, and Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the private
respondents No.9 to 11, have in a consistent stand opposed the said
submission relying upon decisions of the Apex Court.
17.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has on the one hand placed
reliance upon the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Raj Kumar and
others vrs. Shakti Raj and others reported in (1997) 9 SCC 527 (Paragraph16). On the other hand, learned counsel for the TPSC has placed reliance
upon a recent decision of the Apex Court in the case of Tajvir Singh Sodhi
and others vrs. State of Jammu and Kashmir and others reported in 2023
SCC OnLine SC 344 (Paragraphs-64 to 69). The Apex Court in the case of
Raj Kumar and others (supra) has at paragraph-16 of the judgment held
that since the Government had committed glaring illegalities in the
procedure to get the candidates for examination under the 1955 Rules, so
also in the method of selection and exercise of the power in taking out from
the purview of the Board and also conduct of the selection in accordance
with the Rules, the principle of estoppel by conduct or acquiescence shall
have no application to the facts in the case.
18.
In the case of Tajvir Singh Sodhi (supra), the Apex Court after
dealing with the precedents on the point such as, Manish Kumar Shahi vrs.
State of Bihar and others reported in (2010) 12 SCC 576, Ramesh
Chandra Shah and others vrs. Anil Joshi and others reported in (2013) 11
SCC 309, Ashok Kumar and another vrs. State of Bihar and others
reported in (2017) 4 SCC 357 and other decisions on the point at paragraph70 of the judgment referred to the case of Sadananda Halo and others vrs.
Momtaz Ali Sheikh and others reported in (2008) 4 SCC 619 wherein it
was observed that the only exception to the rule of waiver is the existence of
mala fides on the part of the Selection Board. The Apex Court in the said
case did not find any mala fides or arbitrariness in the selection process and,
therefore, held that the said exception could not be invoked. In the present
case, as has been observed hereinabove, the petitioners have not alleged any
mala fides on the members of the Scrutiny Committee or the TPSC in the
selection process and this Court has in the foregoing paragraphs held that no
discrimination or arbitrariness could be made out in the selection process.
Petitioners have consciously participated in the selection exercise being
fully aware of the selection procedure followed by the Scrutiny Committee
in the computation of score for Teaching Experience and still subjected
them to the interview process.
19.
One other distinguishing feature on facts which is noted in the
present cases is that even if the Teaching Experience of the petitioner Dr.
Jayanta Dhar or Dr. Anindita Choudhury for having worked under ICFAI
Law College, Tripura could have been counted, their total API score based
on the formula, i.e. 85% of the total API score would not have been above
the last recommended candidate in the UR category who scored 76.85
marks. Learned counsel for the petitioners has in this regard referred to the
computation of the score by the Scrutiny Committee at Page-47,
Annexure-10 to WP(C) No.90 of 2023, where the name of the petitioner Dr.
Jayanta Dhar appears at Sl. No.21 with API score out of 100 marks as 72
and that of one Ankur Sarkar at Sl. No.29, a selected candidate, (whose API
score is shown as 78) but it has been pointed out by the learned counsel for
the TPSC that the computation of the API score for purposes of preparation
of the final result would be only 85% of the API score and as such, in the
ultimate analysis the petitioners would not have gone higher even if their
contention of counting their Teaching Experience as Assistant Professor in
ICFAI Law College, Tripura could have been accepted. However, on the
main plank of challenge laid by the petitioners, this Court is satisfied that
the Scrutiny Committee had not committed any illegality or arbitrariness in
following the UGC Regulations, 2018 in the matter of counting of Teaching
Experience of the candidates by reference to Clause-10.0 of the Regulations
as they squarely apply to counting of such an experience of past services in
matters of direct recruitment and promotion under CAS and that the
principle has been applied uniformly without any discrimination to all
candidates.
20.
Learned counsel for the respondent-TPSC has rightly referred
to the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Tajvir Singh Sodhi (supra)
at paragraphs-64 to 69 of the judgment which lay down the principles of
interference by Courts in selection process for public employment. The
Apex Court after relying upon the precedents on the point came to the
inexorable conclusion that it is not within the domain of the Courts,
exercising the power of judicial review, to enter into the merits of a
selection process, a task which is the prerogative of and is within the expert
domain of a Selection Committee, subject of course to a caveat that if there
are proven allegations of malfeasance or violations of statutory rules, only in
such cases of inherent arbitrariness, can the Courts intervene. The opinion of
the Apex Court at paragraphs-65 to 69 are extracted hereunder as they are
illuminating on the issue in controversy raised in the present writ petitions
as well:
"65. Before proceeding further, it is necessary to preface
our judgment with the view that Courts in India generally
avoid interfering in the selection process of public
employment, recognising the importance of maintaining the
autonomy and integrity of the selection process. The Courts
recognise that the process of selection involves a high degree
of expertise and discretion and that it is not appropriate for
Courts to substitute their judgment for that of a selection
committee. It would be indeed, treading on thin ice for us if
we were to venture into reviewing the decision of experts who
form a part of a selection board. The law on the scope and
extent of judicial review of a selection process and results
thereof, may be understood on consideration of the following
case law:
i) In Dalpat Abasaheb Solunke vs. Dr. B.S. Mahajan,
(1990) 1 SCC 305 : AIR 1990 SC 434, this Court clarified the
scope of judicial review of a selection process, in the
following words:
"9...It is needless to emphasise that it is not the
function of the court to hear appeals over the
decisions of the selection committees and to
scrutinise the relative merits of the candidates.
Whether the candidate is fit for a particular post or
not has to be decided by the duly constituted
selection committee which has the expertise on the
subject. The court has no such expertise. The
decision of the selection committee can be interfered
with only on limited grounds, such as illegality or
patent material irregularity in the constitution of the
committee or its procedure vitiating the selection, or
proved malafides affecting the selection etc…..”
ii) In a similar vein, in Secy. (Health) Deptt. Of Health
& F.W. vs. Dr. Anita Puri, (1996) 6 SCC 282, this Court
observed as under as regards the sanctity of a selection
process and the grounds on which the results thereof may be
interfered with:
"9. ... It is too well settled that when a selection
is made by an expert body like the Public Service
Commission which is also advised by experts having
technical experience and high academic qualification
in the field for which the selection is to be made, the
courts should be slow to interfere with the opinion
expressed by experts unless allegations of mala fide
are made and established. It would be prudent and
safe for the courts to leave the decisions on such
matters to the experts who are more familiar with the
problems they face than the courts. If the expert
body considers suitability of a candidate for a
specified post after giving due consideration to all
the relevant factors, then the court should not
ordinarily interfere with such selection and
evaluation…….”
iii) This position was reiterated by this Court in M. V.
Thimmaiah vs. Union Public Service Commission, (2008) 2
SCC 119, in the following words:
“21. Now, comes the question with regard to the
selection of the candidates. Normally, the
recommendations of the Selection Committee cannot
be challenged except on the ground of mala fides or
serious violation of the statutory rules. The courts
cannot sit as an Appellate Authority to examine the
recommendations of the Selection Committee like
the court of appeal. This discretion has been given to
the Selection Committee only and courts rarely sit as
a court of appeal to examine the selection of the
candidates nor is the business of the court to
examine each candidate and record its opinion...
xxx
30. We fail to understand how the Tribunal can
sit as an Appellate Authority to call for the personal
records and constitute Selection Committee to
undertake this exercise. This power is not given to
the Tribunal and it should be clearly understood that
the assessment of the Selection Committee is not
subject to appeal either before the Tribunal or by the
courts. One has to give credit to the Selection
Committee for making their assessment and it is not
subject to appeal. Taking the overall view of ACRs
of the candidates, one may be held to be very good
and another may be held to be good. If this type of
interference is permitted then it would virtually
amount that the Tribunals and the High Courts have
started sitting as Selection Committee or act as an
Appellate Authority over the selection. It is not their
domain, it should be clearly understood, as has been
clearly held by this Court in a number of
decisions…..”
iv) Om Prakash Poplai and Rajesh Kumar
Maheshwari vs. Delhi Stock Exchange Association Ltd.,
(1994) 2 SCC 117, was a case where an appeal was filed
before this Court challenging the selection of members to the
Delhi Stock Exchange on the ground that the Selection
Committee formed for the aforesaid purpose, arbitrarily
favoured some candidates and was thus, against Article
14. This Court rejected the allegation of favouritism and bias
by holding as under:
“5. …the selection of members by the Expert
Committee had to be done on the basis of an
objective criteria taking into consideration
experience, professional qualifications and similar
related factors. In the present cases, we find that
certain percentage of marks were allocated for each
of these factors, namely, educational qualifications,
experience, financial background and knowledge of
the relevant laws and procedures pertaining to public
issues etc. Of the total marks allocated only 20 per
cent were reserved for interviews. Therefore, the
process of selection by the Expert Committee was
not left entirely to the sweet-will of the members of
the Committee. The area of play was limited to 20
per cent and having regard to the fact that the
members of the Expert Committee comprised of two
members nominated by the Central Government it is
difficult to accept the contention that they acted in
an unreasonable or arbitrary fashion…...”
66.
Thus, the inexorable conclusion that can be drawn is
that it is not within the domain of the Courts, exercising the
power of judicial review, to enter into the merits of a selection
process, a task which is the prerogative of and is within the
expert domain of a Selection Committee, subject of course to
a caveat that if there are proven allegations of malfeasance or
violations of statutory rules, only in such cases of inherent
arbitrariness, can the Courts intervene.
67.
Thus, Courts while exercising the power of judicial
review cannot step into the shoes of the Selection Committee
or assume an appellate role to examine whether the marks
awarded by the Selection Committee in the viva-voce are
excessive and not corresponding to their performance in such
test. The assessment and evaluation of the performance of
candidates appearing before the Selection Committee/
Interview Board should be best left to the members of the
committee. In light of the position that a Court cannot sit in
appeal against the decision taken pursuant to a reasonably
sound selection process, the following grounds raised by the
writ petitioners, which are based on an attack of subjective
criteria employed by the selection board/interview panel in
assessing the suitability of candidates, namely, (i) that the
candidates who had done their post-graduation had been
awarded 10 marks and in the viva-voce, such PG candidates
had been granted either 18 marks or 20 marks out of 20. (ii)
that although the writ petitioners had performed exceptionally
well in the interview, the authorities had acted in an arbitrary
manner while carrying out the selection process, would not
hold any water.
68.
The next aspect of the matter which requires
consideration is the contention of the writ petitioners to the
effect that the entire selection process was vitiated as the
eligibility criteria enshrined in the Advertisement Notice dated
5th May, 2008 was recast vide a corrigendum dated 12th June,
2009, without any justifiable reason. In order to consider this
contention, regard may be had to the following case law:
i) In Manish Kumar Shahi vs. State of Bihar, (2010) 12
SCC 576, this Court authoritatively declared that having
participated in a selection process without any protest, it
would not be open to an unsuccessful candidate to challenge
the selection criteria subsequently.
ii) In Ramesh Chandra Shah vs. Anil Joshi, (2013) 11
SCC 309, an advertisement was issued inviting applications
for appointment for the post of physiotherapist. Candidates
who failed to clear the written test presented a writ petition
and prayed for quashing the advertisement and the process of
selection. They pleaded that the advertisement and the test
were ultra vires the provisions of the Uttar Pradesh Medical
Health and Family Welfare Department Physiotherapist and
Occupational Therapist Service Rules, 1998. After referring to
a catena of judgments on the principle of waiver and estoppel,
this Court did not entertain the challenge for the reason that
the same would not be maintainable after participation in the
selection process. The pertinent observations of this Court are
as under:
“24. In view of the propositions laid down in the
above noted judgments, it must be held that by
having taken part in the process of selection with full
knowledge that the recruitment was being made
under the General Rules, the respondents had
waived their right to question the advertisement or
the methodology adopted by the Board for making
selection and the learned Single Judge and the
Division Bench of the High Court committed grave
error by entertaining the grievance made by the
respondents."
iii) Similarly, in Ashok Kumar vs. State of Bihar,
(2017) 4 SCC 357, a process was initiated for promotion to
Class-III posts from amongst Class-IV employees of a civil
court. In the said case, the selection was to be made on the
basis of a written test and interview, for which 85% and 15%
marks were earmarked respectively as per norms. Out of 27
(twenty-seven) candidates who appeared in the written
examination, 14 (fourteen) qualified. They were interviewed.
The committee selected candidates on the basis of merit and
prepared a list. The High Court declined to approve the Select
List on the ground that the ratio of full marks for the written
examination and the interview ought to have been 90:10 and
45 ought to be the qualifying marks in the written
examination. A fresh process followed comprising of a written
examination (full marks - 90 and qualifying marks - 45) and
an interview (carrying 10 marks). On the basis of the
performance of the candidates, results were declared and 6
(six) persons were appointed on Class-III posts. It was
thereafter that the appellants along with 4 (four) other
unsuccessful candidates filed a writ petition before the High
Court challenging the order of the High Court on the
administrative side declining to approve the initial Select List.
The primary ground was that the appointment process was
vitiated, since under the relevant rules, the written test was
required to carry 85 marks and the interview 15 marks. This
Court dismissed the appeals on the grounds that the appellants
were clearly put on notice when the fresh selection process
took place that the written examination would carry 90 marks
and the interview 10 marks. The Court was of the view that
the appellants having participated in the selection process
without objection and subsequently found to be not
successful, a challenge to the process at their instance was
precluded. The relevant observations are as under:
"13. The law on the subject has been crystalized
in several decisions of this Court. In Chandra
Prakash Tiwari v. Shakuntala Shukla, this Court laid
down the principle that when a candidate appears at
an examination without objection and is
subsequently found to be not successful, a challenge
to the process is precluded. The question of
entertaining a petition challenging an examination
would not arise where a candidate has appeared and
participated. He or she cannot subsequently turn
around and contend that the process was unfair or
that there was a lacuna therein, merely because the
result is not palatable. In Union of India v. S.
Vinodh Kumar (2007) 8 SCC 100, this Court held
that: "18. It is also well settled that those candidates
who had taken part in the selection process knowing
fully well the procedure laid down therein were not
entitled to question the same (See also Munindra
Kumar v. Rajiv Govil (1991) 3 SCC 368
and Rashmi Mishra v. M.P. Public Service
Commission (2006) 12 SCC 724)".
69.
It is therefore trite that candidates, having taken part in
the selection process without any demur or protest, cannot
challenge the same after having been declared unsuccessful.
The candidates cannot approbate and reprobate at the same
time. In other words, simply because the result of the selection
process is not palatable to a candidate, he cannot allege that
the process of interview was unfair or that there was some
lacuna in the process. Therefore, we find that the writ
petitioners in these cases, could not have questioned before a
Court of law, the rationale behind recasting the selection
criteria, as they willingly took part in the selection process
even after the criteria had been so recast. Their candidature
was not withdrawn in light of the amended criteria. A
challenge was thrown against the same only after they had
been declared unsuccessful in the selection process, at which
stage, the challenge ought not to have been entertained in light
of the principle of waiver and acquiescence."
21.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has referred to two
decisions rendered by Division Bench of this Court at Annexures-14 and 16
to WP(C) No.90 of 2023. The decision in the case of Tripura Public
Service Commission vrs. Partha Sarathi Dutta and another in Writ Appeal
Nos.9 & 10 of 2008 vide judgment dated 04.06.2008 [Annexure-16 to
WP(C) No.90 of 2023] has also been taken note of by the Division Bench of
this Court in the case of Sri Bimal Kumar Chanda vrs. Dr. Ratna Roy and
others in WP(C)(PIL) No.12 of 2014 vide judgment dated 10.12.2014
[Annexure-14 to WP(C) No.90 of 2023]. The proposition which has been
relied upon by the petitioners at paragraph-8 of the decision in the case of
Bimal Kumar Chanda (supra) is to the effect that the rule in question did
not lay down that the teaching experience had to be as a whole time teacher
or as a regularly appointed teacher. All it stated that there should be teaching
experience of ten years. When the rule making authority framed the rule, it
is for it to use the language which it chooses. If the language is amenable to
two interpretations, then the more liberal interpretation will have to be given
and, therefore, the Court was clearly of the view that the teaching
experience as a part-time teacher had to be counted towards total teaching
experience. The observations of this Court in the case of Bimal Kumar
Chanda (supra) do not fit in the facts of the present case where the
recruitment was being held under an advertisement which prescribed
application of UGC Regulations, 2018 as amended at Clause-10.0 which
clearly laid down the principles on which the past services could be counted
for direct recruitment and promotion under CAS. The cases of the present
petitioners, therefore, stand on a different footing compared to the case of
Bimal Kumar Chanda (supra) cited by the petitioners.
22.
Learned counsel for the TPSC has, on the other hand, placed
reliance upon two decisions of the Coordinate Bench of this Court, i.e.
WP(C) No.190 of 2023 [Dr. Sandip Saha vrs. The State of Tripura and 4
others, judgment dated 03.04.2023] and WP(C) No.950 of 2022 [Sri Kanu
Nath vrs. The State of Tripura and 2 others, order dated 10.11.2022]
where, according to him, the same principles under the same Advertisement
No.06/2022 so far as the application of Clause-10.0 of the UGC
Regulations, 2018 were in question and have been approved by the learned
Single Bench of this Court. It is informed that one of the decisions, i.e.
WP(C) No.190 of 2023 has been subject to challenge in a writ appeal which
is pending.
23.
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, learned
Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents-State and Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned
senior counsel assisted by Mrs. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing
for the private respondents No.6 to 8, both have adopted the submission of
learned counsel for the TPSC, the Body which has conducted the
recruitment exercise. Learned Government Advocate has referred to the
prayers made by the writ petitioners and the nature of representations made
by them after result of the Scrutiny Committee and submitted that the case
made out by the petitioners at this stage before the Writ Court is a novation
as the petitioners had duly accepted the selection procedure and subjected
themselves to the interview. They have turned around to challenge the
selection procedure only after they have failed which should not be
countenanced in law.
24.
Learned counsel for the private respondents have also
submitted that the API scores in respect of the petitioners or the private
respondents have been computed on the same yardsticks and all these
candidates had signed on the score before participating in the interview.
Therefore, the petitioners are estopped from laying down a challenge to the
selection procedure after they have failed. There is no infirmity in the
selection procedure.
25.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties at length and taken into note the relevant pleadings placed from the
record. I have also taken note of decisions cited by the parties on the
propositions urged by them. As a result of the discussions made hereinabove
and the reasons recorded, this Court is of the considered view that the
petitioners have failed to make out any grounds of illegality, discrimination
or arbitrariness in the procedure adopted by the TPSC and the Scrutiny
Committee in computation of the scores of Teaching Experience for the
purposes of selection of the candidates. These petitioners having
consciously participated in the exercise have laid challenge to the selection
procedure only after they have failed to qualify. Petitioners have not alleged
any mala fides in the selection procedure and no arbitrariness or
discrimination have been made out on their part.
26.
Therefore, in the totality of facts and circumstances and for the
reasons recorded hereinabove, this Court does not find any merit in these
writ petitions which are accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review